B Subject Prominence by Year

There are 138 tables below, one for each year In each table there are 90 rows, one for each subject. In each row, there are 8 columns. This is what each of the columns represents.

Weight

The weighted number of articles in that subject in that year. This is the main data point that’s used throughout the book as the measure of the subject’s prominence in the year.

Raw

The raw number of articles in that subject in that year.

W-Ratio

The weighted number of articles in that subject in that year per 1000 articles published that year.

R-Ratio

The raw number of articles in that subject in that year per 1000 articles published that year.

W-Pages

The weighted number of pages of articles on that subject in that year.

R-Pages

The raw number of pages of articles on that subject in that year.

WP-Ratio

The weighted number of pages of articles in that subject in that year per 1000 pages published that year.

RP-Ratio

The raw number of pages of articles in that subject in that year per 1000 pages published that year.

1876

Table B.1: Measures of the prominence of each subject in 1876 ’s journals.

Subject	Weight	Raw	W-Ratio	R-Ratio	W-Pages	R-Pages	WP-Ratio	RP-Ratio
Psychology	5.7	7	112	137	70.4	87	148	182
Idealism	4.0	6	79	118	43.0	79	90	166
Life and value	2.1	3	41	59	26.0	36	55	75
Other history	6.7	9	132	176	84.7	115	178	241
Dewey and pragmatism	0.5	0	10	0	5.5	0	12	0
Definitions	0.7	0	13	0	4.2	0	9	0
Propositions and implications	0.6	1	13	20	2.5	2	5	4
Beauty	0.3	1	7	20	4.3	12	9	25
Physicalism	0.4	0	8	0	4.0	0	8	0
History and culture	0.2	0	3	0	1.7	0	4	0
Faith and theism	0.1	0	2	0	1.2	0	3	0
Self-consciousness	1.3	0	25	0	8.6	0	18	0
Ancient	0.2	0	4	0	2.0	0	4	0
Universals and particulars	0.7	1	14	20	2.9	2	6	4
Verification	0.1	0	2	0	0.9	0	2	0
Value	0.3	0	6	0	4.6	0	10	0
Deduction	0.9	0	18	0	5.5	0	12	0
Mechanisms	0.9	1	18	20	5.9	2	12	4
Temporal paradoxes	1.1	1	22	20	5.5	2	12	4
Classical space and time	1.7	2	34	39	18.3	23	38	48
Early modern	0.7	1	14	20	3.6	3	8	6
Meaning and use	0.2	1	4	20	1.4	7	3	15
Marx	0.2	0	5	0	3.4	0	7	0
Ordinary language	1.9	2	36	39	21.9	25	46	52
Moral conscience	1.9	3	37	59	19.4	33	41	69
Methodology of science	1.6	2	31	39	19.0	19	40	40
Heidegger and Husserl	0.1	0	3	0	1.1	0	2	0
Emotions	2.5	3	49	59	9.6	7	20	15
Ontological argument	0.2	0	4	0	2.2	0	5	0
Chemistry	0.7	0	15	0	5.6	0	12	0
Social contract theory	1.1	0	22	0	5.6	0	12	0
Kant	0.5	0	11	0	7.4	0	16	0
Promises and imperatives	0.2	0	5	0	2.3	0	5	0
Analytic/synthetic	0.1	0	2	0	0.9	0	2	0
Freedom and free will	0.1	0	1	0	0.6	0	1	0
Crime and punishment	0.0	0	0	0	0.2	0	0	0
Sets and grue	0.1	0	2	0	1.5	0	3	0
Origins and purposes	0.1	0	2	0	1.1	0	2	0
Time	0.9	1	18	20	3.0	3	6	6
Color/colour	0.6	1	12	20	5.0	8	10	17
War	0.1	0	3	0	1.2	0	3	0
Depiction	0.1	0	2	0	0.7	0	1	0
Denoting	0.1	0	1	0	0.6	0	1	0
Chance	0.2	0	4	0	1.2	0	3	0
Hume	0.2	0	5	0	1.1	0	2	0
Laws	1.1	3	22	59	5.4	7	11	15
Perception	0.1	0	1	0	0.8	0	2	0
Intention	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Virtues	0.1	0	3	0	0.7	0	2	0
Space and time	0.0	0	1	0	0.5	0	1	0
Mathematics	0.4	0	8	0	4.9	0	10	0
Liberal democracy	0.1	0	1	0	1.2	0	2	0
Duties	0.1	0	2	0	0.9	0	2	0
Causation	0.2	0	5	0	1.7	0	4	0
Arguments	0.0	0	1	0	0.5	0	1	0
Theory testing	0.1	0	2	0	1.0	0	2	0
Decision theory	1.0	2	21	39	6.3	5	13	10
Minds and machines	0.4	0	8	0	2.6	0	5	0
Truth	0.1	0	2	0	0.5	0	1	0
Radical translation	0.0	0	1	0	0.3	0	1	0
Explanation	0.1	0	1	0	0.9	0	2	0
Personal identity	0.5	0	11	0	1.5	0	3	0
Speech acts	0.1	0	1	0	0.3	0	1	0
Sense and reference	0.0	0	0	0	0.2	0	0	0
Egalitarianism	0.0	0	1	0	0.3	0	1	0
Quantum physics	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0
Theories and realism	0.5	0	9	0	2.1	0	4	0
Functions	0.0	0	1	0	0.6	0	1	0
Feminism	0.2	0	4	0	3.7	0	8	0
Medical ethics and Freud	0.3	0	6	0	1.6	0	3	0
Abortion and self-defence	0.2	0	5	0	2.1	0	4	0
Belief ascriptions	0.0	0	1	0	0.3	0	1	0
Thermodynamics	0.2	0	4	0	2.7	0	6	0
Knowledge	0.2	0	4	0	1.4	0	3	0
Game theory	0.0	0	1	0	0.1	0	0	0
Justification	0.1	0	3	0	0.7	0	2	0
Frankfurt cases	0.0	0	1	0	0.2	0	0	0
Concepts	0.1	0	2	0	0.9	0	2	0
Races and DNA	0.2	0	4	0	1.6	0	3	0
Modality	0.1	0	2	0	1.0	0	2	0
Reasons	0.1	0	1	0	0.5	0	1	0
Evolutionary biology	0.2	0	4	0	2.3	0	5	0
Population ethics	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Formal epistemology	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Wide content	0.1	0	2	0	0.5	0	1	0
Vagueness	0.0	0	1	0	0.4	0	1	0
Cognitive science	0.1	0	2	0	0.9	0	2	0
Models	0.0	0	0	0	0.2	0	0	0
Composition and constitution	0.0	0	1	0	0.5	0	1	0
Norms	0.1	0	1	0	0.4	0	1	0

1877

Table B.2: Measures of the prominence of each subject in 1877 ’s journals.

Subject	Weight	Raw	W-Ratio	R-Ratio	W-Pages	R-Pages	WP-Ratio	RP-Ratio
Psychology	4.0	8	99	200	50.1	107	108	230
Idealism	3.4	3	86	75	40.4	26	87	56
Life and value	1.5	2	39	50	22.1	28	47	60
Other history	5.5	9	138	225	106.5	174	229	373
Dewey and pragmatism	0.4	0	10	0	3.3	0	7	0
Definitions	0.4	0	10	0	4.2	0	9	0
Propositions and implications	0.3	0	8	0	2.5	0	5	0
Beauty	0.1	0	2	0	1.3	0	3	0
Physicalism	0.3	0	8	0	4.1	0	9	0
History and culture	0.3	0	7	0	5.0	0	11	0
Faith and theism	0.5	0	13	0	6.4	0	14	0
Self-consciousness	1.3	2	32	50	11.9	16	26	34
Ancient	0.2	0	4	0	2.1	0	4	0
Universals and particulars	0.3	1	8	25	3.9	17	8	36
Verification	0.3	0	7	0	1.3	0	3	0
Value	1.4	3	35	75	11.2	28	24	60
Deduction	0.4	1	11	25	5.3	9	11	19
Mechanisms	0.1	0	2	0	0.7	0	2	0
Temporal paradoxes	1.0	1	24	25	3.0	1	6	2
Classical space and time	0.6	1	16	25	5.7	9	12	19
Early modern	0.7	0	17	0	4.3	0	9	0
Meaning and use	0.3	0	6	0	2.9	0	6	0
Marx	0.1	0	1	0	0.9	0	2	0
Ordinary language	1.6	0	40	0	21.9	0	47	0
Moral conscience	1.3	2	32	50	13.4	26	29	56
Methodology of science	0.4	0	10	0	7.2	0	16	0
Heidegger and Husserl	0.0	0	1	0	0.7	0	2	0
Emotions	1.8	2	45	50	11.4	8	24	17
Ontological argument	1.0	1	24	25	6.6	6	14	13
Chemistry	0.3	0	7	0	3.2	0	7	0
Social contract theory	0.5	0	12	0	8.7	0	19	0
Kant	0.7	0	17	0	8.3	0	18	0
Promises and imperatives	0.7	0	18	0	7.5	0	16	0
Analytic/synthetic	0.3	1	8	25	2.2	5	5	11
Freedom and free will	0.0	0	1	0	0.2	0	0	0
Crime and punishment	0.2	0	4	0	3.6	0	8	0
Sets and grue	0.5	1	12	25	3.3	2	7	4
Origins and purposes	0.2	0	4	0	1.7	0	4	0
Time	0.4	0	9	0	6.8	0	15	0
Color/colour	0.2	0	6	0	2.1	0	5	0
War	0.0	0	1	0	0.7	0	1	0
Depiction	0.6	0	14	0	2.6	0	6	0
Denoting	0.1	0	2	0	0.7	0	2	0
Chance	0.0	0	1	0	0.2	0	1	0
Hume	0.1	0	2	0	2.0	0	4	0
Laws	0.1	0	3	0	1.8	0	4	0
Perception	0.1	0	3	0	2.1	0	4	0
Intention	0.6	1	15	25	2.4	2	5	4
Virtues	0.4	1	9	25	1.0	2	2	4
Space and time	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0
Mathematics	0.2	0	5	0	1.8	0	4	0
Liberal democracy	0.2	0	4	0	3.5	0	7	0
Duties	0.0	0	0	0	0.2	0	0	0
Causation	0.3	0	7	0	1.8	0	4	0
Arguments	0.1	0	3	0	1.3	0	3	0
Theory testing	0.1	0	2	0	1.0	0	2	0
Decision theory	0.2	0	5	0	5.2	0	11	0
Minds and machines	0.2	0	4	0	1.3	0	3	0
Truth	0.1	0	2	0	0.7	0	1	0
Radical translation	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Explanation	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Personal identity	0.1	0	3	0	1.4	0	3	0
Speech acts	0.0	0	1	0	0.2	0	1	0
Sense and reference	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0
Egalitarianism	0.1	0	2	0	1.0	0	2	0
Quantum physics	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Theories and realism	0.1	0	2	0	0.8	0	2	0
Functions	0.0	0	1	0	0.5	0	1	0
Feminism	0.2	0	6	0	3.5	0	8	0
Medical ethics and Freud	0.3	0	7	0	0.6	0	1	0
Abortion and self-defence	0.3	0	9	0	1.6	0	3	0
Belief ascriptions	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0
Thermodynamics	0.1	0	3	0	1.8	0	4	0
Knowledge	0.4	0	11	0	3.7	0	8	0
Game theory	0.4	0	9	0	0.8	0	2	0
Justification	0.3	0	8	0	5.5	0	12	0
Frankfurt cases	0.0	0	1	0	0.2	0	0	0
Concepts	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Races and DNA	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0
Modality	0.1	0	2	0	0.2	0	0	0
Reasons	0.4	0	9	0	1.7	0	4	0
Evolutionary biology	0.1	0	2	0	0.8	0	2	0
Population ethics	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0
Formal epistemology	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Wide content	0.1	0	3	0	1.7	0	4	0
Vagueness	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Cognitive science	0.1	0	1	0	0.5	0	1	0
Models	0.0	0	1	0	0.5	0	1	0
Composition and constitution	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0
Norms	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0

1878

Table B.3: Measures of the prominence of each subject in 1878 ’s journals.

Subject	Weight	Raw	W-Ratio	R-Ratio	W-Pages	R-Pages	WP-Ratio	RP-Ratio
Psychology	5.6	8	139	200	78.3	122	174	271
Idealism	2.4	2	60	50	31.2	30	69	67
Life and value	2.7	3	67	75	27.5	26	61	58
Other history	2.5	5	63	125	46.3	86	103	191
Dewey and pragmatism	0.1	0	3	0	2.0	0	4	0
Definitions	0.9	1	21	25	5.2	3	12	7
Propositions and implications	0.5	0	12	0	4.6	0	10	0
Beauty	0.7	0	17	0	6.4	0	14	0
Physicalism	0.8	1	19	25	4.5	2	10	4
History and culture	0.3	0	8	0	3.9	0	9	0
Faith and theism	0.3	0	8	0	5.5	0	12	0
Self-consciousness	0.3	0	9	0	4.1	0	9	0
Ancient	0.1	0	3	0	0.9	0	2	0
Universals and particulars	0.4	0	9	0	3.4	0	7	0
Verification	0.1	0	2	0	0.9	0	2	0
Value	0.5	0	12	0	4.7	0	10	0
Deduction	2.1	5	53	125	14.2	28	32	62
Mechanisms	0.1	0	3	0	0.7	0	2	0
Temporal paradoxes	0.9	1	22	25	8.4	7	19	16
Classical space and time	1.1	1	29	25	21.2	14	47	31
Early modern	0.5	1	13	25	7.4	18	16	40
Meaning and use	0.5	1	14	25	3.5	2	8	4
Marx	0.5	1	13	25	7.9	15	18	33
Ordinary language	1.9	1	46	25	26.5	14	59	31
Moral conscience	1.1	3	26	75	12.1	39	27	86
Methodology of science	0.7	0	17	0	7.9	0	18	0
Heidegger and Husserl	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Emotions	1.1	2	27	50	12.2	27	27	60
Ontological argument	0.2	0	5	0	2.8	0	6	0
Chemistry	0.3	0	6	0	3.1	0	7	0
Social contract theory	0.6	0	14	0	8.4	0	19	0
Kant	0.7	0	17	0	9.9	0	22	0
Promises and imperatives	0.6	0	14	0	4.6	0	10	0
Analytic/synthetic	0.1	0	2	0	0.9	0	2	0
Freedom and free will	0.0	0	1	0	0.5	0	1	0
Crime and punishment	0.3	0	8	0	3.3	0	7	0
Sets and grue	0.1	0	2	0	1.0	0	2	0
Origins and purposes	0.3	0	8	0	2.1	0	5	0
Time	0.1	0	3	0	1.2	0	3	0
Color/colour	1.5	2	37	50	4.5	6	10	13
War	0.0	0	0	0	0.2	0	1	0
Depiction	1.1	1	28	25	7.7	4	17	9
Denoting	0.1	0	3	0	1.1	0	2	0
Chance	0.1	0	3	0	0.8	0	2	0
Hume	0.0	0	1	0	0.5	0	1	0
Laws	0.5	0	11	0	3.5	0	8	0
Perception	0.5	0	13	0	6.0	0	13	0
Intention	0.0	0	1	0	0.3	0	1	0
Virtues	0.1	0	2	0	1.1	0	2	0
Space and time	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Mathematics	0.8	1	19	25	5.4	8	12	18
Liberal democracy	0.1	0	1	0	1.0	0	2	0
Duties	0.0	0	1	0	0.4	0	1	0
Causation	0.2	0	5	0	1.9	0	4	0
Arguments	0.2	0	5	0	1.6	0	4	0
Theory testing	0.2	0	6	0	2.5	0	5	0
Decision theory	0.5	0	12	0	2.9	0	6	0
Minds and machines	0.1	0	2	0	0.8	0	2	0
Truth	0.1	0	3	0	0.8	0	2	0
Radical translation	0.0	0	0	0	0.2	0	0	0
Explanation	0.0	0	1	0	0.2	0	0	0
Personal identity	0.0	0	1	0	0.4	0	1	0
Speech acts	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Sense and reference	0.0	0	1	0	0.3	0	1	0
Egalitarianism	0.1	0	3	0	1.3	0	3	0
Quantum physics	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0
Theories and realism	0.1	0	3	0	1.4	0	3	0
Functions	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0
Feminism	0.2	0	5	0	2.4	0	5	0
Medical ethics and Freud	0.0	0	0	0	0.3	0	1	0
Abortion and self-defence	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Belief ascriptions	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0
Thermodynamics	0.2	0	4	0	1.8	0	4	0
Knowledge	0.3	0	7	0	2.2	0	5	0
Game theory	0.0	0	0	0	0.2	0	0	0
Justification	0.2	0	6	0	1.9	0	4	0
Frankfurt cases	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Concepts	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Races and DNA	0.1	0	1	0	0.6	0	1	0
Modality	0.0	0	0	0	0.2	0	0	0
Reasons	0.2	0	4	0	0.4	0	1	0
Evolutionary biology	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Population ethics	0.1	0	3	0	0.8	0	2	0
Formal epistemology	0.1	0	1	0	0.8	0	2	0
Wide content	0.1	0	2	0	1.1	0	2	0
Vagueness	0.1	0	1	0	0.4	0	1	0
Cognitive science	0.0	0	1	0	0.3	0	1	0
Models	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Composition and constitution	0.1	0	2	0	0.8	0	2	0
Norms	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0

1879

Table B.4: Measures of the prominence of each subject in 1879 ’s journals.

Subject	Weight	Raw	W-Ratio	R-Ratio	W-Pages	R-Pages	WP-Ratio	RP-Ratio
Psychology	3.2	6	88	167	54.2	95	113	199
Idealism	2.9	4	82	111	36.9	60	77	126
Life and value	1.9	1	54	28	32.5	22	68	46
Other history	4.0	6	112	167	70.5	96	148	201
Dewey and pragmatism	0.4	0	12	0	3.4	0	7	0
Definitions	0.4	0	12	0	5.8	0	12	0
Propositions and implications	0.3	0	7	0	2.9	0	6	0
Beauty	0.5	0	15	0	9.8	0	21	0
Physicalism	0.3	0	7	0	3.8	0	8	0
History and culture	0.4	0	10	0	6.4	0	13	0
Faith and theism	0.4	1	12	28	7.4	17	15	36
Self-consciousness	1.0	1	27	28	7.9	6	17	13
Ancient	0.3	1	9	28	5.4	22	11	46
Universals and particulars	0.6	0	18	0	5.0	0	10	0
Verification	0.1	0	3	0	0.7	0	2	0
Value	0.2	0	7	0	4.2	0	9	0
Deduction	1.4	3	40	83	11.0	19	23	40
Mechanisms	0.1	0	2	0	0.8	0	2	0
Temporal paradoxes	0.2	0	5	0	2.9	0	6	0
Classical space and time	0.8	1	21	28	8.6	5	18	10
Early modern	0.2	0	5	0	2.4	0	5	0
Meaning and use	0.6	0	17	0	4.5	0	9	0
Marx	0.2	0	5	0	2.5	0	5	0
Ordinary language	2.4	3	67	83	40.7	41	85	86
Moral conscience	0.6	1	18	28	8.1	12	17	25
Methodology of science	0.6	0	17	0	6.2	0	13	0
Heidegger and Husserl	0.1	0	2	0	1.3	0	3	0
Emotions	0.7	0	18	0	12.0	0	25	0
Ontological argument	0.3	0	9	0	3.7	0	8	0
Chemistry	0.6	0	17	0	6.6	0	14	0
Social contract theory	0.4	0	12	0	4.3	0	9	0
Kant	1.1	1	31	28	6.3	3	13	6
Promises and imperatives	0.2	0	5	0	2.6	0	5	0
Analytic/synthetic	0.1	0	1	0	0.8	0	2	0
Freedom and free will	0.2	0	4	0	2.1	0	4	0
Crime and punishment	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0
Sets and grue	0.2	0	7	0	3.2	0	7	0
Origins and purposes	1.6	4	45	111	14.6	43	30	90
Time	0.1	0	3	0	1.7	0	4	0
Color/colour	1.6	2	43	56	13.1	22	27	46
War	0.1	0	3	0	1.5	0	3	0
Depiction	0.1	0	3	0	1.6	0	3	0
Denoting	0.2	0	5	0	2.3	0	5	0
Chance	0.2	0	5	0	2.8	0	6	0
Hume	0.3	0	8	0	1.6	0	3	0
Laws	0.4	0	10	0	4.0	0	8	0
Perception	0.1	0	3	0	2.2	0	5	0
Intention	0.1	0	2	0	1.4	0	3	0
Virtues	0.0	0	1	0	0.5	0	1	0
Space and time	0.2	0	6	0	1.9	0	4	0
Mathematics	0.0	0	1	0	1.0	0	2	0
Liberal democracy	0.1	0	4	0	2.6	0	5	0
Duties	0.0	0	1	0	0.2	0	1	0
Causation	0.2	0	6	0	4.4	0	9	0
Arguments	0.1	0	4	0	1.0	0	2	0
Theory testing	0.0	0	1	0	0.3	0	1	0
Decision theory	0.4	0	10	0	5.6	0	12	0
Minds and machines	0.2	0	6	0	2.6	0	6	0
Truth	0.0	0	1	0	0.4	0	1	0
Radical translation	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Explanation	0.1	0	2	0	1.7	0	4	0
Personal identity	0.1	0	2	0	1.4	0	3	0
Speech acts	0.0	0	1	0	0.3	0	1	0
Sense and reference	0.0	0	1	0	0.2	0	0	0
Egalitarianism	0.2	1	5	28	2.4	15	5	31
Quantum physics	0.0	0	0	0	0.2	0	0	0
Theories and realism	0.1	0	2	0	0.8	0	2	0
Functions	0.1	0	2	0	1.0	0	2	0
Feminism	0.1	0	4	0	2.0	0	4	0
Medical ethics and Freud	0.0	0	1	0	0.6	0	1	0
Abortion and self-defence	0.2	0	5	0	1.0	0	2	0
Belief ascriptions	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Thermodynamics	0.1	0	2	0	1.1	0	2	0
Knowledge	0.1	0	3	0	0.7	0	1	0
Game theory	0.0	0	1	0	0.2	0	0	0
Justification	0.2	0	4	0	1.2	0	3	0
Frankfurt cases	0.1	0	2	0	1.1	0	2	0
Concepts	0.1	0	3	0	1.6	0	3	0
Races and DNA	0.0	0	1	0	0.4	0	1	0
Modality	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0
Reasons	0.1	0	3	0	2.2	0	5	0
Evolutionary biology	0.1	0	3	0	2.0	0	4	0
Population ethics	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Formal epistemology	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Wide content	0.0	0	1	0	0.4	0	1	0
Vagueness	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Cognitive science	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Models	0.1	0	2	0	0.4	0	1	0
Composition and constitution	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0
Norms	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0

1880

Table B.5: Measures of the prominence of each subject in 1880 ’s journals.

Subject	Weight	Raw	W-Ratio	R-Ratio	W-Pages	R-Pages	WP-Ratio	RP-Ratio
Psychology	4.2	10	126	303	70.8	155	145	318
Idealism	2.3	2	70	61	41.5	44	85	90
Life and value	3.0	8	92	242	46.0	106	94	217
Other history	1.6	2	48	61	20.7	25	42	51
Dewey and pragmatism	0.1	0	2	0	1.4	0	3	0
Definitions	0.3	0	10	0	4.6	0	9	0
Propositions and implications	0.4	1	13	30	6.5	16	13	33
Beauty	0.5	1	14	30	9.5	20	19	41
Physicalism	0.4	0	11	0	2.1	0	4	0
History and culture	0.1	0	2	0	1.3	0	3	0
Faith and theism	0.3	0	8	0	5.3	0	11	0
Self-consciousness	0.4	0	13	0	7.2	0	15	0
Ancient	0.1	0	3	0	1.7	0	4	0
Universals and particulars	0.5	0	15	0	7.6	0	16	0
Verification	0.3	0	8	0	4.0	0	8	0
Value	0.3	0	10	0	4.8	0	10	0
Deduction	0.3	0	10	0	4.9	0	10	0
Mechanisms	0.1	0	4	0	2.6	0	5	0
Temporal paradoxes	0.9	1	27	30	5.5	5	11	10
Classical space and time	0.5	0	16	0	8.5	0	17	0
Early modern	0.7	1	21	30	15.3	23	31	47
Meaning and use	0.4	0	12	0	3.5	0	7	0
Marx	0.1	0	4	0	2.4	0	5	0
Ordinary language	2.2	2	67	61	34.6	39	71	80
Moral conscience	0.7	0	21	0	9.1	0	19	0
Methodology of science	0.4	0	13	0	7.4	0	15	0
Heidegger and Husserl	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Emotions	0.6	0	19	0	10.3	0	21	0
Ontological argument	0.3	0	10	0	3.5	0	7	0
Chemistry	0.9	1	28	30	22.1	25	45	51
Social contract theory	0.5	0	15	0	7.4	0	15	0
Kant	0.6	1	18	30	5.2	5	11	10
Promises and imperatives	0.8	0	23	0	10.8	0	22	0
Analytic/synthetic	0.1	0	2	0	0.7	0	1	0
Freedom and free will	0.5	0	16	0	9.9	0	20	0
Crime and punishment	0.6	1	19	30	4.4	6	9	12
Sets and grue	0.2	0	5	0	2.6	0	5	0
Origins and purposes	0.8	1	23	30	10.2	16	21	33
Time	0.1	0	4	0	1.6	0	3	0
Color/colour	0.1	0	5	0	2.3	0	5	0
War	0.1	0	2	0	0.7	0	1	0
Depiction	0.4	0	11	0	5.1	0	10	0
Denoting	0.0	0	1	0	0.6	0	1	0
Chance	0.1	0	3	0	2.0	0	4	0
Hume	0.1	0	4	0	2.2	0	5	0
Laws	0.3	0	9	0	3.8	0	8	0
Perception	0.1	0	3	0	1.3	0	3	0
Intention	0.1	0	2	0	0.4	0	1	0
Virtues	0.1	0	2	0	0.5	0	1	0
Space and time	0.0	0	1	0	0.4	0	1	0
Mathematics	0.1	0	4	0	2.1	0	4	0
Liberal democracy	0.1	0	2	0	1.2	0	2	0
Duties	0.5	1	15	30	3.1	3	6	6
Causation	0.2	0	6	0	3.6	0	7	0
Arguments	0.2	0	6	0	2.8	0	6	0
Theory testing	0.2	0	5	0	1.8	0	4	0
Decision theory	0.1	0	3	0	2.1	0	4	0
Minds and machines	0.1	0	4	0	0.7	0	1	0
Truth	0.1	0	2	0	0.5	0	1	0
Radical translation	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0
Explanation	0.0	0	1	0	0.5	0	1	0
Personal identity	0.0	0	1	0	0.5	0	1	0
Speech acts	0.3	0	8	0	1.9	0	4	0
Sense and reference	0.0	0	0	0	0.2	0	0	0
Egalitarianism	0.2	0	5	0	1.4	0	3	0
Quantum physics	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Theories and realism	0.1	0	2	0	1.3	0	3	0
Functions	0.1	0	3	0	1.7	0	3	0
Feminism	0.5	0	14	0	3.3	0	7	0
Medical ethics and Freud	0.1	0	4	0	1.3	0	3	0
Abortion and self-defence	0.1	0	2	0	0.9	0	2	0
Belief ascriptions	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Thermodynamics	0.2	0	5	0	1.8	0	4	0
Knowledge	0.1	0	3	0	1.4	0	3	0
Game theory	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Justification	0.1	0	4	0	2.8	0	6	0
Frankfurt cases	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Concepts	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Races and DNA	0.1	0	3	0	1.8	0	4	0
Modality	0.0	0	1	0	0.2	0	0	0
Reasons	0.7	0	20	0	4.8	0	10	0
Evolutionary biology	0.2	0	6	0	3.7	0	8	0
Population ethics	0.0	0	1	0	0.3	0	1	0
Formal epistemology	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0
Wide content	0.0	0	1	0	0.5	0	1	0
Vagueness	0.0	0	1	0	0.7	0	1	0
Cognitive science	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0
Models	0.0	0	1	0	0.3	0	1	0
Composition and constitution	0.1	0	2	0	1.8	0	4	0
Norms	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0

1881

Table B.6: Measures of the prominence of each subject in 1881 ’s journals.

Subject	Weight	Raw	W-Ratio	R-Ratio	W-Pages	R-Pages	WP-Ratio	RP-Ratio
Psychology	6.3	8	203	258	77.3	81	164	172
Idealism	4.0	10	130	323	76.8	191	163	406
Life and value	2.0	2	65	65	36.8	33	78	70
Other history	1.8	2	57	65	30.0	50	64	106
Dewey and pragmatism	0.2	0	5	0	1.9	0	4	0
Definitions	0.8	2	25	65	11.8	33	25	70
Propositions and implications	0.0	0	1	0	0.3	0	1	0
Beauty	0.4	1	13	32	6.7	17	14	36
Physicalism	0.6	0	21	0	10.5	0	22	0
History and culture	0.3	0	9	0	5.1	0	11	0
Faith and theism	0.1	0	3	0	2.5	0	5	0
Self-consciousness	1.5	1	49	32	17.0	7	36	15
Ancient	0.3	1	10	32	4.5	13	10	28
Universals and particulars	0.2	0	7	0	4.4	0	9	0
Verification	0.1	0	3	0	1.6	0	3	0
Value	0.4	1	14	32	8.5	20	18	42
Deduction	0.2	0	6	0	3.8	0	8	0
Mechanisms	0.0	0	1	0	0.3	0	1	0
Temporal paradoxes	0.4	0	12	0	5.4	0	11	0
Classical space and time	0.3	0	9	0	4.1	0	9	0
Early modern	0.3	0	10	0	5.6	0	12	0
Meaning and use	0.7	0	22	0	10.0	0	21	0
Marx	0.3	0	9	0	5.7	0	12	0
Ordinary language	1.6	1	51	32	27.9	14	59	30
Moral conscience	0.3	0	11	0	6.2	0	13	0
Methodology of science	0.6	0	19	0	9.9	0	21	0
Heidegger and Husserl	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Emotions	0.7	0	22	0	8.9	0	19	0
Ontological argument	0.2	0	6	0	3.5	0	7	0
Chemistry	0.3	0	9	0	3.9	0	8	0
Social contract theory	0.3	0	10	0	4.4	0	9	0
Kant	0.4	0	14	0	5.8	0	12	0
Promises and imperatives	0.6	0	18	0	5.1	0	11	0
Analytic/synthetic	0.0	0	1	0	0.6	0	1	0
Freedom and free will	0.4	1	13	32	6.5	8	14	17
Crime and punishment	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Sets and grue	0.0	0	2	0	1.0	0	2	0
Origins and purposes	0.5	0	15	0	6.3	0	13	0
Time	0.1	0	2	0	1.3	0	3	0
Color/colour	0.1	0	2	0	0.8	0	2	0
War	0.0	0	2	0	0.7	0	1	0
Depiction	0.4	0	13	0	2.4	0	5	0
Denoting	0.2	0	5	0	1.9	0	4	0
Chance	0.0	0	1	0	0.1	0	0	0
Hume	0.1	0	2	0	1.5	0	3	0
Laws	0.2	0	6	0	3.4	0	7	0
Perception	0.2	0	7	0	3.6	0	8	0
Intention	0.0	0	1	0	0.4	0	1	0
Virtues	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Space and time	0.0	0	0	0	0.2	0	0	0
Mathematics	0.1	0	2	0	0.9	0	2	0
Liberal democracy	0.0	0	2	0	0.9	0	2	0
Duties	0.0	0	1	0	0.3	0	1	0
Causation	0.1	0	5	0	2.8	0	6	0
Arguments	0.2	0	6	0	2.3	0	5	0
Theory testing	0.1	0	3	0	1.1	0	2	0
Decision theory	0.0	0	1	0	0.4	0	1	0
Minds and machines	0.2	0	6	0	2.3	0	5	0
Truth	0.1	0	2	0	0.5	0	1	0
Radical translation	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Explanation	0.0	0	1	0	0.6	0	1	0
Personal identity	0.1	0	3	0	1.5	0	3	0
Speech acts	0.1	0	2	0	0.5	0	1	0
Sense and reference	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0
Egalitarianism	0.0	0	1	0	0.7	0	2	0
Quantum physics	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Theories and realism	0.1	0	3	0	1.6	0	3	0
Functions	0.0	0	1	0	1.2	0	2	0
Feminism	0.1	0	5	0	0.9	0	2	0
Medical ethics and Freud	0.0	0	1	0	0.2	0	0	0
Abortion and self-defence	0.2	1	8	32	1.5	4	3	8
Belief ascriptions	0.1	0	3	0	1.2	0	3	0
Thermodynamics	0.0	0	1	0	0.7	0	1	0
Knowledge	0.2	0	6	0	1.8	0	4	0
Game theory	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Justification	0.1	0	2	0	1.3	0	3	0
Frankfurt cases	0.0	0	0	0	0.3	0	1	0
Concepts	0.0	0	0	0	0.2	0	0	0
Races and DNA	0.1	0	2	0	0.7	0	1	0
Modality	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Reasons	0.0	0	1	0	0.5	0	1	0
Evolutionary biology	0.1	0	4	0	1.7	0	4	0
Population ethics	0.0	0	1	0	0.5	0	1	0
Formal epistemology	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Wide content	0.1	0	3	0	1.8	0	4	0
Vagueness	0.1	0	4	0	1.3	0	3	0
Cognitive science	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Models	0.0	0	0	0	0.3	0	1	0
Composition and constitution	0.1	0	4	0	1.6	0	3	0
Norms	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0

1882

Table B.7: Measures of the prominence of each subject in 1882 ’s journals.

Subject	Weight	Raw	W-Ratio	R-Ratio	W-Pages	R-Pages	WP-Ratio	RP-Ratio
Psychology	5.2	9	163	281	58.7	108	135	248
Idealism	4.7	10	147	312	99.9	235	230	540
Life and value	1.8	2	56	62	27.2	20	63	46
Other history	0.9	1	29	31	17.0	24	39	55
Dewey and pragmatism	0.3	0	9	0	5.0	0	11	0
Definitions	0.1	0	4	0	1.7	0	4	0
Propositions and implications	0.8	1	25	31	3.7	2	8	5
Beauty	0.2	0	7	0	2.6	0	6	0
Physicalism	0.8	1	24	31	8.0	5	19	11
History and culture	0.2	0	6	0	3.2	0	7	0
Faith and theism	0.2	0	5	0	2.8	0	6	0
Self-consciousness	0.6	0	20	0	13.6	0	31	0
Ancient	0.4	0	13	0	9.3	0	21	0
Universals and particulars	0.3	0	8	0	4.6	0	11	0
Verification	0.1	0	4	0	1.6	0	4	0
Value	0.7	1	23	31	5.5	5	13	11
Deduction	0.6	2	20	62	6.0	13	14	30
Mechanisms	0.0	0	1	0	0.7	0	2	0
Temporal paradoxes	0.3	0	10	0	6.5	0	15	0
Classical space and time	0.7	1	21	31	5.2	4	12	9
Early modern	1.0	1	31	31	10.9	6	25	14
Meaning and use	0.2	0	6	0	1.3	0	3	0
Marx	0.1	0	2	0	0.8	0	2	0
Ordinary language	1.4	0	44	0	21.4	0	49	0
Moral conscience	0.7	0	22	0	6.9	0	16	0
Methodology of science	0.5	0	14	0	9.8	0	23	0
Heidegger and Husserl	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Emotions	0.5	0	16	0	5.7	0	13	0
Ontological argument	0.3	0	9	0	5.1	0	12	0
Chemistry	0.6	0	19	0	6.3	0	14	0
Social contract theory	0.3	0	10	0	5.0	0	12	0
Kant	0.4	1	14	31	5.8	7	13	16
Promises and imperatives	0.8	1	25	31	7.5	4	17	9
Analytic/synthetic	0.2	0	6	0	2.4	0	6	0
Freedom and free will	0.0	0	1	0	1.0	0	2	0
Crime and punishment	0.2	0	5	0	1.5	0	3	0
Sets and grue	0.2	0	5	0	1.1	0	3	0
Origins and purposes	0.1	0	3	0	1.5	0	3	0
Time	0.1	0	3	0	1.4	0	3	0
Color/colour	0.1	0	2	0	0.6	0	1	0
War	0.1	0	2	0	0.2	0	1	0
Depiction	0.0	0	1	0	0.2	0	1	0
Denoting	0.2	0	7	0	0.8	0	2	0
Chance	0.1	0	4	0	0.6	0	1	0
Hume	0.0	0	1	0	0.8	0	2	0
Laws	0.3	0	8	0	3.7	0	9	0
Perception	0.6	0	20	0	7.3	0	17	0
Intention	0.0	0	1	0	0.1	0	0	0
Virtues	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Space and time	0.0	0	1	0	0.5	0	1	0
Mathematics	0.1	0	3	0	1.1	0	3	0
Liberal democracy	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0
Duties	0.0	0	1	0	0.4	0	1	0
Causation	0.3	0	11	0	6.2	0	14	0
Arguments	0.1	0	3	0	0.9	0	2	0
Theory testing	0.1	0	3	0	1.3	0	3	0
Decision theory	0.7	1	21	31	2.5	2	6	5
Minds and machines	0.1	0	3	0	2.0	0	5	0
Truth	0.1	0	3	0	1.4	0	3	0
Radical translation	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Explanation	0.2	0	6	0	1.5	0	4	0
Personal identity	0.1	0	2	0	1.1	0	3	0
Speech acts	0.0	0	2	0	0.6	0	1	0
Sense and reference	0.1	0	2	0	0.5	0	1	0
Egalitarianism	0.1	0	3	0	1.4	0	3	0
Quantum physics	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Theories and realism	0.1	0	2	0	1.2	0	3	0
Functions	0.1	0	2	0	1.4	0	3	0
Feminism	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0
Medical ethics and Freud	0.1	0	4	0	0.5	0	1	0
Abortion and self-defence	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Belief ascriptions	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Thermodynamics	0.1	0	3	0	1.3	0	3	0
Knowledge	0.1	0	4	0	2.8	0	6	0
Game theory	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0
Justification	0.2	0	5	0	1.7	0	4	0
Frankfurt cases	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Concepts	0.1	0	3	0	1.5	0	4	0
Races and DNA	0.5	0	14	0	2.4	0	6	0
Modality	0.0	0	1	0	0.4	0	1	0
Reasons	0.3	0	9	0	3.2	0	7	0
Evolutionary biology	0.1	0	3	0	1.0	0	2	0
Population ethics	0.0	0	1	0	0.5	0	1	0
Formal epistemology	0.2	0	5	0	0.3	0	1	0
Wide content	0.1	0	3	0	0.6	0	1	0
Vagueness	0.0	0	1	0	0.7	0	2	0
Cognitive science	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Models	0.0	0	1	0	0.2	0	1	0
Composition and constitution	0.1	0	2	0	0.7	0	2	0
Norms	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0

1883

Table B.8: Measures of the prominence of each subject in 1883 ’s journals.

Subject	Weight	Raw	W-Ratio	R-Ratio	W-Pages	R-Pages	WP-Ratio	RP-Ratio
Psychology	3.2	4	100	125	48.9	54	113	125
Idealism	2.7	3	86	94	48.4	45	112	104
Life and value	2.1	3	67	94	41.2	71	95	164
Other history	0.6	0	19	0	11.5	0	27	0
Dewey and pragmatism	0.3	0	8	0	3.6	0	8	0
Definitions	0.4	0	12	0	5.2	0	12	0
Propositions and implications	0.7	0	21	0	6.5	0	15	0
Beauty	0.1	0	2	0	1.6	0	4	0
Physicalism	0.3	0	9	0	4.3	0	10	0
History and culture	0.0	0	1	0	0.9	0	2	0
Faith and theism	0.9	1	29	31	11.2	3	26	7
Self-consciousness	0.9	0	27	0	10.0	0	23	0
Ancient	0.1	0	3	0	2.7	0	6	0
Universals and particulars	0.9	2	29	62	10.9	32	25	74
Verification	0.1	0	3	0	1.1	0	3	0
Value	1.0	1	32	31	5.4	3	12	7
Deduction	0.7	1	21	31	6.8	15	16	35
Mechanisms	0.2	0	5	0	1.6	0	4	0
Temporal paradoxes	0.2	0	7	0	3.5	0	8	0
Classical space and time	0.2	0	5	0	1.8	0	4	0
Early modern	0.9	2	28	62	12.2	20	28	46
Meaning and use	0.5	0	16	0	6.3	0	15	0
Marx	0.3	0	9	0	6.9	0	16	0
Ordinary language	2.8	4	89	125	45.1	69	104	159
Moral conscience	1.1	0	35	0	12.1	0	28	0
Methodology of science	0.5	0	16	0	6.5	0	15	0
Heidegger and Husserl	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Emotions	1.9	3	60	94	14.9	18	35	42
Ontological argument	0.2	0	5	0	3.3	0	8	0
Chemistry	0.0	0	1	0	0.3	0	1	0
Social contract theory	0.5	1	15	31	8.5	19	20	44
Kant	3.0	6	94	188	32.7	80	75	185
Promises and imperatives	0.1	0	3	0	1.8	0	4	0
Analytic/synthetic	0.1	0	3	0	1.3	0	3	0
Freedom and free will	0.1	0	2	0	1.4	0	3	0
Crime and punishment	0.1	0	4	0	2.4	0	5	0
Sets and grue	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0
Origins and purposes	0.1	0	4	0	2.2	0	5	0
Time	0.1	0	2	0	1.2	0	3	0
Color/colour	0.1	0	2	0	0.8	0	2	0
War	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0
Depiction	0.0	0	1	0	0.3	0	1	0
Denoting	0.0	0	1	0	0.6	0	1	0
Chance	0.1	0	2	0	0.8	0	2	0
Hume	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Laws	0.2	0	5	0	3.4	0	8	0
Perception	0.2	0	5	0	2.1	0	5	0
Intention	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0
Virtues	0.3	0	9	0	1.2	0	3	0
Space and time	0.0	0	0	0	0.2	0	0	0
Mathematics	0.9	1	28	31	5.1	4	12	9
Liberal democracy	0.0	0	1	0	0.7	0	2	0
Duties	0.2	0	6	0	2.6	0	6	0
Causation	0.1	0	2	0	1.3	0	3	0
Arguments	0.2	0	7	0	2.5	0	6	0
Theory testing	0.0	0	1	0	0.4	0	1	0
Decision theory	0.0	0	1	0	0.2	0	1	0
Minds and machines	0.1	0	3	0	1.4	0	3	0
Truth	0.1	0	2	0	0.6	0	1	0
Radical translation	0.1	0	4	0	0.8	0	2	0
Explanation	0.1	0	3	0	0.8	0	2	0
Personal identity	0.0	0	1	0	0.3	0	1	0
Speech acts	0.1	0	4	0	2.6	0	6	0
Sense and reference	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0
Egalitarianism	0.2	0	7	0	3.6	0	8	0
Quantum physics	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Theories and realism	0.1	0	2	0	0.5	0	1	0
Functions	0.0	0	2	0	0.9	0	2	0
Feminism	0.1	0	2	0	1.3	0	3	0
Medical ethics and Freud	0.0	0	1	0	0.4	0	1	0
Abortion and self-defence	0.0	0	0	0	0.2	0	0	0
Belief ascriptions	0.1	0	2	0	0.2	0	0	0
Thermodynamics	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Knowledge	0.1	0	4	0	2.1	0	5	0
Game theory	0.0	0	0	0	0.2	0	0	0
Justification	0.0	0	0	0	0.2	0	0	0
Frankfurt cases	0.0	0	1	0	0.3	0	1	0
Concepts	0.1	0	2	0	1.7	0	4	0
Races and DNA	0.1	0	3	0	1.4	0	3	0
Modality	0.0	0	1	0	0.1	0	0	0
Reasons	0.0	0	1	0	0.7	0	2	0
Evolutionary biology	0.1	0	3	0	2.1	0	5	0
Population ethics	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Formal epistemology	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Wide content	0.1	0	4	0	1.1	0	3	0
Vagueness	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0
Cognitive science	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Models	0.0	0	1	0	0.1	0	0	0
Composition and constitution	0.0	0	1	0	0.7	0	2	0
Norms	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0

1884

Table B.9: Measures of the prominence of each subject in 1884 ’s journals.

Subject	Weight	Raw	W-Ratio	R-Ratio	W-Pages	R-Pages	WP-Ratio	RP-Ratio
Psychology	4.5	9	174	346	89.8	178	208	413
Idealism	3.4	6	129	231	62.5	110	145	255
Life and value	1.6	3	62	115	29.6	52	69	121
Other history	0.6	0	22	0	11.3	0	26	0
Dewey and pragmatism	0.0	0	1	0	0.3	0	1	0
Definitions	0.1	0	3	0	1.8	0	4	0
Propositions and implications	0.0	0	1	0	0.5	0	1	0
Beauty	0.1	0	5	0	1.7	0	4	0
Physicalism	0.1	0	5	0	1.7	0	4	0
History and culture	0.1	0	4	0	0.9	0	2	0
Faith and theism	0.2	0	8	0	4.9	0	11	0
Self-consciousness	0.6	0	23	0	13.7	0	32	0
Ancient	0.1	0	5	0	3.3	0	8	0
Universals and particulars	0.2	0	6	0	3.3	0	8	0
Verification	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Value	0.1	0	5	0	2.5	0	6	0
Deduction	0.2	0	6	0	1.7	0	4	0
Mechanisms	0.2	0	9	0	3.2	0	7	0
Temporal paradoxes	0.2	0	6	0	3.3	0	8	0
Classical space and time	0.5	0	19	0	7.5	0	17	0
Early modern	0.5	1	18	38	9.1	29	21	67
Meaning and use	0.1	0	4	0	1.8	0	4	0
Marx	0.2	0	7	0	2.0	0	5	0
Ordinary language	2.6	2	100	77	37.8	25	88	58
Moral conscience	0.3	0	11	0	4.7	0	11	0
Methodology of science	0.7	1	26	38	9.8	10	23	23
Heidegger and Husserl	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Emotions	1.5	1	57	38	22.5	5	52	12
Ontological argument	0.1	0	5	0	2.0	0	5	0
Chemistry	0.5	0	20	0	7.8	0	18	0
Social contract theory	0.2	0	10	0	5.2	0	12	0
Kant	0.5	0	20	0	7.2	0	17	0
Promises and imperatives	0.5	0	19	0	7.8	0	18	0
Analytic/synthetic	0.1	0	5	0	1.3	0	3	0
Freedom and free will	0.1	0	5	0	1.8	0	4	0
Crime and punishment	0.0	0	1	0	0.2	0	1	0
Sets and grue	0.1	0	3	0	1.5	0	4	0
Origins and purposes	0.2	0	7	0	2.7	0	6	0
Time	0.1	0	4	0	1.2	0	3	0
Color/colour	0.2	0	6	0	2.3	0	5	0
War	0.0	0	1	0	0.3	0	1	0
Depiction	0.4	1	16	38	1.6	3	4	7
Denoting	0.0	0	2	0	1.1	0	3	0
Chance	0.3	1	13	38	4.5	13	10	30
Hume	0.2	0	7	0	3.3	0	8	0
Laws	0.1	0	5	0	2.1	0	5	0
Perception	0.4	0	15	0	2.8	0	7	0
Intention	0.2	0	9	0	3.5	0	8	0
Virtues	0.0	0	2	0	0.8	0	2	0
Space and time	0.0	0	1	0	0.2	0	1	0
Mathematics	0.1	0	3	0	0.9	0	2	0
Liberal democracy	0.0	0	1	0	0.3	0	1	0
Duties	0.1	0	3	0	1.1	0	3	0
Causation	0.3	0	11	0	5.1	0	12	0
Arguments	0.1	0	4	0	1.4	0	3	0
Theory testing	0.2	0	7	0	1.9	0	4	0
Decision theory	0.0	0	1	0	0.4	0	1	0
Minds and machines	0.2	0	8	0	3.2	0	7	0
Truth	0.1	0	2	0	0.9	0	2	0
Radical translation	0.0	0	0	0	0.2	0	0	0
Explanation	0.0	0	0	0	0.3	0	1	0
Personal identity	0.1	0	4	0	1.2	0	3	0
Speech acts	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0
Sense and reference	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0
Egalitarianism	0.0	0	0	0	0.2	0	1	0
Quantum physics	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0
Theories and realism	0.0	0	1	0	0.7	0	2	0
Functions	0.1	0	4	0	1.9	0	4	0
Feminism	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0
Medical ethics and Freud	0.1	0	4	0	1.2	0	3	0
Abortion and self-defence	0.0	0	0	0	0.2	0	0	0
Belief ascriptions	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0
Thermodynamics	0.1	0	3	0	1.1	0	3	0
Knowledge	0.1	0	3	0	1.0	0	2	0
Game theory	0.0	0	1	0	0.3	0	1	0
Justification	0.1	0	3	0	1.0	0	2	0
Frankfurt cases	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0
Concepts	0.0	0	1	0	0.8	0	2	0
Races and DNA	0.5	1	20	38	3.6	6	8	14
Modality	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Reasons	0.1	0	2	0	1.0	0	2	0
Evolutionary biology	0.3	0	12	0	5.6	0	13	0
Population ethics	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Formal epistemology	0.0	0	0	0	0.2	0	1	0
Wide content	0.1	0	3	0	1.2	0	3	0
Vagueness	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Cognitive science	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0
Models	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0
Composition and constitution	0.0	0	1	0	0.6	0	1	0
Norms	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0

1885

Table B.10: Measures of the prominence of each subject in 1885 ’s journals.

Subject	Weight	Raw	W-Ratio	R-Ratio	W-Pages	R-Pages	WP-Ratio	RP-Ratio
Psychology	6.1	10	276	455	119.6	194	303	491
Idealism	2.2	3	101	136	39.4	40	100	101
Life and value	1.5	3	69	136	20.6	35	52	89
Other history	0.4	0	20	0	3.5	0	9	0
Dewey and pragmatism	0.4	0	20	0	7.3	0	18	0
Definitions	0.1	0	5	0	2.3	0	6	0
Propositions and implications	0.3	0	13	0	2.4	0	6	0
Beauty	0.0	0	2	0	0.5	0	1	0
Physicalism	0.2	0	9	0	3.1	0	8	0
History and culture	0.0	0	1	0	0.4	0	1	0
Faith and theism	0.1	0	5	0	1.4	0	3	0
Self-consciousness	0.5	0	23	0	10.2	0	26	0
Ancient	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Universals and particulars	0.3	0	13	0	3.2	0	8	0
Verification	0.1	0	4	0	1.4	0	4	0
Value	0.3	1	15	45	7.8	27	20	68
Deduction	0.1	0	6	0	1.1	0	3	0
Mechanisms	0.0	0	0	0	0.2	0	1	0
Temporal paradoxes	0.7	1	32	45	11.4	16	29	41
Classical space and time	0.9	0	40	0	16.9	0	43	0
Early modern	0.0	0	1	0	0.6	0	1	0
Meaning and use	0.1	0	3	0	0.7	0	2	0
Marx	0.1	0	5	0	2.0	0	5	0
Ordinary language	1.1	0	49	0	23.6	0	60	0
Moral conscience	0.4	0	19	0	8.8	0	22	0
Methodology of science	0.3	0	14	0	3.2	0	8	0
Heidegger and Husserl	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0
Emotions	0.4	1	20	45	10.2	26	26	66
Ontological argument	0.5	1	23	45	3.9	4	10	10
Chemistry	0.5	0	21	0	8.4	0	21	0
Social contract theory	0.1	0	7	0	3.3	0	8	0
Kant	0.3	1	13	45	7.0	28	18	71
Promises and imperatives	0.3	0	16	0	7.1	0	18	0
Analytic/synthetic	0.0	0	2	0	1.0	0	3	0
Freedom and free will	0.3	1	15	45	7.0	25	18	63
Crime and punishment	0.0	0	2	0	1.1	0	3	0
Sets and grue	0.1	0	3	0	1.8	0	5	0
Origins and purposes	0.1	0	5	0	1.3	0	3	0
Time	0.1	0	6	0	1.3	0	3	0
Color/colour	0.2	0	8	0	3.9	0	10	0
War	0.0	0	2	0	1.1	0	3	0
Depiction	0.2	0	8	0	4.4	0	11	0
Denoting	0.0	0	1	0	0.4	0	1	0
Chance	0.0	0	1	0	0.4	0	1	0
Hume	0.0	0	2	0	1.3	0	3	0
Laws	0.1	0	4	0	1.6	0	4	0
Perception	0.3	0	15	0	7.6	0	19	0
Intention	0.1	0	3	0	1.5	0	4	0
Virtues	0.0	0	0	0	0.2	0	0	0
Space and time	0.0	0	1	0	0.4	0	1	0
Mathematics	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0
Liberal democracy	0.1	0	5	0	2.2	0	6	0
Duties	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0
Causation	0.1	0	4	0	1.6	0	4	0
Arguments	0.1	0	3	0	1.0	0	3	0
Theory testing	0.2	0	7	0	2.1	0	5	0
Decision theory	0.2	0	7	0	2.2	0	6	0
Minds and machines	0.2	0	7	0	1.6	0	4	0
Truth	0.0	0	1	0	0.4	0	1	0
Radical translation	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Explanation	0.0	0	1	0	0.3	0	1	0
Personal identity	0.0	0	1	0	0.4	0	1	0
Speech acts	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Sense and reference	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0
Egalitarianism	0.1	0	3	0	0.9	0	2	0
Quantum physics	0.0	0	2	0	0.6	0	2	0
Theories and realism	0.0	0	1	0	0.4	0	1	0
Functions	0.1	0	4	0	1.1	0	3	0
Feminism	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0
Medical ethics and Freud	0.0	0	1	0	0.6	0	2	0
Abortion and self-defence	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0
Belief ascriptions	0.0	0	1	0	0.6	0	2	0
Thermodynamics	0.1	0	3	0	1.1	0	3	0
Knowledge	0.1	0	5	0	1.3	0	3	0
Game theory	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0
Justification	0.0	0	1	0	0.4	0	1	0
Frankfurt cases	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Concepts	0.0	0	0	0	0.2	0	0	0
Races and DNA	0.0	0	0	0	0.2	0	1	0
Modality	0.0	0	1	0	0.3	0	1	0
Reasons	0.1	0	3	0	1.9	0	5	0
Evolutionary biology	0.1	0	6	0	2.6	0	6	0
Population ethics	0.0	0	0	0	0.2	0	0	0
Formal epistemology	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0
Wide content	0.0	0	2	0	0.8	0	2	0
Vagueness	0.0	0	1	0	0.5	0	1	0
Cognitive science	0.0	0	2	0	0.4	0	1	0
Models	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Composition and constitution	0.1	0	3	0	0.5	0	1	0
Norms	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0

1886

Table B.11: Measures of the prominence of each subject in 1886 ’s journals.

Subject	Weight	Raw	W-Ratio	R-Ratio	W-Pages	R-Pages	WP-Ratio	RP-Ratio
Psychology	4.7	8	163	276	67.7	126	165	307
Idealism	3.4	5	116	172	64.0	100	156	244
Life and value	1.9	2	64	69	29.7	38	72	93
Other history	1.0	0	36	0	9.7	0	24	0
Dewey and pragmatism	0.6	1	20	34	5.2	4	13	10
Definitions	0.1	0	4	0	1.3	0	3	0
Propositions and implications	0.0	0	0	0	0.2	0	1	0
Beauty	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Physicalism	0.4	0	14	0	3.2	0	8	0
History and culture	0.2	0	7	0	4.4	0	11	0
Faith and theism	0.3	0	11	0	4.9	0	12	0
Self-consciousness	0.9	0	32	0	16.3	0	40	0
Ancient	0.7	2	23	69	12.2	32	30	78
Universals and particulars	0.3	0	10	0	2.5	0	6	0
Verification	0.1	0	4	0	1.8	0	4	0
Value	0.2	0	7	0	4.7	0	11	0
Deduction	0.1	0	4	0	1.4	0	3	0
Mechanisms	0.4	0	12	0	3.5	0	9	0
Temporal paradoxes	2.0	3	70	103	23.5	23	57	56
Classical space and time	0.8	1	26	34	12.0	16	29	39
Early modern	0.5	1	16	34	7.0	15	17	37
Meaning and use	0.4	0	14	0	3.8	0	9	0
Marx	0.3	1	11	34	2.8	6	7	15
Ordinary language	1.2	0	40	0	18.4	0	45	0
Moral conscience	0.8	1	29	34	11.4	8	28	20
Methodology of science	0.8	1	29	34	11.2	17	27	41
Heidegger and Husserl	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Emotions	0.9	2	31	69	10.3	18	25	44
Ontological argument	0.2	0	6	0	2.8	0	7	0
Chemistry	0.3	0	11	0	7.8	0	19	0
Social contract theory	0.1	0	5	0	1.7	0	4	0
Kant	0.2	0	7	0	3.0	0	7	0
Promises and imperatives	0.2	0	7	0	3.4	0	8	0
Analytic/synthetic	0.0	0	1	0	0.3	0	1	0
Freedom and free will	0.1	0	4	0	1.6	0	4	0
Crime and punishment	0.1	0	2	0	0.8	0	2	0
Sets and grue	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0
Origins and purposes	0.4	0	12	0	4.7	0	11	0
Time	0.1	0	4	0	1.3	0	3	0
Color/colour	0.4	0	13	0	5.8	0	14	0
War	0.0	0	1	0	0.2	0	1	0
Depiction	0.1	0	3	0	1.1	0	3	0
Denoting	0.1	0	4	0	1.2	0	3	0
Chance	0.1	0	3	0	1.0	0	3	0
Hume	0.0	0	1	0	0.5	0	1	0
Laws	0.5	1	17	34	4.2	7	10	17
Perception	0.2	0	8	0	3.1	0	8	0
Intention	0.0	0	1	0	0.6	0	1	0
Virtues	0.1	0	2	0	0.9	0	2	0
Space and time	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0
Mathematics	0.2	0	7	0	1.9	0	5	0
Liberal democracy	0.1	0	3	0	0.8	0	2	0
Duties	0.1	0	2	0	0.9	0	2	0
Causation	0.0	0	1	0	0.4	0	1	0
Arguments	0.1	0	4	0	1.9	0	5	0
Theory testing	0.6	0	20	0	6.4	0	16	0
Decision theory	0.0	0	0	0	0.2	0	1	0
Minds and machines	0.0	0	1	0	0.5	0	1	0
Truth	0.1	0	2	0	0.9	0	2	0
Radical translation	0.0	0	0	0	0.2	0	1	0
Explanation	0.0	0	1	0	0.4	0	1	0
Personal identity	0.3	0	11	0	2.0	0	5	0
Speech acts	0.0	0	1	0	0.4	0	1	0
Sense and reference	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Egalitarianism	0.0	0	1	0	0.3	0	1	0
Quantum physics	0.1	0	4	0	1.1	0	3	0
Theories and realism	0.1	0	3	0	1.0	0	3	0
Functions	0.0	0	1	0	0.4	0	1	0
Feminism	0.0	0	1	0	0.3	0	1	0
Medical ethics and Freud	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0
Abortion and self-defence	0.0	0	1	0	0.3	0	1	0
Belief ascriptions	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Thermodynamics	0.1	0	2	0	0.9	0	2	0
Knowledge	0.1	0	2	0	0.8	0	2	0
Game theory	0.0	0	0	0	0.3	0	1	0
Justification	0.0	0	2	0	0.8	0	2	0
Frankfurt cases	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0
Concepts	0.1	0	2	0	1.0	0	2	0
Races and DNA	0.0	0	1	0	0.3	0	1	0
Modality	0.1	0	4	0	0.5	0	1	0
Reasons	0.1	0	2	0	0.6	0	2	0
Evolutionary biology	0.3	0	9	0	2.9	0	7	0
Population ethics	0.0	0	2	0	0.3	0	1	0
Formal epistemology	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Wide content	0.0	0	1	0	0.4	0	1	0
Vagueness	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0
Cognitive science	0.0	0	2	0	0.5	0	1	0
Models	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Composition and constitution	0.1	0	2	0	0.4	0	1	0
Norms	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0

1887

Table B.12: Measures of the prominence of each subject in 1887 ’s journals.

Subject	Weight	Raw	W-Ratio	R-Ratio	W-Pages	R-Pages	WP-Ratio	RP-Ratio
Psychology	8.0	15	257	484	163.7	314	369	709
Idealism	2.1	2	66	65	28.8	21	65	47
Life and value	0.8	0	25	0	11.1	0	25	0
Other history	3.5	5	114	161	21.9	39	50	88
Dewey and pragmatism	0.1	0	3	0	1.4	0	3	0
Definitions	0.3	0	10	0	4.7	0	11	0
Propositions and implications	0.0	0	1	0	0.1	0	0	0
Beauty	0.0	0	1	0	0.2	0	0	0
Physicalism	0.1	0	3	0	1.9	0	4	0
History and culture	0.0	0	1	0	0.3	0	1	0
Faith and theism	0.3	0	9	0	6.1	0	14	0
Self-consciousness	1.2	1	39	32	12.6	7	28	16
Ancient	0.0	0	1	0	0.7	0	2	0
Universals and particulars	0.9	3	30	97	7.3	30	17	68
Verification	0.2	0	5	0	1.5	0	3	0
Value	0.1	0	2	0	0.8	0	2	0
Deduction	0.3	0	9	0	2.1	0	5	0
Mechanisms	0.1	0	3	0	0.9	0	2	0
Temporal paradoxes	0.6	1	20	32	5.4	5	12	11
Classical space and time	1.3	0	42	0	36.0	0	81	0
Early modern	0.3	0	11	0	2.9	0	6	0
Meaning and use	0.2	0	6	0	1.6	0	4	0
Marx	0.1	0	3	0	1.7	0	4	0
Ordinary language	1.8	0	59	0	40.7	0	92	0
Moral conscience	0.4	1	14	32	6.4	14	14	32
Methodology of science	0.5	0	16	0	4.9	0	11	0
Heidegger and Husserl	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Emotions	1.0	1	33	32	9.8	4	22	9
Ontological argument	0.2	0	5	0	2.0	0	5	0
Chemistry	0.3	0	8	0	3.7	0	8	0
Social contract theory	0.6	0	20	0	5.0	0	11	0
Kant	0.0	0	1	0	0.6	0	1	0
Promises and imperatives	0.2	0	8	0	3.5	0	8	0
Analytic/synthetic	0.2	0	6	0	1.0	0	2	0
Freedom and free will	0.0	0	1	0	0.4	0	1	0
Crime and punishment	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0
Sets and grue	0.2	0	6	0	1.5	0	3	0
Origins and purposes	0.1	0	4	0	2.2	0	5	0
Time	0.5	1	17	32	2.5	4	6	9
Color/colour	0.0	0	1	0	1.2	0	3	0
War	0.0	0	1	0	0.6	0	1	0
Depiction	0.5	0	15	0	3.5	0	8	0
Denoting	0.1	0	3	0	0.7	0	2	0
Chance	0.1	0	3	0	0.5	0	1	0
Hume	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Laws	0.7	1	22	32	5.9	5	13	11
Perception	0.2	0	7	0	5.3	0	12	0
Intention	0.1	0	2	0	1.7	0	4	0
Virtues	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Space and time	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0
Mathematics	0.2	0	6	0	1.1	0	2	0
Liberal democracy	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0
Duties	0.0	0	1	0	0.2	0	0	0
Causation	0.2	0	6	0	3.1	0	7	0
Arguments	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Theory testing	0.5	0	15	0	3.4	0	8	0
Decision theory	0.2	0	6	0	1.2	0	3	0
Minds and machines	0.1	0	3	0	0.8	0	2	0
Truth	0.0	0	1	0	0.2	0	0	0
Radical translation	0.0	0	1	0	0.3	0	1	0
Explanation	0.0	0	1	0	0.3	0	1	0
Personal identity	0.1	0	2	0	1.8	0	4	0
Speech acts	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Sense and reference	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0
Egalitarianism	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Quantum physics	0.0	0	0	0	0.2	0	0	0
Theories and realism	0.1	0	2	0	1.1	0	2	0
Functions	0.1	0	2	0	1.2	0	3	0
Feminism	0.2	0	5	0	1.0	0	2	0
Medical ethics and Freud	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Abortion and self-defence	0.1	0	3	0	0.5	0	1	0
Belief ascriptions	0.0	0	1	0	0.2	0	0	0
Thermodynamics	0.1	0	3	0	1.3	0	3	0
Knowledge	0.1	0	2	0	0.4	0	1	0
Game theory	0.2	0	7	0	1.4	0	3	0
Justification	0.0	0	2	0	0.3	0	1	0
Frankfurt cases	0.0	0	0	0	0.3	0	1	0
Concepts	0.0	0	1	0	0.2	0	0	0
Races and DNA	0.1	0	2	0	0.4	0	1	0
Modality	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Reasons	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Evolutionary biology	0.2	0	5	0	1.5	0	3	0
Population ethics	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Formal epistemology	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0
Wide content	0.1	0	3	0	1.2	0	3	0
Vagueness	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0
Cognitive science	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Models	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Composition and constitution	0.1	0	4	0	1.1	0	2	0
Norms	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0

1888

Table B.13: Measures of the prominence of each subject in 1888 ’s journals.

Subject	Weight	Raw	W-Ratio	R-Ratio	W-Pages	R-Pages	WP-Ratio	RP-Ratio
Psychology	7.4	12	176	286	117.6	185	226	356
Idealism	5.0	8	118	190	80.5	131	155	252
Life and value	1.6	1	37	24	23.4	30	45	58
Other history	2.2	4	53	95	19.3	52	37	100
Dewey and pragmatism	0.5	0	12	0	6.1	0	12	0
Definitions	0.6	1	14	24	9.9	20	19	38
Propositions and implications	0.4	0	11	0	2.0	0	4	0
Beauty	0.1	0	1	0	0.8	0	1	0
Physicalism	1.2	2	29	48	9.0	5	17	10
History and culture	0.7	0	17	0	3.3	0	6	0
Faith and theism	0.5	0	11	0	5.5	0	11	0
Self-consciousness	1.4	0	33	0	21.1	0	41	0
Ancient	0.4	0	10	0	2.3	0	4	0
Universals and particulars	0.9	2	22	48	4.9	6	9	12
Verification	0.1	0	1	0	1.1	0	2	0
Value	0.2	0	6	0	3.1	0	6	0
Deduction	0.4	0	9	0	6.4	0	12	0
Mechanisms	0.2	0	4	0	1.9	0	4	0
Temporal paradoxes	1.3	2	31	48	10.7	19	21	37
Classical space and time	0.7	0	17	0	12.2	0	23	0
Early modern	1.4	2	34	48	6.6	7	13	13
Meaning and use	0.2	0	5	0	3.1	0	6	0
Marx	0.4	1	10	24	5.9	11	11	21
Ordinary language	1.6	0	38	0	32.9	0	63	0
Moral conscience	0.7	1	16	24	9.6	23	19	44
Methodology of science	0.9	0	21	0	11.8	0	23	0
Heidegger and Husserl	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Emotions	1.5	2	36	48	18.5	12	36	23
Ontological argument	0.1	0	3	0	3.0	0	6	0
Chemistry	0.5	0	12	0	2.7	0	5	0
Social contract theory	0.3	0	7	0	2.2	0	4	0
Kant	0.4	0	10	0	3.8	0	7	0
Promises and imperatives	0.5	0	13	0	9.3	0	18	0
Analytic/synthetic	0.1	0	1	0	1.0	0	2	0
Freedom and free will	0.4	1	9	24	4.3	8	8	15
Crime and punishment	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Sets and grue	0.2	0	5	0	2.0	0	4	0
Origins and purposes	0.1	0	2	0	0.9	0	2	0
Time	0.5	0	11	0	3.3	0	6	0
Color/colour	0.2	0	5	0	1.4	0	3	0
War	0.0	0	1	0	0.5	0	1	0
Depiction	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0
Denoting	0.0	0	1	0	0.7	0	1	0
Chance	0.1	0	3	0	0.3	0	1	0
Hume	0.1	0	2	0	0.5	0	1	0
Laws	0.3	0	7	0	3.2	0	6	0
Perception	0.5	0	11	0	4.9	0	9	0
Intention	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Virtues	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Space and time	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0
Mathematics	0.1	0	4	0	2.9	0	5	0
Liberal democracy	0.1	0	1	0	0.7	0	1	0
Duties	0.1	0	3	0	2.1	0	4	0
Causation	0.5	1	11	24	3.4	5	7	10
Arguments	0.1	0	2	0	1.4	0	3	0
Theory testing	0.7	1	17	24	3.0	3	6	6
Decision theory	0.2	0	4	0	1.8	0	3	0
Minds and machines	0.3	0	8	0	3.5	0	7	0
Truth	0.0	0	1	0	0.6	0	1	0
Radical translation	0.0	0	1	0	0.3	0	1	0
Explanation	0.1	0	2	0	1.0	0	2	0
Personal identity	0.2	0	4	0	2.5	0	5	0
Speech acts	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Sense and reference	0.0	0	0	0	0.2	0	0	0
Egalitarianism	0.0	0	1	0	0.6	0	1	0
Quantum physics	0.0	0	1	0	0.4	0	1	0
Theories and realism	0.1	0	3	0	1.4	0	3	0
Functions	0.1	0	2	0	0.8	0	2	0
Feminism	0.2	0	4	0	0.7	0	1	0
Medical ethics and Freud	0.1	0	3	0	1.2	0	2	0
Abortion and self-defence	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0
Belief ascriptions	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Thermodynamics	0.2	0	5	0	1.8	0	3	0
Knowledge	0.4	0	10	0	2.4	0	5	0
Game theory	0.0	0	1	0	0.2	0	0	0
Justification	0.3	1	7	24	1.1	3	2	6
Frankfurt cases	0.1	0	3	0	0.6	0	1	0
Concepts	0.1	0	1	0	1.4	0	3	0
Races and DNA	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Modality	0.0	0	0	0	0.2	0	0	0
Reasons	0.4	0	9	0	5.7	0	11	0
Evolutionary biology	0.0	0	1	0	0.4	0	1	0
Population ethics	0.1	0	3	0	0.7	0	1	0
Formal epistemology	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Wide content	0.2	0	5	0	1.9	0	4	0
Vagueness	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0
Cognitive science	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Models	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Composition and constitution	0.1	0	3	0	0.4	0	1	0
Norms	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0

1889

Table B.14: Measures of the prominence of each subject in 1889 ’s journals.

Subject	Weight	Raw	W-Ratio	R-Ratio	W-Pages	R-Pages	WP-Ratio	RP-Ratio
Psychology	7.8	11	299	423	116.5	170	298	435
Idealism	2.7	5	105	192	57.6	105	147	269
Life and value	0.9	1	35	38	17.7	23	45	59
Other history	0.6	0	22	0	7.2	0	18	0
Dewey and pragmatism	0.1	0	5	0	2.0	0	5	0
Definitions	0.3	0	11	0	1.8	0	5	0
Propositions and implications	0.1	0	4	0	2.0	0	5	0
Beauty	0.0	0	0	0	0.2	0	0	0
Physicalism	0.2	0	7	0	2.4	0	6	0
History and culture	0.2	0	6	0	0.6	0	1	0
Faith and theism	0.1	0	4	0	1.5	0	4	0
Self-consciousness	0.8	0	30	0	11.1	0	28	0
Ancient	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0
Universals and particulars	0.1	0	5	0	2.9	0	7	0
Verification	0.1	0	5	0	2.3	0	6	0
Value	0.1	0	3	0	1.5	0	4	0
Deduction	0.1	0	2	0	1.1	0	3	0
Mechanisms	0.0	0	2	0	1.0	0	2	0
Temporal paradoxes	0.6	0	22	0	9.0	0	23	0
Classical space and time	1.3	2	52	77	19.6	38	50	97
Early modern	0.1	0	5	0	1.2	0	3	0
Meaning and use	0.3	0	10	0	3.8	0	10	0
Marx	0.1	0	3	0	1.6	0	4	0
Ordinary language	1.4	1	53	38	26.9	16	69	41
Moral conscience	0.5	1	20	38	9.3	15	24	38
Methodology of science	0.2	0	8	0	2.3	0	6	0
Heidegger and Husserl	0.0	0	1	0	0.3	0	1	0
Emotions	1.2	2	47	77	17.6	18	45	46
Ontological argument	0.2	0	6	0	3.1	0	8	0
Chemistry	0.1	0	5	0	2.2	0	6	0
Social contract theory	0.1	0	5	0	3.0	0	8	0
Kant	0.3	0	10	0	4.6	0	12	0
Promises and imperatives	0.2	0	6	0	3.4	0	9	0
Analytic/synthetic	0.1	0	4	0	2.2	0	6	0
Freedom and free will	0.1	0	3	0	1.2	0	3	0
Crime and punishment	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Sets and grue	0.1	0	5	0	3.3	0	8	0
Origins and purposes	0.2	0	9	0	2.4	0	6	0
Time	0.0	0	2	0	0.9	0	2	0
Color/colour	0.8	1	30	38	0.9	1	2	3
War	0.0	0	0	0	0.3	0	1	0
Depiction	0.2	0	6	0	1.5	0	4	0
Denoting	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0
Chance	0.0	0	1	0	0.4	0	1	0
Hume	0.0	0	2	0	1.3	0	3	0
Laws	0.1	0	2	0	1.2	0	3	0
Perception	0.7	1	28	38	4.8	2	12	5
Intention	0.0	0	0	0	0.3	0	1	0
Virtues	0.0	0	1	0	0.3	0	1	0
Space and time	0.0	0	1	0	0.6	0	1	0
Mathematics	0.1	0	4	0	0.6	0	1	0
Liberal democracy	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0
Duties	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Causation	0.4	0	14	0	1.8	0	5	0
Arguments	0.1	0	2	0	1.3	0	3	0
Theory testing	0.1	0	4	0	2.1	0	5	0
Decision theory	0.1	0	3	0	1.3	0	3	0
Minds and machines	0.2	0	6	0	1.9	0	5	0
Truth	0.1	0	3	0	1.1	0	3	0
Radical translation	0.1	0	2	0	0.6	0	1	0
Explanation	0.4	0	15	0	1.7	0	4	0
Personal identity	0.1	0	2	0	1.3	0	3	0
Speech acts	0.0	0	0	0	0.2	0	0	0
Sense and reference	0.0	0	0	0	0.3	0	1	0
Egalitarianism	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0
Quantum physics	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Theories and realism	0.1	0	5	0	1.5	0	4	0
Functions	0.1	0	4	0	1.6	0	4	0
Feminism	0.2	1	8	38	1.2	3	3	8
Medical ethics and Freud	0.0	0	1	0	0.4	0	1	0
Abortion and self-defence	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0
Belief ascriptions	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Thermodynamics	0.3	0	10	0	1.9	0	5	0
Knowledge	0.1	0	2	0	0.2	0	1	0
Game theory	0.0	0	0	0	0.3	0	1	0
Justification	0.1	0	2	0	1.7	0	4	0
Frankfurt cases	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Concepts	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0
Races and DNA	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0
Modality	0.0	0	1	0	0.5	0	1	0
Reasons	0.1	0	2	0	1.0	0	3	0
Evolutionary biology	0.1	0	3	0	2.0	0	5	0
Population ethics	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Formal epistemology	0.0	0	1	0	0.2	0	0	0
Wide content	0.1	0	5	0	2.6	0	7	0
Vagueness	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0
Cognitive science	0.1	0	3	0	1.9	0	5	0
Models	0.0	0	0	0	0.2	0	0	0
Composition and constitution	0.0	0	1	0	0.3	0	1	0
Norms	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0

1890

Table B.15: Measures of the prominence of each subject in 1890 ’s journals.

Subject	Weight	Raw	W-Ratio	R-Ratio	W-Pages	R-Pages	WP-Ratio	RP-Ratio
Psychology	9.3	17	198	362	149.4	266	219	390
Idealism	6.5	8	139	170	103.1	151	151	221
Life and value	3.2	5	69	106	48.8	79	72	116
Other history	1.8	2	37	43	22.5	27	33	40
Dewey and pragmatism	0.3	0	7	0	6.0	0	9	0
Definitions	0.3	0	6	0	4.8	0	7	0
Propositions and implications	0.5	1	11	21	7.8	14	11	21
Beauty	1.6	3	35	64	28.8	50	42	73
Physicalism	1.3	1	27	21	10.3	2	15	3
History and culture	0.4	0	9	0	5.5	0	8	0
Faith and theism	0.9	1	19	21	11.9	12	17	18
Self-consciousness	1.6	0	34	0	22.7	0	33	0
Ancient	0.4	1	9	21	5.8	14	9	21
Universals and particulars	0.5	0	11	0	7.8	0	11	0
Verification	0.1	0	2	0	1.1	0	2	0
Value	0.5	1	11	21	3.6	3	5	4
Deduction	0.5	0	10	0	8.8	0	13	0
Mechanisms	0.4	1	9	21	4.4	7	6	10
Temporal paradoxes	0.8	1	17	21	11.1	13	16	19
Classical space and time	0.7	0	14	0	10.1	0	15	0
Early modern	0.5	0	10	0	5.8	0	9	0
Meaning and use	0.2	0	4	0	2.7	0	4	0
Marx	0.3	1	7	21	2.6	7	4	10
Ordinary language	2.7	2	58	43	39.5	16	58	23
Moral conscience	0.9	2	20	43	9.8	21	14	31
Methodology of science	0.7	0	16	0	11.3	0	17	0
Heidegger and Husserl	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Emotions	0.7	0	14	0	9.1	0	13	0
Ontological argument	0.4	0	9	0	5.5	0	8	0
Chemistry	0.2	0	4	0	2.5	0	4	0
Social contract theory	0.3	0	6	0	4.3	0	6	0
Kant	0.5	0	10	0	7.0	0	10	0
Promises and imperatives	0.5	0	12	0	8.5	0	12	0
Analytic/synthetic	0.2	0	4	0	2.1	0	3	0
Freedom and free will	0.3	0	6	0	3.2	0	5	0
Crime and punishment	0.0	0	1	0	0.4	0	1	0
Sets and grue	0.1	0	3	0	1.2	0	2	0
Origins and purposes	0.2	0	5	0	4.7	0	7	0
Time	0.1	0	2	0	1.7	0	2	0
Color/colour	0.2	0	5	0	3.2	0	5	0
War	0.0	0	0	0	0.3	0	0	0
Depiction	0.2	0	4	0	3.7	0	5	0
Denoting	0.1	0	3	0	2.0	0	3	0
Chance	0.1	0	3	0	1.5	0	2	0
Hume	0.2	0	5	0	2.9	0	4	0
Laws	0.4	0	8	0	6.4	0	9	0
Perception	0.4	0	8	0	5.8	0	9	0
Intention	0.0	0	1	0	0.5	0	1	0
Virtues	0.1	0	3	0	1.9	0	3	0
Space and time	0.0	0	1	0	0.4	0	1	0
Mathematics	0.1	0	3	0	1.0	0	1	0
Liberal democracy	0.2	0	4	0	1.6	0	2	0
Duties	0.1	0	3	0	0.5	0	1	0
Causation	0.2	0	5	0	3.9	0	6	0
Arguments	0.2	0	3	0	2.4	0	4	0
Theory testing	0.4	0	8	0	4.9	0	7	0
Decision theory	0.2	0	5	0	1.9	0	3	0
Minds and machines	0.2	0	4	0	1.7	0	2	0
Truth	0.1	0	3	0	1.5	0	2	0
Radical translation	0.0	0	0	0	0.4	0	1	0
Explanation	0.1	0	1	0	1.1	0	2	0
Personal identity	0.1	0	2	0	1.4	0	2	0
Speech acts	0.1	0	1	0	1.2	0	2	0
Sense and reference	0.0	0	0	0	0.3	0	0	0
Egalitarianism	0.2	0	4	0	1.0	0	2	0
Quantum physics	0.0	0	0	0	0.2	0	0	0
Theories and realism	0.1	0	3	0	1.7	0	3	0
Functions	0.4	0	8	0	5.0	0	7	0
Feminism	0.1	0	3	0	1.5	0	2	0
Medical ethics and Freud	0.0	0	1	0	0.3	0	0	0
Abortion and self-defence	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0
Belief ascriptions	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Thermodynamics	0.1	0	2	0	1.4	0	2	0
Knowledge	0.2	0	4	0	2.1	0	3	0
Game theory	0.1	0	3	0	1.2	0	2	0
Justification	0.1	0	2	0	1.6	0	2	0
Frankfurt cases	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Concepts	0.2	0	4	0	3.3	0	5	0
Races and DNA	0.1	0	1	0	0.6	0	1	0
Modality	0.2	0	5	0	2.0	0	3	0
Reasons	0.3	0	6	0	3.7	0	5	0
Evolutionary biology	0.2	0	5	0	4.5	0	7	0
Population ethics	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0
Formal epistemology	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Wide content	0.1	0	2	0	1.7	0	2	0
Vagueness	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Cognitive science	0.0	0	1	0	0.9	0	1	0
Models	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Composition and constitution	0.0	0	1	0	0.3	0	0	0
Norms	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0

1891

Table B.16: Measures of the prominence of each subject in 1891 ’s journals.

Subject	Weight	Raw	W-Ratio	R-Ratio	W-Pages	R-Pages	WP-Ratio	RP-Ratio
Psychology	7.2	13	232	419	147.4	274	289	537
Idealism	4.4	8	142	258	60.3	108	118	212
Life and value	1.5	1	49	32	21.4	8	42	16
Other history	1.5	2	50	65	27.9	34	55	67
Dewey and pragmatism	0.3	0	10	0	5.5	0	11	0
Definitions	0.1	0	4	0	1.9	0	4	0
Propositions and implications	0.1	0	2	0	1.1	0	2	0
Beauty	1.0	2	33	65	7.5	17	15	33
Physicalism	0.4	0	12	0	7.6	0	15	0
History and culture	0.2	0	6	0	3.1	0	6	0
Faith and theism	0.2	0	7	0	2.7	0	5	0
Self-consciousness	0.6	0	19	0	9.4	0	18	0
Ancient	0.2	0	7	0	2.9	0	6	0
Universals and particulars	0.3	0	9	0	5.1	0	10	0
Verification	0.3	0	11	0	4.8	0	9	0
Value	0.3	0	10	0	3.0	0	6	0
Deduction	0.6	1	18	32	8.3	14	16	27
Mechanisms	0.2	0	6	0	1.4	0	3	0
Temporal paradoxes	0.2	0	6	0	2.5	0	5	0
Classical space and time	0.4	0	12	0	8.5	0	17	0
Early modern	0.4	1	12	32	7.9	23	15	45
Meaning and use	0.4	0	14	0	9.0	0	18	0
Marx	0.1	0	4	0	2.2	0	4	0
Ordinary language	1.4	1	47	32	23.0	12	45	24
Moral conscience	0.4	1	12	32	5.3	14	10	27
Methodology of science	0.9	0	29	0	14.7	0	29	0
Heidegger and Husserl	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0
Emotions	1.2	1	38	32	21.9	6	43	12
Ontological argument	0.2	0	5	0	2.9	0	6	0
Chemistry	0.1	0	2	0	1.1	0	2	0
Social contract theory	0.2	0	8	0	3.7	0	7	0
Kant	0.5	0	17	0	9.3	0	18	0
Promises and imperatives	0.6	0	19	0	9.3	0	18	0
Analytic/synthetic	0.0	0	1	0	0.6	0	1	0
Freedom and free will	0.2	0	7	0	4.2	0	8	0
Crime and punishment	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0
Sets and grue	0.2	0	7	0	3.3	0	6	0
Origins and purposes	0.2	0	8	0	3.0	0	6	0
Time	0.2	0	5	0	0.9	0	2	0
Color/colour	0.1	0	2	0	0.5	0	1	0
War	0.0	0	1	0	0.4	0	1	0
Depiction	0.3	0	10	0	3.2	0	6	0
Denoting	0.1	0	2	0	0.5	0	1	0
Chance	0.0	0	1	0	0.6	0	1	0
Hume	0.0	0	0	0	0.2	0	0	0
Laws	0.2	0	6	0	3.4	0	7	0
Perception	0.3	0	9	0	5.6	0	11	0
Intention	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0
Virtues	0.0	0	1	0	0.4	0	1	0
Space and time	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Mathematics	0.0	0	1	0	0.5	0	1	0
Liberal democracy	0.0	0	1	0	0.7	0	1	0
Duties	0.0	0	1	0	0.4	0	1	0
Causation	0.2	0	5	0	2.1	0	4	0
Arguments	0.0	0	2	0	0.8	0	2	0
Theory testing	0.1	0	2	0	1.2	0	2	0
Decision theory	0.1	0	4	0	1.7	0	3	0
Minds and machines	0.0	0	1	0	0.9	0	2	0
Truth	0.0	0	0	0	0.2	0	0	0
Radical translation	0.0	0	0	0	0.2	0	0	0
Explanation	0.0	0	1	0	0.9	0	2	0
Personal identity	0.0	0	1	0	0.9	0	2	0
Speech acts	0.2	0	6	0	1.8	0	4	0
Sense and reference	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Egalitarianism	0.0	0	0	0	0.3	0	1	0
Quantum physics	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0
Theories and realism	0.1	0	4	0	2.4	0	5	0
Functions	0.1	0	3	0	2.3	0	5	0
Feminism	0.1	0	2	0	0.7	0	1	0
Medical ethics and Freud	0.0	0	1	0	0.5	0	1	0
Abortion and self-defence	0.1	0	3	0	1.0	0	2	0
Belief ascriptions	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0
Thermodynamics	0.2	0	7	0	5.1	0	10	0
Knowledge	0.1	0	5	0	2.0	0	4	0
Game theory	0.0	0	1	0	0.2	0	0	0
Justification	0.2	0	5	0	1.9	0	4	0
Frankfurt cases	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Concepts	0.1	0	3	0	2.5	0	5	0
Races and DNA	0.2	0	8	0	2.0	0	4	0
Modality	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Reasons	0.2	0	5	0	1.6	0	3	0
Evolutionary biology	0.2	0	5	0	2.3	0	4	0
Population ethics	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Formal epistemology	0.0	0	1	0	0.3	0	1	0
Wide content	0.1	0	3	0	2.1	0	4	0
Vagueness	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0
Cognitive science	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Models	0.1	0	4	0	0.5	0	1	0
Composition and constitution	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Norms	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0

1892

Table B.17: Measures of the prominence of each subject in 1892 ’s journals.

Subject	Weight	Raw	W-Ratio	R-Ratio	W-Pages	R-Pages	WP-Ratio	RP-Ratio
Psychology	11.6	20	193	333	195.1	352	211	381
Idealism	9.3	16	155	267	154.3	266	167	288
Life and value	3.9	5	65	83	56.9	56	62	61
Other history	1.6	2	27	33	25.6	19	28	21
Dewey and pragmatism	0.5	1	9	17	7.4	6	8	6
Definitions	0.6	0	10	0	10.6	0	11	0
Propositions and implications	1.4	3	23	50	22.7	62	25	67
Beauty	1.0	1	17	17	14.6	2	16	2
Physicalism	0.9	0	15	0	13.0	0	14	0
History and culture	0.3	0	5	0	5.5	0	6	0
Faith and theism	0.6	1	10	17	9.4	17	10	18
Self-consciousness	1.7	0	29	0	25.7	0	28	0
Ancient	0.7	1	11	17	8.7	13	9	14
Universals and particulars	0.9	0	15	0	12.4	0	13	0
Verification	0.2	0	4	0	3.4	0	4	0
Value	0.5	1	9	17	8.5	25	9	27
Deduction	0.8	1	13	17	10.3	4	11	4
Mechanisms	0.2	0	3	0	2.8	0	3	0
Temporal paradoxes	0.8	0	14	0	12.7	0	14	0
Classical space and time	0.8	0	13	0	10.4	0	11	0
Early modern	0.1	0	2	0	2.2	0	2	0
Meaning and use	0.6	0	10	0	5.5	0	6	0
Marx	0.3	0	5	0	6.1	0	7	0
Ordinary language	2.2	0	37	0	35.9	0	39	0
Moral conscience	0.7	0	12	0	11.3	0	12	0
Methodology of science	0.9	0	16	0	12.7	0	14	0
Heidegger and Husserl	0.1	0	2	0	1.0	0	1	0
Emotions	3.1	3	51	50	44.6	29	48	31
Ontological argument	0.3	0	5	0	4.6	0	5	0
Chemistry	0.7	0	12	0	10.4	0	11	0
Social contract theory	0.3	0	4	0	3.3	0	4	0
Kant	0.5	0	8	0	8.0	0	9	0
Promises and imperatives	0.5	0	9	0	9.4	0	10	0
Analytic/synthetic	0.2	0	3	0	2.7	0	3	0
Freedom and free will	0.3	0	4	0	4.1	0	4	0
Crime and punishment	0.4	1	6	17	11.2	29	12	31
Sets and grue	0.5	1	9	17	6.5	9	7	10
Origins and purposes	0.3	0	6	0	3.9	0	4	0
Time	0.2	0	3	0	2.3	0	3	0
Color/colour	0.5	0	9	0	6.3	0	7	0
War	0.1	0	2	0	1.9	0	2	0
Depiction	1.0	1	17	17	16.3	25	18	27
Denoting	0.0	0	1	0	0.8	0	1	0
Chance	0.3	0	5	0	5.5	0	6	0
Hume	0.1	0	1	0	1.2	0	1	0
Laws	0.3	0	5	0	5.5	0	6	0
Perception	0.5	0	9	0	8.9	0	10	0
Intention	0.2	0	4	0	1.9	0	2	0
Virtues	0.0	0	0	0	0.4	0	0	0
Space and time	0.1	0	2	0	1.9	0	2	0
Mathematics	0.2	0	3	0	2.0	0	2	0
Liberal democracy	0.0	0	1	0	0.5	0	0	0
Duties	0.1	0	2	0	1.6	0	2	0
Causation	0.3	0	6	0	5.7	0	6	0
Arguments	0.5	0	9	0	6.1	0	7	0
Theory testing	0.5	1	8	17	4.8	6	5	6
Decision theory	0.1	0	1	0	1.2	0	1	0
Minds and machines	0.3	0	5	0	3.1	0	3	0
Truth	0.1	0	2	0	2.0	0	2	0
Radical translation	0.0	0	0	0	0.3	0	0	0
Explanation	0.1	0	2	0	2.8	0	3	0
Personal identity	0.2	0	3	0	2.3	0	2	0
Speech acts	0.3	0	5	0	1.4	0	2	0
Sense and reference	0.0	0	1	0	0.5	0	1	0
Egalitarianism	0.0	0	1	0	0.6	0	1	0
Quantum physics	0.0	0	1	0	0.5	0	1	0
Theories and realism	0.3	0	4	0	4.5	0	5	0
Functions	0.1	0	2	0	2.8	0	3	0
Feminism	0.3	0	5	0	3.8	0	4	0
Medical ethics and Freud	0.0	0	0	0	0.5	0	1	0
Abortion and self-defence	0.0	0	0	0	0.4	0	0	0
Belief ascriptions	0.0	0	0	0	0.3	0	0	0
Thermodynamics	0.3	0	4	0	5.0	0	5	0
Knowledge	0.2	0	3	0	2.9	0	3	0
Game theory	0.2	0	4	0	1.4	0	1	0
Justification	0.2	0	3	0	2.1	0	2	0
Frankfurt cases	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0
Concepts	0.0	0	1	0	0.7	0	1	0
Races and DNA	0.1	0	2	0	1.6	0	2	0
Modality	0.0	0	0	0	0.4	0	0	0
Reasons	0.5	1	9	17	4.9	4	5	4
Evolutionary biology	0.3	0	4	0	4.0	0	4	0
Population ethics	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0
Formal epistemology	0.0	0	0	0	0.3	0	0	0
Wide content	0.2	0	4	0	3.6	0	4	0
Vagueness	0.1	0	1	0	0.9	0	1	0
Cognitive science	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0
Models	0.1	0	1	0	0.6	0	1	0
Composition and constitution	0.1	0	1	0	1.4	0	2	0
Norms	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0

1893

Table B.18: Measures of the prominence of each subject in 1893 ’s journals.

