A Subject Prominence by Subject

There are 90 tables below, one for each subject. In each table there are 138 rows, one for each year. In each year, there are 8 columns. This is what each of the columns represents.


Weight
The weighted number of articles in that subject in that year. This is the main data point that’s used throughout the book as the measure of the subject’s prominence in the year.
Raw
The raw number of articles in that subject in that year.
W-Ratio
The weighted number of articles in that subject in that year per 1000 articles published that year.
R-Ratio
The raw number of articles in that subject in that year per 1000 articles published that year.
W-Pages
The weighted number of pages of articles on that subject in that year.
R-Pages
The raw number of pages of articles on that subject in that year.
WP-Ratio
The weighted number of pages of articles in that subject in that year per 1000 pages published that year.
RP-Ratio
The raw number of pages of articles in that subject in that year per 1000 pages published that year.

Psychology

Table A.1: Measures of the prominence of Psychology in each year’s journals.
Year Weight Raw W-Ratio R-Ratio W-Pages R-Pages WP-Ratio RP-Ratio
1876 5.7 7 112 137 70.4 87 148 182
1877 4.0 8 99 200 50.1 107 108 230
1878 5.6 8 139 200 78.3 122 174 271
1879 3.2 6 88 167 54.2 95 113 199
1880 4.2 10 126 303 70.8 155 145 318
1881 6.3 8 203 258 77.3 81 164 172
1882 5.2 9 163 281 58.7 108 135 248
1883 3.2 4 100 125 48.9 54 113 125
1884 4.5 9 174 346 89.8 178 208 413
1885 6.1 10 276 455 119.6 194 303 491
1886 4.7 8 163 276 67.7 126 165 307
1887 8.0 15 257 484 163.7 314 369 709
1888 7.4 12 176 286 117.6 185 226 356
1889 7.8 11 299 423 116.5 170 298 435
1890 9.3 17 198 362 149.4 266 219 390
1891 7.2 13 232 419 147.4 274 289 537
1892 11.6 20 193 333 195.1 352 211 381
1893 8.9 15 136 231 110.6 191 133 230
1894 8.9 12 129 174 140.1 208 154 229
1895 9.9 15 140 211 162.3 253 165 257
1896 5.4 7 83 108 76.1 88 82 94
1897 6.8 9 119 158 92.3 120 114 149
1898 6.7 10 127 189 100.3 152 123 186
1899 3.7 6 90 146 66.5 103 89 137
1900 4.9 7 98 140 69.0 98 91 129
1901 6.1 8 103 136 148.9 232 153 238
1902 3.9 5 81 104 100.0 129 108 139
1903 4.0 3 76 58 75.3 42 83 46
1904 5.5 8 96 140 90.9 112 96 119
1905 2.7 1 43 16 44.3 9 46 9
1906 4.7 6 76 97 134.7 153 121 137
1907 5.3 8 86 129 112.6 160 111 157
1908 3.1 5 47 76 77.9 137 79 138
1909 3.1 5 55 89 70.5 113 73 117
1910 4.3 10 74 172 101.3 253 100 249
1911 4.7 7 73 109 83.0 125 88 132
1912 2.8 5 42 76 67.9 184 62 168
1913 3.2 3 47 45 85.7 129 81 121
1914 4.1 7 60 103 93.1 177 79 151
1915 2.5 3 37 45 64.8 67 53 55
1916 2.1 1 28 13 48.9 17 35 12
1917 4.4 8 64 116 102.2 166 81 131
1918 4.7 7 62 91 91.8 155 61 103
1919 3.6 6 52 86 98.0 224 76 174
1920 3.6 5 55 77 63.2 98 61 94
1921 6.6 10 60 90 94.9 159 71 118
1922 7.0 11 49 78 96.1 141 61 89
1923 4.7 6 35 45 55.5 74 33 44
1924 4.1 5 36 43 61.5 81 39 51
1925 3.7 3 31 25 69.4 64 39 36
1926 5.7 8 46 65 87.8 113 51 66
1927 4.9 7 40 56 101.4 166 55 91
1928 3.8 4 29 30 58.1 88 32 49
1929 2.8 2 24 17 59.9 71 32 38
1930 1.6 2 15 19 29.6 38 20 25
1931 4.4 8 43 78 69.2 115 44 73
1932 2.1 1 18 8 30.9 10 17 6
1933 1.3 1 11 9 25.3 26 14 15
1934 2.2 3 11 16 30.4 40 13 18
1935 2.3 4 14 24 49.3 127 22 57
1936 3.4 4 18 22 40.7 38 17 16
1937 1.1 0 7 0 22.5 0 10 0
1938 2.1 2 11 10 32.3 26 12 10
1939 2.5 3 12 15 49.7 74 18 27
1940 4.7 10 23 48 70.8 129 26 48
1941 3.0 3 14 14 47.3 51 17 19
1942 3.2 1 15 5 41.5 26 16 10
1943 2.3 2 11 10 35.0 42 16 19
1944 2.7 4 15 21 42.2 69 17 28
1945 3.1 2 16 10 46.5 29 17 10
1946 2.5 2 11 9 32.4 15 11 5
1947 3.0 3 13 13 50.6 27 17 9
1948 1.7 0 7 0 19.8 0 6 0
1949 1.7 3 6 11 27.7 51 9 17
1950 2.4 2 9 7 44.3 21 14 7
1951 2.7 2 9 6 39.5 25 11 7
1952 3.0 3 10 9 51.2 44 14 12
1953 3.3 3 10 9 42.5 26 12 7
1954 4.0 1 12 3 60.4 14 15 4
1955 1.4 0 4 0 21.6 0 5 0
1956 2.0 0 6 0 34.2 0 9 0
1957 2.6 2 8 6 38.9 29 10 7
1958 1.4 0 4 0 18.8 0 5 0
1959 2.5 1 7 3 26.2 7 7 2
1960 3.3 4 10 12 39.7 53 10 14
1961 3.2 3 8 8 35.1 27 9 7
1962 1.9 1 5 3 20.0 4 5 1
1963 2.0 2 5 5 31.4 39 8 10
1964 2.2 0 6 0 27.2 0 7 0
1965 2.4 2 6 5 28.5 39 8 10
1966 2.3 3 6 8 17.8 15 5 4
1967 1.4 2 3 5 11.4 12 3 3
1968 1.6 1 4 3 20.2 2 5 0
1969 2.6 1 6 2 19.3 5 4 1
1970 3.0 4 7 9 44.8 73 9 15
1971 3.4 5 7 11 32.5 44 7 9
1972 2.3 1 5 2 23.3 7 5 1
1973 1.9 1 4 2 20.2 2 4 0
1974 1.0 0 3 0 16.5 0 3 0
1975 1.9 1 5 3 27.3 19 6 4
1976 1.6 1 4 3 20.2 5 4 1
1977 0.9 0 3 0 12.3 0 3 0
1978 1.7 1 4 3 29.4 35 6 7
1979 0.7 0 2 0 8.4 0 2 0
1980 0.8 0 2 0 12.8 0 3 0
1981 2.1 2 5 5 22.8 10 5 2
1982 1.0 1 3 3 14.0 9 3 2
1983 1.7 2 4 5 19.5 14 4 3
1984 0.8 1 2 3 13.6 17 3 3
1985 1.7 1 4 2 24.0 7 4 1
1986 2.2 2 6 5 26.2 16 5 3
1987 0.7 0 2 0 12.2 0 2 0
1988 0.8 0 2 0 15.2 0 3 0
1989 1.1 1 3 3 22.6 36 4 6
1990 1.2 0 3 0 16.7 0 3 0
1991 0.6 0 2 0 8.2 0 1 0
1992 0.5 0 1 0 8.6 0 1 0
1993 0.9 1 2 3 18.2 23 3 4
1994 0.6 0 2 0 9.9 0 2 0
1995 0.6 0 2 0 9.1 0 2 0
1996 0.8 0 2 0 14.5 0 2 0
1997 0.5 0 1 0 10.8 0 2 0
1998 0.8 1 2 3 16.4 14 3 2
1999 0.9 1 2 3 16.5 21 2 3
2000 0.7 1 2 2 17.4 24 2 3
2001 0.7 0 2 0 20.2 0 3 0
2002 1.0 1 3 3 17.8 21 3 3
2003 0.4 0 1 0 8.1 0 1 0
2004 0.5 0 1 0 9.0 0 1 0
2005 0.4 0 1 0 10.0 0 1 0
2006 0.7 0 2 0 11.8 0 1 0
2007 0.5 0 1 0 11.7 0 1 0
2008 0.7 1 2 2 21.8 35 3 4
2009 0.3 0 1 0 5.6 0 1 0
2010 1.1 0 2 0 16.4 0 2 0
2011 0.7 0 2 0 15.8 0 2 0
2012 0.3 0 1 0 7.6 0 1 0
2013 1.3 1 3 2 25.1 9 3 1

Idealism

Table A.2: Measures of the prominence of Idealism in each year’s journals.
Year Weight Raw W-Ratio R-Ratio W-Pages R-Pages WP-Ratio RP-Ratio
1876 4.0 6 79 118 43.0 79 90 166
1877 3.4 3 86 75 40.4 26 87 56
1878 2.4 2 60 50 31.2 30 69 67
1879 2.9 4 82 111 36.9 60 77 126
1880 2.3 2 70 61 41.5 44 85 90
1881 4.0 10 130 323 76.8 191 163 406
1882 4.7 10 147 312 99.9 235 230 540
1883 2.7 3 86 94 48.4 45 112 104
1884 3.4 6 129 231 62.5 110 145 255
1885 2.2 3 101 136 39.4 40 100 101
1886 3.4 5 116 172 64.0 100 156 244
1887 2.1 2 66 65 28.8 21 65 47
1888 5.0 8 118 190 80.5 131 155 252
1889 2.7 5 105 192 57.6 105 147 269
1890 6.5 8 139 170 103.1 151 151 221
1891 4.4 8 142 258 60.3 108 118 212
1892 9.3 16 155 267 154.3 266 167 288
1893 13.3 24 205 369 176.9 310 213 374
1894 14.1 25 205 362 208.2 378 229 415
1895 11.5 19 162 268 170.4 272 173 276
1896 11.1 17 171 262 178.6 272 191 291
1897 11.0 19 192 333 169.5 317 210 393
1898 11.9 21 224 396 195.8 343 240 420
1899 8.8 12 215 293 151.0 200 201 267
1900 9.1 15 182 300 170.6 296 224 389
1901 12.3 22 208 373 190.2 330 195 339
1902 10.6 22 221 458 223.9 459 241 494
1903 14.7 29 283 558 272.2 565 300 623
1904 12.3 26 216 456 220.3 511 234 542
1905 13.9 27 225 435 253.0 519 261 535
1906 14.4 31 232 500 270.5 576 242 516
1907 16.8 33 271 532 260.3 519 255 509
1908 15.4 26 233 394 256.6 399 259 402
1909 16.3 30 291 536 292.8 566 304 588
1910 12.6 22 217 379 229.3 359 225 353
1911 14.7 25 230 391 246.4 426 261 451
1912 14.8 26 224 394 258.9 436 236 397
1913 14.1 22 210 328 246.4 371 232 349
1914 12.6 25 185 368 239.6 501 205 428
1915 11.2 18 167 269 223.6 395 184 325
1916 14.1 26 183 338 265.6 483 189 344
1917 12.3 21 178 304 238.4 426 189 337
1918 12.5 16 162 208 311.3 446 207 296
1919 15.3 31 219 443 261.8 498 203 386
1920 12.3 24 190 369 189.5 408 182 392
1921 13.3 18 120 162 186.4 256 139 191
1922 20.5 39 145 277 269.6 514 170 325
1923 22.3 41 166 306 294.9 562 174 331
1924 17.8 35 155 304 278.6 576 175 363
1925 21.8 37 184 311 358.0 613 202 345
1926 15.3 23 123 185 240.9 340 141 199
1927 16.7 29 134 232 294.3 539 161 295
1928 14.4 25 108 188 254.4 448 141 249
1929 16.2 27 136 227 242.0 375 131 203
1930 12.6 21 120 200 210.5 350 140 233
1931 11.4 18 112 176 184.5 318 117 202
1932 14.9 30 122 246 232.3 449 130 252
1933 18.4 29 162 254 280.4 445 157 249
1934 18.7 36 98 188 266.2 518 117 227
1935 14.9 22 90 133 226.8 328 102 147
1936 14.3 23 77 124 207.9 303 86 125
1937 14.0 18 82 105 188.7 228 85 102
1938 17.5 26 89 131 275.2 408 102 151
1939 14.5 26 71 127 218.8 451 79 163
1940 15.4 20 74 97 225.9 316 84 118
1941 15.5 23 73 107 207.5 308 76 112
1942 13.8 21 66 100 194.7 298 74 113
1943 11.3 9 56 44 147.8 115 66 51
1944 12.2 12 65 64 173.9 174 70 70
1945 8.7 10 45 52 181.0 206 65 74
1946 12.9 19 58 85 201.5 290 70 101
1947 13.3 18 58 79 188.9 234 64 80
1948 12.3 14 48 54 153.8 159 50 52
1949 10.3 13 38 48 129.7 152 43 50
1950 8.4 9 31 33 117.6 152 37 48
1951 11.8 17 37 54 155.5 204 41 54
1952 10.2 12 32 38 131.5 146 36 40
1953 9.8 9 30 28 126.2 130 35 36
1954 9.8 9 29 27 124.3 91 32 23
1955 9.8 12 28 34 135.8 147 34 37
1956 9.6 12 27 34 121.1 161 31 42
1957 8.6 11 25 32 101.6 108 26 28
1958 14.7 21 40 57 167.3 217 41 54
1959 8.6 8 24 22 108.0 88 28 23
1960 5.8 4 17 12 75.2 48 20 13
1961 7.7 6 20 16 95.3 65 24 17
1962 6.5 4 18 11 71.9 40 20 11
1963 5.6 4 15 11 75.4 33 20 9
1964 4.4 1 12 3 57.5 7 15 2
1965 3.6 2 9 5 47.4 24 13 6
1966 4.3 2 11 5 63.2 40 16 10
1967 4.6 4 11 10 66.8 60 16 14
1968 3.5 4 9 10 51.8 50 12 12
1969 4.6 4 11 9 65.4 59 15 13
1970 4.1 2 9 5 46.7 10 10 2
1971 3.9 2 8 4 48.3 11 10 2
1972 3.3 1 7 2 46.9 12 10 2
1973 2.0 1 5 2 29.0 17 6 4
1974 3.7 1 9 2 53.6 14 11 3
1975 2.2 0 6 0 32.5 0 7 0
1976 2.6 1 7 3 41.2 14 8 3
1977 3.1 4 8 11 53.9 83 11 17
1978 1.8 0 5 0 26.2 0 6 0
1979 3.0 2 8 5 48.2 31 10 6
1980 3.5 3 9 8 58.3 48 12 10
1981 2.5 2 7 5 42.2 40 9 8
1982 2.8 0 7 0 46.2 0 9 0
1983 2.8 1 7 3 50.8 7 10 1
1984 2.0 0 5 0 31.8 0 6 0
1985 2.6 1 6 2 49.4 14 9 2
1986 1.8 1 4 3 32.2 20 6 4
1987 2.7 0 7 0 52.4 0 10 0
1988 2.4 0 6 0 46.4 0 8 0
1989 2.3 1 6 3 39.8 18 7 3
1990 2.7 0 7 0 49.3 0 8 0
1991 2.8 1 7 3 52.4 18 9 3
1992 2.8 2 8 6 53.9 27 9 4
1993 1.9 0 5 0 29.6 0 5 0
1994 2.4 2 7 5 46.5 20 7 3
1995 1.9 0 5 0 36.4 0 6 0
1996 2.1 1 5 3 41.2 14 7 2
1997 2.2 0 5 0 38.7 0 6 0
1998 1.3 0 4 0 26.3 0 4 0
1999 1.4 0 3 0 27.4 0 4 0
2000 1.8 0 4 0 27.9 0 4 0
2001 1.8 1 5 3 34.4 20 5 3
2002 1.7 0 5 0 38.2 0 6 0
2003 1.7 0 4 0 33.8 0 4 0
2004 1.9 0 5 0 40.7 0 5 0
2005 1.8 0 4 0 34.0 0 4 0
2006 1.4 0 3 0 29.6 0 4 0
2007 1.4 0 3 0 31.7 0 4 0
2008 1.6 1 4 2 28.9 12 3 1
2009 1.3 0 3 0 26.3 0 3 0
2010 1.4 0 3 0 33.1 0 4 0
2011 1.6 0 4 0 31.2 0 3 0
2012 0.7 0 2 0 16.8 0 2 0
2013 1.9 1 4 2 35.1 5 4 1

