2.17 Deduction

Category: Logic and Mathematics

Keywords: syllogism, premisses, valid, logic, inferences, deductive, validity, inference, deduction, premiss, induction, calculus, premises, infer, formal

Number of Articles: 414
Percentage of Total: 1.3%
Rank: 27th

Weighted Number of Articles: 466.3
Percentage of Total: 1.4%
Rank: 15th

Mean Publication Year: 1959.7
Weighted Mean Publication Year: 1963.8
Median Publication Year: 1963
Modal Publication Year: 1971

Topic with Most Overlap: Arguments (0.0437)
Topic this Overlaps Most With: Propositions and Implications (0.0551)
Topic with Least Overlap: Evolutionary Biology (0.00042)
Topic this Overlaps Least With: Feminism (0.00083)

Deduction

Figure 2.45: Deduction

Deduction Articles in Each Journal

Figure 2.46: Deduction Articles in Each Journal

Comments

This is a hard to classify topic. On the one hand, it’s clearly about logic, so that’s easy enough. But everything else about it is a little odd. The graphs don’t show much life after 1920. But it ends up being either the 27th or 15th largest topic, depending on how you measure things. And the measure that makes it 15th is the one the graphs are showing. Its top keyword is syllogism, but most of the characteristic articles are very modern pieces that barely mention the word. In fact, the word mostly vanishes frm the journals after the 1960s.

How frequently does 'syllogism' appear in the journals

Figure 2.47: How frequently does ‘syllogism’ appear in the journals

Part of what’s happened here is that while the model has decided to treat talk of ‘implication’ back in Topic 7 differently to talk here of validity, it’s thrown some very old notions in with this topic. That’s not absurd, but it does lead to some od results. if you squint you can see a brief uptick at the end of the graph. But a big part of the story here is that this kind of work, to the extent that its supported by the discipline at all, has largely moved to more specialist journals. So we don’t see as much of it in these journals as we use to. And it would take a broader study to see what happens when you add the specialist logic journals to the mix.