Subject	Weight	Raw	W-Ratio	R-Ratio	W-Pages	R-Pages	WP-Ratio	RP-Ratio
Psychology	8.9	15	136	231	110.6	191	133	230
Idealism	13.3	24	205	369	176.9	310	213	374
Life and value	2.6	3	40	46	37.2	35	45	42
Other history	3.2	3	50	46	37.7	37	45	45
Dewey and pragmatism	0.7	0	11	0	11.8	0	14	0
Definitions	1.1	1	17	15	11.2	8	14	10
Propositions and implications	0.6	1	9	15	6.3	16	8	19
Beauty	0.5	0	7	0	7.7	0	9	0
Physicalism	0.9	0	13	0	12.1	0	15	0
History and culture	0.3	0	4	0	4.9	0	6	0
Faith and theism	0.6	1	8	15	10.7	23	13	28
Self-consciousness	2.2	0	33	0	30.3	0	37	0
Ancient	0.8	1	12	15	10.4	12	13	14
Universals and particulars	1.1	1	18	15	8.3	5	10	6
Verification	0.2	0	3	0	2.6	0	3	0
Value	0.3	0	5	0	3.7	0	4	0
Deduction	0.5	1	8	15	7.0	15	8	18
Mechanisms	0.7	1	10	15	4.6	6	6	7
Temporal paradoxes	1.0	0	16	0	13.3	0	16	0
Classical space and time	1.0	1	16	15	6.7	3	8	4
Early modern	0.3	0	4	0	4.1	0	5	0
Meaning and use	0.9	0	14	0	8.2	0	10	0
Marx	0.1	0	2	0	1.7	0	2	0
Ordinary language	2.3	1	35	15	31.2	6	38	7
Moral conscience	1.0	2	15	31	13.7	22	17	27
Methodology of science	2.3	0	36	0	29.8	0	36	0
Heidegger and Husserl	0.1	0	2	0	2.9	0	3	0
Emotions	1.1	0	17	0	13.4	0	16	0
Ontological argument	0.5	0	8	0	7.5	0	9	0
Chemistry	1.0	1	15	15	11.5	8	14	10
Social contract theory	0.4	1	6	15	6.7	19	8	23
Kant	1.6	2	25	31	32.6	47	39	57
Promises and imperatives	0.5	1	8	15	7.4	14	9	17
Analytic/synthetic	0.3	0	5	0	7.6	0	9	0
Freedom and free will	0.3	1	4	15	3.8	15	5	18
Crime and punishment	0.3	0	4	0	4.1	0	5	0
Sets and grue	0.2	0	2	0	2.1	0	2	0
Origins and purposes	0.1	0	1	0	0.9	0	1	0
Time	0.3	0	4	0	3.6	0	4	0
Color/colour	0.5	0	7	0	6.8	0	8	0
War	0.1	0	1	0	0.7	0	1	0
Depiction	1.2	1	18	15	7.7	5	9	6
Denoting	0.5	0	7	0	2.1	0	3	0
Chance	0.1	0	2	0	1.8	0	2	0
Hume	0.2	0	4	0	3.5	0	4	0
Laws	0.9	1	13	15	11.9	12	14	14
Perception	0.8	0	12	0	12.9	0	16	0
Intention	0.0	0	1	0	0.5	0	1	0
Virtues	0.1	0	1	0	0.8	0	1	0
Space and time	0.1	0	2	0	1.4	0	2	0
Mathematics	0.1	0	2	0	2.1	0	3	0
Liberal democracy	0.1	0	1	0	0.9	0	1	0
Duties	0.0	0	1	0	0.5	0	1	0
Causation	0.5	1	8	15	8.9	20	11	24
Arguments	0.4	0	6	0	3.2	0	4	0
Theory testing	0.5	0	7	0	5.0	0	6	0
Decision theory	0.1	0	1	0	1.5	0	2	0
Minds and machines	0.1	0	2	0	2.4	0	3	0
Truth	0.1	0	2	0	1.8	0	2	0
Radical translation	0.0	0	0	0	0.2	0	0	0
Explanation	0.1	0	2	0	1.9	0	2	0
Personal identity	0.8	0	12	0	4.3	0	5	0
Speech acts	0.2	0	3	0	2.7	0	3	0
Sense and reference	0.0	0	0	0	0.2	0	0	0
Egalitarianism	0.0	0	1	0	0.8	0	1	0
Quantum physics	0.4	0	6	0	4.0	0	5	0
Theories and realism	0.4	0	6	0	3.7	0	4	0
Functions	0.0	0	1	0	0.6	0	1	0
Feminism	0.1	0	1	0	0.8	0	1	0
Medical ethics and Freud	0.0	0	1	0	0.5	0	1	0
Abortion and self-defence	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0
Belief ascriptions	0.0	0	1	0	0.4	0	0	0
Thermodynamics	0.1	0	2	0	1.3	0	2	0
Knowledge	0.6	0	10	0	9.0	0	11	0
Game theory	0.0	0	0	0	0.2	0	0	0
Justification	0.1	0	2	0	1.9	0	2	0
Frankfurt cases	0.1	0	1	0	0.8	0	1	0
Concepts	0.2	0	4	0	3.4	0	4	0
Races and DNA	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0
Modality	0.0	0	1	0	0.4	0	1	0
Reasons	0.2	0	2	0	2.1	0	3	0
Evolutionary biology	0.3	0	5	0	1.3	0	2	0
Population ethics	0.0	0	0	0	0.3	0	0	0
Formal epistemology	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Wide content	0.2	0	4	0	3.1	0	4	0
Vagueness	0.1	0	1	0	1.0	0	1	0
Cognitive science	0.0	0	0	0	0.2	0	0	0
Models	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0
Composition and constitution	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0
Norms	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0

1894

Table B.19: Measures of the prominence of each subject in 1894 ’s journals.

Subject	Weight	Raw	W-Ratio	R-Ratio	W-Pages	R-Pages	WP-Ratio	RP-Ratio
Psychology	8.9	12	129	174	140.1	208	154	229
Idealism	14.1	25	205	362	208.2	378	229	415
Life and value	2.8	2	40	29	49.7	36	55	40
Other history	1.4	1	21	14	16.9	18	19	20
Dewey and pragmatism	0.6	0	8	0	7.6	0	8	0
Definitions	0.7	0	10	0	10.3	0	11	0
Propositions and implications	2.0	3	29	43	13.2	33	14	36
Beauty	0.6	0	9	0	9.0	0	10	0
Physicalism	1.3	2	19	29	13.6	13	15	14
History and culture	0.5	1	7	14	8.6	17	9	19
Faith and theism	1.1	1	16	14	16.0	14	18	15
Self-consciousness	3.1	2	45	29	39.0	18	43	20
Ancient	0.8	1	12	14	9.5	9	10	10
Universals and particulars	1.2	1	17	14	12.4	4	14	4
Verification	0.3	0	5	0	3.7	0	4	0
Value	0.5	1	7	14	7.5	17	8	19
Deduction	0.4	0	6	0	6.4	0	7	0
Mechanisms	0.3	0	4	0	2.7	0	3	0
Temporal paradoxes	0.7	0	11	0	10.8	0	12	0
Classical space and time	0.9	2	13	29	4.6	5	5	5
Early modern	0.8	1	12	14	10.7	20	12	22
Meaning and use	0.8	0	11	0	10.1	0	11	0
Marx	0.1	0	2	0	2.0	0	2	0
Ordinary language	3.3	1	48	14	53.7	8	59	9
Moral conscience	1.1	0	16	0	16.2	0	18	0
Methodology of science	0.8	0	12	0	11.2	0	12	0
Heidegger and Husserl	0.0	0	0	0	0.3	0	0	0
Emotions	2.3	2	33	29	21.5	24	24	26
Ontological argument	0.6	0	9	0	9.3	0	10	0
Chemistry	0.5	0	7	0	5.8	0	6	0
Social contract theory	0.5	0	7	0	6.6	0	7	0
Kant	1.1	1	16	14	14.0	16	15	18
Promises and imperatives	0.9	1	13	14	10.3	4	11	4
Analytic/synthetic	0.2	0	3	0	2.7	0	3	0
Freedom and free will	1.6	3	22	43	16.9	17	19	19
Crime and punishment	0.1	0	2	0	2.0	0	2	0
Sets and grue	0.1	0	1	0	1.7	0	2	0
Origins and purposes	0.1	0	2	0	2.3	0	3	0
Time	0.2	0	2	0	1.9	0	2	0
Color/colour	0.9	1	14	14	7.7	7	8	8
War	0.1	0	1	0	0.9	0	1	0
Depiction	0.4	0	6	0	2.9	0	3	0
Denoting	0.2	0	2	0	2.0	0	2	0
Chance	0.0	0	0	0	0.6	0	1	0
Hume	0.6	1	9	14	10.3	17	11	19
Laws	0.4	0	6	0	5.9	0	6	0
Perception	0.5	0	8	0	4.9	0	5	0
Intention	0.4	0	6	0	1.9	0	2	0
Virtues	0.0	0	0	0	0.4	0	0	0
Space and time	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Mathematics	0.1	0	1	0	1.2	0	1	0
Liberal democracy	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Duties	0.3	1	4	14	3.9	14	4	15
Causation	0.9	0	14	0	11.5	0	13	0
Arguments	0.4	0	6	0	5.6	0	6	0
Theory testing	0.4	0	6	0	4.0	0	4	0
Decision theory	0.2	0	2	0	1.4	0	2	0
Minds and machines	0.2	0	3	0	3.1	0	3	0
Truth	0.9	1	12	14	3.5	1	4	1
Radical translation	0.1	0	1	0	1.0	0	1	0
Explanation	0.2	0	2	0	2.2	0	2	0
Personal identity	0.3	0	4	0	2.8	0	3	0
Speech acts	0.1	0	2	0	1.3	0	1	0
Sense and reference	0.0	0	0	0	0.2	0	0	0
Egalitarianism	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Quantum physics	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Theories and realism	0.3	0	4	0	3.8	0	4	0
Functions	0.1	0	1	0	1.2	0	1	0
Feminism	0.1	0	1	0	1.7	0	2	0
Medical ethics and Freud	0.0	0	1	0	0.7	0	1	0
Abortion and self-defence	0.2	0	2	0	0.6	0	1	0
Belief ascriptions	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Thermodynamics	0.4	0	6	0	2.3	0	3	0
Knowledge	0.6	0	8	0	7.4	0	8	0
Game theory	0.0	0	1	0	0.5	0	1	0
Justification	0.2	0	3	0	3.3	0	4	0
Frankfurt cases	0.3	0	4	0	2.7	0	3	0
Concepts	0.1	0	2	0	2.1	0	2	0
Races and DNA	0.1	0	1	0	1.4	0	2	0
Modality	0.0	0	1	0	0.2	0	0	0
Reasons	0.5	0	7	0	5.4	0	6	0
Evolutionary biology	0.4	1	5	14	4.5	11	5	12
Population ethics	0.0	0	0	0	0.4	0	0	0
Formal epistemology	0.4	1	6	14	0.4	1	0	1
Wide content	0.2	0	3	0	1.4	0	2	0
Vagueness	0.0	0	1	0	0.8	0	1	0
Cognitive science	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Models	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0
Composition and constitution	0.0	0	0	0	0.4	0	0	0
Norms	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0

1895

Table B.20: Measures of the prominence of each subject in 1895 ’s journals.

Subject	Weight	Raw	W-Ratio	R-Ratio	W-Pages	R-Pages	WP-Ratio	RP-Ratio
Psychology	9.9	15	140	211	162.3	253	165	257
Idealism	11.5	19	162	268	170.4	272	173	276
Life and value	4.1	5	58	70	66.8	95	68	97
Other history	1.7	1	24	14	24.2	14	25	14
Dewey and pragmatism	0.4	0	5	0	6.4	0	6	0
Definitions	1.1	0	15	0	17.3	0	18	0
Propositions and implications	0.8	1	11	14	5.6	2	6	2
Beauty	1.0	1	14	14	10.6	15	11	15
Physicalism	0.7	0	10	0	8.9	0	9	0
History and culture	0.2	0	3	0	3.3	0	3	0
Faith and theism	1.1	1	16	14	16.0	11	16	11
Self-consciousness	2.5	0	35	0	28.4	0	29	0
Ancient	1.2	1	16	14	12.8	10	13	10
Universals and particulars	0.6	0	8	0	7.1	0	7	0
Verification	0.4	0	5	0	4.0	0	4	0
Value	0.7	2	10	28	14.4	42	15	43
Deduction	1.0	1	14	14	18.5	17	19	17
Mechanisms	0.2	0	4	0	3.6	0	4	0
Temporal paradoxes	1.8	1	26	14	21.5	3	22	3
Classical space and time	1.2	2	16	28	18.2	34	18	35
Early modern	1.0	1	14	14	8.2	2	8	2
Meaning and use	0.5	0	8	0	6.0	0	6	0
Marx	0.5	1	7	14	6.2	4	6	4
Ordinary language	4.8	6	68	85	74.4	76	76	77
Moral conscience	1.8	1	25	14	20.3	8	21	8
Methodology of science	1.1	0	16	0	14.5	0	15	0
Heidegger and Husserl	0.1	0	2	0	1.6	0	2	0
Emotions	3.0	4	43	56	34.8	27	35	27
Ontological argument	0.6	0	8	0	7.9	0	8	0
Chemistry	0.6	0	9	0	9.1	0	9	0
Social contract theory	1.4	3	20	42	27.1	63	28	64
Kant	0.6	0	9	0	6.4	0	7	0
Promises and imperatives	0.7	0	10	0	9.0	0	9	0
Analytic/synthetic	0.8	1	11	14	2.4	1	2	1
Freedom and free will	0.2	0	3	0	3.1	0	3	0
Crime and punishment	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0
Sets and grue	0.1	0	2	0	1.9	0	2	0
Origins and purposes	0.3	0	4	0	3.9	0	4	0
Time	0.3	0	4	0	4.5	0	5	0
Color/colour	0.2	0	2	0	2.0	0	2	0
War	0.1	0	1	0	0.6	0	1	0
Depiction	0.6	1	9	14	4.6	4	5	4
Denoting	0.4	1	6	14	7.9	18	8	18
Chance	0.0	0	0	0	0.4	0	0	0
Hume	0.3	0	4	0	4.0	0	4	0
Laws	0.7	0	10	0	7.2	0	7	0
Perception	0.7	0	9	0	11.1	0	11	0
Intention	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0
Virtues	0.3	0	4	0	2.1	0	2	0
Space and time	0.0	0	0	0	0.2	0	0	0
Mathematics	0.2	0	2	0	1.8	0	2	0
Liberal democracy	0.1	0	1	0	0.3	0	0	0
Duties	0.0	0	0	0	0.4	0	0	0
Causation	0.6	0	9	0	7.5	0	8	0
Arguments	0.3	0	5	0	3.7	0	4	0
Theory testing	0.4	0	6	0	7.8	0	8	0
Decision theory	0.2	0	3	0	2.7	0	3	0
Minds and machines	0.4	0	6	0	5.0	0	5	0
Truth	0.6	0	8	0	3.5	0	4	0
Radical translation	0.0	0	0	0	0.2	0	0	0
Explanation	0.3	0	4	0	3.6	0	4	0
Personal identity	0.1	0	1	0	1.4	0	1	0
Speech acts	0.1	0	2	0	2.3	0	2	0
Sense and reference	0.0	0	1	0	0.2	0	0	0
Egalitarianism	0.4	0	5	0	2.3	0	2	0
Quantum physics	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Theories and realism	0.4	0	6	0	4.6	0	5	0
Functions	0.1	0	1	0	1.4	0	1	0
Feminism	0.0	0	0	0	0.2	0	0	0
Medical ethics and Freud	0.0	0	1	0	0.6	0	1	0
Abortion and self-defence	0.0	0	0	0	0.2	0	0	0
Belief ascriptions	0.4	1	5	14	0.8	2	1	2
Thermodynamics	0.1	0	2	0	2.5	0	2	0
Knowledge	0.4	0	6	0	5.8	0	6	0
Game theory	0.1	0	2	0	2.4	0	2	0
Justification	0.1	0	2	0	2.0	0	2	0
Frankfurt cases	0.1	0	1	0	0.9	0	1	0
Concepts	0.2	0	2	0	2.1	0	2	0
Races and DNA	0.1	0	1	0	0.6	0	1	0
Modality	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0
Reasons	0.3	0	4	0	4.7	0	5	0
Evolutionary biology	0.4	1	6	14	5.7	11	6	11
Population ethics	0.0	0	0	0	0.2	0	0	0
Formal epistemology	0.3	0	4	0	0.8	0	1	0
Wide content	0.1	0	1	0	1.5	0	1	0
Vagueness	0.0	0	0	0	0.4	0	0	0
Cognitive science	0.0	0	0	0	0.4	0	0	0
Models	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Composition and constitution	0.1	0	1	0	1.2	0	1	0
Norms	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0

1896

Table B.21: Measures of the prominence of each subject in 1896 ’s journals.

Subject	Weight	Raw	W-Ratio	R-Ratio	W-Pages	R-Pages	WP-Ratio	RP-Ratio
Psychology	5.4	7	83	108	76.1	88	82	94
Idealism	11.1	17	171	262	178.6	272	191	291
Life and value	4.4	2	68	31	67.2	35	72	37
Other history	1.9	2	29	31	17.7	7	19	7
Dewey and pragmatism	0.4	0	6	0	6.9	0	7	0
Definitions	1.2	1	18	15	15.9	14	17	15
Propositions and implications	0.6	1	9	15	6.3	3	7	3
Beauty	0.6	1	9	15	9.6	16	10	17
Physicalism	0.6	0	9	0	7.2	0	8	0
History and culture	0.6	0	9	0	7.8	0	8	0
Faith and theism	1.7	3	26	46	24.4	29	26	31
Self-consciousness	2.1	2	32	31	19.6	9	21	10
Ancient	1.1	2	17	31	20.8	28	22	30
Universals and particulars	0.4	0	6	0	6.1	0	7	0
Verification	0.2	0	3	0	2.8	0	3	0
Value	0.4	0	7	0	5.7	0	6	0
Deduction	0.7	0	11	0	12.3	0	13	0
Mechanisms	0.7	0	11	0	9.1	0	10	0
Temporal paradoxes	0.7	0	11	0	9.9	0	11	0
Classical space and time	3.2	4	49	62	44.8	66	48	71
Early modern	1.8	3	28	46	30.5	60	33	64
Meaning and use	0.7	0	11	0	9.9	0	11	0
Marx	0.6	0	9	0	5.7	0	6	0
Ordinary language	3.7	4	57	62	59.5	66	64	71
Moral conscience	2.9	8	44	123	39.9	117	43	125
Methodology of science	1.6	2	25	31	19.4	22	21	24
Heidegger and Husserl	0.1	0	1	0	0.3	0	0	0
Emotions	1.1	2	18	31	21.4	37	23	40
Ontological argument	0.9	1	13	15	14.0	19	15	20
Chemistry	0.3	0	5	0	4.2	0	5	0
Social contract theory	0.5	0	8	0	8.6	0	9	0
Kant	1.2	1	19	15	17.0	8	18	9
Promises and imperatives	0.9	0	14	0	13.1	0	14	0
Analytic/synthetic	0.7	0	10	0	7.3	0	8	0
Freedom and free will	0.2	0	3	0	2.6	0	3	0
Crime and punishment	0.3	1	5	15	5.2	15	6	16
Sets and grue	0.2	0	4	0	4.7	0	5	0
Origins and purposes	0.5	1	7	15	8.4	23	9	25
Time	0.3	0	5	0	3.9	0	4	0
Color/colour	0.3	0	5	0	3.1	0	3	0
War	0.1	0	2	0	1.5	0	2	0
Depiction	0.3	0	5	0	5.7	0	6	0
Denoting	0.1	0	1	0	1.0	0	1	0
Chance	0.0	0	1	0	0.4	0	0	0
Hume	0.3	0	5	0	2.7	0	3	0
Laws	0.4	0	6	0	5.0	0	5	0
Perception	0.6	0	9	0	5.2	0	6	0
Intention	0.0	0	1	0	0.5	0	1	0
Virtues	0.1	0	1	0	1.2	0	1	0
Space and time	0.0	0	1	0	0.8	0	1	0
Mathematics	0.3	0	4	0	4.6	0	5	0
Liberal democracy	0.2	0	3	0	0.7	0	1	0
Duties	0.2	0	3	0	2.5	0	3	0
Causation	0.4	0	7	0	6.9	0	7	0
Arguments	0.5	0	8	0	9.0	0	10	0
Theory testing	0.2	0	3	0	2.6	0	3	0
Decision theory	0.2	0	3	0	2.2	0	2	0
Minds and machines	0.1	0	2	0	1.4	0	2	0
Truth	0.2	0	2	0	2.5	0	3	0
Radical translation	0.0	0	1	0	0.8	0	1	0
Explanation	0.1	0	2	0	2.2	0	2	0
Personal identity	0.2	0	3	0	2.9	0	3	0
Speech acts	0.1	0	1	0	0.6	0	1	0
Sense and reference	0.1	0	2	0	0.9	0	1	0
Egalitarianism	0.1	0	1	0	0.8	0	1	0
Quantum physics	0.0	0	0	0	0.4	0	0	0
Theories and realism	0.3	0	5	0	4.3	0	5	0
Functions	0.1	0	2	0	1.8	0	2	0
Feminism	0.0	0	1	0	0.7	0	1	0
Medical ethics and Freud	0.1	0	2	0	1.4	0	1	0
Abortion and self-defence	0.0	0	0	0	0.3	0	0	0
Belief ascriptions	0.0	0	1	0	0.2	0	0	0
Thermodynamics	0.2	0	2	0	2.3	0	2	0
Knowledge	0.6	0	9	0	6.7	0	7	0
Game theory	0.1	0	2	0	1.1	0	1	0
Justification	0.2	0	4	0	3.8	0	4	0
Frankfurt cases	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0
Concepts	0.3	0	5	0	5.1	0	6	0
Races and DNA	0.2	0	3	0	2.3	0	2	0
Modality	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0
Reasons	0.1	0	2	0	1.9	0	2	0
Evolutionary biology	0.2	0	3	0	3.4	0	4	0
Population ethics	0.1	0	1	0	0.8	0	1	0
Formal epistemology	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0
Wide content	0.1	0	2	0	0.9	0	1	0
Vagueness	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0
Cognitive science	0.0	0	0	0	0.2	0	0	0
Models	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0
Composition and constitution	0.4	0	6	0	3.5	0	4	0
Norms	0.0	0	1	0	0.2	0	0	0

1897

Table B.22: Measures of the prominence of each subject in 1897 ’s journals.

Subject	Weight	Raw	W-Ratio	R-Ratio	W-Pages	R-Pages	WP-Ratio	RP-Ratio
Psychology	6.8	9	119	158	92.3	120	114	149
Idealism	11.0	19	192	333	169.5	317	210	393
Life and value	4.5	6	79	105	66.0	113	82	140
Other history	1.5	1	26	18	10.8	2	13	2
Dewey and pragmatism	0.9	0	15	0	14.1	0	18	0
Definitions	0.5	0	8	0	8.3	0	10	0
Propositions and implications	1.0	2	17	35	11.4	23	14	29
Beauty	0.7	1	12	18	6.9	15	9	19
Physicalism	0.9	1	16	18	8.5	6	10	7
History and culture	0.2	0	3	0	3.6	0	4	0
Faith and theism	0.7	0	13	0	9.2	0	11	0
Self-consciousness	2.4	1	42	18	36.1	17	45	21
Ancient	1.3	1	22	18	22.0	6	27	7
Universals and particulars	1.2	1	22	18	22.7	17	28	21
Verification	0.3	0	6	0	5.0	0	6	0
Value	1.2	1	21	18	12.6	10	16	12
Deduction	0.8	1	14	18	11.0	17	14	21
Mechanisms	0.2	0	3	0	1.9	0	2	0
Temporal paradoxes	0.9	0	15	0	15.4	0	19	0
Classical space and time	0.4	0	7	0	5.6	0	7	0
Early modern	0.6	1	11	18	7.9	14	10	17
Meaning and use	0.4	0	6	0	3.4	0	4	0
Marx	0.6	0	10	0	6.2	0	8	0
Ordinary language	2.1	1	36	18	38.7	12	48	15
Moral conscience	2.5	7	43	123	21.7	60	27	74
Methodology of science	0.9	0	15	0	10.2	0	13	0
Heidegger and Husserl	0.1	0	2	0	2.1	0	3	0
Emotions	2.1	2	37	35	37.3	35	46	43
Ontological argument	0.9	1	15	18	9.0	4	11	5
Chemistry	0.5	0	8	0	6.2	0	8	0
Social contract theory	0.2	0	4	0	3.3	0	4	0
Kant	0.4	0	7	0	6.2	0	8	0
Promises and imperatives	0.8	0	14	0	16.3	0	20	0
Analytic/synthetic	0.2	0	3	0	2.2	0	3	0
Freedom and free will	0.2	0	4	0	2.7	0	3	0
Crime and punishment	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0
Sets and grue	0.1	0	2	0	2.2	0	3	0
Origins and purposes	0.2	0	3	0	2.6	0	3	0
Time	0.3	0	5	0	4.5	0	6	0
Color/colour	0.2	0	3	0	3.1	0	4	0
War	0.0	0	1	0	0.4	0	1	0
Depiction	0.2	0	4	0	1.8	0	2	0
Denoting	0.0	0	1	0	0.5	0	1	0
Chance	0.1	0	2	0	1.5	0	2	0
Hume	0.4	1	7	18	6.9	19	9	24
Laws	0.3	0	5	0	3.9	0	5	0
Perception	0.5	0	9	0	6.3	0	8	0
Intention	0.2	0	3	0	0.9	0	1	0
Virtues	0.2	0	3	0	2.8	0	3	0
Space and time	0.0	0	0	0	0.2	0	0	0
Mathematics	0.2	0	3	0	2.7	0	3	0
Liberal democracy	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0
Duties	0.0	0	1	0	0.5	0	1	0
Causation	0.2	0	4	0	4.3	0	5	0
Arguments	0.2	0	4	0	3.1	0	4	0
Theory testing	0.1	0	2	0	2.3	0	3	0
Decision theory	0.2	0	4	0	3.6	0	4	0
Minds and machines	0.3	0	5	0	3.1	0	4	0
Truth	0.1	0	2	0	1.3	0	2	0
Radical translation	0.0	0	0	0	0.2	0	0	0
Explanation	0.1	0	2	0	1.3	0	2	0
Personal identity	0.2	0	3	0	2.6	0	3	0
Speech acts	0.1	0	1	0	0.4	0	0	0
Sense and reference	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Egalitarianism	0.0	0	1	0	0.7	0	1	0
Quantum physics	0.1	0	3	0	0.8	0	1	0
Theories and realism	0.4	0	6	0	2.6	0	3	0
Functions	0.1	0	2	0	1.8	0	2	0
Feminism	0.2	0	3	0	2.7	0	3	0
Medical ethics and Freud	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0
Abortion and self-defence	0.1	0	3	0	0.9	0	1	0
Belief ascriptions	0.0	0	1	0	0.2	0	0	0
Thermodynamics	0.2	0	3	0	3.6	0	4	0
Knowledge	0.3	0	4	0	2.9	0	4	0
Game theory	0.0	0	1	0	0.5	0	1	0
Justification	0.0	0	0	0	0.5	0	1	0
Frankfurt cases	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Concepts	0.3	0	6	0	5.6	0	7	0
Races and DNA	0.1	0	1	0	1.2	0	1	0
Modality	0.0	0	0	0	0.2	0	0	0
Reasons	0.2	0	4	0	4.2	0	5	0
Evolutionary biology	0.1	0	1	0	1.3	0	2	0
Population ethics	0.0	0	1	0	0.4	0	1	0
Formal epistemology	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Wide content	0.2	0	3	0	2.5	0	3	0
Vagueness	0.2	0	3	0	0.7	0	1	0
Cognitive science	0.1	0	1	0	0.4	0	1	0
Models	0.1	0	1	0	1.0	0	1	0
Composition and constitution	0.1	0	2	0	1.6	0	2	0
Norms	0.1	0	1	0	0.8	0	1	0

1898

Table B.23: Measures of the prominence of each subject in 1898 ’s journals.

Subject	Weight	Raw	W-Ratio	R-Ratio	W-Pages	R-Pages	WP-Ratio	RP-Ratio
Psychology	6.7	10	127	189	100.3	152	123	186
Idealism	11.9	21	224	396	195.8	343	240	420
Life and value	2.4	3	46	57	39.7	34	49	42
Other history	2.0	3	37	57	33.5	37	41	45
Dewey and pragmatism	0.9	0	16	0	14.2	0	17	0
Definitions	0.8	0	16	0	9.4	0	11	0
Propositions and implications	0.5	0	10	0	10.1	0	12	0
Beauty	0.1	0	2	0	1.5	0	2	0
Physicalism	0.7	1	13	19	8.1	8	10	10
History and culture	0.5	0	10	0	7.0	0	9	0
Faith and theism	0.3	0	6	0	4.3	0	5	0
Self-consciousness	1.3	0	25	0	16.2	0	20	0
Ancient	0.7	0	14	0	16.6	0	20	0
Universals and particulars	0.3	0	7	0	5.9	0	7	0
Verification	0.2	0	3	0	2.3	0	3	0
Value	0.5	0	9	0	5.4	0	7	0
Deduction	1.1	1	20	19	16.7	14	20	17
Mechanisms	1.0	1	18	19	9.1	2	11	2
Temporal paradoxes	0.5	0	9	0	6.9	0	8	0
Classical space and time	0.6	0	10	0	5.4	0	7	0
Early modern	0.9	2	17	38	18.9	46	23	56
Meaning and use	0.3	0	5	0	2.5	0	3	0
Marx	0.7	1	14	19	6.9	8	8	10
Ordinary language	2.1	1	39	19	39.1	21	48	26
Moral conscience	0.7	1	13	19	11.5	22	14	27
Methodology of science	1.3	0	25	0	23.1	0	28	0
Heidegger and Husserl	0.0	0	0	0	0.4	0	0	0
Emotions	1.9	1	35	19	15.8	5	19	6
Ontological argument	0.4	0	7	0	6.7	0	8	0
Chemistry	0.4	0	8	0	4.4	0	5	0
Social contract theory	0.5	0	9	0	7.4	0	9	0
Kant	1.9	3	36	57	38.1	64	47	78
Promises and imperatives	0.3	0	6	0	4.1	0	5	0
Analytic/synthetic	0.2	0	4	0	4.2	0	5	0
Freedom and free will	0.3	0	5	0	5.5	0	7	0
Crime and punishment	1.1	3	20	57	13.5	42	17	51
Sets and grue	0.1	0	1	0	1.3	0	2	0
Origins and purposes	0.4	0	7	0	6.0	0	7	0
Time	0.1	0	2	0	1.8	0	2	0
Color/colour	0.1	0	2	0	1.6	0	2	0
War	0.1	0	1	0	1.6	0	2	0
Depiction	0.1	0	2	0	1.0	0	1	0
Denoting	0.2	0	3	0	1.0	0	1	0
Chance	0.0	0	1	0	0.4	0	0	0
Hume	0.6	1	11	19	12.8	19	16	23
Laws	0.2	0	3	0	3.1	0	4	0
Perception	0.3	0	6	0	6.7	0	8	0
Intention	0.0	0	0	0	0.2	0	0	0
Virtues	0.2	0	4	0	3.5	0	4	0
Space and time	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0
Mathematics	0.2	0	5	0	3.8	0	5	0
Liberal democracy	0.0	0	1	0	0.4	0	0	0
Duties	0.2	0	5	0	1.5	0	2	0
Causation	0.3	0	5	0	6.3	0	8	0
Arguments	0.3	0	5	0	3.3	0	4	0
Theory testing	0.1	0	2	0	1.9	0	2	0
Decision theory	0.0	0	1	0	0.8	0	1	0
Minds and machines	0.3	0	6	0	2.9	0	4	0
Truth	0.3	0	5	0	3.4	0	4	0
Radical translation	0.1	0	2	0	0.4	0	1	0
Explanation	0.0	0	1	0	0.9	0	1	0
Personal identity	0.2	0	4	0	2.7	0	3	0
Speech acts	0.0	0	1	0	0.8	0	1	0
Sense and reference	0.0	0	0	0	0.3	0	0	0
Egalitarianism	0.0	0	0	0	0.4	0	0	0
Quantum physics	0.0	0	1	0	0.3	0	0	0
Theories and realism	0.2	0	4	0	2.7	0	3	0
Functions	0.3	0	6	0	4.5	0	6	0
Feminism	0.1	0	2	0	1.2	0	1	0
Medical ethics and Freud	0.0	0	1	0	0.5	0	1	0
Abortion and self-defence	0.2	0	4	0	3.1	0	4	0
Belief ascriptions	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Thermodynamics	0.2	0	3	0	3.3	0	4	0
Knowledge	0.5	0	9	0	5.0	0	6	0
Game theory	0.0	0	0	0	0.3	0	0	0
Justification	0.1	0	2	0	2.2	0	3	0
Frankfurt cases	0.0	0	0	0	0.2	0	0	0
Concepts	0.1	0	3	0	2.3	0	3	0
Races and DNA	0.1	0	1	0	0.8	0	1	0
Modality	0.1	0	1	0	1.1	0	1	0
Reasons	0.1	0	1	0	1.0	0	1	0
Evolutionary biology	0.1	0	3	0	1.5	0	2	0
Population ethics	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Formal epistemology	0.0	0	1	0	0.5	0	1	0
Wide content	0.2	0	4	0	2.4	0	3	0
Vagueness	0.0	0	0	0	0.3	0	0	0
Cognitive science	0.1	0	2	0	1.8	0	2	0
Models	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0
Composition and constitution	0.1	0	1	0	0.6	0	1	0
Norms	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0

1899

Table B.24: Measures of the prominence of each subject in 1899 ’s journals.

Subject	Weight	Raw	W-Ratio	R-Ratio	W-Pages	R-Pages	WP-Ratio	RP-Ratio
Psychology	3.7	6	90	146	66.5	103	89	137
Idealism	8.8	12	215	293	151.0	200	201	267
Life and value	3.0	4	73	98	53.0	57	71	76
Other history	2.4	4	59	98	46.3	68	62	91
Dewey and pragmatism	0.4	0	9	0	8.1	0	11	0
Definitions	0.3	0	7	0	5.0	0	7	0
Propositions and implications	0.4	0	9	0	7.0	0	9	0
Beauty	0.6	1	16	24	14.8	28	20	37
Physicalism	0.4	0	9	0	4.6	0	6	0
History and culture	0.3	0	8	0	6.7	0	9	0
Faith and theism	0.4	0	9	0	5.0	0	7	0
Self-consciousness	1.3	0	33	0	19.8	0	26	0
Ancient	0.3	0	6	0	4.3	0	6	0
Universals and particulars	0.3	0	8	0	7.5	0	10	0
Verification	0.2	0	5	0	4.2	0	6	0
Value	0.4	0	10	0	9.9	0	13	0
Deduction	0.7	1	17	24	11.8	15	16	20
Mechanisms	0.4	1	9	24	4.1	10	5	13
Temporal paradoxes	0.8	0	20	0	14.7	0	20	0
Classical space and time	0.9	0	21	0	15.0	0	20	0
Early modern	0.7	1	18	24	16.2	24	22	32
Meaning and use	0.5	1	11	24	15.5	44	21	59
Marx	0.4	0	9	0	7.2	0	10	0
Ordinary language	1.6	1	40	24	36.4	21	49	28
Moral conscience	0.8	1	20	24	13.4	18	18	24
Methodology of science	1.0	1	23	24	18.8	19	25	25
Heidegger and Husserl	0.1	0	4	0	2.6	0	4	0
Emotions	0.4	1	10	24	10.0	26	13	35
Ontological argument	0.2	0	4	0	2.8	0	4	0
Chemistry	0.4	1	10	24	9.0	20	12	27
Social contract theory	0.5	0	12	0	9.1	0	12	0
Kant	2.2	4	53	98	41.0	79	55	105
Promises and imperatives	0.2	0	5	0	2.9	0	4	0
Analytic/synthetic	0.4	0	9	0	7.0	0	9	0
Freedom and free will	0.2	0	5	0	3.7	0	5	0
Crime and punishment	0.0	0	0	0	0.5	0	1	0
Sets and grue	0.0	0	0	0	0.2	0	0	0
Origins and purposes	0.1	0	1	0	0.9	0	1	0
Time	0.5	0	12	0	7.7	0	10	0
Color/colour	0.3	0	8	0	3.5	0	5	0
War	0.0	0	0	0	0.4	0	1	0
Depiction	0.1	0	3	0	1.6	0	2	0
Denoting	0.1	0	2	0	2.2	0	3	0
Chance	0.0	0	1	0	0.5	0	1	0
Hume	0.2	0	5	0	3.9	0	5	0
Laws	0.1	0	3	0	2.7	0	4	0
Perception	0.7	0	18	0	12.8	0	17	0
Intention	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0
Virtues	0.0	0	1	0	0.6	0	1	0
Space and time	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0
Mathematics	0.5	1	11	24	9.0	18	12	24
Liberal democracy	0.1	0	1	0	1.2	0	2	0
Duties	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0
Causation	0.2	0	6	0	4.5	0	6	0
Arguments	0.2	0	6	0	4.1	0	5	0
Theory testing	0.2	0	5	0	3.1	0	4	0
Decision theory	0.0	0	0	0	0.3	0	0	0
Minds and machines	0.0	0	1	0	0.7	0	1	0
Truth	0.1	0	2	0	1.3	0	2	0
Radical translation	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Explanation	0.1	0	2	0	1.3	0	2	0
Personal identity	0.1	0	3	0	2.0	0	3	0
Speech acts	0.0	0	1	0	1.1	0	1	0
Sense and reference	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Egalitarianism	0.0	0	1	0	0.6	0	1	0
Quantum physics	0.0	0	0	0	0.3	0	0	0
Theories and realism	0.2	0	5	0	2.5	0	3	0
Functions	0.2	0	4	0	2.4	0	3	0
Feminism	0.0	0	1	0	1.0	0	1	0
Medical ethics and Freud	0.1	0	1	0	1.2	0	2	0
Abortion and self-defence	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Belief ascriptions	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0
Thermodynamics	0.2	0	4	0	3.5	0	5	0
Knowledge	0.1	0	3	0	2.6	0	3	0
Game theory	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Justification	0.0	0	1	0	0.8	0	1	0
Frankfurt cases	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0
Concepts	0.3	0	8	0	7.5	0	10	0
Races and DNA	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Modality	0.0	0	0	0	0.2	0	0	0
Reasons	0.1	0	3	0	2.0	0	3	0
Evolutionary biology	0.0	0	1	0	0.9	0	1	0
Population ethics	0.0	0	0	0	0.3	0	0	0
Formal epistemology	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Wide content	0.1	0	1	0	0.8	0	1	0
Vagueness	0.0	0	1	0	0.4	0	1	0
Cognitive science	0.0	0	1	0	0.7	0	1	0
Models	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Composition and constitution	0.0	0	0	0	0.3	0	0	0
Norms	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0

1900

Table B.25: Measures of the prominence of each subject in 1900 ’s journals.

Subject	Weight	Raw	W-Ratio	R-Ratio	W-Pages	R-Pages	WP-Ratio	RP-Ratio
Psychology	4.9	7	98	140	69.0	98	91	129
Idealism	9.1	15	182	300	170.6	296	224	389
Life and value	4.1	4	82	80	66.9	52	88	68
Other history	2.4	5	49	100	36.7	79	48	104
Dewey and pragmatism	0.7	0	14	0	11.4	0	15	0
Definitions	0.6	0	11	0	6.5	0	9	0
Propositions and implications	0.8	1	16	20	9.2	10	12	13
Beauty	0.7	1	13	20	7.9	11	10	14
Physicalism	1.0	0	20	0	10.1	0	13	0
History and culture	0.2	0	4	0	2.4	0	3	0
Faith and theism	0.3	0	6	0	5.7	0	7	0
Self-consciousness	1.7	1	34	20	25.3	12	33	16
Ancient	0.4	1	8	20	6.3	16	8	21
Universals and particulars	0.5	0	9	0	9.5	0	12	0
Verification	1.0	1	20	20	6.7	1	9	1
Value	0.2	0	4	0	3.8	0	5	0
Deduction	1.0	2	20	40	12.3	18	16	24
Mechanisms	0.2	0	5	0	3.4	0	4	0
Temporal paradoxes	1.1	0	22	0	11.4	0	15	0
Classical space and time	0.7	1	14	20	6.0	5	8	7
Early modern	1.1	1	23	20	20.8	16	27	21
Meaning and use	0.4	0	8	0	5.4	0	7	0
Marx	0.4	0	7	0	8.0	0	10	0
Ordinary language	2.3	3	46	60	43.7	58	57	76
Moral conscience	1.7	2	35	40	28.6	37	38	49
Methodology of science	1.2	0	24	0	21.4	0	28	0
Heidegger and Husserl	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Emotions	0.8	1	16	20	12.6	12	17	16
Ontological argument	0.8	1	17	20	7.7	5	10	7
Chemistry	1.2	1	24	20	17.5	13	23	17
Social contract theory	0.3	0	5	0	4.5	0	6	0
Kant	0.6	0	12	0	10.6	0	14	0
Promises and imperatives	0.5	0	11	0	7.8	0	10	0
Analytic/synthetic	0.2	0	4	0	3.1	0	4	0
Freedom and free will	0.2	0	3	0	3.1	0	4	0
Crime and punishment	0.1	0	2	0	2.3	0	3	0
Sets and grue	0.1	0	1	0	0.5	0	1	0
Origins and purposes	0.1	0	2	0	1.6	0	2	0
Time	0.4	0	7	0	3.7	0	5	0
Color/colour	0.1	0	3	0	1.9	0	2	0
War	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0
Depiction	0.4	0	7	0	3.3	0	4	0
Denoting	0.0	0	1	0	0.2	0	0	0
Chance	0.9	1	19	20	3.3	1	4	1
Hume	0.1	0	1	0	0.8	0	1	0
Laws	0.3	0	5	0	4.9	0	6	0
Perception	0.4	0	9	0	4.4	0	6	0
Intention	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Virtues	0.3	0	6	0	5.0	0	7	0
Space and time	0.3	0	6	0	2.1	0	3	0
Mathematics	0.3	0	5	0	2.3	0	3	0
Liberal democracy	0.1	0	2	0	1.9	0	2	0
Duties	0.3	1	6	20	6.1	21	8	28
Causation	0.2	0	5	0	3.9	0	5	0
Arguments	0.2	0	3	0	3.0	0	4	0
Theory testing	0.1	0	1	0	1.2	0	2	0
Decision theory	0.1	0	1	0	1.0	0	1	0
Minds and machines	0.2	0	3	0	2.8	0	4	0
Truth	0.2	0	3	0	2.8	0	4	0
Radical translation	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Explanation	0.1	0	2	0	1.9	0	2	0
Personal identity	0.2	0	3	0	2.1	0	3	0
Speech acts	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Sense and reference	0.1	0	1	0	0.7	0	1	0
Egalitarianism	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0
Quantum physics	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Theories and realism	0.3	0	5	0	4.3	0	6	0
Functions	0.1	0	2	0	1.6	0	2	0
Feminism	0.1	0	2	0	1.7	0	2	0
Medical ethics and Freud	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Abortion and self-defence	0.0	0	0	0	0.3	0	0	0
Belief ascriptions	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Thermodynamics	0.1	0	3	0	1.7	0	2	0
Knowledge	0.1	0	2	0	1.2	0	2	0
Game theory	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0
Justification	0.1	0	2	0	1.4	0	2	0
Frankfurt cases	0.0	0	1	0	0.5	0	1	0
Concepts	0.2	0	3	0	2.8	0	4	0
Races and DNA	0.0	0	0	0	0.2	0	0	0
Modality	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0
Reasons	0.0	0	1	0	0.7	0	1	0
Evolutionary biology	0.1	0	2	0	2.1	0	3	0
Population ethics	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Formal epistemology	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Wide content	0.1	0	1	0	0.7	0	1	0
Vagueness	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Cognitive science	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Models	0.0	0	0	0	0.2	0	0	0
Composition and constitution	0.0	0	1	0	0.6	0	1	0
Norms	0.1	0	1	0	1.2	0	2	0

1901

Table B.26: Measures of the prominence of each subject in 1901 ’s journals.

Subject	Weight	Raw	W-Ratio	R-Ratio	W-Pages	R-Pages	WP-Ratio	RP-Ratio
Psychology	6.1	8	103	136	148.9	232	153	238
Idealism	12.3	22	208	373	190.2	330	195	339
Life and value	4.8	6	81	102	71.2	76	73	78
Other history	2.2	2	38	34	41.2	48	42	49
Dewey and pragmatism	0.4	0	7	0	4.5	0	5	0
Definitions	0.4	0	7	0	7.1	0	7	0
Propositions and implications	0.2	0	3	0	4.3	0	4	0
Beauty	1.9	4	33	68	26.1	59	27	61
Physicalism	0.9	1	14	17	11.9	10	12	10
History and culture	0.1	0	2	0	2.0	0	2	0
Faith and theism	0.7	1	12	17	8.2	11	8	11
Self-consciousness	3.2	1	55	17	41.6	2	43	2
Ancient	1.2	2	21	34	19.9	32	20	33
Universals and particulars	0.7	0	11	0	12.5	0	13	0
Verification	0.1	0	2	0	2.2	0	2	0
Value	0.4	0	7	0	6.5	0	7	0
Deduction	0.1	0	1	0	1.1	0	1	0
Mechanisms	0.1	0	2	0	2.3	0	2	0
Temporal paradoxes	2.1	2	35	34	34.7	29	36	30
Classical space and time	1.8	2	31	34	33.6	47	35	48
Early modern	0.5	0	8	0	8.9	0	9	0
Meaning and use	0.4	1	6	17	7.0	22	7	23
Marx	0.3	0	6	0	7.7	0	8	0
Ordinary language	2.7	1	45	17	45.7	18	47	18
Moral conscience	1.8	2	31	34	26.6	26	27	27
Methodology of science	1.5	1	25	17	20.3	8	21	8
Heidegger and Husserl	0.0	0	1	0	0.5	0	0	0
Emotions	1.1	1	18	17	8.5	2	9	2
Ontological argument	0.6	0	10	0	9.4	0	10	0
Chemistry	1.1	1	19	17	15.4	15	16	15
Social contract theory	0.1	0	2	0	2.0	0	2	0
Kant	1.1	0	18	0	14.0	0	14	0
Promises and imperatives	0.2	0	4	0	3.0	0	3	0
Analytic/synthetic	0.0	0	1	0	0.5	0	0	0
Freedom and free will	0.1	0	2	0	1.6	0	2	0
Crime and punishment	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Sets and grue	0.2	0	4	0	5.2	0	5	0
Origins and purposes	0.3	0	5	0	2.5	0	3	0
Time	0.4	0	7	0	4.7	0	5	0
Color/colour	1.0	0	18	0	33.7	0	35	0
War	0.0	0	0	0	0.2	0	0	0
Depiction	0.2	0	3	0	4.3	0	4	0
Denoting	0.0	0	1	0	0.9	0	1	0
Chance	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0
Hume	0.0	0	0	0	0.2	0	0	0
Laws	0.3	0	4	0	4.0	0	4	0
Perception	0.4	0	6	0	4.6	0	5	0
Intention	0.0	0	0	0	0.2	0	0	0
Virtues	0.1	0	1	0	0.8	0	1	0
Space and time	0.1	0	2	0	0.3	0	0	0
Mathematics	0.4	0	6	0	4.2	0	4	0
Liberal democracy	0.2	0	3	0	0.9	0	1	0
Duties	0.1	0	1	0	1.5	0	1	0
Causation	0.5	0	9	0	8.0	0	8	0
Arguments	0.2	0	3	0	2.9	0	3	0
Theory testing	0.1	0	1	0	1.3	0	1	0
Decision theory	0.0	0	0	0	0.4	0	0	0
Minds and machines	0.2	0	3	0	3.6	0	4	0
Truth	0.2	0	4	0	2.8	0	3	0
Radical translation	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Explanation	0.1	0	1	0	1.6	0	2	0
Personal identity	0.6	1	10	17	5.8	7	6	7
Speech acts	0.0	0	1	0	0.7	0	1	0
Sense and reference	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0
Egalitarianism	0.1	0	2	0	1.0	0	1	0
Quantum physics	0.0	0	0	0	0.5	0	1	0
Theories and realism	0.2	0	4	0	4.6	0	5	0
Functions	0.1	0	1	0	1.4	0	1	0
Feminism	0.0	0	1	0	0.7	0	1	0
Medical ethics and Freud	0.0	0	0	0	0.4	0	0	0
Abortion and self-defence	0.0	0	0	0	0.3	0	0	0
Belief ascriptions	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Thermodynamics	0.2	0	4	0	6.0	0	6	0
Knowledge	0.3	0	5	0	4.6	0	5	0
Game theory	0.1	0	2	0	4.1	0	4	0
Justification	0.1	0	2	0	1.8	0	2	0
Frankfurt cases	0.0	0	0	0	0.2	0	0	0
Concepts	0.2	0	3	0	2.5	0	3	0
Races and DNA	0.0	0	1	0	0.9	0	1	0
Modality	0.0	0	0	0	0.2	0	0	0
Reasons	0.1	0	2	0	1.5	0	2	0
Evolutionary biology	0.2	0	4	0	3.2	0	3	0
Population ethics	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Formal epistemology	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Wide content	0.1	0	2	0	1.8	0	2	0
Vagueness	0.1	0	1	0	0.5	0	1	0
Cognitive science	0.0	0	0	0	0.3	0	0	0
Models	0.0	0	0	0	0.2	0	0	0
Composition and constitution	0.0	0	1	0	0.6	0	1	0
Norms	0.0	0	0	0	0.2	0	0	0

1902

Table B.27: Measures of the prominence of each subject in 1902 ’s journals.

Subject	Weight	Raw	W-Ratio	R-Ratio	W-Pages	R-Pages	WP-Ratio	RP-Ratio
Psychology	3.9	5	81	104	100.0	129	108	139
Idealism	10.6	22	221	458	223.9	459	241	494
Life and value	3.4	2	72	42	63.6	31	68	33
Other history	1.8	3	37	62	29.6	47	32	51
Dewey and pragmatism	1.0	0	20	0	17.2	0	19	0
Definitions	1.1	1	23	21	20.2	39	22	42
Propositions and implications	0.6	2	13	42	10.0	29	11	31
Beauty	0.3	0	7	0	5.4	0	6	0
Physicalism	0.4	0	9	0	6.3	0	7	0
History and culture	0.6	0	12	0	9.2	0	10	0
Faith and theism	1.0	1	21	21	12.5	11	13	12
Self-consciousness	1.1	0	24	0	22.8	0	25	0
Ancient	0.6	1	14	21	11.4	23	12	25
Universals and particulars	0.6	0	13	0	10.9	0	12	0
Verification	0.3	0	5	0	5.1	0	5	0
Value	1.2	2	24	42	18.9	32	20	34
Deduction	0.4	0	8	0	9.7	0	10	0
Mechanisms	0.3	0	7	0	7.3	0	8	0
Temporal paradoxes	1.4	1	29	21	23.4	12	25	13
Classical space and time	0.9	1	18	21	12.1	8	13	9
Early modern	0.9	2	19	42	13.1	25	14	27
Meaning and use	0.1	0	3	0	3.2	0	3	0
Marx	0.5	0	11	0	7.4	0	8	0
Ordinary language	2.8	1	59	21	64.4	20	69	22
Moral conscience	1.8	2	38	42	22.9	10	25	11
Methodology of science	1.4	0	29	0	23.1	0	25	0
Heidegger and Husserl	0.0	0	0	0	0.2	0	0	0
Emotions	0.2	0	4	0	3.6	0	4	0
Ontological argument	0.5	0	10	0	10.6	0	11	0
Chemistry	0.3	0	7	0	5.5	0	6	0
Social contract theory	0.1	0	2	0	1.6	0	2	0
Kant	0.9	2	19	42	18.5	54	20	58
Promises and imperatives	0.4	0	8	0	9.4	0	10	0
Analytic/synthetic	0.3	0	7	0	3.4	0	4	0
Freedom and free will	0.2	0	3	0	4.0	0	4	0
Crime and punishment	0.0	0	1	0	0.4	0	0	0
Sets and grue	0.2	0	3	0	3.1	0	3	0
Origins and purposes	0.2	0	3	0	2.8	0	3	0
Time	0.3	0	7	0	9.1	0	10	0
Color/colour	0.2	0	5	0	5.1	0	6	0
War	0.0	0	0	0	0.4	0	0	0
Depiction	0.1	0	1	0	1.1	0	1	0
Denoting	0.1	0	2	0	1.4	0	1	0
Chance	0.1	0	2	0	3.7	0	4	0
Hume	0.0	0	0	0	0.3	0	0	0
Laws	0.1	0	3	0	4.0	0	4	0
Perception	0.3	0	7	0	5.9	0	6	0
Intention	0.1	0	1	0	1.9	0	2	0
Virtues	0.0	0	0	0	0.5	0	1	0
Space and time	0.0	0	1	0	0.7	0	1	0
Mathematics	0.3	0	7	0	7.1	0	8	0
Liberal democracy	0.0	0	1	0	0.8	0	1	0
Duties	0.1	0	3	0	3.1	0	3	0
Causation	0.2	0	4	0	3.9	0	4	0
Arguments	0.3	0	7	0	6.6	0	7	0
Theory testing	0.1	0	1	0	1.6	0	2	0
Decision theory	0.2	0	4	0	3.2	0	3	0
Minds and machines	0.2	0	3	0	2.4	0	3	0
Truth	0.2	0	3	0	3.1	0	3	0
Radical translation	0.0	0	0	0	0.5	0	1	0
Explanation	0.0	0	0	0	0.4	0	0	0
Personal identity	0.3	0	5	0	5.4	0	6	0
Speech acts	0.0	0	0	0	0.3	0	0	0
Sense and reference	0.0	0	1	0	0.4	0	0	0
Egalitarianism	0.1	0	1	0	1.0	0	1	0
Quantum physics	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Theories and realism	0.2	0	4	0	2.3	0	3	0
Functions	0.1	0	2	0	1.8	0	2	0
Feminism	0.0	0	0	0	0.3	0	0	0
Medical ethics and Freud	0.0	0	0	0	0.3	0	0	0
Abortion and self-defence	0.0	0	1	0	0.5	0	1	0
Belief ascriptions	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Thermodynamics	0.2	0	4	0	4.8	0	5	0
Knowledge	0.2	0	4	0	3.4	0	4	0
Game theory	0.1	0	1	0	0.9	0	1	0
Justification	0.1	0	1	0	1.3	0	1	0
Frankfurt cases	0.0	0	0	0	0.3	0	0	0
Concepts	0.2	0	4	0	3.1	0	3	0
Races and DNA	0.0	0	1	0	0.5	0	1	0
Modality	0.0	0	1	0	0.6	0	1	0
Reasons	0.4	0	8	0	6.5	0	7	0
Evolutionary biology	0.2	0	4	0	3.3	0	4	0
Population ethics	0.0	0	0	0	0.7	0	1	0
Formal epistemology	0.0	0	1	0	0.6	0	1	0
Wide content	0.1	0	3	0	2.3	0	2	0
Vagueness	0.2	0	4	0	2.4	0	3	0
Cognitive science	0.0	0	0	0	0.2	0	0	0
Models	0.0	0	1	0	1.0	0	1	0
Composition and constitution	0.0	0	0	0	0.2	0	0	0
Norms	0.1	0	1	0	1.0	0	1	0

1903

Table B.28: Measures of the prominence of each subject in 1903 ’s journals.

Subject	Weight	Raw	W-Ratio	R-Ratio	W-Pages	R-Pages	WP-Ratio	RP-Ratio
Psychology	4.0	3	76	58	75.3	42	83	46
Idealism	14.7	29	283	558	272.2	565	300	623
Life and value	2.9	1	55	19	46.0	12	51	13
Other history	0.8	0	16	0	13.5	0	15	0
Dewey and pragmatism	1.0	0	19	0	18.9	0	21	0
Definitions	1.0	0	20	0	15.3	0	17	0
Propositions and implications	0.9	2	18	38	12.6	23	14	25
Beauty	1.0	2	20	38	16.4	33	18	36
Physicalism	0.6	0	11	0	8.4	0	9	0
History and culture	0.1	0	2	0	1.9	0	2	0
Faith and theism	0.6	1	11	19	6.6	8	7	9
Self-consciousness	2.0	1	38	19	36.3	10	40	11
Ancient	1.5	2	29	38	14.4	10	16	11
Universals and particulars	0.5	0	10	0	10.4	0	12	0
Verification	0.5	0	9	0	7.5	0	8	0
Value	0.4	0	7	0	7.0	0	8	0
Deduction	0.9	1	17	19	14.8	11	16	12
Mechanisms	0.5	0	10	0	10.5	0	12	0
Temporal paradoxes	0.4	0	8	0	7.5	0	8	0
Classical space and time	1.0	0	19	0	17.5	0	19	0
Early modern	0.9	2	17	38	14.4	43	16	47
Meaning and use	0.3	0	5	0	4.2	0	5	0
Marx	0.2	0	4	0	3.3	0	4	0
Ordinary language	2.2	1	42	19	42.0	23	46	25
Moral conscience	0.8	1	16	19	15.1	25	17	28
Methodology of science	1.7	2	33	38	27.8	35	31	39
Heidegger and Husserl	0.0	0	1	0	0.7	0	1	0
Emotions	0.6	0	12	0	14.7	0	16	0
Ontological argument	0.7	0	14	0	10.3	0	11	0
Chemistry	0.3	0	5	0	4.7	0	5	0
Social contract theory	0.1	0	1	0	1.4	0	2	0
Kant	0.9	1	18	19	19.9	19	22	21
Promises and imperatives	0.4	0	8	0	7.7	0	8	0
Analytic/synthetic	0.2	0	4	0	4.0	0	4	0
Freedom and free will	0.1	0	3	0	3.4	0	4	0
Crime and punishment	0.0	0	0	0	0.3	0	0	0
Sets and grue	0.3	0	5	0	3.2	0	4	0
Origins and purposes	0.1	0	3	0	2.0	0	2	0
Time	0.1	0	2	0	1.1	0	1	0
Color/colour	0.3	0	6	0	5.3	0	6	0
War	0.0	0	0	0	0.4	0	0	0
Depiction	0.0	0	1	0	0.6	0	1	0
Denoting	0.0	0	1	0	0.5	0	1	0
Chance	0.0	0	0	0	0.4	0	0	0
Hume	0.5	1	10	19	12.6	27	14	30
Laws	0.3	0	5	0	4.8	0	5	0
Perception	0.8	1	16	19	15.9	16	18	18
Intention	0.4	0	7	0	3.3	0	4	0
Virtues	0.0	0	1	0	0.9	0	1	0
Space and time	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0
Mathematics	0.3	0	5	0	6.0	0	7	0
Liberal democracy	0.0	0	1	0	0.4	0	0	0
Duties	0.1	0	1	0	1.4	0	1	0
Causation	0.3	0	5	0	4.4	0	5	0
Arguments	0.5	0	9	0	7.4	0	8	0
Theory testing	0.3	0	6	0	3.2	0	4	0
Decision theory	0.1	0	2	0	1.4	0	2	0
Minds and machines	0.1	0	2	0	2.6	0	3	0
Truth	0.3	0	5	0	3.2	0	4	0
Radical translation	0.0	0	1	0	0.8	0	1	0
Explanation	0.1	0	2	0	1.8	0	2	0
Personal identity	0.1	0	1	0	1.2	0	1	0
Speech acts	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Sense and reference	0.0	0	1	0	0.6	0	1	0
Egalitarianism	0.0	0	0	0	0.4	0	0	0
Quantum physics	0.0	0	0	0	0.2	0	0	0
Theories and realism	0.1	0	1	0	0.8	0	1	0
Functions	0.2	0	4	0	4.6	0	5	0
Feminism	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0
Medical ethics and Freud	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Abortion and self-defence	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0
Belief ascriptions	0.0	0	0	0	0.3	0	0	0
Thermodynamics	0.3	0	5	0	3.9	0	4	0
Knowledge	0.2	0	4	0	4.2	0	5	0
Game theory	0.0	0	1	0	0.4	0	0	0
Justification	0.2	0	3	0	1.5	0	2	0
Frankfurt cases	0.0	0	0	0	0.3	0	0	0
Concepts	0.3	0	5	0	5.2	0	6	0
Races and DNA	0.0	0	0	0	0.3	0	0	0
Modality	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0
Reasons	0.2	0	3	0	2.9	0	3	0
Evolutionary biology	0.0	0	1	0	0.5	0	1	0
Population ethics	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Formal epistemology	0.2	1	5	19	1.3	5	1	6
Wide content	0.2	0	4	0	4.8	0	5	0
Vagueness	0.0	0	1	0	0.9	0	1	0
Cognitive science	0.0	0	0	0	0.3	0	0	0
Models	0.0	0	0	0	0.4	0	0	0
Composition and constitution	0.0	0	1	0	0.5	0	1	0
Norms	0.0	0	0	0	0.6	0	1	0

1904

Table B.29: Measures of the prominence of each subject in 1904 ’s journals.

Subject	Weight	Raw	W-Ratio	R-Ratio	W-Pages	R-Pages	WP-Ratio	RP-Ratio
Psychology	5.5	8	96	140	90.9	112	96	119
Idealism	12.3	26	216	456	220.3	511	234	542
Life and value	3.8	3	66	53	64.6	48	68	51
Other history	3.0	2	52	35	38.6	21	41	22
Dewey and pragmatism	1.4	0	25	0	26.2	0	28	0
Definitions	0.9	0	17	0	13.4	0	14	0
Propositions and implications	0.6	2	11	35	10.6	35	11	37
Beauty	0.5	1	9	18	5.1	8	5	8
Physicalism	1.4	1	24	18	17.6	6	19	6
History and culture	0.1	0	2	0	1.8	0	2	0
Faith and theism	0.5	0	8	0	8.8	0	9	0
Self-consciousness	2.3	2	40	35	29.6	12	31	13
Ancient	0.8	1	14	18	12.3	15	13	16
Universals and particulars	0.7	1	12	18	10.7	15	11	16
Verification	0.2	0	3	0	2.8	0	3	0
Value	0.6	1	10	18	10.7	21	11	22
Deduction	0.6	0	10	0	8.9	0	9	0
Mechanisms	0.5	0	9	0	8.2	0	9	0
Temporal paradoxes	0.5	0	9	0	10.4	0	11	0
Classical space and time	0.7	0	12	0	12.5	0	13	0
Early modern	0.9	1	15	18	13.4	14	14	15
Meaning and use	0.1	0	2	0	1.3	0	1	0
Marx	0.3	0	5	0	3.9	0	4	0
Ordinary language	3.8	3	67	53	72.1	44	76	47
Moral conscience	1.0	1	17	18	16.8	18	18	19
Methodology of science	1.7	1	30	18	24.1	10	26	11
Heidegger and Husserl	0.2	0	3	0	1.9	0	2	0
Emotions	0.5	0	9	0	10.9	0	12	0
Ontological argument	0.6	0	10	0	10.3	0	11	0
Chemistry	0.6	1	10	18	10.0	19	11	20
Social contract theory	0.3	0	4	0	3.8	0	4	0
Kant	0.9	1	16	18	16.6	18	18	19
Promises and imperatives	0.6	1	11	18	11.1	16	12	17
Analytic/synthetic	0.2	0	3	0	2.5	0	3	0
Freedom and free will	0.0	0	1	0	0.8	0	1	0
Crime and punishment	0.0	0	0	0	0.2	0	0	0
Sets and grue	0.0	0	0	0	0.5	0	1	0
Origins and purposes	0.2	0	3	0	2.9	0	3	0
Time	0.2	0	3	0	2.5	0	3	0
Color/colour	0.3	0	6	0	6.2	0	7	0
War	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0
Depiction	0.0	0	1	0	0.7	0	1	0
Denoting	0.3	0	6	0	6.0	0	6	0
Chance	0.1	0	1	0	0.9	0	1	0
Hume	0.2	0	3	0	2.7	0	3	0
Laws	0.1	0	2	0	2.4	0	3	0
Perception	1.1	0	19	0	15.2	0	16	0
Intention	0.1	0	2	0	2.0	0	2	0
Virtues	0.1	0	1	0	1.4	0	1	0
Space and time	0.0	0	0	0	0.3	0	0	0
Mathematics	0.4	0	7	0	7.3	0	8	0
Liberal democracy	0.0	0	0	0	0.5	0	0	0
Duties	0.1	0	1	0	0.5	0	1	0
Causation	0.5	0	9	0	8.1	0	9	0
Arguments	0.5	0	9	0	7.2	0	8	0
Theory testing	0.2	0	4	0	3.6	0	4	0
Decision theory	0.1	0	2	0	1.8	0	2	0
Minds and machines	0.3	0	5	0	4.0	0	4	0
Truth	0.4	0	7	0	7.4	0	8	0
Radical translation	0.0	0	1	0	0.5	0	1	0
Explanation	0.2	0	3	0	2.3	0	2	0
Personal identity	0.2	0	3	0	1.9	0	2	0
Speech acts	0.0	0	0	0	0.4	0	0	0
Sense and reference	0.0	0	0	0	0.2	0	0	0
Egalitarianism	0.0	0	0	0	0.4	0	0	0
Quantum physics	0.1	0	2	0	2.5	0	3	0
Theories and realism	0.2	0	3	0	2.3	0	2	0
Functions	0.3	0	5	0	3.5	0	4	0
Feminism	0.0	0	0	0	0.4	0	0	0
Medical ethics and Freud	0.0	0	1	0	0.6	0	1	0
Abortion and self-defence	0.0	0	1	0	0.6	0	1	0
Belief ascriptions	0.0	0	0	0	0.3	0	0	0
Thermodynamics	0.1	0	2	0	2.3	0	2	0
Knowledge	0.2	0	3	0	3.1	0	3	0
Game theory	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Justification	0.5	0	8	0	8.0	0	8	0
Frankfurt cases	0.0	0	1	0	0.6	0	1	0
Concepts	0.1	0	2	0	1.8	0	2	0
Races and DNA	0.1	0	1	0	1.3	0	1	0
Modality	0.1	0	1	0	1.9	0	2	0
Reasons	0.3	0	5	0	6.5	0	7	0
Evolutionary biology	0.2	0	3	0	2.8	0	3	0
Population ethics	0.0	0	0	0	0.4	0	0	0
Formal epistemology	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Wide content	0.2	0	4	0	4.8	0	5	0
Vagueness	0.1	0	1	0	1.5	0	2	0
Cognitive science	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Models	0.0	0	0	0	0.2	0	0	0
Composition and constitution	0.1	0	2	0	2.2	0	2	0
Norms	0.1	0	1	0	1.9	0	2	0

1905

Table B.30: Measures of the prominence of each subject in 1905 ’s journals.

Subject	Weight	Raw	W-Ratio	R-Ratio	W-Pages	R-Pages	WP-Ratio	RP-Ratio
Psychology	2.7	1	43	16	44.3	9	46	9
Idealism	13.9	27	225	435	253.0	519	261	535
Life and value	4.2	5	68	81	71.2	80	73	82
Other history	2.7	4	44	65	50.9	74	52	76
Dewey and pragmatism	2.2	1	35	16	36.8	6	38	6
Definitions	1.1	0	18	0	14.9	0	15	0
Propositions and implications	3.5	4	56	65	24.5	40	25	41
Beauty	0.5	1	9	16	10.0	20	10	21
Physicalism	0.5	0	9	0	6.2	0	6	0
History and culture	0.3	0	5	0	4.4	0	5	0
Faith and theism	0.9	2	15	32	14.5	29	15	30
Self-consciousness	2.2	1	35	16	28.9	3	30	3
Ancient	0.4	1	7	16	7.5	19	8	20
Universals and particulars	0.5	1	9	16	6.4	9	7	9
Verification	0.6	0	9	0	8.9	0	9	0
Value	0.8	1	13	16	15.7	21	16	22
Deduction	1.1	1	18	16	17.2	8	18	8
Mechanisms	0.4	0	7	0	6.2	0	6	0
Temporal paradoxes	0.7	0	11	0	12.5	0	13	0
Classical space and time	0.2	0	3	0	3.1	0	3	0
Early modern	0.4	0	7	0	7.0	0	7	0
Meaning and use	0.1	0	2	0	2.3	0	2	0
Marx	0.3	0	4	0	4.2	0	4	0
Ordinary language	2.6	3	42	48	50.2	50	52	51
Moral conscience	1.0	0	15	0	16.4	0	17	0
Methodology of science	1.6	0	26	0	29.9	0	31	0
Heidegger and Husserl	0.0	0	1	0	0.9	0	1	0
Emotions	1.1	0	18	0	15.3	0	16	0
Ontological argument	1.1	0	18	0	12.1	0	12	0
Chemistry	0.7	1	11	16	6.6	3	7	3
Social contract theory	0.1	0	1	0	0.9	0	1	0
Kant	0.6	0	9	0	12.2	0	13	0
Promises and imperatives	0.1	0	2	0	1.9	0	2	0
Analytic/synthetic	0.2	0	4	0	3.8	0	4	0
Freedom and free will	0.0	0	1	0	0.6	0	1	0
Crime and punishment	0.2	0	3	0	2.4	0	2	0
Sets and grue	1.8	4	28	65	9.8	18	10	19
Origins and purposes	0.1	0	2	0	1.1	0	1	0
Time	0.3	0	6	0	5.5	0	6	0
Color/colour	0.2	0	4	0	3.1	0	3	0
War	0.1	0	2	0	1.2	0	1	0
Depiction	0.2	0	4	0	2.2	0	2	0
Denoting	0.7	1	12	16	10.3	15	11	15
Chance	0.1	0	1	0	1.0	0	1	0
Hume	0.9	2	15	32	16.8	38	17	39
Laws	0.3	0	5	0	5.6	0	6	0
Perception	0.9	1	14	16	13.7	10	14	10
Intention	0.1	0	1	0	1.6	0	2	0
Virtues	0.1	0	1	0	0.6	0	1	0
Space and time	0.1	0	1	0	2.1	0	2	0
Mathematics	0.4	0	6	0	5.6	0	6	0
Liberal democracy	0.1	0	1	0	0.9	0	1	0
Duties	0.0	0	0	0	0.2	0	0	0
Causation	0.5	0	8	0	10.5	0	11	0
Arguments	0.4	0	6	0	6.2	0	6	0
Theory testing	0.2	0	3	0	2.4	0	3	0
Decision theory	0.1	0	1	0	1.6	0	2	0
Minds and machines	0.2	0	3	0	3.2	0	3	0
Truth	0.9	0	14	0	13.3	0	14	0
Radical translation	0.0	0	0	0	0.2	0	0	0
Explanation	0.1	0	1	0	1.3	0	1	0
Personal identity	0.2	0	3	0	2.2	0	2	0
Speech acts	0.1	0	2	0	0.9	0	1	0
Sense and reference	0.1	0	2	0	3.1	0	3	0
Egalitarianism	0.0	0	1	0	0.5	0	1	0
Quantum physics	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Theories and realism	0.2	0	3	0	2.6	0	3	0
Functions	0.2	0	3	0	2.9	0	3	0
Feminism	0.1	0	1	0	0.6	0	1	0
Medical ethics and Freud	0.0	0	0	0	0.4	0	0	0
Abortion and self-defence	0.3	0	4	0	0.7	0	1	0
Belief ascriptions	0.1	0	1	0	0.2	0	0	0
Thermodynamics	0.3	0	5	0	4.3	0	4	0
Knowledge	0.2	0	3	0	2.5	0	3	0
Game theory	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Justification	0.2	0	3	0	3.1	0	3	0
Frankfurt cases	0.3	0	5	0	1.1	0	1	0
Concepts	0.5	0	8	0	5.1	0	5	0
Races and DNA	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0
Modality	0.2	0	3	0	1.9	0	2	0
Reasons	0.1	0	1	0	1.5	0	2	0
Evolutionary biology	0.4	0	6	0	6.2	0	6	0
Population ethics	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0
Formal epistemology	0.1	0	1	0	0.3	0	0	0
Wide content	0.2	0	3	0	3.3	0	3	0
Vagueness	0.1	0	1	0	0.8	0	1	0
Cognitive science	0.0	0	1	0	0.5	0	1	0
Models	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Composition and constitution	0.0	0	1	0	0.3	0	0	0
Norms	0.1	0	2	0	1.9	0	2	0

1906

Table B.31: Measures of the prominence of each subject in 1906 ’s journals.

Subject	Weight	Raw	W-Ratio	R-Ratio	W-Pages	R-Pages	WP-Ratio	RP-Ratio
Psychology	4.7	6	76	97	134.7	153	121	137
Idealism	14.4	31	232	500	270.5	576	242	516
Life and value	4.0	6	65	97	66.4	109	59	98
Other history	2.1	3	35	48	32.5	47	29	42
Dewey and pragmatism	2.4	0	39	0	39.7	0	36	0
Definitions	1.2	2	19	32	18.1	28	16	25
Propositions and implications	0.5	0	8	0	8.7	0	8	0
Beauty	0.3	0	5	0	5.2	0	5	0
Physicalism	0.7	0	12	0	10.2	0	9	0
History and culture	0.4	0	6	0	7.4	0	7	0
Faith and theism	0.5	0	8	0	8.9	0	8	0
Self-consciousness	1.8	0	29	0	28.3	0	25	0
Ancient	1.0	2	16	32	10.3	17	9	15
Universals and particulars	0.3	0	5	0	5.2	0	5	0
Verification	0.4	0	7	0	9.0	0	8	0
Value	0.6	1	10	16	10.2	13	9	12
Deduction	0.7	0	12	0	12.1	0	11	0
Mechanisms	0.6	0	9	0	9.3	0	8	0
Temporal paradoxes	0.8	0	12	0	13.6	0	12	0
Classical space and time	0.6	1	9	16	9.5	15	9	13
Early modern	0.5	0	8	0	8.3	0	7	0
Meaning and use	0.4	0	6	0	6.7	0	6	0
Marx	0.6	0	9	0	9.9	0	9	0
Ordinary language	3.9	2	64	32	92.2	73	83	65
Moral conscience	0.6	0	10	0	10.2	0	9	0
Methodology of science	1.8	1	30	16	29.0	15	26	13
Heidegger and Husserl	0.5	0	8	0	3.7	0	3	0
Emotions	0.4	0	6	0	7.5	0	7	0
Ontological argument	0.4	0	7	0	13.1	0	12	0
Chemistry	0.5	1	8	16	8.8	10	8	9
Social contract theory	0.1	0	2	0	2.7	0	2	0
Kant	0.9	1	15	16	15.5	24	14	21
Promises and imperatives	0.2	0	3	0	3.8	0	3	0
Analytic/synthetic	0.6	0	10	0	8.0	0	7	0
Freedom and free will	0.1	0	2	0	2.1	0	2	0
Crime and punishment	0.0	0	1	0	0.6	0	1	0
Sets and grue	0.2	0	4	0	2.7	0	2	0
Origins and purposes	0.2	0	3	0	2.8	0	2	0
Time	0.7	0	11	0	10.3	0	9	0
Color/colour	0.4	0	6	0	8.8	0	8	0
War	0.0	0	0	0	0.5	0	0	0
Depiction	0.2	0	3	0	3.1	0	3	0
Denoting	0.2	0	3	0	2.6	0	2	0
Chance	0.0	0	1	0	1.0	0	1	0
Hume	0.1	0	2	0	2.8	0	3	0
Laws	0.4	0	6	0	9.2	0	8	0
Perception	2.2	2	36	32	27.6	10	25	9
Intention	0.3	0	6	0	3.8	0	3	0
Virtues	0.0	0	0	0	0.8	0	1	0
Space and time	0.0	0	0	0	0.4	0	0	0
Mathematics	0.6	1	10	16	7.1	9	6	8
Liberal democracy	0.1	0	1	0	1.1	0	1	0
Duties	0.1	0	1	0	1.3	0	1	0
Causation	0.2	0	3	0	3.9	0	3	0
Arguments	0.3	0	5	0	5.9	0	5	0
Theory testing	0.2	0	3	0	3.8	0	3	0
Decision theory	0.0	0	0	0	0.2	0	0	0
Minds and machines	0.2	0	4	0	2.6	0	2	0
Truth	0.5	1	8	16	8.2	16	7	14
Radical translation	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Explanation	0.1	0	2	0	1.5	0	1	0
Personal identity	0.1	0	2	0	2.8	0	3	0
Speech acts	0.0	0	1	0	0.6	0	1	0
Sense and reference	0.1	0	2	0	1.3	0	1	0
Egalitarianism	0.2	0	4	0	4.5	0	4	0
Quantum physics	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Theories and realism	0.1	0	2	0	2.0	0	2	0
Functions	0.2	0	3	0	2.8	0	3	0
Feminism	0.4	0	7	0	6.0	0	5	0
Medical ethics and Freud	0.0	0	0	0	0.3	0	0	0
Abortion and self-defence	0.8	1	13	16	1.8	2	2	2
Belief ascriptions	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Thermodynamics	0.2	0	4	0	4.3	0	4	0
Knowledge	0.6	0	10	0	7.7	0	7	0
Game theory	0.3	0	5	0	6.4	0	6	0
Justification	0.3	0	5	0	6.9	0	6	0
Frankfurt cases	0.0	0	0	0	0.5	0	0	0
Concepts	0.2	0	4	0	5.3	0	5	0
Races and DNA	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0
Modality	0.0	0	0	0	0.6	0	1	0
Reasons	0.1	0	2	0	3.5	0	3	0
Evolutionary biology	0.1	0	2	0	1.2	0	1	0
Population ethics	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0
Formal epistemology	0.1	0	1	0	0.7	0	1	0
Wide content	0.4	0	7	0	9.0	0	8	0
Vagueness	0.0	0	1	0	0.7	0	1	0
Cognitive science	0.1	0	1	0	0.7	0	1	0
Models	0.0	0	0	0	0.2	0	0	0
Composition and constitution	0.1	0	2	0	1.7	0	2	0
Norms	0.1	0	1	0	1.1	0	1	0

1907

Table B.32: Measures of the prominence of each subject in 1907 ’s journals.

Subject	Weight	Raw	W-Ratio	R-Ratio	W-Pages	R-Pages	WP-Ratio	RP-Ratio
Psychology	5.3	8	86	129	112.6	160	111	157
Idealism	16.8	33	271	532	260.3	519	255	509
Life and value	3.0	4	49	65	56.3	56	55	55
Other history	2.5	4	40	65	54.3	99	53	97
Dewey and pragmatism	1.5	0	24	0	23.4	0	23	0
Definitions	0.5	0	8	0	8.6	0	8	0
Propositions and implications	1.7	2	27	32	14.4	6	14	6
Beauty	0.1	0	1	0	1.0	0	1	0
Physicalism	0.6	0	10	0	7.0	0	7	0
History and culture	0.3	0	5	0	7.9	0	8	0
Faith and theism	0.4	0	7	0	8.1	0	8	0
Self-consciousness	1.1	0	17	0	22.7	0	22	0
Ancient	0.5	0	9	0	10.5	0	10	0
Universals and particulars	0.9	1	14	16	11.6	16	11	16
Verification	0.5	0	8	0	6.9	0	7	0
Value	0.4	0	6	0	6.7	0	7	0
Deduction	0.9	0	15	0	9.8	0	10	0
Mechanisms	0.5	0	7	0	6.2	0	6	0
Temporal paradoxes	1.2	2	20	32	20.8	25	20	25
Classical space and time	0.8	0	13	0	9.9	0	10	0
Early modern	0.7	1	12	16	15.9	27	16	26
Meaning and use	1.0	0	16	0	8.8	0	9	0
Marx	0.2	0	3	0	2.9	0	3	0
Ordinary language	3.6	2	57	32	62.7	18	61	18
Moral conscience	0.6	0	9	0	8.8	0	9	0
Methodology of science	0.8	0	13	0	13.7	0	13	0
Heidegger and Husserl	0.1	0	1	0	1.5	0	2	0
Emotions	0.9	1	15	16	25.8	29	25	28
Ontological argument	0.9	1	14	16	15.3	12	15	12
Chemistry	0.6	1	9	16	13.9	31	14	30
Social contract theory	0.2	0	3	0	4.5	0	4	0
Kant	0.6	0	10	0	13.1	0	13	0
Promises and imperatives	0.3	0	5	0	4.9	0	5	0
Analytic/synthetic	0.2	0	2	0	2.9	0	3	0
Freedom and free will	0.4	0	6	0	4.0	0	4	0
Crime and punishment	0.1	0	1	0	0.8	0	1	0
Sets and grue	0.2	0	3	0	3.0	0	3	0
Origins and purposes	0.3	0	4	0	3.5	0	3	0
Time	0.7	0	11	0	11.6	0	11	0
Color/colour	0.2	0	3	0	3.8	0	4	0
War	0.0	0	0	0	0.4	0	0	0
Depiction	0.2	0	3	0	2.7	0	3	0
Denoting	0.1	0	2	0	1.8	0	2	0
Chance	0.1	0	1	0	0.8	0	1	0
Hume	0.2	0	4	0	4.9	0	5	0
Laws	0.4	0	6	0	5.0	0	5	0
Perception	1.7	1	27	16	19.4	13	19	13
Intention	0.2	0	3	0	1.1	0	1	0
Virtues	0.2	0	2	0	1.5	0	2	0
Space and time	0.0	0	0	0	0.4	0	0	0
Mathematics	0.2	0	3	0	3.0	0	3	0
Liberal democracy	0.0	0	0	0	0.7	0	1	0
Duties	0.1	0	2	0	1.3	0	1	0
Causation	0.5	0	8	0	9.4	0	9	0
Arguments	0.4	0	7	0	7.4	0	7	0
Theory testing	0.2	0	3	0	4.3	0	4	0
Decision theory	0.7	1	11	16	6.2	8	6	8
Minds and machines	0.1	0	1	0	1.4	0	1	0
Truth	0.9	0	15	0	11.2	0	11	0
Radical translation	0.2	0	2	0	0.8	0	1	0
Explanation	0.1	0	2	0	3.1	0	3	0
Personal identity	0.4	0	6	0	5.1	0	5	0
Speech acts	0.0	0	1	0	0.7	0	1	0
Sense and reference	0.1	0	2	0	0.7	0	1	0
Egalitarianism	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0
Quantum physics	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Theories and realism	0.3	0	4	0	3.6	0	4	0
Functions	0.2	0	2	0	2.6	0	3	0
Feminism	0.1	0	2	0	2.1	0	2	0
Medical ethics and Freud	0.1	0	1	0	1.3	0	1	0
Abortion and self-defence	0.0	0	0	0	0.4	0	0	0
Belief ascriptions	0.0	0	0	0	0.2	0	0	0
Thermodynamics	0.2	0	4	0	4.4	0	4	0
Knowledge	0.5	0	8	0	6.2	0	6	0
Game theory	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Justification	0.2	0	4	0	4.0	0	4	0
Frankfurt cases	0.0	0	0	0	0.2	0	0	0
Concepts	0.4	0	6	0	5.4	0	5	0
Races and DNA	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0
Modality	0.1	0	1	0	0.8	0	1	0
Reasons	0.2	0	3	0	2.6	0	3	0
Evolutionary biology	0.2	0	3	0	2.5	0	2	0
Population ethics	0.1	0	1	0	0.4	0	0	0
Formal epistemology	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Wide content	0.1	0	2	0	3.6	0	3	0
Vagueness	0.1	0	1	0	0.9	0	1	0
Cognitive science	0.1	0	1	0	0.4	0	0	0
Models	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0
Composition and constitution	0.1	0	1	0	0.9	0	1	0
Norms	0.1	0	2	0	2.3	0	2	0

1908

Table B.33: Measures of the prominence of each subject in 1908 ’s journals.

Subject	Weight	Raw	W-Ratio	R-Ratio	W-Pages	R-Pages	WP-Ratio	RP-Ratio
Psychology	3.1	5	47	76	77.9	137	79	138
Idealism	15.4	26	233	394	256.6	399	259	402
Life and value	3.6	3	54	45	61.5	47	62	47
Other history	2.0	3	30	45	32.3	57	33	57
Dewey and pragmatism	3.4	3	51	45	46.7	33	47	33
Definitions	1.0	0	15	0	13.0	0	13	0
Propositions and implications	2.6	5	40	76	14.0	16	14	16
Beauty	0.3	0	4	0	3.9	0	4	0
Physicalism	0.5	0	8	0	9.2	0	9	0
History and culture	0.3	0	5	0	4.8	0	5	0
Faith and theism	0.2	0	3	0	3.9	0	4	0
Self-consciousness	2.1	0	32	0	32.5	0	33	0
Ancient	1.9	4	29	61	29.5	72	30	73
Universals and particulars	0.6	1	9	15	6.4	12	6	12
Verification	0.7	0	10	0	9.5	0	10	0
Value	1.4	1	22	15	21.9	20	22	20
Deduction	1.2	0	18	0	10.8	0	11	0
Mechanisms	0.2	0	3	0	3.2	0	3	0
Temporal paradoxes	1.5	2	22	30	19.3	30	19	30
Classical space and time	1.0	2	16	30	10.1	32	10	32
Early modern	0.7	1	10	15	10.5	9	11	9
Meaning and use	0.2	0	3	0	4.4	0	4	0
Marx	0.5	0	7	0	4.9	0	5	0
Ordinary language	3.4	3	52	45	73.7	80	74	81
Moral conscience	1.0	1	16	15	15.9	11	16	11
Methodology of science	0.7	0	11	0	12.3	0	12	0
Heidegger and Husserl	0.2	0	2	0	2.0	0	2	0
Emotions	0.9	1	14	15	15.8	17	16	17
Ontological argument	0.2	0	3	0	3.8	0	4	0
Chemistry	0.2	0	3	0	2.8	0	3	0
Social contract theory	0.5	1	8	15	6.1	9	6	9
Kant	1.7	2	26	30	11.0	4	11	4
Promises and imperatives	0.9	0	14	0	9.2	0	9	0
Analytic/synthetic	0.2	0	3	0	3.3	0	3	0
Freedom and free will	0.2	0	3	0	2.2	0	2	0
Crime and punishment	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Sets and grue	0.2	0	3	0	1.2	0	1	0
Origins and purposes	0.1	0	2	0	2.0	0	2	0
Time	0.5	0	8	0	9.8	0	10	0
Color/colour	0.8	0	12	0	4.2	0	4	0
War	0.0	0	0	0	0.4	0	0	0
Depiction	0.2	0	3	0	1.9	0	2	0
Denoting	0.4	0	6	0	3.0	0	3	0
Chance	0.1	0	2	0	0.6	0	1	0
Hume	0.4	0	6	0	7.0	0	7	0
Laws	0.3	0	5	0	4.4	0	4	0
Perception	0.5	0	7	0	9.5	0	10	0
Intention	0.0	0	1	0	0.6	0	1	0
Virtues	0.1	0	1	0	0.9	0	1	0
Space and time	0.1	0	1	0	1.0	0	1	0
Mathematics	0.7	1	11	15	8.8	5	9	5
Liberal democracy	0.0	0	0	0	0.4	0	0	0
Duties	0.1	0	1	0	1.0	0	1	0
Causation	0.2	0	2	0	2.3	0	2	0
Arguments	0.5	0	7	0	6.8	0	7	0
Theory testing	0.2	0	2	0	3.0	0	3	0
Decision theory	0.7	0	11	0	6.5	0	7	0
Minds and machines	0.1	0	2	0	2.2	0	2	0
Truth	1.6	1	25	15	21.5	2	22	2
Radical translation	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Explanation	0.1	0	1	0	0.8	0	1	0
Personal identity	0.3	0	4	0	3.5	0	4	0
Speech acts	0.1	0	1	0	0.6	0	1	0
Sense and reference	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Egalitarianism	0.1	0	1	0	1.3	0	1	0
Quantum physics	0.0	0	1	0	0.5	0	1	0
Theories and realism	0.4	0	5	0	3.3	0	3	0
Functions	0.2	0	3	0	2.7	0	3	0
Feminism	0.1	0	1	0	0.9	0	1	0
Medical ethics and Freud	0.4	0	6	0	1.0	0	1	0
Abortion and self-defence	0.1	0	1	0	1.1	0	1	0
Belief ascriptions	0.0	0	1	0	0.6	0	1	0
Thermodynamics	0.2	0	3	0	3.9	0	4	0
Knowledge	0.3	0	5	0	5.6	0	6	0
Game theory	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0
Justification	0.3	0	4	0	5.4	0	5	0
Frankfurt cases	0.1	0	1	0	0.3	0	0	0
Concepts	0.2	0	3	0	2.7	0	3	0
Races and DNA	0.0	0	0	0	0.2	0	0	0
Modality	0.0	0	0	0	0.3	0	0	0
Reasons	0.1	0	2	0	1.6	0	2	0
Evolutionary biology	0.1	0	2	0	1.2	0	1	0
Population ethics	0.0	0	1	0	0.7	0	1	0
Formal epistemology	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Wide content	0.2	0	3	0	3.9	0	4	0
Vagueness	0.2	0	3	0	2.2	0	2	0
Cognitive science	0.1	0	1	0	1.1	0	1	0
Models	0.0	0	0	0	0.2	0	0	0
Composition and constitution	0.1	0	1	0	1.2	0	1	0
Norms	0.1	0	1	0	1.0	0	1	0

1909

Table B.34: Measures of the prominence of each subject in 1909 ’s journals.

Subject	Weight	Raw	W-Ratio	R-Ratio	W-Pages	R-Pages	WP-Ratio	RP-Ratio
Psychology	3.1	5	55	89	70.5	113	73	117
Idealism	16.3	30	291	536	292.8	566	304	588
Life and value	3.4	3	60	54	59.7	47	62	49
Other history	2.6	3	46	54	47.9	60	50	62
Dewey and pragmatism	2.1	3	38	54	25.3	20	26	21
Definitions	0.4	0	8	0	7.3	0	8	0
Propositions and implications	0.1	0	2	0	2.9	0	3	0
Beauty	0.7	1	12	18	12.8	18	13	19
Physicalism	0.6	0	10	0	12.0	0	12	0
History and culture	0.5	0	9	0	6.4	0	7	0
Faith and theism	1.2	1	21	18	16.5	3	17	3
Self-consciousness	1.6	0	28	0	24.6	0	26	0
Ancient	2.4	4	42	71	28.9	50	30	52
Universals and particulars	0.3	0	6	0	5.6	0	6	0
Verification	0.3	0	6	0	7.0	0	7	0
Value	0.6	0	10	0	8.1	0	8	0
Deduction	0.6	1	11	18	9.4	14	10	15
Mechanisms	0.2	0	4	0	3.6	0	4	0
Temporal paradoxes	1.7	2	30	36	26.8	23	28	24
Classical space and time	0.3	0	5	0	5.7	0	6	0
Early modern	0.2	0	3	0	3.7	0	4	0
Meaning and use	0.2	0	4	0	3.5	0	4	0
Marx	0.2	0	4	0	2.6	0	3	0
Ordinary language	3.9	1	70	18	77.9	12	81	12
Moral conscience	0.5	0	9	0	3.6	0	4	0
Methodology of science	0.9	0	16	0	16.0	0	17	0
Heidegger and Husserl	0.1	0	2	0	1.6	0	2	0
Emotions	0.5	0	8	0	9.1	0	9	0
Ontological argument	0.4	0	7	0	7.5	0	8	0
Chemistry	0.3	0	5	0	3.0	0	3	0
Social contract theory	0.1	0	2	0	2.4	0	2	0
Kant	1.1	1	19	18	13.2	13	14	13
Promises and imperatives	0.3	0	5	0	3.3	0	3	0
Analytic/synthetic	0.2	0	3	0	2.8	0	3	0
Freedom and free will	0.1	0	2	0	1.5	0	2	0
Crime and punishment	0.1	0	2	0	1.9	0	2	0
Sets and grue	0.1	0	2	0	2.3	0	2	0
Origins and purposes	0.4	0	6	0	3.3	0	3	0
Time	0.5	0	9	0	9.9	0	10	0
Color/colour	0.2	0	4	0	4.7	0	5	0
War	0.0	0	0	0	0.4	0	0	0
Depiction	0.1	0	1	0	1.8	0	2	0
Denoting	0.0	0	1	0	1.2	0	1	0
Chance	0.1	0	1	0	0.8	0	1	0
Hume	0.1	0	2	0	1.9	0	2	0
Laws	0.3	0	5	0	3.4	0	4	0
Perception	1.0	0	18	0	17.5	0	18	0
Intention	0.1	0	1	0	1.8	0	2	0
Virtues	0.0	0	1	0	0.7	0	1	0
Space and time	0.0	0	0	0	0.3	0	0	0
Mathematics	0.5	0	8	0	10.6	0	11	0
Liberal democracy	0.4	1	8	18	10.5	24	11	25
Duties	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Causation	0.2	0	4	0	3.2	0	3	0
Arguments	0.4	0	8	0	6.8	0	7	0
Theory testing	0.1	0	2	0	1.8	0	2	0
Decision theory	0.1	0	2	0	1.5	0	2	0
Minds and machines	0.1	0	2	0	2.3	0	2	0
Truth	0.6	0	10	0	7.2	0	8	0
Radical translation	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Explanation	0.1	0	2	0	1.4	0	1	0
Personal identity	0.1	0	2	0	1.6	0	2	0
Speech acts	0.0	0	1	0	0.4	0	0	0
Sense and reference	0.0	0	1	0	0.8	0	1	0
Egalitarianism	0.0	0	0	0	0.3	0	0	0
Quantum physics	0.0	0	0	0	0.6	0	1	0
Theories and realism	0.3	0	6	0	4.7	0	5	0
Functions	0.1	0	2	0	1.6	0	2	0
Feminism	0.3	0	5	0	1.9	0	2	0
Medical ethics and Freud	0.0	0	0	0	0.3	0	0	0
Abortion and self-defence	0.0	0	1	0	0.5	0	1	0
Belief ascriptions	0.0	0	0	0	0.3	0	0	0
Thermodynamics	0.2	0	3	0	2.4	0	2	0
Knowledge	0.4	0	7	0	6.2	0	6	0
Game theory	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0
Justification	0.1	0	2	0	3.7	0	4	0
Frankfurt cases	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0
Concepts	0.1	0	2	0	2.0	0	2	0
Races and DNA	0.0	0	0	0	0.3	0	0	0
Modality	0.0	0	0	0	0.2	0	0	0
Reasons	0.1	0	1	0	1.8	0	2	0
Evolutionary biology	0.1	0	1	0	1.3	0	1	0
Population ethics	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0
Formal epistemology	0.1	0	2	0	0.4	0	0	0
Wide content	0.1	0	2	0	2.2	0	2	0
Vagueness	0.2	0	4	0	3.7	0	4	0
Cognitive science	0.0	0	0	0	0.2	0	0	0
Models	0.0	0	0	0	0.3	0	0	0
Composition and constitution	0.1	0	1	0	1.2	0	1	0
Norms	0.1	0	1	0	1.0	0	1	0

1910

Table B.35: Measures of the prominence of each subject in 1910 ’s journals.