Life and Value

Table A.3: Measures of the prominence of Life and Value in each year’s journals.
Year Weight Raw W-Ratio R-Ratio W-Pages R-Pages WP-Ratio RP-Ratio
1876 2.1 3 41 59 26.0 36 55 75
1877 1.5 2 39 50 22.1 28 47 60
1878 2.7 3 67 75 27.5 26 61 58
1879 1.9 1 54 28 32.5 22 68 46
1880 3.0 8 92 242 46.0 106 94 217
1881 2.0 2 65 65 36.8 33 78 70
1882 1.8 2 56 62 27.2 20 63 46
1883 2.1 3 67 94 41.2 71 95 164
1884 1.6 3 62 115 29.6 52 69 121
1885 1.5 3 69 136 20.6 35 52 89
1886 1.9 2 64 69 29.7 38 72 93
1887 0.8 0 25 0 11.1 0 25 0
1888 1.6 1 37 24 23.4 30 45 58
1889 0.9 1 35 38 17.7 23 45 59
1890 3.2 5 69 106 48.8 79 72 116
1891 1.5 1 49 32 21.4 8 42 16
1892 3.9 5 65 83 56.9 56 62 61
1893 2.6 3 40 46 37.2 35 45 42
1894 2.8 2 40 29 49.7 36 55 40
1895 4.1 5 58 70 66.8 95 68 97
1896 4.4 2 68 31 67.2 35 72 37
1897 4.5 6 79 105 66.0 113 82 140
1898 2.4 3 46 57 39.7 34 49 42
1899 3.0 4 73 98 53.0 57 71 76
1900 4.1 4 82 80 66.9 52 88 68
1901 4.8 6 81 102 71.2 76 73 78
1902 3.4 2 72 42 63.6 31 68 33
1903 2.9 1 55 19 46.0 12 51 13
1904 3.8 3 66 53 64.6 48 68 51
1905 4.2 5 68 81 71.2 80 73 82
1906 4.0 6 65 97 66.4 109 59 98
1907 3.0 4 49 65 56.3 56 55 55
1908 3.6 3 54 45 61.5 47 62 47
1909 3.4 3 60 54 59.7 47 62 49
1910 3.3 4 56 69 62.5 80 61 79
1911 3.2 2 50 31 55.1 39 58 41
1912 4.0 5 60 76 70.8 86 64 78
1913 6.6 12 98 179 107.1 226 101 212
1914 3.9 5 57 74 71.9 84 61 72
1915 5.3 7 80 104 116.6 161 96 133
1916 6.0 5 78 65 108.9 73 78 52
1917 4.1 4 59 58 81.5 76 64 60
1918 6.7 10 86 130 147.4 170 98 113
1919 5.9 8 85 114 103.0 127 80 98
1920 6.4 6 99 92 107.4 108 103 104
1921 11.0 13 99 117 142.9 184 106 137
1922 9.6 11 68 78 93.2 96 59 61
1923 11.1 14 83 104 172.2 233 101 137
1924 9.3 12 81 104 125.3 146 79 92
1925 8.0 7 67 59 122.4 109 69 61
1926 8.9 12 72 97 127.4 166 75 97
1927 8.1 14 65 112 123.3 203 67 111
1928 6.4 5 48 38 100.1 68 56 38
1929 5.4 6 45 50 84.6 80 46 43
1930 3.9 5 38 48 59.6 59 40 39
1931 6.9 12 67 118 99.7 150 63 95
1932 4.0 5 32 41 66.4 60 37 34
1933 4.1 2 36 18 65.6 32 37 18
1934 6.9 8 36 42 99.4 105 43 46
1935 6.6 9 40 55 97.6 123 44 55
1936 5.6 4 30 22 78.6 50 32 21
1937 5.8 7 34 41 85.1 78 38 35
1938 7.8 8 39 40 105.5 87 39 32
1939 8.3 7 40 34 136.5 109 49 39
1940 8.9 7 43 34 132.7 116 49 43
1941 9.7 6 45 28 136.4 108 50 39
1942 12.4 15 59 71 176.0 230 67 88
1943 9.9 8 49 39 113.7 93 51 41
1944 10.7 10 57 53 152.8 131 61 52
1945 9.7 8 50 41 143.5 119 51 43
1946 10.1 10 45 45 151.6 141 53 49
1947 9.9 12 43 52 119.5 127 41 43
1948 10.3 14 40 54 131.6 189 43 61
1949 8.2 10 30 37 103.2 147 34 48
1950 7.5 2 27 7 93.7 17 30 5
1951 8.3 6 26 19 100.3 56 27 15
1952 9.4 12 30 38 111.9 122 30 33
1953 7.6 7 24 22 93.8 75 26 21
1954 10.2 8 30 24 112.8 72 29 18
1955 7.7 5 22 14 99.1 59 25 15
1956 10.5 6 30 17 123.6 69 32 18
1957 8.0 7 23 20 95.4 99 25 26
1958 8.3 6 22 16 98.7 73 24 18
1959 8.7 5 24 14 86.1 33 22 9
1960 6.1 5 18 15 83.3 66 22 17
1961 4.8 4 13 10 54.0 43 14 11
1962 5.4 1 15 3 67.0 6 18 2
1963 6.1 4 16 11 71.4 35 18 9
1964 6.2 9 16 24 74.5 100 20 26
1965 4.6 4 12 10 54.1 54 14 14
1966 5.0 2 13 5 58.1 6 15 2
1967 4.5 4 11 10 50.6 44 12 10
1968 4.4 1 11 3 44.6 7 10 2
1969 5.9 3 14 7 67.6 41 15 9
1970 4.1 2 9 5 45.6 15 9 3
1971 5.9 3 13 7 76.5 37 16 8
1972 5.7 2 13 4 72.9 22 15 5
1973 4.4 0 10 0 59.2 0 12 0
1974 4.7 3 12 7 71.9 40 15 8
1975 5.8 4 15 10 65.6 28 14 6
1976 4.0 0 10 0 55.6 0 11 0
1977 4.6 0 12 0 72.6 0 15 0
1978 4.9 2 13 5 71.4 27 15 6
1979 3.7 2 10 5 58.8 29 12 6
1980 3.9 0 11 0 67.0 0 13 0
1981 3.7 0 10 0 66.1 0 13 0
1982 4.7 2 12 5 64.4 10 13 2
1983 3.7 1 9 3 54.6 17 11 3
1984 4.0 3 10 8 67.3 65 13 13
1985 3.2 0 7 0 47.3 0 8 0
1986 2.2 1 6 3 38.3 16 7 3
1987 3.0 0 8 0 48.4 0 9 0
1988 4.1 0 10 0 63.6 0 12 0
1989 3.9 1 10 3 77.0 49 13 8
1990 3.5 2 9 5 63.1 34 11 6
1991 2.6 0 7 0 44.2 0 8 0
1992 2.9 0 8 0 52.9 0 9 0
1993 3.5 3 9 8 56.5 60 10 11
1994 2.1 0 6 0 37.8 0 6 0
1995 2.8 1 8 3 52.4 2 9 0
1996 2.0 1 5 3 41.6 20 7 3
1997 2.8 1 7 2 54.3 22 8 3
1998 2.4 0 7 0 49.1 0 8 0
1999 3.1 1 8 3 63.7 18 9 3
2000 3.2 3 7 7 58.7 64 8 8
2001 2.3 0 6 0 47.6 0 7 0
2002 2.7 1 7 3 51.7 5 8 1
2003 2.8 0 6 0 59.0 0 8 0
2004 2.4 0 6 0 53.0 0 7 0
2005 3.1 0 7 0 67.9 0 8 0
2006 2.6 1 6 2 57.1 13 7 2
2007 1.4 0 3 0 30.5 0 4 0
2008 2.4 0 6 0 53.6 0 6 0
2009 2.1 0 5 0 49.7 0 6 0
2010 2.4 0 5 0 53.7 0 6 0
2011 2.1 1 5 2 43.1 16 5 2
2012 2.2 1 5 2 49.7 33 6 4
2013 2.4 0 5 0 50.3 0 6 0

Other History

Table A.4: Measures of the prominence of Other History in each year’s journals.
Year Weight Raw W-Ratio R-Ratio W-Pages R-Pages WP-Ratio RP-Ratio
1876 6.7 9 132 176 84.7 115 178 241
1877 5.5 9 138 225 106.5 174 229 373
1878 2.5 5 63 125 46.3 86 103 191
1879 4.0 6 112 167 70.5 96 148 201
1880 1.6 2 48 61 20.7 25 42 51
1881 1.8 2 57 65 30.0 50 64 106
1882 0.9 1 29 31 17.0 24 39 55
1883 0.6 0 19 0 11.5 0 27 0
1884 0.6 0 22 0 11.3 0 26 0
1885 0.4 0 20 0 3.5 0 9 0
1886 1.0 0 36 0 9.7 0 24 0
1887 3.5 5 114 161 21.9 39 50 88
1888 2.2 4 53 95 19.3 52 37 100
1889 0.6 0 22 0 7.2 0 18 0
1890 1.8 2 37 43 22.5 27 33 40
1891 1.5 2 50 65 27.9 34 55 67
1892 1.6 2 27 33 25.6 19 28 21
1893 3.2 3 50 46 37.7 37 45 45
1894 1.4 1 21 14 16.9 18 19 20
1895 1.7 1 24 14 24.2 14 25 14
1896 1.9 2 29 31 17.7 7 19 7
1897 1.5 1 26 18 10.8 2 13 2
1898 2.0 3 37 57 33.5 37 41 45
1899 2.4 4 59 98 46.3 68 62 91
1900 2.4 5 49 100 36.7 79 48 104
1901 2.2 2 38 34 41.2 48 42 49
1902 1.8 3 37 62 29.6 47 32 51
1903 0.8 0 16 0 13.5 0 15 0
1904 3.0 2 52 35 38.6 21 41 22
1905 2.7 4 44 65 50.9 74 52 76
1906 2.1 3 35 48 32.5 47 29 42
1907 2.5 4 40 65 54.3 99 53 97
1908 2.0 3 30 45 32.3 57 33 57
1909 2.6 3 46 54 47.9 60 50 62
1910 2.2 3 38 52 24.2 29 24 29
1911 1.5 1 23 16 21.1 20 22 21
1912 2.7 3 41 45 41.7 51 38 46
1913 2.4 2 35 30 26.4 21 25 20
1914 2.5 3 37 44 50.4 57 43 49
1915 3.4 5 50 75 60.1 97 50 80
1916 5.6 6 73 78 81.8 63 58 45
1917 3.7 6 53 87 60.5 117 48 93
1918 2.6 2 33 26 43.8 44 29 29
1919 1.4 2 21 29 27.7 40 21 31
1920 2.1 3 33 46 34.1 37 33 36
1921 6.5 8 58 72 61.7 79 46 59
1922 3.3 3 24 21 47.0 35 30 22
1923 5.4 5 40 37 58.0 63 34 37
1924 4.6 3 40 26 61.5 45 39 28
1925 6.9 6 58 50 98.7 80 56 45
1926 6.6 7 53 56 84.6 95 50 56
1927 5.9 7 47 56 73.6 91 40 50
1928 9.3 13 70 98 102.3 157 57 87
1929 5.7 7 47 59 88.0 104 48 56
1930 4.9 6 47 57 72.5 86 48 57
1931 4.1 5 40 49 55.3 63 35 40
1932 5.0 6 41 49 68.6 87 38 49
1933 4.2 6 37 53 67.8 89 38 50
1934 3.9 3 20 16 58.5 55 26 24
1935 4.1 5 25 30 61.7 86 28 39
1936 4.8 6 26 32 81.4 110 34 45
1937 6.3 7 37 41 90.8 124 41 56
1938 8.3 8 42 40 111.3 119 41 44
1939 5.7 5 28 25 77.8 60 28 22
1940 8.0 10 38 48 112.3 134 42 50
1941 5.3 7 25 33 58.0 83 21 30
1942 6.6 7 31 33 89.1 86 34 33
1943 8.4 9 41 44 93.6 116 42 52
1944 4.4 4 23 21 54.5 44 22 18
1945 5.8 4 30 21 76.9 48 27 17
1946 9.3 15 42 67 132.4 265 46 92
1947 10.5 13 46 57 141.6 163 48 55
1948 7.2 6 28 23 86.6 84 28 27
1949 7.5 8 27 29 94.7 123 31 40
1950 6.5 4 24 15 78.7 59 25 19
1951 11.5 15 36 48 123.6 144 33 38
1952 10.5 12 33 38 110.2 119 30 32
1953 11.6 12 36 37 133.0 117 37 33
1954 13.8 21 41 62 141.5 200 36 51
1955 10.6 12 30 34 103.9 112 26 28
1956 9.7 8 28 23 87.9 51 23 13
1957 6.3 6 18 17 54.6 37 14 10
1958 7.6 6 20 16 74.2 54 18 13
1959 6.6 5 18 14 74.9 56 19 15
1960 6.8 4 20 12 76.9 43 20 11
1961 5.5 2 14 5 65.6 25 17 6
1962 6.9 4 19 11 65.5 33 18 9
1963 6.0 4 16 11 58.2 24 15 6
1964 5.7 3 15 8 55.0 19 14 5
1965 7.2 5 18 13 64.1 31 17 8
1966 5.7 5 15 13 70.0 77 18 20
1967 5.4 3 13 7 43.3 14 10 3
1968 6.5 9 16 23 64.4 86 15 20
1969 5.2 5 12 12 54.7 54 12 12
1970 4.7 6 11 14 54.9 115 11 24
1971 2.6 1 6 2 32.9 12 7 3
1972 3.8 4 9 9 52.8 34 11 7
1973 3.1 2 7 5 34.0 7 7 1
1974 3.7 2 9 5 59.1 40 12 8
1975 2.1 1 5 3 23.2 2 5 0
1976 6.4 6 16 15 74.4 66 15 14
1977 3.9 4 10 11 44.4 24 9 5
1978 2.5 2 6 5 25.8 15 5 3
1979 2.6 1 7 3 35.2 13 7 3
1980 3.2 2 9 5 45.5 33 9 7
1981 1.9 0 5 0 26.9 0 5 0
1982 3.4 2 9 5 41.7 22 8 4
1983 2.9 3 7 8 40.7 61 8 12
1984 3.4 2 9 5 33.4 21 6 4
1985 4.5 5 11 12 52.4 48 9 8
1986 2.9 2 7 5 41.4 23 8 4
1987 3.5 2 9 5 49.1 42 9 8
1988 3.3 1 8 3 54.1 14 10 3
1989 3.6 3 9 8 64.8 58 11 10
1990 3.5 1 9 3 59.2 25 10 4
1991 3.5 3 10 8 44.3 31 8 6
1992 2.7 4 8 11 71.2 162 12 27
1993 5.1 4 14 11 59.8 28 11 5
1994 2.1 1 6 3 46.5 18 7 3
1995 1.9 0 6 0 38.9 0 7 0
1996 2.8 2 7 5 45.7 34 7 5
1997 3.0 3 8 7 64.6 88 10 13
1998 2.7 3 8 9 48.2 39 8 7
1999 2.6 1 7 3 52.3 7 7 1
2000 3.7 2 8 4 53.6 6 7 1
2001 2.8 2 7 5 56.1 41 8 6
2002 2.7 0 7 0 35.7 0 6 0
2003 2.7 2 6 5 44.9 27 6 3
2004 2.3 0 6 0 46.9 0 6 0
2005 2.8 2 6 4 58.9 25 7 3
2006 3.0 2 7 5 67.1 39 9 5
2007 3.3 2 8 5 65.5 33 8 4
2008 2.1 0 5 0 42.9 0 5 0
2009 2.7 0 6 0 62.1 0 7 0
2010 3.0 2 6 4 48.7 21 5 2
2011 3.2 2 7 4 67.7 16 7 2
2012 3.5 2 8 5 67.7 22 8 3
2013 4.0 2 9 5 79.3 42 9 5

Dewey and Pragmatism

Table A.5: Measures of the prominence of Dewey and Pragmatism in each year’s journals.
Year Weight Raw W-Ratio R-Ratio W-Pages R-Pages WP-Ratio RP-Ratio
1876 0.5 0 10 0 5.5 0 12 0
1877 0.4 0 10 0 3.3 0 7 0
1878 0.1 0 3 0 2.0 0 4 0
1879 0.4 0 12 0 3.4 0 7 0
1880 0.1 0 2 0 1.4 0 3 0
1881 0.2 0 5 0 1.9 0 4 0
1882 0.3 0 9 0 5.0 0 11 0
1883 0.3 0 8 0 3.6 0 8 0
1884 0.0 0 1 0 0.3 0 1 0
1885 0.4 0 20 0 7.3 0 18 0
1886 0.6 1 20 34 5.2 4 13 10
1887 0.1 0 3 0 1.4 0 3 0
1888 0.5 0 12 0 6.1 0 12 0
1889 0.1 0 5 0 2.0 0 5 0
1890 0.3 0 7 0 6.0 0 9 0
1891 0.3 0 10 0 5.5 0 11 0
1892 0.5 1 9 17 7.4 6 8 6
1893 0.7 0 11 0 11.8 0 14 0
1894 0.6 0 8 0 7.6 0 8 0
1895 0.4 0 5 0 6.4 0 6 0
1896 0.4 0 6 0 6.9 0 7 0
1897 0.9 0 15 0 14.1 0 18 0
1898 0.9 0 16 0 14.2 0 17 0
1899 0.4 0 9 0 8.1 0 11 0
1900 0.7 0 14 0 11.4 0 15 0
1901 0.4 0 7 0 4.5 0 5 0
1902 1.0 0 20 0 17.2 0 19 0
1903 1.0 0 19 0 18.9 0 21 0
1904 1.4 0 25 0 26.2 0 28 0
1905 2.2 1 35 16 36.8 6 38 6
1906 2.4 0 39 0 39.7 0 36 0
1907 1.5 0 24 0 23.4 0 23 0
1908 3.4 3 51 45 46.7 33 47 33
1909 2.1 3 38 54 25.3 20 26 21
1910 1.2 1 20 17 18.9 13 19 13
1911 1.9 2 30 31 28.2 37 30 39
1912 1.9 1 29 15 23.3 6 21 5
1913 2.2 3 33 45 28.6 25 27 23
1914 1.9 1 28 15 34.4 21 29 18
1915 1.9 2 28 30 24.7 17 20 14
1916 1.9 1 24 13 28.9 18 21 13
1917 1.3 0 19 0 24.7 0 20 0
1918 1.2 1 15 13 17.5 9 12 6
1919 1.2 0 17 0 20.6 0 16 0
1920 0.9 1 14 15 14.5 9 14 9
1921 1.9 1 17 9 21.0 5 16 4
1922 4.4 4 31 28 53.1 54 34 34
1923 3.4 2 25 15 33.5 16 20 9
1924 1.9 0 17 0 24.3 0 15 0
1925 2.9 1 24 8 35.8 5 20 3
1926 2.5 2 20 16 28.4 11 17 6
1927 2.2 1 18 8 33.3 5 18 3
1928 3.1 2 23 15 36.1 11 20 6
1929 2.2 0 18 0 30.5 0 17 0
1930 2.3 2 22 19 25.6 18 17 12
1931 2.5 0 24 0 36.1 0 23 0
1932 2.9 2 24 16 36.2 19 20 11
1933 2.5 0 22 0 32.7 0 18 0
1934 2.7 1 14 5 30.3 10 13 4
1935 3.7 2 23 12 41.6 13 19 6
1936 3.9 6 21 32 48.5 72 20 30
1937 3.8 4 22 23 45.2 49 20 22
1938 4.4 1 22 5 57.3 11 21 4
1939 5.6 7 27 34 74.0 86 27 31
1940 5.9 6 28 29 70.8 79 26 29
1941 5.5 4 25 19 74.0 49 27 18
1942 6.2 9 30 43 69.3 81 26 31
1943 7.0 10 34 49 73.3 100 33 44
1944 5.8 3 31 16 83.6 66 33 26
1945 4.6 6 24 31 72.2 79 26 28
1946 5.5 5 25 22 62.2 63 22 22
1947 6.7 7 29 31 68.6 61 23 21
1948 6.1 8 24 31 69.8 79 23 26
1949 8.5 10 31 37 92.6 114 30 38
1950 5.6 2 20 7 63.9 31 20 10
1951 7.4 12 24 38 87.0 120 23 32
1952 6.8 6 21 19 82.5 104 22 28
1953 7.8 8 24 25 84.5 71 23 20
1954 6.1 3 18 9 71.8 42 18 11
1955 7.5 7 21 20 78.8 57 20 14
1956 5.3 2 15 6 57.4 9 15 2
1957 5.9 6 17 17 71.0 69 18 18
1958 8.2 8 22 22 82.0 58 20 14
1959 8.6 11 24 30 89.0 112 23 29
1960 6.0 5 17 15 73.9 60 20 16
1961 5.8 8 15 21 60.4 80 16 21
1962 3.6 0 10 0 38.3 0 10 0
1963 3.8 1 10 3 42.2 9 11 2
1964 5.2 7 14 18 42.5 46 11 12
1965 2.5 1 6 3 34.9 23 9 6
1966 3.5 1 9 3 35.0 6 9 2
1967 4.3 5 11 12 45.7 62 11 15
1968 3.7 1 9 3 52.7 15 12 3
1969 3.2 2 8 5 31.8 14 7 3
1970 3.6 0 8 0 34.3 0 7 0
1971 3.0 2 7 4 29.1 18 6 4
1972 2.6 0 6 0 35.4 0 7 0
1973 2.7 1 6 2 29.2 11 6 2
1974 2.4 0 6 0 32.5 0 7 0
1975 2.6 0 7 0 33.6 0 7 0
1976 3.7 3 9 8 44.1 28 9 6
1977 3.1 1 8 3 44.4 42 9 9
1978 3.0 4 8 10 36.1 33 8 7
1979 2.2 0 6 0 31.3 0 6 0
1980 2.2 0 6 0 29.1 0 6 0
1981 2.3 0 6 0 33.1 0 7 0
1982 2.7 2 7 5 34.1 14 7 3
1983 3.2 2 8 5 45.0 43 9 9
1984 2.4 0 6 0 33.1 0 6 0
1985 3.2 2 7 5 47.1 41 8 7
1986 2.2 1 6 3 32.9 18 6 3
1987 3.4 2 9 5 49.3 20 9 4
1988 2.1 0 5 0 34.4 0 6 0
1989 2.9 1 8 3 45.7 12 8 2
1990 3.3 2 9 5 59.8 24 10 4
1991 2.4 0 6 0 36.0 0 6 0
1992 3.0 1 8 3 54.5 21 9 3
1993 2.1 1 5 3 39.1 20 7 4
1994 1.8 0 5 0 33.1 0 5 0
1995 2.0 0 6 0 43.2 0 7 0
1996 2.3 1 6 3 41.7 14 7 2
1997 3.3 2 8 5 47.5 23 7 3
1998 1.3 0 4 0 20.8 0 4 0
1999 2.0 1 5 3 39.5 9 6 1
2000 2.1 0 5 0 40.2 0 5 0
2001 1.7 0 4 0 33.1 0 5 0
2002 1.8 1 5 3 31.6 11 5 2
2003 1.8 0 4 0 40.6 0 5 0
2004 2.3 1 6 2 44.5 26 6 3
2005 2.0 0 5 0 44.9 0 5 0
2006 1.3 0 3 0 31.8 0 4 0
2007 2.2 0 5 0 46.7 0 6 0
2008 1.7 0 4 0 35.7 0 4 0
2009 2.1 0 5 0 46.1 0 5 0
2010 1.8 0 4 0 45.0 0 5 0
2011 1.8 0 4 0 38.8 0 4 0
2012 2.3 0 5 0 40.5 0 5 0
2013 2.2 1 5 2 45.2 10 5 1

Definitions

Table A.6: Measures of the prominence of Definitions in each year’s journals.
Year Weight Raw W-Ratio R-Ratio W-Pages R-Pages WP-Ratio RP-Ratio
1876 0.7 0 13 0 4.2 0 9 0
1877 0.4 0 10 0 4.2 0 9 0
1878 0.9 1 21 25 5.2 3 12 7
1879 0.4 0 12 0 5.8 0 12 0
1880 0.3 0 10 0 4.6 0 9 0
1881 0.8 2 25 65 11.8 33 25 70
1882 0.1 0 4 0 1.7 0 4 0
1883 0.4 0 12 0 5.2 0 12 0
1884 0.1 0 3 0 1.8 0 4 0
1885 0.1 0 5 0 2.3 0 6 0
1886 0.1 0 4 0 1.3 0 3 0
1887 0.3 0 10 0 4.7 0 11 0
1888 0.6 1 14 24 9.9 20 19 38
1889 0.3 0 11 0 1.8 0 5 0
1890 0.3 0 6 0 4.8 0 7 0
1891 0.1 0 4 0 1.9 0 4 0
1892 0.6 0 10 0 10.6 0 11 0
1893 1.1 1 17 15 11.2 8 14 10
1894 0.7 0 10 0 10.3 0 11 0
1895 1.1 0 15 0 17.3 0 18 0
1896 1.2 1 18 15 15.9 14 17 15
1897 0.5 0 8 0 8.3 0 10 0
1898 0.8 0 16 0 9.4 0 11 0
1899 0.3 0 7 0 5.0 0 7 0
1900 0.6 0 11 0 6.5 0 9 0
1901 0.4 0 7 0 7.1 0 7 0
1902 1.1 1 23 21 20.2 39 22 42
1903 1.0 0 20 0 15.3 0 17 0
1904 0.9 0 17 0 13.4 0 14 0
1905 1.1 0 18 0 14.9 0 15 0
1906 1.2 2 19 32 18.1 28 16 25
1907 0.5 0 8 0 8.6 0 8 0
1908 1.0 0 15 0 13.0 0 13 0
1909 0.4 0 8 0 7.3 0 8 0
1910 2.0 1 35 17 25.8 3 25 3
1911 1.7 0 27 0 21.4 0 23 0
1912 1.2 0 18 0 18.3 0 17 0
1913 1.0 0 16 0 17.3 0 16 0
1914 1.0 0 14 0 16.1 0 14 0
1915 1.6 1 23 15 24.0 2 20 2
1916 1.1 0 14 0 17.7 0 13 0
1917 1.3 0 18 0 17.4 0 14 0
1918 1.3 0 17 0 23.6 0 16 0
1919 0.9 0 13 0 19.6 0 15 0
1920 1.1 1 17 15 20.0 13 19 12
1921 2.2 1 20 9 23.5 6 17 4
1922 3.3 0 24 0 33.0 0 21 0
1923 3.3 2 24 15 35.2 16 21 9
1924 2.7 1 24 9 29.4 1 19 1
1925 2.8 1 23 8 39.3 19 22 11
1926 2.1 1 17 8 26.6 8 16 5
1927 3.7 3 29 24 43.5 42 24 23
1928 2.9 3 22 23 38.0 33 21 18
1929 2.8 2 24 17 47.8 40 26 22
1930 3.8 3 36 29 47.2 30 31 20
1931 3.6 3 36 29 48.6 28 31 18
1932 3.8 2 31 16 43.7 7 24 4
1933 4.6 6 40 53 78.4 139 44 78
1934 10.0 15 52 78 90.7 120 40 53
1935 6.1 7 37 42 82.6 75 37 34
1936 8.2 8 44 43 101.2 68 42 28
1937 7.4 5 43 29 79.8 63 36 28
1938 6.8 5 34 25 102.5 84 38 31
1939 7.2 7 36 34 97.9 93 35 34
1940 6.4 3 31 14 76.1 38 28 14
1941 7.0 8 33 37 87.3 86 32 31
1942 7.4 8 35 38 80.8 90 31 34
1943 7.1 8 35 39 75.6 86 34 38
1944 8.4 7 45 37 96.2 56 38 22
1945 6.6 4 34 21 82.6 54 30 19
1946 8.0 7 36 31 83.1 58 29 20
1947 7.5 4 33 17 96.1 65 33 22
1948 8.1 6 32 23 104.0 80 34 26
1949 10.6 10 39 37 114.7 90 38 30
1950 11.5 11 42 40 116.3 81 37 26
1951 11.1 9 35 29 125.1 118 33 31
1952 10.3 7 33 22 107.0 66 29 18
1953 11.6 14 36 43 119.8 134 33 37
1954 10.9 12 32 36 108.8 102 28 26
1955 7.7 4 22 11 83.2 42 21 11
1956 10.7 8 30 23 119.6 93 31 24
1957 9.3 6 27 17 95.5 47 25 12
1958 8.7 1 23 3 97.0 9 24 2
1959 8.9 7 24 19 93.1 68 24 18
1960 9.4 7 27 20 109.2 92 29 24
1961 7.4 2 19 5 74.0 19 19 5
1962 7.6 6 20 16 72.9 52 20 14
1963 7.2 3 19 8 81.3 18 21 5
1964 8.6 8 22 21 84.7 61 22 16
1965 9.2 5 23 13 84.6 36 22 10
1966 7.3 3 19 8 68.2 23 18 6
1967 7.3 3 18 7 79.0 29 19 7
1968 7.7 6 19 15 96.6 78 23 18
1969 7.5 1 18 2 83.2 9 19 2
1970 7.7 1 18 2 88.2 22 18 5
1971 9.3 5 20 11 94.5 49 20 10
1972 5.5 2 12 4 66.9 19 14 4
1973 7.2 4 16 9 75.2 35 15 7
1974 4.6 1 12 2 53.5 9 11 2
1975 5.6 2 14 5 73.6 9 16 2
1976 4.7 2 12 5 61.3 32 13 7
1977 4.2 0 11 0 55.9 0 12 0
1978 4.8 1 12 3 61.9 11 13 2
1979 4.8 3 13 8 69.6 24 14 5
1980 4.0 1 11 3 57.8 9 12 2
1981 3.8 0 10 0 49.8 0 10 0
1982 3.2 0 8 0 49.0 0 10 0
1983 4.1 1 10 3 48.0 2 10 0
1984 4.5 1 12 3 54.1 2 10 0
1985 3.1 1 7 2 43.3 13 8 2
1986 4.2 1 10 3 54.9 20 10 4
1987 3.5 2 9 5 37.4 8 7 2
1988 3.2 1 8 3 51.6 25 9 5
1989 3.2 1 8 3 51.7 14 9 2
1990 2.5 1 7 3 43.3 18 7 3
1991 2.5 0 7 0 40.9 0 7 0
1992 2.9 0 8 0 46.3 0 8 0
1993 2.7 0 7 0 40.8 0 7 0
1994 2.4 0 7 0 44.7 0 7 0
1995 2.3 1 7 3 45.3 21 8 4
1996 3.2 1 8 3 59.1 20 10 3
1997 3.1 2 8 5 62.4 48 9 7
1998 2.4 2 7 6 40.2 15 7 3
1999 2.2 0 6 0 39.9 0 6 0
2000 2.9 1 6 2 45.7 2 6 0
2001 2.8 1 7 3 53.0 30 8 4
2002 2.0 0 5 0 40.1 0 6 0
2003 2.7 0 6 0 50.3 0 6 0
2004 2.7 1 7 2 48.9 13 7 2
2005 2.8 1 6 2 48.2 4 6 0
2006 1.8 0 4 0 40.8 0 5 0
2007 2.8 0 6 0 49.7 0 6 0
2008 2.3 0 5 0 43.0 0 5 0
2009 2.7 0 6 0 57.3 0 7 0
2010 1.9 0 4 0 38.1 0 4 0
2011 1.9 0 4 0 42.7 0 5 0
2012 2.0 0 5 0 42.2 0 5 0
2013 1.6 0 4 0 35.7 0 4 0

Propositions and Implications

Table A.7: Measures of the prominence of Propositions and Implications in each year’s journals.
Year Weight Raw W-Ratio R-Ratio W-Pages R-Pages WP-Ratio RP-Ratio
1876 0.6 1 13 20 2.5 2 5 4
1877 0.3 0 8 0 2.5 0 5 0
1878 0.5 0 12 0 4.6 0 10 0
1879 0.3 0 7 0 2.9 0 6 0
1880 0.4 1 13 30 6.5 16 13 33
1881 0.0 0 1 0 0.3 0 1 0
1882 0.8 1 25 31 3.7 2 8 5
1883 0.7 0 21 0 6.5 0 15 0
1884 0.0 0 1 0 0.5 0 1 0
1885 0.3 0 13 0 2.4 0 6 0
1886 0.0 0 0 0 0.2 0 1 0
1887 0.0 0 1 0 0.1 0 0 0
1888 0.4 0 11 0 2.0 0 4 0
1889 0.1 0 4 0 2.0 0 5 0
1890 0.5 1 11 21 7.8 14 11 21
1891 0.1 0 2 0 1.1 0 2 0
1892 1.4 3 23 50 22.7 62 25 67
1893 0.6 1 9 15 6.3 16 8 19
1894 2.0 3 29 43 13.2 33 14 36
1895 0.8 1 11 14 5.6 2 6 2
1896 0.6 1 9 15 6.3 3 7 3
1897 1.0 2 17 35 11.4 23 14 29
1898 0.5 0 10 0 10.1 0 12 0
1899 0.4 0 9 0 7.0 0 9 0
1900 0.8 1 16 20 9.2 10 12 13
1901 0.2 0 3 0 4.3 0 4 0
1902 0.6 2 13 42 10.0 29 11 31
1903 0.9 2 18 38 12.6 23 14 25
1904 0.6 2 11 35 10.6 35 11 37
1905 3.5 4 56 65 24.5 40 25 41
1906 0.5 0 8 0 8.7 0 8 0
1907 1.7 2 27 32 14.4 6 14 6
1908 2.6 5 40 76 14.0 16 14 16
1909 0.1 0 2 0 2.9 0 3 0
1910 1.5 1 26 17 19.2 14 19 14
1911 1.4 3 22 47 13.1 24 14 25
1912 1.7 3 26 45 20.4 41 19 37
1913 1.2 1 19 15 14.7 4 14 4
1914 2.1 3 31 44 17.8 18 15 15
1915 1.1 3 17 45 23.7 93 20 77
1916 1.0 0 13 0 16.0 0 11 0
1917 1.6 2 23 29 18.9 33 15 26
1918 1.3 2 17 26 19.6 28 13 19
1919 0.7 0 10 0 15.2 0 12 0
1920 1.0 2 16 31 14.7 28 14 27
1921 1.6 2 14 18 11.6 9 9 7
1922 2.7 4 19 28 18.2 25 11 16
1923 2.4 4 18 30 23.1 46 14 27
1924 1.3 1 11 9 11.5 3 7 2
1925 0.7 0 6 0 9.5 0 5 0
1926 1.1 0 9 0 13.7 0 8 0
1927 4.2 8 33 64 53.8 124 29 68
1928 3.6 7 27 53 48.3 93 27 52
1929 3.1 4 26 34 51.7 83 28 45
1930 2.8 2 27 19 40.0 22 27 15
1931 2.2 3 22 29 24.3 24 15 15
1932 3.2 3 27 25 40.3 33 23 18
1933 5.0 7 44 61 72.2 56 40 31
1934 6.9 6 36 31 69.5 42 30 18
1935 6.2 10 37 61 73.0 111 33 50
1936 9.1 9 49 48 116.0 113 48 47
1937 7.0 10 41 58 73.2 70 33 31
1938 6.6 11 33 56 82.4 132 31 49
1939 5.6 7 27 34 62.2 58 22 21
1940 5.7 6 28 29 58.7 54 22 20
1941 3.6 5 17 23 40.0 64 15 23
1942 4.2 4 20 19 36.2 17 14 6
1943 2.6 3 13 15 29.0 33 13 15
1944 3.1 5 16 27 53.3 82 21 33
1945 4.2 6 22 31 35.6 28 13 10
1946 4.1 5 18 22 50.7 48 18 17
1947 4.7 7 21 31 48.4 43 16 15
1948 5.5 7 21 27 62.1 59 20 19
1949 6.6 8 24 29 68.1 90 22 30
1950 4.8 5 17 18 41.8 19 13 6
1951 5.6 6 18 19 56.5 55 15 15
1952 4.5 4 14 13 46.9 32 13 9
1953 5.6 6 17 19 54.9 53 15 15
1954 6.0 6 18 18 60.8 47 16 12
1955 6.3 8 18 23 53.2 54 13 14
1956 4.8 6 14 17 61.8 94 16 24
1957 5.3 7 15 20 65.5 78 17 20
1958 5.8 9 16 24 74.3 134 18 33
1959 5.6 6 16 17 49.2 42 13 11
1960 7.4 11 22 32 64.9 86 17 23
1961 8.6 9 22 23 79.6 74 20 19
1962 6.5 5 18 14 49.5 22 13 6
1963 5.7 4 15 11 47.3 38 12 10
1964 7.0 6 18 16 69.6 63 18 17
1965 6.3 4 16 10 51.7 19 14 5
1966 7.9 7 21 18 64.4 59 17 15
1967 10.8 15 26 36 90.1 105 21 25
1968 7.6 9 19 23 69.0 34 16 8
1969 12.3 20 29 47 119.4 239 27 53
1970 9.1 8 21 18 93.9 71 19 15
1971 10.4 12 23 26 94.3 110 20 23
1972 9.3 12 21 27 80.7 80 17 17
1973 7.2 9 16 20 72.5 72 15 15
1974 8.2 10 20 25 68.1 73 14 15
1975 7.1 11 18 28 70.9 123 15 26
1976 3.7 2 9 5 39.4 16 8 3
1977 5.7 6 15 16 55.1 45 12 9
1978 4.1 2 11 5 41.7 16 9 3
1979 6.2 5 17 13 53.6 17 11 3
1980 4.6 2 12 5 48.4 27 10 5
1981 4.1 3 11 8 32.1 14 6 3
1982 4.8 5 12 13 46.8 26 10 5
1983 3.5 1 9 3 39.0 2 8 0
1984 4.8 2 12 5 52.3 7 10 1
1985 3.1 2 7 5 36.3 9 6 2
1986 5.0 5 12 13 51.8 41 10 8
1987 2.8 1 7 3 30.9 6 6 1
1988 3.3 2 8 5 33.7 20 6 4
1989 3.8 2 10 5 35.5 4 6 1
1990 2.5 0 7 0 34.6 0 6 0
1991 3.0 0 8 0 33.3 0 6 0
1992 3.0 0 8 0 42.5 0 7 0
1993 3.0 0 8 0 43.2 0 8 0
1994 2.2 1 6 3 37.8 4 6 1
1995 3.0 1 9 3 51.1 27 9 5
1996 2.4 0 6 0 39.3 0 6 0
1997 3.2 0 8 0 53.3 0 8 0
1998 3.4 2 10 6 48.8 12 8 2
1999 2.3 1 6 3 37.7 3 5 0
2000 3.3 0 7 0 51.7 0 7 0
2001 2.9 1 8 3 47.3 5 7 1
2002 2.3 0 6 0 38.6 0 6 0
2003 3.5 2 8 5 50.8 33 7 4
2004 3.2 1 8 2 49.0 7 7 1
2005 3.9 0 9 0 73.0 0 9 0
2006 2.4 0 6 0 48.6 0 6 0
2007 3.7 1 9 2 56.7 3 7 0
2008 4.3 2 10 5 70.9 47 9 6
2009 4.3 0 10 0 71.0 0 8 0
2010 4.1 1 9 2 64.6 5 7 1
2011 3.9 2 9 4 92.1 87 10 10
2012 4.1 3 10 7 73.3 21 9 3
2013 3.4 0 8 0 65.0 0 7 0