Subject	Weight	Raw	W-Ratio	R-Ratio	W-Pages	R-Pages	WP-Ratio	RP-Ratio
Psychology	4.3	10	74	172	101.3	253	100	249
Idealism	12.6	22	217	379	229.3	359	225	353
Life and value	3.3	4	56	69	62.5	80	61	79
Other history	2.2	3	38	52	24.2	29	24	29
Dewey and pragmatism	1.2	1	20	17	18.9	13	19	13
Definitions	2.0	1	35	17	25.8	3	25	3
Propositions and implications	1.5	1	26	17	19.2	14	19	14
Beauty	1.1	2	20	34	15.4	24	15	24
Physicalism	1.0	0	17	0	21.7	0	21	0
History and culture	0.4	0	7	0	7.2	0	7	0
Faith and theism	0.4	0	6	0	5.5	0	5	0
Self-consciousness	1.4	1	25	17	25.7	12	25	12
Ancient	0.8	2	14	34	9.5	28	9	28
Universals and particulars	0.6	0	11	0	14.9	0	15	0
Verification	0.5	0	9	0	9.2	0	9	0
Value	0.7	1	11	17	6.2	3	6	3
Deduction	1.8	3	32	52	20.3	24	20	24
Mechanisms	0.4	0	8	0	6.5	0	6	0
Temporal paradoxes	0.8	0	14	0	17.2	0	17	0
Classical space and time	0.9	0	15	0	15.9	0	16	0
Early modern	0.6	0	10	0	7.0	0	7	0
Meaning and use	0.4	0	7	0	7.3	0	7	0
Marx	0.1	0	3	0	2.8	0	3	0
Ordinary language	3.1	2	53	34	68.5	84	67	83
Moral conscience	0.5	0	8	0	9.1	0	9	0
Methodology of science	0.8	0	14	0	15.6	0	15	0
Heidegger and Husserl	0.1	0	2	0	2.7	0	3	0
Emotions	0.4	0	7	0	6.1	0	6	0
Ontological argument	0.3	0	6	0	7.4	0	7	0
Chemistry	0.5	1	9	17	9.3	18	9	18
Social contract theory	0.5	0	8	0	5.7	0	6	0
Kant	1.4	2	24	34	23.9	39	23	38
Promises and imperatives	0.2	0	4	0	6.9	0	7	0
Analytic/synthetic	0.3	0	5	0	3.9	0	4	0
Freedom and free will	0.1	0	1	0	0.8	0	1	0
Crime and punishment	0.1	0	1	0	0.3	0	0	0
Sets and grue	0.5	0	8	0	6.4	0	6	0
Origins and purposes	0.1	0	2	0	2.3	0	2	0
Time	0.3	0	5	0	4.5	0	4	0
Color/colour	0.7	0	12	0	10.1	0	10	0
War	0.0	0	0	0	0.3	0	0	0
Depiction	0.1	0	1	0	1.8	0	2	0
Denoting	0.7	1	12	17	9.7	8	10	8
Chance	0.1	0	1	0	1.0	0	1	0
Hume	0.1	0	1	0	1.2	0	1	0
Laws	0.3	0	5	0	5.1	0	5	0
Perception	1.1	0	19	0	22.8	0	22	0
Intention	0.1	0	2	0	2.1	0	2	0
Virtues	0.1	0	1	0	1.1	0	1	0
Space and time	0.0	0	0	0	0.3	0	0	0
Mathematics	0.6	0	11	0	14.4	0	14	0
Liberal democracy	0.0	0	1	0	0.8	0	1	0
Duties	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Causation	0.3	0	5	0	4.8	0	5	0
Arguments	0.8	1	13	17	16.2	26	16	26
Theory testing	0.1	0	2	0	2.1	0	2	0
Decision theory	0.1	0	1	0	1.0	0	1	0
Minds and machines	0.2	0	3	0	2.8	0	3	0
Truth	0.6	0	10	0	6.6	0	6	0
Radical translation	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Explanation	0.1	0	2	0	1.7	0	2	0
Personal identity	0.3	0	5	0	6.3	0	6	0
Speech acts	0.1	0	1	0	0.6	0	1	0
Sense and reference	0.0	0	0	0	0.3	0	0	0
Egalitarianism	0.0	0	0	0	0.5	0	0	0
Quantum physics	0.0	0	0	0	0.4	0	0	0
Theories and realism	0.3	0	5	0	3.2	0	3	0
Functions	0.2	0	3	0	3.0	0	3	0
Feminism	0.0	0	1	0	0.7	0	1	0
Medical ethics and Freud	0.0	0	1	0	0.9	0	1	0
Abortion and self-defence	0.0	0	0	0	0.3	0	0	0
Belief ascriptions	0.1	0	2	0	3.1	0	3	0
Thermodynamics	0.2	0	4	0	4.3	0	4	0
Knowledge	0.6	0	10	0	5.9	0	6	0
Game theory	0.1	0	1	0	0.6	0	1	0
Justification	0.2	0	3	0	2.3	0	2	0
Frankfurt cases	0.0	0	1	0	0.5	0	1	0
Concepts	0.3	0	4	0	6.3	0	6	0
Races and DNA	0.1	0	2	0	1.2	0	1	0
Modality	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0
Reasons	0.2	0	3	0	1.3	0	1	0
Evolutionary biology	0.5	0	9	0	10.0	0	10	0
Population ethics	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Formal epistemology	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Wide content	0.2	0	3	0	4.6	0	5	0
Vagueness	0.1	0	1	0	1.8	0	2	0
Cognitive science	0.1	0	2	0	1.1	0	1	0
Models	0.1	0	1	0	0.8	0	1	0
Composition and constitution	0.1	0	2	0	4.1	0	4	0
Norms	0.0	0	0	0	0.6	0	1	0

1911

Table B.36: Measures of the prominence of each subject in 1911 ’s journals.

Subject	Weight	Raw	W-Ratio	R-Ratio	W-Pages	R-Pages	WP-Ratio	RP-Ratio
Psychology	4.7	7	73	109	83.0	125	88	132
Idealism	14.7	25	230	391	246.4	426	261	451
Life and value	3.2	2	50	31	55.1	39	58	41
Other history	1.5	1	23	16	21.1	20	22	21
Dewey and pragmatism	1.9	2	30	31	28.2	37	30	39
Definitions	1.7	0	27	0	21.4	0	23	0
Propositions and implications	1.4	3	22	47	13.1	24	14	25
Beauty	0.2	0	3	0	2.5	0	3	0
Physicalism	0.8	0	12	0	15.8	0	17	0
History and culture	0.2	0	2	0	2.5	0	3	0
Faith and theism	0.6	0	9	0	6.5	0	7	0
Self-consciousness	1.9	1	29	16	29.5	8	31	8
Ancient	2.1	5	33	78	18.3	44	19	47
Universals and particulars	0.6	0	10	0	8.3	0	9	0
Verification	0.3	0	4	0	3.6	0	4	0
Value	0.9	1	13	16	7.5	2	8	2
Deduction	0.9	0	14	0	8.8	0	9	0
Mechanisms	0.3	0	5	0	5.0	0	5	0
Temporal paradoxes	0.7	0	11	0	12.9	0	14	0
Classical space and time	1.0	1	15	16	8.0	1	8	1
Early modern	1.0	1	15	16	6.4	4	7	4
Meaning and use	0.1	0	2	0	2.0	0	2	0
Marx	0.6	1	10	16	10.0	16	11	17
Ordinary language	4.0	3	63	47	74.3	36	79	38
Moral conscience	0.2	0	4	0	4.2	0	4	0
Methodology of science	0.8	0	12	0	12.7	0	13	0
Heidegger and Husserl	0.2	0	3	0	3.6	0	4	0
Emotions	1.3	2	21	31	21.6	42	23	44
Ontological argument	0.8	0	12	0	9.8	0	10	0
Chemistry	0.9	0	14	0	8.3	0	9	0
Social contract theory	0.2	0	3	0	2.8	0	3	0
Kant	0.5	1	7	16	4.6	2	5	2
Promises and imperatives	0.8	1	12	16	11.0	13	12	14
Analytic/synthetic	0.3	0	4	0	1.7	0	2	0
Freedom and free will	0.2	0	4	0	4.0	0	4	0
Crime and punishment	0.4	1	6	16	5.0	14	5	15
Sets and grue	0.1	0	1	0	1.1	0	1	0
Origins and purposes	0.1	0	2	0	1.3	0	1	0
Time	0.3	0	5	0	7.8	0	8	0
Color/colour	0.4	1	6	16	6.9	19	7	20
War	0.0	0	1	0	0.6	0	1	0
Depiction	0.1	0	1	0	1.2	0	1	0
Denoting	1.4	2	22	31	23.2	42	25	44
Chance	0.0	0	0	0	0.2	0	0	0
Hume	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0
Laws	0.6	0	10	0	4.8	0	5	0
Perception	1.1	0	18	0	20.6	0	22	0
Intention	0.5	1	8	16	5.1	7	5	7
Virtues	0.0	0	1	0	0.6	0	1	0
Space and time	0.0	0	1	0	0.6	0	1	0
Mathematics	0.4	0	7	0	3.7	0	4	0
Liberal democracy	0.3	1	4	16	3.9	16	4	17
Duties	0.1	0	1	0	1.3	0	1	0
Causation	0.4	0	6	0	4.3	0	5	0
Arguments	0.5	0	8	0	5.7	0	6	0
Theory testing	0.4	0	6	0	3.0	0	3	0
Decision theory	0.1	0	2	0	2.0	0	2	0
Minds and machines	0.3	0	4	0	4.6	0	5	0
Truth	1.5	1	23	16	14.8	8	16	8
Radical translation	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Explanation	0.1	0	2	0	1.5	0	2	0
Personal identity	0.3	0	5	0	4.8	0	5	0
Speech acts	0.2	0	3	0	2.8	0	3	0
Sense and reference	0.0	0	0	0	0.3	0	0	0
Egalitarianism	0.0	0	1	0	0.5	0	1	0
Quantum physics	0.0	0	1	0	0.1	0	0	0
Theories and realism	0.3	0	5	0	4.2	0	4	0
Functions	0.2	0	2	0	2.6	0	3	0
Feminism	0.1	0	1	0	0.6	0	1	0
Medical ethics and Freud	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Abortion and self-defence	0.2	0	3	0	1.2	0	1	0
Belief ascriptions	0.1	0	1	0	0.3	0	0	0
Thermodynamics	0.1	0	2	0	1.9	0	2	0
Knowledge	0.3	0	5	0	6.8	0	7	0
Game theory	0.0	0	1	0	0.7	0	1	0
Justification	0.2	0	3	0	3.1	0	3	0
Frankfurt cases	0.1	0	1	0	0.8	0	1	0
Concepts	0.3	0	5	0	3.8	0	4	0
Races and DNA	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0
Modality	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0
Reasons	0.1	0	2	0	1.7	0	2	0
Evolutionary biology	0.2	0	2	0	1.7	0	2	0
Population ethics	0.0	0	1	0	0.7	0	1	0
Formal epistemology	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Wide content	0.3	0	4	0	2.9	0	3	0
Vagueness	0.1	0	2	0	2.1	0	2	0
Cognitive science	0.3	0	4	0	1.3	0	1	0
Models	0.0	0	1	0	0.7	0	1	0
Composition and constitution	0.0	0	0	0	0.4	0	0	0
Norms	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0

1912

Table B.37: Measures of the prominence of each subject in 1912 ’s journals.

Subject	Weight	Raw	W-Ratio	R-Ratio	W-Pages	R-Pages	WP-Ratio	RP-Ratio
Psychology	2.8	5	42	76	67.9	184	62	168
Idealism	14.8	26	224	394	258.9	436	236	397
Life and value	4.0	5	60	76	70.8	86	64	78
Other history	2.7	3	41	45	41.7	51	38	46
Dewey and pragmatism	1.9	1	29	15	23.3	6	21	5
Definitions	1.2	0	18	0	18.3	0	17	0
Propositions and implications	1.7	3	26	45	20.4	41	19	37
Beauty	0.4	0	6	0	4.9	0	5	0
Physicalism	1.5	2	23	30	18.1	8	16	7
History and culture	0.5	0	7	0	9.0	0	8	0
Faith and theism	0.4	1	7	15	10.0	24	9	22
Self-consciousness	1.7	1	26	15	27.4	8	25	7
Ancient	0.7	0	11	0	11.5	0	11	0
Universals and particulars	0.7	1	10	15	15.0	24	14	22
Verification	0.5	0	7	0	6.9	0	6	0
Value	0.5	0	7	0	9.8	0	9	0
Deduction	1.8	2	28	30	22.1	24	20	22
Mechanisms	0.3	0	5	0	8.4	0	8	0
Temporal paradoxes	2.2	2	33	30	45.0	41	41	37
Classical space and time	0.9	0	13	0	15.3	0	14	0
Early modern	0.3	0	5	0	4.7	0	4	0
Meaning and use	0.3	0	5	0	4.1	0	4	0
Marx	0.5	0	7	0	4.6	0	4	0
Ordinary language	3.7	3	56	45	75.5	46	69	42
Moral conscience	0.6	2	9	30	11.7	43	11	39
Methodology of science	1.5	1	23	15	21.3	1	19	1
Heidegger and Husserl	0.5	1	7	15	1.9	2	2	2
Emotions	0.3	0	5	0	3.3	0	3	0
Ontological argument	0.7	0	11	0	15.3	0	14	0
Chemistry	0.7	1	11	15	29.0	40	26	36
Social contract theory	0.5	0	8	0	11.6	0	11	0
Kant	1.2	0	17	0	14.7	0	13	0
Promises and imperatives	0.4	0	6	0	7.9	0	7	0
Analytic/synthetic	0.3	0	4	0	3.0	0	3	0
Freedom and free will	0.1	0	2	0	2.5	0	2	0
Crime and punishment	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0
Sets and grue	0.3	0	5	0	4.7	0	4	0
Origins and purposes	0.2	0	3	0	3.4	0	3	0
Time	0.5	0	8	0	12.8	0	12	0
Color/colour	0.5	0	8	0	8.9	0	8	0
War	0.0	0	1	0	0.6	0	1	0
Depiction	0.5	1	8	15	4.3	1	4	1
Denoting	0.3	0	5	0	2.9	0	3	0
Chance	0.0	0	0	0	0.6	0	1	0
Hume	0.2	0	2	0	4.2	0	4	0
Laws	0.4	0	6	0	4.3	0	4	0
Perception	1.6	1	24	15	34.7	18	32	16
Intention	0.2	0	2	0	1.5	0	1	0
Virtues	0.1	0	1	0	1.1	0	1	0
Space and time	0.1	0	1	0	3.2	0	3	0
Mathematics	1.6	1	25	15	7.5	2	7	2
Liberal democracy	0.0	0	0	0	0.4	0	0	0
Duties	0.1	0	2	0	2.5	0	2	0
Causation	0.3	0	5	0	7.0	0	6	0
Arguments	0.7	0	11	0	7.7	0	7	0
Theory testing	0.3	0	4	0	3.5	0	3	0
Decision theory	0.1	0	2	0	1.5	0	1	0
Minds and machines	0.1	0	1	0	1.7	0	2	0
Truth	1.3	2	20	30	8.9	6	8	5
Radical translation	0.0	0	0	0	0.3	0	0	0
Explanation	0.1	0	1	0	2.1	0	2	0
Personal identity	0.3	0	5	0	3.8	0	4	0
Speech acts	0.0	0	0	0	0.3	0	0	0
Sense and reference	0.1	0	1	0	0.4	0	0	0
Egalitarianism	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0
Quantum physics	0.0	0	0	0	0.3	0	0	0
Theories and realism	0.4	0	5	0	5.3	0	5	0
Functions	0.1	0	2	0	1.5	0	1	0
Feminism	0.1	0	1	0	0.8	0	1	0
Medical ethics and Freud	0.0	0	0	0	0.2	0	0	0
Abortion and self-defence	0.0	0	0	0	0.2	0	0	0
Belief ascriptions	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Thermodynamics	0.4	0	6	0	6.9	0	6	0
Knowledge	0.2	0	3	0	2.8	0	3	0
Game theory	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0
Justification	0.3	1	5	15	2.6	5	2	5
Frankfurt cases	0.0	0	1	0	0.2	0	0	0
Concepts	0.3	0	5	0	6.7	0	6	0
Races and DNA	0.0	0	0	0	0.3	0	0	0
Modality	0.0	0	0	0	0.3	0	0	0
Reasons	0.2	0	2	0	3.9	0	4	0
Evolutionary biology	0.3	0	4	0	2.7	0	2	0
Population ethics	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Formal epistemology	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Wide content	0.3	0	5	0	3.2	0	3	0
Vagueness	0.3	0	4	0	4.5	0	4	0
Cognitive science	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0
Models	0.0	0	0	0	0.2	0	0	0
Composition and constitution	0.0	0	0	0	0.4	0	0	0
Norms	0.2	0	3	0	3.0	0	3	0

1913

Table B.38: Measures of the prominence of each subject in 1913 ’s journals.

Subject	Weight	Raw	W-Ratio	R-Ratio	W-Pages	R-Pages	WP-Ratio	RP-Ratio
Psychology	3.2	3	47	45	85.7	129	81	121
Idealism	14.1	22	210	328	246.4	371	232	349
Life and value	6.6	12	98	179	107.1	226	101	212
Other history	2.4	2	35	30	26.4	21	25	20
Dewey and pragmatism	2.2	3	33	45	28.6	25	27	23
Definitions	1.0	0	16	0	17.3	0	16	0
Propositions and implications	1.2	1	19	15	14.7	4	14	4
Beauty	0.2	0	3	0	4.2	0	4	0
Physicalism	1.7	2	25	30	18.0	11	17	10
History and culture	0.8	0	12	0	6.3	0	6	0
Faith and theism	0.5	1	8	15	5.9	13	6	12
Self-consciousness	2.7	2	40	30	30.9	4	29	4
Ancient	0.5	1	8	15	7.2	12	7	11
Universals and particulars	0.5	0	8	0	7.6	0	7	0
Verification	0.6	0	9	0	8.8	0	8	0
Value	0.8	1	12	15	13.4	5	13	5
Deduction	1.4	2	20	30	16.7	25	16	23
Mechanisms	0.4	0	6	0	5.9	0	6	0
Temporal paradoxes	1.8	3	27	45	29.7	47	28	44
Classical space and time	1.8	3	27	45	25.7	47	24	44
Early modern	0.3	0	5	0	5.5	0	5	0
Meaning and use	0.3	0	4	0	3.0	0	3	0
Marx	0.3	0	5	0	5.9	0	6	0
Ordinary language	3.6	0	53	0	76.2	0	72	0
Moral conscience	0.4	0	6	0	5.5	0	5	0
Methodology of science	2.0	1	30	15	32.4	14	30	13
Heidegger and Husserl	0.1	0	1	0	1.0	0	1	0
Emotions	0.3	0	4	0	4.7	0	4	0
Ontological argument	0.3	0	5	0	5.2	0	5	0
Chemistry	0.9	1	13	15	8.0	3	8	3
Social contract theory	0.2	0	3	0	2.4	0	2	0
Kant	1.6	0	24	0	20.0	0	19	0
Promises and imperatives	0.4	0	5	0	8.3	0	8	0
Analytic/synthetic	0.5	0	8	0	5.9	0	6	0
Freedom and free will	0.3	0	5	0	6.1	0	6	0
Crime and punishment	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0
Sets and grue	0.2	0	2	0	1.3	0	1	0
Origins and purposes	0.4	1	7	15	1.9	2	2	2
Time	0.6	1	10	15	9.6	15	9	14
Color/colour	0.5	0	8	0	5.7	0	5	0
War	0.0	0	0	0	0.3	0	0	0
Depiction	0.1	0	2	0	2.2	0	2	0
Denoting	0.5	1	7	15	4.9	6	5	6
Chance	0.3	1	5	15	8.4	34	8	32
Hume	0.1	0	1	0	2.2	0	2	0
Laws	0.3	0	5	0	8.1	0	8	0
Perception	0.9	0	13	0	15.5	0	15	0
Intention	0.1	0	2	0	0.7	0	1	0
Virtues	0.2	0	3	0	3.2	0	3	0
Space and time	0.0	0	1	0	0.7	0	1	0
Mathematics	0.4	0	6	0	5.0	0	5	0
Liberal democracy	0.0	0	0	0	0.3	0	0	0
Duties	0.1	0	1	0	1.3	0	1	0
Causation	0.3	1	5	15	7.5	26	7	24
Arguments	0.4	0	6	0	6.2	0	6	0
Theory testing	0.2	0	3	0	3.6	0	3	0
Decision theory	0.1	0	1	0	1.7	0	2	0
Minds and machines	0.1	0	2	0	3.1	0	3	0
Truth	1.1	0	16	0	12.3	0	12	0
Radical translation	0.0	0	0	0	0.4	0	0	0
Explanation	0.0	0	1	0	0.8	0	1	0
Personal identity	0.4	1	6	15	7.5	20	7	19
Speech acts	0.0	0	0	0	0.4	0	0	0
Sense and reference	0.0	0	0	0	0.3	0	0	0
Egalitarianism	0.0	0	1	0	0.6	0	1	0
Quantum physics	0.0	0	1	0	0.4	0	0	0
Theories and realism	0.2	0	2	0	3.3	0	3	0
Functions	0.1	0	1	0	2.0	0	2	0
Feminism	0.2	0	3	0	0.9	0	1	0
Medical ethics and Freud	0.0	0	1	0	0.7	0	1	0
Abortion and self-defence	0.1	0	1	0	0.8	0	1	0
Belief ascriptions	0.0	0	0	0	0.4	0	0	0
Thermodynamics	0.2	0	3	0	3.2	0	3	0
Knowledge	0.2	0	3	0	3.4	0	3	0
Game theory	0.1	0	1	0	0.5	0	0	0
Justification	0.2	0	3	0	4.0	0	4	0
Frankfurt cases	0.1	0	1	0	0.7	0	1	0
Concepts	0.5	0	7	0	5.8	0	5	0
Races and DNA	0.0	0	1	0	1.0	0	1	0
Modality	0.1	0	2	0	3.3	0	3	0
Reasons	0.2	0	2	0	3.0	0	3	0
Evolutionary biology	0.3	0	4	0	4.1	0	4	0
Population ethics	0.0	0	1	0	0.3	0	0	0
Formal epistemology	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Wide content	0.1	0	2	0	3.6	0	3	0
Vagueness	0.6	1	10	15	5.7	4	5	4
Cognitive science	0.0	0	1	0	0.8	0	1	0
Models	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Composition and constitution	0.2	0	3	0	2.1	0	2	0
Norms	0.1	0	1	0	1.6	0	1	0

1914

Table B.39: Measures of the prominence of each subject in 1914 ’s journals.

Subject	Weight	Raw	W-Ratio	R-Ratio	W-Pages	R-Pages	WP-Ratio	RP-Ratio
Psychology	4.1	7	60	103	93.1	177	79	151
Idealism	12.6	25	185	368	239.6	501	205	428
Life and value	3.9	5	57	74	71.9	84	61	72
Other history	2.5	3	37	44	50.4	57	43	49
Dewey and pragmatism	1.9	1	28	15	34.4	21	29	18
Definitions	1.0	0	14	0	16.1	0	14	0
Propositions and implications	2.1	3	31	44	17.8	18	15	15
Beauty	0.4	1	6	15	3.6	7	3	6
Physicalism	1.2	1	17	15	20.4	5	17	4
History and culture	0.2	0	3	0	5.1	0	4	0
Faith and theism	0.8	1	11	15	11.8	10	10	9
Self-consciousness	1.3	0	19	0	24.4	0	21	0
Ancient	1.7	1	25	15	15.0	1	13	1
Universals and particulars	1.8	2	27	29	23.5	32	20	27
Verification	0.6	1	9	15	6.5	3	6	3
Value	0.8	1	12	15	16.0	17	14	15
Deduction	4.1	5	60	74	39.8	73	34	62
Mechanisms	0.6	0	8	0	9.4	0	8	0
Temporal paradoxes	1.6	1	24	15	31.1	25	27	21
Classical space and time	0.6	0	9	0	10.0	0	9	0
Early modern	0.5	0	7	0	9.2	0	8	0
Meaning and use	0.2	0	3	0	3.0	0	3	0
Marx	0.1	0	1	0	1.3	0	1	0
Ordinary language	4.7	4	69	59	105.2	56	90	48
Moral conscience	0.4	0	5	0	5.5	0	5	0
Methodology of science	1.9	1	27	15	39.6	26	34	22
Heidegger and Husserl	0.3	0	5	0	7.0	0	6	0
Emotions	0.5	0	8	0	8.8	0	7	0
Ontological argument	0.6	0	9	0	12.6	0	11	0
Chemistry	0.4	0	6	0	7.7	0	7	0
Social contract theory	0.1	0	2	0	2.3	0	2	0
Kant	1.0	0	15	0	16.7	0	14	0
Promises and imperatives	0.3	0	4	0	6.2	0	5	0
Analytic/synthetic	0.3	0	4	0	5.1	0	4	0
Freedom and free will	0.4	1	7	15	9.8	17	8	15
Crime and punishment	0.2	0	3	0	3.0	0	3	0
Sets and grue	0.2	0	2	0	3.2	0	3	0
Origins and purposes	0.5	0	7	0	5.5	0	5	0
Time	1.0	0	14	0	18.3	0	16	0
Color/colour	0.6	1	8	15	6.8	3	6	3
War	0.1	0	1	0	0.7	0	1	0
Depiction	0.0	0	1	0	0.5	0	0	0
Denoting	0.7	0	10	0	9.2	0	8	0
Chance	0.1	0	2	0	1.7	0	1	0
Hume	0.1	0	2	0	2.2	0	2	0
Laws	0.2	0	2	0	2.8	0	2	0
Perception	0.9	0	14	0	24.1	0	21	0
Intention	0.4	1	5	15	6.5	14	6	12
Virtues	0.0	0	0	0	0.5	0	0	0
Space and time	0.4	1	6	15	6.7	18	6	15
Mathematics	0.3	0	4	0	3.6	0	3	0
Liberal democracy	0.0	0	1	0	0.3	0	0	0
Duties	0.2	0	2	0	1.3	0	1	0
Causation	0.3	0	4	0	6.3	0	5	0
Arguments	0.5	0	8	0	8.3	0	7	0
Theory testing	0.2	0	2	0	3.5	0	3	0
Decision theory	0.0	0	1	0	1.1	0	1	0
Minds and machines	0.1	0	2	0	2.7	0	2	0
Truth	1.0	1	15	15	9.9	6	8	5
Radical translation	0.0	0	1	0	0.4	0	0	0
Explanation	0.1	0	1	0	1.4	0	1	0
Personal identity	0.3	0	5	0	5.7	0	5	0
Speech acts	0.1	0	1	0	1.2	0	1	0
Sense and reference	0.0	0	0	0	0.6	0	0	0
Egalitarianism	0.1	0	1	0	0.6	0	0	0
Quantum physics	0.0	0	0	0	0.2	0	0	0
Theories and realism	0.2	0	3	0	3.4	0	3	0
Functions	0.1	0	2	0	2.2	0	2	0
Feminism	0.1	0	1	0	0.9	0	1	0
Medical ethics and Freud	0.0	0	0	0	0.6	0	0	0
Abortion and self-defence	0.1	0	1	0	1.0	0	1	0
Belief ascriptions	0.0	0	0	0	0.5	0	0	0
Thermodynamics	0.2	0	3	0	3.1	0	3	0
Knowledge	0.8	0	12	0	11.9	0	10	0
Game theory	0.4	0	6	0	1.5	0	1	0
Justification	0.4	0	6	0	4.2	0	4	0
Frankfurt cases	0.2	0	2	0	1.0	0	1	0
Concepts	0.3	0	4	0	5.3	0	5	0
Races and DNA	0.1	0	1	0	0.9	0	1	0
Modality	0.1	0	2	0	0.6	0	1	0
Reasons	0.2	0	2	0	1.7	0	1	0
Evolutionary biology	0.1	0	1	0	1.5	0	1	0
Population ethics	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Formal epistemology	0.1	0	1	0	0.7	0	1	0
Wide content	0.1	0	2	0	2.6	0	2	0
Vagueness	0.3	0	5	0	5.0	0	4	0
Cognitive science	0.0	0	1	0	0.7	0	1	0
Models	0.0	0	0	0	0.4	0	0	0
Composition and constitution	0.1	0	1	0	1.4	0	1	0
Norms	0.1	0	1	0	1.3	0	1	0

1915

Table B.40: Measures of the prominence of each subject in 1915 ’s journals.

Subject	Weight	Raw	W-Ratio	R-Ratio	W-Pages	R-Pages	WP-Ratio	RP-Ratio
Psychology	2.5	3	37	45	64.8	67	53	55
Idealism	11.2	18	167	269	223.6	395	184	325
Life and value	5.3	7	80	104	116.6	161	96	133
Other history	3.4	5	50	75	60.1	97	50	80
Dewey and pragmatism	1.9	2	28	30	24.7	17	20	14
Definitions	1.6	1	23	15	24.0	2	20	2
Propositions and implications	1.1	3	17	45	23.7	93	20	77
Beauty	0.8	1	11	15	20.0	35	17	29
Physicalism	2.5	5	38	75	35.0	51	29	42
History and culture	0.2	0	3	0	2.9	0	2	0
Faith and theism	1.0	1	15	15	19.6	17	16	14
Self-consciousness	1.3	0	20	0	20.5	0	17	0
Ancient	1.4	3	21	45	16.3	41	13	34
Universals and particulars	1.5	1	22	15	17.8	6	15	5
Verification	0.4	0	6	0	6.9	0	6	0
Value	1.2	0	18	0	24.3	0	20	0
Deduction	2.6	5	39	75	21.4	31	18	26
Mechanisms	0.5	0	7	0	9.0	0	7	0
Temporal paradoxes	0.9	0	13	0	16.8	0	14	0
Classical space and time	0.9	1	13	15	13.9	17	11	14
Early modern	0.5	0	8	0	13.5	0	11	0
Meaning and use	0.3	0	5	0	6.9	0	6	0
Marx	0.9	0	13	0	13.4	0	11	0
Ordinary language	4.0	0	60	0	86.1	0	71	0
Moral conscience	0.9	1	13	15	14.3	12	12	10
Methodology of science	1.2	0	18	0	20.0	0	16	0
Heidegger and Husserl	0.0	0	0	0	0.2	0	0	0
Emotions	1.1	1	17	15	46.8	78	39	64
Ontological argument	1.1	1	17	15	10.5	1	9	1
Chemistry	0.3	0	4	0	5.4	0	4	0
Social contract theory	0.7	0	11	0	12.6	0	10	0
Kant	1.2	0	18	0	19.0	0	16	0
Promises and imperatives	0.2	0	4	0	4.7	0	4	0
Analytic/synthetic	0.4	0	6	0	5.2	0	4	0
Freedom and free will	0.1	0	2	0	2.9	0	2	0
Crime and punishment	0.0	0	0	0	0.2	0	0	0
Sets and grue	0.1	0	2	0	2.5	0	2	0
Origins and purposes	0.3	0	5	0	5.2	0	4	0
Time	0.4	0	6	0	6.0	0	5	0
Color/colour	0.4	0	6	0	4.8	0	4	0
War	0.2	1	4	15	4.3	19	4	16
Depiction	0.0	0	1	0	0.7	0	1	0
Denoting	1.0	1	15	15	18.0	4	15	3
Chance	0.0	0	0	0	0.4	0	0	0
Hume	0.4	1	6	15	5.2	9	4	7
Laws	0.3	0	5	0	6.6	0	5	0
Perception	1.0	0	15	0	18.4	0	15	0
Intention	0.1	0	1	0	1.3	0	1	0
Virtues	0.4	1	6	15	2.2	2	2	2
Space and time	0.4	1	6	15	6.4	16	5	13
Mathematics	0.2	0	3	0	2.8	0	2	0
Liberal democracy	0.6	1	9	15	10.7	20	9	16
Duties	0.1	0	1	0	2.0	0	2	0
Causation	0.4	1	7	15	8.6	19	7	16
Arguments	0.7	0	11	0	7.9	0	7	0
Theory testing	0.0	0	1	0	0.9	0	1	0
Decision theory	0.1	0	1	0	1.6	0	1	0
Minds and machines	0.5	1	7	15	4.6	4	4	3
Truth	0.3	0	5	0	5.3	0	4	0
Radical translation	0.0	0	1	0	0.8	0	1	0
Explanation	0.1	0	1	0	1.3	0	1	0
Personal identity	0.3	0	4	0	5.8	0	5	0
Speech acts	0.1	0	1	0	2.9	0	2	0
Sense and reference	0.0	0	1	0	0.3	0	0	0
Egalitarianism	0.1	0	1	0	1.4	0	1	0
Quantum physics	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0
Theories and realism	0.3	0	4	0	4.7	0	4	0
Functions	0.1	0	2	0	2.3	0	2	0
Feminism	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0
Medical ethics and Freud	0.0	0	0	0	0.6	0	0	0
Abortion and self-defence	0.2	0	3	0	1.2	0	1	0
Belief ascriptions	0.0	0	0	0	0.4	0	0	0
Thermodynamics	0.2	0	3	0	4.8	0	4	0
Knowledge	0.8	0	11	0	9.2	0	8	0
Game theory	0.1	0	2	0	1.2	0	1	0
Justification	0.3	0	4	0	5.6	0	5	0
Frankfurt cases	0.0	0	1	0	2.1	0	2	0
Concepts	0.1	0	1	0	2.1	0	2	0
Races and DNA	0.0	0	0	0	0.2	0	0	0
Modality	0.1	0	2	0	1.7	0	1	0
Reasons	0.0	0	1	0	0.5	0	0	0
Evolutionary biology	0.1	0	2	0	2.6	0	2	0
Population ethics	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Formal epistemology	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0
Wide content	0.2	0	2	0	2.1	0	2	0
Vagueness	0.2	0	3	0	2.3	0	2	0
Cognitive science	0.0	0	0	0	0.6	0	0	0
Models	0.0	0	1	0	0.3	0	0	0
Composition and constitution	0.3	0	5	0	5.3	0	4	0
Norms	0.0	0	1	0	1.3	0	1	0

1916

Table B.41: Measures of the prominence of each subject in 1916 ’s journals.

Subject	Weight	Raw	W-Ratio	R-Ratio	W-Pages	R-Pages	WP-Ratio	RP-Ratio
Psychology	2.1	1	28	13	48.9	17	35	12
Idealism	14.1	26	183	338	265.6	483	189	344
Life and value	6.0	5	78	65	108.9	73	78	52
Other history	5.6	6	73	78	81.8	63	58	45
Dewey and pragmatism	1.9	1	24	13	28.9	18	21	13
Definitions	1.1	0	14	0	17.7	0	13	0
Propositions and implications	1.0	0	13	0	16.0	0	11	0
Beauty	0.2	0	3	0	3.2	0	2	0
Physicalism	1.6	2	20	26	24.4	26	17	19
History and culture	0.5	0	7	0	10.5	0	7	0
Faith and theism	2.6	3	33	39	43.9	45	31	32
Self-consciousness	1.2	0	15	0	20.4	0	15	0
Ancient	1.8	5	23	65	55.5	173	40	123
Universals and particulars	1.2	1	15	13	18.5	19	13	14
Verification	0.3	0	3	0	5.1	0	4	0
Value	0.6	0	7	0	12.4	0	9	0
Deduction	2.2	4	29	52	20.6	22	15	16
Mechanisms	0.3	0	4	0	6.0	0	4	0
Temporal paradoxes	2.2	2	28	26	40.8	35	29	25
Classical space and time	1.9	0	25	0	26.7	0	19	0
Early modern	2.0	5	25	65	34.5	92	25	66
Meaning and use	0.4	0	5	0	5.5	0	4	0
Marx	0.8	1	10	13	11.6	8	8	6
Ordinary language	4.6	3	59	39	107.0	90	76	64
Moral conscience	1.0	1	13	13	18.8	16	13	11
Methodology of science	0.8	0	11	0	17.1	0	12	0
Heidegger and Husserl	0.1	0	1	0	2.3	0	2	0
Emotions	0.9	1	12	13	15.6	17	11	12
Ontological argument	0.5	0	6	0	9.9	0	7	0
Chemistry	0.8	1	10	13	11.0	16	8	11
Social contract theory	0.5	0	6	0	9.7	0	7	0
Kant	1.2	1	15	13	25.1	24	18	17
Promises and imperatives	0.4	0	5	0	7.5	0	5	0
Analytic/synthetic	0.1	0	1	0	1.8	0	1	0
Freedom and free will	0.3	0	4	0	6.6	0	5	0
Crime and punishment	0.3	1	3	13	4.4	17	3	12
Sets and grue	0.8	2	10	26	11.6	25	8	18
Origins and purposes	0.2	0	2	0	2.7	0	2	0
Time	0.4	0	5	0	9.9	0	7	0
Color/colour	0.2	0	2	0	4.0	0	3	0
War	0.2	0	3	0	4.4	0	3	0
Depiction	0.1	0	1	0	1.4	0	1	0
Denoting	0.3	0	5	0	9.4	0	7	0
Chance	0.1	0	1	0	1.0	0	1	0
Hume	0.2	0	3	0	3.7	0	3	0
Laws	0.3	0	3	0	4.4	0	3	0
Perception	0.9	0	12	0	21.2	0	15	0
Intention	0.7	1	9	13	10.8	13	8	9
Virtues	0.3	0	4	0	6.0	0	4	0
Space and time	0.4	1	5	13	8.2	26	6	19
Mathematics	0.7	0	9	0	10.2	0	7	0
Liberal democracy	0.8	2	11	26	17.4	53	12	38
Duties	0.2	0	2	0	3.9	0	3	0
Causation	0.3	0	4	0	3.5	0	2	0
Arguments	1.1	0	14	0	16.8	0	12	0
Theory testing	0.1	0	1	0	2.2	0	2	0
Decision theory	0.0	0	1	0	0.6	0	0	0
Minds and machines	0.4	0	5	0	10.3	0	7	0
Truth	0.3	0	4	0	4.7	0	3	0
Radical translation	0.4	0	5	0	2.6	0	2	0
Explanation	0.1	0	2	0	1.7	0	1	0
Personal identity	0.2	0	3	0	4.4	0	3	0
Speech acts	0.1	0	1	0	1.6	0	1	0
Sense and reference	0.1	0	1	0	0.9	0	1	0
Egalitarianism	0.4	0	6	0	12.2	0	9	0
Quantum physics	0.0	0	0	0	0.2	0	0	0
Theories and realism	0.2	0	3	0	3.9	0	3	0
Functions	0.1	0	2	0	2.2	0	2	0
Feminism	0.3	0	4	0	3.5	0	3	0
Medical ethics and Freud	0.4	1	6	13	9.3	32	7	23
Abortion and self-defence	0.2	0	3	0	0.8	0	1	0
Belief ascriptions	0.0	0	0	0	0.3	0	0	0
Thermodynamics	0.4	0	6	0	7.3	0	5	0
Knowledge	0.4	0	6	0	6.9	0	5	0
Game theory	0.0	0	0	0	0.6	0	0	0
Justification	0.2	0	3	0	4.2	0	3	0
Frankfurt cases	0.0	0	0	0	0.2	0	0	0
Concepts	0.3	0	4	0	6.4	0	5	0
Races and DNA	0.1	0	1	0	0.6	0	0	0
Modality	0.0	0	1	0	0.7	0	1	0
Reasons	0.1	0	1	0	1.9	0	1	0
Evolutionary biology	0.2	0	3	0	3.6	0	3	0
Population ethics	0.1	0	1	0	0.6	0	0	0
Formal epistemology	0.0	0	0	0	0.8	0	1	0
Wide content	0.1	0	2	0	2.5	0	2	0
Vagueness	0.3	0	4	0	4.3	0	3	0
Cognitive science	0.0	0	0	0	0.4	0	0	0
Models	0.0	0	0	0	0.3	0	0	0
Composition and constitution	0.3	0	3	0	4.7	0	3	0
Norms	0.0	0	0	0	0.6	0	0	0

1917

Table B.42: Measures of the prominence of each subject in 1917 ’s journals.

Subject	Weight	Raw	W-Ratio	R-Ratio	W-Pages	R-Pages	WP-Ratio	RP-Ratio
Psychology	4.4	8	64	116	102.2	166	81	131
Idealism	12.3	21	178	304	238.4	426	189	337
Life and value	4.1	4	59	58	81.5	76	64	60
Other history	3.7	6	53	87	60.5	117	48	93
Dewey and pragmatism	1.3	0	19	0	24.7	0	20	0
Definitions	1.3	0	18	0	17.4	0	14	0
Propositions and implications	1.6	2	23	29	18.9	33	15	26
Beauty	0.2	0	3	0	3.8	0	3	0
Physicalism	1.6	1	23	14	25.3	5	20	4
History and culture	0.2	0	3	0	4.1	0	3	0
Faith and theism	0.7	1	10	14	15.5	17	12	13
Self-consciousness	1.2	0	18	0	23.8	0	19	0
Ancient	0.7	1	11	14	14.7	14	12	11
Universals and particulars	1.1	1	16	14	14.5	6	11	5
Verification	0.4	0	5	0	6.7	0	5	0
Value	1.2	2	18	29	22.6	43	18	34
Deduction	3.0	6	44	87	28.2	49	22	39
Mechanisms	1.1	1	16	14	16.8	19	13	15
Temporal paradoxes	1.1	1	16	14	19.5	17	15	13
Classical space and time	0.9	1	13	14	13.1	21	10	17
Early modern	1.8	3	26	43	36.7	83	29	66
Meaning and use	0.3	0	4	0	5.3	0	4	0
Marx	0.5	0	7	0	11.3	0	9	0
Ordinary language	4.7	1	69	14	101.1	14	80	11
Moral conscience	1.0	1	15	14	20.8	16	16	13
Methodology of science	2.1	1	30	14	34.6	9	27	7
Heidegger and Husserl	0.3	1	4	14	4.0	15	3	12
Emotions	0.6	0	8	0	10.3	0	8	0
Ontological argument	0.6	0	8	0	12.4	0	10	0
Chemistry	0.8	2	12	29	13.8	30	11	24
Social contract theory	0.4	0	6	0	6.6	0	5	0
Kant	0.6	0	8	0	12.4	0	10	0
Promises and imperatives	0.4	0	5	0	8.3	0	7	0
Analytic/synthetic	0.3	0	4	0	4.2	0	3	0
Freedom and free will	0.2	0	2	0	3.0	0	2	0
Crime and punishment	0.1	0	1	0	1.5	0	1	0
Sets and grue	0.2	0	3	0	3.3	0	3	0
Origins and purposes	0.3	0	5	0	5.9	0	5	0
Time	1.0	1	15	14	20.0	12	16	9
Color/colour	0.2	0	4	0	6.2	0	5	0
War	0.3	1	4	14	11.1	44	9	35
Depiction	0.1	0	1	0	1.7	0	1	0
Denoting	0.3	0	5	0	5.9	0	5	0
Chance	0.1	0	1	0	1.3	0	1	0
Hume	0.4	1	6	14	6.9	18	5	14
Laws	0.4	0	6	0	7.9	0	6	0
Perception	1.0	1	14	14	19.4	14	15	11
Intention	0.1	0	2	0	0.5	0	0	0
Virtues	0.2	0	3	0	4.9	0	4	0
Space and time	0.1	0	1	0	1.1	0	1	0
Mathematics	0.2	0	3	0	3.4	0	3	0
Liberal democracy	0.4	0	6	0	10.2	0	8	0
Duties	0.1	0	2	0	3.3	0	3	0
Causation	0.7	0	10	0	8.7	0	7	0
Arguments	1.0	0	15	0	11.9	0	9	0
Theory testing	0.2	0	3	0	3.6	0	3	0
Decision theory	0.0	0	1	0	1.0	0	1	0
Minds and machines	0.4	0	5	0	6.4	0	5	0
Truth	0.3	0	5	0	5.5	0	4	0
Radical translation	0.0	0	0	0	0.3	0	0	0
Explanation	0.2	0	3	0	2.9	0	2	0
Personal identity	0.2	0	3	0	4.7	0	4	0
Speech acts	0.0	0	1	0	1.0	0	1	0
Sense and reference	0.2	0	3	0	2.1	0	2	0
Egalitarianism	0.1	0	2	0	2.1	0	2	0
Quantum physics	0.1	0	2	0	1.3	0	1	0
Theories and realism	0.2	0	3	0	3.6	0	3	0
Functions	0.2	0	2	0	3.1	0	2	0
Feminism	0.2	0	3	0	1.8	0	1	0
Medical ethics and Freud	0.1	0	2	0	0.7	0	1	0
Abortion and self-defence	0.1	0	1	0	1.1	0	1	0
Belief ascriptions	0.0	0	1	0	0.6	0	0	0
Thermodynamics	0.4	0	5	0	6.4	0	5	0
Knowledge	0.5	0	8	0	9.8	0	8	0
Game theory	0.2	0	3	0	3.6	0	3	0
Justification	0.3	0	5	0	6.8	0	5	0
Frankfurt cases	0.0	0	0	0	0.6	0	0	0
Concepts	0.1	0	2	0	3.2	0	3	0
Races and DNA	0.1	0	1	0	1.0	0	1	0
Modality	0.0	0	0	0	0.2	0	0	0
Reasons	0.2	0	2	0	2.9	0	2	0
Evolutionary biology	0.1	0	2	0	2.4	0	2	0
Population ethics	0.1	0	2	0	0.7	0	1	0
Formal epistemology	0.0	0	0	0	0.2	0	0	0
Wide content	0.2	0	2	0	2.9	0	2	0
Vagueness	0.1	0	2	0	2.6	0	2	0
Cognitive science	0.0	0	0	0	0.6	0	0	0
Models	0.0	0	0	0	0.2	0	0	0
Composition and constitution	0.2	0	3	0	4.1	0	3	0
Norms	0.1	0	2	0	2.2	0	2	0

1918

Table B.43: Measures of the prominence of each subject in 1918 ’s journals.

Subject	Weight	Raw	W-Ratio	R-Ratio	W-Pages	R-Pages	WP-Ratio	RP-Ratio
Psychology	4.7	7	62	91	91.8	155	61	103
Idealism	12.5	16	162	208	311.3	446	207	296
Life and value	6.7	10	86	130	147.4	170	98	113
Other history	2.6	2	33	26	43.8	44	29	29
Dewey and pragmatism	1.2	1	15	13	17.5	9	12	6
Definitions	1.3	0	17	0	23.6	0	16	0
Propositions and implications	1.3	2	17	26	19.6	28	13	19
Beauty	0.8	1	10	13	13.4	22	9	15
Physicalism	2.1	3	27	39	35.1	34	23	23
History and culture	0.3	0	3	0	4.2	0	3	0
Faith and theism	2.2	3	28	39	48.5	78	32	52
Self-consciousness	1.5	1	20	13	35.5	20	24	13
Ancient	0.8	0	11	0	18.6	0	12	0
Universals and particulars	1.8	3	23	39	40.4	47	27	31
Verification	0.4	0	5	0	6.1	0	4	0
Value	1.0	0	13	0	16.2	0	11	0
Deduction	1.6	3	21	39	14.6	23	10	15
Mechanisms	2.0	3	26	39	42.7	40	28	27
Temporal paradoxes	1.4	2	19	26	20.6	12	14	8
Classical space and time	0.7	0	9	0	9.4	0	6	0
Early modern	1.3	2	16	26	26.2	43	17	29
Meaning and use	0.5	0	7	0	9.2	0	6	0
Marx	0.6	0	8	0	13.7	0	9	0
Ordinary language	4.6	2	60	26	102.4	29	68	19
Moral conscience	1.1	1	14	13	17.3	12	11	8
Methodology of science	1.9	1	25	13	35.5	16	24	11
Heidegger and Husserl	0.0	0	1	0	0.6	0	0	0
Emotions	1.0	2	12	26	15.7	26	10	17
Ontological argument	1.1	1	14	13	21.7	22	14	15
Chemistry	1.7	4	22	52	49.4	168	33	111
Social contract theory	0.2	0	3	0	5.1	0	3	0
Kant	1.2	1	15	13	10.9	5	7	3
Promises and imperatives	0.5	0	7	0	10.5	0	7	0
Analytic/synthetic	0.1	0	1	0	1.8	0	1	0
Freedom and free will	0.1	0	1	0	2.8	0	2	0
Crime and punishment	0.2	0	2	0	4.1	0	3	0
Sets and grue	1.1	2	14	26	12.2	23	8	15
Origins and purposes	0.4	0	6	0	7.8	0	5	0
Time	0.4	0	6	0	8.5	0	6	0
Color/colour	0.3	0	4	0	3.8	0	3	0
War	0.2	0	3	0	3.3	0	2	0
Depiction	0.3	0	4	0	3.2	0	2	0
Denoting	0.4	0	5	0	7.8	0	5	0
Chance	0.4	1	5	13	5.7	16	4	11
Hume	0.0	0	1	0	0.6	0	0	0
Laws	0.5	0	6	0	8.6	0	6	0
Perception	1.5	1	19	13	21.4	5	14	3
Intention	0.5	1	6	13	2.5	4	2	3
Virtues	0.1	0	1	0	1.3	0	1	0
Space and time	0.0	0	0	0	0.3	0	0	0
Mathematics	0.4	0	5	0	4.9	0	3	0
Liberal democracy	0.5	1	6	13	6.9	10	5	7
Duties	0.1	0	2	0	3.0	0	2	0
Causation	0.5	0	7	0	7.0	0	5	0
Arguments	0.5	0	7	0	10.4	0	7	0
Theory testing	0.4	0	5	0	8.2	0	5	0
Decision theory	0.1	0	1	0	1.7	0	1	0
Minds and machines	0.5	0	7	0	8.6	0	6	0
Truth	0.8	0	10	0	6.8	0	5	0
Radical translation	0.0	0	0	0	0.4	0	0	0
Explanation	0.2	0	2	0	4.1	0	3	0
Personal identity	0.1	0	1	0	3.9	0	3	0
Speech acts	0.0	0	0	0	0.6	0	0	0
Sense and reference	0.1	0	2	0	1.7	0	1	0
Egalitarianism	0.1	0	1	0	1.4	0	1	0
Quantum physics	0.0	0	0	0	0.3	0	0	0
Theories and realism	0.1	0	1	0	1.5	0	1	0
Functions	0.2	0	3	0	5.2	0	3	0
Feminism	0.1	0	1	0	1.4	0	1	0
Medical ethics and Freud	0.0	0	0	0	0.4	0	0	0
Abortion and self-defence	0.0	0	1	0	0.9	0	1	0
Belief ascriptions	0.1	0	1	0	1.1	0	1	0
Thermodynamics	0.3	0	4	0	5.4	0	4	0
Knowledge	0.5	0	6	0	7.0	0	5	0
Game theory	0.1	0	1	0	0.9	0	1	0
Justification	0.4	0	6	0	4.9	0	3	0
Frankfurt cases	0.1	0	1	0	1.5	0	1	0
Concepts	0.4	0	5	0	7.7	0	5	0
Races and DNA	0.1	0	1	0	2.3	0	2	0
Modality	0.1	0	2	0	1.5	0	1	0
Reasons	0.1	0	2	0	2.8	0	2	0
Evolutionary biology	0.2	0	3	0	3.8	0	3	0
Population ethics	0.0	0	1	0	1.2	0	1	0
Formal epistemology	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0
Wide content	0.3	0	3	0	4.1	0	3	0
Vagueness	0.2	0	3	0	4.3	0	3	0
Cognitive science	0.0	0	0	0	0.3	0	0	0
Models	0.0	0	0	0	0.3	0	0	0
Composition and constitution	0.1	0	1	0	1.7	0	1	0
Norms	0.1	0	1	0	2.8	0	2	0

1919

Table B.44: Measures of the prominence of each subject in 1919 ’s journals.

Subject	Weight	Raw	W-Ratio	R-Ratio	W-Pages	R-Pages	WP-Ratio	RP-Ratio
Psychology	3.6	6	52	86	98.0	224	76	174
Idealism	15.3	31	219	443	261.8	498	203	386
Life and value	5.9	8	85	114	103.0	127	80	98
Other history	1.4	2	21	29	27.7	40	21	31
Dewey and pragmatism	1.2	0	17	0	20.6	0	16	0
Definitions	0.9	0	13	0	19.6	0	15	0
Propositions and implications	0.7	0	10	0	15.2	0	12	0
Beauty	0.7	0	9	0	9.3	0	7	0
Physicalism	2.1	1	30	14	39.9	12	31	9
History and culture	0.2	0	3	0	4.3	0	3	0
Faith and theism	1.5	1	21	14	32.3	20	25	15
Self-consciousness	2.1	0	30	0	34.5	0	27	0
Ancient	1.0	1	15	14	16.1	11	12	9
Universals and particulars	0.6	0	8	0	10.6	0	8	0
Verification	0.2	0	3	0	5.4	0	4	0
Value	0.8	1	12	14	18.3	28	14	22
Deduction	1.4	2	20	29	17.5	27	14	21
Mechanisms	0.7	0	10	0	12.9	0	10	0
Temporal paradoxes	0.9	1	13	14	15.3	2	12	2
Classical space and time	1.3	1	19	14	16.8	4	13	3
Early modern	0.5	0	8	0	9.7	0	8	0
Meaning and use	0.5	0	7	0	13.9	0	11	0
Marx	1.4	2	20	29	23.2	41	18	32
Ordinary language	4.7	4	67	57	108.8	122	84	95
Moral conscience	0.4	0	5	0	5.7	0	4	0
Methodology of science	1.3	1	18	14	27.6	29	21	22
Heidegger and Husserl	0.1	0	2	0	1.3	0	1	0
Emotions	1.4	2	20	29	26.3	29	20	22
Ontological argument	0.7	1	11	14	11.7	9	9	7
Chemistry	1.0	1	14	14	32.0	39	25	30
Social contract theory	0.5	0	7	0	9.1	0	7	0
Kant	0.6	0	8	0	9.6	0	7	0
Promises and imperatives	0.2	0	3	0	4.1	0	3	0
Analytic/synthetic	0.2	0	3	0	3.0	0	2	0
Freedom and free will	0.3	0	4	0	3.5	0	3	0
Crime and punishment	0.0	0	1	0	0.5	0	0	0
Sets and grue	0.9	1	12	14	5.5	3	4	2
Origins and purposes	0.1	0	1	0	2.2	0	2	0
Time	0.3	0	5	0	6.1	0	5	0
Color/colour	0.5	1	7	14	6.8	8	5	6
War	0.2	0	2	0	2.4	0	2	0
Depiction	0.4	0	5	0	6.2	0	5	0
Denoting	0.4	0	5	0	12.8	0	10	0
Chance	0.1	0	1	0	1.0	0	1	0
Hume	0.1	0	1	0	1.1	0	1	0
Laws	0.4	0	6	0	8.9	0	7	0
Perception	1.7	0	24	0	35.1	0	27	0
Intention	0.1	0	1	0	1.0	0	1	0
Virtues	0.3	0	4	0	2.2	0	2	0
Space and time	0.3	0	4	0	3.6	0	3	0
Mathematics	0.4	0	6	0	4.2	0	3	0
Liberal democracy	1.3	2	19	29	17.5	18	14	14
Duties	0.0	0	0	0	0.3	0	0	0
Causation	0.3	0	4	0	3.8	0	3	0
Arguments	0.7	0	9	0	11.8	0	9	0
Theory testing	0.2	0	2	0	1.3	0	1	0
Decision theory	0.0	0	1	0	1.0	0	1	0
Minds and machines	0.4	0	6	0	6.1	0	5	0
Truth	0.6	0	9	0	5.5	0	4	0
Radical translation	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Explanation	0.1	0	2	0	4.2	0	3	0
Personal identity	0.1	0	2	0	2.2	0	2	0
Speech acts	0.1	0	1	0	1.4	0	1	0
Sense and reference	0.2	0	2	0	2.3	0	2	0
Egalitarianism	0.1	0	1	0	1.0	0	1	0
Quantum physics	0.0	0	0	0	1.1	0	1	0
Theories and realism	0.4	0	6	0	5.5	0	4	0
Functions	0.3	0	4	0	5.5	0	4	0
Feminism	0.0	0	1	0	1.1	0	1	0
Medical ethics and Freud	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Abortion and self-defence	0.0	0	0	0	0.3	0	0	0
Belief ascriptions	0.0	0	0	0	0.6	0	1	0
Thermodynamics	0.3	0	5	0	5.9	0	5	0
Knowledge	0.6	0	8	0	13.1	0	10	0
Game theory	0.0	0	0	0	0.5	0	0	0
Justification	0.2	0	4	0	5.3	0	4	0
Frankfurt cases	0.1	0	2	0	0.5	0	0	0
Concepts	0.2	0	3	0	5.6	0	4	0
Races and DNA	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Modality	0.0	0	0	0	0.5	0	0	0
Reasons	0.2	0	3	0	2.1	0	2	0
Evolutionary biology	0.2	0	3	0	3.6	0	3	0
Population ethics	0.0	0	1	0	0.8	0	1	0
Formal epistemology	0.1	0	1	0	0.9	0	1	0
Wide content	0.2	0	3	0	3.1	0	2	0
Vagueness	0.2	0	2	0	2.2	0	2	0
Cognitive science	0.0	0	1	0	1.3	0	1	0
Models	0.1	0	1	0	2.0	0	2	0
Composition and constitution	0.2	0	2	0	2.6	0	2	0
Norms	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0

1920

Table B.45: Measures of the prominence of each subject in 1920 ’s journals.

Subject	Weight	Raw	W-Ratio	R-Ratio	W-Pages	R-Pages	WP-Ratio	RP-Ratio
Psychology	3.6	5	55	77	63.2	98	61	94
Idealism	12.3	24	190	369	189.5	408	182	392
Life and value	6.4	6	99	92	107.4	108	103	104
Other history	2.1	3	33	46	34.1	37	33	36
Dewey and pragmatism	0.9	1	14	15	14.5	9	14	9
Definitions	1.1	1	17	15	20.0	13	19	12
Propositions and implications	1.0	2	16	31	14.7	28	14	27
Beauty	2.0	4	30	62	24.6	44	24	42
Physicalism	2.2	2	33	31	31.3	28	30	27
History and culture	0.6	0	9	0	7.1	0	7	0
Faith and theism	2.2	3	34	46	40.5	54	39	52
Self-consciousness	1.5	0	23	0	22.7	0	22	0
Ancient	1.0	1	16	15	15.0	19	14	18
Universals and particulars	0.7	0	10	0	17.3	0	17	0
Verification	0.2	0	3	0	5.3	0	5	0
Value	0.6	0	10	0	11.9	0	11	0
Deduction	0.5	0	8	0	5.4	0	5	0
Mechanisms	0.5	0	7	0	7.0	0	7	0
Temporal paradoxes	0.9	1	15	15	9.7	1	9	1
Classical space and time	0.5	0	8	0	10.1	0	10	0
Early modern	1.1	1	17	15	26.9	29	26	28
Meaning and use	0.5	0	7	0	7.3	0	7	0
Marx	1.4	1	21	15	20.7	13	20	12
Ordinary language	3.4	2	53	31	66.9	40	64	38
Moral conscience	0.7	1	11	15	11.5	12	11	12
Methodology of science	0.9	0	14	0	14.3	0	14	0
Heidegger and Husserl	0.0	0	1	0	1.1	0	1	0
Emotions	1.0	1	15	15	13.0	10	12	10
Ontological argument	0.9	1	14	15	14.5	7	14	7
Chemistry	0.8	1	13	15	11.2	14	11	13
Social contract theory	0.7	1	11	15	10.3	18	10	17
Kant	0.7	0	11	0	8.8	0	8	0
Promises and imperatives	0.5	0	7	0	7.4	0	7	0
Analytic/synthetic	0.1	0	1	0	1.8	0	2	0
Freedom and free will	0.1	0	1	0	1.0	0	1	0
Crime and punishment	0.2	0	2	0	2.0	0	2	0
Sets and grue	0.1	0	1	0	1.6	0	2	0
Origins and purposes	0.2	0	3	0	2.0	0	2	0
Time	0.7	1	11	15	8.0	16	8	15
Color/colour	0.3	0	4	0	4.7	0	4	0
War	0.3	0	4	0	6.4	0	6	0
Depiction	0.4	0	5	0	7.5	0	7	0
Denoting	0.2	0	3	0	4.7	0	5	0
Chance	0.1	0	1	0	2.4	0	2	0
Hume	0.1	0	2	0	2.0	0	2	0
Laws	0.4	0	6	0	7.3	0	7	0
Perception	0.8	0	13	0	8.9	0	9	0
Intention	0.4	0	7	0	5.4	0	5	0
Virtues	0.1	0	2	0	1.9	0	2	0
Space and time	0.4	1	6	15	11.2	31	11	30
Mathematics	0.3	0	4	0	4.3	0	4	0
Liberal democracy	1.1	1	18	15	16.0	5	15	5
Duties	0.1	0	2	0	2.2	0	2	0
Causation	0.0	0	1	0	1.2	0	1	0
Arguments	0.2	0	3	0	5.6	0	5	0
Theory testing	0.1	0	2	0	2.6	0	3	0
Decision theory	0.0	0	1	0	0.7	0	1	0
Minds and machines	0.2	0	4	0	3.3	0	3	0
Truth	0.3	0	5	0	4.4	0	4	0
Radical translation	0.0	0	0	0	0.2	0	0	0
Explanation	0.1	0	2	0	1.4	0	1	0
Personal identity	0.1	0	1	0	0.9	0	1	0
Speech acts	0.1	0	1	0	1.0	0	1	0
Sense and reference	0.0	0	1	0	0.5	0	0	0
Egalitarianism	0.0	0	0	0	0.4	0	0	0
Quantum physics	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0
Theories and realism	0.5	0	7	0	5.7	0	5	0
Functions	0.1	0	1	0	1.6	0	2	0
Feminism	0.1	0	1	0	1.0	0	1	0
Medical ethics and Freud	0.1	0	1	0	1.1	0	1	0
Abortion and self-defence	0.1	0	1	0	1.5	0	1	0
Belief ascriptions	0.0	0	0	0	0.3	0	0	0
Thermodynamics	0.3	0	4	0	3.4	0	3	0
Knowledge	0.6	0	9	0	5.1	0	5	0
Game theory	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0
Justification	0.1	0	2	0	2.7	0	3	0
Frankfurt cases	0.1	0	1	0	0.6	0	1	0
Concepts	0.5	0	8	0	7.4	0	7	0
Races and DNA	0.0	0	0	0	0.7	0	1	0
Modality	0.1	0	1	0	1.1	0	1	0
Reasons	0.1	0	1	0	1.1	0	1	0
Evolutionary biology	0.2	0	3	0	2.4	0	2	0
Population ethics	0.0	0	1	0	0.3	0	0	0
Formal epistemology	0.0	0	0	0	0.0	0	0	0
Wide content	0.2	0	3	0	3.7	0	4	0
Vagueness	0.3	0	5	0	3.2	0	3	0
Cognitive science	0.1	0	1	0	1.5	0	1	0
Models	0.0	0	1	0	0.5	0	0	0
Composition and constitution	0.4	0	5	0	8.2	0	8	0
Norms	0.0	0	0	0	0.3	0	0	0

1921

Table B.46: Measures of the prominence of each subject in 1921 ’s journals.

Subject	Weight	Raw	W-Ratio	R-Ratio	W-Pages	R-Pages	WP-Ratio	RP-Ratio
Psychology	6.6	10	60	90	94.9	159	71	118
Idealism	13.3	18	120	162	186.4	256	139	191
Life and value	11.0	13	99	117	142.9	184	106	137
Other history	6.5	8	58	72	61.7	79	46	59
Dewey and pragmatism	1.9	1	17	9	21.0	5	16	4
Definitions	2.2	1	20	9	23.5	6	17	4
Propositions and implications	1.6	2	14	18	11.6	9	9	7
Beauty	1.6	3	14	27	20.4	42	15	31
Physicalism	4.2	5	38	45	41.1	28	31	21
History and culture	1.2	1	10	9	11.9	19	9	14
Faith and theism	2.0	3	18	27	20.5	24	15	18
Self-consciousness	1.2	0	11	0	14.0	0	10	0
Ancient	2.1	3	19	27	23.3	41	17	31
Universals and particulars	0.7	0	6	0	10.7	0	8	0
Verification	0.5	0	4	0	7.5	0	6	0
Value	2.5	2	22	18	31.4	34	23	25
Deduction	2.0	3	18	27	20.5	28	15	21
Mechanisms	3.5	6	32	54	47.1	70	35	52
Temporal paradoxes	1.6	2	14	18	22.0	27	16	20
Classical space and time	1.0	0	9	0	14.1	0	10	0
Early modern	0.4	0	3	0	3.6	0	3	0
Meaning and use	0.9	2	8	18	12.3	25	9	19
Marx	1.4	2	12	18	15.3	17	11	13
Ordinary language	5.1	3	46	27	81.9	74	61	55
Moral conscience	1.1	1	10	9	17.8	21	13	16
Methodology of science	3.3	4	30	36	36.5	55	27	41
Heidegger and Husserl	0.2	0	2	0	3.4	0	3	0
Emotions	1.8	1	16	9	20.5	12	15	9
Ontological argument	0.9	0	8	0	11.2	0	8	0
Chemistry	2.3	5	21	45	25.6	34	19	25
Social contract theory	0.6	0	5	0	9.0	0	7	0
Kant	0.1	0	1	0	1.8	0	1	0
Promises and imperatives	0.9	0	8	0	17.0	0	13	0
Analytic/synthetic	0.2	0	2	0	2.5	0	2	0
Freedom and free will	0.1	0	1	0	1.8	0	1	0
Crime and punishment	0.1	0	1	0	0.9	0	1	0
Sets and grue	0.3	0	3	0	4.5	0	3	0
Origins and purposes	0.7	0	6	0	6.1	0	5	0
Time	0.8	1	7	9	10.4	10	8	7
Color/colour	0.5	0	5	0	6.9	0	5	0
War	0.3	0	3	0	4.1	0	3	0
Depiction	0.7	0	6	0	6.4	0	5	0
Denoting	0.4	0	3	0	4.0	0	3	0
Chance	0.4	0	4	0	4.9	0	4	0
Hume	0.4	1	4	9	7.2	17	5	13
Laws	1.2	0	10	0	11.6	0	9	0
Perception	2.5	1	22	9	26.8	2	20	1
Intention	0.9	1	8	9	2.6	2	2	1
Virtues	0.1	0	1	0	1.5	0	1	0
Space and time	1.6	3	14	27	14.0	25	10	19
Mathematics	0.4	0	4	0	4.1	0	3	0
Liberal democracy	0.8	1	7	9	11.9	20	9	15
Duties	0.0	0	0	0	0.2	0	0	0
Causation	0.3	0	3	0	4.5	0	3	0
Arguments	1.0	1	9	9	8.1	3	6	2
Theory testing	0.9	1	8	9	7.4	6	6	4
Decision theory	0.1	0	1	0	1.2	0	1	0
Minds and machines	0.3	0	3	0	3.6	0	3	0
Truth	0.3	0	3	0	3.7	0	3	0
Radical translation	0.2	0	2	0	1.1	0	1	0
Explanation	0.2	0	2	0	2.1	0	2	0
Personal identity	0.2	0	2	0	1.6	0	1	0
Speech acts	0.1	0	1	0	1.2	0	1	0
Sense and reference	0.1	0	1	0	1.4	0	1	0
Egalitarianism	0.2	0	1	0	1.8	0	1	0
Quantum physics	0.2	0	1	0	2.2	0	2	0
Theories and realism	0.9	0	8	0	8.8	0	7	0
Functions	0.2	0	2	0	3.1	0	2	0
Feminism	0.3	0	2	0	3.5	0	3	0
Medical ethics and Freud	0.1	0	1	0	1.3	0	1	0
Abortion and self-defence	0.4	0	3	0	2.1	0	2	0
Belief ascriptions	0.0	0	0	0	0.4	0	0	0
Thermodynamics	0.7	0	6	0	9.7	0	7	0
Knowledge	0.9	0	8	0	7.5	0	6	0
Game theory	0.4	0	3	0	2.1	0	2	0
Justification	0.6	0	6	0	8.7	0	6	0
Frankfurt cases	0.0	0	0	0	0.3	0	0	0
Concepts	0.5	0	5	0	3.1	0	2	0
Races and DNA	0.2	0	2	0	1.8	0	1	0
Modality	0.4	1	4	9	2.3	3	2	2
Reasons	0.5	0	4	0	6.9	0	5	0
Evolutionary biology	1.0	1	9	9	10.2	6	8	4
Population ethics	0.0	0	0	0	0.2	0	0	0
Formal epistemology	0.2	0	1	0	1.4	0	1	0
Wide content	0.2	0	2	0	2.5	0	2	0
Vagueness	0.3	0	2	0	3.6	0	3	0
Cognitive science	0.2	0	1	0	3.6	0	3	0
Models	0.2	0	2	0	1.3	0	1	0
Composition and constitution	0.3	0	3	0	4.4	0	3	0
Norms	0.0	0	0	0	0.8	0	1	0

1922

Table B.47: Measures of the prominence of each subject in 1922 ’s journals.

Subject	Weight	Raw	W-Ratio	R-Ratio	W-Pages	R-Pages	WP-Ratio	RP-Ratio
Psychology	7.0	11	49	78	96.1	141	61	89
Idealism	20.5	39	145	277	269.6	514	170	325
Life and value	9.6	11	68	78	93.2	96	59	61
Other history	3.3	3	24	21	47.0	35	30	22
Dewey and pragmatism	4.4	4	31	28	53.1	54	34	34
Definitions	3.3	0	24	0	33.0	0	21	0
Propositions and implications	2.7	4	19	28	18.2	25	11	16
Beauty	2.8	6	20	43	31.2	76	20	48
Physicalism	7.5	15	53	106	74.8	160	47	101
History and culture	1.3	1	9	7	15.4	10	10	6
Faith and theism	1.4	1	10	7	15.2	10	10	6
Self-consciousness	4.2	4	30	28	39.1	23	25	15
Ancient	2.2	4	16	28	23.6	38	15	24
Universals and particulars	1.2	0	9	0	14.1	0	9	0
Verification	0.6	0	4	0	8.8	0	6	0
Value	2.2	1	15	7	29.6	13	19	8
Deduction	2.0	1	14	7	19.4	8	12	5
Mechanisms	5.5	7	39	50	46.6	65	29	41
Temporal paradoxes	2.4	0	17	0	22.8	0	14	0
Classical space and time	3.7	6	26	43	53.7	90	34	57
Early modern	0.8	0	6	0	9.5	0	6	0
Meaning and use	1.2	0	8	0	11.1	0	7	0
Marx	0.5	0	4	0	7.7	0	5	0
Ordinary language	5.9	4	42	28	87.3	73	55	46
Moral conscience	0.7	0	5	0	7.7	0	5	0
Methodology of science	4.0	1	28	7	43.4	8	27	5
Heidegger and Husserl	0.1	0	1	0	0.8	0	1	0
Emotions	1.2	0	9	0	12.5	0	8	0
Ontological argument	1.7	0	12	0	20.0	0	13	0
Chemistry	0.9	0	6	0	12.4	0	8	0
Social contract theory	0.4	0	3	0	4.9	0	3	0
Kant	1.0	1	7	7	13.6	17	9	11
Promises and imperatives	0.9	0	6	0	11.7	0	7	0
Analytic/synthetic	0.6	0	4	0	5.5	0	4	0
Freedom and free will	0.1	0	0	0	0.4	0	0	0
Crime and punishment	0.1	0	1	0	1.6	0	1	0
Sets and grue	0.6	0	4	0	7.4	0	5	0
Origins and purposes	0.8	0	6	0	7.3	0	5	0
Time	1.9	2	14	14	20.7	14	13	9
Color/colour	0.7	0	5	0	9.0	0	6	0
War	0.1	0	1	0	1.5	0	1	0
Depiction	0.9	1	6	7	11.6	14	7	9
Denoting	0.7	0	5	0	9.4	0	6	0
Chance	0.7	1	5	7	12.1	27	8	17
Hume	0.6	0	4	0	5.4	0	3	0
Laws	0.6	0	4	0	8.2	0	5	0
Perception	4.1	2	29	14	44.8	12	28	8
Intention	0.2	0	2	0	3.0	0	2	0
Virtues	0.3	0	2	0	2.0	0	1	0
Space and time	3.7	6	26	43	28.5	40	18	25
Mathematics	0.6	0	5	0	6.2	0	4	0
Liberal democracy	0.3	0	2	0	3.0	0	2	0
Duties	0.2	0	1	0	2.9	0	2	0
Causation	0.7	0	5	0	8.4	0	5	0
Arguments	1.0	0	7	0	9.1	0	6	0
Theory testing	1.3	1	9	7	12.0	6	8	4
Decision theory	0.2	0	1	0	2.3	0	1	0
Minds and machines	0.5	0	4	0	4.6	0	3	0
Truth	1.1	0	8	0	10.7	0	7	0
Radical translation	0.1	0	1	0	0.5	0	0	0
Explanation	0.2	0	1	0	2.1	0	1	0
Personal identity	0.7	0	5	0	6.4	0	4	0
Speech acts	0.3	0	2	0	2.6	0	2	0
Sense and reference	0.2	0	2	0	1.5	0	1	0
Egalitarianism	0.3	0	2	0	2.1	0	1	0
Quantum physics	0.0	0	0	0	0.3	0	0	0
Theories and realism	1.2	1	9	7	8.5	3	5	2
Functions	0.3	0	2	0	3.4	0	2	0
Feminism	1.1	1	8	7	8.9	5	6	3
Medical ethics and Freud	0.2	0	1	0	1.9	0	1	0
Abortion and self-defence	0.1	0	1	0	0.5	0	0	0
Belief ascriptions	0.2	0	1	0	1.6	0	1	0
Thermodynamics	0.5	0	4	0	5.8	0	4	0
Knowledge	1.5	0	10	0	14.5	0	9	0
Game theory	0.2	0	1	0	1.0	0	1	0
Justification	0.3	0	2	0	2.9	0	2	0
Frankfurt cases	0.3	1	2	7	1.6	2	1	1
Concepts	0.5	0	4	0	6.0	0	4	0
Races and DNA	0.0	0	0	0	0.4	0	0	0
Modality	0.7	1	5	7	3.9	4	2	3
Reasons	0.2	0	2	0	2.2	0	1	0
Evolutionary biology	0.3	0	2	0	2.3	0	1	0
Population ethics	0.0	0	0	0	0.3	0	0	0
Formal epistemology	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0
Wide content	0.4	0	3	0	3.5	0	2	0
Vagueness	0.7	0	5	0	7.1	0	4	0
Cognitive science	0.2	0	1	0	2.0	0	1	0
Models	0.1	0	0	0	0.8	0	1	0
Composition and constitution	0.3	0	2	0	2.8	0	2	0
Norms	0.3	0	2	0	1.1	0	1	0

1923

Table B.48: Measures of the prominence of each subject in 1923 ’s journals.

Subject	Weight	Raw	W-Ratio	R-Ratio	W-Pages	R-Pages	WP-Ratio	RP-Ratio
Psychology	4.7	6	35	45	55.5	74	33	44
Idealism	22.3	41	166	306	294.9	562	174	331
Life and value	11.1	14	83	104	172.2	233	101	137
Other history	5.4	5	40	37	58.0	63	34	37
Dewey and pragmatism	3.4	2	25	15	33.5	16	20	9
Definitions	3.3	2	24	15	35.2	16	21	9
Propositions and implications	2.4	4	18	30	23.1	46	14	27
Beauty	2.9	6	22	45	23.8	43	14	25
Physicalism	5.6	5	42	37	64.1	53	38	31
History and culture	2.5	2	19	15	32.6	19	19	11
Faith and theism	2.9	3	22	22	44.0	41	26	24
Self-consciousness	3.6	4	26	30	47.4	44	28	26
Ancient	1.0	1	7	7	11.0	9	6	5
Universals and particulars	1.9	3	14	22	34.0	53	20	31
Verification	0.3	0	2	0	3.8	0	2	0
Value	2.5	1	19	7	25.3	6	15	4
Deduction	2.8	2	21	15	19.2	3	11	2
Mechanisms	4.3	7	32	52	47.4	71	28	42
Temporal paradoxes	2.3	2	17	15	33.7	34	20	20
Classical space and time	1.5	1	11	7	18.1	12	11	7
Early modern	3.5	5	26	37	51.5	75	30	44
Meaning and use	0.8	0	6	0	11.5	0	7	0
Marx	2.2	0	16	0	31.7	0	19	0
Ordinary language	6.1	5	46	37	90.8	78	53	46
Moral conscience	1.6	2	12	15	20.9	25	12	15
Methodology of science	3.3	2	25	15	41.8	29	25	17
Heidegger and Husserl	0.3	0	2	0	2.6	0	2	0
Emotions	1.2	1	9	7	19.5	17	11	10
Ontological argument	1.5	0	11	0	22.6	0	13	0
Chemistry	1.8	3	14	22	26.3	38	15	22
Social contract theory	0.2	0	2	0	3.1	0	2	0
Kant	1.0	0	7	0	14.4	0	8	0
Promises and imperatives	0.7	0	5	0	9.1	0	5	0
Analytic/synthetic	0.5	0	4	0	4.8	0	3	0
Freedom and free will	0.3	0	2	0	5.2	0	3	0
Crime and punishment	0.4	1	3	7	4.6	12	3	7
Sets and grue	0.4	0	3	0	4.3	0	3	0
Origins and purposes	0.8	0	6	0	10.0	0	6	0
Time	1.3	2	9	15	14.3	10	8	6
Color/colour	1.2	0	9	0	16.8	0	10	0
War	0.1	0	1	0	1.2	0	1	0
Depiction	0.7	0	6	0	6.8	0	4	0
Denoting	0.4	0	3	0	3.5	0	2	0
Chance	0.5	0	4	0	7.0	0	4	0
Hume	0.4	0	3	0	6.2	0	4	0
Laws	1.2	0	9	0	12.9	0	8	0
Perception	2.1	1	16	7	29.1	11	17	6
Intention	0.1	0	1	0	2.0	0	1	0
Virtues	0.2	0	1	0	2.1	0	1	0
Space and time	0.8	0	6	0	10.1	0	6	0
Mathematics	0.3	0	2	0	4.7	0	3	0
Liberal democracy	0.4	0	3	0	6.2	0	4	0
Duties	0.1	0	1	0	1.9	0	1	0
Causation	0.5	0	4	0	5.0	0	3	0
Arguments	0.6	0	5	0	9.3	0	5	0
Theory testing	0.3	0	2	0	4.4	0	3	0
Decision theory	0.3	0	2	0	3.3	0	2	0
Minds and machines	0.3	0	2	0	3.9	0	2	0
Truth	0.6	0	4	0	4.4	0	3	0
Radical translation	0.0	0	0	0	0.3	0	0	0
Explanation	0.1	0	1	0	1.3	0	1	0
Personal identity	0.5	0	4	0	5.5	0	3	0
Speech acts	0.1	0	1	0	0.8	0	0	0
Sense and reference	0.1	0	0	0	0.4	0	0	0
Egalitarianism	0.2	0	1	0	1.9	0	1	0
Quantum physics	0.0	0	0	0	0.3	0	0	0
Theories and realism	0.7	0	5	0	7.3	0	4	0
Functions	0.5	0	4	0	4.0	0	2	0
Feminism	0.2	0	1	0	2.3	0	1	0
Medical ethics and Freud	0.1	0	1	0	0.8	0	0	0
Abortion and self-defence	0.1	0	1	0	0.8	0	0	0
Belief ascriptions	0.1	0	1	0	0.8	0	0	0
Thermodynamics	0.6	0	4	0	6.4	0	4	0
Knowledge	1.1	1	8	7	10.4	5	6	3
Game theory	0.1	0	1	0	1.0	0	1	0
Justification	0.3	0	2	0	4.6	0	3	0
Frankfurt cases	0.2	0	1	0	1.9	0	1	0
Concepts	0.6	0	5	0	6.9	0	4	0
Races and DNA	0.1	0	0	0	0.9	0	1	0
Modality	0.3	0	2	0	3.6	0	2	0
Reasons	0.5	0	4	0	7.1	0	4	0
Evolutionary biology	0.4	0	3	0	4.6	0	3	0
Population ethics	0.1	0	0	0	0.8	0	0	0
Formal epistemology	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0
Wide content	0.7	0	5	0	6.6	0	4	0
Vagueness	0.4	0	3	0	3.8	0	2	0
Cognitive science	0.1	0	0	0	0.5	0	0	0
Models	0.1	0	0	0	0.3	0	0	0
Composition and constitution	0.2	0	2	0	2.4	0	1	0
Norms	0.2	0	1	0	2.7	0	2	0

1924

Table B.49: Measures of the prominence of each subject in 1924 ’s journals.

Subject	Weight	Raw	W-Ratio	R-Ratio	W-Pages	R-Pages	WP-Ratio	RP-Ratio
Psychology	4.1	5	36	43	61.5	81	39	51
Idealism	17.8	35	155	304	278.6	576	175	363
Life and value	9.3	12	81	104	125.3	146	79	92
Other history	4.6	3	40	26	61.5	45	39	28
Dewey and pragmatism	1.9	0	17	0	24.3	0	15	0
Definitions	2.7	1	24	9	29.4	1	19	1
Propositions and implications	1.3	1	11	9	11.5	3	7	2
Beauty	1.9	3	16	26	25.9	49	16	31
Physicalism	4.7	4	41	35	60.3	51	38	32
History and culture	1.5	2	13	17	16.0	20	10	13
Faith and theism	3.7	6	32	52	50.0	71	31	45
Self-consciousness	1.3	1	11	9	15.1	6	10	4
Ancient	1.5	1	13	9	16.4	5	10	3
Universals and particulars	1.5	1	13	9	22.5	2	14	1
Verification	0.6	0	5	0	7.9	0	5	0
Value	1.5	0	13	0	21.5	0	14	0
Deduction	1.0	2	9	17	14.8	30	9	19
Mechanisms	2.3	2	20	17	34.5	30	22	19
Temporal paradoxes	1.7	2	15	17	29.9	37	19	23
Classical space and time	1.6	0	14	0	25.3	0	16	0
Early modern	2.4	3	21	26	32.1	25	20	16
Meaning and use	1.2	1	11	9	14.3	4	9	3
Marx	1.8	3	15	26	20.6	32	13	20
Ordinary language	6.4	7	56	61	107.8	113	68	71
Moral conscience	0.7	0	6	0	9.9	0	6	0
Methodology of science	2.2	0	19	0	31.5	0	20	0
Heidegger and Husserl	0.3	0	3	0	7.1	0	4	0
Emotions	1.2	1	11	9	12.3	8	8	5
Ontological argument	2.1	2	19	17	25.3	16	16	10
Chemistry	1.8	3	15	26	30.8	60	19	38
Social contract theory	0.8	1	7	9	12.8	20	8	13
Kant	1.5	2	13	17	18.7	16	12	10
Promises and imperatives	0.5	0	4	0	7.7	0	5	0
Analytic/synthetic	0.3	0	2	0	4.6	0	3	0
Freedom and free will	0.3	0	3	0	3.3	0	2	0
Crime and punishment	0.2	0	1	0	2.0	0	1	0
Sets and grue	0.4	0	3	0	7.0	0	4	0
Origins and purposes	1.4	1	12	9	10.9	1	7	1
Time	0.9	1	8	9	11.1	13	7	8
Color/colour	0.8	0	7	0	14.6	0	9	0
War	0.1	0	1	0	1.1	0	1	0
Depiction	0.3	0	3	0	3.5	0	2	0
Denoting	0.2	0	2	0	2.9	0	2	0
Chance	0.5	1	5	9	4.4	4	3	3
Hume	0.3	0	3	0	3.2	0	2	0
Laws	1.1	1	10	9	15.0	36	9	23
Perception	3.0	3	26	26	37.0	23	23	14
Intention	0.6	0	5	0	4.3	0	3	0
Virtues	0.2	0	1	0	1.3	0	1	0
Space and time	1.1	1	9	9	22.7	28	14	18
Mathematics	0.9	0	8	0	9.1	0	6	0
Liberal democracy	0.6	0	5	0	8.1	0	5	0
Duties	0.1	0	1	0	0.8	0	1	0
Causation	0.4	1	3	9	6.8	16	4	10
Arguments	0.6	0	6	0	7.3	0	5	0
Theory testing	0.4	0	4	0	5.4	0	3	0
Decision theory	0.2	0	2	0	2.3	0	1	0
Minds and machines	0.5	0	4	0	6.3	0	4	0
Truth	0.4	0	3	0	5.7	0	4	0
Radical translation	0.0	0	0	0	0.4	0	0	0
Explanation	0.5	0	5	0	4.9	0	3	0
Personal identity	0.7	0	6	0	6.9	0	4	0
Speech acts	0.5	0	4	0	5.9	0	4	0
Sense and reference	0.2	0	1	0	1.0	0	1	0
Egalitarianism	0.1	0	1	0	1.9	0	1	0
Quantum physics	0.4	0	3	0	5.9	0	4	0
Theories and realism	0.8	0	7	0	8.9	0	6	0
Functions	0.4	0	3	0	4.1	0	3	0
Feminism	0.1	0	1	0	2.4	0	1	0
Medical ethics and Freud	0.0	0	0	0	0.6	0	0	0
Abortion and self-defence	0.0	0	0	0	0.2	0	0	0
Belief ascriptions	0.0	0	0	0	0.3	0	0	0
Thermodynamics	0.4	0	4	0	5.4	0	3	0
Knowledge	1.5	1	13	9	14.5	4	9	3
Game theory	0.1	0	1	0	0.4	0	0	0
Justification	0.5	0	4	0	8.6	0	5	0
Frankfurt cases	0.0	0	0	0	0.2	0	0	0
Concepts	0.8	0	7	0	15.2	0	10	0
Races and DNA	0.2	0	2	0	6.0	0	4	0
Modality	0.2	0	1	0	2.1	0	1	0
Reasons	0.2	0	2	0	1.9	0	1	0
Evolutionary biology	0.7	1	6	9	9.8	16	6	10
Population ethics	0.0	0	0	0	0.2	0	0	0
Formal epistemology	0.0	0	0	0	0.4	0	0	0
Wide content	0.2	0	2	0	2.5	0	2	0
Vagueness	0.5	0	4	0	6.5	0	4	0
Cognitive science	0.1	0	1	0	0.8	0	1	0
Models	0.0	0	0	0	0.4	0	0	0
Composition and constitution	0.4	0	3	0	4.9	0	3	0
Norms	0.1	0	1	0	0.9	0	1	0

1925

Table B.50: Measures of the prominence of each subject in 1925 ’s journals.

Subject	Weight	Raw	W-Ratio	R-Ratio	W-Pages	R-Pages	WP-Ratio	RP-Ratio
Psychology	3.7	3	31	25	69.4	64	39	36
Idealism	21.8	37	184	311	358.0	613	202	345
Life and value	8.0	7	67	59	122.4	109	69	61
Other history	6.9	6	58	50	98.7	80	56	45
Dewey and pragmatism	2.9	1	24	8	35.8	5	20	3
Definitions	2.8	1	23	8	39.3	19	22	11
Propositions and implications	0.7	0	6	0	9.5	0	5	0
Beauty	3.2	6	27	50	53.0	105	30	59
Physicalism	2.5	3	21	25	32.4	29	18	16
History and culture	1.6	2	14	17	27.8	31	16	17
Faith and theism	1.4	0	11	0	22.9	0	13	0
Self-consciousness	1.9	0	16	0	24.0	0	14	0
Ancient	3.1	4	26	34	48.8	58	28	33
Universals and particulars	2.4	4	20	34	33.1	58	19	33
Verification	0.5	0	5	0	8.7	0	5	0
Value	2.5	4	21	34	32.9	51	19	29
Deduction	1.0	1	8	8	11.8	10	7	6
Mechanisms	3.4	7	28	59	36.3	67	20	38
Temporal paradoxes	2.3	1	19	8	29.5	5	17	3
Classical space and time	0.6	0	5	0	9.6	0	5	0
Early modern	1.2	1	10	8	21.7	19	12	11
Meaning and use	1.0	1	9	8	16.1	12	9	7
Marx	1.7	2	15	17	28.8	35	16	20
Ordinary language	7.4	7	62	59	118.1	99	67	56
Moral conscience	1.9	2	16	17	19.0	17	11	10
Methodology of science	3.5	3	29	25	48.7	29	27	16
Heidegger and Husserl	0.9	1	7	8	15.4	23	9	13
Emotions	0.5	0	4	0	7.8	0	4	0
Ontological argument	1.5	1	13	8	18.4	10	10	6
Chemistry	1.9	3	16	25	42.0	84	24	47
Social contract theory	1.1	1	9	8	16.4	19	9	11
Kant	0.9	0	7	0	11.8	0	7	0
Promises and imperatives	1.0	0	8	0	10.9	0	6	0
Analytic/synthetic	0.5	0	4	0	6.6	0	4	0
Freedom and free will	0.4	0	3	0	5.6	0	3	0
Crime and punishment	0.5	1	4	8	7.7	16	4	9
Sets and grue	0.4	0	3	0	4.6	0	3	0
Origins and purposes	0.8	0	7	0	8.6	0	5	0
Time	1.2	1	10	8	17.7	18	10	10
Color/colour	1.1	1	9	8	13.3	16	8	9
War	0.1	0	1	0	1.5	0	1	0
Depiction	0.3	0	3	0	6.1	0	3	0
Denoting	0.3	0	3	0	4.4	0	3	0
Chance	0.2	0	2	0	2.8	0	2	0
Hume	0.3	0	3	0	4.1	0	2	0
Laws	0.8	0	7	0	11.4	0	6	0
Perception	1.8	2	15	17	26.1	13	15	7
Intention	0.1	0	1	0	0.9	0	1	0
Virtues	0.4	0	3	0	4.4	0	2	0
Space and time	0.2	0	2	0	3.4	0	2	0
Mathematics	0.7	1	6	8	8.2	10	5	6
Liberal democracy	0.5	1	4	8	10.5	24	6	14
Duties	0.1	0	0	0	0.7	0	0	0
Causation	0.5	0	5	0	7.4	0	4	0
Arguments	0.6	0	5	0	7.2	0	4	0
Theory testing	0.7	0	6	0	8.3	0	5	0
Decision theory	0.2	0	1	0	2.5	0	1	0
Minds and machines	0.4	0	3	0	5.9	0	3	0
Truth	0.7	0	6	0	8.4	0	5	0
Radical translation	0.0	0	0	0	0.5	0	0	0
Explanation	0.3	1	3	8	3.4	6	2	3
Personal identity	0.4	0	4	0	4.6	0	3	0
Speech acts	0.1	0	1	0	1.5	0	1	0
Sense and reference	0.1	0	1	0	1.1	0	1	0
Egalitarianism	0.1	0	1	0	2.5	0	1	0
Quantum physics	0.3	1	3	8	3.3	13	2	7
Theories and realism	0.5	0	4	0	5.5	0	3	0
Functions	0.3	0	3	0	5.0	0	3	0
Feminism	0.3	0	2	0	4.2	0	2	0
Medical ethics and Freud	0.2	0	2	0	3.1	0	2	0
Abortion and self-defence	0.1	0	1	0	2.0	0	1	0
Belief ascriptions	0.0	0	0	0	0.6	0	0	0
Thermodynamics	0.3	0	2	0	4.0	0	2	0
Knowledge	1.2	1	10	8	15.0	8	8	5
Game theory	0.0	0	0	0	0.7	0	0	0
Justification	0.3	0	3	0	3.5	0	2	0
Frankfurt cases	0.1	0	1	0	2.2	0	1	0
Concepts	0.7	0	6	0	12.3	0	7	0
Races and DNA	0.1	0	1	0	1.5	0	1	0
Modality	0.1	0	1	0	1.5	0	1	0
Reasons	0.4	0	3	0	5.5	0	3	0
Evolutionary biology	0.7	0	6	0	7.3	0	4	0
Population ethics	0.0	0	0	0	0.7	0	0	0
Formal epistemology	0.0	0	0	0	0.5	0	0	0
Wide content	0.1	0	1	0	1.9	0	1	0
Vagueness	0.2	0	2	0	3.2	0	2	0
Cognitive science	0.1	0	1	0	1.5	0	1	0
Models	0.1	0	1	0	1.4	0	1	0
Composition and constitution	0.3	0	3	0	3.9	0	2	0
Norms	0.2	0	2	0	3.8	0	2	0

1926

Table B.51: Measures of the prominence of each subject in 1926 ’s journals.