Beauty

Table A.8: Measures of the prominence of Beauty in each year’s journals.
Year Weight Raw W-Ratio R-Ratio W-Pages R-Pages WP-Ratio RP-Ratio
1876 0.3 1 7 20 4.3 12 9 25
1877 0.1 0 2 0 1.3 0 3 0
1878 0.7 0 17 0 6.4 0 14 0
1879 0.5 0 15 0 9.8 0 21 0
1880 0.5 1 14 30 9.5 20 19 41
1881 0.4 1 13 32 6.7 17 14 36
1882 0.2 0 7 0 2.6 0 6 0
1883 0.1 0 2 0 1.6 0 4 0
1884 0.1 0 5 0 1.7 0 4 0
1885 0.0 0 2 0 0.5 0 1 0
1886 0.0 0 0 0 0.0 0 0 0
1887 0.0 0 1 0 0.2 0 0 0
1888 0.1 0 1 0 0.8 0 1 0
1889 0.0 0 0 0 0.2 0 0 0
1890 1.6 3 35 64 28.8 50 42 73
1891 1.0 2 33 65 7.5 17 15 33
1892 1.0 1 17 17 14.6 2 16 2
1893 0.5 0 7 0 7.7 0 9 0
1894 0.6 0 9 0 9.0 0 10 0
1895 1.0 1 14 14 10.6 15 11 15
1896 0.6 1 9 15 9.6 16 10 17
1897 0.7 1 12 18 6.9 15 9 19
1898 0.1 0 2 0 1.5 0 2 0
1899 0.6 1 16 24 14.8 28 20 37
1900 0.7 1 13 20 7.9 11 10 14
1901 1.9 4 33 68 26.1 59 27 61
1902 0.3 0 7 0 5.4 0 6 0
1903 1.0 2 20 38 16.4 33 18 36
1904 0.5 1 9 18 5.1 8 5 8
1905 0.5 1 9 16 10.0 20 10 21
1906 0.3 0 5 0 5.2 0 5 0
1907 0.1 0 1 0 1.0 0 1 0
1908 0.3 0 4 0 3.9 0 4 0
1909 0.7 1 12 18 12.8 18 13 19
1910 1.1 2 20 34 15.4 24 15 24
1911 0.2 0 3 0 2.5 0 3 0
1912 0.4 0 6 0 4.9 0 5 0
1913 0.2 0 3 0 4.2 0 4 0
1914 0.4 1 6 15 3.6 7 3 6
1915 0.8 1 11 15 20.0 35 17 29
1916 0.2 0 3 0 3.2 0 2 0
1917 0.2 0 3 0 3.8 0 3 0
1918 0.8 1 10 13 13.4 22 9 15
1919 0.7 0 9 0 9.3 0 7 0
1920 2.0 4 30 62 24.6 44 24 42
1921 1.6 3 14 27 20.4 42 15 31
1922 2.8 6 20 43 31.2 76 20 48
1923 2.9 6 22 45 23.8 43 14 25
1924 1.9 3 16 26 25.9 49 16 31
1925 3.2 6 27 50 53.0 105 30 59
1926 4.4 9 35 73 54.5 120 32 70
1927 0.9 2 7 16 9.2 19 5 10
1928 4.4 8 33 60 47.5 81 26 45
1929 3.3 6 27 50 48.1 81 26 44
1930 2.1 4 20 38 28.0 52 19 35
1931 2.7 4 26 39 31.4 54 20 34
1932 1.0 2 8 16 33.3 73 19 41
1933 3.3 8 29 70 49.9 127 28 71
1934 2.4 5 12 26 40.8 88 18 39
1935 5.8 11 35 67 61.0 115 27 52
1936 2.6 4 14 22 29.9 49 12 20
1937 2.4 4 14 23 31.5 50 14 22
1938 6.0 11 30 56 62.8 115 23 43
1939 3.4 6 16 29 42.7 85 15 31
1940 4.9 9 24 43 57.4 102 21 38
1941 5.2 12 24 56 59.0 147 21 54
1942 5.8 10 28 48 46.3 75 18 29
1943 5.1 10 25 49 45.1 86 20 38
1944 7.9 15 42 80 65.7 133 26 53
1945 2.7 4 14 21 43.0 74 15 26
1946 4.0 7 18 31 52.5 89 18 31
1947 4.3 8 19 35 41.3 71 14 24
1948 6.6 12 26 47 74.9 149 24 48
1949 5.0 10 18 37 59.9 123 20 40
1950 4.9 9 18 33 51.8 101 16 32
1951 3.6 6 11 19 30.5 51 8 14
1952 7.5 14 24 44 68.6 122 19 33
1953 5.6 11 17 34 62.4 115 17 32
1954 3.9 7 11 21 53.9 112 14 29
1955 7.1 12 20 34 82.6 153 21 39
1956 3.7 6 11 17 47.1 73 12 19
1957 5.7 13 17 38 82.5 188 21 48
1958 7.6 15 20 40 69.4 142 17 35
1959 7.8 13 22 36 101.0 183 26 47
1960 4.8 7 14 20 61.3 102 16 27
1961 11.0 23 29 60 101.6 218 26 56
1962 5.9 13 16 35 63.0 158 17 43
1963 3.0 4 8 11 26.3 33 7 9
1964 4.1 8 11 21 42.2 83 11 22
1965 4.8 6 12 15 49.5 85 13 23
1966 2.5 5 7 13 23.8 35 6 9
1967 3.2 5 8 12 37.0 60 9 14
1968 3.6 6 9 15 50.2 89 12 21
1969 4.1 7 9 16 49.0 92 11 20
1970 4.2 7 10 16 49.7 94 10 19
1971 2.2 2 5 4 27.4 25 6 5
1972 4.9 7 11 16 64.5 112 13 23
1973 4.6 7 10 16 32.8 54 7 11
1974 2.5 5 6 12 27.0 55 6 11
1975 2.8 6 7 15 39.9 96 9 20
1976 2.3 2 6 5 25.6 29 5 6
1977 2.0 3 5 8 16.6 22 3 5
1978 3.4 7 9 18 38.3 80 8 17
1979 2.2 4 6 11 25.7 39 5 8
1980 2.8 4 7 11 46.9 82 9 16
1981 3.3 7 9 19 52.1 125 11 25
1982 2.1 4 5 10 26.4 48 5 10
1983 2.3 4 6 10 33.9 61 7 12
1984 1.7 2 4 5 18.9 24 4 5
1985 3.3 7 8 17 58.2 134 10 23
1986 1.2 2 3 5 18.6 30 3 6
1987 1.2 2 3 5 15.5 31 3 6
1988 2.0 2 5 5 23.8 21 4 4
1989 0.5 0 1 0 7.2 0 1 0
1990 1.8 3 5 8 27.5 49 5 8
1991 2.4 4 6 11 38.7 57 7 10
1992 0.5 1 1 3 7.3 14 1 2
1993 1.5 2 4 5 18.6 27 3 5
1994 0.3 0 1 0 8.5 0 1 0
1995 1.0 1 3 3 17.9 18 3 3
1996 1.8 3 5 8 34.4 63 6 10
1997 1.4 2 4 5 26.6 38 4 6
1998 0.2 0 1 0 3.6 0 1 0
1999 0.7 1 2 3 12.6 20 2 3
2000 2.5 4 5 9 46.3 79 6 10
2001 0.9 1 2 3 14.9 16 2 2
2002 1.4 3 4 8 37.5 88 6 14
2003 0.8 0 2 0 13.6 0 2 0
2004 0.4 1 1 2 10.7 27 1 4
2005 0.6 1 1 2 17.9 37 2 4
2006 0.8 1 2 2 13.7 18 2 2
2007 0.2 0 1 0 5.0 0 1 0
2008 1.6 1 4 2 26.0 19 3 2
2009 1.7 3 4 7 19.5 37 2 4
2010 2.6 4 5 9 33.7 70 4 8
2011 2.1 5 5 11 38.9 83 4 9
2012 2.3 4 6 10 42.8 82 5 10
2013 2.1 4 5 9 37.2 79 4 9

Physicalism

Table A.9: Measures of the prominence of Physicalism in each year’s journals.
Year Weight Raw W-Ratio R-Ratio W-Pages R-Pages WP-Ratio RP-Ratio
1876 0.4 0 8 0 4.0 0 8 0
1877 0.3 0 8 0 4.1 0 9 0
1878 0.8 1 19 25 4.5 2 10 4
1879 0.3 0 7 0 3.8 0 8 0
1880 0.4 0 11 0 2.1 0 4 0
1881 0.6 0 21 0 10.5 0 22 0
1882 0.8 1 24 31 8.0 5 19 11
1883 0.3 0 9 0 4.3 0 10 0
1884 0.1 0 5 0 1.7 0 4 0
1885 0.2 0 9 0 3.1 0 8 0
1886 0.4 0 14 0 3.2 0 8 0
1887 0.1 0 3 0 1.9 0 4 0
1888 1.2 2 29 48 9.0 5 17 10
1889 0.2 0 7 0 2.4 0 6 0
1890 1.3 1 27 21 10.3 2 15 3
1891 0.4 0 12 0 7.6 0 15 0
1892 0.9 0 15 0 13.0 0 14 0
1893 0.9 0 13 0 12.1 0 15 0
1894 1.3 2 19 29 13.6 13 15 14
1895 0.7 0 10 0 8.9 0 9 0
1896 0.6 0 9 0 7.2 0 8 0
1897 0.9 1 16 18 8.5 6 10 7
1898 0.7 1 13 19 8.1 8 10 10
1899 0.4 0 9 0 4.6 0 6 0
1900 1.0 0 20 0 10.1 0 13 0
1901 0.9 1 14 17 11.9 10 12 10
1902 0.4 0 9 0 6.3 0 7 0
1903 0.6 0 11 0 8.4 0 9 0
1904 1.4 1 24 18 17.6 6 19 6
1905 0.5 0 9 0 6.2 0 6 0
1906 0.7 0 12 0 10.2 0 9 0
1907 0.6 0 10 0 7.0 0 7 0
1908 0.5 0 8 0 9.2 0 9 0
1909 0.6 0 10 0 12.0 0 12 0
1910 1.0 0 17 0 21.7 0 21 0
1911 0.8 0 12 0 15.8 0 17 0
1912 1.5 2 23 30 18.1 8 16 7
1913 1.7 2 25 30 18.0 11 17 10
1914 1.2 1 17 15 20.4 5 17 4
1915 2.5 5 38 75 35.0 51 29 42
1916 1.6 2 20 26 24.4 26 17 19
1917 1.6 1 23 14 25.3 5 20 4
1918 2.1 3 27 39 35.1 34 23 23
1919 2.1 1 30 14 39.9 12 31 9
1920 2.2 2 33 31 31.3 28 30 27
1921 4.2 5 38 45 41.1 28 31 21
1922 7.5 15 53 106 74.8 160 47 101
1923 5.6 5 42 37 64.1 53 38 31
1924 4.7 4 41 35 60.3 51 38 32
1925 2.5 3 21 25 32.4 29 18 16
1926 4.0 3 32 24 59.0 12 35 7
1927 5.1 5 41 40 63.7 37 35 20
1928 5.1 5 38 38 52.8 40 29 22
1929 4.2 4 35 34 63.2 82 34 44
1930 1.9 0 19 0 32.0 0 21 0
1931 3.8 3 37 29 59.8 49 38 31
1932 3.8 6 31 49 54.5 88 31 49
1933 4.1 6 36 53 45.1 63 25 35
1934 9.5 7 49 36 96.2 79 42 35
1935 5.6 7 34 42 57.7 63 26 28
1936 4.3 4 23 22 59.8 69 25 28
1937 3.2 2 19 12 42.1 21 19 9
1938 4.7 3 24 15 62.0 44 23 16
1939 4.5 5 22 25 55.8 49 20 18
1940 4.6 4 22 19 57.0 38 21 14
1941 5.9 6 28 28 56.9 48 21 17
1942 6.6 11 31 52 60.7 99 23 38
1943 2.9 3 14 15 37.6 27 17 12
1944 5.0 7 27 37 64.3 103 26 41
1945 4.6 4 24 21 73.6 38 26 14
1946 5.5 11 25 49 61.4 133 21 46
1947 4.3 3 19 13 54.5 31 19 11
1948 4.2 6 16 23 42.9 62 14 20
1949 4.6 6 17 22 43.4 31 14 10
1950 5.8 6 21 22 66.1 60 21 19
1951 5.5 5 18 16 56.1 37 15 10
1952 6.9 5 22 16 61.6 32 17 9
1953 6.0 6 19 19 61.3 62 17 17
1954 5.2 6 16 18 62.3 77 16 20
1955 5.0 6 14 17 53.3 78 13 20
1956 3.6 1 10 3 40.6 11 11 3
1957 4.2 2 12 6 45.5 19 12 5
1958 6.8 6 18 16 62.4 54 15 13
1959 4.3 5 12 14 46.9 56 12 15
1960 4.3 6 12 17 46.2 69 12 18
1961 3.6 4 9 10 32.8 32 8 8
1962 4.6 5 12 14 37.4 29 10 8
1963 6.8 8 18 21 49.7 59 13 15
1964 4.5 3 12 8 45.0 30 12 8
1965 4.1 5 10 13 39.0 36 10 10
1966 5.0 7 13 18 48.1 61 12 16
1967 3.1 4 7 10 36.3 62 9 15
1968 2.5 1 6 3 27.1 2 6 0
1969 3.4 2 8 5 33.1 21 7 5
1970 6.6 7 15 16 71.6 93 15 19
1971 5.6 6 12 13 50.8 56 11 12
1972 3.9 2 9 4 37.0 19 8 4
1973 5.4 6 12 14 61.2 61 13 13
1974 3.1 3 8 7 44.9 59 9 12
1975 5.0 8 13 20 46.1 59 10 13
1976 3.2 2 8 5 40.3 42 8 9
1977 3.0 2 8 5 38.3 6 8 1
1978 3.8 3 10 8 44.2 30 9 6
1979 3.7 7 10 19 54.3 117 11 23
1980 2.5 0 7 0 30.6 0 6 0
1981 4.2 2 11 5 52.7 31 11 6
1982 4.6 3 12 8 53.6 41 11 8
1983 3.9 2 10 5 37.9 12 8 2
1984 6.0 7 15 18 50.2 38 10 7
1985 4.0 5 9 12 38.6 37 7 6
1986 3.8 3 10 8 46.5 18 9 3
1987 3.1 3 8 8 41.9 34 8 6
1988 2.5 0 6 0 37.1 0 7 0
1989 3.3 3 9 8 45.6 38 8 7
1990 3.6 3 9 8 42.9 29 7 5
1991 4.4 5 12 13 44.0 29 8 5
1992 3.4 0 10 0 55.5 0 9 0
1993 4.5 6 12 16 53.1 74 9 13
1994 2.9 1 8 3 46.7 21 8 3
1995 3.5 6 10 17 46.5 67 8 11
1996 4.2 3 11 8 51.5 15 8 2
1997 3.3 2 8 5 46.7 22 7 3
1998 2.8 1 8 3 44.8 3 8 1
1999 4.2 4 11 10 66.5 56 9 8
2000 3.6 3 8 7 55.6 50 7 7
2001 3.0 3 8 8 43.6 41 6 6
2002 2.5 0 7 0 42.6 0 7 0
2003 3.3 1 7 2 58.4 15 8 2
2004 2.2 0 5 0 34.8 0 5 0
2005 3.4 3 8 7 55.8 22 7 3
2006 2.3 0 6 0 42.2 0 5 0
2007 2.2 1 5 2 38.8 14 5 2
2008 1.7 0 4 0 36.4 0 4 0
2009 2.7 1 6 2 57.8 19 7 2
2010 2.9 2 6 4 49.9 53 6 6
2011 3.2 4 7 9 60.3 105 7 12
2012 2.3 1 5 2 40.9 23 5 3
2013 1.9 1 4 2 37.1 18 4 2

History and Culture

Table A.10: Measures of the prominence of History and Culture in each year’s journals.
Year Weight Raw W-Ratio R-Ratio W-Pages R-Pages WP-Ratio RP-Ratio
1876 0.2 0 3 0 1.7 0 4 0
1877 0.3 0 7 0 5.0 0 11 0
1878 0.3 0 8 0 3.9 0 9 0
1879 0.4 0 10 0 6.4 0 13 0
1880 0.1 0 2 0 1.3 0 3 0
1881 0.3 0 9 0 5.1 0 11 0
1882 0.2 0 6 0 3.2 0 7 0
1883 0.0 0 1 0 0.9 0 2 0
1884 0.1 0 4 0 0.9 0 2 0
1885 0.0 0 1 0 0.4 0 1 0
1886 0.2 0 7 0 4.4 0 11 0
1887 0.0 0 1 0 0.3 0 1 0
1888 0.7 0 17 0 3.3 0 6 0
1889 0.2 0 6 0 0.6 0 1 0
1890 0.4 0 9 0 5.5 0 8 0
1891 0.2 0 6 0 3.1 0 6 0
1892 0.3 0 5 0 5.5 0 6 0
1893 0.3 0 4 0 4.9 0 6 0
1894 0.5 1 7 14 8.6 17 9 19
1895 0.2 0 3 0 3.3 0 3 0
1896 0.6 0 9 0 7.8 0 8 0
1897 0.2 0 3 0 3.6 0 4 0
1898 0.5 0 10 0 7.0 0 9 0
1899 0.3 0 8 0 6.7 0 9 0
1900 0.2 0 4 0 2.4 0 3 0
1901 0.1 0 2 0 2.0 0 2 0
1902 0.6 0 12 0 9.2 0 10 0
1903 0.1 0 2 0 1.9 0 2 0
1904 0.1 0 2 0 1.8 0 2 0
1905 0.3 0 5 0 4.4 0 5 0
1906 0.4 0 6 0 7.4 0 7 0
1907 0.3 0 5 0 7.9 0 8 0
1908 0.3 0 5 0 4.8 0 5 0
1909 0.5 0 9 0 6.4 0 7 0
1910 0.4 0 7 0 7.2 0 7 0
1911 0.2 0 2 0 2.5 0 3 0
1912 0.5 0 7 0 9.0 0 8 0
1913 0.8 0 12 0 6.3 0 6 0
1914 0.2 0 3 0 5.1 0 4 0
1915 0.2 0 3 0 2.9 0 2 0
1916 0.5 0 7 0 10.5 0 7 0
1917 0.2 0 3 0 4.1 0 3 0
1918 0.3 0 3 0 4.2 0 3 0
1919 0.2 0 3 0 4.3 0 3 0
1920 0.6 0 9 0 7.1 0 7 0
1921 1.2 1 10 9 11.9 19 9 14
1922 1.3 1 9 7 15.4 10 10 6
1923 2.5 2 19 15 32.6 19 19 11
1924 1.5 2 13 17 16.0 20 10 13
1925 1.6 2 14 17 27.8 31 16 17
1926 3.6 5 29 40 44.9 67 26 39
1927 1.2 1 10 8 18.7 9 10 5
1928 2.8 5 21 38 31.1 52 17 29
1929 1.5 2 13 17 28.3 41 15 22
1930 0.8 0 8 0 11.7 0 8 0
1931 1.0 2 10 20 19.3 36 12 23
1932 3.3 5 27 41 57.3 74 32 41
1933 1.8 2 16 18 28.3 36 16 20
1934 1.4 1 7 5 23.6 21 10 9
1935 2.1 2 13 12 37.3 49 17 22
1936 1.3 0 7 0 17.5 0 7 0
1937 2.1 2 12 12 25.5 22 11 10
1938 3.1 5 16 25 41.4 49 15 18
1939 4.9 8 24 39 66.0 121 24 44
1940 3.4 7 17 34 56.2 108 21 40
1941 3.0 3 14 14 30.7 29 11 11
1942 3.5 4 17 19 48.0 48 18 18
1943 7.6 9 37 44 61.4 51 27 23
1944 4.3 8 23 43 70.7 136 28 54
1945 4.1 6 21 31 57.3 109 20 39
1946 5.0 6 22 27 77.2 93 27 32
1947 6.4 12 28 52 84.7 184 29 63
1948 6.6 11 26 43 94.6 156 31 51
1949 9.4 15 35 55 120.7 194 40 64
1950 4.6 6 17 22 45.9 49 15 16
1951 6.4 7 20 22 78.2 98 21 26
1952 5.5 8 17 25 72.4 103 20 28
1953 7.8 13 24 40 77.4 146 22 41
1954 5.3 9 16 27 73.5 148 19 38
1955 8.1 14 23 40 91.8 169 23 43
1956 7.3 11 21 31 96.0 141 25 36
1957 6.6 8 19 23 78.7 85 20 22
1958 7.6 11 20 30 74.7 96 19 24
1959 4.4 4 12 11 55.1 59 14 15
1960 5.2 8 15 23 60.6 101 16 27
1961 4.5 6 12 16 53.7 84 14 22
1962 4.9 6 13 16 58.4 66 16 18
1963 3.1 4 8 11 37.3 44 10 11
1964 4.6 8 12 21 35.9 55 9 14
1965 3.5 3 9 8 32.2 35 9 9
1966 4.9 7 13 18 39.6 54 10 14
1967 4.1 6 10 15 45.9 72 11 17
1968 1.7 0 4 0 15.6 0 4 0
1969 4.7 5 11 12 55.5 66 12 15
1970 3.3 6 8 14 30.2 50 6 10
1971 2.2 2 5 4 25.9 18 5 4
1972 3.1 6 7 13 36.5 79 8 16
1973 3.0 5 7 11 42.5 66 9 14
1974 1.8 1 5 2 27.1 15 6 3
1975 2.4 3 6 8 33.6 35 7 7
1976 2.5 4 6 10 25.4 56 5 11
1977 2.4 1 6 3 29.3 2 6 0
1978 2.3 2 6 5 25.9 15 5 3
1979 1.8 1 5 3 35.3 15 7 3
1980 3.0 4 8 11 32.9 29 7 6
1981 2.2 2 6 5 29.3 32 6 6
1982 2.3 2 6 5 25.0 16 5 3
1983 1.5 0 4 0 16.7 0 3 0
1984 1.9 2 5 5 22.0 18 4 3
1985 4.3 6 10 14 47.4 87 8 15
1986 1.6 1 4 3 22.8 24 4 4
1987 0.7 0 2 0 12.4 0 2 0
1988 1.5 2 4 5 30.9 64 6 12
1989 1.1 0 3 0 14.8 0 3 0
1990 1.2 1 3 3 16.6 9 3 2
1991 3.3 5 9 13 22.4 18 4 3
1992 1.2 2 3 6 31.2 57 5 9
1993 1.3 1 3 3 16.2 16 3 3
1994 1.5 2 4 5 28.8 37 5 6
1995 0.7 1 2 3 16.7 30 3 5
1996 2.4 3 6 8 44.0 72 7 12
1997 0.8 1 2 2 13.2 14 2 2
1998 0.8 0 2 0 16.6 0 3 0
1999 0.6 0 1 0 9.1 0 1 0
2000 0.6 0 1 0 11.6 0 2 0
2001 0.9 0 2 0 14.8 0 2 0
2002 0.8 0 2 0 14.7 0 2 0
2003 1.0 1 2 2 22.3 25 3 3
2004 0.9 0 2 0 16.1 0 2 0
2005 0.8 0 2 0 14.8 0 2 0
2006 0.6 0 2 0 12.7 0 2 0
2007 0.8 0 2 0 16.2 0 2 0
2008 0.8 1 2 2 19.1 31 2 4
2009 0.8 0 2 0 12.6 0 1 0
2010 0.6 0 1 0 14.1 0 2 0
2011 1.2 0 3 0 21.7 0 2 0
2012 0.6 0 1 0 12.7 0 2 0
2013 1.0 0 2 0 23.4 0 3 0

Faith and Theism

Table A.11: Measures of the prominence of Faith and Theism in each year’s journals.
Year Weight Raw W-Ratio R-Ratio W-Pages R-Pages WP-Ratio RP-Ratio
1876 0.1 0 2 0 1.2 0 3 0
1877 0.5 0 13 0 6.4 0 14 0
1878 0.3 0 8 0 5.5 0 12 0
1879 0.4 1 12 28 7.4 17 15 36
1880 0.3 0 8 0 5.3 0 11 0
1881 0.1 0 3 0 2.5 0 5 0
1882 0.2 0 5 0 2.8 0 6 0
1883 0.9 1 29 31 11.2 3 26 7
1884 0.2 0 8 0 4.9 0 11 0
1885 0.1 0 5 0 1.4 0 3 0
1886 0.3 0 11 0 4.9 0 12 0
1887 0.3 0 9 0 6.1 0 14 0
1888 0.5 0 11 0 5.5 0 11 0
1889 0.1 0 4 0 1.5 0 4 0
1890 0.9 1 19 21 11.9 12 17 18
1891 0.2 0 7 0 2.7 0 5 0
1892 0.6 1 10 17 9.4 17 10 18
1893 0.6 1 8 15 10.7 23 13 28
1894 1.1 1 16 14 16.0 14 18 15
1895 1.1 1 16 14 16.0 11 16 11
1896 1.7 3 26 46 24.4 29 26 31
1897 0.7 0 13 0 9.2 0 11 0
1898 0.3 0 6 0 4.3 0 5 0
1899 0.4 0 9 0 5.0 0 7 0
1900 0.3 0 6 0 5.7 0 7 0
1901 0.7 1 12 17 8.2 11 8 11
1902 1.0 1 21 21 12.5 11 13 12
1903 0.6 1 11 19 6.6 8 7 9
1904 0.5 0 8 0 8.8 0 9 0
1905 0.9 2 15 32 14.5 29 15 30
1906 0.5 0 8 0 8.9 0 8 0
1907 0.4 0 7 0 8.1 0 8 0
1908 0.2 0 3 0 3.9 0 4 0
1909 1.2 1 21 18 16.5 3 17 3
1910 0.4 0 6 0 5.5 0 5 0
1911 0.6 0 9 0 6.5 0 7 0
1912 0.4 1 7 15 10.0 24 9 22
1913 0.5 1 8 15 5.9 13 6 12
1914 0.8 1 11 15 11.8 10 10 9
1915 1.0 1 15 15 19.6 17 16 14
1916 2.6 3 33 39 43.9 45 31 32
1917 0.7 1 10 14 15.5 17 12 13
1918 2.2 3 28 39 48.5 78 32 52
1919 1.5 1 21 14 32.3 20 25 15
1920 2.2 3 34 46 40.5 54 39 52
1921 2.0 3 18 27 20.5 24 15 18
1922 1.4 1 10 7 15.2 10 10 6
1923 2.9 3 22 22 44.0 41 26 24
1924 3.7 6 32 52 50.0 71 31 45
1925 1.4 0 11 0 22.9 0 13 0
1926 2.7 5 22 40 42.0 107 25 63
1927 2.4 2 19 16 34.0 17 19 9
1928 2.5 2 19 15 36.0 37 20 21
1929 1.7 0 15 0 29.6 0 16 0
1930 2.3 3 22 29 36.9 50 25 33
1931 1.6 2 15 20 30.0 47 19 30
1932 1.0 1 8 8 15.7 6 9 3
1933 1.0 1 9 9 11.5 6 6 3
1934 1.2 0 6 0 20.4 0 9 0
1935 1.7 0 10 0 28.5 0 13 0
1936 2.2 2 12 11 26.8 19 11 8
1937 1.6 1 9 6 25.6 22 11 10
1938 2.3 4 11 20 29.6 38 11 14
1939 1.6 1 8 5 24.6 10 9 4
1940 2.3 1 11 5 31.1 15 12 6
1941 2.4 0 11 0 29.5 0 11 0
1942 2.5 2 12 10 44.7 42 17 16
1943 2.7 3 13 15 23.1 18 10 8
1944 3.4 5 18 27 46.1 51 18 20
1945 5.0 8 26 41 38.6 33 14 12
1946 2.9 3 13 13 33.9 25 12 9
1947 3.1 5 14 22 46.9 69 16 23
1948 4.0 4 16 16 45.0 53 15 17
1949 4.9 5 18 18 46.4 38 15 12
1950 2.2 3 8 11 22.2 25 7 8
1951 4.7 6 15 19 39.9 46 11 12
1952 2.7 3 9 9 37.9 40 10 11
1953 3.0 3 9 9 35.5 43 10 12
1954 4.2 3 12 9 51.0 57 13 15
1955 4.1 4 12 11 55.0 62 14 16
1956 6.5 10 18 28 55.7 72 14 19
1957 3.5 4 10 12 30.8 27 8 7
1958 7.8 13 21 35 90.2 160 22 40
1959 4.7 8 13 22 46.4 89 12 23
1960 4.9 8 14 23 53.5 99 14 26
1961 5.2 5 13 13 49.5 45 13 12
1962 3.0 4 8 11 23.6 36 6 10
1963 3.8 5 10 13 43.9 49 11 13
1964 4.9 9 13 24 54.8 104 14 27
1965 3.4 5 9 13 27.4 55 7 15
1966 1.9 1 5 3 22.8 5 6 1
1967 3.6 5 9 12 42.9 79 10 19
1968 2.7 3 7 8 24.5 22 6 5
1969 3.8 4 9 9 37.5 33 8 7
1970 2.7 2 6 5 25.1 19 5 4
1971 1.7 2 4 4 13.1 9 3 2
1972 2.3 4 5 9 27.4 63 6 13
1973 2.2 3 5 7 20.5 20 4 4
1974 4.2 5 10 12 29.5 29 6 6
1975 3.0 4 8 10 31.6 40 7 9
1976 1.4 1 4 3 11.2 4 2 1
1977 3.7 7 10 19 40.1 66 8 14
1978 3.1 4 8 10 23.1 23 5 5
1979 1.8 2 5 5 19.9 25 4 5
1980 2.0 0 5 0 19.2 0 4 0
1981 1.4 1 4 3 16.2 4 3 1
1982 2.4 2 6 5 27.0 24 5 5
1983 4.9 7 12 18 48.2 47 10 10
1984 1.8 1 5 3 25.0 8 5 2
1985 2.3 3 5 7 26.7 28 5 5
1986 3.6 6 9 15 23.6 47 4 9
1987 2.7 4 7 10 18.2 18 3 3
1988 3.0 3 8 8 30.5 33 6 6
1989 3.0 6 8 16 49.8 87 9 15
1990 2.7 4 7 11 33.3 48 6 8
1991 1.8 1 5 3 20.9 24 4 4
1992 1.3 2 4 6 27.2 42 4 7
1993 2.0 3 5 8 28.6 39 5 7
1994 1.3 3 4 8 16.0 27 3 4
1995 1.1 0 3 0 17.8 0 3 0
1996 0.6 0 2 0 9.0 0 1 0
1997 1.5 1 4 2 14.5 11 2 2
1998 1.9 2 6 6 28.9 35 5 6
1999 0.9 0 2 0 13.9 0 2 0
2000 1.6 2 4 4 19.8 21 3 3
2001 1.5 2 4 5 21.1 10 3 1
2002 0.3 0 1 0 6.5 0 1 0
2003 0.8 0 2 0 15.0 0 2 0
2004 1.2 2 3 5 29.7 32 4 4
2005 1.4 0 3 0 27.5 0 3 0
2006 0.9 0 2 0 17.4 0 2 0
2007 1.5 1 3 2 32.8 20 4 2
2008 2.4 3 5 7 47.0 58 6 7
2009 1.2 0 3 0 17.6 0 2 0
2010 1.5 1 3 2 22.2 12 3 1
2011 2.9 4 6 9 42.2 59 5 6
2012 1.4 0 3 0 19.8 0 2 0
2013 1.1 0 2 0 14.8 0 2 0