Subject	Weight	Raw	W-Ratio	R-Ratio	W-Pages	R-Pages	WP-Ratio	RP-Ratio
Psychology	5.7	8	46	65	87.8	113	51	66
Idealism	15.3	23	123	185	240.9	340	141	199
Life and value	8.9	12	72	97	127.4	166	75	97
Other history	6.6	7	53	56	84.6	95	50	56
Dewey and pragmatism	2.5	2	20	16	28.4	11	17	6
Definitions	2.1	1	17	8	26.6	8	16	5
Propositions and implications	1.1	0	9	0	13.7	0	8	0
Beauty	4.4	9	35	73	54.5	120	32	70
Physicalism	4.0	3	32	24	59.0	12	35	7
History and culture	3.6	5	29	40	44.9	67	26	39
Faith and theism	2.7	5	22	40	42.0	107	25	63
Self-consciousness	1.6	0	13	0	22.0	0	13	0
Ancient	1.1	0	9	0	16.6	0	10	0
Universals and particulars	1.3	1	10	8	26.5	38	15	22
Verification	1.1	0	9	0	16.7	0	10	0
Value	1.4	1	11	8	20.7	14	12	8
Deduction	1.3	0	11	0	14.6	0	9	0
Mechanisms	2.9	2	23	16	29.4	18	17	11
Temporal paradoxes	4.3	6	35	48	53.5	89	31	52
Classical space and time	1.0	0	8	0	16.4	0	10	0
Early modern	2.8	4	23	32	36.1	44	21	26
Meaning and use	0.8	0	6	0	8.8	0	5	0
Marx	0.9	0	7	0	13.0	0	8	0
Ordinary language	7.4	6	60	48	130.5	134	76	78
Moral conscience	1.3	3	11	24	19.2	40	11	23
Methodology of science	4.1	4	33	32	50.8	46	30	27
Heidegger and Husserl	0.6	1	5	8	3.8	7	2	4
Emotions	1.1	1	9	8	15.8	9	9	5
Ontological argument	1.5	2	12	16	19.8	30	12	18
Chemistry	1.7	1	14	8	23.4	9	14	5
Social contract theory	1.8	1	15	8	26.6	14	16	8
Kant	1.5	2	12	16	9.8	4	6	2
Promises and imperatives	0.4	0	3	0	5.8	0	3	0
Analytic/synthetic	0.4	0	3	0	5.0	0	3	0
Freedom and free will	0.1	0	1	0	2.0	0	1	0
Crime and punishment	0.1	0	1	0	1.4	0	1	0
Sets and grue	0.8	1	7	8	5.6	4	3	2
Origins and purposes	0.5	0	4	0	5.4	0	3	0
Time	1.8	1	15	8	17.1	6	10	4
Color/colour	1.9	1	15	8	17.4	4	10	2
War	0.2	0	2	0	2.6	0	2	0
Depiction	0.2	0	2	0	2.5	0	1	0
Denoting	0.3	0	3	0	4.9	0	3	0
Chance	0.8	2	7	16	17.5	45	10	26
Hume	0.3	0	2	0	3.7	0	2	0
Laws	1.0	1	8	8	13.4	5	8	3
Perception	2.7	2	22	16	43.0	23	25	13
Intention	0.1	0	1	0	1.1	0	1	0
Virtues	0.3	1	2	8	5.2	19	3	11
Space and time	0.5	1	4	8	4.9	8	3	5
Mathematics	1.0	1	8	8	13.6	22	8	13
Liberal democracy	0.5	1	4	8	9.4	20	5	12
Duties	0.1	0	1	0	1.2	0	1	0
Causation	1.0	2	8	16	12.5	17	7	10
Arguments	0.5	0	4	0	8.4	0	5	0
Theory testing	0.3	0	2	0	4.5	0	3	0
Decision theory	0.2	0	1	0	2.2	0	1	0
Minds and machines	0.4	0	3	0	5.5	0	3	0
Truth	1.0	0	8	0	7.7	0	5	0
Radical translation	0.1	0	1	0	1.2	0	1	0
Explanation	0.6	0	5	0	8.1	0	5	0
Personal identity	0.1	0	1	0	2.6	0	2	0
Speech acts	0.1	0	1	0	1.8	0	1	0
Sense and reference	0.4	0	3	0	3.9	0	2	0
Egalitarianism	0.1	0	0	0	0.8	0	0	0
Quantum physics	0.1	0	1	0	1.2	0	1	0
Theories and realism	0.5	0	4	0	8.0	0	5	0
Functions	0.3	0	2	0	3.1	0	2	0
Feminism	0.1	0	1	0	0.8	0	0	0
Medical ethics and Freud	0.1	0	1	0	0.8	0	0	0
Abortion and self-defence	0.2	0	1	0	1.8	0	1	0
Belief ascriptions	0.1	0	1	0	0.6	0	0	0
Thermodynamics	0.4	0	3	0	5.4	0	3	0
Knowledge	0.9	0	7	0	12.0	0	7	0
Game theory	0.1	0	1	0	0.8	0	0	0
Justification	0.3	0	3	0	5.4	0	3	0
Frankfurt cases	0.2	0	1	0	2.4	0	1	0
Concepts	0.5	0	4	0	6.4	0	4	0
Races and DNA	0.2	0	2	0	1.7	0	1	0
Modality	0.3	0	3	0	2.2	0	1	0
Reasons	0.3	0	2	0	3.8	0	2	0
Evolutionary biology	0.6	0	4	0	6.6	0	4	0
Population ethics	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0
Formal epistemology	0.1	0	1	0	0.5	0	0	0
Wide content	0.3	0	2	0	3.3	0	2	0
Vagueness	0.3	0	2	0	3.2	0	2	0
Cognitive science	0.1	0	1	0	1.0	0	1	0
Models	0.2	0	1	0	2.2	0	1	0
Composition and constitution	0.4	0	3	0	7.3	0	4	0
Norms	0.1	0	1	0	1.7	0	1	0

1927

Table B.52: Measures of the prominence of each subject in 1927 ’s journals.

Subject	Weight	Raw	W-Ratio	R-Ratio	W-Pages	R-Pages	WP-Ratio	RP-Ratio
Psychology	4.9	7	40	56	101.4	166	55	91
Idealism	16.7	29	134	232	294.3	539	161	295
Life and value	8.1	14	65	112	123.3	203	67	111
Other history	5.9	7	47	56	73.6	91	40	50
Dewey and pragmatism	2.2	1	18	8	33.3	5	18	3
Definitions	3.7	3	29	24	43.5	42	24	23
Propositions and implications	4.2	8	33	64	53.8	124	29	68
Beauty	0.9	2	7	16	9.2	19	5	10
Physicalism	5.1	5	41	40	63.7	37	35	20
History and culture	1.2	1	10	8	18.7	9	10	5
Faith and theism	2.4	2	19	16	34.0	17	19	9
Self-consciousness	2.1	0	17	0	27.3	0	15	0
Ancient	2.6	3	21	24	29.9	25	16	14
Universals and particulars	3.5	4	28	32	64.1	85	35	46
Verification	0.8	0	7	0	10.3	0	6	0
Value	1.3	1	11	8	17.7	5	10	3
Deduction	1.5	1	12	8	15.9	11	9	6
Mechanisms	4.1	3	33	24	50.9	23	28	13
Temporal paradoxes	3.1	2	24	16	29.8	5	16	3
Classical space and time	1.4	1	11	8	27.9	32	15	17
Early modern	1.5	1	12	8	24.0	16	13	9
Meaning and use	1.4	1	11	8	22.8	3	12	2
Marx	2.1	3	17	24	23.9	36	13	20
Ordinary language	6.1	2	49	16	122.3	34	67	19
Moral conscience	0.7	1	6	8	13.4	29	7	16
Methodology of science	2.9	1	23	8	36.4	20	20	11
Heidegger and Husserl	0.8	1	6	8	9.8	20	5	11
Emotions	0.6	0	5	0	9.4	0	5	0
Ontological argument	2.1	3	17	24	23.6	26	13	14
Chemistry	2.9	5	24	40	45.3	69	25	38
Social contract theory	0.6	0	5	0	10.0	0	5	0
Kant	0.8	1	7	8	13.4	8	7	4
Promises and imperatives	1.1	1	8	8	7.1	1	4	1
Analytic/synthetic	0.7	0	6	0	6.7	0	4	0
Freedom and free will	0.4	1	3	8	4.1	9	2	5
Crime and punishment	0.7	1	6	8	9.0	14	5	8
Sets and grue	0.5	0	4	0	8.4	0	5	0
Origins and purposes	0.4	0	3	0	8.5	0	5	0
Time	0.5	0	4	0	10.4	0	6	0
Color/colour	0.9	0	7	0	13.7	0	7	0
War	0.0	0	0	0	0.5	0	0	0
Depiction	0.2	0	2	0	2.8	0	2	0
Denoting	0.3	0	2	0	5.3	0	3	0
Chance	0.4	0	3	0	3.7	0	2	0
Hume	0.5	1	4	8	6.3	8	3	4
Laws	0.9	0	7	0	14.9	0	8	0
Perception	2.7	2	21	16	36.3	19	20	10
Intention	0.2	0	2	0	1.2	0	1	0
Virtues	0.2	0	2	0	2.9	0	2	0
Space and time	1.8	3	14	24	18.5	32	10	17
Mathematics	0.6	1	5	8	12.3	22	7	12
Liberal democracy	0.5	0	4	0	6.7	0	4	0
Duties	0.1	0	1	0	0.5	0	0	0
Causation	0.8	0	7	0	10.4	0	6	0
Arguments	0.8	0	7	0	11.8	0	6	0
Theory testing	0.6	0	5	0	8.3	0	5	0
Decision theory	0.2	0	1	0	2.3	0	1	0
Minds and machines	0.3	0	2	0	4.2	0	2	0
Truth	0.6	0	5	0	6.5	0	4	0
Radical translation	0.3	0	2	0	1.4	0	1	0
Explanation	0.3	0	3	0	5.5	0	3	0
Personal identity	0.6	0	5	0	7.9	0	4	0
Speech acts	0.3	0	2	0	3.1	0	2	0
Sense and reference	0.2	0	2	0	3.2	0	2	0
Egalitarianism	0.3	0	2	0	2.4	0	1	0
Quantum physics	0.2	0	2	0	3.5	0	2	0
Theories and realism	0.7	0	6	0	11.5	0	6	0
Functions	0.5	0	4	0	7.6	0	4	0
Feminism	0.1	0	1	0	1.7	0	1	0
Medical ethics and Freud	0.1	0	1	0	1.9	0	1	0
Abortion and self-defence	0.1	0	1	0	1.3	0	1	0
Belief ascriptions	0.0	0	0	0	0.2	0	0	0
Thermodynamics	0.5	0	4	0	6.8	0	4	0
Knowledge	1.2	1	9	8	14.6	5	8	3
Game theory	0.1	0	1	0	0.7	0	0	0
Justification	0.6	0	5	0	7.5	0	4	0
Frankfurt cases	0.2	0	1	0	1.3	0	1	0
Concepts	0.9	0	7	0	13.2	0	7	0
Races and DNA	0.4	1	3	8	4.4	20	2	11
Modality	0.2	0	1	0	2.5	0	1	0
Reasons	0.4	0	3	0	4.7	0	3	0
Evolutionary biology	0.3	0	2	0	5.8	0	3	0
Population ethics	0.1	0	0	0	0.8	0	0	0
Formal epistemology	0.0	0	0	0	0.3	0	0	0
Wide content	0.2	0	2	0	2.5	0	1	0
Vagueness	0.4	0	3	0	3.9	0	2	0
Cognitive science	0.0	0	0	0	0.3	0	0	0
Models	0.1	0	1	0	0.9	0	0	0
Composition and constitution	0.5	0	4	0	5.4	0	3	0
Norms	0.1	0	1	0	1.8	0	1	0

1928

Table B.53: Measures of the prominence of each subject in 1928 ’s journals.

Subject	Weight	Raw	W-Ratio	R-Ratio	W-Pages	R-Pages	WP-Ratio	RP-Ratio
Psychology	3.8	4	29	30	58.1	88	32	49
Idealism	14.4	25	108	188	254.4	448	141	249
Life and value	6.4	5	48	38	100.1	68	56	38
Other history	9.3	13	70	98	102.3	157	57	87
Dewey and pragmatism	3.1	2	23	15	36.1	11	20	6
Definitions	2.9	3	22	23	38.0	33	21	18
Propositions and implications	3.6	7	27	53	48.3	93	27	52
Beauty	4.4	8	33	60	47.5	81	26	45
Physicalism	5.1	5	38	38	52.8	40	29	22
History and culture	2.8	5	21	38	31.1	52	17	29
Faith and theism	2.5	2	19	15	36.0	37	20	21
Self-consciousness	2.5	2	19	15	29.6	10	16	6
Ancient	1.9	3	15	23	32.7	51	18	28
Universals and particulars	3.0	4	22	30	24.8	29	14	16
Verification	1.3	0	10	0	20.6	0	11	0
Value	1.7	2	13	15	21.7	25	12	14
Deduction	2.4	3	18	23	18.4	10	10	6
Mechanisms	2.3	2	18	15	27.5	27	15	15
Temporal paradoxes	2.5	2	18	15	43.4	27	24	15
Classical space and time	1.9	2	14	15	28.9	35	16	19
Early modern	1.8	2	14	15	35.2	43	20	24
Meaning and use	1.5	0	11	0	19.0	0	11	0
Marx	1.3	0	9	0	16.2	0	9	0
Ordinary language	7.1	4	53	30	129.5	76	72	42
Moral conscience	1.3	1	9	8	19.6	7	11	4
Methodology of science	3.8	5	28	38	47.1	61	26	34
Heidegger and Husserl	0.6	0	4	0	2.7	0	2	0
Emotions	0.6	0	5	0	6.3	0	3	0
Ontological argument	4.0	4	30	30	41.9	29	23	16
Chemistry	2.0	2	15	15	28.6	13	16	7
Social contract theory	1.0	2	7	15	12.5	33	7	18
Kant	0.8	0	6	0	11.8	0	7	0
Promises and imperatives	0.9	1	7	8	17.7	37	10	21
Analytic/synthetic	0.5	0	4	0	4.7	0	3	0
Freedom and free will	0.5	1	3	8	3.3	5	2	3
Crime and punishment	0.8	2	6	15	10.4	24	6	13
Sets and grue	1.3	2	10	15	20.6	27	11	15
Origins and purposes	1.0	0	8	0	7.0	0	4	0
Time	0.7	0	5	0	13.6	0	8	0
Color/colour	0.8	0	6	0	11.7	0	7	0
War	0.3	0	2	0	5.0	0	3	0
Depiction	0.9	1	7	8	6.1	3	3	2
Denoting	0.4	0	3	0	5.9	0	3	0
Chance	0.5	1	4	8	18.9	46	10	26
Hume	0.3	0	2	0	1.9	0	1	0
Laws	1.2	1	9	8	18.6	8	10	4
Perception	2.6	1	19	8	31.5	16	17	9
Intention	0.4	0	3	0	4.3	0	2	0
Virtues	0.2	0	1	0	2.2	0	1	0
Space and time	0.8	1	6	8	10.8	19	6	11
Mathematics	0.6	0	5	0	7.5	0	4	0
Liberal democracy	0.4	0	3	0	4.8	0	3	0
Duties	0.5	1	4	8	10.6	20	6	11
Causation	0.8	1	6	8	9.6	11	5	6
Arguments	1.4	0	11	0	17.9	0	10	0
Theory testing	0.4	0	3	0	3.1	0	2	0
Decision theory	0.2	0	2	0	2.1	0	1	0
Minds and machines	0.4	0	3	0	4.6	0	3	0
Truth	0.8	0	6	0	7.5	0	4	0
Radical translation	0.2	0	2	0	1.1	0	1	0
Explanation	0.2	0	2	0	3.1	0	2	0
Personal identity	0.5	0	4	0	5.8	0	3	0
Speech acts	0.2	0	2	0	2.1	0	1	0
Sense and reference	0.4	0	3	0	5.9	0	3	0
Egalitarianism	0.1	0	0	0	1.0	0	1	0
Quantum physics	0.0	0	0	0	0.5	0	0	0
Theories and realism	1.0	0	8	0	12.6	0	7	0
Functions	0.3	0	3	0	4.6	0	3	0
Feminism	0.4	0	3	0	5.1	0	3	0
Medical ethics and Freud	0.3	0	3	0	4.4	0	2	0
Abortion and self-defence	0.9	1	7	8	2.2	1	1	1
Belief ascriptions	0.1	0	1	0	0.9	0	1	0
Thermodynamics	0.6	0	4	0	5.8	0	3	0
Knowledge	1.0	0	8	0	13.1	0	7	0
Game theory	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0
Justification	0.7	0	5	0	7.9	0	4	0
Frankfurt cases	0.2	0	2	0	1.6	0	1	0
Concepts	0.6	0	5	0	8.1	0	4	0
Races and DNA	0.2	0	1	0	1.8	0	1	0
Modality	0.2	0	1	0	1.3	0	1	0
Reasons	0.2	0	2	0	4.5	0	2	0
Evolutionary biology	0.3	0	2	0	4.5	0	3	0
Population ethics	0.1	0	0	0	0.7	0	0	0
Formal epistemology	0.0	0	0	0	0.5	0	0	0
Wide content	0.3	0	2	0	4.2	0	2	0
Vagueness	0.4	0	3	0	3.4	0	2	0
Cognitive science	0.1	0	0	0	0.7	0	0	0
Models	0.1	0	1	0	1.0	0	1	0
Composition and constitution	0.4	0	3	0	6.4	0	4	0
Norms	0.1	0	1	0	1.6	0	1	0

1929

Table B.54: Measures of the prominence of each subject in 1929 ’s journals.

Subject	Weight	Raw	W-Ratio	R-Ratio	W-Pages	R-Pages	WP-Ratio	RP-Ratio
Psychology	2.8	2	24	17	59.9	71	32	38
Idealism	16.2	27	136	227	242.0	375	131	203
Life and value	5.4	6	45	50	84.6	80	46	43
Other history	5.7	7	47	59	88.0	104	48	56
Dewey and pragmatism	2.2	0	18	0	30.5	0	17	0
Definitions	2.8	2	24	17	47.8	40	26	22
Propositions and implications	3.1	4	26	34	51.7	83	28	45
Beauty	3.3	6	27	50	48.1	81	26	44
Physicalism	4.2	4	35	34	63.2	82	34	44
History and culture	1.5	2	13	17	28.3	41	15	22
Faith and theism	1.7	0	15	0	29.6	0	16	0
Self-consciousness	1.6	0	13	0	22.9	0	12	0
Ancient	1.0	2	9	17	16.7	41	9	22
Universals and particulars	2.8	4	23	34	42.3	67	23	36
Verification	0.6	0	5	0	10.2	0	6	0
Value	1.5	1	13	8	29.3	23	16	12
Deduction	1.9	2	16	17	24.7	19	13	10
Mechanisms	2.0	3	17	25	23.7	35	13	19
Temporal paradoxes	2.3	2	19	17	27.5	17	15	9
Classical space and time	1.3	0	11	0	20.0	0	11	0
Early modern	4.0	7	34	59	59.7	101	32	55
Meaning and use	2.2	3	18	25	25.1	22	14	12
Marx	1.0	0	8	0	16.9	0	9	0
Ordinary language	7.2	9	61	76	148.4	170	80	92
Moral conscience	0.4	0	4	0	8.1	0	4	0
Methodology of science	3.9	2	33	17	54.3	12	29	7
Heidegger and Husserl	0.6	0	5	0	9.5	0	5	0
Emotions	1.7	2	15	17	17.5	11	9	6
Ontological argument	2.3	2	19	17	23.1	14	13	8
Chemistry	1.5	2	13	17	30.4	54	16	29
Social contract theory	0.6	0	5	0	6.8	0	4	0
Kant	0.7	0	5	0	8.4	0	5	0
Promises and imperatives	1.0	1	8	8	19.6	24	11	13
Analytic/synthetic	0.7	0	6	0	8.6	0	5	0
Freedom and free will	0.2	0	2	0	2.3	0	1	0
Crime and punishment	0.0	0	0	0	0.2	0	0	0
Sets and grue	0.9	0	8	0	10.9	0	6	0
Origins and purposes	0.7	0	5	0	7.3	0	4	0
Time	1.1	1	9	8	23.2	28	13	15
Color/colour	1.9	1	16	8	31.2	21	17	11
War	0.1	0	1	0	1.8	0	1	0
Depiction	0.5	0	4	0	3.5	0	2	0
Denoting	0.4	0	4	0	8.7	0	5	0
Chance	0.4	0	3	0	5.7	0	3	0
Hume	0.3	1	3	8	4.5	14	2	8
Laws	1.2	1	10	8	16.4	9	9	5
Perception	2.0	1	17	8	36.3	12	20	7
Intention	0.1	0	1	0	1.1	0	1	0
Virtues	0.2	0	1	0	2.8	0	1	0
Space and time	1.2	2	10	17	17.2	36	9	20
Mathematics	2.3	5	20	42	34.6	78	19	42
Liberal democracy	0.2	1	2	8	5.0	22	3	12
Duties	0.3	0	2	0	6.0	0	3	0
Causation	0.7	1	6	8	9.4	8	5	4
Arguments	0.6	0	5	0	10.6	0	6	0
Theory testing	0.6	0	5	0	9.0	0	5	0
Decision theory	0.1	0	1	0	1.8	0	1	0
Minds and machines	0.5	0	4	0	5.8	0	3	0
Truth	0.5	0	5	0	5.8	0	3	0
Radical translation	0.1	0	1	0	1.2	0	1	0
Explanation	0.4	0	3	0	5.2	0	3	0
Personal identity	0.4	0	3	0	5.0	0	3	0
Speech acts	0.3	0	3	0	4.3	0	2	0
Sense and reference	0.3	0	2	0	5.6	0	3	0
Egalitarianism	0.1	0	1	0	1.5	0	1	0
Quantum physics	0.3	0	3	0	7.5	0	4	0
Theories and realism	0.5	0	4	0	7.5	0	4	0
Functions	0.4	0	3	0	5.5	0	3	0
Feminism	0.2	0	2	0	3.1	0	2	0
Medical ethics and Freud	0.0	0	0	0	0.2	0	0	0
Abortion and self-defence	0.0	0	0	0	0.7	0	0	0
Belief ascriptions	0.1	0	0	0	1.0	0	1	0
Thermodynamics	1.3	2	11	17	8.6	3	5	2
Knowledge	1.6	1	13	8	37.8	48	20	26
Game theory	0.2	0	1	0	2.3	0	1	0
Justification	0.6	0	5	0	9.4	0	5	0
Frankfurt cases	0.1	0	1	0	1.9	0	1	0
Concepts	0.6	0	5	0	8.2	0	4	0
Races and DNA	0.1	0	1	0	2.4	0	1	0
Modality	0.2	0	2	0	3.0	0	2	0
Reasons	0.1	0	1	0	1.8	0	1	0
Evolutionary biology	0.4	0	3	0	5.7	0	3	0
Population ethics	0.0	0	0	0	0.4	0	0	0
Formal epistemology	0.0	0	0	0	0.3	0	0	0
Wide content	0.3	0	3	0	5.2	0	3	0
Vagueness	0.4	0	4	0	6.8	0	4	0
Cognitive science	0.1	0	1	0	1.6	0	1	0
Models	0.1	0	1	0	1.2	0	1	0
Composition and constitution	0.6	0	5	0	10.1	0	5	0
Norms	0.1	0	1	0	2.5	0	1	0

1930

Table B.55: Measures of the prominence of each subject in 1930 ’s journals.

Subject	Weight	Raw	W-Ratio	R-Ratio	W-Pages	R-Pages	WP-Ratio	RP-Ratio
Psychology	1.6	2	15	19	29.6	38	20	25
Idealism	12.6	21	120	200	210.5	350	140	233
Life and value	3.9	5	38	48	59.6	59	40	39
Other history	4.9	6	47	57	72.5	86	48	57
Dewey and pragmatism	2.3	2	22	19	25.6	18	17	12
Definitions	3.8	3	36	29	47.2	30	31	20
Propositions and implications	2.8	2	27	19	40.0	22	27	15
Beauty	2.1	4	20	38	28.0	52	19	35
Physicalism	1.9	0	19	0	32.0	0	21	0
History and culture	0.8	0	8	0	11.7	0	8	0
Faith and theism	2.3	3	22	29	36.9	50	25	33
Self-consciousness	1.1	1	11	10	19.2	24	13	16
Ancient	1.1	1	11	10	19.6	18	13	12
Universals and particulars	2.0	2	19	19	27.7	21	18	14
Verification	1.0	0	10	0	14.9	0	10	0
Value	1.1	1	11	10	14.8	8	10	5
Deduction	2.4	2	22	19	23.5	13	16	9
Mechanisms	1.4	0	14	0	15.4	0	10	0
Temporal paradoxes	2.4	1	22	10	31.8	12	21	8
Classical space and time	0.7	0	7	0	9.4	0	6	0
Early modern	4.8	8	45	76	89.5	151	60	101
Meaning and use	0.6	0	6	0	8.5	0	6	0
Marx	1.4	3	13	29	15.3	37	10	25
Ordinary language	4.9	4	47	38	85.0	88	57	59
Moral conscience	0.9	1	9	10	8.4	6	6	4
Methodology of science	4.3	3	41	29	57.5	58	38	39
Heidegger and Husserl	2.6	4	25	38	25.9	36	17	24
Emotions	0.4	0	4	0	5.9	0	4	0
Ontological argument	1.5	1	14	10	19.4	6	13	4
Chemistry	2.4	2	23	19	27.2	26	18	17
Social contract theory	0.3	0	3	0	6.0	0	4	0
Kant	1.5	2	14	19	36.3	50	24	33
Promises and imperatives	1.1	0	11	0	11.7	0	8	0
Analytic/synthetic	0.6	0	6	0	7.5	0	5	0
Freedom and free will	0.2	0	2	0	3.0	0	2	0
Crime and punishment	0.1	0	1	0	1.0	0	1	0
Sets and grue	0.7	1	6	10	8.9	14	6	9
Origins and purposes	0.3	0	3	0	4.0	0	3	0
Time	1.0	1	10	10	16.2	17	11	11
Color/colour	1.2	2	11	19	17.8	38	12	25
War	0.1	0	1	0	1.1	0	1	0
Depiction	0.2	0	2	0	3.9	0	3	0
Denoting	0.5	0	5	0	9.3	0	6	0
Chance	0.7	1	7	10	10.8	16	7	11
Hume	0.3	0	3	0	5.1	0	3	0
Laws	0.9	1	9	10	12.1	7	8	5
Perception	1.8	1	17	10	27.6	17	18	11
Intention	0.3	0	3	0	1.8	0	1	0
Virtues	0.1	0	1	0	1.1	0	1	0
Space and time	3.5	7	34	67	30.7	59	20	39
Mathematics	1.0	2	9	19	14.0	27	9	18
Liberal democracy	0.0	0	0	0	0.7	0	0	0
Duties	0.2	0	2	0	2.4	0	2	0
Causation	1.9	3	18	29	23.7	34	16	23
Arguments	0.8	0	8	0	15.3	0	10	0
Theory testing	0.8	1	7	10	7.8	4	5	3
Decision theory	0.2	0	2	0	1.8	0	1	0
Minds and machines	0.2	0	2	0	3.4	0	2	0
Truth	0.5	0	5	0	7.0	0	5	0
Radical translation	0.0	0	0	0	0.5	0	0	0
Explanation	0.3	0	3	0	4.1	0	3	0
Personal identity	0.3	0	3	0	5.1	0	3	0
Speech acts	0.1	0	1	0	0.9	0	1	0
Sense and reference	0.3	0	2	0	3.0	0	2	0
Egalitarianism	0.1	0	1	0	1.0	0	1	0
Quantum physics	0.2	0	2	0	3.3	0	2	0
Theories and realism	0.7	0	7	0	7.9	0	5	0
Functions	0.4	0	4	0	4.1	0	3	0
Feminism	0.1	0	1	0	1.7	0	1	0
Medical ethics and Freud	0.2	0	2	0	1.7	0	1	0
Abortion and self-defence	0.1	0	1	0	0.8	0	1	0
Belief ascriptions	0.0	0	0	0	0.5	0	0	0
Thermodynamics	0.4	0	4	0	4.7	0	3	0
Knowledge	1.1	0	11	0	15.8	0	11	0
Game theory	0.0	0	0	0	0.4	0	0	0
Justification	0.2	0	2	0	3.9	0	3	0
Frankfurt cases	0.1	0	1	0	1.9	0	1	0
Concepts	0.8	0	8	0	10.0	0	7	0
Races and DNA	0.1	0	1	0	1.6	0	1	0
Modality	0.0	0	0	0	0.5	0	0	0
Reasons	0.1	0	1	0	1.1	0	1	0
Evolutionary biology	0.2	0	2	0	0.9	0	1	0
Population ethics	0.1	0	1	0	0.9	0	1	0
Formal epistemology	0.1	0	1	0	1.0	0	1	0
Wide content	0.2	0	2	0	3.8	0	3	0
Vagueness	0.1	0	1	0	1.7	0	1	0
Cognitive science	0.1	0	1	0	1.0	0	1	0
Models	0.0	0	0	0	0.3	0	0	0
Composition and constitution	1.0	1	10	10	10.3	8	7	5
Norms	0.1	0	1	0	1.0	0	1	0

1931

Table B.56: Measures of the prominence of each subject in 1931 ’s journals.

Subject	Weight	Raw	W-Ratio	R-Ratio	W-Pages	R-Pages	WP-Ratio	RP-Ratio
Psychology	4.4	8	43	78	69.2	115	44	73
Idealism	11.4	18	112	176	184.5	318	117	202
Life and value	6.9	12	67	118	99.7	150	63	95
Other history	4.1	5	40	49	55.3	63	35	40
Dewey and pragmatism	2.5	0	24	0	36.1	0	23	0
Definitions	3.6	3	36	29	48.6	28	31	18
Propositions and implications	2.2	3	22	29	24.3	24	15	15
Beauty	2.7	4	26	39	31.4	54	20	34
Physicalism	3.8	3	37	29	59.8	49	38	31
History and culture	1.0	2	10	20	19.3	36	12	23
Faith and theism	1.6	2	15	20	30.0	47	19	30
Self-consciousness	1.1	0	11	0	14.2	0	9	0
Ancient	0.8	0	8	0	10.7	0	7	0
Universals and particulars	2.1	2	20	20	34.6	45	22	29
Verification	0.9	0	9	0	14.1	0	9	0
Value	2.4	3	23	29	36.2	37	23	24
Deduction	1.9	2	19	20	37.2	53	24	34
Mechanisms	1.7	1	17	10	22.8	9	14	6
Temporal paradoxes	3.7	3	37	29	59.4	48	38	31
Classical space and time	1.1	2	11	20	15.8	37	10	24
Early modern	2.0	2	20	20	44.1	49	28	31
Meaning and use	1.3	0	13	0	19.8	0	13	0
Marx	1.2	1	12	10	16.7	16	11	10
Ordinary language	5.6	5	54	49	105.9	148	67	94
Moral conscience	0.9	1	9	10	15.7	24	10	15
Methodology of science	2.0	0	20	0	36.5	0	23	0
Heidegger and Husserl	0.6	0	5	0	5.0	0	3	0
Emotions	0.4	0	4	0	5.2	0	3	0
Ontological argument	1.6	1	16	10	19.7	8	13	5
Chemistry	1.6	2	16	20	22.0	21	14	13
Social contract theory	0.9	1	9	10	12.4	15	8	10
Kant	1.5	3	14	29	22.1	40	14	25
Promises and imperatives	0.6	0	6	0	10.1	0	6	0
Analytic/synthetic	0.7	1	7	10	11.5	16	7	10
Freedom and free will	0.4	1	4	10	6.3	8	4	5
Crime and punishment	0.4	1	4	10	4.1	10	3	6
Sets and grue	0.3	1	3	10	3.3	3	2	2
Origins and purposes	0.2	0	2	0	3.0	0	2	0
Time	0.4	0	4	0	7.8	0	5	0
Color/colour	0.6	0	6	0	11.2	0	7	0
War	0.5	0	4	0	4.0	0	3	0
Depiction	0.7	0	6	0	11.0	0	7	0
Denoting	0.2	0	2	0	3.1	0	2	0
Chance	0.6	1	6	10	10.9	14	7	9
Hume	0.2	0	2	0	3.7	0	2	0
Laws	0.7	0	7	0	14.6	0	9	0
Perception	2.0	2	20	20	29.4	19	19	12
Intention	0.2	0	2	0	4.3	0	3	0
Virtues	0.3	0	3	0	4.7	0	3	0
Space and time	2.3	3	23	29	39.3	52	25	33
Mathematics	0.4	0	4	0	5.7	0	4	0
Liberal democracy	0.2	0	2	0	1.8	0	1	0
Duties	0.2	0	2	0	5.0	0	3	0
Causation	0.7	0	7	0	10.1	0	6	0
Arguments	0.7	0	7	0	15.4	0	10	0
Theory testing	0.3	0	3	0	6.5	0	4	0
Decision theory	0.1	0	1	0	1.6	0	1	0
Minds and machines	0.5	0	5	0	5.9	0	4	0
Truth	1.0	1	10	10	10.0	3	6	2
Radical translation	0.1	0	1	0	1.0	0	1	0
Explanation	0.2	0	2	0	3.2	0	2	0
Personal identity	1.0	1	10	10	3.9	1	3	1
Speech acts	0.0	0	0	0	0.4	0	0	0
Sense and reference	0.3	0	3	0	3.3	0	2	0
Egalitarianism	0.1	0	1	0	0.7	0	0	0
Quantum physics	0.1	0	1	0	2.0	0	1	0
Theories and realism	0.4	0	4	0	6.6	0	4	0
Functions	0.2	0	2	0	2.7	0	2	0
Feminism	0.1	0	1	0	1.3	0	1	0
Medical ethics and Freud	0.0	0	0	0	0.3	0	0	0
Abortion and self-defence	0.0	0	0	0	0.7	0	0	0
Belief ascriptions	0.1	0	1	0	2.2	0	1	0
Thermodynamics	0.5	0	5	0	6.8	0	4	0
Knowledge	0.6	0	6	0	8.1	0	5	0
Game theory	0.0	0	0	0	0.7	0	0	0
Justification	0.3	0	3	0	5.9	0	4	0
Frankfurt cases	0.0	0	0	0	0.7	0	0	0
Concepts	0.7	0	7	0	11.3	0	7	0
Races and DNA	0.3	0	3	0	3.2	0	2	0
Modality	0.2	0	2	0	3.9	0	2	0
Reasons	0.2	0	2	0	2.7	0	2	0
Evolutionary biology	0.5	0	5	0	8.3	0	5	0
Population ethics	0.0	0	0	0	0.2	0	0	0
Formal epistemology	0.0	0	0	0	0.3	0	0	0
Wide content	0.2	0	2	0	3.6	0	2	0
Vagueness	0.1	0	1	0	2.7	0	2	0
Cognitive science	0.0	0	0	0	0.8	0	0	0
Models	0.3	1	3	10	3.4	11	2	7
Composition and constitution	0.3	0	3	0	6.3	0	4	0
Norms	0.2	0	2	0	1.4	0	1	0

1932

Table B.57: Measures of the prominence of each subject in 1932 ’s journals.

Subject	Weight	Raw	W-Ratio	R-Ratio	W-Pages	R-Pages	WP-Ratio	RP-Ratio
Psychology	2.1	1	18	8	30.9	10	17	6
Idealism	14.9	30	122	246	232.3	449	130	252
Life and value	4.0	5	32	41	66.4	60	37	34
Other history	5.0	6	41	49	68.6	87	38	49
Dewey and pragmatism	2.9	2	24	16	36.2	19	20	11
Definitions	3.8	2	31	16	43.7	7	24	4
Propositions and implications	3.2	3	27	25	40.3	33	23	18
Beauty	1.0	2	8	16	33.3	73	19	41
Physicalism	3.8	6	31	49	54.5	88	31	49
History and culture	3.3	5	27	41	57.3	74	32	41
Faith and theism	1.0	1	8	8	15.7	6	9	3
Self-consciousness	1.2	0	10	0	19.7	0	11	0
Ancient	1.3	3	11	25	23.1	51	13	29
Universals and particulars	3.0	3	25	25	46.8	50	26	28
Verification	1.0	0	8	0	15.2	0	8	0
Value	1.7	1	14	8	44.1	14	25	8
Deduction	4.7	8	39	66	37.3	61	21	34
Mechanisms	1.5	0	12	0	18.6	0	10	0
Temporal paradoxes	4.7	5	39	41	47.1	54	26	30
Classical space and time	1.6	0	13	0	16.9	0	9	0
Early modern	4.8	7	39	57	54.9	88	31	49
Meaning and use	1.8	1	15	8	32.5	32	18	18
Marx	0.5	1	4	8	7.7	9	4	5
Ordinary language	7.2	9	59	74	143.8	236	81	132
Moral conscience	1.0	1	8	8	16.1	8	9	4
Methodology of science	3.0	0	25	0	46.3	0	26	0
Heidegger and Husserl	0.9	2	7	16	18.0	57	10	32
Emotions	0.5	0	4	0	8.7	0	5	0
Ontological argument	1.3	0	11	0	19.4	0	11	0
Chemistry	1.1	2	9	16	18.4	31	10	17
Social contract theory	0.4	0	3	0	7.1	0	4	0
Kant	1.8	1	15	8	16.6	1	9	1
Promises and imperatives	1.3	0	10	0	27.5	0	15	0
Analytic/synthetic	1.0	0	8	0	12.9	0	7	0
Freedom and free will	0.2	0	2	0	3.0	0	2	0
Crime and punishment	0.1	0	1	0	0.7	0	0	0
Sets and grue	0.9	0	7	0	14.0	0	8	0
Origins and purposes	0.5	0	4	0	5.1	0	3	0
Time	1.3	0	10	0	18.2	0	10	0
Color/colour	0.4	0	3	0	5.8	0	3	0
War	0.4	1	3	8	3.1	6	2	3
Depiction	0.3	0	2	0	4.3	0	2	0
Denoting	0.7	0	6	0	10.5	0	6	0
Chance	1.9	4	16	33	31.9	80	18	45
Hume	0.4	0	3	0	5.0	0	3	0
Laws	1.0	0	8	0	14.5	0	8	0
Perception	2.0	1	17	8	24.3	10	14	6
Intention	0.1	0	1	0	1.7	0	1	0
Virtues	0.2	0	2	0	4.1	0	2	0
Space and time	1.7	1	14	8	21.2	6	12	3
Mathematics	2.1	2	17	16	21.1	15	12	8
Liberal democracy	0.3	0	2	0	4.3	0	2	0
Duties	1.1	1	9	8	27.7	28	16	16
Causation	1.8	2	15	16	24.1	16	13	9
Arguments	1.1	0	9	0	18.2	0	10	0
Theory testing	0.6	0	5	0	11.0	0	6	0
Decision theory	0.1	0	1	0	2.7	0	2	0
Minds and machines	0.3	0	3	0	5.3	0	3	0
Truth	0.4	0	4	0	4.5	0	3	0
Radical translation	0.0	0	0	0	0.4	0	0	0
Explanation	0.1	0	1	0	2.2	0	1	0
Personal identity	0.9	1	7	8	6.9	1	4	1
Speech acts	0.2	0	2	0	3.0	0	2	0
Sense and reference	0.5	0	4	0	8.1	0	5	0
Egalitarianism	0.1	0	1	0	1.8	0	1	0
Quantum physics	0.3	0	3	0	2.6	0	1	0
Theories and realism	0.4	0	3	0	6.5	0	4	0
Functions	0.2	0	2	0	4.0	0	2	0
Feminism	0.1	0	1	0	0.9	0	1	0
Medical ethics and Freud	0.1	0	1	0	1.1	0	1	0
Abortion and self-defence	0.1	0	1	0	0.9	0	1	0
Belief ascriptions	0.1	0	0	0	0.8	0	0	0
Thermodynamics	0.6	0	5	0	6.6	0	4	0
Knowledge	0.9	0	7	0	11.3	0	6	0
Game theory	0.3	0	2	0	1.1	0	1	0
Justification	0.5	0	4	0	6.3	0	4	0
Frankfurt cases	0.1	0	1	0	2.1	0	1	0
Concepts	0.9	1	8	8	12.2	18	7	10
Races and DNA	0.0	0	0	0	0.3	0	0	0
Modality	0.4	0	3	0	3.3	0	2	0
Reasons	0.5	0	4	0	7.2	0	4	0
Evolutionary biology	0.2	0	1	0	3.5	0	2	0
Population ethics	0.2	0	2	0	5.1	0	3	0
Formal epistemology	0.1	0	1	0	0.8	0	0	0
Wide content	0.4	0	3	0	4.7	0	3	0
Vagueness	0.2	0	2	0	3.0	0	2	0
Cognitive science	0.2	0	2	0	1.5	0	1	0
Models	0.2	1	2	8	1.6	7	1	4
Composition and constitution	0.5	0	4	0	9.6	0	5	0
Norms	0.1	0	1	0	1.4	0	1	0

1933

Table B.58: Measures of the prominence of each subject in 1933 ’s journals.

Subject	Weight	Raw	W-Ratio	R-Ratio	W-Pages	R-Pages	WP-Ratio	RP-Ratio
Psychology	1.3	1	11	9	25.3	26	14	15
Idealism	18.4	29	162	254	280.4	445	157	249
Life and value	4.1	2	36	18	65.6	32	37	18
Other history	4.2	6	37	53	67.8	89	38	50
Dewey and pragmatism	2.5	0	22	0	32.7	0	18	0
Definitions	4.6	6	40	53	78.4	139	44	78
Propositions and implications	5.0	7	44	61	72.2	56	40	31
Beauty	3.3	8	29	70	49.9	127	28	71
Physicalism	4.1	6	36	53	45.1	63	25	35
History and culture	1.8	2	16	18	28.3	36	16	20
Faith and theism	1.0	1	9	9	11.5	6	6	3
Self-consciousness	1.7	0	15	0	22.1	0	12	0
Ancient	1.1	2	10	18	14.3	25	8	14
Universals and particulars	4.1	5	36	44	60.5	72	34	40
Verification	1.1	0	10	0	18.8	0	11	0
Value	1.8	1	16	9	24.2	7	14	4
Deduction	3.4	3	30	26	38.8	18	22	10
Mechanisms	1.4	1	12	9	21.9	12	12	7
Temporal paradoxes	1.1	0	9	0	16.5	0	9	0
Classical space and time	0.8	0	7	0	11.8	0	7	0
Early modern	2.5	5	22	44	53.5	111	30	62
Meaning and use	2.9	3	26	26	52.9	13	30	7
Marx	0.4	0	3	0	7.0	0	4	0
Ordinary language	6.1	4	53	35	137.0	130	77	73
Moral conscience	0.9	2	8	18	11.2	20	6	11
Methodology of science	2.5	1	22	9	48.9	25	27	14
Heidegger and Husserl	0.5	0	4	0	9.2	0	5	0
Emotions	0.4	0	3	0	6.2	0	3	0
Ontological argument	1.6	1	14	9	22.8	10	13	6
Chemistry	0.6	1	6	9	14.9	34	8	19
Social contract theory	0.2	0	2	0	5.0	0	3	0
Kant	1.0	0	8	0	12.9	0	7	0
Promises and imperatives	1.2	3	10	26	16.0	36	9	20
Analytic/synthetic	1.1	1	10	9	17.3	10	10	6
Freedom and free will	0.5	0	5	0	9.4	0	5	0
Crime and punishment	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0
Sets and grue	1.6	1	14	9	15.3	5	9	3
Origins and purposes	0.4	0	3	0	5.2	0	3	0
Time	0.6	0	5	0	13.2	0	7	0
Color/colour	1.1	0	10	0	15.3	0	9	0
War	0.3	0	3	0	2.6	0	1	0
Depiction	0.5	1	5	9	10.4	15	6	8
Denoting	1.3	2	12	18	36.5	80	20	45
Chance	1.2	2	11	18	16.8	27	9	15
Hume	0.2	0	2	0	3.9	0	2	0
Laws	0.9	0	8	0	12.9	0	7	0
Perception	1.6	1	14	9	26.4	15	15	8
Intention	0.1	0	1	0	0.9	0	0	0
Virtues	0.1	0	1	0	1.1	0	1	0
Space and time	0.6	1	5	9	5.5	9	3	5
Mathematics	2.0	2	17	18	20.9	19	12	11
Liberal democracy	0.3	1	3	9	9.1	47	5	26
Duties	0.4	0	3	0	4.0	0	2	0
Causation	0.5	0	4	0	12.6	0	7	0
Arguments	0.9	0	8	0	14.6	0	8	0
Theory testing	0.5	0	4	0	7.1	0	4	0
Decision theory	0.2	0	1	0	1.8	0	1	0
Minds and machines	0.3	0	2	0	4.0	0	2	0
Truth	1.0	0	9	0	11.6	0	7	0
Radical translation	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0
Explanation	0.2	0	1	0	2.1	0	1	0
Personal identity	0.3	0	3	0	5.3	0	3	0
Speech acts	0.4	0	4	0	6.9	0	4	0
Sense and reference	0.5	0	4	0	5.9	0	3	0
Egalitarianism	0.1	0	1	0	0.6	0	0	0
Quantum physics	0.5	1	4	9	4.3	8	2	4
Theories and realism	0.6	0	5	0	8.7	0	5	0
Functions	0.4	0	3	0	7.3	0	4	0
Feminism	0.2	0	1	0	2.2	0	1	0
Medical ethics and Freud	0.0	0	0	0	0.6	0	0	0
Abortion and self-defence	0.0	0	0	0	0.5	0	0	0
Belief ascriptions	0.0	0	0	0	1.3	0	1	0
Thermodynamics	0.9	0	8	0	14.6	0	8	0
Knowledge	1.1	0	10	0	14.3	0	8	0
Game theory	0.2	0	1	0	0.8	0	0	0
Justification	0.5	1	4	9	9.2	18	5	10
Frankfurt cases	0.2	0	1	0	3.3	0	2	0
Concepts	0.5	0	4	0	8.0	0	4	0
Races and DNA	0.1	0	1	0	1.1	0	1	0
Modality	0.4	0	3	0	3.5	0	2	0
Reasons	0.1	0	1	0	0.9	0	0	0
Evolutionary biology	0.2	0	1	0	2.4	0	1	0
Population ethics	0.0	0	0	0	0.1	0	0	0
Formal epistemology	0.0	0	0	0	0.3	0	0	0
Wide content	0.1	0	1	0	0.9	0	1	0
Vagueness	0.4	0	3	0	4.4	0	2	0
Cognitive science	0.1	0	0	0	1.4	0	1	0
Models	0.1	0	1	0	1.7	0	1	0
Composition and constitution	0.3	0	3	0	5.1	0	3	0
Norms	0.2	0	2	0	5.1	0	3	0

1934

Table B.59: Measures of the prominence of each subject in 1934 ’s journals.

Subject	Weight	Raw	W-Ratio	R-Ratio	W-Pages	R-Pages	WP-Ratio	RP-Ratio
Psychology	2.2	3	11	16	30.4	40	13	18
Idealism	18.7	36	98	188	266.2	518	117	227
Life and value	6.9	8	36	42	99.4	105	43	46
Other history	3.9	3	20	16	58.5	55	26	24
Dewey and pragmatism	2.7	1	14	5	30.3	10	13	4
Definitions	10.0	15	52	78	90.7	120	40	53
Propositions and implications	6.9	6	36	31	69.5	42	30	18
Beauty	2.4	5	12	26	40.8	88	18	39
Physicalism	9.5	7	49	36	96.2	79	42	35
History and culture	1.4	1	7	5	23.6	21	10	9
Faith and theism	1.2	0	6	0	20.4	0	9	0
Self-consciousness	1.8	0	10	0	23.4	0	10	0
Ancient	3.4	5	17	26	46.3	77	20	34
Universals and particulars	4.1	4	21	21	57.5	115	25	50
Verification	4.0	5	21	26	43.6	66	19	29
Value	2.4	2	12	10	22.0	16	10	7
Deduction	4.1	4	21	21	38.7	48	17	21
Mechanisms	3.5	4	18	21	44.1	51	19	22
Temporal paradoxes	3.2	1	17	5	29.9	3	13	1
Classical space and time	3.8	3	20	16	28.9	12	13	5
Early modern	2.5	3	13	16	35.8	52	16	23
Meaning and use	5.7	10	30	52	60.8	69	27	30
Marx	1.5	1	8	5	26.0	18	11	8
Ordinary language	8.3	6	43	31	145.6	103	64	45
Moral conscience	0.7	0	4	0	10.4	0	5	0
Methodology of science	5.8	4	30	21	73.7	36	32	16
Heidegger and Husserl	1.8	2	10	10	15.8	8	7	4
Emotions	0.6	0	3	0	7.6	0	3	0
Ontological argument	2.1	2	11	10	20.3	16	9	7
Chemistry	4.7	6	24	31	54.1	83	24	36
Social contract theory	1.1	1	6	5	18.8	24	8	11
Kant	0.5	0	2	0	6.7	0	3	0
Promises and imperatives	1.9	1	10	5	25.7	26	11	11
Analytic/synthetic	2.3	1	12	5	25.0	9	11	4
Freedom and free will	0.4	0	2	0	9.3	0	4	0
Crime and punishment	0.1	0	0	0	1.1	0	0	0
Sets and grue	5.1	7	27	36	51.0	79	22	35
Origins and purposes	0.8	0	4	0	8.7	0	4	0
Time	2.0	3	11	16	26.4	31	12	14
Color/colour	2.3	3	12	16	21.6	26	9	11
War	0.3	0	1	0	4.2	0	2	0
Depiction	0.6	0	3	0	7.3	0	3	0
Denoting	1.6	3	8	16	26.6	47	12	21
Chance	2.1	2	11	10	23.2	26	10	11
Hume	0.4	0	2	0	5.8	0	3	0
Laws	1.4	1	7	5	15.5	12	7	5
Perception	4.4	2	23	10	46.4	15	20	7
Intention	0.7	1	4	5	6.9	8	3	4
Virtues	1.2	1	6	5	4.9	1	2	0
Space and time	1.3	3	7	16	13.0	19	6	8
Mathematics	2.0	1	10	5	27.5	20	12	9
Liberal democracy	0.3	0	1	0	6.5	0	3	0
Duties	0.6	1	3	5	3.2	3	1	1
Causation	1.8	2	9	10	19.5	11	9	5
Arguments	1.4	0	7	0	13.4	0	6	0
Theory testing	1.0	0	5	0	8.7	0	4	0
Decision theory	0.5	0	2	0	11.0	0	5	0
Minds and machines	0.3	0	2	0	4.5	0	2	0
Truth	1.8	0	9	0	11.7	0	5	0
Radical translation	0.2	0	1	0	2.9	0	1	0
Explanation	0.3	0	1	0	3.4	0	1	0
Personal identity	0.7	0	4	0	7.9	0	3	0
Speech acts	1.2	1	6	5	13.0	1	6	0
Sense and reference	0.8	1	4	5	6.6	6	3	3
Egalitarianism	0.1	0	0	0	0.7	0	0	0
Quantum physics	1.9	2	10	10	17.8	17	8	7
Theories and realism	1.4	0	7	0	15.1	0	7	0
Functions	0.7	0	4	0	7.9	0	3	0
Feminism	0.3	0	1	0	3.1	0	1	0
Medical ethics and Freud	0.1	0	0	0	0.5	0	0	0
Abortion and self-defence	0.2	0	1	0	1.9	0	1	0
Belief ascriptions	0.1	0	1	0	0.7	0	0	0
Thermodynamics	1.7	0	9	0	21.0	0	9	0
Knowledge	2.3	1	12	5	24.0	5	11	2
Game theory	0.2	0	1	0	1.2	0	1	0
Justification	0.8	1	4	5	8.2	8	4	4
Frankfurt cases	0.2	0	1	0	3.6	0	2	0
Concepts	1.2	1	6	5	14.1	4	6	2
Races and DNA	0.5	0	2	0	6.0	0	3	0
Modality	0.6	0	3	0	5.7	0	3	0
Reasons	0.4	0	2	0	4.9	0	2	0
Evolutionary biology	1.1	2	5	10	13.4	29	6	13
Population ethics	0.2	0	1	0	1.2	0	1	0
Formal epistemology	0.1	0	0	0	0.7	0	0	0
Wide content	0.7	0	4	0	6.5	0	3	0
Vagueness	0.9	1	5	5	7.6	2	3	1
Cognitive science	0.2	0	1	0	1.8	0	1	0
Models	1.4	2	7	10	6.7	5	3	2
Composition and constitution	1.1	0	6	0	10.8	0	5	0
Norms	0.6	0	3	0	1.6	0	1	0

1935

Table B.60: Measures of the prominence of each subject in 1935 ’s journals.

Subject	Weight	Raw	W-Ratio	R-Ratio	W-Pages	R-Pages	WP-Ratio	RP-Ratio
Psychology	2.3	4	14	24	49.3	127	22	57
Idealism	14.9	22	90	133	226.8	328	102	147
Life and value	6.6	9	40	55	97.6	123	44	55
Other history	4.1	5	25	30	61.7	86	28	39
Dewey and pragmatism	3.7	2	23	12	41.6	13	19	6
Definitions	6.1	7	37	42	82.6	75	37	34
Propositions and implications	6.2	10	37	61	73.0	111	33	50
Beauty	5.8	11	35	67	61.0	115	27	52
Physicalism	5.6	7	34	42	57.7	63	26	28
History and culture	2.1	2	13	12	37.3	49	17	22
Faith and theism	1.7	0	10	0	28.5	0	13	0
Self-consciousness	2.1	1	13	6	23.3	3	10	1
Ancient	4.0	7	24	42	49.8	98	22	44
Universals and particulars	2.5	1	15	6	34.5	5	15	2
Verification	3.4	3	20	18	44.7	36	20	16
Value	2.2	2	14	12	29.2	37	13	17
Deduction	2.7	2	17	12	37.9	27	17	12
Mechanisms	3.9	5	23	30	49.9	68	22	30
Temporal paradoxes	2.2	1	13	6	29.9	13	13	6
Classical space and time	2.8	3	17	18	35.5	25	16	11
Early modern	2.3	3	14	18	27.9	38	13	17
Meaning and use	3.2	4	19	24	44.9	56	20	25
Marx	3.3	6	20	36	57.2	91	26	41
Ordinary language	6.6	4	40	24	131.6	80	59	36
Moral conscience	0.3	0	2	0	4.5	0	2	0
Methodology of science	8.2	9	50	55	112.6	164	50	73
Heidegger and Husserl	1.3	1	8	6	14.4	8	6	4
Emotions	0.8	1	5	6	13.1	20	6	9
Ontological argument	2.0	1	12	6	21.9	5	10	2
Chemistry	2.7	2	17	12	45.2	38	20	17
Social contract theory	0.8	1	5	6	9.2	15	4	7
Kant	0.6	0	4	0	8.2	0	4	0
Promises and imperatives	0.4	0	2	0	5.7	0	3	0
Analytic/synthetic	2.2	2	13	12	24.7	10	11	4
Freedom and free will	0.5	0	3	0	5.2	0	2	0
Crime and punishment	0.3	0	2	0	4.3	0	2	0
Sets and grue	2.3	3	14	18	28.9	33	13	15
Origins and purposes	0.5	0	3	0	7.7	0	3	0
Time	1.0	1	6	6	11.4	5	5	2
Color/colour	2.0	1	12	6	22.0	7	10	3
War	0.2	0	1	0	2.9	0	1	0
Depiction	0.4	0	2	0	4.7	0	2	0
Denoting	0.3	0	2	0	4.1	0	2	0
Chance	1.6	3	10	18	10.7	13	5	6
Hume	1.2	1	7	6	16.1	11	7	5
Laws	1.6	1	10	6	22.9	2	10	1
Perception	3.0	1	18	6	36.1	14	16	6
Intention	0.8	0	5	0	4.0	0	2	0
Virtues	0.3	0	2	0	2.3	0	1	0
Space and time	1.5	0	9	0	18.9	0	8	0
Mathematics	3.8	5	23	30	50.6	77	23	34
Liberal democracy	1.0	2	6	12	12.9	24	6	11
Duties	0.1	0	1	0	1.3	0	1	0
Causation	1.7	0	10	0	32.9	0	15	0
Arguments	1.1	0	6	0	18.5	0	8	0
Theory testing	2.0	0	12	0	17.3	0	8	0
Decision theory	0.2	0	1	0	3.4	0	2	0
Minds and machines	0.3	0	2	0	5.4	0	2	0
Truth	1.5	2	9	12	15.0	25	7	11
Radical translation	0.3	0	2	0	4.0	0	2	0
Explanation	0.2	0	1	0	4.5	0	2	0
Personal identity	0.7	1	4	6	5.8	6	3	3
Speech acts	0.4	0	2	0	5.4	0	2	0
Sense and reference	0.4	0	3	0	6.8	0	3	0
Egalitarianism	0.1	0	1	0	1.2	0	1	0
Quantum physics	1.0	2	6	12	15.2	34	7	15
Theories and realism	1.3	1	8	6	17.1	10	8	4
Functions	0.5	0	3	0	7.5	0	3	0
Feminism	0.3	0	2	0	2.4	0	1	0
Medical ethics and Freud	0.2	0	1	0	1.6	0	1	0
Abortion and self-defence	0.2	0	1	0	2.0	0	1	0
Belief ascriptions	0.1	0	1	0	1.9	0	1	0
Thermodynamics	1.8	1	11	6	24.6	30	11	13
Knowledge	0.9	0	5	0	10.3	0	5	0
Game theory	0.1	0	0	0	0.6	0	0	0
Justification	0.6	0	4	0	12.2	0	5	0
Frankfurt cases	0.5	0	3	0	2.3	0	1	0
Concepts	1.1	0	6	0	17.7	0	8	0
Races and DNA	0.1	0	1	0	2.8	0	1	0
Modality	0.4	0	2	0	4.5	0	2	0
Reasons	0.4	0	3	0	5.7	0	3	0
Evolutionary biology	1.1	1	7	6	12.3	12	5	5
Population ethics	0.1	0	0	0	0.3	0	0	0
Formal epistemology	0.0	0	0	0	0.2	0	0	0
Wide content	0.6	0	4	0	2.7	0	1	0
Vagueness	0.4	0	2	0	3.2	0	1	0
Cognitive science	0.1	0	0	0	0.6	0	0	0
Models	1.1	1	6	6	8.8	2	4	1
Composition and constitution	1.2	0	7	0	12.9	0	6	0
Norms	0.2	0	1	0	2.4	0	1	0

1936

Table B.61: Measures of the prominence of each subject in 1936 ’s journals.

Subject	Weight	Raw	W-Ratio	R-Ratio	W-Pages	R-Pages	WP-Ratio	RP-Ratio
Psychology	3.4	4	18	22	40.7	38	17	16
Idealism	14.3	23	77	124	207.9	303	86	125
Life and value	5.6	4	30	22	78.6	50	32	21
Other history	4.8	6	26	32	81.4	110	34	45
Dewey and pragmatism	3.9	6	21	32	48.5	72	20	30
Definitions	8.2	8	44	43	101.2	68	42	28
Propositions and implications	9.1	9	49	48	116.0	113	48	47
Beauty	2.6	4	14	22	29.9	49	12	20
Physicalism	4.3	4	23	22	59.8	69	25	28
History and culture	1.3	0	7	0	17.5	0	7	0
Faith and theism	2.2	2	12	11	26.8	19	11	8
Self-consciousness	1.3	1	7	5	17.5	8	7	3
Ancient	5.2	7	28	38	65.9	85	27	35
Universals and particulars	5.9	6	32	32	78.8	96	32	40
Verification	4.8	6	26	32	62.9	41	26	17
Value	3.6	6	19	32	40.5	54	17	22
Deduction	4.8	4	26	22	51.1	21	21	9
Mechanisms	3.0	5	16	27	39.1	88	16	36
Temporal paradoxes	3.5	2	19	11	41.6	16	17	7
Classical space and time	1.3	1	7	5	17.5	8	7	3
Early modern	2.9	3	16	16	36.8	37	15	15
Meaning and use	7.1	10	38	54	84.6	118	35	49
Marx	2.9	5	16	27	51.7	82	21	34
Ordinary language	8.0	13	43	70	149.7	304	62	125
Moral conscience	2.7	2	14	11	25.5	24	11	10
Methodology of science	5.6	4	30	22	71.5	39	29	16
Heidegger and Husserl	0.4	0	2	0	7.4	0	3	0
Emotions	1.1	2	6	11	11.0	18	5	7
Ontological argument	2.2	2	12	11	29.8	40	12	16
Chemistry	2.1	3	11	16	21.1	26	9	11
Social contract theory	0.6	0	3	0	7.2	0	3	0
Kant	2.1	2	11	11	23.1	22	10	9
Promises and imperatives	0.9	0	5	0	14.0	0	6	0
Analytic/synthetic	3.1	3	17	16	48.7	86	20	35
Freedom and free will	1.4	3	7	16	10.9	20	5	8
Crime and punishment	0.1	0	1	0	0.9	0	0	0
Sets and grue	3.1	4	17	22	58.8	122	24	50
Origins and purposes	0.7	0	4	0	8.1	0	3	0
Time	1.2	0	7	0	23.0	0	9	0
Color/colour	1.9	0	10	0	23.0	0	9	0
War	0.5	1	3	5	4.5	5	2	2
Depiction	0.7	0	4	0	11.2	0	5	0
Denoting	1.0	0	6	0	9.9	0	4	0
Chance	2.0	3	11	16	15.4	17	6	7
Hume	0.9	1	5	5	10.3	16	4	7
Laws	1.7	1	9	5	20.3	8	8	3
Perception	3.5	3	19	16	43.6	24	18	10
Intention	0.3	0	1	0	3.6	0	1	0
Virtues	0.6	0	3	0	9.0	0	4	0
Space and time	0.6	0	3	0	9.3	0	4	0
Mathematics	2.0	2	11	11	31.9	21	13	9
Liberal democracy	1.1	0	6	0	10.4	0	4	0
Duties	0.7	0	4	0	6.0	0	2	0
Causation	1.3	0	7	0	16.8	0	7	0
Arguments	1.0	0	5	0	14.3	0	6	0
Theory testing	1.8	1	10	5	18.3	5	8	2
Decision theory	1.9	3	10	16	24.2	30	10	12
Minds and machines	0.4	0	2	0	6.3	0	3	0
Truth	2.3	2	12	11	25.0	8	10	3
Radical translation	0.6	0	3	0	6.4	0	3	0
Explanation	0.5	0	2	0	6.6	0	3	0
Personal identity	0.4	0	2	0	4.8	0	2	0
Speech acts	0.8	0	4	0	5.5	0	2	0
Sense and reference	1.2	1	7	5	9.5	8	4	3
Egalitarianism	0.2	0	1	0	2.8	0	1	0
Quantum physics	0.7	1	4	5	9.3	18	4	7
Theories and realism	1.4	1	8	5	15.0	5	6	2
Functions	1.2	0	6	0	11.8	0	5	0
Feminism	0.4	0	2	0	1.5	0	1	0
Medical ethics and Freud	0.2	0	1	0	3.3	0	1	0
Abortion and self-defence	0.4	0	2	0	1.6	0	1	0
Belief ascriptions	0.2	0	1	0	2.1	0	1	0
Thermodynamics	1.1	0	6	0	14.3	0	6	0
Knowledge	1.6	0	8	0	23.5	0	10	0
Game theory	0.4	0	2	0	2.6	0	1	0
Justification	0.4	0	2	0	6.6	0	3	0
Frankfurt cases	0.4	1	2	5	3.5	4	1	2
Concepts	1.4	1	8	5	20.3	12	8	5
Races and DNA	0.1	0	1	0	1.7	0	1	0
Modality	1.0	0	5	0	7.9	0	3	0
Reasons	0.7	0	4	0	8.1	0	3	0
Evolutionary biology	0.5	0	2	0	7.0	0	3	0
Population ethics	0.2	0	1	0	2.6	0	1	0
Formal epistemology	0.1	0	0	0	0.7	0	0	0
Wide content	0.6	0	3	0	3.4	0	1	0
Vagueness	0.4	0	2	0	3.8	0	2	0
Cognitive science	0.2	0	1	0	1.2	0	0	0
Models	0.6	0	3	0	5.6	0	2	0
Composition and constitution	0.6	0	3	0	9.7	0	4	0
Norms	0.2	0	1	0	3.6	0	1	0

1937

Table B.62: Measures of the prominence of each subject in 1937 ’s journals.

Subject	Weight	Raw	W-Ratio	R-Ratio	W-Pages	R-Pages	WP-Ratio	RP-Ratio
Psychology	1.1	0	7	0	22.5	0	10	0
Idealism	14.0	18	82	105	188.7	228	85	102
Life and value	5.8	7	34	41	85.1	78	38	35
Other history	6.3	7	37	41	90.8	124	41	56
Dewey and pragmatism	3.8	4	22	23	45.2	49	20	22
Definitions	7.4	5	43	29	79.8	63	36	28
Propositions and implications	7.0	10	41	58	73.2	70	33	31
Beauty	2.4	4	14	23	31.5	50	14	22
Physicalism	3.2	2	19	12	42.1	21	19	9
History and culture	2.1	2	12	12	25.5	22	11	10
Faith and theism	1.6	1	9	6	25.6	22	11	10
Self-consciousness	1.3	0	7	0	18.1	0	8	0
Ancient	2.4	5	14	29	27.8	58	12	26
Universals and particulars	2.0	1	12	6	24.0	13	11	6
Verification	4.4	5	26	29	72.5	117	32	52
Value	3.8	5	22	29	52.5	77	24	34
Deduction	2.8	1	17	6	30.9	4	14	2
Mechanisms	1.7	4	10	23	29.4	83	13	37
Temporal paradoxes	1.7	2	10	12	31.0	39	14	17
Classical space and time	2.4	1	14	6	32.0	16	14	7
Early modern	4.5	8	26	47	66.1	120	30	54
Meaning and use	6.6	9	38	53	72.2	71	32	32
Marx	2.3	1	14	6	35.2	23	16	10
Ordinary language	8.2	6	48	35	140.8	171	63	77
Moral conscience	2.8	5	16	29	30.7	48	14	21
Methodology of science	6.3	7	37	41	68.9	50	31	22
Heidegger and Husserl	1.4	1	8	6	13.2	3	6	1
Emotions	0.6	0	4	0	7.4	0	3	0
Ontological argument	1.2	1	7	6	13.6	5	6	2
Chemistry	3.7	6	21	35	56.1	113	25	51
Social contract theory	0.6	0	4	0	9.3	0	4	0
Kant	3.9	8	23	47	35.7	72	16	32
Promises and imperatives	1.3	0	7	0	15.2	0	7	0
Analytic/synthetic	2.5	3	15	18	36.8	52	16	23
Freedom and free will	1.2	2	7	12	15.6	25	7	11
Crime and punishment	0.4	0	2	0	5.1	0	2	0
Sets and grue	1.4	0	8	0	26.3	0	12	0
Origins and purposes	1.0	0	6	0	7.3	0	3	0
Time	1.3	1	7	6	23.7	33	11	15
Color/colour	1.6	1	9	6	16.4	2	7	1
War	0.3	0	2	0	3.2	0	1	0
Depiction	0.5	0	3	0	5.9	0	3	0
Denoting	0.5	0	3	0	7.3	0	3	0
Chance	1.5	2	9	12	27.4	34	12	15
Hume	0.5	0	3	0	4.4	0	2	0
Laws	1.1	0	7	0	17.1	0	8	0
Perception	2.3	0	14	0	32.3	0	14	0
Intention	0.1	0	1	0	2.0	0	1	0
Virtues	1.3	0	8	0	14.1	0	6	0
Space and time	1.8	2	11	12	23.4	23	10	10
Mathematics	3.4	6	20	35	37.1	69	17	31
Liberal democracy	1.0	2	6	12	15.3	26	7	12
Duties	0.7	2	4	12	9.6	24	4	11
Causation	1.9	3	11	18	27.5	37	12	17
Arguments	1.6	0	9	0	19.6	0	9	0
Theory testing	1.3	1	8	6	20.6	10	9	4
Decision theory	0.5	0	3	0	6.9	0	3	0
Minds and machines	0.4	0	2	0	5.7	0	3	0
Truth	3.5	4	20	23	25.3	21	11	9
Radical translation	0.4	0	2	0	4.6	0	2	0
Explanation	0.2	0	1	0	2.6	0	1	0
Personal identity	1.0	1	6	6	6.6	2	3	1
Speech acts	0.2	0	1	0	1.9	0	1	0
Sense and reference	1.3	1	8	6	8.9	7	4	3
Egalitarianism	0.7	0	4	0	4.6	0	2	0
Quantum physics	1.2	2	7	12	27.7	44	12	20
Theories and realism	1.3	0	7	0	17.0	0	8	0
Functions	0.6	0	4	0	7.5	0	3	0
Feminism	0.2	0	1	0	1.7	0	1	0
Medical ethics and Freud	0.1	0	1	0	1.0	0	0	0
Abortion and self-defence	0.1	0	1	0	1.2	0	1	0
Belief ascriptions	0.4	1	2	6	2.2	4	1	2
Thermodynamics	1.3	1	7	6	17.6	10	8	4
Knowledge	1.2	0	7	0	17.7	0	8	0
Game theory	0.3	0	2	0	3.2	0	1	0
Justification	0.3	0	2	0	6.4	0	3	0
Frankfurt cases	0.2	0	1	0	1.8	0	1	0
Concepts	1.1	0	6	0	13.7	0	6	0
Races and DNA	0.3	0	2	0	4.3	0	2	0
Modality	0.8	0	5	0	6.2	0	3	0
Reasons	0.5	0	3	0	6.7	0	3	0
Evolutionary biology	0.2	0	1	0	3.5	0	2	0
Population ethics	0.1	0	0	0	1.1	0	0	0
Formal epistemology	0.1	0	1	0	0.8	0	0	0
Wide content	0.5	0	3	0	5.7	0	3	0
Vagueness	0.7	0	4	0	9.0	0	4	0
Cognitive science	0.2	0	1	0	2.2	0	1	0
Models	0.3	0	2	0	3.8	0	2	0
Composition and constitution	0.6	0	4	0	8.2	0	4	0
Norms	0.3	0	2	0	5.1	0	2	0

1938

Table B.63: Measures of the prominence of each subject in 1938 ’s journals.

Subject	Weight	Raw	W-Ratio	R-Ratio	W-Pages	R-Pages	WP-Ratio	RP-Ratio
Psychology	2.1	2	11	10	32.3	26	12	10
Idealism	17.5	26	89	131	275.2	408	102	151
Life and value	7.8	8	39	40	105.5	87	39	32
Other history	8.3	8	42	40	111.3	119	41	44
Dewey and pragmatism	4.4	1	22	5	57.3	11	21	4
Definitions	6.8	5	34	25	102.5	84	38	31
Propositions and implications	6.6	11	33	56	82.4	132	31	49
Beauty	6.0	11	30	56	62.8	115	23	43
Physicalism	4.7	3	24	15	62.0	44	23	16
History and culture	3.1	5	16	25	41.4	49	15	18
Faith and theism	2.3	4	11	20	29.6	38	11	14
Self-consciousness	1.6	1	8	5	19.6	6	7	2
Ancient	2.4	3	12	15	42.3	61	16	23
Universals and particulars	2.7	3	14	15	37.6	43	14	16
Verification	5.2	4	26	20	59.5	20	22	7
Value	3.8	6	19	30	46.4	76	17	28
Deduction	3.4	2	17	10	34.6	9	13	3
Mechanisms	1.7	0	9	0	27.3	0	10	0
Temporal paradoxes	2.8	2	14	10	31.9	10	12	4
Classical space and time	1.2	0	6	0	12.0	0	4	0
Early modern	3.8	6	19	30	61.5	101	23	37
Meaning and use	8.3	13	42	66	108.2	174	40	64
Marx	3.5	2	18	10	38.8	12	14	4
Ordinary language	11.0	15	56	76	192.5	304	71	113
Moral conscience	3.3	5	17	25	41.3	75	15	28
Methodology of science	8.7	8	44	40	106.0	90	39	33
Heidegger and Husserl	1.1	1	5	5	15.8	12	6	4
Emotions	1.1	0	6	0	12.9	0	5	0
Ontological argument	1.4	0	7	0	15.1	0	6	0
Chemistry	2.8	5	14	25	39.7	79	15	29
Social contract theory	1.3	2	6	10	34.2	72	13	27
Kant	1.5	2	8	10	19.5	19	7	7
Promises and imperatives	1.3	2	7	10	25.5	65	9	24
Analytic/synthetic	3.3	3	17	15	37.9	20	14	7
Freedom and free will	0.6	0	3	0	7.9	0	3	0
Crime and punishment	0.8	1	4	5	12.8	28	5	10
Sets and grue	1.5	1	8	5	14.0	4	5	1
Origins and purposes	0.9	0	5	0	12.4	0	5	0
Time	1.2	0	6	0	15.8	0	6	0
Color/colour	1.0	0	5	0	13.7	0	5	0
War	0.9	1	5	5	9.6	7	4	3
Depiction	1.0	0	5	0	10.1	0	4	0
Denoting	1.0	1	5	5	10.4	4	4	1
Chance	2.5	7	13	35	30.9	78	11	29
Hume	0.5	0	3	0	6.6	0	2	0
Laws	2.0	1	10	5	23.2	8	9	3
Perception	4.3	2	22	10	53.4	9	20	3
Intention	0.2	0	1	0	3.1	0	1	0
Virtues	0.9	2	5	10	10.8	24	4	9
Space and time	1.6	2	8	10	18.1	18	7	7
Mathematics	1.7	1	8	5	22.8	12	8	4
Liberal democracy	1.7	0	8	0	28.5	0	11	0
Duties	0.5	0	3	0	10.7	0	4	0
Causation	2.0	4	10	20	34.0	67	13	25
Arguments	1.3	0	7	0	19.6	0	7	0
Theory testing	1.6	1	8	5	19.3	9	7	3
Decision theory	0.5	0	2	0	6.7	0	2	0
Minds and machines	0.4	0	2	0	5.4	0	2	0
Truth	2.3	2	12	10	23.2	16	9	6
Radical translation	0.7	0	4	0	6.1	0	2	0
Explanation	0.5	0	3	0	6.0	0	2	0
Personal identity	0.4	0	2	0	5.3	0	2	0
Speech acts	0.9	0	4	0	12.6	0	5	0
Sense and reference	1.0	0	5	0	11.4	0	4	0
Egalitarianism	0.3	0	1	0	6.0	0	2	0
Quantum physics	1.3	1	6	5	18.0	15	7	6
Theories and realism	1.8	0	9	0	24.4	0	9	0
Functions	0.7	0	4	0	7.4	0	3	0
Feminism	0.3	0	2	0	6.1	0	2	0
Medical ethics and Freud	0.3	0	2	0	3.2	0	1	0
Abortion and self-defence	0.1	0	1	0	1.9	0	1	0
Belief ascriptions	0.1	0	1	0	1.5	0	1	0
Thermodynamics	0.9	0	5	0	12.7	0	5	0
Knowledge	1.2	0	6	0	18.9	0	7	0
Game theory	0.1	0	1	0	2.0	0	1	0
Justification	0.9	0	4	0	12.2	0	5	0
Frankfurt cases	0.4	0	2	0	4.0	0	1	0
Concepts	1.9	1	10	5	28.1	8	10	3
Races and DNA	0.1	0	1	0	1.9	0	1	0
Modality	0.4	0	2	0	4.6	0	2	0
Reasons	0.6	0	3	0	8.4	0	3	0
Evolutionary biology	0.2	0	1	0	2.6	0	1	0
Population ethics	0.1	0	1	0	1.2	0	0	0
Formal epistemology	0.1	0	0	0	0.8	0	0	0
Wide content	0.3	0	1	0	4.9	0	2	0
Vagueness	0.6	0	3	0	5.6	0	2	0
Cognitive science	0.1	0	1	0	2.3	0	1	0
Models	0.5	1	3	5	9.8	30	4	11
Composition and constitution	0.8	0	4	0	16.7	0	6	0
Norms	0.4	0	2	0	5.7	0	2	0

1939

Table B.64: Measures of the prominence of each subject in 1939 ’s journals.

Subject	Weight	Raw	W-Ratio	R-Ratio	W-Pages	R-Pages	WP-Ratio	RP-Ratio
Psychology	2.5	3	12	15	49.7	74	18	27
Idealism	14.5	26	71	127	218.8	451	79	163
Life and value	8.3	7	40	34	136.5	109	49	39
Other history	5.7	5	28	25	77.8	60	28	22
Dewey and pragmatism	5.6	7	27	34	74.0	86	27	31
Definitions	7.2	7	36	34	97.9	93	35	34
Propositions and implications	5.6	7	27	34	62.2	58	22	21
Beauty	3.4	6	16	29	42.7	85	15	31
Physicalism	4.5	5	22	25	55.8	49	20	18
History and culture	4.9	8	24	39	66.0	121	24	44
Faith and theism	1.6	1	8	5	24.6	10	9	4
Self-consciousness	1.2	0	6	0	20.0	0	7	0
Ancient	3.8	6	19	29	57.7	112	21	40
Universals and particulars	4.8	6	23	29	61.3	61	22	22
Verification	5.0	5	25	25	63.2	53	23	19
Value	3.9	4	19	20	57.0	62	21	22
Deduction	3.7	4	18	20	48.9	45	18	16
Mechanisms	2.6	2	13	10	34.8	24	13	9
Temporal paradoxes	1.2	0	6	0	15.0	0	5	0
Classical space and time	1.4	1	7	5	18.6	13	7	5
Early modern	2.8	4	14	20	34.0	49	12	18
Meaning and use	6.2	8	31	39	76.7	104	28	38
Marx	4.4	7	22	34	66.8	127	24	46
Ordinary language	11.7	11	57	54	209.5	224	76	81
Moral conscience	4.4	5	22	25	69.3	45	25	16
Methodology of science	8.8	10	43	49	92.1	69	33	25
Heidegger and Husserl	3.4	4	16	20	17.9	8	6	3
Emotions	2.2	3	11	15	34.6	61	13	22
Ontological argument	1.3	0	7	0	19.7	0	7	0
Chemistry	3.4	6	17	29	38.8	65	14	23
Social contract theory	2.0	2	10	10	28.4	31	10	11
Kant	1.9	2	9	10	30.2	35	11	13
Promises and imperatives	2.5	2	12	10	35.6	21	13	8
Analytic/synthetic	2.1	1	10	5	25.4	12	9	4
Freedom and free will	1.5	3	7	15	22.1	39	8	14
Crime and punishment	2.2	2	11	10	25.8	20	9	7
Sets and grue	1.6	0	8	0	12.9	0	5	0
Origins and purposes	1.3	1	6	5	10.0	2	4	1
Time	1.9	0	9	0	26.9	0	10	0
Color/colour	2.0	0	10	0	23.8	0	9	0
War	0.7	0	4	0	8.3	0	3	0
Depiction	0.6	0	3	0	6.5	0	2	0
Denoting	1.2	1	6	5	13.3	9	5	3
Chance	2.1	4	10	20	22.4	74	8	27
Hume	2.0	3	10	15	26.7	26	10	9
Laws	1.5	0	7	0	20.5	0	7	0
Perception	4.3	3	21	15	52.4	35	19	13
Intention	0.3	0	2	0	3.2	0	1	0
Virtues	0.3	0	1	0	5.4	0	2	0
Space and time	1.0	1	5	5	14.4	26	5	9
Mathematics	1.0	1	5	5	17.4	16	6	6
Liberal democracy	3.1	5	15	25	43.3	66	16	24
Duties	1.8	1	9	5	26.7	12	10	4
Causation	1.0	0	5	0	15.1	0	5	0
Arguments	1.5	0	7	0	24.3	0	9	0
Theory testing	1.8	1	9	5	22.3	9	8	3
Decision theory	0.6	0	3	0	7.9	0	3	0
Minds and machines	0.8	0	4	0	9.4	0	3	0
Truth	2.0	0	10	0	21.7	0	8	0
Radical translation	0.8	0	4	0	8.0	0	3	0
Explanation	0.9	0	5	0	11.8	0	4	0
Personal identity	0.5	0	3	0	8.7	0	3	0
Speech acts	0.7	0	3	0	6.6	0	2	0
Sense and reference	0.5	0	3	0	6.1	0	2	0
Egalitarianism	0.5	1	2	5	5.6	6	2	2
Quantum physics	0.3	0	2	0	5.3	0	2	0
Theories and realism	1.5	0	7	0	25.2	0	9	0
Functions	0.9	0	5	0	10.0	0	4	0
Feminism	0.4	0	2	0	5.7	0	2	0
Medical ethics and Freud	0.2	0	1	0	1.8	0	1	0
Abortion and self-defence	0.3	0	1	0	1.8	0	1	0
Belief ascriptions	0.1	0	0	0	1.1	0	0	0
Thermodynamics	1.1	0	5	0	13.5	0	5	0
Knowledge	1.2	0	6	0	13.6	0	5	0
Game theory	0.1	0	1	0	1.4	0	0	0
Justification	1.0	1	5	5	11.1	6	4	2
Frankfurt cases	0.3	0	1	0	3.2	0	1	0
Concepts	1.1	0	6	0	20.6	0	7	0
Races and DNA	1.0	1	5	5	8.2	5	3	2
Modality	0.5	0	3	0	4.9	0	2	0
Reasons	0.7	0	3	0	10.7	0	4	0
Evolutionary biology	0.3	0	2	0	5.5	0	2	0
Population ethics	0.1	0	0	0	0.9	0	0	0
Formal epistemology	0.1	0	0	0	0.8	0	0	0
Wide content	0.4	0	2	0	4.0	0	1	0
Vagueness	0.8	0	4	0	10.3	0	4	0
Cognitive science	0.1	0	0	0	0.7	0	0	0
Models	0.2	0	1	0	2.7	0	1	0
Composition and constitution	0.8	0	4	0	10.4	0	4	0
Norms	0.3	0	1	0	3.6	0	1	0

1940

Table B.65: Measures of the prominence of each subject in 1940 ’s journals.

Subject	Weight	Raw	W-Ratio	R-Ratio	W-Pages	R-Pages	WP-Ratio	RP-Ratio
Psychology	4.7	10	23	48	70.8	129	26	48
Idealism	15.4	20	74	97	225.9	316	84	118
Life and value	8.9	7	43	34	132.7	116	49	43
Other history	8.0	10	38	48	112.3	134	42	50
Dewey and pragmatism	5.9	6	28	29	70.8	79	26	29
Definitions	6.4	3	31	14	76.1	38	28	14
Propositions and implications	5.7	6	28	29	58.7	54	22	20
Beauty	4.9	9	24	43	57.4	102	21	38
Physicalism	4.6	4	22	19	57.0	38	21	14
History and culture	3.4	7	17	34	56.2	108	21	40
Faith and theism	2.3	1	11	5	31.1	15	12	6
Self-consciousness	2.1	0	10	0	29.2	0	11	0
Ancient	3.2	5	16	24	43.3	80	16	30
Universals and particulars	3.1	2	15	10	32.1	17	12	6
Verification	3.5	2	17	10	41.4	14	15	5
Value	2.9	0	14	0	35.6	0	13	0
Deduction	5.1	6	25	29	51.5	44	19	16
Mechanisms	3.2	1	16	5	42.6	23	16	9
Temporal paradoxes	3.0	2	14	10	38.9	25	14	9
Classical space and time	2.2	1	11	5	25.3	10	9	4
Early modern	3.5	7	17	34	42.1	90	16	33
Meaning and use	5.8	10	28	48	76.6	130	29	48
Marx	5.1	6	25	29	77.5	111	29	41
Ordinary language	10.4	10	50	48	163.6	201	61	75
Moral conscience	4.7	12	23	58	54.9	112	20	42
Methodology of science	9.9	8	48	39	115.2	90	43	33
Heidegger and Husserl	2.9	4	14	19	48.4	69	18	26
Emotions	1.8	1	9	5	25.4	30	9	11
Ontological argument	1.9	2	9	10	20.1	16	7	6
Chemistry	3.1	6	15	29	40.6	63	15	23
Social contract theory	2.9	5	14	24	39.8	77	15	29
Kant	2.6	2	12	10	33.0	29	12	11
Promises and imperatives	2.0	1	10	5	29.4	16	11	6
Analytic/synthetic	3.1	1	15	5	31.3	9	12	3
Freedom and free will	2.2	4	11	19	22.8	31	8	12
Crime and punishment	0.5	0	2	0	10.0	0	4	0
Sets and grue	0.4	0	2	0	6.1	0	2	0
Origins and purposes	1.4	1	7	5	13.7	2	5	1
Time	1.1	0	5	0	14.0	0	5	0
Color/colour	2.5	3	12	14	24.7	25	9	9
War	1.2	1	6	5	12.1	4	4	1
Depiction	1.7	1	8	5	19.8	9	7	3
Denoting	0.5	0	2	0	7.8	0	3	0
Chance	2.5	5	12	24	26.1	61	10	23
Hume	0.3	0	2	0	4.6	0	2	0
Laws	1.5	0	7	0	19.6	0	7	0
Perception	3.5	2	17	10	48.6	19	18	7
Intention	0.3	1	2	5	4.3	7	2	3
Virtues	0.8	0	4	0	8.5	0	3	0
Space and time	0.6	0	3	0	7.6	0	3	0
Mathematics	1.5	1	7	5	18.5	18	7	7
Liberal democracy	1.6	1	8	5	35.6	21	13	8
Duties	0.8	0	4	0	10.1	0	4	0
Causation	1.7	2	8	10	21.3	22	8	8
Arguments	1.4	1	7	5	16.7	5	6	2
Theory testing	0.9	1	4	5	12.4	20	5	7
Decision theory	0.5	0	2	0	7.3	0	3	0
Minds and machines	0.5	0	2	0	8.1	0	3	0
Truth	1.2	0	6	0	13.1	0	5	0
Radical translation	0.5	1	2	5	8.0	19	3	7
Explanation	0.3	0	2	0	4.4	0	2	0
Personal identity	0.5	0	2	0	5.6	0	2	0
Speech acts	1.2	2	6	10	7.8	8	3	3
Sense and reference	0.4	0	2	0	2.9	0	1	0
Egalitarianism	0.3	0	1	0	3.8	0	1	0
Quantum physics	1.4	2	7	10	14.4	23	5	9
Theories and realism	1.8	0	9	0	23.8	0	9	0
Functions	0.4	0	2	0	5.4	0	2	0
Feminism	0.4	0	2	0	6.1	0	2	0
Medical ethics and Freud	0.2	0	1	0	3.1	0	1	0
Abortion and self-defence	0.1	0	1	0	1.2	0	0	0
Belief ascriptions	0.3	0	1	0	1.7	0	1	0
Thermodynamics	1.3	1	6	5	14.2	8	5	3
Knowledge	0.9	0	4	0	10.6	0	4	0
Game theory	0.2	0	1	0	1.6	0	1	0
Justification	1.0	0	5	0	10.4	0	4	0
Frankfurt cases	0.3	0	1	0	5.5	0	2	0
Concepts	1.2	0	6	0	16.3	0	6	0
Races and DNA	0.5	0	2	0	6.9	0	3	0
Modality	0.5	0	2	0	5.6	0	2	0
Reasons	0.8	0	4	0	11.3	0	4	0
Evolutionary biology	0.6	0	3	0	6.3	0	2	0
Population ethics	0.1	0	0	0	0.6	0	0	0
Formal epistemology	0.0	0	0	0	0.5	0	0	0
Wide content	0.6	0	3	0	7.0	0	3	0
Vagueness	0.4	0	2	0	5.7	0	2	0
Cognitive science	0.3	0	1	0	3.0	0	1	0
Models	0.6	0	3	0	4.0	0	1	0
Composition and constitution	0.6	0	3	0	6.5	0	2	0
Norms	0.3	0	1	0	3.9	0	1	0

1941

Table B.66: Measures of the prominence of each subject in 1941 ’s journals.

Subject	Weight	Raw	W-Ratio	R-Ratio	W-Pages	R-Pages	WP-Ratio	RP-Ratio
Psychology	3.0	3	14	14	47.3	51	17	19
Idealism	15.5	23	73	107	207.5	308	76	112
Life and value	9.7	6	45	28	136.4	108	50	39
Other history	5.3	7	25	33	58.0	83	21	30
Dewey and pragmatism	5.5	4	25	19	74.0	49	27	18
Definitions	7.0	8	33	37	87.3	86	32	31
Propositions and implications	3.6	5	17	23	40.0	64	15	23
Beauty	5.2	12	24	56	59.0	147	21	54
Physicalism	5.9	6	28	28	56.9	48	21	17
History and culture	3.0	3	14	14	30.7	29	11	11
Faith and theism	2.4	0	11	0	29.5	0	11	0
Self-consciousness	3.6	2	17	9	33.3	6	12	2
Ancient	2.9	4	14	19	49.3	72	18	26
Universals and particulars	1.9	0	9	0	22.2	0	8	0
Verification	4.0	4	19	19	45.2	35	16	13
Value	3.4	2	16	9	40.9	20	15	7
Deduction	2.4	0	11	0	29.9	0	11	0
Mechanisms	3.8	5	18	23	44.9	69	16	25
Temporal paradoxes	3.4	2	16	9	41.0	18	15	7
Classical space and time	3.2	2	15	9	43.8	26	16	9
Early modern	3.8	6	18	28	53.5	94	19	34
Meaning and use	4.1	3	19	14	60.9	43	22	16
Marx	4.8	6	22	28	68.5	97	25	35
Ordinary language	9.5	11	45	51	171.2	239	62	87
Moral conscience	2.2	2	10	9	30.8	20	11	7
Methodology of science	8.3	9	39	42	95.5	92	35	34
Heidegger and Husserl	9.7	19	45	89	90.0	199	33	72
Emotions	1.7	2	8	9	41.0	54	15	20
Ontological argument	2.0	1	10	5	23.0	3	8	1
Chemistry	8.0	11	37	51	94.2	106	34	39
Social contract theory	1.4	1	7	5	21.1	6	8	2
Kant	1.9	1	9	5	22.1	14	8	5
Promises and imperatives	1.8	1	8	5	22.7	15	8	5
Analytic/synthetic	2.8	2	13	9	33.3	12	12	4
Freedom and free will	1.1	2	5	9	12.2	19	4	7
Crime and punishment	1.0	3	5	14	21.6	73	8	27
Sets and grue	1.3	2	6	9	20.0	22	7	8
Origins and purposes	1.2	0	6	0	19.0	0	7	0
Time	2.5	3	12	14	32.8	38	12	14
Color/colour	1.1	0	5	0	13.6	0	5	0
War	0.7	0	3	0	9.3	0	3	0
Depiction	1.6	1	7	5	22.9	6	8	2
Denoting	1.0	2	5	9	11.7	22	4	8
Chance	2.5	4	12	19	31.3	51	11	19
Hume	1.1	1	5	5	13.8	15	5	5
Laws	1.6	1	7	5	19.5	13	7	5
Perception	3.4	2	16	9	44.6	18	16	7
Intention	0.4	0	2	0	5.7	0	2	0
Virtues	0.4	0	2	0	6.9	0	2	0
Space and time	2.4	2	11	9	25.8	16	9	6
Mathematics	1.7	1	8	5	17.1	8	6	3
Liberal democracy	3.3	3	15	14	51.1	39	19	14
Duties	0.7	1	3	5	8.2	7	3	3
Causation	1.5	0	7	0	20.3	0	7	0
Arguments	1.3	0	6	0	17.2	0	6	0
Theory testing	1.1	0	5	0	15.3	0	6	0
Decision theory	0.8	1	4	5	12.1	21	4	8
Minds and machines	0.9	0	4	0	10.8	0	4	0
Truth	1.7	0	8	0	17.0	0	6	0
Radical translation	0.5	1	3	5	6.7	11	2	4
Explanation	0.5	1	2	5	5.4	7	2	3
Personal identity	0.6	0	3	0	6.8	0	2	0
Speech acts	0.5	1	2	5	7.3	13	3	5
Sense and reference	0.4	0	2	0	3.9	0	1	0
Egalitarianism	0.1	0	1	0	1.4	0	1	0
Quantum physics	1.9	3	9	14	34.3	72	13	26
Theories and realism	1.5	0	7	0	17.4	0	6	0
Functions	0.8	0	4	0	11.7	0	4	0
Feminism	1.0	1	5	5	8.3	6	3	2
Medical ethics and Freud	0.2	0	1	0	4.3	0	2	0
Abortion and self-defence	0.2	0	1	0	2.1	0	1	0
Belief ascriptions	0.1	0	0	0	1.1	0	0	0
Thermodynamics	2.2	2	10	9	25.8	28	9	10
Knowledge	2.0	0	10	0	27.3	0	10	0
Game theory	0.6	2	3	9	6.6	22	2	8
Justification	0.6	0	3	0	7.5	0	3	0
Frankfurt cases	0.3	0	1	0	5.2	0	2	0
Concepts	1.4	1	6	5	16.6	5	6	2
Races and DNA	0.9	0	4	0	8.7	0	3	0
Modality	0.7	0	3	0	4.7	0	2	0
Reasons	0.5	0	2	0	6.8	0	2	0
Evolutionary biology	0.4	0	2	0	5.9	0	2	0
Population ethics	0.2	0	1	0	2.1	0	1	0
Formal epistemology	0.1	0	1	0	1.3	0	0	0
Wide content	0.6	0	3	0	5.7	0	2	0
Vagueness	0.3	0	2	0	3.3	0	1	0
Cognitive science	0.3	0	1	0	2.0	0	1	0
Models	0.4	0	2	0	3.1	0	1	0
Composition and constitution	0.7	0	3	0	10.3	0	4	0
Norms	0.5	0	3	0	8.2	0	3	0

1942

Table B.67: Measures of the prominence of each subject in 1942 ’s journals.