Self-Consciousness

Table A.12: Measures of the prominence of Self-Consciousness in each year’s journals.
Year Weight Raw W-Ratio R-Ratio W-Pages R-Pages WP-Ratio RP-Ratio
1876 1.3 0 25 0 8.6 0 18 0
1877 1.3 2 32 50 11.9 16 26 34
1878 0.3 0 9 0 4.1 0 9 0
1879 1.0 1 27 28 7.9 6 17 13
1880 0.4 0 13 0 7.2 0 15 0
1881 1.5 1 49 32 17.0 7 36 15
1882 0.6 0 20 0 13.6 0 31 0
1883 0.9 0 27 0 10.0 0 23 0
1884 0.6 0 23 0 13.7 0 32 0
1885 0.5 0 23 0 10.2 0 26 0
1886 0.9 0 32 0 16.3 0 40 0
1887 1.2 1 39 32 12.6 7 28 16
1888 1.4 0 33 0 21.1 0 41 0
1889 0.8 0 30 0 11.1 0 28 0
1890 1.6 0 34 0 22.7 0 33 0
1891 0.6 0 19 0 9.4 0 18 0
1892 1.7 0 29 0 25.7 0 28 0
1893 2.2 0 33 0 30.3 0 37 0
1894 3.1 2 45 29 39.0 18 43 20
1895 2.5 0 35 0 28.4 0 29 0
1896 2.1 2 32 31 19.6 9 21 10
1897 2.4 1 42 18 36.1 17 45 21
1898 1.3 0 25 0 16.2 0 20 0
1899 1.3 0 33 0 19.8 0 26 0
1900 1.7 1 34 20 25.3 12 33 16
1901 3.2 1 55 17 41.6 2 43 2
1902 1.1 0 24 0 22.8 0 25 0
1903 2.0 1 38 19 36.3 10 40 11
1904 2.3 2 40 35 29.6 12 31 13
1905 2.2 1 35 16 28.9 3 30 3
1906 1.8 0 29 0 28.3 0 25 0
1907 1.1 0 17 0 22.7 0 22 0
1908 2.1 0 32 0 32.5 0 33 0
1909 1.6 0 28 0 24.6 0 26 0
1910 1.4 1 25 17 25.7 12 25 12
1911 1.9 1 29 16 29.5 8 31 8
1912 1.7 1 26 15 27.4 8 25 7
1913 2.7 2 40 30 30.9 4 29 4
1914 1.3 0 19 0 24.4 0 21 0
1915 1.3 0 20 0 20.5 0 17 0
1916 1.2 0 15 0 20.4 0 15 0
1917 1.2 0 18 0 23.8 0 19 0
1918 1.5 1 20 13 35.5 20 24 13
1919 2.1 0 30 0 34.5 0 27 0
1920 1.5 0 23 0 22.7 0 22 0
1921 1.2 0 11 0 14.0 0 10 0
1922 4.2 4 30 28 39.1 23 25 15
1923 3.6 4 26 30 47.4 44 28 26
1924 1.3 1 11 9 15.1 6 10 4
1925 1.9 0 16 0 24.0 0 14 0
1926 1.6 0 13 0 22.0 0 13 0
1927 2.1 0 17 0 27.3 0 15 0
1928 2.5 2 19 15 29.6 10 16 6
1929 1.6 0 13 0 22.9 0 12 0
1930 1.1 1 11 10 19.2 24 13 16
1931 1.1 0 11 0 14.2 0 9 0
1932 1.2 0 10 0 19.7 0 11 0
1933 1.7 0 15 0 22.1 0 12 0
1934 1.8 0 10 0 23.4 0 10 0
1935 2.1 1 13 6 23.3 3 10 1
1936 1.3 1 7 5 17.5 8 7 3
1937 1.3 0 7 0 18.1 0 8 0
1938 1.6 1 8 5 19.6 6 7 2
1939 1.2 0 6 0 20.0 0 7 0
1940 2.1 0 10 0 29.2 0 11 0
1941 3.6 2 17 9 33.3 6 12 2
1942 2.4 1 12 5 35.9 30 14 11
1943 2.1 2 10 10 24.7 38 11 17
1944 2.7 1 14 5 32.7 3 13 1
1945 2.0 1 10 5 26.7 8 10 3
1946 2.1 0 10 0 28.4 0 10 0
1947 2.2 0 9 0 25.1 0 9 0
1948 3.0 2 12 8 28.8 9 9 3
1949 2.3 0 9 0 24.0 0 8 0
1950 1.3 0 5 0 16.5 0 5 0
1951 2.1 0 7 0 21.1 0 6 0
1952 2.1 1 7 3 22.3 7 6 2
1953 2.5 0 8 0 26.5 0 7 0
1954 2.0 0 6 0 23.4 0 6 0
1955 2.3 1 7 3 24.1 8 6 2
1956 3.0 0 9 0 36.5 0 9 0
1957 2.1 1 6 3 22.6 15 6 4
1958 2.7 0 7 0 28.9 0 7 0
1959 3.4 1 9 3 36.2 5 9 1
1960 2.6 1 7 3 26.3 7 7 2
1961 3.0 2 8 5 21.8 3 6 1
1962 3.0 1 8 3 23.8 4 6 1
1963 3.2 0 9 0 32.9 0 9 0
1964 2.7 1 7 3 26.0 6 7 2
1965 2.2 0 6 0 21.0 0 6 0
1966 2.2 0 6 0 22.2 0 6 0
1967 3.1 1 7 2 26.0 8 6 2
1968 2.9 1 7 3 28.9 13 7 3
1969 2.9 0 7 0 25.5 0 6 0
1970 2.2 1 5 2 28.8 14 6 3
1971 2.3 1 5 2 27.4 19 6 4
1972 2.0 0 4 0 21.1 0 4 0
1973 3.0 2 7 5 31.2 11 6 2
1974 2.2 1 6 2 26.6 4 5 1
1975 3.0 1 8 3 31.4 12 7 3
1976 2.5 1 6 3 28.7 1 6 0
1977 3.0 2 8 5 33.0 12 7 3
1978 2.2 1 6 3 26.5 9 6 2
1979 2.4 1 6 3 28.5 5 6 1
1980 2.1 2 6 5 25.5 27 5 5
1981 3.4 3 9 8 45.6 26 9 5
1982 2.4 1 6 3 28.6 25 6 5
1983 3.7 2 9 5 44.5 24 9 5
1984 2.0 1 5 3 32.6 19 6 4
1985 2.8 2 7 5 34.2 12 6 2
1986 2.3 1 6 3 29.7 7 6 1
1987 2.2 1 6 3 27.3 10 5 2
1988 1.4 0 3 0 24.5 0 4 0
1989 2.3 1 6 3 40.0 12 7 2
1990 2.7 0 7 0 40.2 0 7 0
1991 2.0 2 5 5 30.4 31 5 6
1992 2.1 1 6 3 32.7 18 5 3
1993 2.6 1 7 3 35.0 21 6 4
1994 3.0 2 8 5 44.8 25 7 4
1995 2.6 2 8 6 49.1 33 8 6
1996 3.1 1 8 3 56.9 20 9 3
1997 3.0 1 7 2 39.3 6 6 1
1998 1.9 0 6 0 27.3 0 5 0
1999 2.9 1 7 3 54.3 7 8 1
2000 2.0 0 4 0 36.7 0 5 0
2001 3.4 2 9 5 53.4 36 8 5
2002 2.3 0 6 0 42.7 0 7 0
2003 3.4 4 8 9 53.8 49 7 6
2004 2.8 1 7 2 47.3 19 6 3
2005 2.0 0 4 0 39.7 0 5 0
2006 1.1 0 3 0 22.5 0 3 0
2007 2.4 1 6 2 44.3 22 5 3
2008 2.4 1 5 2 57.3 28 7 3
2009 2.0 1 5 2 42.1 32 5 4
2010 2.9 2 6 4 53.3 25 6 3
2011 4.1 3 9 7 70.3 41 8 4
2012 2.0 2 5 5 41.9 37 5 4
2013 2.1 1 5 2 33.6 10 4 1

Ancient

Table A.13: Measures of the prominence of Ancient in each year’s journals.
Year Weight Raw W-Ratio R-Ratio W-Pages R-Pages WP-Ratio RP-Ratio
1876 0.2 0 4 0 2.0 0 4 0
1877 0.2 0 4 0 2.1 0 4 0
1878 0.1 0 3 0 0.9 0 2 0
1879 0.3 1 9 28 5.4 22 11 46
1880 0.1 0 3 0 1.7 0 4 0
1881 0.3 1 10 32 4.5 13 10 28
1882 0.4 0 13 0 9.3 0 21 0
1883 0.1 0 3 0 2.7 0 6 0
1884 0.1 0 5 0 3.3 0 8 0
1885 0.0 0 0 0 0.0 0 0 0
1886 0.7 2 23 69 12.2 32 30 78
1887 0.0 0 1 0 0.7 0 2 0
1888 0.4 0 10 0 2.3 0 4 0
1889 0.0 0 0 0 0.1 0 0 0
1890 0.4 1 9 21 5.8 14 9 21
1891 0.2 0 7 0 2.9 0 6 0
1892 0.7 1 11 17 8.7 13 9 14
1893 0.8 1 12 15 10.4 12 13 14
1894 0.8 1 12 14 9.5 9 10 10
1895 1.2 1 16 14 12.8 10 13 10
1896 1.1 2 17 31 20.8 28 22 30
1897 1.3 1 22 18 22.0 6 27 7
1898 0.7 0 14 0 16.6 0 20 0
1899 0.3 0 6 0 4.3 0 6 0
1900 0.4 1 8 20 6.3 16 8 21
1901 1.2 2 21 34 19.9 32 20 33
1902 0.6 1 14 21 11.4 23 12 25
1903 1.5 2 29 38 14.4 10 16 11
1904 0.8 1 14 18 12.3 15 13 16
1905 0.4 1 7 16 7.5 19 8 20
1906 1.0 2 16 32 10.3 17 9 15
1907 0.5 0 9 0 10.5 0 10 0
1908 1.9 4 29 61 29.5 72 30 73
1909 2.4 4 42 71 28.9 50 30 52
1910 0.8 2 14 34 9.5 28 9 28
1911 2.1 5 33 78 18.3 44 19 47
1912 0.7 0 11 0 11.5 0 11 0
1913 0.5 1 8 15 7.2 12 7 11
1914 1.7 1 25 15 15.0 1 13 1
1915 1.4 3 21 45 16.3 41 13 34
1916 1.8 5 23 65 55.5 173 40 123
1917 0.7 1 11 14 14.7 14 12 11
1918 0.8 0 11 0 18.6 0 12 0
1919 1.0 1 15 14 16.1 11 12 9
1920 1.0 1 16 15 15.0 19 14 18
1921 2.1 3 19 27 23.3 41 17 31
1922 2.2 4 16 28 23.6 38 15 24
1923 1.0 1 7 7 11.0 9 6 5
1924 1.5 1 13 9 16.4 5 10 3
1925 3.1 4 26 34 48.8 58 28 33
1926 1.1 0 9 0 16.6 0 10 0
1927 2.6 3 21 24 29.9 25 16 14
1928 1.9 3 15 23 32.7 51 18 28
1929 1.0 2 9 17 16.7 41 9 22
1930 1.1 1 11 10 19.6 18 13 12
1931 0.8 0 8 0 10.7 0 7 0
1932 1.3 3 11 25 23.1 51 13 29
1933 1.1 2 10 18 14.3 25 8 14
1934 3.4 5 17 26 46.3 77 20 34
1935 4.0 7 24 42 49.8 98 22 44
1936 5.2 7 28 38 65.9 85 27 35
1937 2.4 5 14 29 27.8 58 12 26
1938 2.4 3 12 15 42.3 61 16 23
1939 3.8 6 19 29 57.7 112 21 40
1940 3.2 5 16 24 43.3 80 16 30
1941 2.9 4 14 19 49.3 72 18 26
1942 2.7 3 13 14 50.4 55 19 21
1943 2.3 4 11 20 30.8 44 14 20
1944 2.2 2 12 11 34.5 33 14 13
1945 2.5 3 13 15 42.8 83 15 30
1946 2.7 2 12 9 26.8 17 9 6
1947 2.2 3 10 13 41.5 65 14 22
1948 2.1 2 8 8 23.2 10 8 3
1949 3.1 3 12 11 26.1 21 9 7
1950 4.6 8 17 29 85.3 165 27 52
1951 3.8 4 12 13 41.2 50 11 13
1952 2.8 2 9 6 40.3 51 11 14
1953 5.1 7 16 22 68.9 128 19 36
1954 3.6 2 11 6 49.0 49 13 13
1955 4.1 7 12 20 50.2 87 13 22
1956 3.7 5 10 14 37.8 46 10 12
1957 5.0 6 14 17 42.4 41 11 11
1958 3.1 4 8 11 42.7 68 11 17
1959 3.0 5 8 14 28.9 60 7 16
1960 4.5 7 13 20 42.5 40 11 11
1961 4.0 5 10 13 38.5 41 10 11
1962 4.9 7 13 19 53.5 75 15 20
1963 4.9 7 13 19 62.8 98 16 25
1964 6.7 16 18 42 82.8 200 22 52
1965 3.8 7 10 18 47.2 115 13 31
1966 2.7 4 7 11 38.6 70 10 18
1967 4.5 5 11 12 43.4 51 10 12
1968 4.4 6 11 15 42.4 44 10 10
1969 6.4 10 15 23 82.7 159 18 35
1970 4.0 5 9 12 49.6 81 10 17
1971 3.9 6 9 13 40.5 65 9 14
1972 5.1 6 11 13 69.3 100 14 21
1973 6.5 11 15 25 67.6 154 14 32
1974 3.2 5 8 12 51.0 80 10 16
1975 3.0 2 8 5 46.8 50 10 11
1976 3.9 6 10 15 61.7 95 13 19
1977 4.4 7 12 19 74.6 135 16 28
1978 4.2 7 11 18 70.6 110 15 23
1979 4.0 8 11 21 63.8 133 13 26
1980 2.6 3 7 8 54.2 63 11 13
1981 2.8 5 8 13 34.9 66 7 13
1982 3.9 6 10 15 68.4 136 14 28
1983 3.4 5 9 13 40.5 66 8 13
1984 2.8 3 7 8 51.4 53 10 10
1985 2.6 5 6 12 42.1 102 7 18
1986 1.8 2 5 5 29.0 46 5 9
1987 1.2 1 3 3 17.1 8 3 2
1988 2.6 2 6 5 46.3 40 8 7
1989 0.5 0 1 0 7.7 0 1 0
1990 2.1 4 6 11 34.0 63 6 11
1991 1.9 3 5 8 40.0 77 7 14
1992 1.3 2 4 6 31.2 48 5 8
1993 1.7 1 5 3 35.4 27 6 5
1994 1.6 2 4 5 31.6 35 5 6
1995 2.4 5 7 15 33.6 66 6 11
1996 1.1 3 3 8 27.2 79 4 13
1997 1.4 2 3 5 44.1 88 7 13
1998 1.8 3 6 9 55.2 118 9 20
1999 1.4 4 4 10 28.9 88 4 12
2000 2.3 3 5 7 37.1 46 5 6
2001 1.6 1 4 3 27.8 23 4 3
2002 1.0 1 3 3 25.3 65 4 10
2003 0.7 1 2 2 15.4 27 2 3
2004 2.9 5 7 12 75.5 146 10 20
2005 2.0 3 4 7 55.6 108 7 13
2006 3.6 5 9 12 74.3 113 9 14
2007 1.4 1 3 2 28.8 23 4 3
2008 1.2 1 3 2 32.4 51 4 6
2009 1.2 3 3 7 29.1 72 3 9
2010 1.2 1 3 2 27.6 24 3 3
2011 1.3 1 3 2 30.3 21 3 2
2012 1.3 2 3 5 30.2 47 4 6
2013 1.4 1 3 2 36.6 46 4 5

Universals and Particulars

Table A.14: Measures of the prominence of Universals and Particulars in each year’s journals.
Year Weight Raw W-Ratio R-Ratio W-Pages R-Pages WP-Ratio RP-Ratio
1876 0.7 1 14 20 2.9 2 6 4
1877 0.3 1 8 25 3.9 17 8 36
1878 0.4 0 9 0 3.4 0 7 0
1879 0.6 0 18 0 5.0 0 10 0
1880 0.5 0 15 0 7.6 0 16 0
1881 0.2 0 7 0 4.4 0 9 0
1882 0.3 0 8 0 4.6 0 11 0
1883 0.9 2 29 62 10.9 32 25 74
1884 0.2 0 6 0 3.3 0 8 0
1885 0.3 0 13 0 3.2 0 8 0
1886 0.3 0 10 0 2.5 0 6 0
1887 0.9 3 30 97 7.3 30 17 68
1888 0.9 2 22 48 4.9 6 9 12
1889 0.1 0 5 0 2.9 0 7 0
1890 0.5 0 11 0 7.8 0 11 0
1891 0.3 0 9 0 5.1 0 10 0
1892 0.9 0 15 0 12.4 0 13 0
1893 1.1 1 18 15 8.3 5 10 6
1894 1.2 1 17 14 12.4 4 14 4
1895 0.6 0 8 0 7.1 0 7 0
1896 0.4 0 6 0 6.1 0 7 0
1897 1.2 1 22 18 22.7 17 28 21
1898 0.3 0 7 0 5.9 0 7 0
1899 0.3 0 8 0 7.5 0 10 0
1900 0.5 0 9 0 9.5 0 12 0
1901 0.7 0 11 0 12.5 0 13 0
1902 0.6 0 13 0 10.9 0 12 0
1903 0.5 0 10 0 10.4 0 12 0
1904 0.7 1 12 18 10.7 15 11 16
1905 0.5 1 9 16 6.4 9 7 9
1906 0.3 0 5 0 5.2 0 5 0
1907 0.9 1 14 16 11.6 16 11 16
1908 0.6 1 9 15 6.4 12 6 12
1909 0.3 0 6 0 5.6 0 6 0
1910 0.6 0 11 0 14.9 0 15 0
1911 0.6 0 10 0 8.3 0 9 0
1912 0.7 1 10 15 15.0 24 14 22
1913 0.5 0 8 0 7.6 0 7 0
1914 1.8 2 27 29 23.5 32 20 27
1915 1.5 1 22 15 17.8 6 15 5
1916 1.2 1 15 13 18.5 19 13 14
1917 1.1 1 16 14 14.5 6 11 5
1918 1.8 3 23 39 40.4 47 27 31
1919 0.6 0 8 0 10.6 0 8 0
1920 0.7 0 10 0 17.3 0 17 0
1921 0.7 0 6 0 10.7 0 8 0
1922 1.2 0 9 0 14.1 0 9 0
1923 1.9 3 14 22 34.0 53 20 31
1924 1.5 1 13 9 22.5 2 14 1
1925 2.4 4 20 34 33.1 58 19 33
1926 1.3 1 10 8 26.5 38 15 22
1927 3.5 4 28 32 64.1 85 35 46
1928 3.0 4 22 30 24.8 29 14 16
1929 2.8 4 23 34 42.3 67 23 36
1930 2.0 2 19 19 27.7 21 18 14
1931 2.1 2 20 20 34.6 45 22 29
1932 3.0 3 25 25 46.8 50 26 28
1933 4.1 5 36 44 60.5 72 34 40
1934 4.1 4 21 21 57.5 115 25 50
1935 2.5 1 15 6 34.5 5 15 2
1936 5.9 6 32 32 78.8 96 32 40
1937 2.0 1 12 6 24.0 13 11 6
1938 2.7 3 14 15 37.6 43 14 16
1939 4.8 6 23 29 61.3 61 22 22
1940 3.1 2 15 10 32.1 17 12 6
1941 1.9 0 9 0 22.2 0 8 0
1942 3.3 5 16 24 41.1 79 16 30
1943 3.7 2 18 10 39.8 13 18 6
1944 2.4 2 13 11 31.0 23 12 9
1945 2.8 2 14 10 37.6 15 13 5
1946 3.4 3 15 13 46.9 38 16 13
1947 7.1 14 31 61 84.6 180 29 61
1948 4.5 6 18 23 56.3 92 18 30
1949 6.3 8 23 29 82.9 139 27 46
1950 5.3 5 19 18 57.5 56 18 18
1951 5.4 5 17 16 64.0 39 17 10
1952 4.9 3 16 9 64.1 42 17 11
1953 6.5 5 20 15 74.7 22 21 6
1954 6.5 7 19 21 66.4 71 17 18
1955 6.7 7 19 20 73.5 80 19 20
1956 5.6 4 16 11 65.5 60 17 16
1957 8.6 10 25 29 107.9 171 28 44
1958 8.5 8 23 22 84.2 95 21 24
1959 7.3 8 20 22 86.9 105 23 27
1960 7.8 11 23 32 98.4 175 26 46
1961 7.1 12 18 31 90.1 199 23 51
1962 5.3 7 14 19 58.0 69 16 19
1963 5.7 6 15 16 69.6 87 18 23
1964 6.5 8 17 21 58.1 70 15 18
1965 7.9 8 20 20 73.8 95 20 25
1966 5.7 10 15 26 52.8 93 14 24
1967 8.9 11 22 27 89.0 109 21 26
1968 8.0 8 20 20 85.9 66 20 15
1969 8.5 11 20 26 72.3 79 16 18
1970 10.1 13 23 30 133.5 177 28 37
1971 11.7 14 25 31 99.5 112 21 24
1972 9.9 11 22 24 109.8 131 23 27
1973 8.3 9 19 20 98.9 119 20 25
1974 3.9 3 10 7 44.3 19 9 4
1975 6.4 4 16 10 81.7 37 17 8
1976 5.7 7 14 18 80.2 103 16 21
1977 5.2 4 14 11 60.8 38 13 8
1978 5.5 8 14 21 64.7 67 14 14
1979 4.5 3 12 8 63.6 40 13 8
1980 3.3 2 9 5 52.4 39 11 8
1981 4.9 7 13 19 61.7 108 12 22
1982 3.6 6 9 15 47.8 72 10 15
1983 1.8 0 5 0 29.8 0 6 0
1984 3.3 4 8 10 53.7 72 10 14
1985 1.8 0 4 0 20.8 0 4 0
1986 2.6 1 7 3 38.4 13 7 2
1987 2.1 1 6 3 34.6 5 7 1
1988 3.0 1 8 3 40.4 21 7 4
1989 3.2 2 8 5 49.7 37 9 6
1990 3.3 3 9 8 57.0 47 10 8
1991 4.0 3 11 8 55.2 46 10 8
1992 2.6 3 7 8 34.5 33 6 5
1993 2.9 3 8 8 39.8 33 7 6
1994 3.0 2 8 5 45.8 36 7 6
1995 2.7 1 8 3 42.2 16 7 3
1996 1.9 0 5 0 42.6 0 7 0
1997 2.6 0 6 0 44.2 0 7 0
1998 1.9 3 6 9 31.2 48 5 8
1999 3.2 4 8 10 68.7 113 10 16
2000 3.1 1 7 2 62.1 33 8 4
2001 2.1 1 5 3 41.4 24 6 3
2002 2.7 3 7 8 40.5 27 6 4
2003 2.8 1 6 2 48.0 23 6 3
2004 4.3 5 11 12 104.5 154 14 21
2005 3.6 3 8 7 69.2 56 8 7
2006 2.3 0 6 0 46.8 0 6 0
2007 2.3 0 5 0 46.0 0 6 0
2008 1.8 0 4 0 34.0 0 4 0
2009 2.6 1 6 2 49.4 10 6 1
2010 2.4 0 5 0 45.8 0 5 0
2011 2.6 2 6 4 56.0 53 6 6
2012 1.7 0 4 0 41.5 0 5 0
2013 1.8 0 4 0 35.7 0 4 0