Subject	Weight	Raw	W-Ratio	R-Ratio	W-Pages	R-Pages	WP-Ratio	RP-Ratio
Psychology	3.2	1	15	5	41.5	26	16	10
Idealism	13.8	21	66	100	194.7	298	74	113
Life and value	12.4	15	59	71	176.0	230	67	88
Other history	6.6	7	31	33	89.1	86	34	33
Dewey and pragmatism	6.2	9	30	43	69.3	81	26	31
Definitions	7.4	8	35	38	80.8	90	31	34
Propositions and implications	4.2	4	20	19	36.2	17	14	6
Beauty	5.8	10	28	48	46.3	75	18	29
Physicalism	6.6	11	31	52	60.7	99	23	38
History and culture	3.5	4	17	19	48.0	48	18	18
Faith and theism	2.5	2	12	10	44.7	42	17	16
Self-consciousness	2.4	1	12	5	35.9	30	14	11
Ancient	2.7	3	13	14	50.4	55	19	21
Universals and particulars	3.3	5	16	24	41.1	79	16	30
Verification	4.8	6	23	29	52.3	59	20	22
Value	4.8	6	23	29	53.3	46	20	18
Deduction	3.0	3	14	14	31.6	27	12	10
Mechanisms	3.3	1	16	5	36.7	10	14	4
Temporal paradoxes	2.1	1	10	5	19.4	2	7	1
Classical space and time	3.7	4	18	19	38.9	62	15	24
Early modern	4.4	8	21	38	90.7	207	35	79
Meaning and use	4.5	5	21	24	54.1	50	21	19
Marx	5.5	8	26	38	82.4	122	31	46
Ordinary language	8.3	6	40	29	114.6	96	44	37
Moral conscience	3.5	4	17	19	45.1	57	17	22
Methodology of science	7.0	7	33	33	82.2	78	31	30
Heidegger and Husserl	5.2	8	25	38	81.9	126	31	48
Emotions	1.8	1	9	5	19.5	8	7	3
Ontological argument	1.8	0	9	0	22.5	0	9	0
Chemistry	3.3	3	16	14	48.0	34	18	13
Social contract theory	0.9	1	4	5	11.8	4	5	2
Kant	1.8	1	8	5	23.3	29	9	11
Promises and imperatives	1.8	1	8	5	22.4	10	9	4
Analytic/synthetic	2.3	1	11	5	22.8	7	9	3
Freedom and free will	2.0	3	10	14	28.9	39	11	15
Crime and punishment	1.7	3	8	14	17.9	27	7	10
Sets and grue	1.1	0	5	0	16.9	0	6	0
Origins and purposes	0.9	0	4	0	10.5	0	4	0
Time	1.4	1	7	5	19.1	22	7	8
Color/colour	1.6	1	8	5	17.8	8	7	3
War	1.4	0	7	0	22.5	0	9	0
Depiction	0.9	0	4	0	10.1	0	4	0
Denoting	1.5	2	7	10	12.8	19	5	7
Chance	1.4	2	6	10	11.6	15	4	6
Hume	0.7	0	3	0	11.7	0	4	0
Laws	1.9	0	9	0	23.9	0	9	0
Perception	3.3	2	16	10	32.5	11	12	4
Intention	0.3	0	1	0	3.8	0	1	0
Virtues	1.1	2	5	10	11.5	12	4	5
Space and time	0.6	0	3	0	7.7	0	3	0
Mathematics	1.8	2	9	10	20.0	14	8	5
Liberal democracy	3.4	4	16	19	54.0	74	21	28
Duties	0.5	1	2	5	4.5	0	2	0
Causation	1.6	2	8	10	16.6	14	6	5
Arguments	1.4	0	7	0	18.7	0	7	0
Theory testing	1.2	0	6	0	17.0	0	6	0
Decision theory	0.9	0	4	0	12.5	0	5	0
Minds and machines	0.3	0	2	0	3.8	0	1	0
Truth	1.7	0	8	0	17.5	0	7	0
Radical translation	1.0	0	5	0	9.8	0	4	0
Explanation	0.8	2	4	10	9.0	22	3	8
Personal identity	0.6	0	3	0	7.8	0	3	0
Speech acts	0.4	0	2	0	4.1	0	2	0
Sense and reference	0.7	1	3	5	8.5	9	3	3
Egalitarianism	0.4	0	2	0	5.7	0	2	0
Quantum physics	0.7	1	3	5	4.1	4	2	2
Theories and realism	1.8	0	8	0	19.6	0	7	0
Functions	0.7	0	3	0	8.0	0	3	0
Feminism	0.7	0	3	0	10.9	0	4	0
Medical ethics and Freud	0.1	0	1	0	1.1	0	0	0
Abortion and self-defence	0.2	0	1	0	3.1	0	1	0
Belief ascriptions	0.1	0	0	0	0.5	0	0	0
Thermodynamics	1.2	1	6	5	14.4	4	5	2
Knowledge	2.2	0	10	0	26.5	0	10	0
Game theory	0.9	1	5	5	5.0	3	2	1
Justification	0.9	1	4	5	11.1	18	4	7
Frankfurt cases	0.3	0	1	0	2.3	0	1	0
Concepts	0.9	0	5	0	15.8	0	6	0
Races and DNA	0.3	0	2	0	3.7	0	1	0
Modality	0.4	0	2	0	4.7	0	2	0
Reasons	0.9	0	4	0	10.9	0	4	0
Evolutionary biology	1.1	1	5	5	14.5	16	6	6
Population ethics	0.1	0	1	0	1.0	0	0	0
Formal epistemology	0.2	0	1	0	1.7	0	1	0
Wide content	0.3	0	1	0	3.7	0	1	0
Vagueness	1.0	0	5	0	8.8	0	3	0
Cognitive science	0.2	0	1	0	2.2	0	1	0
Models	0.3	0	1	0	1.8	0	1	0
Composition and constitution	0.7	0	3	0	7.3	0	3	0
Norms	0.9	1	4	5	9.4	6	4	2

1943

Table B.68: Measures of the prominence of each subject in 1943 ’s journals.

Subject	Weight	Raw	W-Ratio	R-Ratio	W-Pages	R-Pages	WP-Ratio	RP-Ratio
Psychology	2.3	2	11	10	35.0	42	16	19
Idealism	11.3	9	56	44	147.8	115	66	51
Life and value	9.9	8	49	39	113.7	93	51	41
Other history	8.4	9	41	44	93.6	116	42	52
Dewey and pragmatism	7.0	10	34	49	73.3	100	33	44
Definitions	7.1	8	35	39	75.6	86	34	38
Propositions and implications	2.6	3	13	15	29.0	33	13	15
Beauty	5.1	10	25	49	45.1	86	20	38
Physicalism	2.9	3	14	15	37.6	27	17	12
History and culture	7.6	9	37	44	61.4	51	27	23
Faith and theism	2.7	3	13	15	23.1	18	10	8
Self-consciousness	2.1	2	10	10	24.7	38	11	17
Ancient	2.3	4	11	20	30.8	44	14	20
Universals and particulars	3.7	2	18	10	39.8	13	18	6
Verification	4.1	3	20	15	44.7	18	20	8
Value	4.7	5	23	25	46.9	53	21	24
Deduction	2.0	1	10	5	19.6	7	9	3
Mechanisms	4.8	6	23	29	43.8	42	19	19
Temporal paradoxes	1.5	0	8	0	21.3	0	9	0
Classical space and time	0.5	0	2	0	5.9	0	3	0
Early modern	3.3	6	16	29	45.8	78	20	35
Meaning and use	3.5	5	17	25	43.0	67	19	30
Marx	5.1	7	25	34	52.1	102	23	45
Ordinary language	8.6	9	42	44	121.2	141	54	63
Moral conscience	3.6	6	18	29	41.4	60	18	27
Methodology of science	9.3	11	46	54	98.5	123	44	55
Heidegger and Husserl	4.2	7	20	34	58.0	96	26	43
Emotions	2.2	1	11	5	22.5	8	10	4
Ontological argument	1.8	1	9	5	23.1	9	10	4
Chemistry	2.7	6	13	29	42.1	127	19	56
Social contract theory	2.9	3	14	15	33.4	32	15	14
Kant	2.2	1	11	5	39.8	36	18	16
Promises and imperatives	1.6	1	8	5	19.2	4	9	2
Analytic/synthetic	2.4	2	12	10	25.0	14	11	6
Freedom and free will	1.8	2	9	10	15.7	18	7	8
Crime and punishment	1.1	1	5	5	11.1	9	5	4
Sets and grue	1.8	2	9	10	16.7	13	7	6
Origins and purposes	0.9	0	4	0	8.2	0	4	0
Time	1.7	2	8	10	17.9	16	8	7
Color/colour	1.4	0	7	0	13.7	0	6	0
War	2.3	4	11	20	15.7	21	7	9
Depiction	1.6	2	8	10	17.4	23	8	10
Denoting	1.4	2	7	10	15.6	22	7	10
Chance	1.1	1	5	5	10.2	7	5	3
Hume	1.6	1	8	5	19.1	7	8	3
Laws	2.2	2	11	10	18.9	12	8	5
Perception	4.0	3	20	15	41.9	38	19	17
Intention	0.3	0	2	0	4.9	0	2	0
Virtues	0.5	0	2	0	5.8	0	3	0
Space and time	0.7	0	3	0	8.2	0	4	0
Mathematics	0.8	1	4	5	8.4	9	4	4
Liberal democracy	3.1	4	15	20	42.1	61	19	27
Duties	1.2	1	6	5	7.7	10	3	4
Causation	1.9	3	9	15	20.0	34	9	15
Arguments	0.9	0	5	0	9.3	0	4	0
Theory testing	2.4	3	12	15	24.5	27	11	12
Decision theory	0.5	0	3	0	7.4	0	3	0
Minds and machines	0.7	0	3	0	7.6	0	3	0
Truth	1.6	0	8	0	16.1	0	7	0
Radical translation	0.6	0	3	0	3.8	0	2	0
Explanation	0.5	1	2	5	7.0	18	3	8
Personal identity	0.6	0	3	0	6.0	0	3	0
Speech acts	0.7	0	3	0	7.1	0	3	0
Sense and reference	1.1	0	5	0	11.5	0	5	0
Egalitarianism	0.8	1	4	5	5.7	6	3	3
Quantum physics	0.3	0	1	0	4.4	0	2	0
Theories and realism	1.6	0	8	0	14.5	0	6	0
Functions	0.7	0	3	0	7.7	0	3	0
Feminism	0.2	0	1	0	1.8	0	1	0
Medical ethics and Freud	0.1	0	0	0	0.9	0	0	0
Abortion and self-defence	0.2	0	1	0	2.9	0	1	0
Belief ascriptions	0.3	0	2	0	2.8	0	1	0
Thermodynamics	1.5	2	7	10	12.9	15	6	7
Knowledge	2.5	2	12	10	24.3	5	11	2
Game theory	0.3	0	2	0	3.3	0	1	0
Justification	0.9	1	4	5	6.7	2	3	1
Frankfurt cases	0.4	0	2	0	6.0	0	3	0
Concepts	1.3	0	6	0	13.4	0	6	0
Races and DNA	0.5	0	3	0	3.4	0	2	0
Modality	0.5	0	3	0	4.6	0	2	0
Reasons	0.5	0	2	0	4.0	0	2	0
Evolutionary biology	0.5	0	3	0	5.1	0	2	0
Population ethics	0.1	0	1	0	1.2	0	1	0
Formal epistemology	0.2	0	1	0	1.6	0	1	0
Wide content	0.8	0	4	0	7.5	0	3	0
Vagueness	0.2	0	1	0	2.2	0	1	0
Cognitive science	0.6	0	3	0	3.3	0	1	0
Models	0.4	0	2	0	3.6	0	2	0
Composition and constitution	0.5	0	2	0	5.2	0	2	0
Norms	0.7	0	3	0	6.6	0	3	0

1944

Table B.69: Measures of the prominence of each subject in 1944 ’s journals.

Subject	Weight	Raw	W-Ratio	R-Ratio	W-Pages	R-Pages	WP-Ratio	RP-Ratio
Psychology	2.7	4	15	21	42.2	69	17	28
Idealism	12.2	12	65	64	173.9	174	70	70
Life and value	10.7	10	57	53	152.8	131	61	52
Other history	4.4	4	23	21	54.5	44	22	18
Dewey and pragmatism	5.8	3	31	16	83.6	66	33	26
Definitions	8.4	7	45	37	96.2	56	38	22
Propositions and implications	3.1	5	16	27	53.3	82	21	33
Beauty	7.9	15	42	80	65.7	133	26	53
Physicalism	5.0	7	27	37	64.3	103	26	41
History and culture	4.3	8	23	43	70.7	136	28	54
Faith and theism	3.4	5	18	27	46.1	51	18	20
Self-consciousness	2.7	1	14	5	32.7	3	13	1
Ancient	2.2	2	12	11	34.5	33	14	13
Universals and particulars	2.4	2	13	11	31.0	23	12	9
Verification	3.6	5	19	27	53.0	82	21	33
Value	5.5	8	29	43	73.0	124	29	50
Deduction	3.3	3	18	16	47.3	37	19	15
Mechanisms	2.7	3	14	16	33.3	42	13	17
Temporal paradoxes	2.1	3	11	16	29.8	43	12	17
Classical space and time	1.3	2	7	11	21.0	44	8	18
Early modern	1.2	1	6	5	13.7	8	5	3
Meaning and use	4.6	6	25	32	46.3	61	19	24
Marx	4.9	8	26	43	63.7	105	25	42
Ordinary language	10.6	10	57	53	162.3	177	65	71
Moral conscience	4.2	4	22	21	52.4	38	21	15
Methodology of science	8.1	8	43	43	93.6	78	37	31
Heidegger and Husserl	2.8	3	15	16	38.8	30	16	12
Emotions	0.8	0	4	0	12.2	0	5	0
Ontological argument	2.4	2	13	11	30.6	30	12	12
Chemistry	1.6	2	8	11	20.9	28	8	11
Social contract theory	1.1	1	6	5	12.9	14	5	6
Kant	0.8	0	4	0	12.8	0	5	0
Promises and imperatives	2.4	2	13	11	34.7	29	14	12
Analytic/synthetic	2.4	3	13	16	33.7	35	13	14
Freedom and free will	1.4	2	7	11	13.0	12	5	5
Crime and punishment	1.2	2	6	11	17.0	42	7	17
Sets and grue	1.7	1	9	5	17.1	1	7	0
Origins and purposes	0.4	0	2	0	5.3	0	2	0
Time	1.2	2	7	11	13.9	12	6	5
Color/colour	0.7	0	4	0	10.7	0	4	0
War	1.6	2	9	11	23.6	30	9	12
Depiction	0.5	0	3	0	6.0	0	2	0
Denoting	1.3	0	7	0	12.8	0	5	0
Chance	2.0	4	11	21	35.0	63	14	25
Hume	0.3	0	2	0	5.0	0	2	0
Laws	1.8	1	10	5	20.4	10	8	4
Perception	2.5	3	13	16	29.6	41	12	16
Intention	0.3	0	1	0	4.2	0	2	0
Virtues	1.3	0	7	0	17.1	0	7	0
Space and time	0.4	0	2	0	6.1	0	2	0
Mathematics	1.5	1	8	5	18.6	6	7	2
Liberal democracy	2.2	2	12	11	28.6	27	11	11
Duties	0.8	1	4	5	10.6	7	4	3
Causation	1.5	1	8	5	18.7	14	7	6
Arguments	1.3	0	7	0	19.5	0	8	0
Theory testing	0.6	0	3	0	11.9	0	5	0
Decision theory	0.7	0	4	0	7.9	0	3	0
Minds and machines	0.6	0	3	0	6.9	0	3	0
Truth	2.2	1	12	5	34.5	36	14	14
Radical translation	0.9	0	5	0	12.3	0	5	0
Explanation	0.4	1	2	5	5.9	13	2	5
Personal identity	0.4	0	2	0	4.0	0	2	0
Speech acts	0.4	0	2	0	5.0	0	2	0
Sense and reference	0.6	0	3	0	6.9	0	3	0
Egalitarianism	0.9	2	5	11	15.8	26	6	10
Quantum physics	0.4	1	2	5	8.3	22	3	9
Theories and realism	1.3	0	7	0	16.5	0	7	0
Functions	0.6	0	3	0	8.7	0	3	0
Feminism	0.4	0	2	0	5.9	0	2	0
Medical ethics and Freud	0.3	0	1	0	2.9	0	1	0
Abortion and self-defence	0.2	0	1	0	3.9	0	2	0
Belief ascriptions	0.1	0	0	0	1.0	0	0	0
Thermodynamics	0.7	0	4	0	8.0	0	3	0
Knowledge	1.4	0	7	0	15.8	0	6	0
Game theory	0.5	1	2	5	5.8	24	2	10
Justification	0.6	1	3	5	7.3	5	3	2
Frankfurt cases	0.2	0	1	0	2.7	0	1	0
Concepts	1.5	0	8	0	21.8	0	9	0
Races and DNA	0.1	0	1	0	2.1	0	1	0
Modality	0.4	0	2	0	3.1	0	1	0
Reasons	0.3	0	2	0	5.4	0	2	0
Evolutionary biology	0.6	0	3	0	6.1	0	2	0
Population ethics	0.2	0	1	0	2.9	0	1	0
Formal epistemology	0.2	0	1	0	2.7	0	1	0
Wide content	0.4	0	2	0	4.8	0	2	0
Vagueness	0.6	0	3	0	9.1	0	4	0
Cognitive science	0.3	0	1	0	3.7	0	1	0
Models	0.2	0	1	0	1.8	0	1	0
Composition and constitution	0.7	0	4	0	10.5	0	4	0
Norms	0.6	0	3	0	8.8	0	4	0

1945

Table B.70: Measures of the prominence of each subject in 1945 ’s journals.

Subject	Weight	Raw	W-Ratio	R-Ratio	W-Pages	R-Pages	WP-Ratio	RP-Ratio
Psychology	3.1	2	16	10	46.5	29	17	10
Idealism	8.7	10	45	52	181.0	206	65	74
Life and value	9.7	8	50	41	143.5	119	51	43
Other history	5.8	4	30	21	76.9	48	27	17
Dewey and pragmatism	4.6	6	24	31	72.2	79	26	28
Definitions	6.6	4	34	21	82.6	54	30	19
Propositions and implications	4.2	6	22	31	35.6	28	13	10
Beauty	2.7	4	14	21	43.0	74	15	26
Physicalism	4.6	4	24	21	73.6	38	26	14
History and culture	4.1	6	21	31	57.3	109	20	39
Faith and theism	5.0	8	26	41	38.6	33	14	12
Self-consciousness	2.0	1	10	5	26.7	8	10	3
Ancient	2.5	3	13	15	42.8	83	15	30
Universals and particulars	2.8	2	14	10	37.6	15	13	5
Verification	4.1	3	21	15	74.2	14	27	5
Value	6.4	10	33	52	71.8	104	26	37
Deduction	2.7	2	14	10	40.0	28	14	10
Mechanisms	3.5	4	18	21	50.8	58	18	21
Temporal paradoxes	1.2	0	6	0	17.4	0	6	0
Classical space and time	0.5	0	2	0	7.8	0	3	0
Early modern	1.2	2	6	10	21.1	29	8	10
Meaning and use	3.5	5	18	26	59.8	69	21	25
Marx	5.5	8	29	41	66.0	83	24	30
Ordinary language	9.5	15	49	77	226.0	496	81	177
Moral conscience	3.2	4	16	21	49.7	74	18	26
Methodology of science	7.9	8	41	41	102.3	104	37	37
Heidegger and Husserl	2.7	4	14	21	51.9	80	19	29
Emotions	1.2	1	6	5	22.8	36	8	13
Ontological argument	2.6	3	13	15	24.6	13	9	5
Chemistry	3.6	5	18	26	44.6	72	16	26
Social contract theory	1.6	1	8	5	19.1	12	7	4
Kant	1.2	2	6	10	14.8	13	5	5
Promises and imperatives	2.1	2	11	10	37.0	25	13	9
Analytic/synthetic	1.7	0	9	0	26.0	0	9	0
Freedom and free will	1.4	1	7	5	16.9	7	6	3
Crime and punishment	1.5	1	8	5	16.7	21	6	8
Sets and grue	2.6	3	13	15	24.7	34	9	12
Origins and purposes	0.7	0	3	0	10.5	0	4	0
Time	1.0	1	5	5	18.6	24	7	9
Color/colour	1.2	1	6	5	22.4	11	8	4
War	1.8	1	9	5	19.1	10	7	4
Depiction	1.1	0	6	0	9.3	0	3	0
Denoting	1.3	1	7	5	18.7	17	7	6
Chance	4.8	11	25	57	79.1	178	28	64
Hume	0.3	0	2	0	4.5	0	2	0
Laws	1.2	0	6	0	18.2	0	6	0
Perception	2.4	0	12	0	45.8	0	16	0
Intention	0.7	0	4	0	17.6	0	6	0
Virtues	1.0	1	5	5	9.1	6	3	2
Space and time	1.3	2	7	10	10.8	8	4	3
Mathematics	0.9	0	4	0	12.7	0	5	0
Liberal democracy	3.8	7	20	36	59.3	93	21	33
Duties	0.7	0	3	0	10.6	0	4	0
Causation	1.0	1	5	5	17.4	19	6	7
Arguments	2.3	1	12	5	25.9	2	9	1
Theory testing	3.4	5	17	26	48.6	69	17	25
Decision theory	0.9	0	5	0	7.4	0	3	0
Minds and machines	1.1	1	6	5	8.0	2	3	1
Truth	2.0	0	10	0	21.7	0	8	0
Radical translation	0.9	1	5	5	6.3	4	2	1
Explanation	0.3	0	2	0	4.2	0	2	0
Personal identity	0.8	0	4	0	8.7	0	3	0
Speech acts	0.2	0	1	0	3.6	0	1	0
Sense and reference	0.6	0	3	0	8.7	0	3	0
Egalitarianism	1.0	2	5	10	10.4	18	4	6
Quantum physics	1.0	1	5	5	9.7	5	3	2
Theories and realism	1.9	0	10	0	27.4	0	10	0
Functions	0.5	0	3	0	8.1	0	3	0
Feminism	0.3	0	2	0	4.3	0	2	0
Medical ethics and Freud	1.0	1	5	5	7.0	4	2	1
Abortion and self-defence	0.2	0	1	0	2.1	0	1	0
Belief ascriptions	0.2	0	1	0	2.2	0	1	0
Thermodynamics	1.1	0	6	0	11.3	0	4	0
Knowledge	1.9	2	10	10	26.0	21	9	8
Game theory	0.4	0	2	0	2.4	0	1	0
Justification	1.3	1	7	5	19.6	6	7	2
Frankfurt cases	0.1	0	1	0	3.4	0	1	0
Concepts	1.6	0	8	0	24.5	0	9	0
Races and DNA	0.9	0	5	0	5.9	0	2	0
Modality	0.4	0	2	0	5.2	0	2	0
Reasons	0.7	0	3	0	8.7	0	3	0
Evolutionary biology	0.3	0	1	0	2.6	0	1	0
Population ethics	0.7	0	4	0	5.8	0	2	0
Formal epistemology	0.1	0	1	0	1.1	0	0	0
Wide content	0.2	0	1	0	3.5	0	1	0
Vagueness	0.3	0	1	0	5.1	0	2	0
Cognitive science	0.2	0	1	0	3.0	0	1	0
Models	0.5	1	3	5	4.0	6	1	2
Composition and constitution	0.8	0	4	0	13.3	0	5	0
Norms	0.6	0	3	0	11.5	0	4	0

1946

Table B.71: Measures of the prominence of each subject in 1946 ’s journals.

Subject	Weight	Raw	W-Ratio	R-Ratio	W-Pages	R-Pages	WP-Ratio	RP-Ratio
Psychology	2.5	2	11	9	32.4	15	11	5
Idealism	12.9	19	58	85	201.5	290	70	101
Life and value	10.1	10	45	45	151.6	141	53	49
Other history	9.3	15	42	67	132.4	265	46	92
Dewey and pragmatism	5.5	5	25	22	62.2	63	22	22
Definitions	8.0	7	36	31	83.1	58	29	20
Propositions and implications	4.1	5	18	22	50.7	48	18	17
Beauty	4.0	7	18	31	52.5	89	18	31
Physicalism	5.5	11	25	49	61.4	133	21	46
History and culture	5.0	6	22	27	77.2	93	27	32
Faith and theism	2.9	3	13	13	33.9	25	12	9
Self-consciousness	2.1	0	10	0	28.4	0	10	0
Ancient	2.7	2	12	9	26.8	17	9	6
Universals and particulars	3.4	3	15	13	46.9	38	16	13
Verification	5.5	5	24	22	72.3	55	25	19
Value	4.9	6	22	27	41.1	41	14	14
Deduction	3.7	5	17	22	54.4	94	19	33
Mechanisms	4.7	3	21	13	61.3	43	21	15
Temporal paradoxes	3.8	4	17	18	45.7	38	16	13
Classical space and time	1.9	1	8	4	21.2	7	7	2
Early modern	2.2	3	10	13	30.3	44	11	15
Meaning and use	5.0	4	22	18	75.7	54	26	19
Marx	6.3	8	28	36	76.6	77	27	27
Ordinary language	11.1	15	49	67	219.9	393	77	137
Moral conscience	4.2	6	19	27	56.4	79	20	28
Methodology of science	11.6	16	52	71	127.1	166	44	58
Heidegger and Husserl	1.8	2	8	9	28.1	32	10	11
Emotions	1.3	1	6	4	28.7	23	10	8
Ontological argument	2.2	0	10	0	26.0	0	9	0
Chemistry	1.8	1	8	4	22.8	18	8	6
Social contract theory	2.8	3	12	13	28.5	22	10	8
Kant	1.3	1	6	4	13.6	4	5	1
Promises and imperatives	2.3	0	10	0	31.6	0	11	0
Analytic/synthetic	3.5	2	16	9	35.8	8	12	3
Freedom and free will	1.6	1	7	4	15.2	10	5	3
Crime and punishment	1.0	1	5	4	21.8	24	8	8
Sets and grue	2.2	3	10	13	23.5	37	8	13
Origins and purposes	0.6	0	3	0	7.5	0	3	0
Time	1.6	0	7	0	19.8	0	7	0
Color/colour	1.0	0	5	0	14.1	0	5	0
War	2.5	3	11	13	26.4	23	9	8
Depiction	0.6	1	3	4	15.4	30	5	10
Denoting	1.0	0	5	0	15.5	0	5	0
Chance	3.2	4	14	18	15.9	14	6	5
Hume	0.7	0	3	0	7.4	0	3	0
Laws	1.8	2	8	9	19.7	12	7	4
Perception	2.2	1	10	4	24.7	4	9	1
Intention	0.6	0	3	0	5.7	0	2	0
Virtues	2.2	3	10	13	14.0	9	5	3
Space and time	2.6	3	12	13	40.0	55	14	19
Mathematics	0.8	0	4	0	12.4	0	4	0
Liberal democracy	4.8	4	21	18	61.9	45	22	16
Duties	0.7	0	3	0	8.8	0	3	0
Causation	1.0	0	4	0	11.7	0	4	0
Arguments	1.9	0	9	0	20.6	0	7	0
Theory testing	2.6	4	12	18	23.0	18	8	6
Decision theory	0.5	0	2	0	6.6	0	2	0
Minds and machines	0.5	0	2	0	5.7	0	2	0
Truth	1.6	0	7	0	18.8	0	7	0
Radical translation	0.5	0	2	0	6.3	0	2	0
Explanation	0.9	1	4	4	15.8	20	5	7
Personal identity	0.3	0	1	0	2.7	0	1	0
Speech acts	0.6	0	3	0	6.8	0	2	0
Sense and reference	0.7	0	3	0	7.0	0	2	0
Egalitarianism	0.7	0	3	0	7.3	0	3	0
Quantum physics	1.1	3	5	13	8.5	24	3	8
Theories and realism	1.7	1	7	4	18.1	10	6	3
Functions	0.9	0	4	0	9.9	0	3	0
Feminism	0.5	0	2	0	9.5	0	3	0
Medical ethics and Freud	1.0	1	4	4	11.0	18	4	6
Abortion and self-defence	0.1	0	1	0	1.2	0	0	0
Belief ascriptions	0.2	0	1	0	3.0	0	1	0
Thermodynamics	1.0	0	4	0	13.7	0	5	0
Knowledge	2.3	1	10	4	30.2	5	11	2
Game theory	0.4	0	2	0	4.9	0	2	0
Justification	1.1	1	5	4	12.9	19	5	7
Frankfurt cases	0.1	0	1	0	2.1	0	1	0
Concepts	1.7	0	7	0	18.7	0	7	0
Races and DNA	0.5	0	2	0	3.4	0	1	0
Modality	1.2	2	5	9	9.3	5	3	2
Reasons	1.4	2	6	9	10.1	9	4	3
Evolutionary biology	0.6	1	3	4	5.8	7	2	2
Population ethics	0.7	0	3	0	5.6	0	2	0
Formal epistemology	0.4	0	2	0	6.1	0	2	0
Wide content	0.5	0	2	0	5.5	0	2	0
Vagueness	0.6	0	3	0	8.2	0	3	0
Cognitive science	0.4	0	2	0	3.4	0	1	0
Models	0.2	0	1	0	2.7	0	1	0
Composition and constitution	0.8	0	4	0	10.9	0	4	0
Norms	1.1	0	5	0	16.3	0	6	0

1947

Table B.72: Measures of the prominence of each subject in 1947 ’s journals.

Subject	Weight	Raw	W-Ratio	R-Ratio	W-Pages	R-Pages	WP-Ratio	RP-Ratio
Psychology	3.0	3	13	13	50.6	27	17	9
Idealism	13.3	18	58	79	188.9	234	64	80
Life and value	9.9	12	43	52	119.5	127	41	43
Other history	10.5	13	46	57	141.6	163	48	55
Dewey and pragmatism	6.7	7	29	31	68.6	61	23	21
Definitions	7.5	4	33	17	96.1	65	33	22
Propositions and implications	4.7	7	21	31	48.4	43	16	15
Beauty	4.3	8	19	35	41.3	71	14	24
Physicalism	4.3	3	19	13	54.5	31	19	11
History and culture	6.4	12	28	52	84.7	184	29	63
Faith and theism	3.1	5	14	22	46.9	69	16	23
Self-consciousness	2.2	0	9	0	25.1	0	9	0
Ancient	2.2	3	10	13	41.5	65	14	22
Universals and particulars	7.1	14	31	61	84.6	180	29	61
Verification	7.7	9	34	39	82.0	69	28	23
Value	3.5	3	15	13	49.2	57	17	19
Deduction	4.2	6	18	26	79.0	159	27	54
Mechanisms	5.0	3	22	13	58.8	52	20	18
Temporal paradoxes	1.9	0	8	0	26.0	0	9	0
Classical space and time	0.8	1	3	4	15.4	22	5	7
Early modern	1.6	1	7	4	21.5	16	7	5
Meaning and use	4.8	5	21	22	74.5	58	25	20
Marx	5.0	7	22	31	60.9	75	21	26
Ordinary language	11.1	13	48	57	203.5	316	69	107
Moral conscience	4.6	9	20	39	49.2	97	17	33
Methodology of science	8.9	8	39	35	96.3	79	33	27
Heidegger and Husserl	5.9	12	26	52	72.4	162	25	55
Emotions	0.9	0	4	0	12.1	0	4	0
Ontological argument	2.9	1	13	4	32.4	4	11	1
Chemistry	2.4	2	11	9	27.6	26	9	9
Social contract theory	1.3	0	6	0	17.6	0	6	0
Kant	0.9	0	4	0	9.5	0	3	0
Promises and imperatives	2.2	0	10	0	26.7	0	9	0
Analytic/synthetic	3.6	1	16	4	39.0	13	13	4
Freedom and free will	1.5	0	7	0	23.7	0	8	0
Crime and punishment	1.3	2	5	9	19.9	23	7	8
Sets and grue	1.9	2	8	9	32.9	19	11	6
Origins and purposes	1.0	0	5	0	7.9	0	3	0
Time	2.0	1	9	4	27.4	16	9	5
Color/colour	1.1	0	5	0	19.1	0	7	0
War	1.9	2	8	9	33.8	47	12	16
Depiction	1.1	2	5	9	20.1	65	7	22
Denoting	0.9	0	4	0	14.2	0	5	0
Chance	3.5	7	15	31	28.0	52	10	18
Hume	0.9	0	4	0	12.4	0	4	0
Laws	2.3	2	10	9	28.3	21	10	7
Perception	4.2	0	18	0	56.8	0	19	0
Intention	0.6	1	2	4	7.6	0	3	0
Virtues	0.7	0	3	0	7.7	0	3	0
Space and time	1.5	1	6	4	12.0	4	4	1
Mathematics	1.5	1	6	4	18.8	10	6	3
Liberal democracy	2.8	4	12	17	30.6	43	10	15
Duties	0.7	0	3	0	10.0	0	3	0
Causation	1.7	3	8	13	17.7	27	6	9
Arguments	1.4	0	6	0	23.0	0	8	0
Theory testing	3.2	2	14	9	30.3	11	10	4
Decision theory	0.7	0	3	0	9.0	0	3	0
Minds and machines	0.7	0	3	0	8.2	0	3	0
Truth	2.0	1	9	4	24.8	9	8	3
Radical translation	0.9	1	4	4	12.5	3	4	1
Explanation	0.5	0	2	0	6.3	0	2	0
Personal identity	0.6	0	2	0	7.2	0	2	0
Speech acts	0.7	0	3	0	6.6	0	2	0
Sense and reference	0.4	0	2	0	5.3	0	2	0
Egalitarianism	0.1	0	0	0	1.4	0	0	0
Quantum physics	1.4	2	6	9	12.6	14	4	5
Theories and realism	2.5	0	11	0	24.5	0	8	0
Functions	0.8	0	4	0	10.4	0	4	0
Feminism	0.6	0	3	0	7.2	0	2	0
Medical ethics and Freud	0.2	0	1	0	2.6	0	1	0
Abortion and self-defence	0.2	0	1	0	2.3	0	1	0
Belief ascriptions	0.2	0	1	0	2.0	0	1	0
Thermodynamics	1.4	1	6	4	17.6	16	6	5
Knowledge	1.7	0	7	0	22.4	0	8	0
Game theory	0.7	1	3	4	3.8	3	1	1
Justification	0.9	0	4	0	9.6	0	3	0
Frankfurt cases	0.2	0	1	0	2.1	0	1	0
Concepts	2.0	0	9	0	21.9	0	7	0
Races and DNA	0.2	0	1	0	2.0	0	1	0
Modality	0.8	0	4	0	11.6	0	4	0
Reasons	0.7	0	3	0	7.2	0	2	0
Evolutionary biology	1.1	1	5	4	13.6	8	5	3
Population ethics	0.2	0	1	0	2.1	0	1	0
Formal epistemology	0.5	0	2	0	6.9	0	2	0
Wide content	0.3	0	1	0	3.7	0	1	0
Vagueness	0.6	0	3	0	7.3	0	2	0
Cognitive science	0.1	0	1	0	1.7	0	1	0
Models	0.3	0	1	0	4.1	0	1	0
Composition and constitution	1.3	1	5	4	17.0	18	6	6
Norms	1.3	1	6	4	15.5	6	5	2

1948

Table B.73: Measures of the prominence of each subject in 1948 ’s journals.

Subject	Weight	Raw	W-Ratio	R-Ratio	W-Pages	R-Pages	WP-Ratio	RP-Ratio
Psychology	1.7	0	7	0	19.8	0	6	0
Idealism	12.3	14	48	54	153.8	159	50	52
Life and value	10.3	14	40	54	131.6	189	43	61
Other history	7.2	6	28	23	86.6	84	28	27
Dewey and pragmatism	6.1	8	24	31	69.8	79	23	26
Definitions	8.1	6	32	23	104.0	80	34	26
Propositions and implications	5.5	7	21	27	62.1	59	20	19
Beauty	6.6	12	26	47	74.9	149	24	48
Physicalism	4.2	6	16	23	42.9	62	14	20
History and culture	6.6	11	26	43	94.6	156	31	51
Faith and theism	4.0	4	16	16	45.0	53	15	17
Self-consciousness	3.0	2	12	8	28.8	9	9	3
Ancient	2.1	2	8	8	23.2	10	8	3
Universals and particulars	4.5	6	18	23	56.3	92	18	30
Verification	8.1	9	32	35	87.3	76	28	25
Value	6.1	8	24	31	64.7	82	21	27
Deduction	3.4	0	13	0	38.7	0	13	0
Mechanisms	4.1	3	16	12	44.2	20	14	6
Temporal paradoxes	2.2	2	9	8	24.0	22	8	7
Classical space and time	1.1	0	4	0	10.8	0	4	0
Early modern	1.9	1	8	4	18.4	7	6	2
Meaning and use	7.8	5	30	19	114.1	119	37	39
Marx	10.2	13	40	51	124.1	161	40	52
Ordinary language	14.9	24	58	93	234.8	427	76	139
Moral conscience	4.8	4	19	16	70.4	35	23	11
Methodology of science	12.8	18	50	70	122.7	140	40	45
Heidegger and Husserl	5.1	7	20	27	84.2	130	27	42
Emotions	1.5	1	6	4	19.3	8	6	3
Ontological argument	4.5	4	17	16	41.2	29	13	9
Chemistry	2.9	4	11	16	31.0	40	10	13
Social contract theory	1.5	2	6	8	15.3	12	5	4
Kant	0.9	1	3	4	13.5	14	4	5
Promises and imperatives	3.6	5	14	19	47.0	75	15	24
Analytic/synthetic	4.8	7	19	27	53.5	81	17	26
Freedom and free will	2.9	1	11	4	31.6	3	10	1
Crime and punishment	0.7	1	3	4	5.0	2	2	1
Sets and grue	2.3	2	9	8	29.9	4	10	1
Origins and purposes	1.1	0	4	0	8.8	0	3	0
Time	1.9	1	7	4	19.9	4	6	1
Color/colour	1.8	1	7	4	19.5	8	6	3
War	1.4	1	6	4	18.5	21	6	7
Depiction	1.1	0	4	0	12.7	0	4	0
Denoting	3.3	3	13	12	24.2	12	8	4
Chance	2.9	4	11	16	29.4	48	10	16
Hume	0.5	0	2	0	8.2	0	3	0
Laws	2.1	2	8	8	20.5	5	7	2
Perception	2.8	1	11	4	31.0	14	10	5
Intention	0.5	1	2	4	4.7	7	2	2
Virtues	1.5	1	6	4	27.6	39	9	13
Space and time	1.0	0	4	0	9.2	0	3	0
Mathematics	1.0	2	4	8	15.9	32	5	10
Liberal democracy	3.6	5	14	19	46.2	58	15	19
Duties	1.5	1	6	4	18.7	8	6	3
Causation	1.8	2	7	8	21.0	22	7	7
Arguments	1.9	0	7	0	25.5	0	8	0
Theory testing	1.9	0	7	0	16.5	0	5	0
Decision theory	1.0	0	4	0	15.3	0	5	0
Minds and machines	1.0	0	4	0	12.6	0	4	0
Truth	4.0	3	16	12	35.1	23	11	7
Radical translation	1.3	1	5	4	11.0	4	4	1
Explanation	1.4	1	6	4	16.4	41	5	13
Personal identity	0.6	0	2	0	5.4	0	2	0
Speech acts	0.7	0	3	0	10.5	0	3	0
Sense and reference	0.7	1	3	4	13.8	22	4	7
Egalitarianism	0.2	0	1	0	2.9	0	1	0
Quantum physics	0.7	1	3	4	8.6	14	3	5
Theories and realism	2.4	1	9	4	25.0	4	8	1
Functions	0.6	0	2	0	8.4	0	3	0
Feminism	0.7	0	3	0	7.0	0	2	0
Medical ethics and Freud	0.5	1	2	4	3.8	3	1	1
Abortion and self-defence	0.3	0	1	0	3.5	0	1	0
Belief ascriptions	0.9	1	4	4	5.9	4	2	1
Thermodynamics	1.1	0	4	0	12.7	0	4	0
Knowledge	2.1	0	8	0	21.4	0	7	0
Game theory	0.2	0	1	0	2.1	0	1	0
Justification	0.9	1	4	4	13.1	14	4	5
Frankfurt cases	0.7	0	3	0	6.8	0	2	0
Concepts	2.0	0	8	0	25.7	0	8	0
Races and DNA	0.9	1	3	4	6.3	2	2	1
Modality	1.4	0	6	0	22.1	0	7	0
Reasons	0.9	0	4	0	16.2	0	5	0
Evolutionary biology	1.1	0	4	0	9.5	0	3	0
Population ethics	0.4	0	2	0	4.0	0	1	0
Formal epistemology	0.3	0	1	0	2.2	0	1	0
Wide content	0.5	0	2	0	6.4	0	2	0
Vagueness	0.4	0	1	0	4.2	0	1	0
Cognitive science	0.4	0	2	0	4.5	0	1	0
Models	0.4	0	2	0	5.4	0	2	0
Composition and constitution	1.0	0	4	0	11.8	0	4	0
Norms	1.5	0	6	0	21.8	0	7	0

1949

Table B.74: Measures of the prominence of each subject in 1949 ’s journals.

Subject	Weight	Raw	W-Ratio	R-Ratio	W-Pages	R-Pages	WP-Ratio	RP-Ratio
Psychology	1.7	3	6	11	27.7	51	9	17
Idealism	10.3	13	38	48	129.7	152	43	50
Life and value	8.2	10	30	37	103.2	147	34	48
Other history	7.5	8	27	29	94.7	123	31	40
Dewey and pragmatism	8.5	10	31	37	92.6	114	30	38
Definitions	10.6	10	39	37	114.7	90	38	30
Propositions and implications	6.6	8	24	29	68.1	90	22	30
Beauty	5.0	10	18	37	59.9	123	20	40
Physicalism	4.6	6	17	22	43.4	31	14	10
History and culture	9.4	15	35	55	120.7	194	40	64
Faith and theism	4.9	5	18	18	46.4	38	15	12
Self-consciousness	2.3	0	9	0	24.0	0	8	0
Ancient	3.1	3	12	11	26.1	21	9	7
Universals and particulars	6.3	8	23	29	82.9	139	27	46
Verification	6.9	6	25	22	77.8	49	26	16
Value	7.6	10	28	37	71.6	93	24	31
Deduction	5.3	2	20	7	55.6	14	18	5
Mechanisms	3.3	2	12	7	49.2	40	16	13
Temporal paradoxes	2.5	2	9	7	28.0	26	9	9
Classical space and time	2.3	2	8	7	17.6	6	6	2
Early modern	1.5	0	6	0	14.1	0	5	0
Meaning and use	11.1	16	41	59	118.0	150	39	49
Marx	7.1	7	26	26	81.8	61	27	20
Ordinary language	14.7	13	54	48	226.9	285	75	94
Moral conscience	4.3	8	16	29	47.3	83	16	27
Methodology of science	11.3	13	42	48	126.1	155	41	51
Heidegger and Husserl	5.9	10	22	37	66.7	108	22	36
Emotions	2.0	1	7	4	20.1	7	7	2
Ontological argument	3.5	3	13	11	28.7	14	9	5
Chemistry	2.7	2	10	7	36.5	36	12	12
Social contract theory	1.3	0	5	0	18.5	0	6	0
Kant	2.0	2	7	7	16.5	16	5	5
Promises and imperatives	3.4	4	12	15	34.2	46	11	15
Analytic/synthetic	6.7	10	25	37	59.7	77	20	25
Freedom and free will	2.1	3	8	11	20.1	31	7	10
Crime and punishment	1.4	3	5	11	17.8	40	6	13
Sets and grue	2.9	4	11	15	23.6	14	8	5
Origins and purposes	1.0	0	4	0	12.5	0	4	0
Time	1.8	0	7	0	19.2	0	6	0
Color/colour	3.1	3	11	11	33.4	18	11	6
War	1.1	1	4	4	14.0	13	5	4
Depiction	1.6	2	6	7	13.0	9	4	3
Denoting	3.0	3	11	11	25.5	19	8	6
Chance	1.1	1	4	4	7.6	5	3	2
Hume	0.8	0	3	0	8.4	0	3	0
Laws	2.7	2	10	7	31.2	24	10	8
Perception	3.9	2	14	7	53.0	50	17	16
Intention	1.1	2	4	7	7.9	10	3	3
Virtues	1.4	0	5	0	15.0	0	5	0
Space and time	0.4	0	2	0	3.2	0	1	0
Mathematics	0.9	0	3	0	7.8	0	3	0
Liberal democracy	3.6	4	13	15	45.9	57	15	19
Duties	1.1	0	4	0	11.4	0	4	0
Causation	1.0	0	4	0	13.0	0	4	0
Arguments	2.6	0	10	0	24.8	0	8	0
Theory testing	2.1	1	8	4	23.1	6	8	2
Decision theory	1.4	1	5	4	14.7	6	5	2
Minds and machines	1.2	0	4	0	11.9	0	4	0
Truth	3.9	1	14	4	40.2	6	13	2
Radical translation	2.0	1	7	4	18.6	18	6	6
Explanation	0.7	0	3	0	7.0	0	2	0
Personal identity	0.7	0	3	0	5.7	0	2	0
Speech acts	1.4	0	5	0	11.9	0	4	0
Sense and reference	1.4	2	5	7	14.0	19	5	6
Egalitarianism	0.5	1	2	4	7.9	15	3	5
Quantum physics	2.3	4	9	15	29.6	56	10	18
Theories and realism	1.8	0	7	0	20.4	0	7	0
Functions	0.9	0	3	0	10.6	0	3	0
Feminism	0.9	1	3	4	9.2	7	3	2
Medical ethics and Freud	0.4	0	2	0	6.6	0	2	0
Abortion and self-defence	0.2	0	1	0	1.4	0	0	0
Belief ascriptions	0.2	0	1	0	2.7	0	1	0
Thermodynamics	1.2	0	4	0	12.7	0	4	0
Knowledge	2.2	3	8	11	23.9	13	8	4
Game theory	0.3	0	1	0	3.2	0	1	0
Justification	0.8	0	3	0	8.0	0	3	0
Frankfurt cases	0.6	0	2	0	5.0	0	2	0
Concepts	2.8	1	10	4	28.3	6	9	2
Races and DNA	0.2	0	1	0	2.3	0	1	0
Modality	1.6	0	6	0	15.8	0	5	0
Reasons	0.8	0	3	0	7.8	0	3	0
Evolutionary biology	0.8	1	3	4	7.6	6	2	2
Population ethics	0.6	1	2	4	4.3	4	1	1
Formal epistemology	0.5	0	2	0	5.3	0	2	0
Wide content	0.5	0	2	0	4.0	0	1	0
Vagueness	0.4	0	2	0	5.7	0	2	0
Cognitive science	0.4	0	2	0	4.1	0	1	0
Models	0.7	0	2	0	6.8	0	2	0
Composition and constitution	1.4	1	5	4	11.5	6	4	2
Norms	1.1	1	4	4	10.3	3	3	1

1950

Table B.75: Measures of the prominence of each subject in 1950 ’s journals.

Subject	Weight	Raw	W-Ratio	R-Ratio	W-Pages	R-Pages	WP-Ratio	RP-Ratio
Psychology	2.4	2	9	7	44.3	21	14	7
Idealism	8.4	9	31	33	117.6	152	37	48
Life and value	7.5	2	27	7	93.7	17	30	5
Other history	6.5	4	24	15	78.7	59	25	19
Dewey and pragmatism	5.6	2	20	7	63.9	31	20	10
Definitions	11.5	11	42	40	116.3	81	37	26
Propositions and implications	4.8	5	17	18	41.8	19	13	6
Beauty	4.9	9	18	33	51.8	101	16	32
Physicalism	5.8	6	21	22	66.1	60	21	19
History and culture	4.6	6	17	22	45.9	49	15	16
Faith and theism	2.2	3	8	11	22.2	25	7	8
Self-consciousness	1.3	0	5	0	16.5	0	5	0
Ancient	4.6	8	17	29	85.3	165	27	52
Universals and particulars	5.3	5	19	18	57.5	56	18	18
Verification	12.4	21	45	76	134.7	226	43	72
Value	6.2	12	22	44	59.4	98	19	31
Deduction	5.2	6	19	22	44.6	37	14	12
Mechanisms	5.2	7	19	25	52.6	59	17	19
Temporal paradoxes	3.3	3	12	11	36.8	33	12	10
Classical space and time	2.6	1	10	4	24.5	3	8	1
Early modern	2.2	2	8	7	30.8	39	10	12
Meaning and use	12.0	14	43	51	127.6	103	40	33
Marx	6.6	12	24	44	83.0	140	26	44
Ordinary language	17.0	25	62	91	286.4	562	91	178
Moral conscience	7.7	11	28	40	73.9	106	23	34
Methodology of science	9.9	17	36	62	117.2	204	37	65
Heidegger and Husserl	2.7	4	10	15	29.2	34	9	11
Emotions	3.1	3	11	11	31.6	27	10	9
Ontological argument	2.9	1	10	4	29.0	12	9	4
Chemistry	1.9	0	7	0	27.8	0	9	0
Social contract theory	2.1	4	8	15	26.1	39	8	12
Kant	1.9	1	7	4	16.6	1	5	0
Promises and imperatives	3.6	3	13	11	33.5	22	11	7
Analytic/synthetic	5.4	4	19	15	49.4	25	16	8
Freedom and free will	1.7	2	6	7	16.1	12	5	4
Crime and punishment	0.8	1	3	4	11.5	11	4	3
Sets and grue	2.4	1	9	4	21.4	8	7	3
Origins and purposes	1.2	0	4	0	15.0	0	5	0
Time	3.0	3	11	11	27.3	21	9	7
Color/colour	2.4	2	9	7	22.2	8	7	3
War	1.9	1	7	4	17.0	12	5	4
Depiction	1.2	0	4	0	11.2	0	4	0
Denoting	4.1	3	15	11	38.1	21	12	7
Chance	1.9	3	7	11	27.4	31	9	10
Hume	1.7	2	6	7	20.1	29	6	9
Laws	2.3	1	8	4	21.9	3	7	1
Perception	4.2	3	15	11	50.5	41	16	13
Intention	1.3	1	5	4	10.1	8	3	3
Virtues	2.2	1	8	4	25.7	6	8	2
Space and time	1.3	1	5	4	9.8	3	3	1
Mathematics	2.8	5	10	18	34.0	62	11	20
Liberal democracy	2.0	3	7	11	28.4	54	9	17
Duties	1.9	1	7	4	25.1	36	8	11
Causation	2.5	1	9	4	29.6	19	9	6
Arguments	2.7	0	10	0	33.0	0	10	0
Theory testing	3.2	2	12	7	32.9	21	10	7
Decision theory	1.3	2	5	7	11.7	13	4	4
Minds and machines	1.1	0	4	0	19.5	0	6	0
Truth	3.9	2	14	7	38.8	27	12	9
Radical translation	1.9	1	7	4	17.8	2	6	1
Explanation	0.8	0	3	0	9.1	0	3	0
Personal identity	1.0	1	4	4	12.3	13	4	4
Speech acts	1.6	1	6	4	22.3	16	7	5
Sense and reference	2.1	1	8	4	17.3	5	5	2
Egalitarianism	0.4	0	1	0	4.0	0	1	0
Quantum physics	1.0	1	4	4	14.9	9	5	3
Theories and realism	3.0	0	11	0	32.4	0	10	0
Functions	1.5	1	5	4	15.2	4	5	1
Feminism	0.5	0	2	0	5.5	0	2	0
Medical ethics and Freud	0.4	0	1	0	5.8	0	2	0
Abortion and self-defence	0.4	0	1	0	3.3	0	1	0
Belief ascriptions	0.4	0	2	0	3.9	0	1	0
Thermodynamics	1.1	0	4	0	12.3	0	4	0
Knowledge	1.8	1	7	4	21.4	8	7	3
Game theory	0.4	0	2	0	5.9	0	2	0
Justification	1.2	0	4	0	15.2	0	5	0
Frankfurt cases	0.6	0	2	0	6.2	0	2	0
Concepts	1.9	1	7	4	22.2	12	7	4
Races and DNA	0.5	0	2	0	3.5	0	1	0
Modality	1.5	0	5	0	15.1	0	5	0
Reasons	1.1	0	4	0	12.0	0	4	0
Evolutionary biology	0.1	0	0	0	1.6	0	1	0
Population ethics	0.2	0	1	0	1.9	0	1	0
Formal epistemology	0.4	0	2	0	3.0	0	1	0
Wide content	0.2	0	1	0	1.9	0	1	0
Vagueness	0.9	0	3	0	6.3	0	2	0
Cognitive science	0.6	0	2	0	7.7	0	2	0
Models	0.5	1	2	4	7.1	15	2	5
Composition and constitution	1.4	2	5	7	14.5	21	5	7
Norms	1.8	0	7	0	20.7	0	7	0

1951

Table B.76: Measures of the prominence of each subject in 1951 ’s journals.

Subject	Weight	Raw	W-Ratio	R-Ratio	W-Pages	R-Pages	WP-Ratio	RP-Ratio
Psychology	2.7	2	9	6	39.5	25	11	7
Idealism	11.8	17	37	54	155.5	204	41	54
Life and value	8.3	6	26	19	100.3	56	27	15
Other history	11.5	15	36	48	123.6	144	33	38
Dewey and pragmatism	7.4	12	24	38	87.0	120	23	32
Definitions	11.1	9	35	29	125.1	118	33	31
Propositions and implications	5.6	6	18	19	56.5	55	15	15
Beauty	3.6	6	11	19	30.5	51	8	14
Physicalism	5.5	5	18	16	56.1	37	15	10
History and culture	6.4	7	20	22	78.2	98	21	26
Faith and theism	4.7	6	15	19	39.9	46	11	12
Self-consciousness	2.1	0	7	0	21.1	0	6	0
Ancient	3.8	4	12	13	41.2	50	11	13
Universals and particulars	5.4	5	17	16	64.0	39	17	10
Verification	11.2	13	36	41	130.9	176	35	47
Value	5.2	6	17	19	49.8	54	13	14
Deduction	6.1	6	19	19	53.7	36	14	10
Mechanisms	5.9	9	19	29	81.4	132	22	35
Temporal paradoxes	5.0	5	16	16	61.6	69	16	18
Classical space and time	2.1	0	7	0	24.7	0	7	0
Early modern	2.7	3	8	10	23.0	16	6	4
Meaning and use	13.6	16	43	51	171.0	173	45	46
Marx	4.8	5	15	16	57.4	63	15	17
Ordinary language	21.3	22	68	70	340.7	447	91	119
Moral conscience	7.3	13	23	41	82.9	140	22	37
Methodology of science	11.9	15	38	48	144.9	200	39	53
Heidegger and Husserl	5.6	10	18	32	71.0	143	19	38
Emotions	1.9	1	6	3	25.9	13	7	3
Ontological argument	3.5	4	11	13	40.6	31	11	8
Chemistry	5.5	9	18	29	83.3	145	22	39
Social contract theory	2.6	3	8	10	25.5	15	7	4
Kant	1.6	2	5	6	21.5	26	6	7
Promises and imperatives	3.4	3	11	10	48.5	43	13	11
Analytic/synthetic	5.3	4	17	13	55.6	51	15	14
Freedom and free will	2.3	2	7	6	30.9	30	8	8
Crime and punishment	1.1	1	3	3	15.9	15	4	4
Sets and grue	3.1	3	10	10	27.0	24	7	6
Origins and purposes	1.6	1	5	3	17.9	3	5	1
Time	2.7	2	9	6	35.4	30	9	8
Color/colour	2.4	3	8	10	25.6	31	7	8
War	2.6	2	8	6	32.0	21	9	6
Depiction	2.5	2	8	6	25.5	21	7	6
Denoting	3.7	6	12	19	54.8	76	15	20
Chance	2.0	4	6	13	24.7	47	7	13
Hume	1.2	1	4	3	19.8	23	5	6
Laws	2.9	0	9	0	28.4	0	8	0
Perception	4.2	2	14	6	51.8	31	14	8
Intention	1.0	1	3	3	10.3	3	3	1
Virtues	2.5	4	8	13	30.6	47	8	13
Space and time	1.3	0	4	0	14.1	0	4	0
Mathematics	2.6	1	8	3	25.9	4	7	1
Liberal democracy	2.6	3	8	10	39.4	58	10	15
Duties	1.1	0	3	0	14.1	0	4	0
Causation	2.0	1	6	3	27.0	6	7	2
Arguments	3.1	0	10	0	35.9	0	10	0
Theory testing	2.2	0	7	0	30.3	0	8	0
Decision theory	2.0	1	6	3	27.0	14	7	4
Minds and machines	2.8	3	9	10	19.6	8	5	2
Truth	3.9	2	13	6	34.6	10	9	3
Radical translation	2.0	1	6	3	23.6	8	6	2
Explanation	0.9	1	3	3	16.1	38	4	10
Personal identity	0.7	0	2	0	7.0	0	2	0
Speech acts	1.1	0	4	0	14.3	0	4	0
Sense and reference	1.5	1	5	3	16.6	8	4	2
Egalitarianism	0.9	1	3	3	18.1	30	5	8
Quantum physics	2.6	4	8	13	41.2	60	11	16
Theories and realism	2.7	0	9	0	30.4	0	8	0
Functions	1.5	0	5	0	16.4	0	4	0
Feminism	1.2	0	4	0	11.9	0	3	0
Medical ethics and Freud	0.5	0	2	0	2.8	0	1	0
Abortion and self-defence	0.8	1	2	3	5.4	5	1	1
Belief ascriptions	0.4	0	1	0	4.3	0	1	0
Thermodynamics	2.5	2	8	6	37.0	35	10	9
Knowledge	2.1	0	7	0	21.0	0	6	0
Game theory	0.6	0	2	0	5.4	0	1	0
Justification	1.4	0	4	0	17.8	0	5	0
Frankfurt cases	0.9	0	3	0	7.6	0	2	0
Concepts	2.3	0	7	0	30.2	0	8	0
Races and DNA	0.7	1	2	3	7.8	7	2	2
Modality	2.1	3	7	10	17.6	14	5	4
Reasons	1.4	2	4	6	13.4	17	4	5
Evolutionary biology	0.4	0	1	0	4.5	0	1	0
Population ethics	0.2	0	1	0	1.4	0	0	0
Formal epistemology	1.1	1	3	3	6.5	4	2	1
Wide content	0.4	0	1	0	4.9	0	1	0
Vagueness	0.8	0	2	0	6.0	0	2	0
Cognitive science	0.7	0	2	0	11.6	0	3	0
Models	1.2	2	4	6	11.1	14	3	4
Composition and constitution	1.1	0	3	0	12.9	0	3	0
Norms	1.7	0	5	0	23.5	0	6	0

1952

Table B.77: Measures of the prominence of each subject in 1952 ’s journals.

Subject	Weight	Raw	W-Ratio	R-Ratio	W-Pages	R-Pages	WP-Ratio	RP-Ratio
Psychology	3.0	3	10	9	51.2	44	14	12
Idealism	10.2	12	32	38	131.5	146	36	40
Life and value	9.4	12	30	38	111.9	122	30	33
Other history	10.5	12	33	38	110.2	119	30	32
Dewey and pragmatism	6.8	6	21	19	82.5	104	22	28
Definitions	10.3	7	33	22	107.0	66	29	18
Propositions and implications	4.5	4	14	13	46.9	32	13	9
Beauty	7.5	14	24	44	68.6	122	19	33
Physicalism	6.9	5	22	16	61.6	32	17	9
History and culture	5.5	8	17	25	72.4	103	20	28
Faith and theism	2.7	3	9	9	37.9	40	10	11
Self-consciousness	2.1	1	7	3	22.3	7	6	2
Ancient	2.8	2	9	6	40.3	51	11	14
Universals and particulars	4.9	3	16	9	64.1	42	17	11
Verification	11.6	12	37	38	121.7	120	33	33
Value	4.8	6	15	19	51.0	57	14	15
Deduction	5.2	8	17	25	57.5	76	16	21
Mechanisms	3.8	4	12	13	53.5	39	14	11
Temporal paradoxes	6.2	9	19	28	59.5	84	16	23
Classical space and time	4.9	5	15	16	50.6	49	14	13
Early modern	2.8	4	9	13	27.6	46	7	12
Meaning and use	13.0	14	41	44	155.8	156	42	42
Marx	5.6	8	18	25	72.1	103	20	28
Ordinary language	18.5	19	58	60	305.4	490	83	133
Moral conscience	8.4	16	26	51	88.5	173	24	47
Methodology of science	8.3	9	26	28	95.1	109	26	30
Heidegger and Husserl	2.9	4	9	13	36.9	64	10	17
Emotions	2.3	0	7	0	28.7	0	8	0
Ontological argument	3.4	3	11	9	33.8	27	9	7
Chemistry	4.6	6	15	19	55.7	65	15	18
Social contract theory	3.4	4	11	13	53.6	78	15	21
Kant	2.1	3	7	9	20.5	30	6	8
Promises and imperatives	3.7	2	12	6	56.8	32	15	9
Analytic/synthetic	3.2	1	10	3	35.3	19	10	5
Freedom and free will	3.3	6	11	19	36.8	67	10	18
Crime and punishment	0.9	1	3	3	10.8	10	3	3
Sets and grue	5.6	11	18	35	58.0	106	16	29
Origins and purposes	1.6	1	5	3	14.4	2	4	1
Time	2.2	2	7	6	20.9	6	6	2
Color/colour	3.4	4	11	13	34.8	30	9	8
War	3.4	7	11	22	29.7	62	8	17
Depiction	3.0	3	10	9	41.2	35	11	9
Denoting	3.2	3	10	9	31.0	13	8	4
Chance	3.4	6	11	19	41.1	63	11	17
Hume	1.4	2	4	6	18.4	35	5	9
Laws	4.1	3	13	9	42.8	45	12	12
Perception	5.0	2	16	6	64.7	12	18	3
Intention	0.7	0	2	0	16.8	0	5	0
Virtues	1.8	0	6	0	18.3	0	5	0
Space and time	1.2	1	4	3	16.3	23	4	6
Mathematics	3.2	2	10	6	40.6	8	11	2
Liberal democracy	4.3	5	14	16	57.5	65	16	18
Duties	1.5	3	5	9	20.5	51	6	14
Causation	2.1	1	7	3	28.3	10	8	3
Arguments	3.6	1	11	3	38.8	4	11	1
Theory testing	2.5	0	8	0	29.2	0	8	0
Decision theory	1.5	1	5	3	14.6	4	4	1
Minds and machines	2.3	1	7	3	21.7	3	6	1
Truth	3.6	2	11	6	34.6	18	9	5
Radical translation	1.3	0	4	0	11.7	0	3	0
Explanation	0.9	0	3	0	14.9	0	4	0
Personal identity	1.5	0	5	0	11.7	0	3	0
Speech acts	2.1	0	7	0	23.7	0	6	0
Sense and reference	1.9	2	6	6	22.0	16	6	4
Egalitarianism	0.9	1	3	3	5.8	3	2	1
Quantum physics	2.8	4	9	13	31.4	49	8	13
Theories and realism	3.2	1	10	3	37.7	7	10	2
Functions	1.4	1	5	3	17.1	14	5	4
Feminism	0.4	0	1	0	4.1	0	1	0
Medical ethics and Freud	0.9	1	3	3	8.7	12	2	3
Abortion and self-defence	0.4	0	1	0	4.5	0	1	0
Belief ascriptions	0.6	0	2	0	5.3	0	1	0
Thermodynamics	1.9	0	6	0	19.3	0	5	0
Knowledge	2.6	0	8	0	28.7	0	8	0
Game theory	0.9	0	3	0	5.4	0	1	0
Justification	2.0	2	6	6	24.4	28	7	8
Frankfurt cases	0.7	0	2	0	6.4	0	2	0
Concepts	2.0	1	6	3	24.8	8	7	2
Races and DNA	1.1	1	3	3	8.2	4	2	1
Modality	1.3	1	4	3	13.5	9	4	2
Reasons	1.0	0	3	0	12.9	0	3	0
Evolutionary biology	1.8	2	6	6	12.8	14	3	4
Population ethics	0.4	0	1	0	3.8	0	1	0
Formal epistemology	0.8	1	3	3	5.5	5	1	1
Wide content	0.6	0	2	0	6.2	0	2	0
Vagueness	0.7	0	2	0	7.1	0	2	0
Cognitive science	0.7	1	2	3	6.1	2	2	1
Models	0.7	0	2	0	8.3	0	2	0
Composition and constitution	1.8	0	6	0	20.8	0	6	0
Norms	2.1	0	7	0	29.9	0	8	0

1953

Table B.78: Measures of the prominence of each subject in 1953 ’s journals.

Subject	Weight	Raw	W-Ratio	R-Ratio	W-Pages	R-Pages	WP-Ratio	RP-Ratio
Psychology	3.3	3	10	9	42.5	26	12	7
Idealism	9.8	9	30	28	126.2	130	35	36
Life and value	7.6	7	24	22	93.8	75	26	21
Other history	11.6	12	36	37	133.0	117	37	33
Dewey and pragmatism	7.8	8	24	25	84.5	71	23	20
Definitions	11.6	14	36	43	119.8	134	33	37
Propositions and implications	5.6	6	17	19	54.9	53	15	15
Beauty	5.6	11	17	34	62.4	115	17	32
Physicalism	6.0	6	19	19	61.3	62	17	17
History and culture	7.8	13	24	40	77.4	146	22	41
Faith and theism	3.0	3	9	9	35.5	43	10	12
Self-consciousness	2.5	0	8	0	26.5	0	7	0
Ancient	5.1	7	16	22	68.9	128	19	36
Universals and particulars	6.5	5	20	15	74.7	22	21	6
Verification	8.5	8	26	25	96.6	93	27	26
Value	4.9	5	15	15	49.7	46	14	13
Deduction	4.4	6	14	19	46.7	67	13	19
Mechanisms	5.7	10	18	31	60.3	103	17	29
Temporal paradoxes	4.8	6	15	19	38.8	31	11	9
Classical space and time	2.4	1	7	3	29.3	14	8	4
Early modern	5.9	8	18	25	56.9	76	16	21
Meaning and use	15.5	19	48	59	168.0	228	47	63
Marx	7.1	13	22	40	117.2	251	33	70
Ordinary language	19.7	19	61	59	285.4	333	79	93
Moral conscience	6.0	11	18	34	67.2	122	19	34
Methodology of science	11.2	9	35	28	105.0	73	29	20
Heidegger and Husserl	5.0	8	15	25	64.8	129	18	36
Emotions	1.9	1	6	3	18.6	7	5	2
Ontological argument	1.9	0	6	0	23.9	0	7	0
Chemistry	4.5	7	14	22	43.8	67	12	19
Social contract theory	2.5	3	8	9	26.9	32	7	9
Kant	2.0	2	6	6	23.0	18	6	5
Promises and imperatives	3.7	3	11	9	55.2	60	15	17
Analytic/synthetic	4.0	1	12	3	48.0	29	13	8
Freedom and free will	1.7	1	5	3	14.4	5	4	1
Crime and punishment	1.2	1	4	3	11.6	5	3	1
Sets and grue	5.7	9	18	28	58.0	74	16	21
Origins and purposes	1.6	2	5	6	17.6	19	5	5
Time	2.0	1	6	3	21.1	3	6	1
Color/colour	1.7	1	5	3	20.6	10	6	3
War	1.9	0	6	0	22.0	0	6	0
Depiction	2.2	0	7	0	29.8	0	8	0
Denoting	2.8	4	9	12	39.0	54	11	15
Chance	3.4	4	11	12	35.2	49	10	14
Hume	0.5	0	2	0	6.3	0	2	0
Laws	2.5	0	8	0	24.6	0	7	0
Perception	6.0	5	18	15	59.8	40	17	11
Intention	1.8	2	6	6	20.0	26	6	7
Virtues	1.9	1	6	3	21.5	9	6	3
Space and time	2.5	2	8	6	16.1	12	4	3
Mathematics	2.8	5	9	15	45.2	98	13	27
Liberal democracy	3.0	5	9	15	37.5	51	10	14
Duties	1.5	1	5	3	18.5	10	5	3
Causation	3.5	6	11	19	31.0	57	9	16
Arguments	2.9	0	9	0	28.9	0	8	0
Theory testing	3.2	2	10	6	26.0	5	7	1
Decision theory	2.6	1	8	3	27.7	10	8	3
Minds and machines	1.7	1	5	3	20.4	11	6	3
Truth	4.3	4	13	12	35.4	18	10	5
Radical translation	2.2	1	7	3	23.3	9	6	3
Explanation	1.2	1	4	3	11.4	3	3	1
Personal identity	0.9	0	3	0	10.9	0	3	0
Speech acts	2.0	1	6	3	22.4	5	6	1
Sense and reference	2.3	3	7	9	20.0	18	6	5
Egalitarianism	0.6	0	2	0	15.8	0	4	0
Quantum physics	2.2	2	7	6	16.4	14	5	4
Theories and realism	3.3	0	10	0	29.5	0	8	0
Functions	1.6	0	5	0	16.5	0	5	0
Feminism	0.4	0	1	0	4.5	0	1	0
Medical ethics and Freud	0.5	0	1	0	4.0	0	1	0
Abortion and self-defence	0.5	0	2	0	4.8	0	1	0
Belief ascriptions	0.5	0	2	0	2.9	0	1	0
Thermodynamics	2.6	1	8	3	21.1	3	6	1
Knowledge	2.8	3	9	9	27.6	17	8	5
Game theory	0.5	0	2	0	4.8	0	1	0
Justification	1.5	0	5	0	16.2	0	4	0
Frankfurt cases	0.8	1	3	3	6.5	2	2	1
Concepts	2.2	0	7	0	28.4	0	8	0
Races and DNA	0.7	1	2	3	4.6	10	1	3
Modality	1.3	0	4	0	13.1	0	4	0
Reasons	1.7	1	5	3	18.5	7	5	2
Evolutionary biology	1.4	1	4	3	10.6	9	3	3
Population ethics	0.6	0	2	0	7.9	0	2	0
Formal epistemology	0.3	0	1	0	2.7	0	1	0
Wide content	0.4	0	1	0	4.0	0	1	0
Vagueness	0.8	0	3	0	7.3	0	2	0
Cognitive science	1.3	1	4	3	10.5	3	3	1
Models	0.8	0	2	0	9.9	0	3	0
Composition and constitution	2.7	1	8	3	19.6	2	5	1
Norms	2.1	3	6	9	27.7	29	8	8

1954

Table B.79: Measures of the prominence of each subject in 1954 ’s journals.

Subject	Weight	Raw	W-Ratio	R-Ratio	W-Pages	R-Pages	WP-Ratio	RP-Ratio
Psychology	4.0	1	12	3	60.4	14	15	4
Idealism	9.8	9	29	27	124.3	91	32	23
Life and value	10.2	8	30	24	112.8	72	29	18
Other history	13.8	21	41	62	141.5	200	36	51
Dewey and pragmatism	6.1	3	18	9	71.8	42	18	11
Definitions	10.9	12	32	36	108.8	102	28	26
Propositions and implications	6.0	6	18	18	60.8	47	16	12
Beauty	3.9	7	11	21	53.9	112	14	29
Physicalism	5.2	6	16	18	62.3	77	16	20
History and culture	5.3	9	16	27	73.5	148	19	38
Faith and theism	4.2	3	12	9	51.0	57	13	15
Self-consciousness	2.0	0	6	0	23.4	0	6	0
Ancient	3.6	2	11	6	49.0	49	13	13
Universals and particulars	6.5	7	19	21	66.4	71	17	18
Verification	10.9	13	32	38	111.3	95	28	24
Value	5.0	6	15	18	50.3	73	13	19
Deduction	4.8	5	14	15	50.4	55	13	14
Mechanisms	3.8	3	11	9	43.5	49	11	13
Temporal paradoxes	6.1	7	18	21	71.7	100	18	26
Classical space and time	3.1	2	9	6	36.0	20	9	5
Early modern	3.8	4	11	12	38.0	45	10	12
Meaning and use	14.3	16	42	47	189.6	263	49	67
Marx	6.3	9	19	27	74.2	97	19	25
Ordinary language	22.3	24	66	71	378.0	404	97	103
Moral conscience	8.1	13	24	38	100.4	155	26	40
Methodology of science	10.9	14	32	41	114.8	131	29	34
Heidegger and Husserl	3.1	5	9	15	40.8	85	10	22
Emotions	3.1	3	9	9	41.2	27	11	7
Ontological argument	4.7	5	14	15	42.4	63	11	16
Chemistry	7.0	12	21	36	76.7	121	20	31
Social contract theory	2.8	3	8	9	30.5	51	8	13
Kant	3.6	5	11	15	39.2	54	10	14
Promises and imperatives	4.6	4	14	12	54.6	34	14	9
Analytic/synthetic	4.5	5	13	15	47.4	48	12	12
Freedom and free will	1.5	0	4	0	17.0	0	4	0
Crime and punishment	1.8	2	5	6	20.9	23	5	6
Sets and grue	3.6	3	11	9	30.9	22	8	6
Origins and purposes	2.4	1	7	3	21.2	13	5	3
Time	3.3	2	10	6	39.0	8	10	2
Color/colour	2.7	3	8	9	28.3	19	7	5
War	2.3	2	7	6	35.8	22	9	6
Depiction	1.5	0	5	0	21.9	0	6	0
Denoting	2.7	1	8	3	32.4	15	8	4
Chance	3.4	5	10	15	23.6	38	6	10
Hume	1.3	1	4	3	12.3	11	3	3
Laws	2.7	0	8	0	30.2	0	8	0
Perception	5.7	8	17	24	84.3	147	22	38
Intention	1.4	1	4	3	11.1	5	3	1
Virtues	1.5	1	4	3	15.0	10	4	3
Space and time	3.9	4	11	12	21.0	11	5	3
Mathematics	3.3	3	10	9	28.8	20	7	5
Liberal democracy	6.1	9	18	27	81.6	137	21	35
Duties	1.6	0	5	0	18.0	0	5	0
Causation	2.1	1	6	3	25.7	3	7	1
Arguments	4.1	0	12	0	48.3	0	12	0
Theory testing	2.9	5	9	15	26.4	32	7	8
Decision theory	1.6	1	5	3	18.0	14	5	4
Minds and machines	1.5	0	4	0	13.2	0	3	0
Truth	4.3	5	13	15	38.4	40	10	10
Radical translation	2.5	2	7	6	25.4	23	7	6
Explanation	0.9	1	3	3	14.1	13	4	3
Personal identity	1.6	2	5	6	15.0	12	4	3
Speech acts	1.3	1	4	3	17.2	19	4	5
Sense and reference	1.8	1	5	3	19.5	21	5	5
Egalitarianism	0.3	0	1	0	2.4	0	1	0
Quantum physics	2.0	2	6	6	19.0	23	5	6
Theories and realism	4.0	2	12	6	36.4	5	9	1
Functions	1.5	1	4	3	17.0	13	4	3
Feminism	0.7	0	2	0	8.9	0	2	0
Medical ethics and Freud	0.8	2	2	6	8.2	22	2	6
Abortion and self-defence	0.6	0	2	0	4.4	0	1	0
Belief ascriptions	1.2	1	3	3	11.9	9	3	2
Thermodynamics	2.7	2	8	6	24.0	13	6	3
Knowledge	3.3	2	10	6	31.1	7	8	2
Game theory	0.6	0	2	0	10.7	0	3	0
Justification	1.6	0	5	0	23.4	0	6	0
Frankfurt cases	0.7	0	2	0	9.7	0	2	0
Concepts	3.0	1	9	3	39.5	10	10	3
Races and DNA	0.3	0	1	0	3.3	0	1	0
Modality	1.5	0	4	0	14.6	0	4	0
Reasons	1.1	0	3	0	12.9	0	3	0
Evolutionary biology	2.0	2	6	6	14.1	12	4	3
Population ethics	0.5	1	1	3	4.1	8	1	2
Formal epistemology	1.0	1	3	3	8.4	15	2	4
Wide content	0.5	0	1	0	5.4	0	1	0
Vagueness	0.9	0	3	0	7.9	0	2	0
Cognitive science	0.7	0	2	0	9.2	0	2	0
Models	1.1	1	3	3	12.6	18	3	5
Composition and constitution	1.9	1	6	3	18.1	8	5	2
Norms	2.1	2	6	6	26.2	16	7	4

1955

Table B.80: Measures of the prominence of each subject in 1955 ’s journals.

Subject	Weight	Raw	W-Ratio	R-Ratio	W-Pages	R-Pages	WP-Ratio	RP-Ratio
Psychology	1.4	0	4	0	21.6	0	5	0
Idealism	9.8	12	28	34	135.8	147	34	37
Life and value	7.7	5	22	14	99.1	59	25	15
Other history	10.6	12	30	34	103.9	112	26	28
Dewey and pragmatism	7.5	7	21	20	78.8	57	20	14
Definitions	7.7	4	22	11	83.2	42	21	11
Propositions and implications	6.3	8	18	23	53.2	54	13	14
Beauty	7.1	12	20	34	82.6	153	21	39
Physicalism	5.0	6	14	17	53.3	78	13	20
History and culture	8.1	14	23	40	91.8	169	23	43
Faith and theism	4.1	4	12	11	55.0	62	14	16
Self-consciousness	2.3	1	7	3	24.1	8	6	2
Ancient	4.1	7	12	20	50.2	87	13	22
Universals and particulars	6.7	7	19	20	73.5	80	19	20
Verification	9.7	9	28	26	116.5	114	29	29
Value	5.8	6	17	17	53.8	52	14	13
Deduction	5.3	5	15	14	54.6	52	14	13
Mechanisms	4.3	2	12	6	49.2	15	12	4
Temporal paradoxes	7.4	8	21	23	67.8	82	17	21
Classical space and time	4.1	3	12	9	35.8	23	9	6
Early modern	2.6	2	8	6	25.8	13	7	3
Meaning and use	13.1	14	38	40	179.4	227	45	57
Marx	6.3	8	18	23	72.6	63	18	16
Ordinary language	26.0	34	74	97	406.8	564	103	143
Moral conscience	7.7	8	22	23	82.8	54	21	14
Methodology of science	7.8	7	22	20	91.1	79	23	20
Heidegger and Husserl	5.2	9	15	26	59.5	105	15	27
Emotions	2.2	1	6	3	25.7	5	7	1
Ontological argument	3.5	3	10	9	31.2	12	8	3
Chemistry	8.1	11	23	32	60.8	60	15	15
Social contract theory	2.3	3	7	9	33.0	36	8	9
Kant	4.1	7	12	20	45.4	70	11	18
Promises and imperatives	4.2	3	12	9	52.4	38	13	10
Analytic/synthetic	2.8	0	8	0	26.0	0	7	0
Freedom and free will	2.6	2	7	6	33.8	23	9	6
Crime and punishment	2.7	5	8	14	49.8	114	13	29
Sets and grue	6.4	11	18	32	58.9	109	15	28
Origins and purposes	1.0	0	3	0	9.7	0	2	0
Time	2.8	3	8	9	33.1	32	8	8
Color/colour	3.4	4	10	11	27.1	17	7	4
War	2.3	1	7	3	31.5	7	8	2
Depiction	3.6	2	10	6	44.4	25	11	6
Denoting	3.9	5	11	14	40.6	57	10	14
Chance	4.1	4	12	11	34.2	46	9	12
Hume	1.5	1	4	3	17.5	11	4	3
Laws	2.4	0	7	0	25.4	0	6	0
Perception	5.3	5	15	14	65.4	67	17	17
Intention	2.0	3	6	9	33.2	40	8	10
Virtues	1.6	0	5	0	16.8	0	4	0
Space and time	5.0	5	14	14	28.1	20	7	5
Mathematics	4.0	6	12	17	33.6	38	9	10
Liberal democracy	3.7	5	11	14	74.0	147	19	37
Duties	3.1	5	9	14	47.9	78	12	20
Causation	2.4	3	7	9	26.4	34	7	9
Arguments	5.4	1	15	3	55.2	3	14	1
Theory testing	3.7	4	11	11	34.7	33	9	8
Decision theory	1.9	0	5	0	23.6	0	6	0
Minds and machines	1.5	1	4	3	15.2	6	4	2
Truth	4.5	3	13	9	30.6	15	8	4
Radical translation	2.1	1	6	3	19.5	5	5	1
Explanation	1.5	2	4	6	18.6	26	5	7
Personal identity	1.8	1	5	3	14.9	4	4	1
Speech acts	1.4	1	4	3	16.8	6	4	2
Sense and reference	2.0	1	6	3	15.7	4	4	1
Egalitarianism	1.6	1	4	3	9.2	1	2	0
Quantum physics	1.9	3	5	9	23.2	39	6	10
Theories and realism	2.9	1	8	3	33.9	11	9	3
Functions	1.5	0	4	0	14.5	0	4	0
Feminism	0.6	0	2	0	5.6	0	1	0
Medical ethics and Freud	0.9	1	3	3	16.4	34	4	9
Abortion and self-defence	0.4	1	1	3	2.5	4	1	1
Belief ascriptions	1.6	2	5	6	11.3	10	3	3
Thermodynamics	3.9	3	11	9	38.3	37	10	9
Knowledge	2.4	3	7	9	24.0	13	6	3
Game theory	0.8	1	2	3	10.0	12	3	3
Justification	1.9	0	5	0	20.1	0	5	0
Frankfurt cases	1.1	1	3	3	12.3	18	3	5
Concepts	3.1	0	9	0	39.1	0	10	0
Races and DNA	0.8	1	2	3	6.7	4	2	1
Modality	1.8	0	5	0	17.5	0	4	0
Reasons	1.4	1	4	3	15.4	9	4	2
Evolutionary biology	1.6	1	5	3	13.9	8	4	2
Population ethics	0.2	0	1	0	2.8	0	1	0
Formal epistemology	0.4	0	1	0	2.9	0	1	0
Wide content	0.7	0	2	0	7.5	0	2	0
Vagueness	0.4	0	1	0	4.9	0	1	0
Cognitive science	0.5	0	1	0	6.1	0	2	0
Models	1.7	0	5	0	13.7	0	3	0
Composition and constitution	2.5	1	7	3	22.4	3	6	1
Norms	1.7	1	5	3	26.2	11	7	3

1956

Table B.81: Measures of the prominence of each subject in 1956 ’s journals.

Subject	Weight	Raw	W-Ratio	R-Ratio	W-Pages	R-Pages	WP-Ratio	RP-Ratio
Psychology	2.0	0	6	0	34.2	0	9	0
Idealism	9.6	12	27	34	121.1	161	31	42
Life and value	10.5	6	30	17	123.6	69	32	18
Other history	9.7	8	28	23	87.9	51	23	13
Dewey and pragmatism	5.3	2	15	6	57.4	9	15	2
Definitions	10.7	8	30	23	119.6	93	31	24
Propositions and implications	4.8	6	14	17	61.8	94	16	24
Beauty	3.7	6	11	17	47.1	73	12	19
Physicalism	3.6	1	10	3	40.6	11	11	3
History and culture	7.3	11	21	31	96.0	141	25	36
Faith and theism	6.5	10	18	28	55.7	72	14	19
Self-consciousness	3.0	0	9	0	36.5	0	9	0
Ancient	3.7	5	10	14	37.8	46	10	12
Universals and particulars	5.6	4	16	11	65.5	60	17	16
Verification	12.2	8	35	23	142.5	111	37	29
Value	5.8	7	16	20	53.3	60	14	16
Deduction	5.0	0	14	0	49.2	0	13	0
Mechanisms	5.0	5	14	14	56.2	50	15	13
Temporal paradoxes	3.0	3	9	9	30.2	24	8	6
Classical space and time	3.1	1	9	3	29.2	4	8	1
Early modern	5.1	8	14	23	46.9	66	12	17
Meaning and use	16.4	19	47	54	177.9	176	46	46
Marx	5.1	5	14	14	51.3	47	13	12
Ordinary language	26.9	39	76	111	382.8	572	99	148
Moral conscience	9.0	17	26	48	95.0	202	25	52
Methodology of science	8.4	8	24	23	99.4	87	26	22
Heidegger and Husserl	7.1	13	20	37	72.2	141	19	36
Emotions	2.5	2	7	6	30.6	23	8	6
Ontological argument	3.0	0	8	0	30.8	0	8	0
Chemistry	2.8	5	8	14	29.0	53	8	14
Social contract theory	2.1	1	6	3	17.5	9	5	2
Kant	2.7	3	8	9	24.0	28	6	7
Promises and imperatives	5.3	6	15	17	57.6	91	15	24
Analytic/synthetic	5.7	5	16	14	52.2	51	13	13
Freedom and free will	2.2	3	6	9	18.7	16	5	4
Crime and punishment	1.1	0	3	0	11.5	0	3	0
Sets and grue	5.7	6	16	17	58.8	51	15	13
Origins and purposes	1.2	0	3	0	14.1	0	4	0
Time	3.3	3	9	9	38.8	23	10	6
Color/colour	3.8	4	11	11	42.9	45	11	12
War	2.8	4	8	11	28.9	31	7	8
Depiction	3.0	2	8	6	33.0	30	9	8
Denoting	5.4	8	15	23	55.3	85	14	22
Chance	5.0	8	14	23	30.4	46	8	12
Hume	1.4	2	4	6	16.2	20	4	5
Laws	2.7	3	8	9	27.9	22	7	6
Perception	4.6	2	13	6	50.4	22	13	6
Intention	4.0	8	12	23	67.0	157	17	41
Virtues	2.6	4	7	11	26.6	51	7	13
Space and time	3.1	4	9	11	32.2	51	8	13
Mathematics	3.0	3	8	9	29.9	25	8	6
Liberal democracy	2.4	4	7	11	30.4	47	8	12
Duties	2.0	1	6	3	25.4	3	7	1
Causation	2.3	3	7	9	23.8	25	6	6
Arguments	4.9	2	14	6	52.0	16	13	4
Theory testing	4.0	5	11	14	39.2	47	10	12
Decision theory	3.0	2	9	6	24.9	14	6	4
Minds and machines	1.7	2	5	6	17.0	11	4	3
Truth	4.5	3	13	9	43.2	13	11	3
Radical translation	2.5	1	7	3	22.7	6	6	2
Explanation	1.7	1	5	3	22.0	9	6	2
Personal identity	1.1	0	3	0	13.7	0	4	0
Speech acts	1.6	2	4	6	17.0	12	4	3
Sense and reference	2.5	2	7	6	30.3	33	8	9
Egalitarianism	1.9	2	5	6	23.5	51	6	13
Quantum physics	1.7	2	5	6	19.7	28	5	7
Theories and realism	2.5	0	7	0	25.2	0	7	0
Functions	1.7	0	5	0	15.8	0	4	0
Feminism	1.1	1	3	3	10.4	9	3	2
Medical ethics and Freud	3.0	4	8	11	26.9	55	7	14
Abortion and self-defence	0.6	0	2	0	7.4	0	2	0
Belief ascriptions	1.8	1	5	3	15.6	11	4	3
Thermodynamics	1.9	0	5	0	20.1	0	5	0
Knowledge	4.6	6	13	17	33.6	38	9	10
Game theory	0.6	0	2	0	9.0	0	2	0
Justification	2.2	2	6	6	22.4	22	6	6
Frankfurt cases	0.7	0	2	0	7.3	0	2	0
Concepts	3.6	1	10	3	47.3	20	12	5
Races and DNA	0.9	1	2	3	5.3	5	1	1
Modality	1.6	1	5	3	14.6	7	4	2
Reasons	1.5	1	4	3	15.7	9	4	2
Evolutionary biology	1.3	2	4	6	7.3	10	2	3
Population ethics	0.4	0	1	0	3.1	0	1	0
Formal epistemology	1.1	1	3	3	12.2	14	3	4
Wide content	0.5	0	1	0	6.2	0	2	0
Vagueness	0.9	1	3	3	8.0	2	2	1
Cognitive science	0.6	0	2	0	6.2	0	2	0
Models	0.7	0	2	0	9.2	0	2	0
Composition and constitution	1.3	0	4	0	13.7	0	4	0
Norms	2.1	0	6	0	24.4	0	6	0

1957

Table B.82: Measures of the prominence of each subject in 1957 ’s journals.

Subject	Weight	Raw	W-Ratio	R-Ratio	W-Pages	R-Pages	WP-Ratio	RP-Ratio
Psychology	2.6	2	8	6	38.9	29	10	7
Idealism	8.6	11	25	32	101.6	108	26	28
Life and value	8.0	7	23	20	95.4	99	25	26
Other history	6.3	6	18	17	54.6	37	14	10
Dewey and pragmatism	5.9	6	17	17	71.0	69	18	18
Definitions	9.3	6	27	17	95.5	47	25	12
Propositions and implications	5.3	7	15	20	65.5	78	17	20
Beauty	5.7	13	17	38	82.5	188	21	48
Physicalism	4.2	2	12	6	45.5	19	12	5
History and culture	6.6	8	19	23	78.7	85	20	22
Faith and theism	3.5	4	10	12	30.8	27	8	7
Self-consciousness	2.1	1	6	3	22.6	15	6	4
Ancient	5.0	6	14	17	42.4	41	11	11
Universals and particulars	8.6	10	25	29	107.9	171	28	44
Verification	11.9	14	34	40	129.2	160	33	41
Value	5.4	3	16	9	49.0	10	13	3
Deduction	5.1	2	15	6	54.6	21	14	5
Mechanisms	4.5	3	13	9	53.3	46	14	12
Temporal paradoxes	4.1	2	12	6	40.0	13	10	3
Classical space and time	2.0	0	6	0	17.9	0	5	0
Early modern	2.6	4	7	12	27.5	44	7	11
Meaning and use	16.3	18	47	52	164.1	142	42	37
Marx	6.5	11	19	32	71.7	147	18	38
Ordinary language	26.5	29	77	84	414.3	529	107	136
Moral conscience	7.7	9	22	26	94.2	90	24	23
Methodology of science	7.6	8	22	23	101.5	93	26	24
Heidegger and Husserl	4.2	5	12	14	56.6	80	15	21
Emotions	4.0	5	12	14	58.7	95	15	24
Ontological argument	4.3	4	12	12	41.3	39	11	10
Chemistry	3.2	4	9	12	28.7	32	7	8
Social contract theory	3.4	5	10	14	32.5	52	8	13
Kant	1.8	2	5	6	23.9	30	6	8
Promises and imperatives	5.4	6	16	17	77.0	75	20	19
Analytic/synthetic	4.1	3	12	9	33.8	28	9	7
Freedom and free will	2.9	5	8	14	29.3	46	8	12
Crime and punishment	2.4	2	7	6	32.9	22	8	6
Sets and grue	5.5	7	16	20	63.2	84	16	22
Origins and purposes	1.2	0	3	0	12.9	0	3	0
Time	4.0	7	12	20	48.0	83	12	21
Color/colour	3.4	2	10	6	31.5	15	8	4
War	3.8	4	11	12	33.1	26	9	7
Depiction	2.9	3	8	9	44.5	44	11	11
Denoting	5.8	6	17	17	47.6	27	12	7
Chance	2.8	7	8	20	28.2	59	7	15
Hume	0.9	1	3	3	10.2	13	3	3
Laws	4.8	5	14	14	53.3	48	14	12
Perception	6.1	8	18	23	74.2	106	19	27
Intention	4.0	7	12	20	31.3	36	8	9
Virtues	3.4	3	10	9	37.7	35	10	9
Space and time	4.0	6	11	17	34.8	56	9	14
Mathematics	3.2	5	9	14	36.8	65	9	17
Liberal democracy	3.1	5	9	14	32.4	44	8	11
Duties	1.7	0	5	0	17.0	0	4	0
Causation	3.5	5	10	14	33.0	32	9	8
Arguments	4.5	1	13	3	52.0	9	13	2
Theory testing	2.7	1	8	3	29.9	14	8	4
Decision theory	3.1	4	9	12	24.3	29	6	7
Minds and machines	1.6	0	5	0	15.5	0	4	0
Truth	5.3	6	15	17	41.5	29	11	7
Radical translation	1.9	0	5	0	19.9	0	5	0
Explanation	2.1	2	6	6	31.4	37	8	10
Personal identity	2.1	1	6	3	24.9	24	6	6
Speech acts	1.7	2	5	6	17.2	23	4	6
Sense and reference	2.7	1	8	3	25.7	3	7	1
Egalitarianism	1.1	1	3	3	9.3	10	2	3
Quantum physics	3.2	4	9	12	30.8	42	8	11
Theories and realism	3.3	0	9	0	33.2	0	9	0
Functions	1.7	0	5	0	18.3	0	5	0
Feminism	0.9	1	3	3	10.7	8	3	2
Medical ethics and Freud	0.8	0	2	0	6.5	0	2	0
Abortion and self-defence	0.5	0	1	0	4.9	0	1	0
Belief ascriptions	1.7	1	5	3	9.8	2	3	1
Thermodynamics	2.0	0	6	0	20.2	0	5	0
Knowledge	3.3	2	9	6	23.8	6	6	2
Game theory	0.6	0	2	0	5.9	0	2	0
Justification	1.0	0	3	0	12.5	0	3	0
Frankfurt cases	2.1	1	6	3	18.8	25	5	6
Concepts	3.3	1	9	3	35.3	14	9	4
Races and DNA	0.5	1	1	3	4.4	9	1	2
Modality	1.3	0	4	0	13.9	0	4	0
Reasons	1.6	1	5	3	17.6	9	5	2
Evolutionary biology	0.5	0	2	0	5.9	0	2	0
Population ethics	0.3	0	1	0	3.9	0	1	0
Formal epistemology	1.3	0	4	0	11.8	0	3	0
Wide content	0.5	0	2	0	4.9	0	1	0
Vagueness	0.8	0	2	0	8.0	0	2	0
Cognitive science	0.4	0	1	0	3.7	0	1	0
Models	0.4	0	1	0	5.4	0	1	0
Composition and constitution	1.9	1	5	3	15.3	5	4	1
Norms	1.9	0	5	0	26.2	0	7	0

1958

Table B.83: Measures of the prominence of each subject in 1958 ’s journals.