Verification

Table A.15: Measures of the prominence of Verification in each year’s journals.
Year Weight Raw W-Ratio R-Ratio W-Pages R-Pages WP-Ratio RP-Ratio
1876 0.1 0 2 0 0.9 0 2 0
1877 0.3 0 7 0 1.3 0 3 0
1878 0.1 0 2 0 0.9 0 2 0
1879 0.1 0 3 0 0.7 0 2 0
1880 0.3 0 8 0 4.0 0 8 0
1881 0.1 0 3 0 1.6 0 3 0
1882 0.1 0 4 0 1.6 0 4 0
1883 0.1 0 3 0 1.1 0 3 0
1884 0.0 0 0 0 0.0 0 0 0
1885 0.1 0 4 0 1.4 0 4 0
1886 0.1 0 4 0 1.8 0 4 0
1887 0.2 0 5 0 1.5 0 3 0
1888 0.1 0 1 0 1.1 0 2 0
1889 0.1 0 5 0 2.3 0 6 0
1890 0.1 0 2 0 1.1 0 2 0
1891 0.3 0 11 0 4.8 0 9 0
1892 0.2 0 4 0 3.4 0 4 0
1893 0.2 0 3 0 2.6 0 3 0
1894 0.3 0 5 0 3.7 0 4 0
1895 0.4 0 5 0 4.0 0 4 0
1896 0.2 0 3 0 2.8 0 3 0
1897 0.3 0 6 0 5.0 0 6 0
1898 0.2 0 3 0 2.3 0 3 0
1899 0.2 0 5 0 4.2 0 6 0
1900 1.0 1 20 20 6.7 1 9 1
1901 0.1 0 2 0 2.2 0 2 0
1902 0.3 0 5 0 5.1 0 5 0
1903 0.5 0 9 0 7.5 0 8 0
1904 0.2 0 3 0 2.8 0 3 0
1905 0.6 0 9 0 8.9 0 9 0
1906 0.4 0 7 0 9.0 0 8 0
1907 0.5 0 8 0 6.9 0 7 0
1908 0.7 0 10 0 9.5 0 10 0
1909 0.3 0 6 0 7.0 0 7 0
1910 0.5 0 9 0 9.2 0 9 0
1911 0.3 0 4 0 3.6 0 4 0
1912 0.5 0 7 0 6.9 0 6 0
1913 0.6 0 9 0 8.8 0 8 0
1914 0.6 1 9 15 6.5 3 6 3
1915 0.4 0 6 0 6.9 0 6 0
1916 0.3 0 3 0 5.1 0 4 0
1917 0.4 0 5 0 6.7 0 5 0
1918 0.4 0 5 0 6.1 0 4 0
1919 0.2 0 3 0 5.4 0 4 0
1920 0.2 0 3 0 5.3 0 5 0
1921 0.5 0 4 0 7.5 0 6 0
1922 0.6 0 4 0 8.8 0 6 0
1923 0.3 0 2 0 3.8 0 2 0
1924 0.6 0 5 0 7.9 0 5 0
1925 0.5 0 5 0 8.7 0 5 0
1926 1.1 0 9 0 16.7 0 10 0
1927 0.8 0 7 0 10.3 0 6 0
1928 1.3 0 10 0 20.6 0 11 0
1929 0.6 0 5 0 10.2 0 6 0
1930 1.0 0 10 0 14.9 0 10 0
1931 0.9 0 9 0 14.1 0 9 0
1932 1.0 0 8 0 15.2 0 8 0
1933 1.1 0 10 0 18.8 0 11 0
1934 4.0 5 21 26 43.6 66 19 29
1935 3.4 3 20 18 44.7 36 20 16
1936 4.8 6 26 32 62.9 41 26 17
1937 4.4 5 26 29 72.5 117 32 52
1938 5.2 4 26 20 59.5 20 22 7
1939 5.0 5 25 25 63.2 53 23 19
1940 3.5 2 17 10 41.4 14 15 5
1941 4.0 4 19 19 45.2 35 16 13
1942 4.8 6 23 29 52.3 59 20 22
1943 4.1 3 20 15 44.7 18 20 8
1944 3.6 5 19 27 53.0 82 21 33
1945 4.1 3 21 15 74.2 14 27 5
1946 5.5 5 24 22 72.3 55 25 19
1947 7.7 9 34 39 82.0 69 28 23
1948 8.1 9 32 35 87.3 76 28 25
1949 6.9 6 25 22 77.8 49 26 16
1950 12.4 21 45 76 134.7 226 43 72
1951 11.2 13 36 41 130.9 176 35 47
1952 11.6 12 37 38 121.7 120 33 33
1953 8.5 8 26 25 96.6 93 27 26
1954 10.9 13 32 38 111.3 95 28 24
1955 9.7 9 28 26 116.5 114 29 29
1956 12.2 8 35 23 142.5 111 37 29
1957 11.9 14 34 40 129.2 160 33 41
1958 11.6 8 31 22 124.7 115 31 29
1959 12.4 11 34 30 124.7 85 32 22
1960 12.5 13 36 38 119.5 105 32 28
1961 14.9 19 39 49 142.3 170 37 44
1962 14.2 10 38 27 134.0 83 36 23
1963 14.7 9 39 24 144.6 68 37 18
1964 15.1 12 40 31 134.8 103 35 27
1965 17.2 17 44 43 139.3 115 37 31
1966 13.9 13 37 34 133.6 108 35 28
1967 12.7 6 31 15 131.6 62 31 15
1968 12.4 9 31 23 138.8 97 32 23
1969 11.6 7 27 16 108.2 69 24 15
1970 12.9 13 30 30 137.7 133 28 27
1971 11.7 7 25 15 106.5 64 22 13
1972 10.9 11 24 24 108.4 111 22 23
1973 10.6 10 24 23 107.1 81 22 17
1974 7.3 6 18 15 80.1 74 16 15
1975 6.8 4 17 10 71.5 21 15 4
1976 6.1 4 15 10 80.9 40 17 8
1977 4.5 0 12 0 62.4 0 13 0
1978 6.9 6 18 15 70.6 60 15 13
1979 4.4 3 12 8 54.3 28 11 6
1980 4.1 3 11 8 42.2 9 8 2
1981 3.2 1 8 3 37.2 8 8 2
1982 3.1 1 8 3 35.9 2 7 0
1983 2.7 2 7 5 31.8 10 6 2
1984 5.2 2 13 5 47.9 7 9 1
1985 3.0 0 7 0 37.6 0 7 0
1986 3.1 1 8 3 30.9 3 6 1
1987 2.9 2 8 5 31.2 17 6 3
1988 2.8 2 7 5 26.8 5 5 1
1989 2.2 1 6 3 33.5 12 6 2
1990 2.2 1 6 3 29.3 23 5 4
1991 2.7 0 7 0 35.9 0 6 0
1992 1.7 0 5 0 25.9 0 4 0
1993 2.2 2 6 5 32.5 33 6 6
1994 1.4 0 4 0 21.8 0 4 0
1995 1.9 0 5 0 25.0 0 4 0
1996 1.3 0 3 0 23.0 0 4 0
1997 1.5 0 4 0 24.0 0 4 0
1998 1.5 0 5 0 25.4 0 4 0
1999 1.5 0 4 0 24.9 0 4 0
2000 2.0 1 4 2 29.2 3 4 0
2001 1.9 1 5 3 26.5 9 4 1
2002 1.4 0 4 0 20.6 0 3 0
2003 2.0 3 5 7 29.5 57 4 7
2004 1.1 0 3 0 18.1 0 2 0
2005 1.5 1 3 2 28.5 18 3 2
2006 1.3 0 3 0 24.8 0 3 0
2007 1.1 0 3 0 18.5 0 2 0
2008 0.9 0 2 0 17.8 0 2 0
2009 1.4 1 3 2 22.8 4 3 0
2010 1.2 0 3 0 21.7 0 2 0
2011 1.2 0 3 0 23.8 0 3 0
2012 1.3 0 3 0 24.8 0 3 0
2013 1.2 0 3 0 18.7 0 2 0

Value

Table A.16: Measures of the prominence of Value in each year’s journals.
Year Weight Raw W-Ratio R-Ratio W-Pages R-Pages WP-Ratio RP-Ratio
1876 0.3 0 6 0 4.6 0 10 0
1877 1.4 3 35 75 11.2 28 24 60
1878 0.5 0 12 0 4.7 0 10 0
1879 0.2 0 7 0 4.2 0 9 0
1880 0.3 0 10 0 4.8 0 10 0
1881 0.4 1 14 32 8.5 20 18 42
1882 0.7 1 23 31 5.5 5 13 11
1883 1.0 1 32 31 5.4 3 12 7
1884 0.1 0 5 0 2.5 0 6 0
1885 0.3 1 15 45 7.8 27 20 68
1886 0.2 0 7 0 4.7 0 11 0
1887 0.1 0 2 0 0.8 0 2 0
1888 0.2 0 6 0 3.1 0 6 0
1889 0.1 0 3 0 1.5 0 4 0
1890 0.5 1 11 21 3.6 3 5 4
1891 0.3 0 10 0 3.0 0 6 0
1892 0.5 1 9 17 8.5 25 9 27
1893 0.3 0 5 0 3.7 0 4 0
1894 0.5 1 7 14 7.5 17 8 19
1895 0.7 2 10 28 14.4 42 15 43
1896 0.4 0 7 0 5.7 0 6 0
1897 1.2 1 21 18 12.6 10 16 12
1898 0.5 0 9 0 5.4 0 7 0
1899 0.4 0 10 0 9.9 0 13 0
1900 0.2 0 4 0 3.8 0 5 0
1901 0.4 0 7 0 6.5 0 7 0
1902 1.2 2 24 42 18.9 32 20 34
1903 0.4 0 7 0 7.0 0 8 0
1904 0.6 1 10 18 10.7 21 11 22
1905 0.8 1 13 16 15.7 21 16 22
1906 0.6 1 10 16 10.2 13 9 12
1907 0.4 0 6 0 6.7 0 7 0
1908 1.4 1 22 15 21.9 20 22 20
1909 0.6 0 10 0 8.1 0 8 0
1910 0.7 1 11 17 6.2 3 6 3
1911 0.9 1 13 16 7.5 2 8 2
1912 0.5 0 7 0 9.8 0 9 0
1913 0.8 1 12 15 13.4 5 13 5
1914 0.8 1 12 15 16.0 17 14 15
1915 1.2 0 18 0 24.3 0 20 0
1916 0.6 0 7 0 12.4 0 9 0
1917 1.2 2 18 29 22.6 43 18 34
1918 1.0 0 13 0 16.2 0 11 0
1919 0.8 1 12 14 18.3 28 14 22
1920 0.6 0 10 0 11.9 0 11 0
1921 2.5 2 22 18 31.4 34 23 25
1922 2.2 1 15 7 29.6 13 19 8
1923 2.5 1 19 7 25.3 6 15 4
1924 1.5 0 13 0 21.5 0 14 0
1925 2.5 4 21 34 32.9 51 19 29
1926 1.4 1 11 8 20.7 14 12 8
1927 1.3 1 11 8 17.7 5 10 3
1928 1.7 2 13 15 21.7 25 12 14
1929 1.5 1 13 8 29.3 23 16 12
1930 1.1 1 11 10 14.8 8 10 5
1931 2.4 3 23 29 36.2 37 23 24
1932 1.7 1 14 8 44.1 14 25 8
1933 1.8 1 16 9 24.2 7 14 4
1934 2.4 2 12 10 22.0 16 10 7
1935 2.2 2 14 12 29.2 37 13 17
1936 3.6 6 19 32 40.5 54 17 22
1937 3.8 5 22 29 52.5 77 24 34
1938 3.8 6 19 30 46.4 76 17 28
1939 3.9 4 19 20 57.0 62 21 22
1940 2.9 0 14 0 35.6 0 13 0
1941 3.4 2 16 9 40.9 20 15 7
1942 4.8 6 23 29 53.3 46 20 18
1943 4.7 5 23 25 46.9 53 21 24
1944 5.5 8 29 43 73.0 124 29 50
1945 6.4 10 33 52 71.8 104 26 37
1946 4.9 6 22 27 41.1 41 14 14
1947 3.5 3 15 13 49.2 57 17 19
1948 6.1 8 24 31 64.7 82 21 27
1949 7.6 10 28 37 71.6 93 24 31
1950 6.2 12 22 44 59.4 98 19 31
1951 5.2 6 17 19 49.8 54 13 14
1952 4.8 6 15 19 51.0 57 14 15
1953 4.9 5 15 15 49.7 46 14 13
1954 5.0 6 15 18 50.3 73 13 19
1955 5.8 6 17 17 53.8 52 14 13
1956 5.8 7 16 20 53.3 60 14 16
1957 5.4 3 16 9 49.0 10 13 3
1958 5.7 3 15 8 67.3 22 17 5
1959 4.5 6 12 17 44.3 48 11 12
1960 3.0 2 9 6 35.0 18 9 5
1961 3.7 4 9 10 43.5 67 11 17
1962 5.0 4 14 11 42.5 28 12 8
1963 3.7 4 10 11 36.9 29 10 8
1964 4.6 4 12 10 44.4 27 12 7
1965 3.4 3 9 8 35.6 41 9 11
1966 4.7 5 12 13 41.6 35 11 9
1967 4.8 7 12 17 48.0 66 11 15
1968 5.3 6 13 15 48.8 55 11 13
1969 3.4 3 8 7 26.3 16 6 4
1970 4.7 6 11 14 34.0 44 7 9
1971 4.1 3 9 7 40.0 34 8 7
1972 4.6 3 10 7 34.6 9 7 2
1973 2.0 1 4 2 22.1 15 5 3
1974 2.8 2 7 5 31.7 13 7 3
1975 4.5 4 11 10 43.3 26 9 6
1976 3.6 3 9 8 47.0 56 10 11
1977 3.0 2 8 5 44.4 28 9 6
1978 3.9 5 10 13 51.0 80 11 17
1979 2.5 2 7 5 39.1 47 8 9
1980 2.9 2 8 5 46.8 35 9 7
1981 3.5 2 9 5 37.3 23 8 5
1982 3.1 3 8 8 43.2 42 9 9
1983 4.3 4 11 10 61.8 67 12 14
1984 4.0 4 10 10 47.6 44 9 8
1985 2.7 1 6 2 36.1 17 6 3
1986 2.6 2 6 5 35.5 24 7 4
1987 3.5 3 9 8 53.3 36 10 7
1988 4.2 3 11 8 43.1 12 8 2
1989 3.1 0 8 0 51.6 0 9 0
1990 3.1 2 8 5 50.8 45 8 8
1991 3.7 3 10 8 55.3 61 10 11
1992 3.3 1 9 3 63.0 37 10 6
1993 2.8 1 7 3 45.6 15 8 3
1994 2.4 1 7 3 34.7 2 6 0
1995 3.4 4 10 12 64.4 99 11 17
1996 3.4 2 9 5 55.3 37 9 6
1997 3.5 1 9 2 65.4 19 10 3
1998 2.3 1 7 3 40.2 23 7 4
1999 2.8 1 7 3 61.8 14 9 2
2000 3.4 1 7 2 58.4 19 8 2
2001 3.6 2 9 5 65.1 35 9 5
2002 3.2 1 9 3 58.4 5 9 1
2003 6.2 9 14 20 113.8 159 15 20
2004 3.4 3 8 7 62.9 54 8 7
2005 4.1 4 9 9 71.8 60 9 7
2006 2.9 5 7 12 65.0 107 8 14
2007 3.4 3 8 7 62.6 49 8 6
2008 3.9 3 9 7 77.5 51 9 6
2009 3.3 3 7 7 62.4 69 7 8
2010 4.3 4 9 9 81.2 63 9 7
2011 3.5 2 8 4 76.7 57 8 6
2012 3.5 2 8 5 63.5 14 8 2
2013 3.7 3 8 7 73.9 52 8 6