Subject	Weight	Raw	W-Ratio	R-Ratio	W-Pages	R-Pages	WP-Ratio	RP-Ratio
Psychology	1.4	0	4	0	18.8	0	5	0
Idealism	14.7	21	40	57	167.3	217	41	54
Life and value	8.3	6	22	16	98.7	73	24	18
Other history	7.6	6	20	16	74.2	54	18	13
Dewey and pragmatism	8.2	8	22	22	82.0	58	20	14
Definitions	8.7	1	23	3	97.0	9	24	2
Propositions and implications	5.8	9	16	24	74.3	134	18	33
Beauty	7.6	15	20	40	69.4	142	17	35
Physicalism	6.8	6	18	16	62.4	54	15	13
History and culture	7.6	11	20	30	74.7	96	19	24
Faith and theism	7.8	13	21	35	90.2	160	22	40
Self-consciousness	2.7	0	7	0	28.9	0	7	0
Ancient	3.1	4	8	11	42.7	68	11	17
Universals and particulars	8.5	8	23	22	84.2	95	21	24
Verification	11.6	8	31	22	124.7	115	31	29
Value	5.7	3	15	8	67.3	22	17	5
Deduction	6.6	6	18	16	61.8	32	15	8
Mechanisms	4.2	2	11	5	40.7	10	10	2
Temporal paradoxes	4.1	3	11	8	43.9	27	11	7
Classical space and time	4.2	4	11	11	34.9	35	9	9
Early modern	2.0	1	5	3	21.8	14	5	3
Meaning and use	13.8	14	37	38	147.7	140	37	35
Marx	5.2	6	14	16	58.9	69	15	17
Ordinary language	25.6	35	69	94	383.0	571	95	142
Moral conscience	11.1	16	30	43	128.2	181	32	45
Methodology of science	10.3	11	28	30	96.5	83	24	21
Heidegger and Husserl	5.4	11	15	30	63.0	161	16	40
Emotions	2.9	3	8	8	30.4	23	8	6
Ontological argument	3.7	1	10	3	33.9	3	8	1
Chemistry	3.8	7	10	19	39.3	73	10	18
Social contract theory	2.4	4	7	11	47.3	108	12	27
Kant	3.1	6	8	16	36.2	65	9	16
Promises and imperatives	6.6	8	18	22	68.3	64	17	16
Analytic/synthetic	6.1	4	17	11	62.0	48	15	12
Freedom and free will	3.5	5	9	13	40.4	51	10	13
Crime and punishment	1.8	2	5	5	18.6	16	5	4
Sets and grue	4.9	6	13	16	50.1	53	12	13
Origins and purposes	1.0	0	3	0	7.9	0	2	0
Time	2.8	3	7	8	28.9	22	7	5
Color/colour	4.6	5	12	13	45.5	53	11	13
War	2.8	1	7	3	30.2	12	7	3
Depiction	4.3	5	12	13	38.8	40	10	10
Denoting	5.5	8	15	22	41.3	49	10	12
Chance	2.2	2	6	5	20.8	22	5	5
Hume	1.0	0	3	0	13.6	0	3	0
Laws	2.6	1	7	3	29.7	11	7	3
Perception	7.6	9	20	24	79.2	92	20	23
Intention	1.7	0	5	0	15.9	0	4	0
Virtues	3.7	3	10	8	43.3	60	11	15
Space and time	1.5	2	4	5	14.5	13	4	3
Mathematics	2.8	3	7	8	20.5	26	5	6
Liberal democracy	3.8	6	10	16	44.3	87	11	22
Duties	1.6	1	4	3	23.3	14	6	3
Causation	2.8	2	8	5	28.7	13	7	3
Arguments	5.5	1	15	3	63.6	5	16	1
Theory testing	4.5	4	12	11	42.5	30	11	7
Decision theory	2.1	1	6	3	23.4	7	6	2
Minds and machines	1.1	0	3	0	13.8	0	3	0
Truth	5.8	7	16	19	41.9	33	10	8
Radical translation	2.5	3	7	8	20.5	21	5	5
Explanation	2.4	3	6	8	25.8	23	6	6
Personal identity	2.7	3	7	8	21.9	16	5	4
Speech acts	2.0	1	5	3	17.7	9	4	2
Sense and reference	3.3	2	9	5	24.6	8	6	2
Egalitarianism	1.5	2	4	5	19.7	35	5	9
Quantum physics	3.6	5	10	13	47.5	97	12	24
Theories and realism	3.7	2	10	5	40.4	12	10	3
Functions	1.4	0	4	0	15.3	0	4	0
Feminism	0.9	1	2	3	9.0	6	2	1
Medical ethics and Freud	0.7	0	2	0	7.5	0	2	0
Abortion and self-defence	0.5	0	1	0	5.0	0	1	0
Belief ascriptions	1.8	2	5	5	10.5	9	3	2
Thermodynamics	1.2	0	3	0	14.7	0	4	0
Knowledge	2.4	3	7	8	25.2	27	6	7
Game theory	0.8	0	2	0	10.0	0	2	0
Justification	2.3	2	6	5	28.7	26	7	6
Frankfurt cases	1.5	1	4	3	21.0	2	5	0
Concepts	2.9	0	8	0	39.8	0	10	0
Races and DNA	0.7	0	2	0	5.5	0	1	0
Modality	1.4	0	4	0	15.2	0	4	0
Reasons	1.9	0	5	0	22.3	0	6	0
Evolutionary biology	1.2	2	3	5	15.9	27	4	7
Population ethics	0.8	1	2	3	5.0	2	1	0
Formal epistemology	0.6	0	2	0	3.4	0	1	0
Wide content	0.6	0	2	0	5.4	0	1	0
Vagueness	0.6	0	2	0	8.3	0	2	0
Cognitive science	0.7	0	2	0	6.9	0	2	0
Models	1.0	0	3	0	10.6	0	3	0
Composition and constitution	2.0	0	5	0	23.5	0	6	0
Norms	2.4	0	7	0	31.0	0	8	0

1959

Table B.84: Measures of the prominence of each subject in 1959 ’s journals.

Subject	Weight	Raw	W-Ratio	R-Ratio	W-Pages	R-Pages	WP-Ratio	RP-Ratio
Psychology	2.5	1	7	3	26.2	7	7	2
Idealism	8.6	8	24	22	108.0	88	28	23
Life and value	8.7	5	24	14	86.1	33	22	9
Other history	6.6	5	18	14	74.9	56	19	15
Dewey and pragmatism	8.6	11	24	30	89.0	112	23	29
Definitions	8.9	7	24	19	93.1	68	24	18
Propositions and implications	5.6	6	16	17	49.2	42	13	11
Beauty	7.8	13	22	36	101.0	183	26	47
Physicalism	4.3	5	12	14	46.9	56	12	15
History and culture	4.4	4	12	11	55.1	59	14	15
Faith and theism	4.7	8	13	22	46.4	89	12	23
Self-consciousness	3.4	1	9	3	36.2	5	9	1
Ancient	3.0	5	8	14	28.9	60	7	16
Universals and particulars	7.3	8	20	22	86.9	105	23	27
Verification	12.4	11	34	30	124.7	85	32	22
Value	4.5	6	12	17	44.3	48	11	12
Deduction	6.4	6	18	17	75.7	88	20	23
Mechanisms	4.3	7	12	19	46.2	81	12	21
Temporal paradoxes	3.4	1	9	3	31.3	6	8	2
Classical space and time	2.3	3	6	8	23.8	26	6	7
Early modern	1.5	1	4	3	22.1	8	6	2
Meaning and use	16.6	19	46	52	176.5	194	46	50
Marx	5.5	8	15	22	48.4	57	13	15
Ordinary language	23.4	18	65	50	324.6	295	84	76
Moral conscience	9.5	19	26	52	100.9	218	26	56
Methodology of science	11.1	9	31	25	103.0	75	27	19
Heidegger and Husserl	6.3	11	17	30	78.1	134	20	35
Emotions	3.4	1	9	3	42.9	20	11	5
Ontological argument	3.7	2	10	6	30.3	25	8	6
Chemistry	4.6	6	13	17	53.3	61	14	16
Social contract theory	4.3	5	12	14	43.3	57	11	15
Kant	3.0	4	8	11	33.5	53	9	14
Promises and imperatives	5.3	5	15	14	58.1	51	15	13
Analytic/synthetic	3.7	2	10	6	37.0	22	10	6
Freedom and free will	3.6	7	10	19	34.9	63	9	16
Crime and punishment	2.2	5	6	14	25.2	64	7	17
Sets and grue	5.5	6	15	17	70.2	73	18	19
Origins and purposes	2.3	0	6	0	19.7	0	5	0
Time	2.3	1	6	3	30.4	16	8	4
Color/colour	2.2	2	6	6	31.9	45	8	12
War	2.3	1	6	3	29.9	22	8	6
Depiction	2.5	1	7	3	23.5	4	6	1
Denoting	5.4	6	15	17	39.2	44	10	11
Chance	4.8	7	13	19	32.7	48	8	12
Hume	3.9	8	11	22	38.9	92	10	24
Laws	3.1	2	9	6	27.0	9	7	2
Perception	4.8	4	13	11	53.3	48	14	12
Intention	5.2	7	14	19	38.9	43	10	11
Virtues	2.9	3	8	8	33.1	18	9	5
Space and time	5.0	9	14	25	46.4	100	12	26
Mathematics	3.7	7	10	19	42.6	88	11	23
Liberal democracy	3.5	4	10	11	31.3	30	8	8
Duties	2.2	2	6	6	25.1	30	6	8
Causation	2.4	2	7	6	25.9	10	7	3
Arguments	5.8	0	16	0	61.9	0	16	0
Theory testing	5.9	5	16	14	44.0	34	11	9
Decision theory	3.1	3	9	8	21.7	12	6	3
Minds and machines	2.2	2	6	6	15.8	13	4	3
Truth	4.1	3	11	8	44.4	42	12	11
Radical translation	2.8	2	8	6	27.7	14	7	4
Explanation	2.7	2	7	6	32.2	24	8	6
Personal identity	1.5	2	4	6	20.0	37	5	10
Speech acts	2.3	1	6	3	23.2	15	6	4
Sense and reference	2.1	2	6	6	21.6	22	6	6
Egalitarianism	0.7	1	2	3	5.3	12	1	3
Quantum physics	3.5	5	10	14	31.7	53	8	14
Theories and realism	4.5	2	13	6	43.0	8	11	2
Functions	1.2	0	3	0	13.5	0	3	0
Feminism	0.6	0	2	0	5.0	0	1	0
Medical ethics and Freud	0.7	0	2	0	6.7	0	2	0
Abortion and self-defence	0.5	0	1	0	4.9	0	1	0
Belief ascriptions	1.9	4	5	11	11.6	31	3	8
Thermodynamics	2.5	2	7	6	26.6	20	7	5
Knowledge	2.5	1	7	3	28.4	11	7	3
Game theory	0.8	1	2	3	7.7	7	2	2
Justification	2.5	2	7	6	29.8	21	8	5
Frankfurt cases	1.2	0	3	0	11.3	0	3	0
Concepts	4.0	0	11	0	54.3	0	14	0
Races and DNA	1.5	3	4	8	15.1	36	4	9
Modality	1.0	0	3	0	10.7	0	3	0
Reasons	2.0	1	6	3	22.1	6	6	2
Evolutionary biology	0.5	0	1	0	6.4	0	2	0
Population ethics	0.5	0	1	0	6.4	0	2	0
Formal epistemology	0.9	2	3	6	9.3	19	2	5
Wide content	0.5	0	1	0	5.0	0	1	0
Vagueness	1.0	0	3	0	10.6	0	3	0
Cognitive science	0.3	0	1	0	2.8	0	1	0
Models	1.0	0	3	0	11.2	0	3	0
Composition and constitution	1.8	0	5	0	20.7	0	5	0
Norms	1.8	1	5	3	21.3	9	6	2

1960

Table B.85: Measures of the prominence of each subject in 1960 ’s journals.

Subject	Weight	Raw	W-Ratio	R-Ratio	W-Pages	R-Pages	WP-Ratio	RP-Ratio
Psychology	3.3	4	10	12	39.7	53	10	14
Idealism	5.8	4	17	12	75.2	48	20	13
Life and value	6.1	5	18	15	83.3	66	22	17
Other history	6.8	4	20	12	76.9	43	20	11
Dewey and pragmatism	6.0	5	17	15	73.9	60	20	16
Definitions	9.4	7	27	20	109.2	92	29	24
Propositions and implications	7.4	11	22	32	64.9	86	17	23
Beauty	4.8	7	14	20	61.3	102	16	27
Physicalism	4.3	6	12	17	46.2	69	12	18
History and culture	5.2	8	15	23	60.6	101	16	27
Faith and theism	4.9	8	14	23	53.5	99	14	26
Self-consciousness	2.6	1	7	3	26.3	7	7	2
Ancient	4.5	7	13	20	42.5	40	11	11
Universals and particulars	7.8	11	23	32	98.4	175	26	46
Verification	12.5	13	36	38	119.5	105	32	28
Value	3.0	2	9	6	35.0	18	9	5
Deduction	7.2	5	21	15	66.1	43	17	11
Mechanisms	4.0	3	12	9	49.0	33	13	9
Temporal paradoxes	4.9	4	14	12	45.5	30	12	8
Classical space and time	2.2	2	6	6	20.9	16	6	4
Early modern	1.5	1	4	3	13.7	4	4	1
Meaning and use	15.1	15	44	44	168.8	173	45	46
Marx	5.3	8	15	23	55.3	79	15	21
Ordinary language	24.8	26	72	76	333.5	419	88	111
Moral conscience	8.3	14	24	41	87.5	147	23	39
Methodology of science	9.4	7	27	20	101.0	55	27	15
Heidegger and Husserl	4.7	8	14	23	52.9	87	14	23
Emotions	2.1	3	6	9	20.8	32	6	8
Ontological argument	6.2	9	18	26	68.4	100	18	26
Chemistry	4.8	7	14	20	46.9	56	12	15
Social contract theory	1.6	1	5	3	19.5	16	5	4
Kant	1.5	1	4	3	16.4	14	4	4
Promises and imperatives	6.3	8	18	23	72.0	91	19	24
Analytic/synthetic	3.9	3	11	9	41.2	27	11	7
Freedom and free will	4.2	6	12	17	51.7	74	14	20
Crime and punishment	3.5	6	10	17	41.3	64	11	17
Sets and grue	5.5	4	16	12	53.8	42	14	11
Origins and purposes	1.1	0	3	0	10.9	0	3	0
Time	3.8	4	11	12	35.1	28	9	7
Color/colour	3.3	2	10	6	33.7	23	9	6
War	2.2	2	7	6	25.4	32	7	8
Depiction	3.4	3	10	9	38.5	26	10	7
Denoting	5.4	4	16	12	49.8	27	13	7
Chance	2.9	3	9	9	26.8	29	7	8
Hume	1.9	4	6	12	28.1	61	7	16
Laws	2.3	1	7	3	25.1	27	7	7
Perception	4.6	6	13	17	49.8	53	13	14
Intention	2.5	3	7	9	36.1	61	10	16
Virtues	3.3	3	10	9	29.6	19	8	5
Space and time	3.9	5	11	15	46.5	68	12	18
Mathematics	2.9	5	8	15	32.7	60	9	16
Liberal democracy	3.4	4	10	12	55.1	84	15	22
Duties	3.0	3	9	9	22.0	13	6	3
Causation	3.6	6	10	17	35.4	55	9	15
Arguments	6.6	0	19	0	68.1	0	18	0
Theory testing	5.6	7	16	20	53.7	54	14	14
Decision theory	2.5	3	7	9	22.7	13	6	3
Minds and machines	1.3	0	4	0	14.5	0	4	0
Truth	4.9	3	14	9	43.5	19	11	5
Radical translation	1.4	0	4	0	12.9	0	3	0
Explanation	1.0	0	3	0	12.7	0	3	0
Personal identity	3.1	4	9	12	22.6	25	6	7
Speech acts	1.8	0	5	0	20.7	0	5	0
Sense and reference	2.0	1	6	3	25.0	14	7	4
Egalitarianism	0.4	0	1	0	4.2	0	1	0
Quantum physics	2.1	2	6	6	24.6	22	7	6
Theories and realism	4.6	4	13	12	46.1	35	12	9
Functions	1.3	1	4	3	12.3	3	3	1
Feminism	1.2	1	3	3	12.8	18	3	5
Medical ethics and Freud	1.7	2	5	6	13.7	16	4	4
Abortion and self-defence	0.6	1	2	3	7.2	12	2	3
Belief ascriptions	1.4	1	4	3	12.3	12	3	3
Thermodynamics	1.3	0	4	0	13.8	0	4	0
Knowledge	1.5	0	4	0	15.6	0	4	0
Game theory	0.9	1	3	3	10.3	10	3	3
Justification	2.2	2	6	6	23.6	18	6	5
Frankfurt cases	1.2	1	3	3	13.1	10	3	3
Concepts	3.1	0	9	0	41.1	0	11	0
Races and DNA	1.4	2	4	6	11.3	17	3	4
Modality	1.7	1	5	3	18.2	20	5	5
Reasons	2.3	1	7	3	23.4	5	6	1
Evolutionary biology	0.6	0	2	0	5.2	0	1	0
Population ethics	0.7	1	2	3	1.7	1	0	0
Formal epistemology	0.6	1	2	3	5.9	10	2	3
Wide content	0.9	0	3	0	13.0	0	3	0
Vagueness	0.6	0	2	0	4.3	0	1	0
Cognitive science	0.7	0	2	0	7.3	0	2	0
Models	1.3	1	4	3	18.3	12	5	3
Composition and constitution	2.0	1	6	3	19.5	5	5	1
Norms	2.7	0	8	0	35.1	0	9	0

1961

Table B.86: Measures of the prominence of each subject in 1961 ’s journals.

Subject	Weight	Raw	W-Ratio	R-Ratio	W-Pages	R-Pages	WP-Ratio	RP-Ratio
Psychology	3.2	3	8	8	35.1	27	9	7
Idealism	7.7	6	20	16	95.3	65	24	17
Life and value	4.8	4	13	10	54.0	43	14	11
Other history	5.5	2	14	5	65.6	25	17	6
Dewey and pragmatism	5.8	8	15	21	60.4	80	16	21
Definitions	7.4	2	19	5	74.0	19	19	5
Propositions and implications	8.6	9	22	23	79.6	74	20	19
Beauty	11.0	23	29	60	101.6	218	26	56
Physicalism	3.6	4	9	10	32.8	32	8	8
History and culture	4.5	6	12	16	53.7	84	14	22
Faith and theism	5.2	5	13	13	49.5	45	13	12
Self-consciousness	3.0	2	8	5	21.8	3	6	1
Ancient	4.0	5	10	13	38.5	41	10	11
Universals and particulars	7.1	12	18	31	90.1	199	23	51
Verification	14.9	19	39	49	142.3	170	37	44
Value	3.7	4	9	10	43.5	67	11	17
Deduction	8.7	11	23	28	82.1	94	21	24
Mechanisms	3.1	2	8	5	35.7	29	9	7
Temporal paradoxes	4.6	5	12	13	54.8	83	14	21
Classical space and time	4.6	3	12	8	42.5	27	11	7
Early modern	3.0	4	8	10	31.2	43	8	11
Meaning and use	19.5	29	50	75	201.9	236	52	61
Marx	5.6	11	15	28	52.1	106	13	27
Ordinary language	29.8	35	77	91	406.3	585	104	150
Moral conscience	9.4	12	24	31	68.7	88	18	23
Methodology of science	6.9	5	18	13	85.9	70	22	18
Heidegger and Husserl	4.0	4	10	10	39.7	35	10	9
Emotions	4.5	2	12	5	36.9	6	9	2
Ontological argument	9.8	13	25	34	77.0	107	20	27
Chemistry	3.3	4	9	10	33.5	22	9	6
Social contract theory	2.2	2	6	5	22.9	10	6	3
Kant	1.3	0	3	0	14.0	0	4	0
Promises and imperatives	4.8	3	12	8	41.1	15	11	4
Analytic/synthetic	3.8	3	10	8	36.0	30	9	8
Freedom and free will	3.5	4	9	10	23.1	30	6	8
Crime and punishment	4.0	5	10	13	49.1	75	13	19
Sets and grue	6.8	6	18	16	69.5	44	18	11
Origins and purposes	1.4	1	4	3	15.2	24	4	6
Time	2.3	2	6	5	20.5	9	5	2
Color/colour	5.8	5	15	13	45.6	26	12	7
War	3.5	1	9	3	24.2	2	6	1
Depiction	2.4	1	6	3	35.3	54	9	14
Denoting	2.6	2	7	5	33.7	33	9	8
Chance	3.7	3	9	8	37.1	28	10	7
Hume	2.6	5	7	13	18.5	40	5	10
Laws	3.4	0	9	0	36.5	0	9	0
Perception	6.4	6	17	16	84.9	72	22	18
Intention	2.8	1	7	3	22.7	4	6	1
Virtues	3.4	4	9	10	30.9	40	8	10
Space and time	3.6	5	9	13	14.3	12	4	3
Mathematics	3.1	3	8	8	28.1	13	7	3
Liberal democracy	3.4	6	9	16	29.7	51	8	13
Duties	3.1	5	8	13	24.3	37	6	9
Causation	3.8	5	10	13	40.6	41	10	11
Arguments	8.6	2	22	5	75.7	6	19	2
Theory testing	6.3	7	16	18	56.8	76	15	20
Decision theory	4.1	4	11	10	28.9	26	7	7
Minds and machines	2.0	1	5	3	17.9	9	5	2
Truth	5.1	1	13	3	42.2	9	11	2
Radical translation	2.8	2	7	5	26.4	13	7	3
Explanation	2.7	2	7	5	29.2	21	7	5
Personal identity	1.6	0	4	0	15.6	0	4	0
Speech acts	2.7	4	7	10	30.1	39	8	10
Sense and reference	2.6	1	7	3	30.5	6	8	2
Egalitarianism	0.9	1	2	3	5.4	5	1	1
Quantum physics	4.5	7	12	18	45.6	79	12	20
Theories and realism	4.8	3	12	8	45.5	37	12	9
Functions	1.8	0	5	0	18.3	0	5	0
Feminism	1.5	1	4	3	14.9	4	4	1
Medical ethics and Freud	1.0	2	2	5	8.8	18	2	5
Abortion and self-defence	0.8	0	2	0	6.8	0	2	0
Belief ascriptions	2.0	4	5	10	12.4	16	3	4
Thermodynamics	2.1	0	5	0	22.7	0	6	0
Knowledge	2.0	0	5	0	20.7	0	5	0
Game theory	1.6	0	4	0	10.2	0	3	0
Justification	3.7	4	10	10	27.8	24	7	6
Frankfurt cases	1.2	1	3	3	15.1	16	4	4
Concepts	3.8	0	10	0	45.1	0	12	0
Races and DNA	1.2	1	3	3	6.5	2	2	1
Modality	1.6	0	4	0	14.7	0	4	0
Reasons	1.9	1	5	3	16.3	6	4	2
Evolutionary biology	1.5	2	4	5	24.5	32	6	8
Population ethics	0.7	0	2	0	6.0	0	2	0
Formal epistemology	1.2	1	3	3	14.0	21	4	5
Wide content	0.9	1	2	3	7.9	7	2	2
Vagueness	0.6	0	1	0	6.8	0	2	0
Cognitive science	1.1	0	3	0	7.9	0	2	0
Models	1.0	0	2	0	17.2	0	4	0
Composition and constitution	2.3	1	6	3	21.0	10	5	3
Norms	1.4	0	4	0	15.2	0	4	0

1962

Table B.87: Measures of the prominence of each subject in 1962 ’s journals.

Subject	Weight	Raw	W-Ratio	R-Ratio	W-Pages	R-Pages	WP-Ratio	RP-Ratio
Psychology	1.9	1	5	3	20.0	4	5	1
Idealism	6.5	4	18	11	71.9	40	20	11
Life and value	5.4	1	15	3	67.0	6	18	2
Other history	6.9	4	19	11	65.5	33	18	9
Dewey and pragmatism	3.6	0	10	0	38.3	0	10	0
Definitions	7.6	6	20	16	72.9	52	20	14
Propositions and implications	6.5	5	18	14	49.5	22	13	6
Beauty	5.9	13	16	35	63.0	158	17	43
Physicalism	4.6	5	12	14	37.4	29	10	8
History and culture	4.9	6	13	16	58.4	66	16	18
Faith and theism	3.0	4	8	11	23.6	36	6	10
Self-consciousness	3.0	1	8	3	23.8	4	6	1
Ancient	4.9	7	13	19	53.5	75	15	20
Universals and particulars	5.3	7	14	19	58.0	69	16	19
Verification	14.2	10	38	27	134.0	83	36	23
Value	5.0	4	14	11	42.5	28	12	8
Deduction	7.6	6	21	16	61.3	31	17	8
Mechanisms	2.8	2	8	5	34.6	25	9	7
Temporal paradoxes	3.7	4	10	11	38.9	47	11	13
Classical space and time	2.7	2	7	5	30.8	30	8	8
Early modern	4.9	8	13	22	42.1	70	11	19
Meaning and use	19.0	27	51	73	198.3	313	54	85
Marx	5.0	8	14	22	61.2	104	17	28
Ordinary language	29.4	31	80	84	392.1	480	107	130
Moral conscience	7.9	10	21	27	76.1	95	21	26
Methodology of science	7.4	9	20	24	79.3	94	22	26
Heidegger and Husserl	7.3	13	20	35	71.1	124	19	34
Emotions	3.2	5	9	14	42.0	74	11	20
Ontological argument	5.6	8	15	22	42.3	51	12	14
Chemistry	4.6	8	12	22	48.1	83	13	23
Social contract theory	1.9	1	5	3	12.2	2	3	1
Kant	1.6	2	4	5	14.7	20	4	5
Promises and imperatives	5.7	4	15	11	57.9	42	16	11
Analytic/synthetic	4.4	1	12	3	32.2	7	9	2
Freedom and free will	3.7	5	10	14	40.1	61	11	17
Crime and punishment	2.7	6	7	16	23.4	56	6	15
Sets and grue	5.2	5	14	14	53.1	62	14	17
Origins and purposes	2.2	2	6	5	28.5	33	8	9
Time	5.9	8	16	22	49.3	61	13	17
Color/colour	3.4	4	9	11	37.8	39	10	11
War	4.0	3	11	8	37.5	25	10	7
Depiction	3.3	2	9	5	35.1	26	10	7
Denoting	5.5	9	15	24	49.5	69	13	19
Chance	2.5	2	7	5	16.1	7	4	2
Hume	1.6	2	4	5	13.2	14	4	4
Laws	2.9	1	8	3	32.8	19	9	5
Perception	4.1	4	11	11	35.4	31	10	8
Intention	5.6	6	15	16	56.7	49	15	13
Virtues	3.4	4	9	11	28.4	24	8	7
Space and time	3.1	5	8	14	35.2	68	10	18
Mathematics	2.3	2	6	5	30.4	47	8	13
Liberal democracy	2.3	3	6	8	29.2	45	8	12
Duties	1.9	2	5	5	18.7	22	5	6
Causation	2.5	1	7	3	24.1	8	7	2
Arguments	7.9	3	21	8	72.7	9	20	2
Theory testing	3.4	2	9	5	34.5	22	9	6
Decision theory	3.3	2	9	5	24.7	6	7	2
Minds and machines	2.3	1	6	3	20.3	3	6	1
Truth	6.9	5	19	14	50.9	29	14	8
Radical translation	3.6	4	10	11	30.9	23	8	6
Explanation	2.4	5	7	14	32.3	70	9	19
Personal identity	1.7	2	5	5	15.6	24	4	7
Speech acts	2.8	2	8	5	30.5	20	8	5
Sense and reference	3.4	2	9	5	24.4	6	7	2
Egalitarianism	0.6	0	2	0	3.9	0	1	0
Quantum physics	6.0	9	16	24	45.6	73	12	20
Theories and realism	4.1	3	11	8	37.8	20	10	5
Functions	1.1	0	3	0	11.5	0	3	0
Feminism	1.5	2	4	5	13.7	13	4	4
Medical ethics and Freud	0.9	0	3	0	16.7	0	5	0
Abortion and self-defence	0.7	0	2	0	5.6	0	2	0
Belief ascriptions	0.7	0	2	0	7.3	0	2	0
Thermodynamics	2.0	0	5	0	21.9	0	6	0
Knowledge	3.7	3	10	8	33.9	14	9	4
Game theory	1.1	2	3	5	7.6	10	2	3
Justification	3.3	3	9	8	24.3	11	7	3
Frankfurt cases	3.9	4	11	11	28.5	35	8	10
Concepts	4.6	1	13	3	48.3	8	13	2
Races and DNA	0.6	0	2	0	5.0	0	1	0
Modality	1.2	1	3	3	9.4	8	3	2
Reasons	2.6	2	7	5	34.5	40	9	11
Evolutionary biology	0.9	2	2	5	7.9	17	2	5
Population ethics	0.3	0	1	0	2.9	0	1	0
Formal epistemology	1.7	3	5	8	15.9	41	4	11
Wide content	1.0	0	3	0	6.6	0	2	0
Vagueness	0.8	0	2	0	7.6	0	2	0
Cognitive science	0.6	0	2	0	4.6	0	1	0
Models	1.1	0	3	0	10.5	0	3	0
Composition and constitution	2.2	1	6	3	22.1	6	6	2
Norms	2.1	2	6	5	20.7	9	6	2

1963

Table B.88: Measures of the prominence of each subject in 1963 ’s journals.

Subject	Weight	Raw	W-Ratio	R-Ratio	W-Pages	R-Pages	WP-Ratio	RP-Ratio
Psychology	2.0	2	5	5	31.4	39	8	10
Idealism	5.6	4	15	11	75.4	33	20	9
Life and value	6.1	4	16	11	71.4	35	18	9
Other history	6.0	4	16	11	58.2	24	15	6
Dewey and pragmatism	3.8	1	10	3	42.2	9	11	2
Definitions	7.2	3	19	8	81.3	18	21	5
Propositions and implications	5.7	4	15	11	47.3	38	12	10
Beauty	3.0	4	8	11	26.3	33	7	9
Physicalism	6.8	8	18	21	49.7	59	13	15
History and culture	3.1	4	8	11	37.3	44	10	11
Faith and theism	3.8	5	10	13	43.9	49	11	13
Self-consciousness	3.2	0	9	0	32.9	0	9	0
Ancient	4.9	7	13	19	62.8	98	16	25
Universals and particulars	5.7	6	15	16	69.6	87	18	23
Verification	14.7	9	39	24	144.6	68	37	18
Value	3.7	4	10	11	36.9	29	10	8
Deduction	6.6	5	17	13	48.4	40	13	10
Mechanisms	3.0	4	8	11	36.5	40	9	10
Temporal paradoxes	4.4	4	12	11	44.2	34	11	9
Classical space and time	2.7	2	7	5	26.7	12	7	3
Early modern	3.6	6	10	16	39.1	67	10	17
Meaning and use	15.0	18	40	48	173.6	213	45	55
Marx	5.0	5	13	13	47.7	39	12	10
Ordinary language	28.5	33	75	87	387.6	467	100	121
Moral conscience	8.5	9	22	24	89.1	84	23	22
Methodology of science	4.5	2	12	5	48.6	24	13	6
Heidegger and Husserl	8.7	14	23	37	97.8	178	25	46
Emotions	5.7	9	15	24	53.0	76	14	20
Ontological argument	4.2	1	11	3	40.0	16	10	4
Chemistry	3.5	6	9	16	24.8	46	6	12
Social contract theory	2.9	3	8	8	25.9	36	7	9
Kant	2.0	2	5	5	22.8	32	6	8
Promises and imperatives	10.5	11	28	29	93.6	108	24	28
Analytic/synthetic	4.3	10	11	26	42.8	139	11	36
Freedom and free will	3.8	4	10	11	29.9	20	8	5
Crime and punishment	6.2	12	16	32	50.4	107	13	28
Sets and grue	6.9	8	18	21	70.9	65	18	17
Origins and purposes	1.6	1	4	3	14.2	3	4	1
Time	6.5	11	17	29	59.4	93	15	24
Color/colour	4.6	6	12	16	32.1	23	8	6
War	3.5	3	9	8	35.7	32	9	8
Depiction	3.7	4	10	11	40.6	48	10	12
Denoting	5.3	7	14	19	47.1	86	12	22
Chance	2.8	2	7	5	22.9	17	6	4
Hume	0.6	0	2	0	7.7	0	2	0
Laws	3.4	2	9	5	28.4	9	7	2
Perception	4.4	6	12	16	48.9	58	13	15
Intention	5.7	6	15	16	43.8	34	11	9
Virtues	3.4	2	9	5	30.2	13	8	3
Space and time	2.9	4	8	11	33.0	46	9	12
Mathematics	6.5	9	17	24	93.4	156	24	40
Liberal democracy	3.3	4	9	11	36.9	47	10	12
Duties	2.7	2	7	5	26.7	15	7	4
Causation	3.4	3	9	8	29.8	31	8	8
Arguments	8.1	2	21	5	77.4	16	20	4
Theory testing	5.4	10	14	26	50.4	84	13	22
Decision theory	2.7	0	7	0	24.2	0	6	0
Minds and machines	3.8	4	10	11	32.0	52	8	13
Truth	4.2	4	11	11	39.3	36	10	9
Radical translation	1.8	0	5	0	19.3	0	5	0
Explanation	2.8	2	7	5	26.3	8	7	2
Personal identity	3.2	4	8	11	33.5	55	9	14
Speech acts	3.3	2	9	5	32.2	6	8	2
Sense and reference	3.5	3	9	8	30.8	29	8	8
Egalitarianism	1.1	1	3	3	14.3	25	4	6
Quantum physics	2.3	3	6	8	28.8	42	7	11
Theories and realism	3.2	2	9	5	30.3	21	8	5
Functions	1.4	0	4	0	14.0	0	4	0
Feminism	1.1	1	3	3	10.8	16	3	4
Medical ethics and Freud	1.6	1	4	3	11.8	1	3	0
Abortion and self-defence	0.9	0	3	0	8.6	0	2	0
Belief ascriptions	1.8	1	5	3	15.9	7	4	2
Thermodynamics	2.0	2	5	5	21.2	26	5	7
Knowledge	4.4	4	12	11	42.6	39	11	10
Game theory	1.3	0	3	0	10.4	0	3	0
Justification	3.2	3	9	8	28.9	15	7	4
Frankfurt cases	4.8	6	13	16	29.2	31	8	8
Concepts	4.6	1	12	3	61.5	18	16	5
Races and DNA	0.7	0	2	0	6.7	0	2	0
Modality	1.4	1	4	3	13.9	3	4	1
Reasons	2.4	4	6	11	26.9	46	7	12
Evolutionary biology	2.0	3	5	8	11.5	17	3	4
Population ethics	0.8	1	2	3	12.8	32	3	8
Formal epistemology	1.8	3	5	8	10.3	21	3	5
Wide content	1.3	0	3	0	10.5	0	3	0
Vagueness	0.4	0	1	0	3.4	0	1	0
Cognitive science	0.6	0	2	0	4.0	0	1	0
Models	1.2	1	3	3	8.9	2	2	1
Composition and constitution	1.3	0	4	0	12.4	0	3	0
Norms	1.4	0	4	0	14.7	0	4	0

1964

Table B.89: Measures of the prominence of each subject in 1964 ’s journals.

Subject	Weight	Raw	W-Ratio	R-Ratio	W-Pages	R-Pages	WP-Ratio	RP-Ratio
Psychology	2.2	0	6	0	27.2	0	7	0
Idealism	4.4	1	12	3	57.5	7	15	2
Life and value	6.2	9	16	24	74.5	100	20	26
Other history	5.7	3	15	8	55.0	19	14	5
Dewey and pragmatism	5.2	7	14	18	42.5	46	11	12
Definitions	8.6	8	22	21	84.7	61	22	16
Propositions and implications	7.0	6	18	16	69.6	63	18	17
Beauty	4.1	8	11	21	42.2	83	11	22
Physicalism	4.5	3	12	8	45.0	30	12	8
History and culture	4.6	8	12	21	35.9	55	9	14
Faith and theism	4.9	9	13	24	54.8	104	14	27
Self-consciousness	2.7	1	7	3	26.0	6	7	2
Ancient	6.7	16	18	42	82.8	200	22	52
Universals and particulars	6.5	8	17	21	58.1	70	15	18
Verification	15.1	12	40	31	134.8	103	35	27
Value	4.6	4	12	10	44.4	27	12	7
Deduction	6.5	6	17	16	59.3	41	16	11
Mechanisms	2.6	1	7	3	25.9	8	7	2
Temporal paradoxes	3.9	3	10	8	43.0	40	11	10
Classical space and time	3.0	3	8	8	38.7	45	10	12
Early modern	2.9	5	8	13	35.3	65	9	17
Meaning and use	13.1	13	34	34	139.3	126	36	33
Marx	6.6	11	17	29	62.8	111	16	29
Ordinary language	26.6	22	70	58	359.1	340	94	89
Moral conscience	8.0	9	21	24	67.4	80	18	21
Methodology of science	5.2	4	14	10	49.4	27	13	7
Heidegger and Husserl	4.7	7	12	18	59.0	87	15	23
Emotions	3.5	5	9	13	45.5	66	12	17
Ontological argument	4.0	5	10	13	38.6	41	10	11
Chemistry	4.4	6	12	16	48.0	81	13	21
Social contract theory	2.2	2	6	5	18.8	18	5	5
Kant	2.5	2	7	5	25.4	29	7	8
Promises and imperatives	8.9	10	23	26	85.0	64	22	17
Analytic/synthetic	3.9	2	10	5	34.5	27	9	7
Freedom and free will	3.8	7	10	18	45.2	84	12	22
Crime and punishment	2.7	3	7	8	22.7	31	6	8
Sets and grue	6.6	7	17	18	64.6	59	17	15
Origins and purposes	2.9	2	8	5	18.4	5	5	1
Time	5.3	8	14	21	46.9	78	12	20
Color/colour	4.1	5	11	13	33.8	40	9	10
War	3.7	2	10	5	30.0	15	8	4
Depiction	2.8	3	7	8	29.5	32	8	8
Denoting	3.9	3	10	8	29.5	7	8	2
Chance	4.1	6	11	16	35.9	68	9	18
Hume	3.0	6	8	16	28.1	57	7	15
Laws	3.4	2	9	5	31.0	15	8	4
Perception	6.2	8	16	21	59.2	72	15	19
Intention	3.8	4	10	10	47.6	53	12	14
Virtues	4.4	4	11	10	36.6	25	10	7
Space and time	1.2	0	3	0	14.3	0	4	0
Mathematics	4.9	7	13	18	63.4	105	17	28
Liberal democracy	2.7	2	7	5	36.8	47	10	12
Duties	4.5	6	12	16	42.5	68	11	18
Causation	2.7	2	7	5	30.2	26	8	7
Arguments	9.2	3	24	8	85.7	18	22	5
Theory testing	5.0	7	13	18	41.8	59	11	15
Decision theory	3.7	3	10	8	31.7	22	8	6
Minds and machines	2.9	2	8	5	29.1	28	8	7
Truth	5.3	5	14	13	45.2	27	12	7
Radical translation	2.2	1	6	3	20.6	11	5	3
Explanation	1.8	1	5	3	17.9	9	5	2
Personal identity	2.9	2	7	5	20.7	10	5	3
Speech acts	4.0	3	10	8	54.4	52	14	14
Sense and reference	3.6	5	9	13	48.9	65	13	17
Egalitarianism	1.2	1	3	3	11.4	18	3	5
Quantum physics	3.6	5	9	13	33.5	52	9	14
Theories and realism	6.3	4	16	10	53.6	29	14	8
Functions	2.5	3	6	8	25.8	36	7	9
Feminism	1.5	1	4	3	14.4	15	4	4
Medical ethics and Freud	0.7	0	2	0	7.6	0	2	0
Abortion and self-defence	1.3	1	4	3	14.2	22	4	6
Belief ascriptions	2.4	3	6	8	17.1	12	4	3
Thermodynamics	3.7	4	10	10	29.7	41	8	11
Knowledge	3.5	0	9	0	31.2	0	8	0
Game theory	2.3	3	6	8	18.6	28	5	7
Justification	5.5	7	14	18	42.9	53	11	14
Frankfurt cases	3.5	3	9	8	22.2	12	6	3
Concepts	4.4	1	12	3	48.6	10	13	3
Races and DNA	1.5	0	4	0	9.7	0	3	0
Modality	2.0	0	5	0	11.8	0	3	0
Reasons	3.4	2	9	5	27.4	9	7	2
Evolutionary biology	1.2	2	3	5	6.3	8	2	2
Population ethics	0.7	0	2	0	6.6	0	2	0
Formal epistemology	0.8	1	2	3	5.9	4	2	1
Wide content	1.1	0	3	0	8.8	0	2	0
Vagueness	0.7	0	2	0	6.1	0	2	0
Cognitive science	0.5	1	1	3	2.7	4	1	1
Models	0.9	0	2	0	9.8	0	3	0
Composition and constitution	2.0	1	5	3	18.6	4	5	1
Norms	2.4	1	6	3	21.6	3	6	1

1965

Table B.90: Measures of the prominence of each subject in 1965 ’s journals.

Subject	Weight	Raw	W-Ratio	R-Ratio	W-Pages	R-Pages	WP-Ratio	RP-Ratio
Psychology	2.4	2	6	5	28.5	39	8	10
Idealism	3.6	2	9	5	47.4	24	13	6
Life and value	4.6	4	12	10	54.1	54	14	14
Other history	7.2	5	18	13	64.1	31	17	8
Dewey and pragmatism	2.5	1	6	3	34.9	23	9	6
Definitions	9.2	5	23	13	84.6	36	22	10
Propositions and implications	6.3	4	16	10	51.7	19	14	5
Beauty	4.8	6	12	15	49.5	85	13	23
Physicalism	4.1	5	10	13	39.0	36	10	10
History and culture	3.5	3	9	8	32.2	35	9	9
Faith and theism	3.4	5	9	13	27.4	55	7	15
Self-consciousness	2.2	0	6	0	21.0	0	6	0
Ancient	3.8	7	10	18	47.2	115	13	31
Universals and particulars	7.9	8	20	20	73.8	95	20	25
Verification	17.2	17	44	43	139.3	115	37	31
Value	3.4	3	9	8	35.6	41	9	11
Deduction	7.7	8	20	20	67.6	70	18	19
Mechanisms	2.9	2	7	5	29.0	12	8	3
Temporal paradoxes	6.3	7	16	18	64.6	71	17	19
Classical space and time	3.6	2	9	5	39.1	23	10	6
Early modern	4.3	6	11	15	29.7	43	8	11
Meaning and use	15.1	14	38	36	165.2	136	44	36
Marx	3.9	5	10	13	37.2	42	10	11
Ordinary language	25.2	31	64	79	341.8	423	91	112
Moral conscience	6.7	8	17	20	65.9	63	17	17
Methodology of science	6.7	9	17	23	54.3	61	14	16
Heidegger and Husserl	5.3	8	13	20	45.4	61	12	16
Emotions	3.4	5	9	13	43.0	57	11	15
Ontological argument	4.7	3	12	8	41.2	28	11	7
Chemistry	3.2	1	8	3	34.0	5	9	1
Social contract theory	1.5	0	4	0	18.0	0	5	0
Kant	2.1	3	5	8	22.1	30	6	8
Promises and imperatives	9.4	14	24	36	87.1	150	23	40
Analytic/synthetic	3.9	1	10	3	34.6	15	9	4
Freedom and free will	3.1	5	8	13	32.1	54	9	14
Crime and punishment	4.1	7	10	18	45.6	86	12	23
Sets and grue	11.8	18	30	46	107.8	166	29	44
Origins and purposes	2.2	0	6	0	22.2	0	6	0
Time	4.2	8	11	20	34.2	74	9	20
Color/colour	5.0	5	13	13	37.0	30	10	8
War	4.5	4	11	10	42.9	44	11	12
Depiction	2.7	4	7	10	31.5	45	8	12
Denoting	6.1	6	15	15	54.1	59	14	16
Chance	8.1	14	21	36	69.7	126	18	33
Hume	1.6	1	4	3	16.9	7	4	2
Laws	3.1	1	8	3	28.9	14	8	4
Perception	3.9	2	10	5	45.5	26	12	7
Intention	4.3	5	11	13	34.2	32	9	8
Virtues	3.3	2	8	5	29.0	18	8	5
Space and time	4.8	7	12	18	44.1	71	12	19
Mathematics	4.9	7	13	18	52.3	110	14	29
Liberal democracy	2.2	2	6	5	19.1	8	5	2
Duties	6.6	8	17	20	60.0	73	16	19
Causation	3.5	3	9	8	37.1	36	10	10
Arguments	9.0	3	23	8	78.0	29	21	8
Theory testing	4.5	3	11	8	29.1	10	8	3
Decision theory	2.9	3	7	8	23.6	20	6	5
Minds and machines	2.5	3	6	8	25.2	29	7	8
Truth	8.2	7	21	18	56.4	27	15	7
Radical translation	3.4	3	9	8	32.5	23	9	6
Explanation	3.4	4	9	10	30.3	31	8	8
Personal identity	3.0	3	8	8	29.2	25	8	7
Speech acts	5.3	5	13	13	34.5	30	9	8
Sense and reference	4.8	5	12	13	44.7	36	12	10
Egalitarianism	1.0	1	3	3	9.1	7	2	2
Quantum physics	2.7	4	7	10	19.3	28	5	7
Theories and realism	4.4	3	11	8	40.0	32	11	8
Functions	2.8	3	7	8	27.7	26	7	7
Feminism	1.0	1	2	3	8.0	8	2	2
Medical ethics and Freud	1.5	1	4	3	13.8	10	4	3
Abortion and self-defence	1.1	0	3	0	8.8	0	2	0
Belief ascriptions	2.1	1	5	3	13.8	5	4	1
Thermodynamics	1.7	0	4	0	17.9	0	5	0
Knowledge	4.4	3	11	8	29.4	17	8	5
Game theory	1.1	1	3	3	9.9	9	3	2
Justification	3.8	4	10	10	32.8	27	9	7
Frankfurt cases	3.5	4	9	10	24.3	18	6	5
Concepts	3.1	0	8	0	41.1	0	11	0
Races and DNA	0.5	0	1	0	3.5	0	1	0
Modality	1.7	1	4	3	13.9	5	4	1
Reasons	4.0	3	10	8	40.0	35	11	9
Evolutionary biology	2.0	3	5	8	27.7	40	7	11
Population ethics	1.0	1	2	3	6.9	5	2	1
Formal epistemology	3.3	5	8	13	20.6	24	5	6
Wide content	0.6	0	2	0	8.2	0	2	0
Vagueness	1.1	0	3	0	11.9	0	3	0
Cognitive science	0.3	0	1	0	3.2	0	1	0
Models	1.8	2	5	5	21.2	37	6	10
Composition and constitution	2.0	1	5	3	18.9	4	5	1
Norms	2.2	0	6	0	19.2	0	5	0

1966

Table B.91: Measures of the prominence of each subject in 1966 ’s journals.

Subject	Weight	Raw	W-Ratio	R-Ratio	W-Pages	R-Pages	WP-Ratio	RP-Ratio
Psychology	2.3	3	6	8	17.8	15	5	4
Idealism	4.3	2	11	5	63.2	40	16	10
Life and value	5.0	2	13	5	58.1	6	15	2
Other history	5.7	5	15	13	70.0	77	18	20
Dewey and pragmatism	3.5	1	9	3	35.0	6	9	2
Definitions	7.3	3	19	8	68.2	23	18	6
Propositions and implications	7.9	7	21	18	64.4	59	17	15
Beauty	2.5	5	7	13	23.8	35	6	9
Physicalism	5.0	7	13	18	48.1	61	12	16
History and culture	4.9	7	13	18	39.6	54	10	14
Faith and theism	1.9	1	5	3	22.8	5	6	1
Self-consciousness	2.2	0	6	0	22.2	0	6	0
Ancient	2.7	4	7	11	38.6	70	10	18
Universals and particulars	5.7	10	15	26	52.8	93	14	24
Verification	13.9	13	37	34	133.6	108	35	28
Value	4.7	5	12	13	41.6	35	11	9
Deduction	8.4	7	22	18	86.5	84	22	22
Mechanisms	4.0	4	11	11	48.6	83	13	21
Temporal paradoxes	3.0	1	8	3	36.9	13	10	3
Classical space and time	2.0	1	5	3	24.7	14	6	4
Early modern	3.6	5	9	13	30.4	53	8	14
Meaning and use	10.2	8	27	21	105.9	100	27	26
Marx	5.6	10	15	26	64.9	123	17	32
Ordinary language	27.2	31	72	82	378.2	394	98	102
Moral conscience	7.5	7	20	18	70.7	58	18	15
Methodology of science	5.0	4	13	11	55.0	30	14	8
Heidegger and Husserl	2.3	2	6	5	30.5	28	8	7
Emotions	5.1	7	13	18	50.0	79	13	20
Ontological argument	4.9	5	13	13	45.3	40	12	10
Chemistry	3.4	6	9	16	43.8	87	11	22
Social contract theory	1.7	2	5	5	20.8	28	5	7
Kant	1.8	1	5	3	16.3	11	4	3
Promises and imperatives	12.0	19	32	50	97.3	147	25	38
Analytic/synthetic	3.9	3	10	8	32.4	20	8	5
Freedom and free will	3.8	5	10	13	41.8	51	11	13
Crime and punishment	6.8	12	18	32	74.5	149	19	39
Sets and grue	12.6	14	33	37	116.0	132	30	34
Origins and purposes	1.5	0	4	0	15.1	0	4	0
Time	6.1	10	16	26	59.4	123	15	32
Color/colour	4.3	3	11	8	35.8	27	9	7
War	5.6	5	15	13	44.2	49	11	13
Depiction	2.7	3	7	8	46.2	67	12	17
Denoting	4.6	6	12	16	32.5	35	8	9
Chance	4.5	8	12	21	49.1	94	13	24
Hume	1.7	2	5	5	16.2	16	4	4
Laws	4.3	2	11	5	38.8	17	10	4
Perception	5.9	3	15	8	64.7	29	17	7
Intention	5.5	8	14	21	45.7	47	12	12
Virtues	3.0	4	8	11	18.7	20	5	5
Space and time	4.7	5	12	13	34.8	42	9	11
Mathematics	2.9	6	8	16	43.0	90	11	23
Liberal democracy	2.0	3	5	8	21.9	21	6	5
Duties	3.2	3	8	8	18.6	10	5	3
Causation	6.3	7	17	18	59.1	56	15	14
Arguments	10.6	2	28	5	99.0	7	26	2
Theory testing	5.8	11	15	29	70.5	134	18	35
Decision theory	3.2	1	8	3	26.3	5	7	1
Minds and machines	3.4	3	9	8	29.5	23	8	6
Truth	6.7	6	18	16	49.8	41	13	11
Radical translation	2.5	0	7	0	22.9	0	6	0
Explanation	3.8	6	10	16	47.0	72	12	19
Personal identity	1.4	1	4	3	18.1	19	5	5
Speech acts	3.7	1	10	3	28.9	3	7	1
Sense and reference	3.7	6	10	16	36.6	55	9	14
Egalitarianism	2.3	3	6	8	18.9	33	5	9
Quantum physics	2.5	3	6	8	26.1	32	7	8
Theories and realism	6.4	3	17	8	63.5	47	16	12
Functions	2.3	2	6	5	17.6	15	5	4
Feminism	1.1	0	3	0	12.2	0	3	0
Medical ethics and Freud	0.9	0	2	0	12.4	0	3	0
Abortion and self-defence	1.6	2	4	5	20.3	33	5	9
Belief ascriptions	1.7	0	4	0	12.2	0	3	0
Thermodynamics	1.7	1	4	3	18.3	13	5	3
Knowledge	3.0	3	8	8	29.0	21	7	5
Game theory	1.7	2	4	5	22.7	32	6	8
Justification	2.3	2	6	5	22.3	12	6	3
Frankfurt cases	2.6	4	7	11	22.6	23	6	6
Concepts	5.1	1	13	3	52.3	22	14	6
Races and DNA	1.1	1	3	3	11.8	10	3	3
Modality	1.3	0	3	0	13.7	0	4	0
Reasons	2.9	0	8	0	32.8	0	8	0
Evolutionary biology	1.5	2	4	5	9.3	9	2	2
Population ethics	0.5	0	1	0	7.2	0	2	0
Formal epistemology	1.2	2	3	5	10.9	11	3	3
Wide content	0.4	0	1	0	5.1	0	1	0
Vagueness	0.7	0	2	0	7.5	0	2	0
Cognitive science	0.6	0	2	0	8.7	0	2	0
Models	1.6	1	4	3	17.4	18	4	5
Composition and constitution	2.4	2	6	5	18.2	11	5	3
Norms	3.1	2	8	5	32.5	13	8	3

1967

Table B.92: Measures of the prominence of each subject in 1967 ’s journals.

Subject	Weight	Raw	W-Ratio	R-Ratio	W-Pages	R-Pages	WP-Ratio	RP-Ratio
Psychology	1.4	2	3	5	11.4	12	3	3
Idealism	4.6	4	11	10	66.8	60	16	14
Life and value	4.5	4	11	10	50.6	44	12	10
Other history	5.4	3	13	7	43.3	14	10	3
Dewey and pragmatism	4.3	5	11	12	45.7	62	11	15
Definitions	7.3	3	18	7	79.0	29	19	7
Propositions and implications	10.8	15	26	36	90.1	105	21	25
Beauty	3.2	5	8	12	37.0	60	9	14
Physicalism	3.1	4	7	10	36.3	62	9	15
History and culture	4.1	6	10	15	45.9	72	11	17
Faith and theism	3.6	5	9	12	42.9	79	10	19
Self-consciousness	3.1	1	7	2	26.0	8	6	2
Ancient	4.5	5	11	12	43.4	51	10	12
Universals and particulars	8.9	11	22	27	89.0	109	21	26
Verification	12.7	6	31	15	131.6	62	31	15
Value	4.8	7	12	17	48.0	66	11	15
Deduction	7.2	5	17	12	85.2	81	20	19
Mechanisms	2.4	0	6	0	26.9	0	6	0
Temporal paradoxes	3.9	2	9	5	35.7	10	8	2
Classical space and time	3.5	3	9	7	31.0	21	7	5
Early modern	1.5	1	4	2	24.6	32	6	8
Meaning and use	13.9	19	34	46	155.2	210	36	49
Marx	4.6	5	11	12	43.7	40	10	9
Ordinary language	30.0	27	73	65	398.8	399	94	94
Moral conscience	6.4	7	16	17	62.9	64	15	15
Methodology of science	5.0	5	12	12	62.0	59	15	14
Heidegger and Husserl	3.5	5	8	12	31.6	33	7	8
Emotions	4.5	5	11	12	41.8	55	10	13
Ontological argument	5.4	7	13	17	47.0	45	11	11
Chemistry	2.9	4	7	10	34.4	71	8	17
Social contract theory	3.8	4	9	10	37.9	44	9	10
Kant	2.2	3	5	7	26.5	36	6	8
Promises and imperatives	9.6	10	23	24	92.1	126	22	30
Analytic/synthetic	2.9	0	7	0	28.1	0	7	0
Freedom and free will	2.8	5	7	12	33.4	70	8	16
Crime and punishment	6.9	12	17	29	60.7	102	14	24
Sets and grue	12.4	18	30	44	123.8	159	29	37
Origins and purposes	1.7	1	4	2	14.3	3	3	1
Time	4.2	4	10	10	38.4	31	9	7
Color/colour	6.3	6	15	15	47.7	30	11	7
War	2.8	1	7	2	31.6	10	7	2
Depiction	4.1	6	10	15	50.6	74	12	17
Denoting	4.7	5	11	12	43.2	38	10	9
Chance	4.7	8	11	19	46.3	78	11	18
Hume	2.1	2	5	5	25.8	31	6	7
Laws	5.4	5	13	12	51.7	40	12	9
Perception	5.9	6	14	15	64.4	70	15	16
Intention	4.1	6	10	15	33.1	37	8	9
Virtues	2.7	1	7	2	28.7	11	7	3
Space and time	3.8	6	9	15	36.9	58	9	14
Mathematics	3.3	4	8	10	40.2	57	9	13
Liberal democracy	4.1	6	10	15	38.3	64	9	15
Duties	3.7	1	9	2	33.0	3	8	1
Causation	6.1	9	15	22	63.3	104	15	24
Arguments	8.2	1	20	2	93.9	5	22	1
Theory testing	6.4	2	16	5	55.1	31	13	7
Decision theory	4.2	4	10	10	34.8	25	8	6
Minds and machines	2.6	1	6	2	26.5	13	6	3
Truth	7.0	4	17	10	66.3	24	16	6
Radical translation	4.9	6	12	15	39.7	47	9	11
Explanation	5.2	9	13	22	50.2	87	12	20
Personal identity	3.0	1	7	2	36.1	11	8	3
Speech acts	5.4	4	13	10	44.0	21	10	5
Sense and reference	5.2	4	13	10	70.1	70	16	16
Egalitarianism	2.2	3	5	7	20.9	27	5	6
Quantum physics	1.6	0	4	0	20.3	0	5	0
Theories and realism	6.6	6	16	15	60.4	45	14	11
Functions	1.1	0	3	0	13.3	0	3	0
Feminism	1.1	0	3	0	10.1	0	2	0
Medical ethics and Freud	2.5	3	6	7	13.1	10	3	2
Abortion and self-defence	2.4	3	6	7	17.3	22	4	5
Belief ascriptions	3.3	4	8	10	25.0	24	6	6
Thermodynamics	1.9	0	5	0	17.2	0	4	0
Knowledge	5.1	5	12	12	60.1	61	14	14
Game theory	2.2	4	5	10	17.8	32	4	8
Justification	4.9	6	12	15	55.3	65	13	15
Frankfurt cases	4.1	3	10	7	37.9	19	9	4
Concepts	3.9	0	9	0	54.6	0	13	0
Races and DNA	2.4	2	6	5	9.1	3	2	1
Modality	3.1	5	8	12	40.7	91	10	21
Reasons	3.6	5	9	12	26.9	31	6	7
Evolutionary biology	1.5	2	4	5	17.9	26	4	6
Population ethics	1.5	2	4	5	16.3	21	4	5
Formal epistemology	3.1	6	8	15	27.6	40	6	9
Wide content	0.8	0	2	0	10.3	0	2	0
Vagueness	2.0	3	5	7	14.4	29	3	7
Cognitive science	1.0	1	2	2	7.0	5	2	1
Models	1.7	0	4	0	19.0	0	4	0
Composition and constitution	2.8	1	7	2	30.5	16	7	4
Norms	3.2	3	8	7	44.8	70	11	16

1968

Table B.93: Measures of the prominence of each subject in 1968 ’s journals.

Subject	Weight	Raw	W-Ratio	R-Ratio	W-Pages	R-Pages	WP-Ratio	RP-Ratio
Psychology	1.6	1	4	3	20.2	2	5	0
Idealism	3.5	4	9	10	51.8	50	12	12
Life and value	4.4	1	11	3	44.6	7	10	2
Other history	6.5	9	16	23	64.4	86	15	20
Dewey and pragmatism	3.7	1	9	3	52.7	15	12	3
Definitions	7.7	6	19	15	96.6	78	23	18
Propositions and implications	7.6	9	19	23	69.0	34	16	8
Beauty	3.6	6	9	15	50.2	89	12	21
Physicalism	2.5	1	6	3	27.1	2	6	0
History and culture	1.7	0	4	0	15.6	0	4	0
Faith and theism	2.7	3	7	8	24.5	22	6	5
Self-consciousness	2.9	1	7	3	28.9	13	7	3
Ancient	4.4	6	11	15	42.4	44	10	10
Universals and particulars	8.0	8	20	20	85.9	66	20	15
Verification	12.4	9	31	23	138.8	97	32	23
Value	5.3	6	13	15	48.8	55	11	13
Deduction	8.5	6	21	15	77.5	58	18	14
Mechanisms	1.8	0	5	0	23.6	0	6	0
Temporal paradoxes	6.1	6	15	15	59.5	67	14	16
Classical space and time	2.7	4	7	10	25.2	35	6	8
Early modern	1.5	3	4	8	22.4	55	5	13
Meaning and use	13.3	14	33	35	145.9	132	34	31
Marx	3.4	6	9	15	32.1	56	7	13
Ordinary language	29.0	27	73	68	416.8	453	97	106
Moral conscience	8.8	11	22	28	84.4	136	20	32
Methodology of science	3.8	3	10	8	45.4	40	11	9
Heidegger and Husserl	4.2	6	11	15	56.3	79	13	18
Emotions	4.4	5	11	13	49.5	46	12	11
Ontological argument	3.4	1	9	3	40.5	12	9	3
Chemistry	2.4	2	6	5	24.6	25	6	6
Social contract theory	2.8	4	7	10	23.6	28	6	7
Kant	2.1	4	5	10	23.5	54	5	13
Promises and imperatives	10.2	11	26	28	99.0	75	23	17
Analytic/synthetic	1.7	1	4	3	21.0	22	5	5
Freedom and free will	3.5	5	9	13	28.6	38	7	9
Crime and punishment	8.5	17	21	43	91.9	179	21	42
Sets and grue	13.8	16	35	40	127.2	138	30	32
Origins and purposes	2.1	1	5	3	21.2	13	5	3
Time	4.1	7	10	18	40.6	70	9	16
Color/colour	4.0	3	10	8	48.4	52	11	12
War	5.6	9	14	23	47.7	68	11	16
Depiction	4.4	4	11	10	50.0	47	12	11
Denoting	4.0	5	10	13	56.2	80	13	19
Chance	5.2	8	13	20	54.2	107	13	25
Hume	0.8	0	2	0	8.7	0	2	0
Laws	3.6	4	9	10	37.1	19	9	4
Perception	3.5	2	9	5	45.5	30	11	7
Intention	5.0	8	13	20	53.2	79	12	18
Virtues	4.7	8	12	20	44.8	79	10	18
Space and time	3.5	5	9	13	29.9	62	7	14
Mathematics	3.8	4	9	10	39.4	34	9	8
Liberal democracy	2.2	2	5	5	27.4	36	6	8
Duties	4.0	3	10	8	27.8	14	6	3
Causation	3.6	1	9	3	30.2	3	7	1
Arguments	8.5	0	21	0	91.9	0	21	0
Theory testing	6.5	9	16	23	61.0	91	14	21
Decision theory	3.7	4	9	10	29.6	32	7	7
Minds and machines	4.1	3	10	8	33.5	30	8	7
Truth	8.4	7	21	18	70.2	51	16	12
Radical translation	3.8	4	10	10	53.5	79	12	18
Explanation	2.9	4	7	10	33.1	36	8	8
Personal identity	3.0	1	8	3	28.4	6	7	1
Speech acts	5.2	4	13	10	62.7	66	15	15
Sense and reference	7.4	11	19	28	109.2	197	25	46
Egalitarianism	2.4	4	6	10	26.0	39	6	9
Quantum physics	4.6	7	12	18	84.0	138	20	32
Theories and realism	4.5	3	11	8	49.0	25	11	6
Functions	1.4	0	4	0	14.2	0	3	0
Feminism	3.3	3	8	8	32.6	37	8	9
Medical ethics and Freud	1.0	0	3	0	10.0	0	2	0
Abortion and self-defence	1.5	1	4	3	11.3	7	3	2
Belief ascriptions	2.8	1	7	3	29.7	7	7	2
Thermodynamics	2.4	1	6	3	23.4	4	5	1
Knowledge	5.2	7	13	18	46.1	52	11	12
Game theory	3.1	2	8	5	16.1	6	4	1
Justification	3.7	2	9	5	35.9	12	8	3
Frankfurt cases	4.2	3	11	8	27.7	9	6	2
Concepts	4.0	1	10	3	47.2	7	11	2
Races and DNA	1.8	1	5	3	8.4	2	2	0
Modality	3.2	3	8	8	30.4	31	7	7
Reasons	2.9	3	7	8	33.9	42	8	10
Evolutionary biology	0.3	0	1	0	2.5	0	1	0
Population ethics	2.4	3	6	8	14.7	10	3	2
Formal epistemology	2.3	4	6	10	17.0	24	4	6
Wide content	0.9	0	2	0	11.2	0	3	0
Vagueness	0.8	0	2	0	8.6	0	2	0
Cognitive science	0.7	0	2	0	6.8	0	2	0
Models	1.3	0	3	0	12.8	0	3	0
Composition and constitution	2.4	2	6	5	31.7	14	7	3
Norms	2.8	3	7	8	39.5	51	9	12

1969

Table B.94: Measures of the prominence of each subject in 1969 ’s journals.

Subject	Weight	Raw	W-Ratio	R-Ratio	W-Pages	R-Pages	WP-Ratio	RP-Ratio
Psychology	2.6	1	6	2	19.3	5	4	1
Idealism	4.6	4	11	9	65.4	59	15	13
Life and value	5.9	3	14	7	67.6	41	15	9
Other history	5.2	5	12	12	54.7	54	12	12
Dewey and pragmatism	3.2	2	8	5	31.8	14	7	3
Definitions	7.5	1	18	2	83.2	9	19	2
Propositions and implications	12.3	20	29	47	119.4	239	27	53
Beauty	4.1	7	9	16	49.0	92	11	20
Physicalism	3.4	2	8	5	33.1	21	7	5
History and culture	4.7	5	11	12	55.5	66	12	15
Faith and theism	3.8	4	9	9	37.5	33	8	7
Self-consciousness	2.9	0	7	0	25.5	0	6	0
Ancient	6.4	10	15	23	82.7	159	18	35
Universals and particulars	8.5	11	20	26	72.3	79	16	18
Verification	11.6	7	27	16	108.2	69	24	15
Value	3.4	3	8	7	26.3	16	6	4
Deduction	7.3	7	17	16	97.7	110	22	24
Mechanisms	3.0	0	7	0	39.1	0	9	0
Temporal paradoxes	6.6	7	16	16	68.6	73	15	16
Classical space and time	4.4	3	10	7	54.1	34	12	8
Early modern	1.5	0	3	0	14.7	0	3	0
Meaning and use	12.7	17	30	40	120.3	145	27	32
Marx	3.6	4	8	9	43.2	47	10	10
Ordinary language	24.8	20	58	47	356.0	307	79	68
Moral conscience	7.3	9	17	21	69.2	86	15	19
Methodology of science	4.6	4	11	9	56.8	34	13	8
Heidegger and Husserl	4.4	4	10	9	51.8	52	12	12
Emotions	6.5	11	15	26	60.4	115	13	26
Ontological argument	4.2	4	10	9	48.8	75	11	17
Chemistry	3.0	3	7	7	45.4	56	10	12
Social contract theory	3.4	4	8	9	34.8	38	8	8
Kant	1.6	1	4	2	19.2	17	4	4
Promises and imperatives	10.1	9	24	21	80.0	47	18	10
Analytic/synthetic	2.1	0	5	0	20.7	0	5	0
Freedom and free will	2.8	4	7	9	27.8	28	6	6
Crime and punishment	5.7	13	13	30	80.1	187	18	42
Sets and grue	12.4	13	29	30	147.0	169	33	38
Origins and purposes	2.7	3	6	7	19.4	11	4	2
Time	4.2	5	10	12	47.4	75	11	17
Color/colour	4.3	4	10	9	33.3	24	7	5
War	4.3	4	10	9	55.0	67	12	15
Depiction	3.9	4	9	9	37.0	38	8	8
Denoting	6.4	10	15	23	52.7	67	12	15
Chance	3.2	5	8	12	41.0	65	9	14
Hume	0.8	0	2	0	9.0	0	2	0
Laws	3.7	2	9	5	43.2	26	10	6
Perception	6.6	5	15	12	55.5	45	12	10
Intention	3.5	3	8	7	31.1	11	7	2
Virtues	3.1	4	7	9	21.6	18	5	4
Space and time	7.2	9	17	21	97.1	125	22	28
Mathematics	6.3	8	15	19	64.3	75	14	17
Liberal democracy	2.2	1	5	2	26.4	17	6	4
Duties	6.1	8	14	19	51.0	63	11	14
Causation	3.2	3	7	7	39.0	32	9	7
Arguments	9.9	3	23	7	109.2	9	24	2
Theory testing	8.1	11	19	26	63.9	67	14	15
Decision theory	2.9	3	7	7	29.7	22	7	5
Minds and machines	3.4	4	8	9	34.0	62	8	14
Truth	9.6	8	23	19	88.1	67	20	15
Radical translation	4.8	6	11	14	44.4	57	10	13
Explanation	3.6	7	8	16	50.4	104	11	23
Personal identity	5.0	5	12	12	30.3	26	7	6
Speech acts	6.3	9	15	21	59.6	73	13	16
Sense and reference	5.0	3	12	7	42.3	26	9	6
Egalitarianism	3.4	3	8	7	29.4	14	7	3
Quantum physics	2.1	2	5	5	28.9	32	6	7
Theories and realism	4.9	4	11	9	61.1	60	14	13
Functions	1.5	0	3	0	16.8	0	4	0
Feminism	2.3	2	5	5	22.9	25	5	6
Medical ethics and Freud	1.5	3	3	7	17.9	42	4	9
Abortion and self-defence	2.3	1	5	2	15.6	6	3	1
Belief ascriptions	3.9	4	9	9	23.3	20	5	4
Thermodynamics	3.8	2	9	5	41.8	11	9	2
Knowledge	6.0	5	14	12	57.4	42	13	9
Game theory	2.3	3	5	7	18.1	26	4	6
Justification	5.5	8	13	19	56.5	77	13	17
Frankfurt cases	4.5	4	11	9	28.0	22	6	5
Concepts	5.8	2	13	5	72.0	37	16	8
Races and DNA	1.5	1	4	2	17.4	24	4	5
Modality	3.6	3	9	7	39.5	25	9	6
Reasons	3.2	4	7	9	31.8	29	7	6
Evolutionary biology	2.1	3	5	7	20.3	32	5	7
Population ethics	0.7	0	2	0	7.5	0	2	0
Formal epistemology	1.5	2	4	5	10.7	14	2	3
Wide content	1.6	2	4	5	13.0	5	3	1
Vagueness	2.0	2	5	5	19.9	16	4	4
Cognitive science	1.6	3	4	7	15.0	39	3	9
Models	1.8	1	4	2	20.2	10	4	2
Composition and constitution	3.5	3	8	7	35.2	26	8	6
Norms	2.4	1	6	2	33.3	15	7	3

1970

Table B.95: Measures of the prominence of each subject in 1970 ’s journals.

Subject	Weight	Raw	W-Ratio	R-Ratio	W-Pages	R-Pages	WP-Ratio	RP-Ratio
Psychology	3.0	4	7	9	44.8	73	9	15
Idealism	4.1	2	9	5	46.7	10	10	2
Life and value	4.1	2	9	5	45.6	15	9	3
Other history	4.7	6	11	14	54.9	115	11	24
Dewey and pragmatism	3.6	0	8	0	34.3	0	7	0
Definitions	7.7	1	18	2	88.2	22	18	5
Propositions and implications	9.1	8	21	18	93.9	71	19	15
Beauty	4.2	7	10	16	49.7	94	10	19
Physicalism	6.6	7	15	16	71.6	93	15	19
History and culture	3.3	6	8	14	30.2	50	6	10
Faith and theism	2.7	2	6	5	25.1	19	5	4
Self-consciousness	2.2	1	5	2	28.8	14	6	3
Ancient	4.0	5	9	12	49.6	81	10	17
Universals and particulars	10.1	13	23	30	133.5	177	28	37
Verification	12.9	13	30	30	137.7	133	28	27
Value	4.7	6	11	14	34.0	44	7	9
Deduction	7.1	6	16	14	76.7	64	16	13
Mechanisms	3.8	4	9	9	44.5	49	9	10
Temporal paradoxes	7.7	9	18	21	64.3	50	13	10
Classical space and time	4.8	3	11	7	98.3	131	20	27
Early modern	4.4	6	10	14	59.4	80	12	17
Meaning and use	9.5	9	22	21	118.3	85	24	18
Marx	5.4	8	12	18	65.2	115	13	24
Ordinary language	28.7	23	66	53	407.9	401	84	83
Moral conscience	7.1	10	16	23	58.8	79	12	16
Methodology of science	5.3	5	12	12	46.2	30	10	6
Heidegger and Husserl	4.1	6	9	14	50.8	82	10	17
Emotions	6.2	9	14	21	74.3	93	15	19
Ontological argument	3.9	2	9	5	39.6	7	8	1
Chemistry	2.9	2	7	5	35.4	26	7	5
Social contract theory	2.9	4	7	9	31.6	50	7	10
Kant	1.7	3	4	7	18.4	31	4	6
Promises and imperatives	7.2	8	17	18	82.3	91	17	19
Analytic/synthetic	2.5	2	6	5	25.7	7	5	1
Freedom and free will	2.2	2	5	5	31.8	27	7	6
Crime and punishment	7.4	12	17	28	64.6	111	13	23
Sets and grue	12.5	16	29	37	138.4	143	29	29
Origins and purposes	2.3	0	5	0	24.8	0	5	0
Time	3.9	3	9	7	30.3	36	6	7
Color/colour	3.9	3	9	7	34.2	22	7	5
War	3.7	2	8	5	34.3	21	7	4
Depiction	5.1	5	12	12	53.2	42	11	9
Denoting	7.2	10	17	23	77.4	100	16	21
Chance	5.0	8	12	18	43.8	84	9	17
Hume	1.5	2	4	5	16.9	21	3	4
Laws	4.8	3	11	7	51.1	25	11	5
Perception	7.2	8	17	18	81.1	89	17	18
Intention	6.4	9	15	21	67.2	81	14	17
Virtues	2.9	3	7	7	25.9	12	5	2
Space and time	6.6	10	15	23	104.7	149	22	31
Mathematics	4.6	6	11	14	50.2	56	10	12
Liberal democracy	3.0	2	7	5	39.3	34	8	7
Duties	3.7	5	8	12	32.1	28	7	6
Causation	3.8	2	9	5	41.7	7	9	1
Arguments	10.4	0	24	0	109.3	0	23	0
Theory testing	5.0	6	12	14	45.5	40	9	8
Decision theory	2.2	1	5	2	19.4	18	4	4
Minds and machines	4.9	5	11	12	57.1	32	12	7
Truth	9.2	8	21	18	82.0	72	17	15
Radical translation	7.9	10	18	23	99.9	123	21	25
Explanation	5.1	6	12	14	54.0	83	11	17
Personal identity	6.7	8	15	18	79.7	95	16	20
Speech acts	6.1	10	14	23	77.6	146	16	30
Sense and reference	7.8	10	18	23	86.2	112	18	23
Egalitarianism	2.4	2	6	5	19.5	22	4	5
Quantum physics	2.8	4	6	9	37.2	56	8	12
Theories and realism	5.2	3	12	7	58.9	34	12	7
Functions	1.8	1	4	2	17.4	3	4	1
Feminism	2.0	2	5	5	15.8	10	3	2
Medical ethics and Freud	1.0	1	2	2	6.7	6	1	1
Abortion and self-defence	2.1	1	5	2	17.6	8	4	2
Belief ascriptions	3.1	3	7	7	37.9	40	8	8
Thermodynamics	1.9	1	4	2	22.0	14	5	3
Knowledge	6.6	9	15	21	59.6	83	12	17
Game theory	0.8	0	2	0	6.6	0	1	0
Justification	5.0	6	12	14	50.7	43	10	9
Frankfurt cases	2.5	2	6	5	21.9	17	5	4
Concepts	5.3	0	12	0	61.6	0	13	0
Races and DNA	1.2	2	3	5	8.2	7	2	1
Modality	3.3	3	8	7	34.5	33	7	7
Reasons	3.0	2	7	5	37.4	26	8	5
Evolutionary biology	3.4	5	8	12	22.0	34	5	7
Population ethics	0.8	0	2	0	7.0	0	1	0
Formal epistemology	1.7	1	4	2	20.0	17	4	4
Wide content	1.2	0	3	0	15.5	0	3	0
Vagueness	0.9	1	2	2	11.0	11	2	2
Cognitive science	1.7	1	4	2	21.0	5	4	1
Models	2.0	1	5	2	24.8	12	5	2
Composition and constitution	4.6	5	11	12	53.8	57	11	12
Norms	2.5	1	6	2	39.3	19	8	4

1971

Table B.96: Measures of the prominence of each subject in 1971 ’s journals.

Subject	Weight	Raw	W-Ratio	R-Ratio	W-Pages	R-Pages	WP-Ratio	RP-Ratio
Psychology	3.4	5	7	11	32.5	44	7	9
Idealism	3.9	2	8	4	48.3	11	10	2
Life and value	5.9	3	13	7	76.5	37	16	8
Other history	2.6	1	6	2	32.9	12	7	3
Dewey and pragmatism	3.0	2	7	4	29.1	18	6	4
Definitions	9.3	5	20	11	94.5	49	20	10
Propositions and implications	10.4	12	23	26	94.3	110	20	23
Beauty	2.2	2	5	4	27.4	25	6	5
Physicalism	5.6	6	12	13	50.8	56	11	12
History and culture	2.2	2	5	4	25.9	18	5	4
Faith and theism	1.7	2	4	4	13.1	9	3	2
Self-consciousness	2.3	1	5	2	27.4	19	6	4
Ancient	3.9	6	9	13	40.5	65	9	14
Universals and particulars	11.7	14	25	31	99.5	112	21	24
Verification	11.7	7	25	15	106.5	64	22	13
Value	4.1	3	9	7	40.0	34	8	7
Deduction	9.3	12	20	26	75.5	86	16	18
Mechanisms	3.5	3	8	7	40.2	23	8	5
Temporal paradoxes	6.1	5	13	11	50.7	31	11	7
Classical space and time	3.6	2	8	4	33.8	2	7	0
Early modern	4.9	6	11	13	57.0	84	12	18
Meaning and use	11.0	9	24	20	105.5	98	22	21
Marx	4.6	7	10	15	57.9	95	12	20
Ordinary language	28.9	23	63	50	426.7	402	90	85
Moral conscience	8.0	10	17	22	70.7	97	15	20
Methodology of science	4.6	4	10	9	55.4	61	12	13
Heidegger and Husserl	3.2	3	7	7	41.5	37	9	8
Emotions	3.8	3	8	7	30.6	19	6	4
Ontological argument	5.7	7	12	15	59.8	85	13	18
Chemistry	3.2	1	7	2	31.0	12	7	3
Social contract theory	2.0	1	4	2	23.6	12	5	3
Kant	2.7	4	6	9	23.2	30	5	6
Promises and imperatives	12.0	13	26	28	112.6	100	24	21
Analytic/synthetic	3.6	4	8	9	33.1	28	7	6
Freedom and free will	4.6	7	10	15	41.4	61	9	13
Crime and punishment	7.5	10	16	22	79.5	106	17	22
Sets and grue	11.5	11	25	24	127.8	107	27	23
Origins and purposes	2.3	0	5	0	23.0	0	5	0
Time	4.4	5	10	11	40.2	47	8	10
Color/colour	3.4	2	7	4	28.8	12	6	3
War	6.1	7	13	15	71.8	95	15	20
Depiction	5.0	6	11	13	43.0	51	9	11
Denoting	6.3	7	14	15	59.4	55	13	12
Chance	5.1	9	11	20	65.0	106	14	22
Hume	1.8	2	4	4	16.7	17	4	4
Laws	5.6	7	12	15	64.0	74	13	16
Perception	5.8	6	13	13	58.0	58	12	12
Intention	8.6	12	19	26	87.5	104	18	22
Virtues	3.1	5	7	11	20.8	22	4	5
Space and time	2.7	4	6	9	26.4	49	6	10
Mathematics	6.1	9	13	20	62.0	99	13	21
Liberal democracy	3.9	4	9	9	54.5	60	11	13
Duties	4.4	5	10	11	42.5	39	9	8
Causation	3.3	1	7	2	42.0	16	9	3
Arguments	14.8	10	32	22	127.8	56	27	12
Theory testing	5.9	6	13	13	59.1	66	12	14
Decision theory	4.2	5	9	11	45.6	53	10	11
Minds and machines	5.2	5	11	11	50.0	37	11	8
Truth	9.0	6	20	13	69.2	44	15	9
Radical translation	7.5	7	16	15	86.1	100	18	21
Explanation	4.8	4	11	9	53.3	58	11	12
Personal identity	7.0	10	15	22	73.0	99	15	21
Speech acts	7.6	12	17	26	72.1	164	15	35
Sense and reference	6.3	10	14	22	67.7	133	14	28
Egalitarianism	3.3	5	7	11	35.7	59	8	12
Quantum physics	4.8	6	10	13	47.0	63	10	13
Theories and realism	7.3	10	16	22	78.2	106	16	22
Functions	2.8	1	6	2	25.1	7	5	1
Feminism	1.7	1	4	2	19.9	19	4	4
Medical ethics and Freud	1.4	1	3	2	10.1	2	2	0
Abortion and self-defence	4.8	7	10	15	55.9	96	12	20
Belief ascriptions	3.6	4	8	9	30.5	29	6	6
Thermodynamics	2.1	0	5	0	24.5	0	5	0
Knowledge	7.8	13	17	28	67.8	94	14	20
Game theory	2.4	2	5	4	19.1	19	4	4
Justification	4.8	3	11	7	49.3	46	10	10
Frankfurt cases	3.7	3	8	7	31.2	23	7	5
Concepts	4.2	0	9	0	53.1	0	11	0
Races and DNA	0.9	0	2	0	6.3	0	1	0
Modality	3.2	3	7	7	34.6	42	7	9
Reasons	3.6	4	8	9	37.3	37	8	8
Evolutionary biology	3.4	4	8	9	28.3	35	6	7
Population ethics	1.3	1	3	2	17.4	18	4	4
Formal epistemology	1.9	1	4	2	16.7	3	4	1
Wide content	1.2	1	3	2	10.5	7	2	1
Vagueness	1.2	0	3	0	9.1	0	2	0
Cognitive science	1.3	2	3	4	12.2	23	3	5
Models	2.4	1	5	2	37.2	35	8	7
Composition and constitution	3.3	2	7	4	34.6	9	7	2
Norms	2.0	0	4	0	26.8	0	6	0

1972

Table B.97: Measures of the prominence of each subject in 1972 ’s journals.

Subject	Weight	Raw	W-Ratio	R-Ratio	W-Pages	R-Pages	WP-Ratio	RP-Ratio
Psychology	2.3	1	5	2	23.3	7	5	1
Idealism	3.3	1	7	2	46.9	12	10	2
Life and value	5.7	2	13	4	72.9	22	15	5
Other history	3.8	4	9	9	52.8	34	11	7
Dewey and pragmatism	2.6	0	6	0	35.4	0	7	0
Definitions	5.5	2	12	4	66.9	19	14	4
Propositions and implications	9.3	12	21	27	80.7	80	17	17
Beauty	4.9	7	11	16	64.5	112	13	23
Physicalism	3.9	2	9	4	37.0	19	8	4
History and culture	3.1	6	7	13	36.5	79	8	16
Faith and theism	2.3	4	5	9	27.4	63	6	13
Self-consciousness	2.0	0	4	0	21.1	0	4	0
Ancient	5.1	6	11	13	69.3	100	14	21
Universals and particulars	9.9	11	22	24	109.8	131	23	27
Verification	10.9	11	24	24	108.4	111	22	23
Value	4.6	3	10	7	34.6	9	7	2
Deduction	6.0	4	13	9	62.7	39	13	8
Mechanisms	3.8	3	8	7	56.0	37	12	8
Temporal paradoxes	3.7	3	8	7	39.1	40	8	8
Classical space and time	2.6	2	6	4	30.9	20	6	4
Early modern	2.1	2	5	4	27.1	27	6	6
Meaning and use	7.8	7	17	16	84.7	73	18	15
Marx	6.0	8	13	18	106.9	157	22	32
Ordinary language	26.2	27	58	60	396.2	441	82	91
Moral conscience	11.6	18	26	40	98.1	153	20	32
Methodology of science	5.8	6	13	13	79.7	80	17	17
Heidegger and Husserl	5.7	7	13	16	63.3	76	13	16
Emotions	4.0	5	9	11	38.3	57	8	12
Ontological argument	4.0	3	9	7	36.6	14	8	3
Chemistry	2.2	0	5	0	28.1	0	6	0
Social contract theory	4.4	5	10	11	59.0	53	12	11
Kant	2.4	4	5	9	24.5	45	5	9
Promises and imperatives	12.7	16	28	36	119.3	131	25	27
Analytic/synthetic	2.6	0	6	0	23.1	0	5	0
Freedom and free will	3.8	4	9	9	37.3	21	8	4
Crime and punishment	7.9	15	18	33	95.3	197	20	41
Sets and grue	10.2	16	23	36	112.8	200	23	41
Origins and purposes	3.8	3	9	7	26.5	8	5	2
Time	3.0	2	7	4	24.9	17	5	4
Color/colour	4.0	3	9	7	34.4	33	7	7
War	5.0	5	11	11	60.4	78	12	16
Depiction	5.4	6	12	13	41.8	39	9	8
Denoting	6.5	8	15	18	62.5	71	13	15
Chance	5.9	7	13	16	35.4	27	7	6
Hume	2.3	4	5	9	30.1	56	6	12
Laws	3.7	1	8	2	36.9	2	8	0
Perception	6.5	8	14	18	52.8	53	11	11
Intention	5.4	5	12	11	41.7	23	9	5
Virtues	4.6	7	10	16	41.8	54	9	11
Space and time	7.4	12	16	27	67.0	118	14	24
Mathematics	3.7	3	8	7	34.3	38	7	8
Liberal democracy	4.7	4	10	9	71.4	59	15	12
Duties	6.5	7	14	16	69.1	106	14	22
Causation	4.2	5	9	11	39.3	43	8	9
Arguments	13.6	4	30	9	128.3	22	27	5
Theory testing	6.5	9	14	20	49.8	63	10	13
Decision theory	5.5	5	12	11	52.5	39	11	8
Minds and machines	5.7	6	13	13	61.4	75	13	16
Truth	9.3	5	21	11	69.8	45	14	9
Radical translation	8.9	11	20	24	97.5	110	20	23
Explanation	3.4	3	8	7	36.8	31	8	6
Personal identity	4.8	5	11	11	47.6	45	10	9
Speech acts	6.7	7	15	16	69.8	79	14	16
Sense and reference	5.0	5	11	11	62.6	73	13	15
Egalitarianism	4.6	6	10	13	44.4	77	9	16
Quantum physics	3.9	5	9	11	40.2	54	8	11
Theories and realism	6.2	7	14	16	74.8	75	15	16
Functions	2.8	1	6	2	24.5	3	5	1
Feminism	3.1	3	7	7	19.7	12	4	2
Medical ethics and Freud	2.7	3	6	7	31.1	36	6	7
Abortion and self-defence	4.6	5	10	11	70.0	118	14	24
Belief ascriptions	2.7	3	6	7	31.6	38	7	8
Thermodynamics	2.4	1	5	2	24.5	6	5	1
Knowledge	4.7	4	10	9	51.3	57	11	12
Game theory	2.4	3	5	7	13.2	9	3	2
Justification	3.4	3	8	7	32.6	17	7	4
Frankfurt cases	3.1	2	7	4	24.4	18	5	4
Concepts	4.4	2	10	4	54.7	10	11	2
Races and DNA	3.1	2	7	4	29.9	26	6	5
Modality	3.4	2	8	4	35.2	19	7	4
Reasons	4.0	4	9	9	46.7	46	10	10
Evolutionary biology	3.2	4	7	9	26.9	36	6	7
Population ethics	2.5	1	6	2	31.2	15	6	3
Formal epistemology	1.9	3	4	7	19.7	38	4	8
Wide content	1.2	0	3	0	12.0	0	2	0
Vagueness	1.4	1	3	2	9.7	1	2	0
Cognitive science	1.2	1	3	2	13.0	11	3	2
Models	1.8	1	4	2	18.7	4	4	1
Composition and constitution	4.0	3	9	7	44.9	30	9	6
Norms	4.7	3	10	7	54.2	10	11	2

1973

Table B.98: Measures of the prominence of each subject in 1973 ’s journals.

Subject	Weight	Raw	W-Ratio	R-Ratio	W-Pages	R-Pages	WP-Ratio	RP-Ratio
Psychology	1.9	1	4	2	20.2	2	4	0
Idealism	2.0	1	5	2	29.0	17	6	4
Life and value	4.4	0	10	0	59.2	0	12	0
Other history	3.1	2	7	5	34.0	7	7	1
Dewey and pragmatism	2.7	1	6	2	29.2	11	6	2
Definitions	7.2	4	16	9	75.2	35	15	7
Propositions and implications	7.2	9	16	20	72.5	72	15	15
Beauty	4.6	7	10	16	32.8	54	7	11
Physicalism	5.4	6	12	14	61.2	61	13	13
History and culture	3.0	5	7	11	42.5	66	9	14
Faith and theism	2.2	3	5	7	20.5	20	4	4
Self-consciousness	3.0	2	7	5	31.2	11	6	2
Ancient	6.5	11	15	25	67.6	154	14	32
Universals and particulars	8.3	9	19	20	98.9	119	20	25
Verification	10.6	10	24	23	107.1	81	22	17
Value	2.0	1	4	2	22.1	15	5	3
Deduction	6.6	6	15	14	64.8	68	13	14
Mechanisms	3.3	2	8	5	35.0	13	7	3
Temporal paradoxes	5.1	6	12	14	50.8	58	10	12
Classical space and time	4.4	3	10	7	55.1	52	11	11
Early modern	0.8	1	2	2	12.0	19	2	4
Meaning and use	7.8	10	18	23	81.2	120	17	25
Marx	6.5	8	15	18	86.2	101	18	21
Ordinary language	26.3	20	60	45	393.5	317	81	65
Moral conscience	10.4	15	24	34	86.2	97	18	20
Methodology of science	5.8	9	13	20	66.8	84	14	17
Heidegger and Husserl	3.3	4	7	9	46.1	67	10	14
Emotions	2.7	4	6	9	24.0	34	5	7
Ontological argument	5.2	3	12	7	36.1	4	7	1
Chemistry	4.3	3	10	7	48.1	25	10	5
Social contract theory	2.6	2	6	5	25.3	22	5	5
Kant	3.5	6	8	14	44.2	85	9	18
Promises and imperatives	10.9	13	25	30	106.3	110	22	23
Analytic/synthetic	1.9	1	4	2	26.9	7	6	1
Freedom and free will	2.1	2	5	5	24.3	24	5	5
Crime and punishment	6.3	11	14	25	62.8	122	13	25
Sets and grue	9.9	10	22	23	108.8	88	22	18
Origins and purposes	4.0	5	9	11	24.4	15	5	3
Time	4.9	6	11	14	56.7	92	12	19
Color/colour	3.0	1	7	2	30.0	9	6	2
War	6.0	5	14	11	77.1	79	16	16
Depiction	5.3	8	12	18	75.1	112	15	23
Denoting	7.2	8	16	18	57.5	63	12	13
Chance	5.7	6	13	14	57.6	45	12	9
Hume	2.8	4	6	9	25.4	39	5	8
Laws	4.6	3	10	7	44.9	20	9	4
Perception	7.5	15	17	34	84.3	165	17	34
Intention	5.0	7	11	16	54.7	84	11	17
Virtues	5.1	4	12	9	36.2	13	7	3
Space and time	6.5	8	15	18	108.2	153	22	32
Mathematics	3.4	3	8	7	23.1	22	5	5
Liberal democracy	4.8	7	11	16	75.5	124	16	26
Duties	5.2	7	12	16	46.3	57	10	12
Causation	6.9	7	16	16	59.8	54	12	11
Arguments	10.4	0	24	0	112.2	0	23	0
Theory testing	5.8	4	13	9	67.4	47	14	10
Decision theory	4.2	2	10	5	37.1	8	8	2
Minds and machines	4.7	5	11	11	42.1	33	9	7
Truth	7.1	3	16	7	72.6	22	15	5
Radical translation	6.1	10	14	23	69.0	129	14	27
Explanation	5.4	9	12	20	57.7	102	12	21
Personal identity	5.8	5	13	11	55.1	63	11	13
Speech acts	4.2	5	10	11	40.3	47	8	10
Sense and reference	8.1	7	18	16	85.1	53	18	11
Egalitarianism	6.2	7	14	16	132.4	174	27	36
Quantum physics	2.1	3	5	7	36.1	61	7	13
Theories and realism	8.9	8	20	18	107.9	80	22	16
Functions	3.3	3	7	7	44.5	68	9	14
Feminism	4.1	5	9	11	30.2	34	6	7
Medical ethics and Freud	1.4	1	3	2	10.0	3	2	1
Abortion and self-defence	5.3	9	12	20	45.4	81	9	17
Belief ascriptions	2.0	0	5	0	18.5	0	4	0
Thermodynamics	4.0	5	9	11	37.6	60	8	12
Knowledge	5.1	2	12	5	47.9	16	10	3
Game theory	2.3	2	5	5	22.0	19	5	4
Justification	4.1	5	9	11	52.4	71	11	15
Frankfurt cases	3.1	3	7	7	25.4	17	5	4
Concepts	5.1	2	11	5	65.5	24	13	5
Races and DNA	1.0	0	2	0	7.3	0	2	0
Modality	5.3	6	12	14	56.9	89	12	18
Reasons	3.6	1	8	2	44.9	5	9	1
Evolutionary biology	1.8	1	4	2	20.5	20	4	4
Population ethics	0.9	0	2	0	11.2	0	2	0
Formal epistemology	2.6	4	6	9	21.4	45	4	9
Wide content	1.4	1	3	2	14.6	13	3	3
Vagueness	0.7	0	1	0	6.4	0	1	0
Cognitive science	2.1	1	5	2	24.0	17	5	4
Models	1.8	0	4	0	16.1	0	3	0
Composition and constitution	4.4	1	10	2	50.2	15	10	3
Norms	4.0	5	9	11	40.1	49	8	10

1974

Table B.99: Measures of the prominence of each subject in 1974 ’s journals.

Subject	Weight	Raw	W-Ratio	R-Ratio	W-Pages	R-Pages	WP-Ratio	RP-Ratio
Psychology	1.0	0	3	0	16.5	0	3	0
Idealism	3.7	1	9	2	53.6	14	11	3
Life and value	4.7	3	12	7	71.9	40	15	8
Other history	3.7	2	9	5	59.1	40	12	8
Dewey and pragmatism	2.4	0	6	0	32.5	0	7	0
Definitions	4.6	1	12	2	53.5	9	11	2
Propositions and implications	8.2	10	20	25	68.1	73	14	15
Beauty	2.5	5	6	12	27.0	55	6	11
Physicalism	3.1	3	8	7	44.9	59	9	12
History and culture	1.8	1	5	2	27.1	15	6	3
Faith and theism	4.2	5	10	12	29.5	29	6	6
Self-consciousness	2.2	1	6	2	26.6	4	5	1
Ancient	3.2	5	8	12	51.0	80	10	16
Universals and particulars	3.9	3	10	7	44.3	19	9	4
Verification	7.3	6	18	15	80.1	74	16	15
Value	2.8	2	7	5	31.7	13	7	3
Deduction	6.0	6	15	15	49.1	30	10	6
Mechanisms	3.1	5	8	12	36.0	46	7	9
Temporal paradoxes	4.0	2	10	5	51.0	50	10	10
Classical space and time	3.5	4	9	10	52.0	67	11	14
Early modern	3.0	4	8	10	41.4	71	9	15
Meaning and use	8.0	5	20	12	72.6	32	15	7
Marx	5.6	6	14	15	82.4	89	17	18
Ordinary language	23.5	19	58	47	394.2	349	81	72
Moral conscience	9.7	13	24	32	103.2	124	21	26
Methodology of science	5.3	7	13	17	84.7	149	17	31
Heidegger and Husserl	4.2	4	10	10	41.2	38	8	8
Emotions	3.5	5	9	12	40.6	42	8	9
Ontological argument	5.4	6	13	15	55.1	50	11	10
Chemistry	1.7	2	4	5	26.8	33	6	7
Social contract theory	2.6	1	7	2	30.0	15	6	3
Kant	3.0	1	7	2	22.6	2	5	0
Promises and imperatives	7.9	1	19	2	96.0	23	20	5
Analytic/synthetic	2.2	3	6	7	21.9	25	5	5
Freedom and free will	4.1	5	10	12	36.8	55	8	11
Crime and punishment	10.8	18	27	45	135.4	188	28	39
Sets and grue	13.8	20	34	50	157.3	210	32	43
Origins and purposes	1.9	0	5	0	19.8	0	4	0
Time	4.8	5	12	12	44.9	30	9	6
Color/colour	2.8	2	7	5	29.2	16	6	3
War	4.5	5	11	12	52.1	64	11	13
Depiction	3.3	3	8	7	31.4	23	6	5
Denoting	4.7	8	12	20	60.3	115	12	24
Chance	5.2	4	13	10	41.2	27	8	6
Hume	2.3	3	6	7	21.7	21	4	4
Laws	2.7	0	7	0	33.8	0	7	0
Perception	5.4	10	13	25	66.9	125	14	26
Intention	4.0	5	10	12	54.2	76	11	16
Virtues	5.1	7	13	17	65.8	74	14	15
Space and time	4.8	6	12	15	67.3	108	14	22
Mathematics	4.4	5	11	12	36.5	45	8	9
Liberal democracy	1.9	2	5	5	23.8	13	5	3
Duties	3.3	5	8	12	37.3	51	8	10
Causation	6.0	7	15	17	75.6	91	16	19
Arguments	11.8	6	29	15	128.0	40	26	8
Theory testing	6.7	11	17	27	130.7	236	27	49
Decision theory	4.6	4	11	10	59.8	50	12	10
Minds and machines	4.2	5	10	12	45.4	42	9	9
Truth	8.4	3	21	7	75.8	40	16	8
Radical translation	7.2	12	18	30	86.5	166	18	34
Explanation	3.2	4	8	10	41.5	47	9	10
Personal identity	4.5	4	11	10	59.5	55	12	11
Speech acts	4.3	4	11	10	46.7	42	10	9
Sense and reference	3.6	2	9	5	55.0	42	11	9
Egalitarianism	10.6	17	26	42	129.4	225	27	46
Quantum physics	3.1	6	8	15	34.3	61	7	13
Theories and realism	7.1	2	18	5	90.1	13	19	3
Functions	1.6	1	4	2	13.9	3	3	1
Feminism	4.4	6	11	15	61.2	70	13	14
Medical ethics and Freud	1.6	3	4	7	25.7	49	5	10
Abortion and self-defence	3.0	4	7	10	32.7	52	7	11
Belief ascriptions	3.0	2	8	5	28.4	9	6	2
Thermodynamics	2.5	1	6	2	26.0	8	5	2
Knowledge	5.5	6	14	15	55.5	68	11	14
Game theory	2.5	2	6	5	24.4	21	5	4
Justification	4.1	2	10	5	42.4	16	9	3
Frankfurt cases	3.6	5	9	12	35.4	48	7	10
Concepts	3.7	0	9	0	51.9	0	11	0
Races and DNA	2.2	3	6	7	32.6	48	7	10
Modality	3.9	5	10	12	47.7	70	10	14
Reasons	5.1	6	13	15	63.2	57	13	12
Evolutionary biology	1.8	3	4	7	24.8	66	5	14
Population ethics	2.0	2	5	5	25.9	38	5	8
Formal epistemology	3.4	5	8	12	29.6	42	6	9
Wide content	1.3	0	3	0	13.4	0	3	0
Vagueness	1.1	1	3	2	6.9	2	1	0
Cognitive science	1.8	1	4	2	20.9	18	4	4
Models	2.0	2	5	5	24.3	18	5	4
Composition and constitution	3.6	1	9	2	39.9	2	8	0
Norms	2.9	1	7	2	41.8	6	9	1

1975

Table B.100: Measures of the prominence of each subject in 1975 ’s journals.

Subject	Weight	Raw	W-Ratio	R-Ratio	W-Pages	R-Pages	WP-Ratio	RP-Ratio
Psychology	1.9	1	5	3	27.3	19	6	4
Idealism	2.2	0	6	0	32.5	0	7	0
Life and value	5.8	4	15	10	65.6	28	14	6
Other history	2.1	1	5	3	23.2	2	5	0
Dewey and pragmatism	2.6	0	7	0	33.6	0	7	0
Definitions	5.6	2	14	5	73.6	9	16	2
Propositions and implications	7.1	11	18	28	70.9	123	15	26
Beauty	2.8	6	7	15	39.9	96	9	20
Physicalism	5.0	8	13	20	46.1	59	10	13
History and culture	2.4	3	6	8	33.6	35	7	7
Faith and theism	3.0	4	8	10	31.6	40	7	9
Self-consciousness	3.0	1	8	3	31.4	12	7	3
Ancient	3.0	2	8	5	46.8	50	10	11
Universals and particulars	6.4	4	16	10	81.7	37	17	8
Verification	6.8	4	17	10	71.5	21	15	4
Value	4.5	4	11	10	43.3	26	9	6
Deduction	6.3	4	16	10	51.6	8	11	2
Mechanisms	3.2	2	8	5	37.2	12	8	3
Temporal paradoxes	3.9	5	10	13	47.8	70	10	15
Classical space and time	2.0	0	5	0	28.7	0	6	0
Early modern	4.3	6	11	15	57.8	89	12	19
Meaning and use	7.8	8	20	20	84.7	77	18	16
Marx	6.2	5	16	13	95.0	83	20	18
Ordinary language	23.3	15	59	38	364.2	243	78	52
Moral conscience	6.6	7	17	18	74.9	68	16	15
Methodology of science	5.1	4	13	10	68.3	59	15	13
Heidegger and Husserl	4.5	6	11	15	56.6	73	12	16
Emotions	4.9	7	12	18	52.4	72	11	15
Ontological argument	3.7	5	9	13	42.1	61	9	13
Chemistry	2.6	2	7	5	34.8	16	7	3
Social contract theory	1.7	0	4	0	22.5	0	5	0
Kant	2.3	3	6	8	37.3	61	8	13
Promises and imperatives	8.1	7	21	18	89.6	61	19	13
Analytic/synthetic	2.9	1	7	3	36.9	22	8	5
Freedom and free will	3.2	3	8	8	44.5	56	10	12
Crime and punishment	5.9	9	15	23	72.9	121	16	26
Sets and grue	11.8	16	30	41	161.5	230	34	49
Origins and purposes	1.4	0	4	0	13.1	0	3	0
Time	3.1	5	8	13	28.4	35	6	7
Color/colour	4.0	4	10	10	45.2	36	10	8
War	4.1	4	10	10	44.6	37	10	8
Depiction	4.0	6	10	15	46.7	54	10	12
Denoting	5.2	10	13	25	60.8	130	13	28
Chance	4.4	8	11	20	41.1	75	9	16
Hume	3.3	7	8	18	38.9	90	8	19
Laws	3.0	1	8	3	28.8	4	6	1
Perception	3.7	4	9	10	42.9	59	9	13
Intention	3.3	4	8	10	20.7	17	4	4
Virtues	2.8	4	7	10	27.4	43	6	9
Space and time	4.4	7	11	18	32.5	48	7	10
Mathematics	2.5	2	6	5	26.2	17	6	4
Liberal democracy	4.5	6	11	15	51.8	53	11	11
Duties	6.1	5	15	13	77.7	73	17	16
Causation	3.5	3	9	8	41.7	58	9	12
Arguments	10.8	5	27	13	112.4	20	24	4
Theory testing	7.4	8	19	20	78.8	87	17	19
Decision theory	3.1	0	8	0	38.8	0	8	0
Minds and machines	2.7	2	7	5	27.1	25	6	5
Truth	8.0	6	20	15	80.3	54	17	12
Radical translation	9.3	14	24	35	135.1	236	29	50
Explanation	3.0	1	8	3	33.0	5	7	1
Personal identity	3.4	2	9	5	34.9	23	7	5
Speech acts	4.6	4	12	10	44.7	32	10	7
Sense and reference	4.9	5	12	13	71.9	60	15	13
Egalitarianism	9.1	15	23	38	153.1	277	33	59
Quantum physics	1.4	0	3	0	14.2	0	3	0
Theories and realism	8.1	9	20	23	104.2	153	22	33
Functions	2.0	2	5	5	33.6	43	7	9
Feminism	4.7	7	12	18	38.7	55	8	12
Medical ethics and Freud	2.3	4	6	10	27.3	47	6	10
Abortion and self-defence	6.8	11	17	28	69.3	145	15	31
Belief ascriptions	3.6	6	9	15	29.6	32	6	7
Thermodynamics	2.1	2	5	5	26.6	30	6	6
Knowledge	3.8	2	10	5	33.4	20	7	4
Game theory	1.2	1	3	3	14.8	20	3	4
Justification	4.8	4	12	10	49.9	48	11	10
Frankfurt cases	3.2	3	8	8	23.7	9	5	2
Concepts	4.8	0	12	0	66.0	0	14	0
Races and DNA	1.8	2	4	5	14.2	16	3	3
Modality	4.8	6	12	15	59.6	101	13	22
Reasons	5.3	7	13	18	58.8	87	13	19
Evolutionary biology	2.0	3	5	8	26.5	38	6	8
Population ethics	2.1	2	5	5	37.8	47	8	10
Formal epistemology	2.1	1	5	3	16.6	5	4	1
Wide content	0.8	0	2	0	7.6	0	2	0
Vagueness	1.1	0	3	0	12.1	0	3	0
Cognitive science	2.7	5	7	13	21.4	39	5	8
Models	1.7	1	4	3	21.7	16	5	3
Composition and constitution	4.7	4	12	10	48.7	37	10	8
Norms	2.8	1	7	3	37.7	12	8	3

1976

Table B.101: Measures of the prominence of each subject in 1976 ’s journals.

Subject	Weight	Raw	W-Ratio	R-Ratio	W-Pages	R-Pages	WP-Ratio	RP-Ratio
Psychology	1.6	1	4	3	20.2	5	4	1
Idealism	2.6	1	7	3	41.2	14	8	3
Life and value	4.0	0	10	0	55.6	0	11	0
Other history	6.4	6	16	15	74.4	66	15	14
Dewey and pragmatism	3.7	3	9	8	44.1	28	9	6
Definitions	4.7	2	12	5	61.3	32	13	7
Propositions and implications	3.7	2	9	5	39.4	16	8	3
Beauty	2.3	2	6	5	25.6	29	5	6
Physicalism	3.2	2	8	5	40.3	42	8	9
History and culture	2.5	4	6	10	25.4	56	5	11
Faith and theism	1.4	1	4	3	11.2	4	2	1
Self-consciousness	2.5	1	6	3	28.7	1	6	0
Ancient	3.9	6	10	15	61.7	95	13	19
Universals and particulars	5.7	7	14	18	80.2	103	16	21
Verification	6.1	4	15	10	80.9	40	17	8
Value	3.6	3	9	8	47.0	56	10	11
Deduction	5.2	2	13	5	50.6	13	10	3
Mechanisms	3.0	1	8	3	53.1	31	11	6
Temporal paradoxes	4.3	4	11	10	63.7	68	13	14
Classical space and time	2.9	4	7	10	34.7	44	7	9
Early modern	4.1	6	10	15	63.0	105	13	22
Meaning and use	7.4	11	19	28	81.6	124	17	25
Marx	4.8	6	12	15	85.6	93	18	19
Ordinary language	23.2	18	59	46	345.9	240	71	49
Moral conscience	9.2	15	23	38	110.8	198	23	41
Methodology of science	3.8	2	10	5	52.0	24	11	5
Heidegger and Husserl	3.6	4	9	10	46.3	47	9	10
Emotions	4.8	7	12	18	60.9	95	12	19
Ontological argument	4.9	4	12	10	60.2	64	12	13
Chemistry	1.8	0	5	0	22.0	0	5	0
Social contract theory	3.4	4	9	10	50.4	62	10	13
Kant	2.1	3	5	8	23.9	29	5	6
Promises and imperatives	7.0	6	18	15	102.1	126	21	26
Analytic/synthetic	2.0	3	5	8	22.6	31	5	6
Freedom and free will	3.1	6	8	15	33.5	69	7	14
Crime and punishment	6.9	8	18	20	104.1	109	21	22
Sets and grue	13.5	16	34	41	164.8	178	34	36
Origins and purposes	2.7	2	7	5	26.2	6	5	1
Time	3.2	5	8	13	44.8	59	9	12
Color/colour	1.9	1	5	3	26.6	20	5	4
War	2.4	1	6	3	25.6	8	5	2
Depiction	2.6	3	7	8	36.0	44	7	9
Denoting	5.2	6	13	15	46.5	44	10	9
Chance	4.4	4	11	10	48.3	36	10	7
Hume	4.4	8	11	20	51.4	96	11	20
Laws	3.5	2	9	5	36.0	20	7	4
Perception	6.6	7	17	18	75.3	80	15	16
Intention	4.1	5	10	13	37.9	36	8	7
Virtues	3.1	2	8	5	34.3	19	7	4
Space and time	6.9	9	18	23	95.3	136	20	28
Mathematics	4.3	4	11	10	44.4	44	9	9
Liberal democracy	2.7	4	7	10	44.9	42	9	9
Duties	6.1	6	16	15	75.7	82	16	17
Causation	4.3	5	11	13	49.8	54	10	11
Arguments	11.3	1	29	3	132.5	26	27	5
Theory testing	5.6	6	14	15	59.9	84	12	17
Decision theory	4.6	4	12	10	66.1	54	14	11
Minds and machines	3.0	3	8	8	39.7	53	8	11
Truth	9.1	10	23	25	100.9	123	21	25
Radical translation	5.8	6	15	15	72.1	78	15	16
Explanation	4.3	8	11	20	53.0	84	11	17
Personal identity	5.4	7	14	18	69.8	127	14	26
Speech acts	3.1	5	8	13	34.5	59	7	12
Sense and reference	5.1	4	13	10	61.0	48	13	10
Egalitarianism	9.4	16	24	41	113.5	210	23	43
Quantum physics	3.3	5	8	13	23.0	31	5	6
Theories and realism	8.2	7	21	18	94.6	79	19	16
Functions	2.5	2	6	5	25.6	19	5	4
Feminism	5.5	7	14	18	64.2	115	13	24
Medical ethics and Freud	1.4	1	4	3	18.5	12	4	2
Abortion and self-defence	4.3	8	11	20	50.7	109	10	22
Belief ascriptions	1.9	1	5	3	15.5	3	3	1
Thermodynamics	2.4	3	6	8	26.4	29	5	6
Knowledge	5.7	7	14	18	55.7	65	11	13
Game theory	2.0	2	5	5	14.4	7	3	1
Justification	6.4	7	16	18	71.1	70	15	14
Frankfurt cases	3.4	2	9	5	33.9	21	7	4
Concepts	3.9	0	10	0	65.7	0	13	0
Races and DNA	0.8	1	2	3	8.7	6	2	1
Modality	4.5	5	11	13	42.7	48	9	10
Reasons	4.4	6	11	15	54.7	53	11	11
Evolutionary biology	2.6	3	7	8	24.3	23	5	5
Population ethics	4.2	4	11	10	47.2	16	10	3
Formal epistemology	1.3	1	3	3	17.0	19	3	4
Wide content	1.5	1	4	3	19.6	12	4	2
Vagueness	1.1	0	3	0	11.4	0	2	0
Cognitive science	2.3	3	6	8	22.9	31	5	6
Models	1.2	0	3	0	14.3	0	3	0
Composition and constitution	3.8	0	10	0	50.4	0	10	0
Norms	2.2	0	6	0	38.4	0	8	0

1977

Table B.102: Measures of the prominence of each subject in 1977 ’s journals.

Subject	Weight	Raw	W-Ratio	R-Ratio	W-Pages	R-Pages	WP-Ratio	RP-Ratio
Psychology	0.9	0	3	0	12.3	0	3	0
Idealism	3.1	4	8	11	53.9	83	11	17
Life and value	4.6	0	12	0	72.6	0	15	0
Other history	3.9	4	10	11	44.4	24	9	5
Dewey and pragmatism	3.1	1	8	3	44.4	42	9	9
Definitions	4.2	0	11	0	55.9	0	12	0
Propositions and implications	5.7	6	15	16	55.1	45	12	9
Beauty	2.0	3	5	8	16.6	22	3	5
Physicalism	3.0	2	8	5	38.3	6	8	1
History and culture	2.4	1	6	3	29.3	2	6	0
Faith and theism	3.7	7	10	19	40.1	66	8	14
Self-consciousness	3.0	2	8	5	33.0	12	7	3
Ancient	4.4	7	12	19	74.6	135	16	28
Universals and particulars	5.2	4	14	11	60.8	38	13	8
Verification	4.5	0	12	0	62.4	0	13	0
Value	3.0	2	8	5	44.4	28	9	6
Deduction	3.7	2	10	5	47.2	10	10	2
Mechanisms	2.9	0	8	0	38.9	0	8	0
Temporal paradoxes	3.4	1	9	3	37.7	6	8	1
Classical space and time	3.3	4	9	11	43.9	55	9	12
Early modern	2.1	2	6	5	27.6	34	6	7
Meaning and use	4.8	4	13	11	63.1	46	13	10
Marx	5.5	8	15	21	79.4	129	17	27
Ordinary language	20.7	18	55	48	359.8	325	76	68
Moral conscience	8.1	10	22	27	97.0	123	20	26
Methodology of science	5.2	5	14	13	86.8	107	18	22
Heidegger and Husserl	7.0	14	19	38	87.0	181	18	38
Emotions	3.5	8	9	21	37.9	89	8	19
Ontological argument	4.7	3	13	8	56.3	47	12	10
Chemistry	2.5	1	7	3	38.3	23	8	5
Social contract theory	4.1	4	11	11	47.2	70	10	15
Kant	2.3	2	6	5	25.1	28	5	6
Promises and imperatives	5.9	6	16	16	67.5	59	14	12
Analytic/synthetic	2.4	3	6	8	30.4	43	6	9
Freedom and free will	3.1	3	8	8	37.2	28	8	6
Crime and punishment	5.8	8	16	21	84.7	128	18	27
Sets and grue	6.9	8	19	21	101.6	134	21	28
Origins and purposes	2.3	0	6	0	16.4	0	3	0
Time	3.0	5	8	13	28.9	40	6	8
Color/colour	2.8	3	7	8	20.0	7	4	1
War	2.9	2	8	5	28.9	8	6	2
Depiction	1.3	0	4	0	18.2	0	4	0
Denoting	4.3	6	12	16	56.5	83	12	17
Chance	6.9	10	18	27	73.9	121	16	25
Hume	1.7	1	4	3	19.9	2	4	0
Laws	2.2	2	6	5	33.5	37	7	8
Perception	3.8	5	10	13	46.9	58	10	12
Intention	3.4	3	9	8	31.1	25	7	5
Virtues	3.3	4	9	11	35.8	32	8	7
Space and time	9.1	15	24	40	126.9	218	27	46
Mathematics	3.5	5	9	13	75.6	125	16	26
Liberal democracy	3.0	2	8	5	39.4	20	8	4
Duties	8.1	10	22	27	77.6	89	16	19
Causation	4.9	7	13	19	62.0	100	13	21
Arguments	9.3	2	25	5	107.8	28	23	6
Theory testing	3.7	2	10	5	54.5	20	11	4
Decision theory	2.6	1	7	3	34.5	12	7	3
Minds and machines	3.6	3	10	8	39.6	20	8	4
Truth	6.7	6	18	16	83.7	59	18	12
Radical translation	6.1	11	16	29	74.6	120	16	25
Explanation	4.0	5	11	13	48.1	50	10	11
Personal identity	3.7	4	10	11	40.0	54	8	11
Speech acts	4.2	5	11	13	37.5	41	8	9
Sense and reference	6.9	8	18	21	82.5	102	17	21
Egalitarianism	13.9	21	37	56	149.1	235	31	49
Quantum physics	4.2	6	11	16	41.3	65	9	14
Theories and realism	5.6	1	15	3	85.3	6	18	1
Functions	3.4	4	9	11	58.6	76	12	16
Feminism	4.9	7	13	19	71.1	114	15	24
Medical ethics and Freud	2.2	4	6	11	39.7	78	8	16
Abortion and self-defence	4.3	7	12	19	41.6	75	9	16
Belief ascriptions	2.8	2	8	5	36.5	27	8	6
Thermodynamics	2.6	2	7	5	40.9	37	9	8
Knowledge	4.4	1	12	3	46.8	5	10	1
Game theory	1.3	0	3	0	18.7	0	4	0
Justification	5.6	5	15	13	60.0	38	13	8
Frankfurt cases	2.1	2	6	5	24.6	26	5	5
Concepts	3.7	0	10	0	50.8	0	11	0
Races and DNA	1.8	2	5	5	21.9	39	5	8
Modality	4.5	5	12	13	46.4	47	10	10
Reasons	4.0	3	11	8	50.5	40	11	8
Evolutionary biology	2.0	3	5	8	28.1	38	6	8
Population ethics	2.3	4	6	11	29.4	54	6	11
Formal epistemology	1.6	2	4	5	23.1	23	5	5
Wide content	1.6	1	4	3	21.2	16	4	3
Vagueness	1.1	0	3	0	11.1	0	2	0
Cognitive science	2.5	2	7	5	19.0	8	4	2
Models	1.9	1	5	3	27.1	23	6	5
Composition and constitution	4.1	3	11	8	45.5	31	10	7
Norms	2.8	1	7	3	47.2	18	10	4

1978

Table B.103: Measures of the prominence of each subject in 1978 ’s journals.

Subject	Weight	Raw	W-Ratio	R-Ratio	W-Pages	R-Pages	WP-Ratio	RP-Ratio
Psychology	1.7	1	4	3	29.4	35	6	7
Idealism	1.8	0	5	0	26.2	0	6	0
Life and value	4.9	2	13	5	71.4	27	15	6
Other history	2.5	2	6	5	25.8	15	5	3
Dewey and pragmatism	3.0	4	8	10	36.1	33	8	7
Definitions	4.8	1	12	3	61.9	11	13	2
Propositions and implications	4.1	2	11	5	41.7	16	9	3
Beauty	3.4	7	9	18	38.3	80	8	17
Physicalism	3.8	3	10	8	44.2	30	9	6
History and culture	2.3	2	6	5	25.9	15	5	3
Faith and theism	3.1	4	8	10	23.1	23	5	5
Self-consciousness	2.2	1	6	3	26.5	9	6	2
Ancient	4.2	7	11	18	70.6	110	15	23
Universals and particulars	5.5	8	14	21	64.7	67	14	14
Verification	6.9	6	18	15	70.6	60	15	13
Value	3.9	5	10	13	51.0	80	11	17
Deduction	4.4	5	11	13	46.0	51	10	11
Mechanisms	3.6	3	9	8	46.6	48	10	10
Temporal paradoxes	3.4	3	9	8	34.8	12	7	3
Classical space and time	1.7	0	4	0	19.2	0	4	0
Early modern	3.1	4	8	10	27.9	28	6	6
Meaning and use	5.3	6	13	15	57.7	71	12	15
Marx	4.6	4	12	10	92.1	103	19	22
Ordinary language	19.9	13	51	33	317.6	223	67	47
Moral conscience	5.8	7	15	18	69.7	82	15	17
Methodology of science	4.9	2	12	5	57.6	29	12	6
Heidegger and Husserl	4.9	7	13	18	62.0	96	13	20
Emotions	3.5	5	9	13	46.4	60	10	13
Ontological argument	3.5	3	9	8	42.3	38	9	8
Chemistry	3.0	1	8	3	30.7	6	6	1
Social contract theory	1.8	1	5	3	25.6	17	5	4
Kant	1.1	0	3	0	11.6	0	2	0
Promises and imperatives	5.6	4	14	10	62.3	41	13	9
Analytic/synthetic	1.6	1	4	3	22.4	9	5	2
Freedom and free will	3.7	6	9	15	41.2	61	9	13
Crime and punishment	6.2	9	16	23	92.6	137	20	29
Sets and grue	9.2	10	24	26	94.4	94	20	20
Origins and purposes	3.9	7	10	18	30.9	38	7	8
Time	4.4	6	11	15	46.6	69	10	15
Color/colour	1.3	0	3	0	18.5	0	4	0
War	3.3	4	9	10	37.8	32	8	7
Depiction	3.1	5	8	13	34.6	51	7	11
Denoting	7.9	14	20	36	71.5	127	15	27
Chance	6.6	9	17	23	92.1	150	19	32
Hume	1.7	1	4	3	25.1	18	5	4
Laws	5.2	7	13	18	68.7	86	15	18
Perception	3.7	3	9	8	41.0	35	9	7
Intention	5.2	7	13	18	46.9	74	10	16
Virtues	2.2	2	6	5	26.3	15	6	3
Space and time	5.9	8	15	21	66.2	94	14	20
Mathematics	2.6	3	7	8	31.1	31	7	7
Liberal democracy	4.2	4	11	10	65.4	68	14	14
Duties	8.6	8	22	21	105.3	103	22	22
Causation	5.8	7	15	18	70.3	86	15	18
Arguments	10.6	0	27	0	119.1	0	25	0
Theory testing	8.6	10	22	26	103.4	134	22	28
Decision theory	4.4	3	11	8	42.8	32	9	7
Minds and machines	3.8	5	10	13	53.3	79	11	17
Truth	6.9	3	18	8	68.1	26	14	5
Radical translation	6.1	8	16	21	80.2	104	17	22
Explanation	5.7	6	15	15	71.2	56	15	12
Personal identity	6.0	9	15	23	50.8	88	11	19
Speech acts	2.1	2	5	5	27.5	28	6	6
Sense and reference	7.3	9	19	23	90.0	145	19	31
Egalitarianism	7.0	8	18	21	97.4	109	21	23
Quantum physics	1.7	1	4	3	34.2	33	7	7
Theories and realism	10.5	9	27	23	122.6	111	26	23
Functions	1.7	1	4	3	16.8	11	4	2
Feminism	4.6	6	12	15	49.6	58	10	12
Medical ethics and Freud	2.9	5	7	13	57.0	124	12	26
Abortion and self-defence	6.0	7	15	18	54.7	72	12	15
Belief ascriptions	3.1	2	8	5	35.0	26	7	5
Thermodynamics	1.9	1	5	3	24.0	13	5	3
Knowledge	5.3	4	14	10	55.8	40	12	8
Game theory	1.3	0	3	0	11.5	0	2	0
Justification	6.1	8	16	21	64.5	69	14	15
Frankfurt cases	4.9	8	13	21	38.7	72	8	15
Concepts	3.4	0	9	0	47.0	0	10	0
Races and DNA	1.5	1	4	3	23.8	23	5	5
Modality	5.2	7	13	18	43.2	38	9	8
Reasons	4.2	3	11	8	59.2	51	12	11
Evolutionary biology	4.3	7	11	18	69.9	119	15	25
Population ethics	3.7	5	10	13	46.1	65	10	14
Formal epistemology	2.7	4	7	10	33.4	58	7	12
Wide content	1.0	0	3	0	15.5	0	3	0
Vagueness	1.2	0	3	0	10.4	0	2	0
Cognitive science	2.0	2	5	5	29.7	32	6	7
Models	2.3	0	6	0	30.2	0	6	0
Composition and constitution	3.5	2	9	5	47.6	27	10	6
Norms	1.9	0	5	0	27.6	0	6	0

1979

Table B.104: Measures of the prominence of each subject in 1979 ’s journals.

Subject	Weight	Raw	W-Ratio	R-Ratio	W-Pages	R-Pages	WP-Ratio	RP-Ratio
Psychology	0.7	0	2	0	8.4	0	2	0
Idealism	3.0	2	8	5	48.2	31	10	6
Life and value	3.7	2	10	5	58.8	29	12	6
Other history	2.6	1	7	3	35.2	13	7	3
Dewey and pragmatism	2.2	0	6	0	31.3	0	6	0
Definitions	4.8	3	13	8	69.6	24	14	5
Propositions and implications	6.2	5	17	13	53.6	17	11	3
Beauty	2.2	4	6	11	25.7	39	5	8
Physicalism	3.7	7	10	19	54.3	117	11	23
History and culture	1.8	1	5	3	35.3	15	7	3
Faith and theism	1.8	2	5	5	19.9	25	4	5
Self-consciousness	2.4	1	6	3	28.5	5	6	1
Ancient	4.0	8	11	21	63.8	133	13	26
Universals and particulars	4.5	3	12	8	63.6	40	13	8
Verification	4.4	3	12	8	54.3	28	11	6
Value	2.5	2	7	5	39.1	47	8	9
Deduction	5.4	8	14	21	58.9	73	12	14
Mechanisms	2.8	2	7	5	44.7	55	9	11
Temporal paradoxes	5.0	3	13	8	53.9	16	11	3
Classical space and time	3.5	4	9	11	41.9	53	8	10
Early modern	2.7	3	7	8	39.0	48	8	9
Meaning and use	5.6	5	15	13	80.3	77	16	15
Marx	6.8	9	18	24	114.8	180	23	36
Ordinary language	22.8	18	61	48	386.0	337	76	67
Moral conscience	4.9	6	13	16	67.4	94	13	19
Methodology of science	4.8	3	13	8	58.7	16	12	3
Heidegger and Husserl	7.6	14	20	37	121.8	227	24	45
Emotions	1.1	1	3	3	14.7	11	3	2
Ontological argument	3.3	4	9	11	42.9	53	8	10
Chemistry	1.7	1	5	3	34.7	34	7	7
Social contract theory	3.5	5	9	13	46.5	73	9	14
Kant	1.2	0	3	0	17.9	0	4	0
Promises and imperatives	7.6	6	20	16	91.4	46	18	9
Analytic/synthetic	1.7	0	4	0	25.3	0	5	0
Freedom and free will	4.1	6	11	16	40.4	56	8	11
Crime and punishment	6.9	9	18	24	113.6	162	22	32
Sets and grue	7.4	7	20	19	93.1	83	18	16
Origins and purposes	1.5	1	4	3	23.0	23	5	5
Time	5.5	5	15	13	50.5	38	10	8
Color/colour	1.7	1	5	3	26.5	18	5	4
War	1.6	0	4	0	24.7	0	5	0
Depiction	4.0	5	11	13	63.3	92	13	18
Denoting	6.7	10	18	27	72.1	113	14	22
Chance	3.2	3	8	8	39.1	27	8	5
Hume	1.2	1	3	3	22.0	15	4	3
Laws	3.5	5	9	13	50.2	68	10	13
Perception	3.6	3	10	8	59.1	54	12	11
Intention	4.5	7	12	19	52.8	66	10	13
Virtues	2.3	2	6	5	24.9	11	5	2
Space and time	8.8	13	23	35	94.2	144	19	28
Mathematics	5.0	8	13	21	91.0	181	18	36
Liberal democracy	3.8	4	10	11	54.9	59	11	12
Duties	7.4	10	20	27	75.1	94	15	19
Causation	6.6	9	18	24	94.6	124	19	25
Arguments	10.3	2	27	5	132.9	9	26	2
Theory testing	3.5	5	9	13	49.5	69	10	14
Decision theory	5.4	7	14	19	64.5	101	13	20
Minds and machines	3.3	4	9	11	42.6	50	8	10
Truth	6.9	5	18	13	85.0	91	17	18
Radical translation	6.4	10	17	27	79.3	117	16	23
Explanation	4.6	3	12	8	69.4	49	14	10
Personal identity	3.2	2	8	5	38.2	23	8	5
Speech acts	5.1	7	14	19	62.8	95	12	19
Sense and reference	7.3	5	19	13	97.3	69	19	14
Egalitarianism	9.2	15	25	40	120.4	199	24	39
Quantum physics	2.4	2	6	5	39.1	30	8	6
Theories and realism	6.7	4	18	11	90.6	65	18	13
Functions	2.2	2	6	5	34.2	38	7	8
Feminism	4.0	5	11	13	37.1	39	7	8
Medical ethics and Freud	1.5	1	4	3	20.3	13	4	3
Abortion and self-defence	3.9	3	10	8	35.0	18	7	4
Belief ascriptions	3.9	2	10	5	48.2	50	10	10
Thermodynamics	1.4	0	4	0	18.4	0	4	0
Knowledge	3.3	3	9	8	41.9	15	8	3
Game theory	1.8	1	5	3	24.3	12	5	2
Justification	5.2	6	14	16	69.0	62	14	12
Frankfurt cases	3.2	2	9	5	24.8	8	5	2
Concepts	3.6	1	9	3	61.2	22	12	4
Races and DNA	1.8	2	5	5	22.5	23	4	5
Modality	6.4	8	17	21	83.5	100	17	20
Reasons	5.0	4	13	11	66.9	68	13	13
Evolutionary biology	2.7	4	7	11	37.7	69	7	14
Population ethics	4.2	5	11	13	61.6	63	12	12
Formal epistemology	3.5	5	9	13	31.1	55	6	11
Wide content	1.2	0	3	0	20.4	0	4	0
Vagueness	1.4	1	4	3	18.5	7	4	1
Cognitive science	0.9	1	2	3	14.3	16	3	3
Models	1.6	0	4	0	21.3	0	4	0
Composition and constitution	3.9	2	10	5	56.1	24	11	5
Norms	2.5	1	7	3	43.0	4	9	1

1980

Table B.105: Measures of the prominence of each subject in 1980 ’s journals.

Subject	Weight	Raw	W-Ratio	R-Ratio	W-Pages	R-Pages	WP-Ratio	RP-Ratio
Psychology	0.8	0	2	0	12.8	0	3	0
Idealism	3.5	3	9	8	58.3	48	12	10
Life and value	3.9	0	11	0	67.0	0	13	0
Other history	3.2	2	9	5	45.5	33	9	7
Dewey and pragmatism	2.2	0	6	0	29.1	0	6	0
Definitions	4.0	1	11	3	57.8	9	12	2
Propositions and implications	4.6	2	12	5	48.4	27	10	5
Beauty	2.8	4	7	11	46.9	82	9	16
Physicalism	2.5	0	7	0	30.6	0	6	0
History and culture	3.0	4	8	11	32.9	29	7	6
Faith and theism	2.0	0	5	0	19.2	0	4	0
Self-consciousness	2.1	2	6	5	25.5	27	5	5
Ancient	2.6	3	7	8	54.2	63	11	13
Universals and particulars	3.3	2	9	5	52.4	39	11	8
Verification	4.1	3	11	8	42.2	9	8	2
Value	2.9	2	8	5	46.8	35	9	7
Deduction	5.2	5	14	13	56.7	60	11	12
Mechanisms	3.5	1	9	3	61.5	15	12	3
Temporal paradoxes	5.7	7	15	19	43.7	47	9	9
Classical space and time	1.9	3	5	8	17.7	18	4	4
Early modern	3.9	7	10	19	47.5	94	10	19
Meaning and use	3.4	3	9	8	47.4	41	10	8
Marx	4.9	7	13	19	67.0	91	13	18
Ordinary language	19.2	16	51	43	331.6	311	67	63
Moral conscience	5.0	6	13	16	68.0	79	14	16
Methodology of science	6.5	6	17	16	79.6	95	16	19
Heidegger and Husserl	5.3	11	14	29	52.6	117	11	24
Emotions	2.9	5	8	13	59.2	103	12	21
Ontological argument	4.0	2	11	5	37.9	6	8	1
Chemistry	2.5	2	7	5	47.9	47	10	9
Social contract theory	2.7	3	7	8	44.7	58	9	12
Kant	2.0	2	5	5	29.4	24	6	5
Promises and imperatives	6.4	4	17	11	81.7	32	16	6
Analytic/synthetic	2.3	2	6	5	27.1	20	5	4
Freedom and free will	4.8	7	13	19	64.6	104	13	21
Crime and punishment	3.6	5	10	13	57.2	79	11	16
Sets and grue	10.3	12	28	32	116.3	101	23	20
Origins and purposes	2.9	3	8	8	36.0	34	7	7
Time	4.0	5	11	13	38.4	46	8	9
Color/colour	2.1	2	6	5	22.5	20	5	4
War	3.2	1	9	3	46.0	22	9	4
Depiction	2.1	3	6	8	30.2	55	6	11
Denoting	4.7	6	12	16	50.7	51	10	10
Chance	5.2	4	14	11	67.1	50	13	10
Hume	2.8	4	7	11	36.3	53	7	11
Laws	3.2	4	9	11	38.3	42	8	8
Perception	3.3	2	9	5	35.2	12	7	2
Intention	6.9	9	19	24	70.8	75	14	15
Virtues	3.4	3	9	8	48.0	36	10	7
Space and time	5.3	8	14	21	95.3	155	19	31
Mathematics	5.3	9	14	24	81.1	183	16	37
Liberal democracy	6.7	7	18	19	95.3	90	19	18
Duties	6.6	8	18	21	90.4	107	18	22
Causation	5.9	6	16	16	64.7	38	13	8
Arguments	10.9	2	29	5	129.7	5	26	1
Theory testing	5.1	5	14	13	65.9	37	13	7
Decision theory	4.3	3	12	8	51.1	20	10	4
Minds and machines	4.5	4	12	11	56.9	57	11	11
Truth	5.9	0	16	0	53.3	0	11	0
Radical translation	4.3	7	11	19	56.0	105	11	21
Explanation	4.3	8	12	21	51.7	90	10	18
Personal identity	5.4	6	14	16	49.2	31	10	6
Speech acts	3.4	5	9	13	35.6	50	7	10
Sense and reference	6.3	6	17	16	61.6	25	12	5
Egalitarianism	6.5	12	17	32	101.8	202	20	41
Quantum physics	1.2	0	3	0	17.6	0	4	0
Theories and realism	5.8	2	15	5	90.6	42	18	8
Functions	1.8	0	5	0	29.2	0	6	0
Feminism	5.2	8	14	21	72.1	111	15	22
Medical ethics and Freud	6.6	15	18	40	113.0	273	23	55
Abortion and self-defence	5.7	9	15	24	62.5	137	13	28
Belief ascriptions	2.1	2	6	5	31.7	45	6	9
Thermodynamics	2.5	1	7	3	35.1	11	7	2
Knowledge	4.6	4	12	11	62.4	77	13	15
Game theory	1.1	1	3	3	12.8	6	3	1
Justification	7.9	10	21	27	100.2	118	20	24
Frankfurt cases	3.4	2	9	5	27.9	6	6	1
Concepts	4.4	0	12	0	77.2	0	16	0
Races and DNA	1.0	2	3	5	17.1	54	3	11
Modality	4.7	6	13	16	61.7	89	12	18
Reasons	4.7	4	13	11	60.6	43	12	9
Evolutionary biology	1.9	3	5	8	44.2	77	9	15
Population ethics	3.2	3	9	8	42.5	34	9	7
Formal epistemology	5.7	8	15	21	48.1	92	10	18
Wide content	1.5	1	4	3	17.1	6	3	1
Vagueness	1.3	0	3	0	18.8	0	4	0
Cognitive science	2.2	3	6	8	41.6	66	8	13
Models	1.4	1	4	3	29.0	19	6	4
Composition and constitution	2.5	1	7	3	37.8	15	8	3
Norms	3.0	1	8	3	54.3	18	11	4

1981

Table B.106: Measures of the prominence of each subject in 1981 ’s journals.

Subject	Weight	Raw	W-Ratio	R-Ratio	W-Pages	R-Pages	WP-Ratio	RP-Ratio
Psychology	2.1	2	5	5	22.8	10	5	2
Idealism	2.5	2	7	5	42.2	40	9	8
Life and value	3.7	0	10	0	66.1	0	13	0
Other history	1.9	0	5	0	26.9	0	5	0
Dewey and pragmatism	2.3	0	6	0	33.1	0	7	0
Definitions	3.8	0	10	0	49.8	0	10	0
Propositions and implications	4.1	3	11	8	32.1	14	6	3
Beauty	3.3	7	9	19	52.1	125	11	25
Physicalism	4.2	2	11	5	52.7	31	11	6
History and culture	2.2	2	6	5	29.3	32	6	6
Faith and theism	1.4	1	4	3	16.2	4	3	1
Self-consciousness	3.4	3	9	8	45.6	26	9	5
Ancient	2.8	5	8	13	34.9	66	7	13
Universals and particulars	4.9	7	13	19	61.7	108	12	22
Verification	3.2	1	8	3	37.2	8	8	2
Value	3.5	2	9	5	37.3	23	8	5
Deduction	5.7	9	15	24	58.4	90	12	18
Mechanisms	3.7	3	10	8	60.3	46	12	9
Temporal paradoxes	3.8	4	10	11	41.6	53	8	11
Classical space and time	2.7	2	7	5	37.5	33	8	7
Early modern	6.0	9	16	24	94.4	170	19	34
Meaning and use	5.0	6	13	16	58.2	59	12	12
Marx	6.0	6	16	16	127.7	146	26	30
Ordinary language	17.1	8	46	21	317.5	122	64	25
Moral conscience	5.8	6	15	16	76.8	78	16	16
Methodology of science	4.7	3	13	8	62.4	28	13	6
Heidegger and Husserl	4.3	6	11	16	51.4	60	10	12
Emotions	2.2	1	6	3	27.1	2	5	0
Ontological argument	4.1	3	11	8	50.2	29	10	6
Chemistry	3.7	2	10	5	32.1	8	6	2
Social contract theory	1.9	2	5	5	22.1	11	4	2
Kant	1.5	2	4	5	26.2	39	5	8
Promises and imperatives	6.9	7	18	19	87.7	91	18	18
Analytic/synthetic	1.3	0	4	0	16.7	0	3	0
Freedom and free will	3.9	3	10	8	56.1	50	11	10
Crime and punishment	1.0	0	3	0	12.9	0	3	0
Sets and grue	9.0	8	24	21	118.6	119	24	24
Origins and purposes	1.3	1	4	3	20.1	19	4	4
Time	2.3	3	6	8	26.4	22	5	4
Color/colour	2.0	2	5	5	14.7	10	3	2
War	2.9	3	8	8	43.5	67	9	14
Depiction	1.7	0	4	0	24.2	0	5	0
Denoting	2.6	2	7	5	29.6	24	6	5
Chance	6.9	9	18	24	74.8	108	15	22
Hume	1.3	2	4	5	21.7	36	4	7
Laws	3.0	4	8	11	34.7	51	7	10
Perception	4.7	4	13	11	58.0	66	12	13
Intention	7.3	9	19	24	74.6	93	15	19
Virtues	3.1	3	8	8	39.1	45	8	9
Space and time	4.3	7	11	19	43.1	67	9	14
Mathematics	4.8	9	13	24	71.7	149	15	30
Liberal democracy	7.7	10	21	27	111.9	118	23	24
Duties	10.9	15	29	40	102.1	150	21	30
Causation	8.6	10	23	27	69.0	59	14	12
Arguments	10.6	3	28	8	117.9	16	24	3
Theory testing	5.2	8	14	21	61.5	78	12	16
Decision theory	4.8	5	13	13	62.4	63	13	13
Minds and machines	5.3	6	14	16	77.1	109	16	22
Truth	5.8	3	16	8	59.5	27	12	5
Radical translation	4.1	4	11	11	66.1	66	13	13
Explanation	3.9	4	10	11	52.2	49	11	10
Personal identity	3.7	4	10	11	39.2	44	8	9
Speech acts	3.5	6	9	16	44.3	79	9	16
Sense and reference	5.1	6	14	16	51.9	50	10	10
Egalitarianism	8.9	13	24	35	207.7	336	42	68
Quantum physics	4.6	6	12	16	48.5	70	10	14
Theories and realism	6.8	4	18	11	93.6	46	19	9
Functions	2.2	1	6	3	23.1	4	5	1
Feminism	1.6	1	4	3	25.7	20	5	4
Medical ethics and Freud	4.7	9	13	24	66.5	110	13	22
Abortion and self-defence	4.4	7	12	19	50.9	95	10	19
Belief ascriptions	2.0	2	5	5	29.7	40	6	8
Thermodynamics	2.1	1	6	3	28.4	13	6	3
Knowledge	4.3	6	11	16	57.1	81	12	16
Game theory	1.4	1	4	3	14.7	2	3	0
Justification	6.3	8	17	21	77.0	119	16	24
Frankfurt cases	2.3	3	6	8	20.1	23	4	5
Concepts	4.6	2	12	5	66.0	13	13	3
Races and DNA	1.3	1	4	3	18.4	16	4	3
Modality	6.2	7	16	19	49.9	33	10	7
Reasons	4.8	2	13	5	63.6	19	13	4
Evolutionary biology	4.9	7	13	19	93.0	143	19	29
Population ethics	3.9	3	10	8	66.5	55	13	11
Formal epistemology	4.2	7	11	19	51.9	97	10	20
Wide content	2.6	3	7	8	28.8	31	6	6
Vagueness	2.5	3	7	8	22.9	30	5	6
Cognitive science	2.6	5	7	13	41.2	85	8	17
Models	1.2	0	3	0	21.5	0	4	0
Composition and constitution	4.1	1	11	3	48.0	19	10	4
Norms	3.6	3	10	8	61.2	57	12	12

1982

Table B.107: Measures of the prominence of each subject in 1982 ’s journals.

Subject	Weight	Raw	W-Ratio	R-Ratio	W-Pages	R-Pages	WP-Ratio	RP-Ratio
Psychology	1.0	1	3	3	14.0	9	3	2
Idealism	2.8	0	7	0	46.2	0	9	0
Life and value	4.7	2	12	5	64.4	10	13	2
Other history	3.4	2	9	5	41.7	22	8	4
Dewey and pragmatism	2.7	2	7	5	34.1	14	7	3
Definitions	3.2	0	8	0	49.0	0	10	0
Propositions and implications	4.8	5	12	13	46.8	26	10	5
Beauty	2.1	4	5	10	26.4	48	5	10
Physicalism	4.6	3	12	8	53.6	41	11	8
History and culture	2.3	2	6	5	25.0	16	5	3
Faith and theism	2.4	2	6	5	27.0	24	5	5
Self-consciousness	2.4	1	6	3	28.6	25	6	5
Ancient	3.9	6	10	15	68.4	136	14	28
Universals and particulars	3.6	6	9	15	47.8	72	10	15
Verification	3.1	1	8	3	35.9	2	7	0
Value	3.1	3	8	8	43.2	42	9	9
Deduction	5.7	5	15	13	68.9	65	14	13
Mechanisms	6.6	9	17	23	83.2	128	17	26
Temporal paradoxes	5.1	6	13	15	56.1	69	11	14
Classical space and time	2.1	1	5	3	30.1	4	6	1
Early modern	4.2	5	11	13	61.4	69	12	14
Meaning and use	6.3	6	16	15	70.8	75	14	15
Marx	4.3	6	11	15	72.1	107	15	22
Ordinary language	17.0	13	43	33	307.5	245	63	50
Moral conscience	8.4	14	21	36	104.2	185	21	38
Methodology of science	5.9	5	15	13	86.6	81	18	16
Heidegger and Husserl	7.3	11	19	28	86.4	127	18	26
Emotions	2.1	2	5	5	31.5	49	6	10
Ontological argument	5.3	3	14	8	48.7	12	10	2
Chemistry	3.3	2	9	5	47.5	49	10	10
Social contract theory	2.3	3	6	8	31.1	41	6	8
Kant	2.4	3	6	8	39.2	76	8	15
Promises and imperatives	5.1	4	13	10	65.9	56	13	11
Analytic/synthetic	3.7	4	9	10	35.5	27	7	5
Freedom and free will	2.9	2	7	5	36.4	21	7	4
Crime and punishment	1.7	2	4	5	25.1	32	5	7
Sets and grue	8.3	7	21	18	80.4	30	16	6
Origins and purposes	3.3	1	8	3	21.6	1	4	0
Time	2.2	0	6	0	21.2	0	4	0
Color/colour	3.2	3	8	8	45.8	53	9	11
War	4.5	5	11	13	66.5	75	14	15
Depiction	2.2	3	6	8	31.1	52	6	11
Denoting	5.1	6	13	15	60.9	83	12	17
Chance	5.2	5	13	13	57.6	57	12	12
Hume	3.8	5	10	13	31.2	37	6	8
Laws	2.0	1	5	3	24.0	4	5	1
Perception	5.7	9	15	23	72.7	93	15	19
Intention	4.6	6	12	15	38.2	40	8	8
Virtues	2.5	2	6	5	30.1	22	6	4
Space and time	4.4	5	11	13	62.4	87	13	18
Mathematics	5.3	6	13	15	55.0	55	11	11
Liberal democracy	1.7	1	4	3	27.1	11	5	2
Duties	6.0	4	15	10	55.7	26	11	5
Causation	7.7	7	20	18	75.4	39	15	8
Arguments	10.9	2	28	5	122.1	9	25	2
Theory testing	5.6	5	14	13	70.2	51	14	10
Decision theory	5.2	7	13	18	61.7	84	13	17
Minds and machines	3.2	1	8	3	44.4	12	9	2
Truth	9.1	10	23	25	91.0	87	18	18
Radical translation	8.0	12	20	31	95.4	172	19	35
Explanation	3.5	1	9	3	41.0	3	8	1
Personal identity	7.4	10	19	25	60.8	44	12	9
Speech acts	2.4	3	6	8	27.3	39	6	8
Sense and reference	6.7	10	17	25	86.9	163	18	33
Egalitarianism	3.5	3	9	8	52.4	43	11	9
Quantum physics	5.1	10	13	25	80.5	177	16	36
Theories and realism	8.5	8	22	20	107.7	121	22	25
Functions	1.6	3	4	8	21.4	40	4	8
Feminism	4.4	5	11	13	48.3	53	10	11
Medical ethics and Freud	2.4	2	6	5	28.7	29	6	6
Abortion and self-defence	5.3	9	14	23	63.2	131	13	27
Belief ascriptions	5.1	4	13	10	64.6	58	13	12
Thermodynamics	3.2	4	8	10	69.7	99	14	20
Knowledge	4.6	3	12	8	40.1	14	8	3
Game theory	2.0	1	5	3	20.4	2	4	0
Justification	7.7	9	19	23	82.9	77	17	16
Frankfurt cases	2.8	4	7	10	31.7	43	6	9
Concepts	4.0	3	10	8	58.1	40	12	8
Races and DNA	1.6	3	4	8	21.9	40	4	8
Modality	5.8	8	15	20	51.9	47	11	10
Reasons	5.3	6	14	15	71.1	82	14	17
Evolutionary biology	3.7	5	10	13	49.7	86	10	17
Population ethics	3.7	5	9	13	91.3	127	19	26
Formal epistemology	2.4	3	6	8	23.2	29	5	6
Wide content	2.0	1	5	3	24.2	19	5	4
Vagueness	3.2	3	8	8	31.9	29	6	6
Cognitive science	2.4	2	6	5	36.9	30	8	6
Models	1.9	0	5	0	29.5	0	6	0
Composition and constitution	5.7	5	15	13	56.7	58	12	12
Norms	3.8	1	10	3	64.0	12	13	2

1983

Table B.108: Measures of the prominence of each subject in 1983 ’s journals.

Subject	Weight	Raw	W-Ratio	R-Ratio	W-Pages	R-Pages	WP-Ratio	RP-Ratio
Psychology	1.7	2	4	5	19.5	14	4	3
Idealism	2.8	1	7	3	50.8	7	10	1
Life and value	3.7	1	9	3	54.6	17	11	3
Other history	2.9	3	7	8	40.7	61	8	12
Dewey and pragmatism	3.2	2	8	5	45.0	43	9	9
Definitions	4.1	1	10	3	48.0	2	10	0
Propositions and implications	3.5	1	9	3	39.0	2	8	0
Beauty	2.3	4	6	10	33.9	61	7	12
Physicalism	3.9	2	10	5	37.9	12	8	2
History and culture	1.5	0	4	0	16.7	0	3	0
Faith and theism	4.9	7	12	18	48.2	47	10	10
Self-consciousness	3.7	2	9	5	44.5	24	9	5
Ancient	3.4	5	9	13	40.5	66	8	13
Universals and particulars	1.8	0	5	0	29.8	0	6	0
Verification	2.7	2	7	5	31.8	10	6	2
Value	4.3	4	11	10	61.8	67	12	14
Deduction	5.4	4	14	10	49.3	30	10	6
Mechanisms	3.7	5	9	13	47.4	62	10	13
Temporal paradoxes	3.4	1	9	3	39.0	7	8	1
Classical space and time	2.6	2	7	5	32.5	10	7	2
Early modern	3.4	6	9	15	57.3	107	12	22
Meaning and use	4.6	5	12	13	53.8	48	11	10
Marx	8.0	10	20	25	104.3	158	21	32
Ordinary language	20.4	14	52	36	341.1	256	69	52
Moral conscience	7.4	10	19	25	88.2	148	18	30
Methodology of science	5.8	5	15	13	61.5	54	12	11
Heidegger and Husserl	3.8	6	10	15	64.6	109	13	22
Emotions	3.8	7	10	18	48.8	91	10	18
Ontological argument	4.6	2	12	5	47.5	15	10	3
Chemistry	4.3	5	11	13	39.0	51	8	10
Social contract theory	3.0	4	8	10	33.5	55	7	11
Kant	3.3	3	8	8	59.5	69	12	14
Promises and imperatives	6.1	4	15	10	79.9	53	16	11
Analytic/synthetic	2.2	2	6	5	23.9	28	5	6
Freedom and free will	5.2	6	13	15	58.5	47	12	10
Crime and punishment	4.8	7	12	18	95.9	147	19	30
Sets and grue	7.4	10	19	25	106.0	140	21	28
Origins and purposes	2.8	4	7	10	36.0	55	7	11
Time	2.9	5	7	13	40.8	78	8	16
Color/colour	1.3	1	3	3	14.3	8	3	2
War	2.7	0	7	0	39.4	0	8	0
Depiction	3.7	6	9	15	43.4	66	9	13
Denoting	4.3	7	11	18	40.9	59	8	12
Chance	6.8	7	17	18	73.8	96	15	19
Hume	3.8	7	10	18	34.2	70	7	14
Laws	2.9	3	7	8	33.8	40	7	8
Perception	3.5	2	9	5	41.3	7	8	1
Intention	6.6	7	17	18	58.1	51	12	10
Virtues	2.3	1	6	3	35.1	7	7	1
Space and time	2.4	3	6	8	30.1	39	6	8
Mathematics	6.2	8	16	20	91.3	121	18	24
Liberal democracy	6.3	9	16	23	88.6	133	18	27
Duties	5.3	4	14	10	59.6	44	12	9
Causation	4.9	5	12	13	56.9	50	12	10
Arguments	10.1	3	26	8	124.0	31	25	6
Theory testing	5.3	7	13	18	69.4	90	14	18
Decision theory	6.5	10	17	25	78.2	125	16	25
Minds and machines	4.4	6	11	15	63.3	81	13	16
Truth	7.8	6	20	15	76.3	35	15	7
Radical translation	6.9	8	18	20	83.1	116	17	23
Explanation	3.2	1	8	3	44.1	5	9	1
Personal identity	4.0	4	10	10	41.5	43	8	9
Speech acts	2.5	0	6	0	29.2	0	6	0
Sense and reference	4.7	4	12	10	53.6	54	11	11
Egalitarianism	8.3	10	21	25	100.2	100	20	20
Quantum physics	3.6	7	9	18	49.4	81	10	16
Theories and realism	8.5	3	22	8	98.4	21	20	4
Functions	1.8	1	5	3	22.3	5	5	1
Feminism	3.8	7	10	18	27.1	56	5	11
Medical ethics and Freud	3.8	5	10	13	39.3	59	8	12
Abortion and self-defence	3.5	6	9	15	47.5	76	10	15
Belief ascriptions	3.9	4	10	10	46.1	61	9	12
Thermodynamics	1.9	1	5	3	21.3	11	4	2
Knowledge	5.2	5	13	13	45.3	22	9	4
Game theory	1.9	1	5	3	26.8	15	5	3
Justification	9.4	10	24	25	99.2	105	20	21
Frankfurt cases	3.0	3	8	8	38.4	46	8	9
Concepts	4.3	1	11	3	64.4	22	13	4
Races and DNA	0.9	0	2	0	11.6	0	2	0
Modality	6.1	8	16	20	68.7	93	14	19
Reasons	6.3	7	16	18	75.8	95	15	19
Evolutionary biology	5.4	8	14	20	58.9	105	12	21
Population ethics	4.0	4	10	10	56.6	68	11	14
Formal epistemology	2.1	3	5	8	28.4	58	6	12
Wide content	2.6	2	7	5	33.0	20	7	4
Vagueness	2.8	4	7	10	32.6	31	7	6
Cognitive science	2.2	2	6	5	38.9	57	8	12
Models	2.3	2	6	5	35.4	30	7	6
Composition and constitution	3.8	4	10	10	55.7	57	11	12
Norms	4.0	2	10	5	65.1	25	13	5

1984

Table B.109: Measures of the prominence of each subject in 1984 ’s journals.

Subject	Weight	Raw	W-Ratio	R-Ratio	W-Pages	R-Pages	WP-Ratio	RP-Ratio
Psychology	0.8	1	2	3	13.6	17	3	3
Idealism	2.0	0	5	0	31.8	0	6	0
Life and value	4.0	3	10	8	67.3	65	13	13
Other history	3.4	2	9	5	33.4	21	6	4
Dewey and pragmatism	2.4	0	6	0	33.1	0	6	0
Definitions	4.5	1	12	3	54.1	2	10	0
Propositions and implications	4.8	2	12	5	52.3	7	10	1
Beauty	1.7	2	4	5	18.9	24	4	5
Physicalism	6.0	7	15	18	50.2	38	10	7
History and culture	1.9	2	5	5	22.0	18	4	3
Faith and theism	1.8	1	5	3	25.0	8	5	2
Self-consciousness	2.0	1	5	3	32.6	19	6	4
Ancient	2.8	3	7	8	51.4	53	10	10
Universals and particulars	3.3	4	8	10	53.7	72	10	14
Verification	5.2	2	13	5	47.9	7	9	1
Value	4.0	4	10	10	47.6	44	9	8
Deduction	4.3	4	11	10	61.2	64	12	12
Mechanisms	3.3	2	8	5	48.0	17	9	3
Temporal paradoxes	4.9	7	12	18	48.6	74	9	14
Classical space and time	2.4	0	6	0	21.7	0	4	0
Early modern	2.0	4	5	10	34.7	72	7	14
Meaning and use	4.7	6	12	15	66.5	81	13	16
Marx	3.4	3	9	8	53.9	57	10	11
Ordinary language	21.1	14	54	36	374.3	239	72	46
Moral conscience	5.7	6	15	15	79.4	73	15	14
Methodology of science	5.2	2	13	5	63.7	21	12	4
Heidegger and Husserl	3.2	6	8	15	39.5	82	8	16
Emotions	2.7	3	7	8	39.2	24	8	5
Ontological argument	3.9	3	10	8	47.6	55	9	11
Chemistry	2.5	3	6	8	41.6	44	8	8
Social contract theory	1.2	0	3	0	23.0	0	4	0
Kant	2.4	4	6	10	45.1	82	9	16
Promises and imperatives	4.7	1	12	3	68.4	10	13	2
Analytic/synthetic	1.9	0	5	0	24.6	0	5	0
Freedom and free will	3.4	4	9	10	41.4	61	8	12
Crime and punishment	3.8	7	10	18	75.0	149	14	29
Sets and grue	6.1	6	16	15	83.7	78	16	15
Origins and purposes	2.2	2	6	5	15.8	6	3	1
Time	4.1	5	11	13	55.9	83	11	16
Color/colour	3.1	2	8	5	32.8	13	6	3
War	3.2	5	8	13	47.1	64	9	12
Depiction	3.3	5	9	13	28.4	51	5	10
Denoting	7.9	14	20	36	104.1	221	20	43
Chance	5.0	9	13	23	62.7	108	12	21
Hume	3.5	4	9	10	31.0	30	6	6
Laws	2.6	2	7	5	40.1	32	8	6
Perception	4.9	4	13	10	64.5	57	12	11
Intention	4.2	6	11	15	53.0	72	10	14
Virtues	3.5	3	9	8	41.6	38	8	7
Space and time	4.3	5	11	13	28.7	30	6	6
Mathematics	5.0	5	13	13	59.8	79	12	15
Liberal democracy	3.3	3	8	8	50.9	65	10	13
Duties	6.7	7	17	18	96.5	87	19	17
Causation	6.4	8	16	21	63.3	87	12	17
Arguments	12.4	3	32	8	139.4	12	27	2
Theory testing	4.2	6	11	15	43.5	51	8	10
Decision theory	4.6	3	12	8	49.7	11	10	2
Minds and machines	5.4	5	14	13	62.5	48	12	9
Truth	7.4	10	19	26	89.6	150	17	29
Radical translation	6.6	8	17	21	98.4	139	19	27
Explanation	3.1	2	8	5	54.0	42	10	8
Personal identity	3.5	1	9	3	34.2	4	7	1
Speech acts	2.3	1	6	3	29.3	19	6	4
Sense and reference	7.9	9	20	23	97.1	104	19	20
Egalitarianism	6.3	6	16	15	92.3	97	18	19
Quantum physics	7.7	12	20	31	105.6	154	20	30
Theories and realism	7.1	5	18	13	87.4	38	17	7
Functions	2.4	3	6	8	28.1	34	5	7
Feminism	3.0	4	8	10	40.8	56	8	11
Medical ethics and Freud	5.4	8	14	21	54.7	70	11	14
Abortion and self-defence	4.7	6	12	15	66.6	87	13	17
Belief ascriptions	3.8	5	10	13	35.4	47	7	9
Thermodynamics	1.4	0	4	0	22.4	0	4	0
Knowledge	7.4	11	19	28	75.2	92	15	18
Game theory	2.4	2	6	5	18.0	5	3	1
Justification	7.7	9	20	23	97.6	120	19	23
Frankfurt cases	3.0	4	8	10	29.6	37	6	7
Concepts	5.1	2	13	5	89.5	48	17	9
Races and DNA	2.1	3	6	8	46.6	71	9	14
Modality	6.4	8	16	21	69.8	85	13	16
Reasons	4.7	6	12	15	68.3	71	13	14
Evolutionary biology	6.6	11	17	28	116.2	208	22	40
Population ethics	5.5	8	14	21	111.8	185	22	36
Formal epistemology	3.9	4	10	10	38.0	37	7	7
Wide content	2.8	2	7	5	41.4	32	8	6
Vagueness	4.4	5	11	13	44.5	44	9	8
Cognitive science	2.9	5	8	13	54.6	117	11	23
Models	1.9	1	5	3	32.8	13	6	3
Composition and constitution	4.2	3	11	8	64.0	49	12	9
Norms	3.2	0	8	0	56.4	0	11	0

1985

Table B.110: Measures of the prominence of each subject in 1985 ’s journals.

Subject	Weight	Raw	W-Ratio	R-Ratio	W-Pages	R-Pages	WP-Ratio	RP-Ratio
Psychology	1.7	1	4	2	24.0	7	4	1
Idealism	2.6	1	6	2	49.4	14	9	2
Life and value	3.2	0	7	0	47.3	0	8	0
Other history	4.5	5	11	12	52.4	48	9	8
Dewey and pragmatism	3.2	2	7	5	47.1	41	8	7
Definitions	3.1	1	7	2	43.3	13	8	2
Propositions and implications	3.1	2	7	5	36.3	9	6	2
Beauty	3.3	7	8	17	58.2	134	10	23
Physicalism	4.0	5	9	12	38.6	37	7	6
History and culture	4.3	6	10	14	47.4	87	8	15
Faith and theism	2.3	3	5	7	26.7	28	5	5
Self-consciousness	2.8	2	7	5	34.2	12	6	2
Ancient	2.6	5	6	12	42.1	102	7	18
Universals and particulars	1.8	0	4	0	20.8	0	4	0
Verification	3.0	0	7	0	37.6	0	7	0
Value	2.7	1	6	2	36.1	17	6	3
Deduction	7.0	7	16	17	73.2	64	13	11
Mechanisms	2.3	0	5	0	38.3	0	7	0
Temporal paradoxes	6.8	9	16	21	55.7	69	10	12
Classical space and time	2.8	1	7	2	42.6	21	7	4
Early modern	3.8	6	9	14	51.1	105	9	18
Meaning and use	4.3	3	10	7	52.1	30	9	5
Marx	6.0	8	14	19	81.8	85	14	15
Ordinary language	21.9	13	52	31	389.3	265	68	46
Moral conscience	10.8	17	26	40	144.9	232	25	41
Methodology of science	6.0	6	14	14	91.6	97	16	17
Heidegger and Husserl	4.3	6	10	14	54.2	70	9	12
Emotions	1.6	0	4	0	17.6	0	3	0
Ontological argument	3.8	3	9	7	47.8	37	8	6
Chemistry	3.4	2	8	5	42.6	17	7	3
Social contract theory	2.6	4	6	9	37.9	71	7	12
Kant	4.1	7	10	17	78.8	121	14	21
Promises and imperatives	7.0	2	16	5	99.3	44	17	8
Analytic/synthetic	2.2	3	5	7	30.5	32	5	6
Freedom and free will	4.3	3	10	7	48.8	63	9	11
Crime and punishment	6.5	10	15	24	131.0	233	23	41
Sets and grue	8.4	12	20	28	119.1	124	21	22
Origins and purposes	2.1	3	5	7	18.6	27	3	5
Time	5.0	6	12	14	43.1	37	8	6
Color/colour	3.5	4	8	9	41.8	37	7	6
War	13.0	18	31	42	227.2	316	40	55
Depiction	2.4	3	6	7	33.0	34	6	6
Denoting	6.5	7	15	17	94.2	118	16	21
Chance	5.9	3	14	7	83.6	58	15	10
Hume	2.6	2	6	5	31.2	17	5	3
Laws	2.8	1	6	2	33.3	9	6	2
Perception	3.5	2	8	5	47.6	31	8	5
Intention	3.6	5	9	12	36.9	30	6	5
Virtues	2.8	2	6	5	35.2	26	6	5
Space and time	3.5	3	8	7	36.4	36	6	6
Mathematics	5.0	8	12	19	87.2	188	15	33
Liberal democracy	2.7	3	6	7	48.3	54	8	9
Duties	8.9	13	21	31	103.3	143	18	25
Causation	7.9	8	19	19	86.5	85	15	15
Arguments	11.2	2	26	5	155.1	9	27	2
Theory testing	6.5	10	15	24	100.4	173	18	30
Decision theory	6.1	9	14	21	75.8	114	13	20
Minds and machines	4.6	5	11	12	60.8	68	11	12
Truth	7.1	3	17	7	73.8	46	13	8
Radical translation	6.1	4	14	9	70.9	56	12	10
Explanation	3.8	4	9	9	50.9	66	9	12
Personal identity	5.3	5	12	12	43.5	38	8	7
Speech acts	1.7	0	4	0	29.6	0	5	0
Sense and reference	8.1	12	19	28	94.1	171	16	30
Egalitarianism	6.3	6	15	14	90.5	55	16	10
Quantum physics	6.1	8	14	19	87.6	124	15	22
Theories and realism	9.0	9	21	21	121.4	134	21	23
Functions	1.2	0	3	0	16.5	0	3	0
Feminism	2.6	2	6	5	40.5	43	7	8
Medical ethics and Freud	3.1	4	7	9	34.2	36	6	6
Abortion and self-defence	7.7	7	18	17	71.8	55	13	10
Belief ascriptions	4.4	5	10	12	67.3	100	12	17
Thermodynamics	1.8	1	4	2	24.1	4	4	1
Knowledge	5.5	7	13	17	61.5	56	11	10
Game theory	2.0	3	5	7	24.5	45	4	8
Justification	6.4	5	15	12	83.9	31	15	5
Frankfurt cases	3.2	3	8	7	42.2	32	7	6
Concepts	5.5	4	13	9	86.1	48	15	8
Races and DNA	0.7	0	2	0	9.3	0	2	0
Modality	5.4	6	13	14	56.4	57	10	10
Reasons	6.0	1	14	2	86.5	8	15	1
Evolutionary biology	3.9	6	9	14	49.2	76	9	13
Population ethics	6.5	9	15	21	98.0	140	17	24
Formal epistemology	3.8	7	9	17	37.1	52	6	9
Wide content	3.0	5	7	12	51.4	117	9	20
Vagueness	5.1	9	12	21	41.7	63	7	11
Cognitive science	1.9	2	4	5	32.7	41	6	7
Models	2.7	0	6	0	47.8	0	8	0
Composition and constitution	4.3	3	10	7	57.1	35	10	6
Norms	5.4	4	13	9	94.8	58	17	10

1986

Table B.111: Measures of the prominence of each subject in 1986 ’s journals.

Subject	Weight	Raw	W-Ratio	R-Ratio	W-Pages	R-Pages	WP-Ratio	RP-Ratio
Psychology	2.2	2	6	5	26.2	16	5	3
Idealism	1.8	1	4	3	32.2	20	6	4
Life and value	2.2	1	6	3	38.3	16	7	3
Other history	2.9	2	7	5	41.4	23	8	4
Dewey and pragmatism	2.2	1	6	3	32.9	18	6	3
Definitions	4.2	1	10	3	54.9	20	10	4
Propositions and implications	5.0	5	12	13	51.8	41	10	8
Beauty	1.2	2	3	5	18.6	30	3	6
Physicalism	3.8	3	10	8	46.5	18	9	3
History and culture	1.6	1	4	3	22.8	24	4	4
Faith and theism	3.6	6	9	15	23.6	47	4	9
Self-consciousness	2.3	1	6	3	29.7	7	6	1
Ancient	1.8	2	5	5	29.0	46	5	9
Universals and particulars	2.6	1	7	3	38.4	13	7	2
Verification	3.1	1	8	3	30.9	3	6	1
Value	2.6	2	6	5	35.5	24	7	4
Deduction	5.5	5	14	13	51.3	48	10	9
Mechanisms	3.0	0	8	0	51.1	0	10	0
Temporal paradoxes	4.9	4	12	10	44.3	33	8	6
Classical space and time	4.0	1	10	3	65.2	7	12	1
Early modern	3.4	6	9	15	62.0	115	12	22
Meaning and use	4.5	6	11	15	67.2	91	13	17
Marx	6.9	11	17	28	112.5	164	21	31
Ordinary language	18.2	13	46	33	337.7	211	63	39
Moral conscience	7.7	8	19	20	97.0	72	18	13
Methodology of science	5.2	6	13	15	67.9	75	13	14
Heidegger and Husserl	1.6	4	4	10	26.8	68	5	13
Emotions	2.5	4	6	10	38.2	56	7	10
Ontological argument	3.7	2	9	5	40.6	17	8	3
Chemistry	3.4	4	8	10	42.2	48	8	9
Social contract theory	2.0	2	5	5	35.2	46	7	9
Kant	1.7	3	4	8	30.9	62	6	12
Promises and imperatives	5.8	2	15	5	80.0	29	15	5
Analytic/synthetic	1.3	1	3	3	16.5	5	3	1
Freedom and free will	3.4	3	9	8	58.0	62	11	12
Crime and punishment	5.5	8	14	20	87.6	119	16	22
Sets and grue	7.8	6	20	15	100.5	87	19	16
Origins and purposes	4.0	5	10	13	25.7	14	5	3
Time	4.7	6	12	15	43.6	55	8	10
Color/colour	4.1	5	10	13	49.5	81	9	15
War	2.1	1	5	3	32.6	16	6	3
Depiction	3.3	4	8	10	45.3	69	8	13
Denoting	4.5	5	11	13	38.5	42	7	8
Chance	5.3	6	13	15	70.0	70	13	13
Hume	3.2	4	8	10	30.3	28	6	5
Laws	4.2	3	11	8	41.4	15	8	3
Perception	5.7	9	14	23	75.3	124	14	23
Intention	2.6	2	7	5	26.9	11	5	2
Virtues	3.7	5	9	13	44.9	54	8	10
Space and time	6.6	7	17	18	54.8	60	10	11
Mathematics	3.7	3	9	8	48.0	56	9	10
Liberal democracy	4.2	4	11	10	65.7	57	12	11
Duties	6.0	10	15	25	96.5	175	18	33
Causation	8.2	8	21	20	105.1	95	20	18
Arguments	12.1	2	30	5	156.3	23	29	4
Theory testing	5.4	5	13	13	48.1	43	9	8
Decision theory	6.3	6	16	15	82.4	50	15	9
Minds and machines	4.0	5	10	13	62.7	108	12	20
Truth	8.7	9	22	23	83.3	76	16	14
Radical translation	4.8	5	12	13	66.1	62	12	12
Explanation	5.3	8	13	20	80.5	104	15	19
Personal identity	7.0	9	18	23	69.7	98	13	18
Speech acts	2.4	3	6	8	35.2	39	7	7
Sense and reference	4.0	4	10	10	64.9	108	12	20
Egalitarianism	6.1	5	15	13	104.5	93	20	17
Quantum physics	5.1	10	13	25	58.9	112	11	21
Theories and realism	7.5	5	19	13	100.2	77	19	14
Functions	2.8	2	7	5	33.9	35	6	7
Feminism	3.4	4	9	10	37.5	36	7	7
Medical ethics and Freud	2.4	3	6	8	41.2	67	8	13
Abortion and self-defence	3.6	5	9	13	45.0	57	8	11
Belief ascriptions	3.2	3	8	8	38.6	34	7	6
Thermodynamics	1.8	1	5	3	23.4	23	4	4
Knowledge	6.1	8	15	20	53.3	56	10	10
Game theory	2.7	3	7	8	48.4	64	9	12
Justification	8.1	8	20	20	112.5	109	21	20
Frankfurt cases	3.9	3	10	8	45.5	33	9	6
Concepts	5.1	2	13	5	63.5	3	12	1
Races and DNA	1.3	2	3	5	16.2	25	3	5
Modality	7.0	8	17	20	76.8	99	14	19
Reasons	7.4	10	19	25	125.9	198	24	37
Evolutionary biology	1.9	2	5	5	26.8	22	5	4
Population ethics	8.2	10	21	25	155.2	225	29	42
Formal epistemology	5.0	10	13	25	56.7	110	11	21
Wide content	3.2	2	8	5	70.4	92	13	17
Vagueness	5.0	6	12	15	52.0	78	10	15
Cognitive science	3.7	4	9	10	63.1	67	12	13
Models	2.3	1	6	3	36.3	20	7	4
Composition and constitution	5.4	4	14	10	69.0	41	13	8
Norms	4.6	3	12	8	83.4	57	16	11

1987

Table B.112: Measures of the prominence of each subject in 1987 ’s journals.

Subject	Weight	Raw	W-Ratio	R-Ratio	W-Pages	R-Pages	WP-Ratio	RP-Ratio
Psychology	0.7	0	2	0	12.2	0	2	0
Idealism	2.7	0	7	0	52.4	0	10	0
Life and value	3.0	0	8	0	48.4	0	9	0
Other history	3.5	2	9	5	49.1	42	9	8
Dewey and pragmatism	3.4	2	9	5	49.3	20	9	4
Definitions	3.5	2	9	5	37.4	8	7	2
Propositions and implications	2.8	1	7	3	30.9	6	6	1
Beauty	1.2	2	3	5	15.5	31	3	6
Physicalism	3.1	3	8	8	41.9	34	8	6
History and culture	0.7	0	2	0	12.4	0	2	0
Faith and theism	2.7	4	7	10	18.2	18	3	3
Self-consciousness	2.2	1	6	3	27.3	10	5	2
Ancient	1.2	1	3	3	17.1	8	3	2
Universals and particulars	2.1	1	6	3	34.6	5	7	1
Verification	2.9	2	8	5	31.2	17	6	3
Value	3.5	3	9	8	53.3	36	10	7
Deduction	3.4	0	9	0	40.1	0	8	0
Mechanisms	2.1	0	5	0	31.9	0	6	0
Temporal paradoxes	5.4	4	14	10	53.9	31	10	6
Classical space and time	4.5	4	12	10	73.7	67	14	13
Early modern	3.2	6	8	16	56.9	124	11	23
Meaning and use	3.8	4	10	10	55.3	66	10	12
Marx	5.4	9	14	23	90.5	155	17	29
Ordinary language	19.0	13	50	34	359.4	242	68	46
Moral conscience	6.0	7	16	18	78.1	84	15	16
Methodology of science	5.7	4	15	10	84.6	83	16	16
Heidegger and Husserl	3.7	6	10	16	70.9	128	13	24
Emotions	2.2	3	6	8	33.3	45	6	8
Ontological argument	3.1	1	8	3	34.7	4	7	1
Chemistry	3.4	5	9	13	57.4	69	11	13
Social contract theory	1.8	0	5	0	28.8	0	5	0
Kant	3.4	5	9	13	68.9	117	13	22
Promises and imperatives	3.2	1	8	3	40.1	4	8	1
Analytic/synthetic	2.3	3	6	8	36.7	53	7	10
Freedom and free will	3.4	5	9	13	50.4	82	10	15
Crime and punishment	4.3	7	11	18	52.7	92	10	17
Sets and grue	6.4	6	17	16	95.6	116	18	22
Origins and purposes	2.2	2	6	5	16.0	5	3	1
Time	5.3	7	14	18	53.9	62	10	12
Color/colour	3.4	6	9	16	44.6	82	8	15
War	1.2	0	3	0	17.0	0	3	0
Depiction	3.9	6	10	16	40.2	61	8	12
Denoting	4.6	6	12	16	48.8	76	9	14
Chance	6.1	5	16	13	84.6	68	16	13
Hume	2.5	5	7	13	39.6	84	7	16
Laws	4.5	6	12	16	48.7	53	9	10
Perception	4.9	3	13	8	78.4	38	15	7
Intention	2.7	3	7	8	21.3	17	4	3
Virtues	3.7	3	10	8	44.6	33	8	6
Space and time	3.5	5	9	13	49.8	102	9	19
Mathematics	5.0	7	13	18	55.4	68	10	13
Liberal democracy	5.0	7	13	18	90.0	145	17	27
Duties	6.4	10	17	26	72.2	112	14	21
Causation	8.6	10	22	26	89.5	88	17	17
Arguments	9.5	1	25	3	126.0	6	24	1
Theory testing	6.6	9	17	23	86.5	117	16	22
Decision theory	3.0	2	8	5	41.1	24	8	5
Minds and machines	4.1	1	11	3	61.0	18	12	3
Truth	9.3	7	24	18	84.4	60	16	11
Radical translation	7.2	9	19	23	93.5	145	18	27
Explanation	4.4	3	11	8	49.9	22	9	4
Personal identity	5.9	8	15	21	73.8	81	14	15
Speech acts	3.5	5	9	13	46.1	82	9	15
Sense and reference	6.3	9	16	23	74.2	103	14	19
Egalitarianism	8.9	12	23	31	159.7	222	30	42
Quantum physics	2.8	5	7	13	56.1	113	11	21
Theories and realism	7.8	6	20	16	98.9	62	19	12
Functions	1.6	1	4	3	27.0	16	5	3
Feminism	2.1	3	5	8	43.4	73	8	14
Medical ethics and Freud	1.5	2	4	5	22.9	34	4	6
Abortion and self-defence	2.9	3	8	8	40.8	55	8	10
Belief ascriptions	3.5	5	9	13	42.1	65	8	12
Thermodynamics	2.8	2	7	5	41.9	23	8	4
Knowledge	4.8	3	12	8	56.3	24	11	5
Game theory	2.7	2	7	5	37.3	23	7	4
Justification	7.9	9	21	23	103.4	104	20	20
Frankfurt cases	2.8	4	7	10	26.4	39	5	7
Concepts	5.7	2	15	5	88.9	11	17	2
Races and DNA	1.5	1	4	3	12.2	6	2	1
Modality	6.5	7	17	18	78.8	84	15	16
Reasons	7.2	9	19	23	105.3	141	20	27
Evolutionary biology	6.7	9	17	23	82.2	114	16	22
Population ethics	8.0	11	21	29	130.0	178	25	34
Formal epistemology	4.8	7	13	18	48.2	69	9	13
Wide content	4.3	8	11	21	78.1	150	15	28
Vagueness	4.0	3	10	8	34.2	15	6	3
Cognitive science	2.0	0	5	0	26.6	0	5	0
Models	2.7	1	7	3	46.7	20	9	4
Composition and constitution	6.4	7	17	18	86.2	108	16	20
Norms	3.6	0	9	0	67.7	0	13	0

1988

Table B.113: Measures of the prominence of each subject in 1988 ’s journals.

Subject	Weight	Raw	W-Ratio	R-Ratio	W-Pages	R-Pages	WP-Ratio	RP-Ratio
Psychology	0.8	0	2	0	15.2	0	3	0
Idealism	2.4	0	6	0	46.4	0	8	0
Life and value	4.1	0	10	0	63.6	0	12	0
Other history	3.3	1	8	3	54.1	14	10	3
Dewey and pragmatism	2.1	0	5	0	34.4	0	6	0
Definitions	3.2	1	8	3	51.6	25	9	5
Propositions and implications	3.3	2	8	5	33.7	20	6	4
Beauty	2.0	2	5	5	23.8	21	4	4
Physicalism	2.5	0	6	0	37.1	0	7	0
History and culture	1.5	2	4	5	30.9	64	6	12
Faith and theism	3.0	3	8	8	30.5	33	6	6
Self-consciousness	1.4	0	3	0	24.5	0	4	0
Ancient	2.6	2	6	5	46.3	40	8	7
Universals and particulars	3.0	1	8	3	40.4	21	7	4
Verification	2.8	2	7	5	26.8	5	5	1
Value	4.2	3	11	8	43.1	12	8	2
Deduction	4.2	1	11	3	58.6	23	11	4
Mechanisms	2.6	0	7	0	50.2	0	9	0
Temporal paradoxes	5.6	3	14	8	67.0	30	12	5
Classical space and time	3.6	4	9	10	51.6	58	9	11
Early modern	4.1	6	10	15	70.4	96	13	18
Meaning and use	2.8	0	7	0	43.2	0	8	0
Marx	3.8	4	10	10	58.7	83	11	15
Ordinary language	19.4	17	49	43	350.4	347	64	63
Moral conscience	9.1	15	23	38	124.9	196	23	36
Methodology of science	7.7	11	20	28	109.2	145	20	26
Heidegger and Husserl	2.5	5	6	13	32.0	73	6	13
Emotions	3.7	5	9	13	61.6	93	11	17
Ontological argument	6.2	7	16	18	62.3	80	11	15
Chemistry	4.4	6	11	15	62.7	86	11	16
Social contract theory	3.2	5	8	13	41.6	72	8	13
Kant	3.2	5	8	13	55.7	92	10	17
Promises and imperatives	4.8	2	12	5	74.4	43	14	8
Analytic/synthetic	2.1	0	5	0	27.7	0	5	0
Freedom and free will	3.2	1	8	3	42.0	16	8	3
Crime and punishment	3.6	8	9	20	70.6	166	13	30
Sets and grue	4.5	2	11	5	54.9	18	10	3
Origins and purposes	2.3	1	6	3	23.5	3	4	1
Time	4.7	6	12	15	47.8	53	9	10
Color/colour	3.2	6	8	15	36.4	83	7	15
War	3.4	4	9	10	57.4	75	10	14
Depiction	3.1	6	8	15	28.6	54	5	10
Denoting	4.0	6	10	15	56.6	78	10	14
Chance	6.9	8	17	20	73.5	77	13	14
Hume	2.9	3	7	8	42.7	54	8	10
Laws	3.6	3	9	8	40.5	36	7	7
Perception	4.9	5	12	13	66.8	37	12	7
Intention	3.6	7	9	18	43.3	96	8	18
Virtues	3.1	3	8	8	54.3	58	10	11
Space and time	4.7	7	12	18	54.2	83	10	15
Mathematics	6.1	9	15	23	55.1	90	10	16
Liberal democracy	6.8	9	17	23	109.0	122	20	22
Duties	5.4	7	14	18	82.8	124	15	23
Causation	5.8	5	15	13	79.1	74	14	14
Arguments	11.9	1	30	3	148.3	3	27	1
Theory testing	6.5	8	17	20	69.4	102	13	19
Decision theory	2.7	1	7	3	46.2	23	8	4
Minds and machines	4.6	4	12	10	67.2	34	12	6
Truth	6.5	7	17	18	59.5	30	11	5
Radical translation	5.6	7	14	18	87.4	114	16	21
Explanation	3.5	1	9	3	54.5	9	10	2
Personal identity	7.7	11	20	28	92.3	140	17	26
Speech acts	1.9	2	5	5	23.9	26	4	5
Sense and reference	4.7	4	12	10	72.5	56	13	10
Egalitarianism	3.2	4	8	10	48.9	56	9	10
Quantum physics	5.1	7	13	18	92.0	142	17	26
Theories and realism	8.4	4	21	10	111.8	40	20	7
Functions	1.2	0	3	0	18.2	0	3	0
Feminism	3.1	1	8	3	46.6	11	9	2
Medical ethics and Freud	1.1	0	3	0	17.1	0	3	0
Abortion and self-defence	4.6	6	12	15	71.4	105	13	19
Belief ascriptions	5.9	7	15	18	60.7	75	11	14
Thermodynamics	2.1	1	5	3	26.0	8	5	1
Knowledge	3.6	2	9	5	47.4	10	9	2
Game theory	4.0	7	10	18	34.4	60	6	11
Justification	12.0	19	30	48	132.1	215	24	39
Frankfurt cases	2.0	2	5	5	27.7	37	5	7
Concepts	6.1	5	16	13	98.0	86	18	16
Races and DNA	1.8	1	4	3	15.3	8	3	1
Modality	5.0	4	13	10	53.8	71	10	13
Reasons	6.6	7	17	18	104.2	114	19	21
Evolutionary biology	5.4	7	14	18	86.1	116	16	21
Population ethics	4.1	4	10	10	71.4	73	13	13
Formal epistemology	3.9	7	10	18	53.5	84	10	15
Wide content	5.1	7	13	18	71.2	75	13	14
Vagueness	4.1	7	10	18	39.5	61	7	11
Cognitive science	5.6	8	14	20	108.2	214	20	39
Models	1.6	1	4	3	23.0	22	4	4
Composition and constitution	6.1	7	16	18	81.3	65	15	12
Norms	5.5	2	14	5	95.5	26	17	5

1989

Table B.114: Measures of the prominence of each subject in 1989 ’s journals.

Subject	Weight	Raw	W-Ratio	R-Ratio	W-Pages	R-Pages	WP-Ratio	RP-Ratio
Psychology	1.1	1	3	3	22.6	36	4	6
Idealism	2.3	1	6	3	39.8	18	7	3
Life and value	3.9	1	10	3	77.0	49	13	8
Other history	3.6	3	9	8	64.8	58	11	10
Dewey and pragmatism	2.9	1	8	3	45.7	12	8	2
Definitions	3.2	1	8	3	51.7	14	9	2
Propositions and implications	3.8	2	10	5	35.5	4	6	1
Beauty	0.5	0	1	0	7.2	0	1	0
Physicalism	3.3	3	9	8	45.6	38	8	7
History and culture	1.1	0	3	0	14.8	0	3	0
Faith and theism	3.0	6	8	16	49.8	87	9	15
Self-consciousness	2.3	1	6	3	40.0	12	7	2
Ancient	0.5	0	1	0	7.7	0	1	0
Universals and particulars	3.2	2	8	5	49.7	37	9	6
Verification	2.2	1	6	3	33.5	12	6	2
Value	3.1	0	8	0	51.6	0	9	0
Deduction	4.8	2	12	5	53.8	40	9	7
Mechanisms	3.9	1	10	3	61.8	15	11	3
Temporal paradoxes	4.0	3	10	8	61.8	49	11	8
Classical space and time	2.8	3	7	8	34.9	30	6	5
Early modern	1.4	1	4	3	23.0	14	4	2
Meaning and use	3.3	4	9	10	60.1	85	10	15
Marx	4.6	6	12	16	79.2	128	14	22
Ordinary language	17.5	7	45	18	333.8	174	57	30
Moral conscience	4.9	4	13	10	81.3	57	14	10
Methodology of science	5.8	8	15	21	79.0	88	14	15
Heidegger and Husserl	1.2	2	3	5	22.7	41	4	7
Emotions	4.8	8	12	21	96.5	167	17	29
Ontological argument	2.7	1	7	3	36.9	4	6	1
Chemistry	2.7	2	7	5	53.0	49	9	8
Social contract theory	2.7	3	7	8	40.5	46	7	8
Kant	2.6	4	7	10	36.4	52	6	9
Promises and imperatives	3.4	1	9	3	52.5	10	9	2
Analytic/synthetic	1.3	1	3	3	22.0	20	4	3
Freedom and free will	3.3	4	8	10	49.2	45	8	8
Crime and punishment	2.4	5	6	13	35.5	78	6	13
Sets and grue	7.7	10	20	26	118.5	142	20	24
Origins and purposes	1.0	0	3	0	11.4	0	2	0
Time	4.3	5	11	13	45.7	52	8	9
Color/colour	5.4	5	14	13	47.2	38	8	7
War	3.4	3	9	8	45.9	37	8	6
Depiction	4.0	7	10	18	48.0	93	8	16
Denoting	3.2	4	8	10	49.1	65	8	11
Chance	6.7	8	17	21	90.1	88	15	15
Hume	1.9	1	5	3	25.9	17	4	3
Laws	3.9	2	10	5	45.1	9	8	2
Perception	4.6	3	12	8	60.2	29	10	5
Intention	2.0	2	5	5	35.9	35	6	6
Virtues	2.6	1	7	3	35.5	12	6	2
Space and time	5.9	9	15	23	75.5	149	13	26
Mathematics	3.7	5	9	13	42.8	36	7	6
Liberal democracy	8.3	12	22	31	185.0	289	32	50
Duties	5.7	7	15	18	82.6	94	14	16
Causation	5.0	6	13	16	73.8	76	13	13
Arguments	9.8	0	25	0	137.9	0	24	0
Theory testing	6.6	10	17	26	76.8	107	13	18
Decision theory	6.4	9	16	23	86.1	132	15	23
Minds and machines	6.1	7	16	18	83.1	99	14	17
Truth	8.3	11	21	28	92.2	101	16	17
Radical translation	5.0	3	13	8	85.2	68	15	12
Explanation	4.7	3	12	8	62.2	45	11	8
Personal identity	5.8	11	15	28	69.3	127	12	22
Speech acts	1.5	1	4	3	23.8	19	4	3
Sense and reference	4.0	4	10	10	55.3	49	9	8
Egalitarianism	8.6	13	22	34	159.0	236	27	40
Quantum physics	5.5	9	14	23	80.6	146	14	25
Theories and realism	6.7	3	17	8	107.6	51	18	9
Functions	2.5	3	7	8	33.1	34	6	6
Feminism	4.6	5	12	13	88.6	107	15	18
Medical ethics and Freud	2.2	2	6	5	51.2	58	9	10
Abortion and self-defence	6.3	11	16	28	99.5	174	17	30
Belief ascriptions	2.9	3	8	8	41.4	46	7	8
Thermodynamics	3.2	4	8	10	47.0	54	8	9
Knowledge	3.7	3	10	8	39.2	22	7	4
Game theory	3.4	4	9	10	35.4	33	6	6
Justification	8.6	7	22	18	112.2	88	19	15
Frankfurt cases	2.0	1	5	3	20.0	3	3	1
Concepts	4.3	3	11	8	74.3	33	13	6
Races and DNA	2.2	1	6	3	30.5	25	5	4
Modality	5.6	5	14	13	84.2	74	14	13
Reasons	7.9	11	20	28	134.4	149	23	26
Evolutionary biology	2.9	3	8	8	45.3	54	8	9
Population ethics	7.8	11	20	28	131.6	180	23	31
Formal epistemology	6.0	10	16	26	95.8	186	16	32
Wide content	5.7	9	15	23	89.8	139	15	24
Vagueness	7.0	10	18	26	79.9	109	14	19
Cognitive science	4.4	7	11	18	73.0	109	12	19
Models	2.3	1	6	3	37.2	20	6	3
Composition and constitution	6.2	3	16	8	81.5	24	14	4
Norms	5.6	2	15	5	124.3	107	21	18

1990

Table B.115: Measures of the prominence of each subject in 1990 ’s journals.