Deduction

Table A.17: Measures of the prominence of Deduction in each year’s journals.
Year Weight Raw W-Ratio R-Ratio W-Pages R-Pages WP-Ratio RP-Ratio
1876 0.9 0 18 0 5.5 0 12 0
1877 0.4 1 11 25 5.3 9 11 19
1878 2.1 5 53 125 14.2 28 32 62
1879 1.4 3 40 83 11.0 19 23 40
1880 0.3 0 10 0 4.9 0 10 0
1881 0.2 0 6 0 3.8 0 8 0
1882 0.6 2 20 62 6.0 13 14 30
1883 0.7 1 21 31 6.8 15 16 35
1884 0.2 0 6 0 1.7 0 4 0
1885 0.1 0 6 0 1.1 0 3 0
1886 0.1 0 4 0 1.4 0 3 0
1887 0.3 0 9 0 2.1 0 5 0
1888 0.4 0 9 0 6.4 0 12 0
1889 0.1 0 2 0 1.1 0 3 0
1890 0.5 0 10 0 8.8 0 13 0
1891 0.6 1 18 32 8.3 14 16 27
1892 0.8 1 13 17 10.3 4 11 4
1893 0.5 1 8 15 7.0 15 8 18
1894 0.4 0 6 0 6.4 0 7 0
1895 1.0 1 14 14 18.5 17 19 17
1896 0.7 0 11 0 12.3 0 13 0
1897 0.8 1 14 18 11.0 17 14 21
1898 1.1 1 20 19 16.7 14 20 17
1899 0.7 1 17 24 11.8 15 16 20
1900 1.0 2 20 40 12.3 18 16 24
1901 0.1 0 1 0 1.1 0 1 0
1902 0.4 0 8 0 9.7 0 10 0
1903 0.9 1 17 19 14.8 11 16 12
1904 0.6 0 10 0 8.9 0 9 0
1905 1.1 1 18 16 17.2 8 18 8
1906 0.7 0 12 0 12.1 0 11 0
1907 0.9 0 15 0 9.8 0 10 0
1908 1.2 0 18 0 10.8 0 11 0
1909 0.6 1 11 18 9.4 14 10 15
1910 1.8 3 32 52 20.3 24 20 24
1911 0.9 0 14 0 8.8 0 9 0
1912 1.8 2 28 30 22.1 24 20 22
1913 1.4 2 20 30 16.7 25 16 23
1914 4.1 5 60 74 39.8 73 34 62
1915 2.6 5 39 75 21.4 31 18 26
1916 2.2 4 29 52 20.6 22 15 16
1917 3.0 6 44 87 28.2 49 22 39
1918 1.6 3 21 39 14.6 23 10 15
1919 1.4 2 20 29 17.5 27 14 21
1920 0.5 0 8 0 5.4 0 5 0
1921 2.0 3 18 27 20.5 28 15 21
1922 2.0 1 14 7 19.4 8 12 5
1923 2.8 2 21 15 19.2 3 11 2
1924 1.0 2 9 17 14.8 30 9 19
1925 1.0 1 8 8 11.8 10 7 6
1926 1.3 0 11 0 14.6 0 9 0
1927 1.5 1 12 8 15.9 11 9 6
1928 2.4 3 18 23 18.4 10 10 6
1929 1.9 2 16 17 24.7 19 13 10
1930 2.4 2 22 19 23.5 13 16 9
1931 1.9 2 19 20 37.2 53 24 34
1932 4.7 8 39 66 37.3 61 21 34
1933 3.4 3 30 26 38.8 18 22 10
1934 4.1 4 21 21 38.7 48 17 21
1935 2.7 2 17 12 37.9 27 17 12
1936 4.8 4 26 22 51.1 21 21 9
1937 2.8 1 17 6 30.9 4 14 2
1938 3.4 2 17 10 34.6 9 13 3
1939 3.7 4 18 20 48.9 45 18 16
1940 5.1 6 25 29 51.5 44 19 16
1941 2.4 0 11 0 29.9 0 11 0
1942 3.0 3 14 14 31.6 27 12 10
1943 2.0 1 10 5 19.6 7 9 3
1944 3.3 3 18 16 47.3 37 19 15
1945 2.7 2 14 10 40.0 28 14 10
1946 3.7 5 17 22 54.4 94 19 33
1947 4.2 6 18 26 79.0 159 27 54
1948 3.4 0 13 0 38.7 0 13 0
1949 5.3 2 20 7 55.6 14 18 5
1950 5.2 6 19 22 44.6 37 14 12
1951 6.1 6 19 19 53.7 36 14 10
1952 5.2 8 17 25 57.5 76 16 21
1953 4.4 6 14 19 46.7 67 13 19
1954 4.8 5 14 15 50.4 55 13 14
1955 5.3 5 15 14 54.6 52 14 13
1956 5.0 0 14 0 49.2 0 13 0
1957 5.1 2 15 6 54.6 21 14 5
1958 6.6 6 18 16 61.8 32 15 8
1959 6.4 6 18 17 75.7 88 20 23
1960 7.2 5 21 15 66.1 43 17 11
1961 8.7 11 23 28 82.1 94 21 24
1962 7.6 6 21 16 61.3 31 17 8
1963 6.6 5 17 13 48.4 40 13 10
1964 6.5 6 17 16 59.3 41 16 11
1965 7.7 8 20 20 67.6 70 18 19
1966 8.4 7 22 18 86.5 84 22 22
1967 7.2 5 17 12 85.2 81 20 19
1968 8.5 6 21 15 77.5 58 18 14
1969 7.3 7 17 16 97.7 110 22 24
1970 7.1 6 16 14 76.7 64 16 13
1971 9.3 12 20 26 75.5 86 16 18
1972 6.0 4 13 9 62.7 39 13 8
1973 6.6 6 15 14 64.8 68 13 14
1974 6.0 6 15 15 49.1 30 10 6
1975 6.3 4 16 10 51.6 8 11 2
1976 5.2 2 13 5 50.6 13 10 3
1977 3.7 2 10 5 47.2 10 10 2
1978 4.4 5 11 13 46.0 51 10 11
1979 5.4 8 14 21 58.9 73 12 14
1980 5.2 5 14 13 56.7 60 11 12
1981 5.7 9 15 24 58.4 90 12 18
1982 5.7 5 15 13 68.9 65 14 13
1983 5.4 4 14 10 49.3 30 10 6
1984 4.3 4 11 10 61.2 64 12 12
1985 7.0 7 16 17 73.2 64 13 11
1986 5.5 5 14 13 51.3 48 10 9
1987 3.4 0 9 0 40.1 0 8 0
1988 4.2 1 11 3 58.6 23 11 4
1989 4.8 2 12 5 53.8 40 9 7
1990 4.3 2 11 5 55.3 34 9 6
1991 3.6 3 10 8 56.9 47 10 8
1992 2.7 0 8 0 45.5 0 8 0
1993 3.4 2 9 5 43.5 27 8 5
1994 3.7 2 10 5 43.0 13 7 2
1995 4.4 4 13 12 57.5 35 10 6
1996 3.2 1 8 3 60.0 9 10 1
1997 4.3 2 11 5 74.4 62 11 9
1998 3.0 0 9 0 52.6 0 9 0
1999 3.5 2 9 5 65.7 52 9 7
2000 4.2 6 9 13 81.6 153 11 20
2001 3.0 1 8 3 55.2 21 8 3
2002 4.7 3 13 8 70.3 41 11 6
2003 2.8 1 6 2 62.4 24 8 3
2004 4.1 2 10 5 67.4 39 9 5
2005 4.5 3 10 7 73.5 61 9 7
2006 3.6 4 9 10 80.7 100 10 13
2007 4.8 4 11 9 94.0 60 12 7
2008 4.9 4 11 9 63.5 36 8 4
2009 5.3 6 12 14 89.7 89 11 11
2010 6.0 7 13 15 94.7 91 11 10
2011 4.2 4 9 9 73.0 40 8 4
2012 3.9 2 9 5 54.2 17 6 2
2013 4.2 5 9 11 78.5 95 9 11

Mechanisms

Table A.18: Measures of the prominence of Mechanisms in each year’s journals.
Year Weight Raw W-Ratio R-Ratio W-Pages R-Pages WP-Ratio RP-Ratio
1876 0.9 1 18 20 5.9 2 12 4
1877 0.1 0 2 0 0.7 0 2 0
1878 0.1 0 3 0 0.7 0 2 0
1879 0.1 0 2 0 0.8 0 2 0
1880 0.1 0 4 0 2.6 0 5 0
1881 0.0 0 1 0 0.3 0 1 0
1882 0.0 0 1 0 0.7 0 2 0
1883 0.2 0 5 0 1.6 0 4 0
1884 0.2 0 9 0 3.2 0 7 0
1885 0.0 0 0 0 0.2 0 1 0
1886 0.4 0 12 0 3.5 0 9 0
1887 0.1 0 3 0 0.9 0 2 0
1888 0.2 0 4 0 1.9 0 4 0
1889 0.0 0 2 0 1.0 0 2 0
1890 0.4 1 9 21 4.4 7 6 10
1891 0.2 0 6 0 1.4 0 3 0
1892 0.2 0 3 0 2.8 0 3 0
1893 0.7 1 10 15 4.6 6 6 7
1894 0.3 0 4 0 2.7 0 3 0
1895 0.2 0 4 0 3.6 0 4 0
1896 0.7 0 11 0 9.1 0 10 0
1897 0.2 0 3 0 1.9 0 2 0
1898 1.0 1 18 19 9.1 2 11 2
1899 0.4 1 9 24 4.1 10 5 13
1900 0.2 0 5 0 3.4 0 4 0
1901 0.1 0 2 0 2.3 0 2 0
1902 0.3 0 7 0 7.3 0 8 0
1903 0.5 0 10 0 10.5 0 12 0
1904 0.5 0 9 0 8.2 0 9 0
1905 0.4 0 7 0 6.2 0 6 0
1906 0.6 0 9 0 9.3 0 8 0
1907 0.5 0 7 0 6.2 0 6 0
1908 0.2 0 3 0 3.2 0 3 0
1909 0.2 0 4 0 3.6 0 4 0
1910 0.4 0 8 0 6.5 0 6 0
1911 0.3 0 5 0 5.0 0 5 0
1912 0.3 0 5 0 8.4 0 8 0
1913 0.4 0 6 0 5.9 0 6 0
1914 0.6 0 8 0 9.4 0 8 0
1915 0.5 0 7 0 9.0 0 7 0
1916 0.3 0 4 0 6.0 0 4 0
1917 1.1 1 16 14 16.8 19 13 15
1918 2.0 3 26 39 42.7 40 28 27
1919 0.7 0 10 0 12.9 0 10 0
1920 0.5 0 7 0 7.0 0 7 0
1921 3.5 6 32 54 47.1 70 35 52
1922 5.5 7 39 50 46.6 65 29 41
1923 4.3 7 32 52 47.4 71 28 42
1924 2.3 2 20 17 34.5 30 22 19
1925 3.4 7 28 59 36.3 67 20 38
1926 2.9 2 23 16 29.4 18 17 11
1927 4.1 3 33 24 50.9 23 28 13
1928 2.3 2 18 15 27.5 27 15 15
1929 2.0 3 17 25 23.7 35 13 19
1930 1.4 0 14 0 15.4 0 10 0
1931 1.7 1 17 10 22.8 9 14 6
1932 1.5 0 12 0 18.6 0 10 0
1933 1.4 1 12 9 21.9 12 12 7
1934 3.5 4 18 21 44.1 51 19 22
1935 3.9 5 23 30 49.9 68 22 30
1936 3.0 5 16 27 39.1 88 16 36
1937 1.7 4 10 23 29.4 83 13 37
1938 1.7 0 9 0 27.3 0 10 0
1939 2.6 2 13 10 34.8 24 13 9
1940 3.2 1 16 5 42.6 23 16 9
1941 3.8 5 18 23 44.9 69 16 25
1942 3.3 1 16 5 36.7 10 14 4
1943 4.8 6 23 29 43.8 42 19 19
1944 2.7 3 14 16 33.3 42 13 17
1945 3.5 4 18 21 50.8 58 18 21
1946 4.7 3 21 13 61.3 43 21 15
1947 5.0 3 22 13 58.8 52 20 18
1948 4.1 3 16 12 44.2 20 14 6
1949 3.3 2 12 7 49.2 40 16 13
1950 5.2 7 19 25 52.6 59 17 19
1951 5.9 9 19 29 81.4 132 22 35
1952 3.8 4 12 13 53.5 39 14 11
1953 5.7 10 18 31 60.3 103 17 29
1954 3.8 3 11 9 43.5 49 11 13
1955 4.3 2 12 6 49.2 15 12 4
1956 5.0 5 14 14 56.2 50 15 13
1957 4.5 3 13 9 53.3 46 14 12
1958 4.2 2 11 5 40.7 10 10 2
1959 4.3 7 12 19 46.2 81 12 21
1960 4.0 3 12 9 49.0 33 13 9
1961 3.1 2 8 5 35.7 29 9 7
1962 2.8 2 8 5 34.6 25 9 7
1963 3.0 4 8 11 36.5 40 9 10
1964 2.6 1 7 3 25.9 8 7 2
1965 2.9 2 7 5 29.0 12 8 3
1966 4.0 4 11 11 48.6 83 13 21
1967 2.4 0 6 0 26.9 0 6 0
1968 1.8 0 5 0 23.6 0 6 0
1969 3.0 0 7 0 39.1 0 9 0
1970 3.8 4 9 9 44.5 49 9 10
1971 3.5 3 8 7 40.2 23 8 5
1972 3.8 3 8 7 56.0 37 12 8
1973 3.3 2 8 5 35.0 13 7 3
1974 3.1 5 8 12 36.0 46 7 9
1975 3.2 2 8 5 37.2 12 8 3
1976 3.0 1 8 3 53.1 31 11 6
1977 2.9 0 8 0 38.9 0 8 0
1978 3.6 3 9 8 46.6 48 10 10
1979 2.8 2 7 5 44.7 55 9 11
1980 3.5 1 9 3 61.5 15 12 3
1981 3.7 3 10 8 60.3 46 12 9
1982 6.6 9 17 23 83.2 128 17 26
1983 3.7 5 9 13 47.4 62 10 13
1984 3.3 2 8 5 48.0 17 9 3
1985 2.3 0 5 0 38.3 0 7 0
1986 3.0 0 8 0 51.1 0 10 0
1987 2.1 0 5 0 31.9 0 6 0
1988 2.6 0 7 0 50.2 0 9 0
1989 3.9 1 10 3 61.8 15 11 3
1990 3.3 3 9 8 50.3 35 8 6
1991 3.0 2 8 5 47.5 21 9 4
1992 2.8 0 8 0 50.4 0 8 0
1993 3.0 0 8 0 46.6 0 8 0
1994 2.9 0 8 0 52.0 0 8 0
1995 3.3 2 10 6 63.7 40 11 7
1996 2.3 0 6 0 38.2 0 6 0
1997 3.7 0 9 0 60.5 0 9 0
1998 3.2 0 10 0 63.8 0 11 0
1999 2.9 2 7 5 52.6 37 7 5
2000 4.7 2 10 4 81.3 39 11 5
2001 2.9 2 8 5 60.3 43 9 6
2002 4.2 3 11 8 68.3 46 11 7
2003 3.3 2 7 5 56.3 25 7 3
2004 4.1 1 10 2 71.8 15 10 2
2005 3.6 4 8 9 61.7 53 7 6
2006 3.7 1 9 2 69.5 22 9 3
2007 4.2 2 10 5 77.8 36 10 4
2008 6.9 9 16 21 109.7 125 13 15
2009 4.0 2 9 5 77.6 56 9 7
2010 4.8 1 10 2 101.2 11 11 1
2011 5.8 4 13 9 107.7 78 12 9
2012 4.3 3 10 7 95.7 58 11 7
2013 6.1 7 14 16 106.8 116 12 13

Temporal Paradoxes

Table A.19: Measures of the prominence of Temporal Paradoxes in each year’s journals.
Year Weight Raw W-Ratio R-Ratio W-Pages R-Pages WP-Ratio RP-Ratio
1876 1.1 1 22 20 5.5 2 12 4
1877 1.0 1 24 25 3.0 1 6 2
1878 0.9 1 22 25 8.4 7 19 16
1879 0.2 0 5 0 2.9 0 6 0
1880 0.9 1 27 30 5.5 5 11 10
1881 0.4 0 12 0 5.4 0 11 0
1882 0.3 0 10 0 6.5 0 15 0
1883 0.2 0 7 0 3.5 0 8 0
1884 0.2 0 6 0 3.3 0 8 0
1885 0.7 1 32 45 11.4 16 29 41
1886 2.0 3 70 103 23.5 23 57 56
1887 0.6 1 20 32 5.4 5 12 11
1888 1.3 2 31 48 10.7 19 21 37
1889 0.6 0 22 0 9.0 0 23 0
1890 0.8 1 17 21 11.1 13 16 19
1891 0.2 0 6 0 2.5 0 5 0
1892 0.8 0 14 0 12.7 0 14 0
1893 1.0 0 16 0 13.3 0 16 0
1894 0.7 0 11 0 10.8 0 12 0
1895 1.8 1 26 14 21.5 3 22 3
1896 0.7 0 11 0 9.9 0 11 0
1897 0.9 0 15 0 15.4 0 19 0
1898 0.5 0 9 0 6.9 0 8 0
1899 0.8 0 20 0 14.7 0 20 0
1900 1.1 0 22 0 11.4 0 15 0
1901 2.1 2 35 34 34.7 29 36 30
1902 1.4 1 29 21 23.4 12 25 13
1903 0.4 0 8 0 7.5 0 8 0
1904 0.5 0 9 0 10.4 0 11 0
1905 0.7 0 11 0 12.5 0 13 0
1906 0.8 0 12 0 13.6 0 12 0
1907 1.2 2 20 32 20.8 25 20 25
1908 1.5 2 22 30 19.3 30 19 30
1909 1.7 2 30 36 26.8 23 28 24
1910 0.8 0 14 0 17.2 0 17 0
1911 0.7 0 11 0 12.9 0 14 0
1912 2.2 2 33 30 45.0 41 41 37
1913 1.8 3 27 45 29.7 47 28 44
1914 1.6 1 24 15 31.1 25 27 21
1915 0.9 0 13 0 16.8 0 14 0
1916 2.2 2 28 26 40.8 35 29 25
1917 1.1 1 16 14 19.5 17 15 13
1918 1.4 2 19 26 20.6 12 14 8
1919 0.9 1 13 14 15.3 2 12 2
1920 0.9 1 15 15 9.7 1 9 1
1921 1.6 2 14 18 22.0 27 16 20
1922 2.4 0 17 0 22.8 0 14 0
1923 2.3 2 17 15 33.7 34 20 20
1924 1.7 2 15 17 29.9 37 19 23
1925 2.3 1 19 8