Subject	Weight	Raw	W-Ratio	R-Ratio	W-Pages	R-Pages	WP-Ratio	RP-Ratio
Psychology	1.2	0	3	0	16.7	0	3	0
Idealism	2.7	0	7	0	49.3	0	8	0
Life and value	3.5	2	9	5	63.1	34	11	6
Other history	3.5	1	9	3	59.2	25	10	4
Dewey and pragmatism	3.3	2	9	5	59.8	24	10	4
Definitions	2.5	1	7	3	43.3	18	7	3
Propositions and implications	2.5	0	7	0	34.6	0	6	0
Beauty	1.8	3	5	8	27.5	49	5	8
Physicalism	3.6	3	9	8	42.9	29	7	5
History and culture	1.2	1	3	3	16.6	9	3	2
Faith and theism	2.7	4	7	11	33.3	48	6	8
Self-consciousness	2.7	0	7	0	40.2	0	7	0
Ancient	2.1	4	6	11	34.0	63	6	11
Universals and particulars	3.3	3	9	8	57.0	47	10	8
Verification	2.2	1	6	3	29.3	23	5	4
Value	3.1	2	8	5	50.8	45	8	8
Deduction	4.3	2	11	5	55.3	34	9	6
Mechanisms	3.3	3	9	8	50.3	35	8	6
Temporal paradoxes	3.6	4	9	11	48.7	62	8	10
Classical space and time	2.2	2	6	5	30.8	29	5	5
Early modern	2.5	3	6	8	66.4	98	11	16
Meaning and use	3.0	1	8	3	53.7	21	9	4
Marx	4.2	6	11	16	74.8	123	13	21
Ordinary language	19.0	13	50	34	357.6	200	60	33
Moral conscience	6.3	7	17	19	107.5	140	18	23
Methodology of science	7.0	9	19	24	110.3	126	18	21
Heidegger and Husserl	4.5	6	12	16	74.5	98	12	16
Emotions	2.6	4	7	11	36.1	50	6	8
Ontological argument	3.4	4	9	11	51.7	70	9	12
Chemistry	4.2	5	11	13	70.0	101	12	17
Social contract theory	2.2	1	6	3	29.5	10	5	2
Kant	4.7	8	12	21	91.7	165	15	28
Promises and imperatives	3.3	0	9	0	54.6	0	9	0
Analytic/synthetic	1.9	0	5	0	31.2	0	5	0
Freedom and free will	4.5	6	12	16	54.7	62	9	10
Crime and punishment	1.9	2	5	5	29.1	24	5	4
Sets and grue	4.9	4	13	11	73.5	36	12	6
Origins and purposes	1.9	2	5	5	23.3	14	4	2
Time	3.4	3	9	8	49.3	45	8	8
Color/colour	2.3	3	6	8	35.2	67	6	11
War	3.0	4	8	11	50.7	67	8	11
Depiction	1.8	1	5	3	21.2	14	4	2
Denoting	3.0	3	8	8	48.6	47	8	8
Chance	4.7	10	12	26	50.3	105	8	18
Hume	3.2	4	9	11	54.9	73	9	12
Laws	2.4	1	6	3	44.0	35	7	6
Perception	5.5	7	15	19	90.6	121	15	20
Intention	4.3	6	11	16	39.9	50	7	8
Virtues	3.1	4	8	11	44.9	52	8	9
Space and time	3.7	6	10	16	59.6	97	10	16
Mathematics	4.6	8	12	21	79.9	160	13	27
Liberal democracy	7.2	13	19	34	155.3	299	26	50
Duties	3.7	6	10	16	63.2	105	11	18
Causation	6.8	8	18	21	86.1	98	14	16
Arguments	10.2	1	27	3	148.9	7	25	1
Theory testing	6.0	7	16	19	76.4	68	13	11
Decision theory	4.7	3	12	8	72.5	50	12	8
Minds and machines	5.4	4	14	11	68.6	45	11	8
Truth	7.4	9	20	24	92.3	131	15	22
Radical translation	5.2	6	14	16	82.2	79	14	13
Explanation	4.7	2	13	5	71.1	16	12	3
Personal identity	4.7	7	13	19	68.6	126	11	21
Speech acts	1.5	0	4	0	26.7	0	4	0
Sense and reference	6.1	10	16	26	125.3	225	21	38
Egalitarianism	8.5	10	23	26	191.1	223	32	37
Quantum physics	4.6	6	12	16	95.6	139	16	23
Theories and realism	7.1	2	19	5	115.6	40	19	7
Functions	2.2	0	6	0	29.8	0	5	0
Feminism	3.0	5	8	13	62.4	124	10	21
Medical ethics and Freud	2.3	2	6	5	37.8	28	6	5
Abortion and self-defence	3.0	3	8	8	29.8	22	5	4
Belief ascriptions	3.8	5	10	13	60.4	84	10	14
Thermodynamics	2.3	1	6	3	36.3	25	6	4
Knowledge	3.4	3	9	8	37.0	17	6	3
Game theory	5.0	8	13	21	82.3	134	14	22
Justification	9.0	8	24	21	132.4	129	22	22
Frankfurt cases	1.7	2	5	5	18.0	7	3	1
Concepts	4.4	1	12	3	85.7	12	14	2
Races and DNA	1.5	2	4	5	18.0	22	3	4
Modality	7.2	10	19	26	85.5	92	14	15
Reasons	9.3	9	25	24	160.7	164	27	27
Evolutionary biology	6.2	7	16	19	77.2	83	13	14
Population ethics	4.8	5	13	13	81.7	88	14	15
Formal epistemology	3.2	4	9	11	35.9	41	6	7
Wide content	6.7	8	18	21	82.0	75	14	13
Vagueness	4.3	8	11	21	52.3	95	9	16
Cognitive science	4.5	7	12	19	69.3	108	12	18
Models	2.0	1	5	3	38.9	22	7	4
Composition and constitution	6.1	3	16	8	91.8	36	15	6
Norms	6.2	3	16	8	131.2	74	22	12

1991

Table B.116: Measures of the prominence of each subject in 1991 ’s journals.

Subject	Weight	Raw	W-Ratio	R-Ratio	W-Pages	R-Pages	WP-Ratio	RP-Ratio
Psychology	0.6	0	2	0	8.2	0	1	0
Idealism	2.8	1	7	3	52.4	18	9	3
Life and value	2.6	0	7	0	44.2	0	8	0
Other history	3.5	3	10	8	44.3	31	8	6
Dewey and pragmatism	2.4	0	6	0	36.0	0	6	0
Definitions	2.5	0	7	0	40.9	0	7	0
Propositions and implications	3.0	0	8	0	33.3	0	6	0
Beauty	2.4	4	6	11	38.7	57	7	10
Physicalism	4.4	5	12	13	44.0	29	8	5
History and culture	3.3	5	9	13	22.4	18	4	3
Faith and theism	1.8	1	5	3	20.9	24	4	4
Self-consciousness	2.0	2	5	5	30.4	31	5	6
Ancient	1.9	3	5	8	40.0	77	7	14
Universals and particulars	4.0	3	11	8	55.2	46	10	8
Verification	2.7	0	7	0	35.9	0	6	0
Value	3.7	3	10	8	55.3	61	10	11
Deduction	3.6	3	10	8	56.9	47	10	8
Mechanisms	3.0	2	8	5	47.5	21	9	4
Temporal paradoxes	2.4	2	6	5	34.2	30	6	5
Classical space and time	3.2	2	9	5	43.5	26	8	5
Early modern	1.8	1	5	3	24.3	14	4	3
Meaning and use	3.2	3	9	8	52.0	51	9	9
Marx	4.0	4	11	11	44.7	33	8	6
Ordinary language	18.8	12	51	32	355.8	238	64	43
Moral conscience	7.5	10	20	27	97.1	101	17	18
Methodology of science	5.5	3	15	8	86.1	53	15	10
Heidegger and Husserl	1.1	1	3	3	19.6	23	4	4
Emotions	1.8	2	5	5	29.0	27	5	5
Ontological argument	1.9	0	5	0	27.8	0	5	0
Chemistry	2.1	1	6	3	33.3	13	6	2
Social contract theory	2.7	2	7	5	38.3	14	7	3
Kant	1.5	2	4	5	21.6	26	4	5
Promises and imperatives	4.4	2	12	5	74.0	48	13	9
Analytic/synthetic	1.9	0	5	0	31.7	0	6	0
Freedom and free will	3.5	7	9	19	44.9	77	8	14
Crime and punishment	2.0	5	5	13	39.5	97	7	17
Sets and grue	6.2	5	17	13	97.1	62	17	11
Origins and purposes	1.9	0	5	0	22.4	0	4	0
Time	3.7	4	10	11	46.9	63	8	11
Color/colour	2.8	4	8	11	42.1	94	8	17
War	3.2	2	9	5	46.0	28	8	5
Depiction	3.0	4	8	11	43.5	63	8	11
Denoting	1.9	3	5	8	34.0	79	6	14
Chance	5.4	7	15	19	76.9	124	14	22
Hume	4.0	5	11	13	54.7	87	10	16
Laws	4.6	5	12	13	49.1	44	9	8
Perception	3.9	3	11	8	57.3	39	10	7
Intention	4.8	7	13	19	64.7	111	12	20
Virtues	2.1	1	6	3	32.6	19	6	3
Space and time	3.5	7	10	19	71.3	127	13	23
Mathematics	2.2	2	6	5	34.6	24	6	4
Liberal democracy	6.3	10	17	27	105.8	172	19	31
Duties	2.8	1	7	3	46.5	17	8	3
Causation	6.4	6	17	16	87.8	75	16	13
Arguments	11.3	2	30	5	160.4	23	29	4
Theory testing	5.9	7	16	19	93.3	109	17	20
Decision theory	3.6	4	10	11	57.9	43	10	8
Minds and machines	3.5	3	9	8	57.0	48	10	9
Truth	5.9	4	16	11	74.8	50	13	9
Radical translation	5.7	7	15	19	95.3	150	17	27
Explanation	2.9	2	8	5	46.0	29	8	5
Personal identity	4.0	5	11	13	50.2	50	9	9
Speech acts	4.2	6	11	16	52.9	74	10	13
Sense and reference	5.2	6	14	16	85.9	103	15	19
Egalitarianism	3.8	3	10	8	80.6	70	14	13
Quantum physics	6.7	9	18	24	130.3	188	23	34
Theories and realism	8.3	7	22	19	122.8	115	22	21
Functions	1.3	1	4	3	23.3	17	4	3
Feminism	4.3	4	12	11	46.8	25	8	4
Medical ethics and Freud	2.1	2	6	5	36.8	49	7	9
Abortion and self-defence	3.2	4	9	11	59.0	79	11	14
Belief ascriptions	2.6	2	7	5	27.8	10	5	2
Thermodynamics	3.2	4	9	11	55.4	70	10	13
Knowledge	3.9	7	11	19	55.1	100	10	18
Game theory	3.7	3	10	8	52.5	31	9	6
Justification	12.1	16	32	43	139.5	158	25	28
Frankfurt cases	2.6	2	7	5	33.8	24	6	4
Concepts	6.0	4	16	11	94.6	55	17	10
Races and DNA	1.7	4	5	11	22.0	54	4	10
Modality	7.8	10	21	27	89.1	96	16	17
Reasons	8.4	13	23	35	122.8	197	22	35
Evolutionary biology	4.6	6	12	16	74.6	99	13	18
Population ethics	8.8	11	24	30	138.8	199	25	36
Formal epistemology	5.9	8	16	22	77.8	118	14	21
Wide content	7.1	11	19	30	118.9	204	21	37
Vagueness	3.7	4	10	11	55.7	70	10	13
Cognitive science	4.6	9	12	24	69.8	147	13	26
Models	2.5	1	7	3	38.9	5	7	1
Composition and constitution	8.0	11	21	30	112.7	141	20	25
Norms	4.7	0	13	0	88.9	0	16	0

1992

Table B.117: Measures of the prominence of each subject in 1992 ’s journals.

Subject	Weight	Raw	W-Ratio	R-Ratio	W-Pages	R-Pages	WP-Ratio	RP-Ratio
Psychology	0.5	0	1	0	8.6	0	1	0
Idealism	2.8	2	8	6	53.9	27	9	4
Life and value	2.9	0	8	0	52.9	0	9	0
Other history	2.7	4	8	11	71.2	162	12	27
Dewey and pragmatism	3.0	1	8	3	54.5	21	9	3
Definitions	2.9	0	8	0	46.3	0	8	0
Propositions and implications	3.0	0	8	0	42.5	0	7	0
Beauty	0.5	1	1	3	7.3	14	1	2
Physicalism	3.4	0	10	0	55.5	0	9	0
History and culture	1.2	2	3	6	31.2	57	5	9
Faith and theism	1.3	2	4	6	27.2	42	4	7
Self-consciousness	2.1	1	6	3	32.7	18	5	3
Ancient	1.3	2	4	6	31.2	48	5	8
Universals and particulars	2.6	3	7	8	34.5	33	6	5
Verification	1.7	0	5	0	25.9	0	4	0
Value	3.3	1	9	3	63.0	37	10	6
Deduction	2.7	0	8	0	45.5	0	8	0
Mechanisms	2.8	0	8	0	50.4	0	8	0
Temporal paradoxes	3.5	1	10	3	43.0	6	7	1
Classical space and time	1.9	0	5	0	36.1	0	6	0
Early modern	3.2	5	9	14	88.0	132	15	22
Meaning and use	3.0	3	8	8	51.5	39	9	6
Marx	3.0	2	8	6	68.8	47	11	8
Ordinary language	17.1	8	47	22	340.7	135	56	22
Moral conscience	5.9	9	16	25	94.9	125	16	21
Methodology of science	6.8	8	19	22	103.9	144	17	24
Heidegger and Husserl	1.5	2	4	6	35.6	48	6	8
Emotions	3.1	4	9	11	47.6	66	8	11
Ontological argument	2.7	2	8	6	41.2	30	7	5
Chemistry	3.7	3	10	8	75.4	53	12	9
Social contract theory	1.2	0	3	0	20.1	0	3	0
Kant	2.1	3	6	8	42.8	60	7	10
Promises and imperatives	3.0	1	8	3	46.1	4	8	1
Analytic/synthetic	2.6	1	7	3	52.7	31	9	5
Freedom and free will	2.6	2	7	6	47.4	41	8	7
Crime and punishment	3.0	4	8	11	53.8	69	9	11
Sets and grue	4.3	5	12	14	72.3	86	12	14
Origins and purposes	2.9	3	8	8	39.0	63	6	10
Time	3.7	4	10	11	49.3	44	8	7
Color/colour	3.3	3	9	8	57.2	54	9	9
War	1.5	1	4	3	21.7	10	4	2
Depiction	1.1	0	3	0	16.3	0	3	0
Denoting	3.9	7	11	19	75.8	132	13	22
Chance	6.8	8	19	22	99.9	101	17	17
Hume	1.5	1	4	3	25.8	26	4	4
Laws	4.7	7	13	19	82.0	129	14	21
Perception	5.2	7	15	19	88.5	132	15	22
Intention	3.4	3	10	8	50.2	49	8	8
Virtues	3.7	3	10	8	58.2	41	10	7
Space and time	2.6	3	7	8	35.4	31	6	5
Mathematics	5.0	8	14	22	89.1	156	15	26
Liberal democracy	5.4	7	15	19	138.2	179	23	30
Duties	1.9	1	5	3	36.9	17	6	3
Causation	7.6	10	21	28	125.5	167	21	28
Arguments	9.9	1	27	3	150.5	6	25	1
Theory testing	3.4	3	9	8	57.1	68	9	11
Decision theory	3.8	3	10	8	67.0	65	11	11
Minds and machines	5.3	6	15	17	72.8	66	12	11
Truth	5.5	4	15	11	83.6	63	14	10
Radical translation	5.0	7	14	19	96.5	133	16	22
Explanation	4.9	5	13	14	89.5	87	15	14
Personal identity	6.5	11	18	30	67.8	103	11	17
Speech acts	2.6	2	7	6	34.3	27	6	4
Sense and reference	4.5	4	13	11	80.6	69	13	11
Egalitarianism	8.1	11	23	30	171.4	227	28	38
Quantum physics	5.2	8	14	22	105.4	170	17	28
Theories and realism	7.7	8	21	22	125.9	153	21	25
Functions	2.1	1	6	3	37.5	20	6	3
Feminism	3.5	4	10	11	71.1	105	12	17
Medical ethics and Freud	1.1	2	3	6	20.3	37	3	6
Abortion and self-defence	3.3	5	9	14	35.2	44	6	7
Belief ascriptions	4.0	7	11	19	46.6	82	8	14
Thermodynamics	2.3	3	6	8	39.9	57	7	9
Knowledge	6.0	8	17	22	77.0	96	13	16
Game theory	1.1	1	3	3	17.0	12	3	2
Justification	10.5	15	29	42	149.6	213	25	35
Frankfurt cases	1.7	2	5	6	21.1	19	3	3
Concepts	5.9	5	16	14	108.0	90	18	15
Races and DNA	1.4	1	4	3	14.1	6	2	1
Modality	4.9	1	14	3	63.0	2	10	0
Reasons	6.8	4	19	11	102.0	71	17	12
Evolutionary biology	4.5	5	13	14	52.0	51	9	8
Population ethics	6.7	10	18	28	92.4	117	15	19
Formal epistemology	5.1	8	14	22	63.1	93	10	15
Wide content	8.7	14	24	39	117.6	180	19	30
Vagueness	3.7	5	10	14	66.0	98	11	16
Cognitive science	5.3	9	15	25	89.1	154	15	25
Models	2.5	0	7	0	46.4	0	8	0
Composition and constitution	8.5	9	24	25	144.6	154	24	25
Norms	9.9	11	27	30	190.6	208	31	34

1993

Table B.118: Measures of the prominence of each subject in 1993 ’s journals.

Subject	Weight	Raw	W-Ratio	R-Ratio	W-Pages	R-Pages	WP-Ratio	RP-Ratio
Psychology	0.9	1	2	3	18.2	23	3	4
Idealism	1.9	0	5	0	29.6	0	5	0
Life and value	3.5	3	9	8	56.5	60	10	11
Other history	5.1	4	14	11	59.8	28	11	5
Dewey and pragmatism	2.1	1	5	3	39.1	20	7	4
Definitions	2.7	0	7	0	40.8	0	7	0
Propositions and implications	3.0	0	8	0	43.2	0	8	0
Beauty	1.5	2	4	5	18.6	27	3	5
Physicalism	4.5	6	12	16	53.1	74	9	13
History and culture	1.3	1	3	3	16.2	16	3	3
Faith and theism	2.0	3	5	8	28.6	39	5	7
Self-consciousness	2.6	1	7	3	35.0	21	6	4
Ancient	1.7	1	5	3	35.4	27	6	5
Universals and particulars	2.9	3	8	8	39.8	33	7	6
Verification	2.2	2	6	5	32.5	33	6	6
Value	2.8	1	7	3	45.6	15	8	3
Deduction	3.4	2	9	5	43.5	27	8	5
Mechanisms	3.0	0	8	0	46.6	0	8	0
Temporal paradoxes	3.1	3	8	8	42.2	49	7	9
Classical space and time	2.0	0	5	0	33.4	0	6	0
Early modern	4.3	6	11	16	90.0	132	16	23
Meaning and use	2.7	0	7	0	41.5	0	7	0
Marx	1.9	0	5	0	31.8	0	6	0
Ordinary language	18.3	8	48	21	332.4	171	59	30
Moral conscience	4.4	7	12	19	77.5	128	14	23
Methodology of science	6.5	7	17	19	91.4	80	16	14
Heidegger and Husserl	1.3	2	3	5	30.3	56	5	10
Emotions	1.7	2	5	5	24.6	26	4	5
Ontological argument	5.3	4	14	11	60.8	37	11	7
Chemistry	3.4	4	9	11	49.4	55	9	10
Social contract theory	1.8	2	5	5	38.2	55	7	10
Kant	1.9	2	5	5	29.5	19	5	3
Promises and imperatives	3.4	1	9	3	66.2	23	12	4
Analytic/synthetic	2.1	0	5	0	31.7	0	6	0
Freedom and free will	2.5	4	7	11	41.2	67	7	12
Crime and punishment	2.0	4	5	11	47.6	103	8	18
Sets and grue	7.2	8	19	21	105.3	129	19	23
Origins and purposes	1.9	2	5	5	21.6	22	4	4
Time	3.6	2	10	5	31.0	11	6	2
Color/colour	3.0	5	8	13	50.5	65	9	12
War	0.9	0	2	0	14.6	0	3	0
Depiction	3.1	4	8	11	42.8	55	8	10
Denoting	3.6	4	10	11	51.6	52	9	9
Chance	5.1	5	14	13	65.0	61	12	11
Hume	2.4	4	6	11	40.2	71	7	13
Laws	4.7	3	12	8	53.7	34	10	6
Perception	4.5	4	12	11	77.6	73	14	13
Intention	4.2	4	11	11	42.1	30	7	5
Virtues	3.1	3	8	8	33.9	21	6	4
Space and time	5.0	9	13	24	85.3	154	15	27
Mathematics	7.1	12	19	32	107.1	194	19	34
Liberal democracy	3.2	4	9	11	89.5	133	16	24
Duties	4.5	6	12	16	70.4	111	12	20
Causation	7.7	11	21	29	103.6	122	18	22
Arguments	11.1	0	30	0	156.4	0	28	0
Theory testing	5.6	4	15	11	81.4	66	14	12
Decision theory	2.8	1	7	3	45.8	16	8	3
Minds and machines	4.4	3	12	8	59.1	37	10	7
Truth	6.4	5	17	13	81.0	64	14	11
Radical translation	6.7	11	18	29	101.9	145	18	26
Explanation	5.2	3	14	8	76.2	39	14	7
Personal identity	5.9	9	16	24	74.5	105	13	19
Speech acts	3.5	4	9	11	61.2	65	11	12
Sense and reference	4.7	5	12	13	67.8	100	12	18
Egalitarianism	2.6	3	7	8	46.4	38	8	7
Quantum physics	5.5	8	15	21	84.1	122	15	22
Theories and realism	10.6	13	28	34	137.5	184	24	33
Functions	2.7	2	7	5	41.2	25	7	4
Feminism	2.8	3	7	8	51.3	59	9	10
Medical ethics and Freud	1.4	1	4	3	20.4	14	4	2
Abortion and self-defence	6.4	8	17	21	84.4	109	15	19
Belief ascriptions	5.5	6	15	16	44.5	33	8	6
Thermodynamics	4.0	4	11	11	65.6	78	12	14
Knowledge	4.1	4	11	11	51.8	43	9	8
Game theory	5.1	7	13	19	65.0	111	12	20
Justification	6.6	8	18	21	109.1	136	19	24
Frankfurt cases	2.7	5	7	13	30.2	48	5	9
Concepts	4.9	2	13	5	80.7	55	14	10
Races and DNA	1.5	1	4	3	19.4	4	3	1
Modality	8.2	8	22	21	101.9	92	18	16
Reasons	5.7	7	15	19	95.5	103	17	18
Evolutionary biology	4.5	6	12	16	78.7	117	14	21
Population ethics	3.7	5	10	13	81.9	102	15	18
Formal epistemology	4.4	8	12	21	46.5	83	8	15
Wide content	7.7	12	21	32	107.0	154	19	27
Vagueness	4.6	4	12	11	63.5	58	11	10
Cognitive science	8.4	15	22	40	138.8	246	25	44
Models	3.0	2	8	5	45.7	34	8	6
Composition and constitution	7.9	9	21	24	105.1	105	19	19
Norms	5.5	4	15	11	107.0	64	19	11

1994

Table B.119: Measures of the prominence of each subject in 1994 ’s journals.

Subject	Weight	Raw	W-Ratio	R-Ratio	W-Pages	R-Pages	WP-Ratio	RP-Ratio
Psychology	0.6	0	2	0	9.9	0	2	0
Idealism	2.4	2	7	5	46.5	20	7	3
Life and value	2.1	0	6	0	37.8	0	6	0
Other history	2.1	1	6	3	46.5	18	7	3
Dewey and pragmatism	1.8	0	5	0	33.1	0	5	0
Definitions	2.4	0	7	0	44.7	0	7	0
Propositions and implications	2.2	1	6	3	37.8	4	6	1
Beauty	0.3	0	1	0	8.5	0	1	0
Physicalism	2.9	1	8	3	46.7	21	8	3
History and culture	1.5	2	4	5	28.8	37	5	6
Faith and theism	1.3	3	4	8	16.0	27	3	4
Self-consciousness	3.0	2	8	5	44.8	25	7	4
Ancient	1.6	2	4	5	31.6	35	5	6
Universals and particulars	3.0	2	8	5	45.8	36	7	6
Verification	1.4	0	4	0	21.8	0	4	0
Value	2.4	1	7	3	34.7	2	6	0
Deduction	3.7	2	10	5	43.0	13	7	2
Mechanisms	2.9	0	8	0	52.0	0	8	0
Temporal paradoxes	3.6	1	10	3	49.5	6	8	1
Classical space and time	3.1	3	9	8	58.0	65	9	10
Early modern	1.9	2	5	5	51.4	72	8	12
Meaning and use	3.5	5	10	14	81.1	118	13	19
Marx	2.0	1	5	3	39.6	29	6	5
Ordinary language	18.8	13	52	36	384.9	309	62	50
Moral conscience	4.6	3	13	8	77.3	39	12	6
Methodology of science	5.2	7	14	19	92.6	119	15	19
Heidegger and Husserl	1.1	1	3	3	27.9	36	4	6
Emotions	1.8	3	5	8	38.2	63	6	10
Ontological argument	3.2	3	9	8	50.8	48	8	8
Chemistry	3.2	3	9	8	62.5	69	10	11
Social contract theory	1.9	2	5	5	34.2	48	6	8
Kant	2.0	3	5	8	40.5	70	7	11
Promises and imperatives	3.7	2	10	5	55.8	24	9	4
Analytic/synthetic	1.2	1	3	3	20.3	17	3	3
Freedom and free will	2.6	2	7	5	48.7	28	8	4
Crime and punishment	3.8	4	10	11	47.8	24	8	4
Sets and grue	5.6	6	15	16	92.0	107	15	17
Origins and purposes	1.5	2	4	5	24.2	34	4	5
Time	2.8	2	8	5	39.4	31	6	5
Color/colour	3.9	6	11	16	69.0	111	11	18
War	2.1	1	6	3	32.3	16	5	3
Depiction	2.0	1	5	3	35.7	18	6	3
Denoting	3.5	5	10	14	75.6	110	12	18
Chance	7.7	10	21	27	106.6	111	17	18
Hume	1.4	1	4	3	19.7	4	3	1
Laws	2.1	1	6	3	32.1	22	5	4
Perception	6.2	9	17	25	101.1	128	16	21
Intention	2.6	2	7	5	54.9	51	9	8
Virtues	1.4	1	4	3	23.2	20	4	3
Space and time	4.9	6	14	16	83.6	111	13	18
Mathematics	4.0	5	11	14	53.0	67	9	11
Liberal democracy	11.5	17	32	47	235.8	342	38	55
Duties	4.3	3	12	8	80.9	60	13	10
Causation	6.7	6	18	16	106.5	104	17	17
Arguments	9.5	2	26	5	156.9	47	25	8
Theory testing	5.0	7	14	19	80.1	121	13	19
Decision theory	4.3	4	12	11	55.8	32	9	5
Minds and machines	5.2	7	14	19	90.7	148	15	24
Truth	7.6	10	21	27	103.9	163	17	26
Radical translation	5.3	7	15	19	90.7	152	15	24
Explanation	4.9	6	14	16	74.0	64	12	10
Personal identity	3.6	4	10	11	61.2	71	10	11
Speech acts	2.1	0	6	0	32.9	0	5	0
Sense and reference	3.5	4	10	11	70.8	60	11	10
Egalitarianism	5.6	7	15	19	131.5	180	21	29
Quantum physics	7.3	12	20	33	114.2	202	18	32
Theories and realism	6.9	5	19	14	115.5	89	19	14
Functions	3.5	4	10	11	49.8	56	8	9
Feminism	3.3	3	9	8	58.6	45	9	7
Medical ethics and Freud	2.7	3	7	8	41.8	45	7	7
Abortion and self-defence	2.6	4	7	11	58.4	102	9	16
Belief ascriptions	1.7	1	5	3	30.2	46	5	7
Thermodynamics	3.2	2	9	5	38.6	16	6	3
Knowledge	4.6	3	13	8	65.4	19	11	3
Game theory	2.7	4	7	11	41.4	58	7	9
Justification	9.1	12	25	33	132.4	181	21	29
Frankfurt cases	4.0	4	11	11	54.3	49	9	8
Concepts	5.1	4	14	11	110.5	84	18	13
Races and DNA	2.0	2	6	5	38.3	39	6	6
Modality	6.8	8	19	22	86.6	93	14	15
Reasons	5.3	5	15	14	96.4	95	15	15
Evolutionary biology	7.7	10	21	27	139.6	181	22	29
Population ethics	6.6	9	18	25	122.2	169	20	27
Formal epistemology	3.3	6	9	16	45.6	83	7	13
Wide content	7.3	9	20	25	120.6	146	19	23
Vagueness	5.9	6	16	16	65.3	41	10	7
Cognitive science	7.1	12	19	33	121.8	189	20	30
Models	4.3	5	12	14	83.7	94	13	15
Composition and constitution	7.7	7	21	19	131.0	109	21	18
Norms	7.6	4	21	11	155.3	85	25	14

1995

Table B.120: Measures of the prominence of each subject in 1995 ’s journals.

Subject	Weight	Raw	W-Ratio	R-Ratio	W-Pages	R-Pages	WP-Ratio	RP-Ratio
Psychology	0.6	0	2	0	9.1	0	2	0
Idealism	1.9	0	5	0	36.4	0	6	0
Life and value	2.8	1	8	3	52.4	2	9	0
Other history	1.9	0	6	0	38.9	0	7	0
Dewey and pragmatism	2.0	0	6	0	43.2	0	7	0
Definitions	2.3	1	7	3	45.3	21	8	4
Propositions and implications	3.0	1	9	3	51.1	27	9	5
Beauty	1.0	1	3	3	17.9	18	3	3
Physicalism	3.5	6	10	17	46.5	67	8	11
History and culture	0.7	1	2	3	16.7	30	3	5
Faith and theism	1.1	0	3	0	17.8	0	3	0
Self-consciousness	2.6	2	8	6	49.1	33	8	6
Ancient	2.4	5	7	15	33.6	66	6	11
Universals and particulars	2.7	1	8	3	42.2	16	7	3
Verification	1.9	0	5	0	25.0	0	4	0
Value	3.4	4	10	12	64.4	99	11	17
Deduction	4.4	4	13	12	57.5	35	10	6
Mechanisms	3.3	2	10	6	63.7	40	11	7
Temporal paradoxes	3.3	4	10	12	41.5	39	7	7
Classical space and time	2.0	0	6	0	30.1	0	5	0
Early modern	1.5	3	4	9	27.3	63	5	11
Meaning and use	2.0	1	6	3	35.7	9	6	2
Marx	1.8	1	5	3	34.8	31	6	5
Ordinary language	17.9	13	52	38	368.2	223	62	38
Moral conscience	5.5	7	16	20	90.0	91	15	15
Methodology of science	3.3	2	10	6	62.1	37	10	6
Heidegger and Husserl	0.4	0	1	0	9.0	0	2	0
Emotions	2.3	4	7	12	36.5	57	6	10
Ontological argument	2.5	2	7	6	37.2	30	6	5
Chemistry	2.6	0	8	0	49.3	0	8	0
Social contract theory	1.4	1	4	3	30.7	28	5	5
Kant	2.9	6	8	17	61.8	126	10	21
Promises and imperatives	3.2	1	9	3	54.3	23	9	4
Analytic/synthetic	2.2	0	7	0	42.7	0	7	0
Freedom and free will	2.8	2	8	6	56.1	47	9	8
Crime and punishment	2.5	4	7	12	35.4	43	6	7
Sets and grue	5.5	3	16	9	94.1	42	16	7
Origins and purposes	2.1	0	6	0	31.6	0	5	0
Time	1.9	0	5	0	25.9	0	4	0
Color/colour	1.1	2	3	6	15.2	22	3	4
War	1.0	0	3	0	17.0	0	3	0
Depiction	2.2	3	6	9	41.8	52	7	9
Denoting	4.7	6	14	17	94.6	151	16	25
Chance	5.6	7	16	20	74.9	97	13	16
Hume	1.5	1	4	3	18.3	31	3	5
Laws	3.1	4	9	12	55.1	70	9	12
Perception	3.2	2	9	6	45.7	11	8	2
Intention	2.5	3	7	9	50.0	78	8	13
Virtues	2.2	3	7	9	40.4	45	7	8
Space and time	4.7	7	14	20	62.1	81	10	14
Mathematics	3.1	5	9	15	50.5	119	9	20
Liberal democracy	10.6	16	31	47	276.5	413	47	70
Duties	2.2	1	6	3	42.7	9	7	2
Causation	4.1	5	12	15	68.3	75	12	13
Arguments	9.9	1	29	3	154.1	3	26	1
Theory testing	5.8	7	17	20	82.2	106	14	18
Decision theory	3.5	3	10	9	51.4	44	9	7
Minds and machines	3.3	3	10	9	49.4	34	8	6
Truth	7.9	8	23	23	96.0	90	16	15
Radical translation	5.7	6	17	17	91.3	129	15	22
Explanation	4.9	4	14	12	85.6	66	14	11
Personal identity	5.0	8	14	23	59.1	64	10	11
Speech acts	3.7	4	11	12	58.5	61	10	10
Sense and reference	6.3	8	18	23	106.1	142	18	24
Egalitarianism	4.7	4	14	12	98.2	91	17	15
Quantum physics	8.1	11	24	32	140.4	205	24	35
Theories and realism	7.0	7	20	20	114.0	109	19	18
Functions	2.7	2	8	6	42.5	22	7	4
Feminism	3.6	4	11	12	74.3	92	13	16
Medical ethics and Freud	3.1	5	9	15	39.9	57	7	10
Abortion and self-defence	2.2	2	6	6	36.9	29	6	5
Belief ascriptions	5.3	7	16	20	87.1	123	15	21
Thermodynamics	2.4	2	7	6	37.6	26	6	4
Knowledge	5.8	9	17	26	112.5	188	19	32
Game theory	1.5	1	4	3	28.4	9	5	2
Justification	8.0	9	23	26	129.3	164	22	28
Frankfurt cases	3.0	5	9	15	43.4	82	7	14
Concepts	4.8	2	14	6	89.3	32	15	5
Races and DNA	1.2	1	4	3	22.8	21	4	4
Modality	7.3	6	21	17	96.1	49	16	8
Reasons	7.3	8	21	23	146.4	179	25	30
Evolutionary biology	5.9	8	17	23	99.8	144	17	24
Population ethics	4.8	7	14	20	98.3	154	17	26
Formal epistemology	3.5	6	10	17	90.0	192	15	32
Wide content	6.8	9	20	26	90.1	106	15	18
Vagueness	3.9	5	11	15	49.8	71	8	12
Cognitive science	4.9	11	14	32	109.4	246	18	41
Models	3.1	3	9	9	48.7	37	8	6
Composition and constitution	8.0	9	23	26	127.5	160	21	27
Norms	6.0	1	17	3	126.4	7	21	1

1996

Table B.121: Measures of the prominence of each subject in 1996 ’s journals.

Subject	Weight	Raw	W-Ratio	R-Ratio	W-Pages	R-Pages	WP-Ratio	RP-Ratio
Psychology	0.8	0	2	0	14.5	0	2	0
Idealism	2.1	1	5	3	41.2	14	7	2
Life and value	2.0	1	5	3	41.6	20	7	3
Other history	2.8	2	7	5	45.7	34	7	5
Dewey and pragmatism	2.3	1	6	3	41.7	14	7	2
Definitions	3.2	1	8	3	59.1	20	10	3
Propositions and implications	2.4	0	6	0	39.3	0	6	0
Beauty	1.8	3	5	8	34.4	63	6	10
Physicalism	4.2	3	11	8	51.5	15	8	2
History and culture	2.4	3	6	8	44.0	72	7	12
Faith and theism	0.6	0	2	0	9.0	0	1	0
Self-consciousness	3.1	1	8	3	56.9	20	9	3
Ancient	1.1	3	3	8	27.2	79	4	13
Universals and particulars	1.9	0	5	0	42.6	0	7	0
Verification	1.3	0	3	0	23.0	0	4	0
Value	3.4	2	9	5	55.3	37	9	6
Deduction	3.2	1	8	3	60.0	9	10	1
Mechanisms	2.3	0	6	0	38.2	0	6	0
Temporal paradoxes	2.3	1	6	3	35.8	11	6	2
Classical space and time	2.4	2	6	5	40.5	34	7	5
Early modern	0.7	0	2	0	15.5	0	2	0
Meaning and use	3.7	4	10	10	63.6	59	10	10
Marx	1.4	1	4	3	28.6	33	5	5
Ordinary language	19.6	11	51	29	379.5	237	61	38
Moral conscience	4.5	5	12	13	81.1	98	13	16
Methodology of science	6.6	8	17	21	87.0	85	14	14
Heidegger and Husserl	1.4	2	4	5	31.9	41	5	7
Emotions	2.2	2	6	5	28.2	15	5	2
Ontological argument	2.0	2	5	5	30.0	26	5	4
Chemistry	3.3	4	8	10	53.5	71	9	11
Social contract theory	1.0	0	3	0	16.0	0	3	0
Kant	1.9	3	5	8	26.6	56	4	9
Promises and imperatives	3.1	2	8	5	53.1	40	9	6
Analytic/synthetic	3.6	4	9	10	64.8	88	10	14
Freedom and free will	3.3	4	9	10	39.9	47	6	8
Crime and punishment	1.5	0	4	0	30.2	0	5	0
Sets and grue	3.6	2	9	5	54.4	14	9	2
Origins and purposes	1.2	1	3	3	15.1	8	2	1
Time	3.3	2	9	5	51.6	26	8	4
Color/colour	3.2	5	8	13	38.3	61	6	10
War	1.4	0	4	0	24.1	0	4	0
Depiction	1.5	1	4	3	27.2	38	4	6
Denoting	3.7	5	10	13	71.2	115	11	19
Chance	5.2	3	13	8	64.2	32	10	5
Hume	1.4	0	4	0	19.2	0	3	0
Laws	2.8	2	7	5	37.1	32	6	5
Perception	4.4	4	12	10	70.6	56	11	9
Intention	1.5	0	4	0	25.8	0	4	0
Virtues	2.9	3	7	8	32.4	35	5	6
Space and time	5.4	9	14	23	72.3	128	12	21
Mathematics	2.9	2	8	5	49.7	43	8	7
Liberal democracy	4.0	8	10	21	83.8	178	14	29
Duties	3.3	3	9	8	53.2	33	9	5
Causation	7.0	8	18	21	110.2	139	18	22
Arguments	11.8	2	31	5	185.7	27	30	4
Theory testing	8.1	9	21	23	92.7	95	15	15
Decision theory	2.8	0	7	0	47.8	0	8	0
Minds and machines	4.5	2	12	5	66.2	43	11	7
Truth	8.1	6	21	16	126.1	92	20	15
Radical translation	5.3	3	14	8	90.6	59	15	10
Explanation	6.2	8	16	21	91.5	99	15	16
Personal identity	3.7	6	10	16	55.5	88	9	14
Speech acts	4.9	8	13	21	67.6	98	11	16
Sense and reference	6.2	7	16	18	104.8	126	17	20
Egalitarianism	1.5	1	4	3	30.3	23	5	4
Quantum physics	13.5	21	35	55	184.7	283	30	46
Theories and realism	9.7	6	25	16	139.5	108	22	17
Functions	2.3	3	6	8	37.4	43	6	7
Feminism	3.7	4	10	10	66.7	72	11	12
Medical ethics and Freud	4.7	9	12	23	71.1	126	11	20
Abortion and self-defence	2.5	2	6	5	46.0	62	7	10
Belief ascriptions	5.6	8	15	21	89.5	113	14	18
Thermodynamics	4.1	4	11	10	71.7	80	12	13
Knowledge	6.0	7	16	18	95.2	125	15	20
Game theory	3.4	5	9	13	51.7	71	8	11
Justification	14.6	22	38	57	203.0	285	33	46
Frankfurt cases	2.5	3	7	8	29.2	25	5	4
Concepts	5.0	3	13	8	98.1	76	16	12
Races and DNA	1.4	2	4	5	15.8	19	3	3
Modality	7.3	7	19	18	96.8	84	16	14
Reasons	9.8	14	25	36	168.1	240	27	39
Evolutionary biology	10.0	15	26	39	135.9	197	22	32
Population ethics	7.9	13	21	34	153.4	262	25	42
Formal epistemology	5.4	9	14	23	94.3	173	15	28
Wide content	8.0	11	21	29	133.9	202	22	33
Vagueness	4.8	6	13	16	73.2	83	12	13
Cognitive science	6.1	9	16	23	105.1	158	17	25
Models	3.3	1	9	3	48.6	9	8	1
Composition and constitution	7.2	8	19	21	131.4	163	21	26
Norms	8.7	6	23	16	178.2	124	29	20

1997

Table B.122: Measures of the prominence of each subject in 1997 ’s journals.

Subject	Weight	Raw	W-Ratio	R-Ratio	W-Pages	R-Pages	WP-Ratio	RP-Ratio
Psychology	0.5	0	1	0	10.8	0	2	0
Idealism	2.2	0	5	0	38.7	0	6	0
Life and value	2.8	1	7	2	54.3	22	8	3
Other history	3.0	3	8	7	64.6	88	10	13
Dewey and pragmatism	3.3	2	8	5	47.5	23	7	3
Definitions	3.1	2	8	5	62.4	48	9	7
Propositions and implications	3.2	0	8	0	53.3	0	8	0
Beauty	1.4	2	4	5	26.6	38	4	6
Physicalism	3.3	2	8	5	46.7	22	7	3
History and culture	0.8	1	2	2	13.2	14	2	2
Faith and theism	1.5	1	4	2	14.5	11	2	2
Self-consciousness	3.0	1	7	2	39.3	6	6	1
Ancient	1.4	2	3	5	44.1	88	7	13
Universals and particulars	2.6	0	6	0	44.2	0	7	0
Verification	1.5	0	4	0	24.0	0	4	0
Value	3.5	1	9	2	65.4	19	10	3
Deduction	4.3	2	11	5	74.4	62	11	9
Mechanisms	3.7	0	9	0	60.5	0	9	0
Temporal paradoxes	2.8	0	7	0	42.5	0	6	0
Classical space and time	3.2	3	8	7	55.5	72	8	11
Early modern	1.6	2	4	5	31.7	54	5	8
Meaning and use	3.5	2	9	5	53.7	46	8	7
Marx	4.0	2	10	5	47.7	22	7	3
Ordinary language	19.7	13	49	32	365.4	232	55	35
Moral conscience	4.2	4	11	10	81.2	75	12	11
Methodology of science	8.1	9	20	22	113.0	116	17	18
Heidegger and Husserl	0.7	1	2	2	12.1	19	2	3
Emotions	2.3	1	6	2	50.2	30	8	5
Ontological argument	3.0	1	7	2	41.8	5	6	1
Chemistry	4.4	6	11	15	69.6	108	11	16
Social contract theory	0.9	1	2	2	23.1	44	3	7
Kant	1.8	1	4	2	33.0	25	5	4
Promises and imperatives	3.6	1	9	2	78.4	44	12	7
Analytic/synthetic	2.2	2	5	5	43.5	48	7	7
Freedom and free will	1.5	0	4	0	28.7	0	4	0
Crime and punishment	1.4	1	3	2	29.5	15	4	2
Sets and grue	7.1	8	18	20	150.0	197	23	30
Origins and purposes	3.5	3	9	7	40.5	26	6	4
Time	2.7	3	7	7	35.7	19	5	3
Color/colour	1.1	0	3	0	17.9	0	3	0
War	1.4	2	4	5	22.4	23	3	3
Depiction	2.5	4	6	10	43.8	71	7	11
Denoting	2.0	3	5	7	43.1	66	7	10
Chance	7.7	9	19	22	120.4	153	18	23
Hume	2.5	1	6	2	37.9	24	6	4
Laws	3.2	2	8	5	44.7	21	7	3
Perception	2.3	2	6	5	42.1	59	6	9
Intention	3.0	5	8	12	56.6	121	9	18
Virtues	3.0	2	8	5	53.1	35	8	5
Space and time	3.8	4	9	10	59.9	48	9	7
Mathematics	3.5	4	9	10	73.5	94	11	14
Liberal democracy	3.9	4	10	10	86.6	82	13	12
Duties	3.0	4	7	10	52.4	52	8	8
Causation	6.2	8	15	20	96.1	117	15	18
Arguments	11.4	3	28	7	176.0	29	27	4
Theory testing	9.5	10	24	25	136.7	166	21	25
Decision theory	5.6	5	14	12	88.5	104	13	16
Minds and machines	3.6	4	9	10	56.0	68	8	10
Truth	10.5	15	26	37	141.1	208	21	31
Radical translation	5.4	6	13	15	98.4	103	15	16
Explanation	5.1	2	13	5	79.0	19	12	3
Personal identity	4.4	5	11	12	57.3	46	9	7
Speech acts	5.9	8	15	20	100.1	158	15	24
Sense and reference	6.2	6	16	15	115.6	107	17	16
Egalitarianism	3.5	4	9	10	76.9	104	12	16
Quantum physics	6.5	10	16	25	86.2	125	13	19
Theories and realism	9.1	9	23	22	120.1	89	18	13
Functions	3.5	4	9	10	59.2	77	9	12
Feminism	2.6	4	7	10	43.3	71	7	11
Medical ethics and Freud	4.0	6	10	15	71.9	114	11	17
Abortion and self-defence	3.4	5	8	12	78.4	133	12	20
Belief ascriptions	5.3	7	13	17	77.9	103	12	16
Thermodynamics	2.9	3	7	7	38.6	39	6	6
Knowledge	7.0	10	17	25	74.9	68	11	10
Game theory	1.9	1	5	2	29.9	8	5	1
Justification	9.5	9	24	22	135.0	109	20	16
Frankfurt cases	3.8	3	9	7	62.4	55	9	8
Concepts	5.2	3	13	7	99.0	32	15	5
Races and DNA	3.4	5	9	12	46.7	60	7	9
Modality	5.8	6	14	15	93.7	138	14	21
Reasons	10.3	15	26	37	200.3	292	30	44
Evolutionary biology	4.7	6	12	15	66.4	78	10	12
Population ethics	7.2	10	18	25	147.5	222	22	34
Formal epistemology	6.9	13	17	32	104.5	177	16	27
Wide content	9.3	14	23	35	123.3	135	19	20
Vagueness	5.2	6	13	15	65.5	71	10	11
Cognitive science	8.1	12	20	30	146.7	235	22	35
Models	6.3	7	16	17	99.5	107	15	16
Composition and constitution	11.9	15	30	37	164.4	193	25	29
Norms	11.3	13	28	32	200.9	177	30	27

1998

Table B.123: Measures of the prominence of each subject in 1998 ’s journals.

Subject	Weight	Raw	W-Ratio	R-Ratio	W-Pages	R-Pages	WP-Ratio	RP-Ratio
Psychology	0.8	1	2	3	16.4	14	3	2
Idealism	1.3	0	4	0	26.3	0	4	0
Life and value	2.4	0	7	0	49.1	0	8	0
Other history	2.7	3	8	9	48.2	39	8	7
Dewey and pragmatism	1.3	0	4	0	20.8	0	4	0
Definitions	2.4	2	7	6	40.2	15	7	3
Propositions and implications	3.4	2	10	6	48.8	12	8	2
Beauty	0.2	0	1	0	3.6	0	1	0
Physicalism	2.8	1	8	3	44.8	3	8	1
History and culture	0.8	0	2	0	16.6	0	3	0
Faith and theism	1.9	2	6	6	28.9	35	5	6
Self-consciousness	1.9	0	6	0	27.3	0	5	0
Ancient	1.8	3	6	9	55.2	118	9	20
Universals and particulars	1.9	3	6	9	31.2	48	5	8
Verification	1.5	0	5	0	25.4	0	4	0
Value	2.3	1	7	3	40.2	23	7	4
Deduction	3.0	0	9	0	52.6	0	9	0
Mechanisms	3.2	0	10	0	63.8	0	11	0
Temporal paradoxes	2.2	0	7	0	41.3	0	7	0
Classical space and time	2.4	0	7	0	50.2	0	8	0
Early modern	1.4	1	4	3	36.0	34	6	6
Meaning and use	2.4	2	7	6	49.0	48	8	8
Marx	0.9	1	3	3	20.2	36	3	6
Ordinary language	14.6	4	44	12	325.9	114	55	19
Moral conscience	2.7	1	8	3	47.8	22	8	4
Methodology of science	2.5	1	8	3	49.4	16	8	3
Heidegger and Husserl	0.2	0	1	0	4.7	0	1	0
Emotions	2.0	2	6	6	36.5	21	6	4
Ontological argument	2.1	1	6	3	33.1	8	6	1
Chemistry	1.5	2	5	6	31.3	43	5	7
Social contract theory	1.6	2	5	6	35.9	50	6	8
Kant	3.1	6	9	18	74.5	156	13	26
Promises and imperatives	2.5	0	7	0	37.0	0	6	0
Analytic/synthetic	3.4	5	10	15	67.9	112	11	19
Freedom and free will	2.1	2	6	6	29.3	37	5	6
Crime and punishment	1.6	3	5	9	28.3	49	5	8
Sets and grue	4.2	6	13	18	84.2	129	14	22
Origins and purposes	2.7	2	8	6	49.1	45	8	8
Time	2.8	4	9	12	38.6	53	6	9
Color/colour	2.7	4	8	12	36.8	42	6	7
War	1.4	0	4	0	30.8	0	5	0
Depiction	1.1	0	3	0	18.8	0	3	0
Denoting	3.6	4	11	12	87.7	113	15	19
Chance	5.9	6	18	18	82.3	74	14	12
Hume	1.9	4	6	12	35.3	79	6	13
Laws	3.6	2	11	6	39.1	9	7	2
Perception	3.6	3	11	9	70.3	70	12	12
Intention	2.6	3	8	9	40.0	34	7	6
Virtues	1.6	1	5	3	28.9	27	5	5
Space and time	3.5	4	10	12	63.1	66	11	11
Mathematics	4.3	8	13	24	104.1	213	17	36
Liberal democracy	7.3	10	22	30	176.3	244	30	41
Duties	1.9	2	6	6	46.9	61	8	10
Causation	8.0	12	24	36	104.6	146	18	25
Arguments	10.9	4	33	12	187.9	48	32	8
Theory testing	3.2	4	10	12	56.8	49	10	8
Decision theory	3.7	4	11	12	60.3	50	10	8
Minds and machines	3.3	2	10	6	58.0	35	10	6
Truth	7.4	9	22	27	110.7	121	19	20
Radical translation	4.0	2	12	6	76.2	29	13	5
Explanation	5.9	6	18	18	102.4	108	17	18
Personal identity	4.1	5	12	15	68.6	72	12	12
Speech acts	4.8	6	15	18	70.8	89	12	15
Sense and reference	8.5	13	26	39	128.8	186	22	31
Egalitarianism	4.6	5	14	15	121.3	136	20	23
Quantum physics	3.9	4	12	12	71.2	71	12	12
Theories and realism	4.5	2	13	6	78.1	31	13	5
Functions	3.6	4	11	12	72.7	82	12	14
Feminism	3.4	5	10	15	80.3	144	13	24
Medical ethics and Freud	0.9	1	3	3	20.7	35	3	6
Abortion and self-defence	4.0	5	12	15	65.2	109	11	18
Belief ascriptions	4.8	7	15	21	122.2	225	21	38
Thermodynamics	4.5	6	14	18	93.9	134	16	23
Knowledge	4.2	5	13	15	65.8	70	11	12
Game theory	2.1	4	6	12	47.7	89	8	15
Justification	6.6	7	20	21	104.5	122	18	21
Frankfurt cases	4.5	4	14	12	57.8	46	10	8
Concepts	5.4	3	16	9	107.0	53	18	9
Races and DNA	4.0	6	12	18	68.4	106	12	18
Modality	6.4	5	19	15	82.9	68	14	11
Reasons	6.3	7	19	21	91.6	65	15	11
Evolutionary biology	4.9	6	15	18	86.5	94	15	16
Population ethics	8.3	12	25	36	118.5	186	20	31
Formal epistemology	4.5	8	13	24	59.2	115	10	19
Wide content	7.5	9	22	27	141.2	160	24	27
Vagueness	4.6	8	14	24	49.2	75	8	13
Cognitive science	5.0	9	15	27	88.4	162	15	27
Models	3.2	3	10	9	72.6	85	12	14
Composition and constitution	11.3	13	34	39	154.7	195	26	33
Norms	6.0	3	18	9	133.2	47	22	8

1999

Table B.124: Measures of the prominence of each subject in 1999 ’s journals.

Subject	Weight	Raw	W-Ratio	R-Ratio	W-Pages	R-Pages	WP-Ratio	RP-Ratio
Psychology	0.9	1	2	3	16.5	21	2	3
Idealism	1.4	0	3	0	27.4	0	4	0
Life and value	3.1	1	8	3	63.7	18	9	3
Other history	2.6	1	7	3	52.3	7	7	1
Dewey and pragmatism	2.0	1	5	3	39.5	9	6	1
Definitions	2.2	0	6	0	39.9	0	6	0
Propositions and implications	2.3	1	6	3	37.7	3	5	0
Beauty	0.7	1	2	3	12.6	20	2	3
Physicalism	4.2	4	11	10	66.5	56	9	8
History and culture	0.6	0	1	0	9.1	0	1	0
Faith and theism	0.9	0	2	0	13.9	0	2	0
Self-consciousness	2.9	1	7	3	54.3	7	8	1
Ancient	1.4	4	4	10	28.9	88	4	12
Universals and particulars	3.2	4	8	10	68.7	113	10	16
Verification	1.5	0	4	0	24.9	0	4	0
Value	2.8	1	7	3	61.8	14	9	2
Deduction	3.5	2	9	5	65.7	52	9	7
Mechanisms	2.9	2	7	5	52.6	37	7	5
Temporal paradoxes	2.9	1	7	3	39.8	2	6	0
Classical space and time	4.0	6	10	15	70.9	100	10	14
Early modern	3.9	6	10	15	111.5	184	16	26
Meaning and use	2.5	2	6	5	49.5	75	7	11
Marx	1.2	1	3	3	20.7	10	3	1
Ordinary language	16.2	2	41	5	359.0	23	51	3
Moral conscience	4.3	2	11	5	92.4	33	13	5
Methodology of science	4.3	4	11	10	70.7	57	10	8
Heidegger and Husserl	0.4	0	1	0	6.3	0	1	0
Emotions	1.7	1	4	3	30.3	15	4	2
Ontological argument	2.6	0	7	0	38.3	0	5	0
Chemistry	2.2	1	6	3	49.2	22	7	3
Social contract theory	1.5	1	4	3	29.1	14	4	2
Kant	2.1	3	5	8	50.7	79	7	11
Promises and imperatives	2.1	0	5	0	40.5	0	6	0
Analytic/synthetic	4.5	6	11	15	61.8	133	9	19
Freedom and free will	2.0	2	5	5	48.6	31	7	4
Crime and punishment	1.6	3	4	8	36.7	76	5	11
Sets and grue	8.0	7	20	18	143.1	154	20	22
Origins and purposes	1.3	1	3	3	19.4	18	3	3
Time	3.6	5	9	13	45.0	57	6	8
Color/colour	2.1	2	5	5	45.0	45	6	6
War	1.5	0	4	0	30.2	0	4	0
Depiction	2.1	1	5	3	38.0	16	5	2
Denoting	2.6	4	7	10	63.4	110	9	16
Chance	7.3	6	18	15	109.9	93	16	13
Hume	1.9	1	5	3	20.6	8	3	1
Laws	4.9	5	12	13	91.6	100	13	14
Perception	3.1	2	8	5	55.1	29	8	4
Intention	2.1	2	5	5	37.8	36	5	5
Virtues	2.9	4	7	10	47.6	64	7	9
Space and time	6.0	5	15	13	100.7	78	14	11
Mathematics	5.2	9	13	23	90.9	150	13	21
Liberal democracy	6.7	10	17	25	168.5	257	24	36
Duties	2.5	2	6	5	65.7	57	9	8
Causation	8.3	9	21	23	141.2	167	20	24
Arguments	11.6	1	29	3	190.3	15	27	2
Theory testing	8.1	13	20	33	118.4	194	17	27
Decision theory	2.8	2	7	5	45.1	40	6	6
Minds and machines	5.4	5	14	13	89.9	92	13	13
Truth	10.4	13	26	33	129.7	158	18	22
Radical translation	5.1	5	13	13	81.7	53	12	7
Explanation	6.3	5	16	13	114.4	92	16	13
Personal identity	4.6	6	12	15	62.0	89	9	13
Speech acts	2.1	0	5	0	33.4	0	5	0
Sense and reference	8.4	11	21	28	128.4	145	18	21
Egalitarianism	4.1	3	10	8	89.3	76	13	11
Quantum physics	12.5	18	32	45	224.6	322	32	46
Theories and realism	6.7	3	17	8	99.8	36	14	5
Functions	2.8	2	7	5	48.4	31	7	4
Feminism	3.0	7	7	18	69.1	184	10	26
Medical ethics and Freud	3.4	5	9	13	67.0	115	9	16
Abortion and self-defence	6.0	10	15	25	109.6	199	16	28
Belief ascriptions	6.3	9	16	23	88.1	158	12	22
Thermodynamics	5.7	7	14	18	111.4	176	16	25
Knowledge	4.7	5	12	13	68.5	77	10	11
Game theory	4.8	5	12	13	70.3	65	10	9
Justification	7.0	7	18	18	117.1	103	17	15
Frankfurt cases	3.3	4	8	10	70.5	93	10	13
Concepts	5.2	2	13	5	96.2	14	14	2
Races and DNA	2.8	2	7	5	55.9	40	8	6
Modality	8.6	11	22	28	154.6	205	22	29
Reasons	9.9	15	25	38	189.1	295	27	42
Evolutionary biology	7.0	11	18	28	107.2	165	15	23
Population ethics	5.4	6	14	15	98.1	107	14	15
Formal epistemology	6.0	10	15	25	131.7	226	19	32
Wide content	8.4	14	21	35	100.2	127	14	18
Vagueness	5.3	9	13	23	59.0	75	8	11
Cognitive science	7.1	10	18	25	139.0	182	20	26
Models	4.1	3	10	8	99.0	104	14	15
Composition and constitution	13.4	13	34	33	195.2	176	28	25
Norms	6.8	4	17	10	159.3	100	23	14

2000

Table B.125: Measures of the prominence of each subject in 2000 ’s journals.

Subject	Weight	Raw	W-Ratio	R-Ratio	W-Pages	R-Pages	WP-Ratio	RP-Ratio
Psychology	0.7	1	2	2	17.4	24	2	3
Idealism	1.8	0	4	0	27.9	0	4	0
Life and value	3.2	3	7	7	58.7	64	8	8
Other history	3.7	2	8	4	53.6	6	7	1
Dewey and pragmatism	2.1	0	5	0	40.2	0	5	0
Definitions	2.9	1	6	2	45.7	2	6	0
Propositions and implications	3.3	0	7	0	51.7	0	7	0
Beauty	2.5	4	5	9	46.3	79	6	10
Physicalism	3.6	3	8	7	55.6	50	7	7
History and culture	0.6	0	1	0	11.6	0	2	0
Faith and theism	1.6	2	4	4	19.8	21	3	3
Self-consciousness	2.0	0	4	0	36.7	0	5	0
Ancient	2.3	3	5	7	37.1	46	5	6
Universals and particulars	3.1	1	7	2	62.1	33	8	4
Verification	2.0	1	4	2	29.2	3	4	0
Value	3.4	1	7	2	58.4	19	8	2
Deduction	4.2	6	9	13	81.6	153	11	20
Mechanisms	4.7	2	10	4	81.3	39	11	5
Temporal paradoxes	3.3	2	7	4	50.5	39	7	5
Classical space and time	3.9	3	9	7	55.8	21	7	3
Early modern	1.6	2	3	4	32.2	56	4	7
Meaning and use	3.5	3	8	7	52.6	44	7	6
Marx	2.3	0	5	0	42.5	0	6	0
Ordinary language	21.5	10	47	22	445.6	173	58	23
Moral conscience	4.3	2	10	4	76.5	45	10	6
Methodology of science	8.2	11	18	24	131.3	173	17	23
Heidegger and Husserl	2.3	4	5	9	39.3	70	5	9
Emotions	3.2	6	7	13	65.7	132	9	17
Ontological argument	4.1	3	9	7	59.6	67	8	9
Chemistry	3.7	4	8	9	75.2	84	10	11
Social contract theory	1.6	1	4	2	36.1	35	5	5
Kant	2.0	2	4	4	48.4	63	6	8
Promises and imperatives	3.4	2	8	4	55.0	17	7	2
Analytic/synthetic	3.9	3	9	7	62.3	51	8	7
Freedom and free will	2.4	3	5	7	50.0	99	7	13
Crime and punishment	0.9	1	2	2	19.3	6	3	1
Sets and grue	8.4	9	18	20	121.1	115	16	15
Origins and purposes	3.1	2	7	4	35.5	23	5	3
Time	3.1	1	7	2	39.5	12	5	2
Color/colour	4.1	3	9	7	44.7	25	6	3
War	1.7	1	4	2	31.5	25	4	3
Depiction	1.5	0	3	0	21.0	0	3	0
Denoting	3.2	3	7	7	50.0	36	7	5
Chance	6.7	5	15	11	106.5	58	14	8
Hume	3.4	4	7	9	70.4	105	9	14
Laws	5.3	6	12	13	107.2	120	14	16
Perception	7.4	12	16	26	118.1	177	15	23
Intention	2.3	3	5	7	44.8	58	6	8
Virtues	2.9	4	6	9	39.1	57	5	7
Space and time	7.5	11	16	24	138.5	185	18	24
Mathematics	6.1	11	13	24	87.6	162	11	21
Liberal democracy	9.4	14	21	31	256.4	403	33	53
Duties	2.0	0	4	0	44.2	0	6	0
Causation	9.0	8	20	18	127.8	115	17	15
Arguments	14.1	3	31	7	225.9	34	29	4
Theory testing	7.0	11	15	24	112.2	157	15	20
Decision theory	5.1	6	11	13	91.4	130	12	17
Minds and machines	3.5	1	8	2	66.6	28	9	4
Truth	10.5	9	23	20	120.7	86	16	11
Radical translation	3.2	2	7	4	56.9	66	7	9
Explanation	4.8	4	11	9	102.9	86	13	11
Personal identity	4.6	5	10	11	54.5	43	7	6
Speech acts	4.3	5	9	11	66.2	68	9	9
Sense and reference	5.0	7	11	15	110.9	198	14	26
Egalitarianism	4.3	5	10	11	88.0	93	11	12
Quantum physics	11.0	15	24	33	189.9	279	25	36
Theories and realism	8.4	10	18	22	130.6	142	17	19
Functions	2.3	1	5	2	38.3	23	5	3
Feminism	3.1	3	7	7	54.7	59	7	8
Medical ethics and Freud	3.2	4	7	9	59.2	77	8	10
Abortion and self-defence	4.9	6	11	13	54.2	50	7	7
Belief ascriptions	6.8	10	15	22	70.5	92	9	12
Thermodynamics	5.1	6	11	13	81.2	91	11	12
Knowledge	8.8	10	19	22	145.1	165	19	22
Game theory	2.7	5	6	11	62.8	127	8	17
Justification	14.7	20	32	44	266.1	342	35	45
Frankfurt cases	4.2	5	9	11	49.3	51	6	7
Concepts	6.0	4	13	9	109.2	113	14	15
Races and DNA	9.6	16	21	35	119.5	192	16	25
Modality	10.1	9	22	20	130.6	123	17	16
Reasons	10.0	12	22	26	195.3	232	25	30
Evolutionary biology	7.2	9	16	20	107.6	117	14	15
Population ethics	7.0	9	15	20	139.8	170	18	22
Formal epistemology	7.1	10	15	22	92.4	140	12	18
Wide content	6.4	5	14	11	81.3	28	11	4
Vagueness	6.8	10	15	22	97.1	149	13	19
Cognitive science	7.5	9	16	20	132.2	161	17	21
Models	4.8	3	10	7	84.4	72	11	9
Composition and constitution	11.1	11	24	24	167.9	165	22	22
Norms	9.9	7	22	15	221.6	135	29	18

2001

Table B.126: Measures of the prominence of each subject in 2001 ’s journals.

Subject	Weight	Raw	W-Ratio	R-Ratio	W-Pages	R-Pages	WP-Ratio	RP-Ratio
Psychology	0.7	0	2	0	20.2	0	3	0
Idealism	1.8	1	5	3	34.4	20	5	3
Life and value	2.3	0	6	0	47.6	0	7	0
Other history	2.8	2	7	5	56.1	41	8	6
Dewey and pragmatism	1.7	0	4	0	33.1	0	5	0
Definitions	2.8	1	7	3	53.0	30	8	4
Propositions and implications	2.9	1	8	3	47.3	5	7	1
Beauty	0.9	1	2	3	14.9	16	2	2
Physicalism	3.0	3	8	8	43.6	41	6	6
History and culture	0.9	0	2	0	14.8	0	2	0
Faith and theism	1.5	2	4	5	21.1	10	3	1
Self-consciousness	3.4	2	9	5	53.4	36	8	5
Ancient	1.6	1	4	3	27.8	23	4	3
Universals and particulars	2.1	1	5	3	41.4	24	6	3
Verification	1.9	1	5	3	26.5	9	4	1
Value	3.6	2	9	5	65.1	35	9	5
Deduction	3.0	1	8	3	55.2	21	8	3
Mechanisms	2.9	2	8	5	60.3	43	9	6
Temporal paradoxes	2.8	1	7	3	40.3	9	6	1
Classical space and time	2.7	2	7	5	50.2	39	7	6
Early modern	1.5	2	4	5	36.9	59	5	8
Meaning and use	2.4	1	6	3	50.5	35	7	5
Marx	1.4	0	4	0	29.1	0	4	0
Ordinary language	16.8	6	43	15	367.7	107	52	15
Moral conscience	2.0	1	5	3	45.1	32	6	5
Methodology of science	6.0	6	15	15	84.6	65	12	9
Heidegger and Husserl	1.3	2	3	5	20.4	26	3	4
Emotions	3.4	6	9	15	62.3	89	9	13
Ontological argument	2.1	1	5	3	30.3	16	4	2
Chemistry	6.3	10	16	26	86.6	157	12	22
Social contract theory	1.7	2	4	5	33.7	24	5	3
Kant	1.5	2	4	5	27.6	19	4	3
Promises and imperatives	2.2	0	6	0	42.5	0	6	0
Analytic/synthetic	3.3	4	9	10	66.6	86	9	12
Freedom and free will	1.9	1	5	3	49.0	25	7	4
Crime and punishment	2.5	2	6	5	62.9	50	9	7
Sets and grue	7.0	5	18	13	134.5	103	19	15
Origins and purposes	1.3	0	3	0	17.9	0	3	0
Time	2.7	2	7	5	33.9	11	5	2
Color/colour	4.1	4	10	10	63.7	69	9	10
War	1.1	0	3	0	24.9	0	4	0
Depiction	2.3	4	6	10	40.7	80	6	11
Denoting	2.5	4	6	10	57.2	102	8	14
Chance	6.9	7	18	18	105.2	106	15	15
Hume	3.9	7	10	18	75.5	139	11	20
Laws	5.3	7	14	18	73.0	93	10	13
Perception	6.9	8	18	21	126.4	159	18	23
Intention	1.7	2	4	5	33.3	37	5	5
Virtues	2.5	3	6	8	52.1	74	7	11
Space and time	6.3	10	16	26	107.6	188	15	27
Mathematics	3.9	6	10	15	74.6	98	11	14
Liberal democracy	8.0	12	21	31	209.1	341	30	48
Duties	3.1	5	8	13	61.6	112	9	16
Causation	5.9	7	15	18	115.1	155	16	22
Arguments	12.3	3	32	8	201.0	42	29	6
Theory testing	4.3	3	11	8	73.8	44	10	6
Decision theory	3.4	3	9	8	52.0	34	7	5
Minds and machines	4.8	5	12	13	71.1	72	10	10
Truth	9.1	8	23	21	98.5	59	14	8
Radical translation	4.9	7	13	18	116.7	215	17	31
Explanation	5.1	4	13	10	90.2	73	13	10
Personal identity	4.6	6	12	15	67.3	87	10	12
Speech acts	2.9	2	7	5	66.2	49	9	7
Sense and reference	6.7	6	17	15	148.6	155	21	22
Egalitarianism	7.7	8	20	21	174.3	188	25	27
Quantum physics	8.6	11	22	28	161.8	216	23	31
Theories and realism	8.4	10	22	26	131.5	173	19	25
Functions	2.0	1	5	3	39.8	20	6	3
Feminism	3.5	4	9	10	87.2	103	12	15
Medical ethics and Freud	2.1	4	5	10	48.3	104	7	15
Abortion and self-defence	2.2	2	6	5	44.5	61	6	9
Belief ascriptions	4.2	4	11	10	69.4	59	10	8
Thermodynamics	3.4	3	9	8	60.7	51	9	7
Knowledge	5.6	9	14	23	108.3	178	15	25
Game theory	2.8	5	7	13	59.2	124	8	18
Justification	8.7	6	22	15	150.4	93	21	13
Frankfurt cases	3.5	5	9	13	42.8	53	6	8
Concepts	7.5	8	19	21	128.9	126	18	18
Races and DNA	3.1	5	8	13	48.2	70	7	10
Modality	8.3	10	21	26	105.9	110	15	16
Reasons	8.1	13	21	33	168.2	254	24	36
Evolutionary biology	7.3	11	19	28	125.2	181	18	26
Population ethics	7.1	8	18	21	107.2	98	15	14
Formal epistemology	3.4	6	9	15	54.7	111	8	16
Wide content	5.1	4	13	10	91.0	65	13	9
Vagueness	6.0	8	15	21	80.7	102	11	14
Cognitive science	6.2	9	16	23	128.4	194	18	28
Models	5.7	4	15	10	109.2	87	16	12
Composition and constitution	13.4	13	34	33	184.0	154	26	22
Norms	11.1	9	28	23	233.5	173	33	25

2002

Table B.127: Measures of the prominence of each subject in 2002 ’s journals.

Subject	Weight	Raw	W-Ratio	R-Ratio	W-Pages	R-Pages	WP-Ratio	RP-Ratio
Psychology	1.0	1	3	3	17.8	21	3	3
Idealism	1.7	0	5	0	38.2	0	6	0
Life and value	2.7	1	7	3	51.7	5	8	1
Other history	2.7	0	7	0	35.7	0	6	0
Dewey and pragmatism	1.8	1	5	3	31.6	11	5	2
Definitions	2.0	0	5	0	40.1	0	6	0
Propositions and implications	2.3	0	6	0	38.6	0	6	0
Beauty	1.4	3	4	8	37.5	88	6	14
Physicalism	2.5	0	7	0	42.6	0	7	0
History and culture	0.8	0	2	0	14.7	0	2	0
Faith and theism	0.3	0	1	0	6.5	0	1	0
Self-consciousness	2.3	0	6	0	42.7	0	7	0
Ancient	1.0	1	3	3	25.3	65	4	10
Universals and particulars	2.7	3	7	8	40.5	27	6	4
Verification	1.4	0	4	0	20.6	0	3	0
Value	3.2	1	9	3	58.4	5	9	1
Deduction	4.7	3	13	8	70.3	41	11	6
Mechanisms	4.2	3	11	8	68.3	46	11	7
Temporal paradoxes	3.5	2	9	5	39.8	19	6	3
Classical space and time	3.9	2	11	5	78.0	63	12	10
Early modern	1.6	1	4	3	35.6	22	6	3
Meaning and use	2.4	3	7	8	47.8	49	8	8
Marx	1.4	0	4	0	23.6	0	4	0
Ordinary language	15.8	7	43	19	327.4	150	52	24
Moral conscience	2.9	4	8	11	57.8	75	9	12
Methodology of science	5.7	10	15	27	71.7	103	11	16
Heidegger and Husserl	0.4	0	1	0	8.0	0	1	0
Emotions	3.9	7	11	19	59.5	115	9	18
Ontological argument	2.9	1	8	3	43.5	6	7	1
Chemistry	5.5	8	15	22	72.2	103	11	16
Social contract theory	3.0	4	8	11	53.2	57	8	9
Kant	2.1	5	6	13	57.7	134	9	21
Promises and imperatives	2.8	1	8	3	53.9	18	8	3
Analytic/synthetic	3.7	4	10	11	58.7	70	9	11
Freedom and free will	1.5	1	4	3	30.6	24	5	4
Crime and punishment	0.8	1	2	3	12.5	19	2	3
Sets and grue	7.5	7	20	19	124.5	129	20	20
Origins and purposes	1.7	1	5	3	20.8	4	3	1
Time	3.1	2	8	5	34.5	27	5	4
Color/colour	2.8	2	7	5	47.1	41	7	6
War	1.1	0	3	0	18.4	0	3	0
Depiction	1.1	0	3	0	19.7	0	3	0
Denoting	3.2	3	9	8	49.3	47	8	7
Chance	7.3	9	20	24	109.2	117	17	18
Hume	3.9	5	11	13	77.4	124	12	20
Laws	3.9	3	10	8	58.3	56	9	9
Perception	5.2	7	14	19	95.1	102	15	16
Intention	1.0	0	3	0	16.0	0	3	0
Virtues	2.3	2	6	5	42.1	43	7	7
Space and time	5.5	8	15	22	91.4	147	14	23
Mathematics	6.4	11	17	30	100.0	184	16	29
Liberal democracy	2.7	3	7	8	67.6	85	11	13
Duties	1.0	1	3	3	21.8	24	3	4
Causation	5.1	2	14	5	81.6	20	13	3
Arguments	11.1	1	30	3	187.1	4	30	1
Theory testing	9.3	11	25	30	149.9	155	24	24
Decision theory	5.3	6	14	16	84.1	88	13	14
Minds and machines	3.5	3	9	8	59.5	75	9	12
Truth	14.0	18	38	49	159.3	176	25	28
Radical translation	4.2	2	11	5	83.4	33	13	5
Explanation	3.9	3	10	8	68.0	60	11	9
Personal identity	4.4	8	12	22	67.2	113	11	18
Speech acts	5.8	8	16	22	96.6	137	15	22
Sense and reference	6.0	7	16	19	136.4	197	22	31
Egalitarianism	7.4	10	20	27	175.0	234	28	37
Quantum physics	5.8	8	16	22	133.2	190	21	30
Theories and realism	5.0	3	14	8	78.8	39	12	6
Functions	1.3	0	4	0	24.2	0	4	0
Feminism	2.2	3	6	8	54.4	84	9	13
Medical ethics and Freud	1.8	1	5	3	24.3	9	4	1
Abortion and self-defence	1.7	2	5	5	32.4	46	5	7
Belief ascriptions	4.0	3	11	8	60.8	39	10	6
Thermodynamics	3.5	6	10	16	59.2	106	9	17
Knowledge	7.6	11	20	30	118.6	163	19	26
Game theory	3.0	3	8	8	49.7	47	8	7
Justification	8.8	15	24	40	131.0	242	21	38
Frankfurt cases	3.2	5	9	13	46.3	67	7	11
Concepts	5.0	3	14	8	97.8	57	15	9
Races and DNA	2.7	4	7	11	49.4	101	8	16
Modality	7.9	7	21	19	113.6	118	18	19
Reasons	6.3	8	17	22	110.7	161	17	25
Evolutionary biology	7.6	10	21	27	129.2	205	20	32
Population ethics	3.7	4	10	11	95.6	108	15	17
Formal epistemology	5.7	6	15	16	65.9	57	10	9
Wide content	4.6	6	12	16	68.7	65	11	10
Vagueness	7.6	12	20	32	127.4	214	20	34
Cognitive science	5.3	7	14	19	86.8	103	14	16
Models	4.9	3	13	8	92.7	66	15	10
Composition and constitution	10.5	11	28	30	134.3	103	21	16
Norms	9.0	9	24	24	199.6	189	31	30

2003

Table B.128: Measures of the prominence of each subject in 2003 ’s journals.

Subject	Weight	Raw	W-Ratio	R-Ratio	W-Pages	R-Pages	WP-Ratio	RP-Ratio
Psychology	0.4	0	1	0	8.1	0	1	0
Idealism	1.7	0	4	0	33.8	0	4	0
Life and value	2.8	0	6	0	59.0	0	8	0
Other history	2.7	2	6	5	44.9	27	6	3
Dewey and pragmatism	1.8	0	4	0	40.6	0	5	0
Definitions	2.7	0	6	0	50.3	0	6	0
Propositions and implications	3.5	2	8	5	50.8	33	7	4
Beauty	0.8	0	2	0	13.6	0	2	0
Physicalism	3.3	1	7	2	58.4	15	8	2
History and culture	1.0	1	2	2	22.3	25	3	3
Faith and theism	0.8	0	2	0	15.0	0	2	0
Self-consciousness	3.4	4	8	9	53.8	49	7	6
Ancient	0.7	1	2	2	15.4	27	2	3
Universals and particulars	2.8	1	6	2	48.0	23	6	3
Verification	2.0	3	5	7	29.5	57	4	7
Value	6.2	9	14	20	113.8	159	15	20
Deduction	2.8	1	6	2	62.4	24	8	3
Mechanisms	3.3	2	7	5	56.3	25	7	3
Temporal paradoxes	4.6	4	10	9	65.9	74	8	10
Classical space and time	4.5	3	10	7	52.9	20	7	3
Early modern	2.6	3	6	7	74.2	91	10	12
Meaning and use	3.6	3	8	7	75.2	86	10	11
Marx	2.1	1	5	2	37.9	20	5	3
Ordinary language	18.7	13	42	29	416.7	236	54	30
Moral conscience	3.8	1	8	2	84.2	13	11	2
Methodology of science	5.7	5	13	11	79.5	45	10	6
Heidegger and Husserl	0.6	0	1	0	10.3	0	1	0
Emotions	3.3	4	8	9	54.6	68	7	9
Ontological argument	2.9	1	7	2	46.7	29	6	4
Chemistry	6.8	8	15	18	98.3	119	13	15
Social contract theory	1.0	0	2	0	19.0	0	2	0
Kant	2.2	4	5	9	53.8	116	7	15
Promises and imperatives	3.7	2	8	5	80.7	64	10	8
Analytic/synthetic	4.9	7	11	16	88.3	127	11	16
Freedom and free will	3.1	3	7	7	67.4	76	9	10
Crime and punishment	2.4	3	5	7	50.9	69	7	9
Sets and grue	6.3	5	14	11	113.6	98	15	13
Origins and purposes	2.7	2	6	5	32.6	31	4	4
Time	3.8	4	9	9	57.2	35	7	5
Color/colour	3.4	4	8	9	62.0	90	8	12
War	1.8	0	4	0	31.1	0	4	0
Depiction	2.7	3	6	7	47.9	65	6	8
Denoting	1.9	3	4	7	42.6	40	5	5
Chance	8.3	8	19	18	105.4	77	14	10
Hume	2.6	4	6	9	45.4	66	6	9
Laws	5.1	5	11	11	82.2	85	11	11
Perception	4.3	4	10	9	77.4	63	10	8
Intention	2.7	3	6	7	50.1	25	6	3
Virtues	2.4	1	5	2	42.5	25	5	3
Space and time	5.9	6	13	14	86.4	84	11	11
Mathematics	6.1	8	14	18	102.5	145	13	19
Liberal democracy	3.4	4	8	9	81.8	107	11	14
Duties	2.9	4	6	9	52.2	75	7	10
Causation	7.7	7	17	16	128.6	116	17	15
Arguments	12.9	1	29	2	211.1	12	27	2
Theory testing	5.6	4	13	9	81.0	49	10	6
Decision theory	6.8	8	15	18	79.8	92	10	12
Minds and machines	4.0	2	9	5	74.2	26	10	3
Truth	9.1	12	20	27	129.5	144	17	19
Radical translation	4.5	2	10	5	84.9	28	11	4
Explanation	5.9	4	13	9	104.9	64	14	8
Personal identity	3.2	3	7	7	57.3	71	7	9
Speech acts	3.0	4	7	9	70.4	106	9	14
Sense and reference	4.9	7	11	16	106.0	156	14	20
Egalitarianism	8.9	12	20	27	168.3	239	22	31
Quantum physics	15.4	22	35	50	248.0	372	32	48
Theories and realism	10.9	13	25	29	180.8	232	23	30
Functions	3.7	2	8	5	67.9	41	9	5
Feminism	2.6	4	6	9	63.5	125	8	16
Medical ethics and Freud	2.4	2	5	5	34.6	19	4	2
Abortion and self-defence	3.2	3	7	7	52.0	67	7	9
Belief ascriptions	1.9	1	4	2	29.5	11	4	1
Thermodynamics	7.2	8	16	18	124.7	146	16	19
Knowledge	6.2	6	14	14	99.4	101	13	13
Game theory	1.2	1	3	2	20.2	16	3	2
Justification	8.3	10	19	23	170.2	227	22	29
Frankfurt cases	4.0	6	9	14	57.0	87	7	11
Concepts	6.3	1	14	2	124.5	13	16	2
Races and DNA	4.6	8	10	18	60.1	107	8	14
Modality	9.3	9	21	20	129.1	109	17	14
Reasons	9.4	10	21	23	201.7	238	26	31
Evolutionary biology	12.1	17	27	38	174.4	246	22	32
Population ethics	10.2	15	23	34	192.7	260	25	34
Formal epistemology	5.6	7	13	16	53.5	55	7	7
Wide content	6.0	8	13	18	103.6	126	13	16
Vagueness	8.1	9	18	20	117.5	122	15	16
Cognitive science	4.2	5	9	11	80.2	88	10	11
Models	9.0	12	20	27	142.1	200	18	26
Composition and constitution	16.3	21	37	47	221.5	291	29	38
Norms	14.1	18	32	41	367.2	527	47	68

2004

Table B.129: Measures of the prominence of each subject in 2004 ’s journals.

Subject	Weight	Raw	W-Ratio	R-Ratio	W-Pages	R-Pages	WP-Ratio	RP-Ratio
Psychology	0.5	0	1	0	9.0	0	1	0
Idealism	1.9	0	5	0	40.7	0	5	0
Life and value	2.4	0	6	0	53.0	0	7	0
Other history	2.3	0	6	0	46.9	0	6	0
Dewey and pragmatism	2.3	1	6	2	44.5	26	6	3
Definitions	2.7	1	7	2	48.9	13	7	2
Propositions and implications	3.2	1	8	2	49.0	7	7	1
Beauty	0.4	1	1	2	10.7	27	1	4
Physicalism	2.2	0	5	0	34.8	0	5	0
History and culture	0.9	0	2	0	16.1	0	2	0
Faith and theism	1.2	2	3	5	29.7	32	4	4
Self-consciousness	2.8	1	7	2	47.3	19	6	3
Ancient	2.9	5	7	12	75.5	146	10	20
Universals and particulars	4.3	5	11	12	104.5	154	14	21
Verification	1.1	0	3	0	18.1	0	2	0
Value	3.4	3	8	7	62.9	54	8	7
Deduction	4.1	2	10	5	67.4	39	9	5
Mechanisms	4.1	1	10	2	71.8	15	10	2
Temporal paradoxes	4.4	3	11	7	55.0	31	7	4
Classical space and time	3.3	2	8	5	49.3	15	7	2
Early modern	3.0	4	7	10	87.4	117	12	16
Meaning and use	2.4	1	6	2	36.8	14	5	2
Marx	2.2	2	5	5	44.9	34	6	5
Ordinary language	17.3	7	43	17	396.9	169	53	23
Moral conscience	3.7	3	9	7	77.5	54	10	7
Methodology of science	5.4	6	13	15	85.7	92	11	12
Heidegger and Husserl	0.4	0	1	0	9.2	0	1	0
Emotions	1.7	2	4	5	34.3	37	5	5
Ontological argument	2.1	2	5	5	58.3	94	8	13
Chemistry	6.0	8	15	20	84.6	104	11	14
Social contract theory	1.0	0	2	0	20.8	0	3	0
Kant	2.7	5	7	12	73.9	165	10	22
Promises and imperatives	3.0	1	8	2	63.3	19	8	3
Analytic/synthetic	3.1	2	8	5	51.3	13	7	2
Freedom and free will	3.0	3	8	7	69.4	58	9	8
Crime and punishment	3.0	3	8	7	62.5	55	8	7
Sets and grue	5.9	2	15	5	106.2	32	14	4
Origins and purposes	1.6	1	4	2	30.0	21	4	3
Time	4.0	2	10	5	52.1	13	7	2
Color/colour	3.6	5	9	12	66.6	114	9	15
War	4.5	6	11	15	120.6	166	16	22
Depiction	1.0	0	2	0	17.0	0	2	0
Denoting	3.3	4	8	10	76.8	75	10	10
Chance	7.4	7	18	17	103.9	101	14	14
Hume	2.4	4	6	10	53.5	114	7	15
Laws	3.5	1	9	2	51.9	12	7	2
Perception	5.0	4	12	10	105.6	131	14	18
Intention	3.1	4	8	10	60.9	51	8	7
Virtues	2.2	3	5	7	48.4	83	6	11
Space and time	6.1	9	15	22	78.7	103	11	14
Mathematics	7.1	9	18	22	110.1	137	15	18
Liberal democracy	5.1	7	13	17	131.3	172	18	23
Duties	2.6	4	6	10	63.9	118	9	16
Causation	5.8	4	14	10	87.7	46	12	6
Arguments	11.5	1	29	2	210.3	5	28	1
Theory testing	9.9	14	24	35	157.6	203	21	27
Decision theory	3.4	3	8	7	61.3	25	8	3
Minds and machines	3.2	2	8	5	62.1	22	8	3
Truth	7.7	11	19	27	102.0	150	14	20
Radical translation	4.0	5	10	12	82.9	109	11	15
Explanation	5.8	7	14	17	105.3	129	14	17
Personal identity	3.7	3	9	7	45.5	27	6	4
Speech acts	2.4	1	6	2	36.2	9	5	1
Sense and reference	5.0	6	12	15	98.0	123	13	16
Egalitarianism	5.7	7	14	17	145.6	192	19	26
Quantum physics	7.7	10	19	25	134.4	164	18	22
Theories and realism	7.3	9	18	22	126.0	159	17	21
Functions	1.4	0	3	0	22.1	0	3	0
Feminism	2.2	2	6	5	37.7	39	5	5
Medical ethics and Freud	2.7	4	7	10	48.6	68	7	9
Abortion and self-defence	3.9	5	10	12	82.1	128	11	17
Belief ascriptions	3.8	5	9	12	61.7	94	8	13
Thermodynamics	4.3	5	11	12	81.4	87	11	12
Knowledge	9.7	10	24	25	127.8	115	17	15
Game theory	2.1	2	5	5	57.4	80	8	11
Justification	10.7	13	26	32	172.7	226	23	30
Frankfurt cases	3.6	4	9	10	49.4	53	7	7
Concepts	5.9	4	15	10	110.2	94	15	13
Races and DNA	3.1	6	8	15	62.6	142	8	19
Modality	8.0	10	20	25	138.5	216	19	29
Reasons	9.8	16	24	40	215.4	361	29	48
Evolutionary biology	9.7	16	24	40	178.9	269	24	36
Population ethics	6.6	6	16	15	152.0	125	20	17
Formal epistemology	7.6	13	19	32	97.6	170	13	23
Wide content	7.3	11	18	27	111.4	157	15	21
Vagueness	5.4	7	13	17	68.9	84	9	11
Cognitive science	4.7	8	12	20	90.8	158	12	21
Models	8.3	8	21	20	134.8	108	18	14
Composition and constitution	9.9	10	25	25	172.5	133	23	18
Norms	10.7	6	26	15	269.6	153	36	20

2005

Table B.130: Measures of the prominence of each subject in 2005 ’s journals.

Subject	Weight	Raw	W-Ratio	R-Ratio	W-Pages	R-Pages	WP-Ratio	RP-Ratio
Psychology	0.4	0	1	0	10.0	0	1	0
Idealism	1.8	0	4	0	34.0	0	4	0
Life and value	3.1	0	7	0	67.9	0	8	0
Other history	2.8	2	6	4	58.9	25	7	3
Dewey and pragmatism	2.0	0	5	0	44.9	0	5	0
Definitions	2.8	1	6	2	48.2	4	6	0
Propositions and implications	3.9	0	9	0	73.0	0	9	0
Beauty	0.6	1	1	2	17.9	37	2	4
Physicalism	3.4	3	8	7	55.8	22	7	3
History and culture	0.8	0	2	0	14.8	0	2	0
Faith and theism	1.4	0	3	0	27.5	0	3	0
Self-consciousness	2.0	0	4	0	39.7	0	5	0
Ancient	2.0	3	4	7	55.6	108	7	13
Universals and particulars	3.6	3	8	7	69.2	56	8	7
Verification	1.5	1	3	2	28.5	18	3	2
Value	4.1	4	9	9	71.8	60	9	7
Deduction	4.5	3	10	7	73.5	61	9	7
Mechanisms	3.6	4	8	9	61.7	53	7	6
Temporal paradoxes	2.6	0	6	0	40.1	0	5	0
Classical space and time	3.9	3	9	7	60.0	38	7	5
Early modern	2.7	3	6	7	65.6	83	8	10
Meaning and use	3.1	2	7	4	60.2	30	7	4
Marx	1.7	0	4	0	37.7	0	5	0
Ordinary language	18.5	8	42	18	447.2	181	54	22
Moral conscience	2.1	1	5	2	50.5	16	6	2
Methodology of science	4.8	4	11	9	78.1	59	9	7
Heidegger and Husserl	0.5	1	1	2	10.8	21	1	3
Emotions	2.4	5	5	11	37.1	78	4	9
Ontological argument	4.2	3	9	7	65.2	34	8	4
Chemistry	5.2	5	12	11	74.7	69	9	8
Social contract theory	0.9	0	2	0	20.5	0	2	0
Kant	1.9	4	4	9	50.2	115	6	14
Promises and imperatives	1.8	0	4	0	36.6	0	4	0
Analytic/synthetic	3.0	2	7	4	51.5	46	6	6
Freedom and free will	2.6	2	6	4	57.6	51	7	6
Crime and punishment	1.4	1	3	2	19.3	4	2	0
Sets and grue	7.5	6	17	13	145.2	118	17	14
Origins and purposes	2.4	2	5	4	36.6	36	4	4
Time	3.3	1	8	2	41.7	3	5	0
Color/colour	3.4	2	8	4	68.6	35	8	4
War	2.2	2	5	4	54.2	66	7	8
Depiction	2.4	3	5	7	48.8	74	6	9
Denoting	6.6	12	15	27	205.8	414	25	50
Chance	7.2	7	16	16	113.1	118	14	14
Hume	2.0	3	5	7	27.1	33	3	4
Laws	4.7	3	11	7	81.3	64	10	8
Perception	5.1	6	12	13	103.6	111	12	13
Intention	1.2	1	3	2	24.0	8	3	1
Virtues	2.3	1	5	2	54.1	38	7	5
Space and time	5.3	5	12	11	97.0	112	12	13
Mathematics	5.3	6	12	13	78.1	78	9	9
Liberal democracy	4.0	5	9	11	109.7	125	13	15
Duties	3.9	4	9	9	67.2	59	8	7
Causation	8.1	6	18	13	146.5	103	18	12
Arguments	12.6	0	28	0	217.8	0	26	0
Theory testing	8.0	7	18	16	119.0	88	14	11
Decision theory	3.9	3	9	7	55.7	34	7	4
Minds and machines	3.1	2	7	4	54.0	62	6	7
Truth	7.5	5	17	11	101.1	47	12	6
Radical translation	3.8	4	8	9	81.6	87	10	10
Explanation	6.4	3	14	7	111.8	52	13	6
Personal identity	5.4	8	12	18	81.5	126	10	15
Speech acts	5.8	5	13	11	121.9	94	15	11
Sense and reference	4.2	2	10	4	132.8	96	16	12
Egalitarianism	6.9	12	16	27	153.0	288	18	35
Quantum physics	9.8	15	22	34	160.3	231	19	28
Theories and realism	8.9	12	20	27	136.0	171	16	21
Functions	2.2	0	5	0	47.1	0	6	0
Feminism	2.9	2	7	4	69.4	46	8	6
Medical ethics and Freud	4.5	6	10	13	116.8	188	14	23
Abortion and self-defence	4.7	8	10	18	111.8	190	13	23
Belief ascriptions	5.1	5	11	11	87.7	104	11	13
Thermodynamics	6.2	10	14	22	102.4	186	12	22
Knowledge	16.3	27	37	61	249.0	432	30	52
Game theory	4.7	5	11	11	84.4	86	10	10
Justification	12.6	14	28	31	228.4	285	27	34
Frankfurt cases	5.1	8	11	18	68.6	89	8	11
Concepts	6.6	7	15	16	136.8	179	16	22
Races and DNA	4.7	9	10	20	71.6	144	9	17
Modality	10.4	13	23	29	169.3	192	20	23
Reasons	7.2	9	16	20	177.3	259	21	31
Evolutionary biology	12.5	17	28	38	190.9	268	23	32
Population ethics	5.0	4	11	9	116.1	90	14	11
Formal epistemology	5.5	9	12	20	88.7	153	11	18
Wide content	4.8	4	11	9	98.3	64	12	8
Vagueness	9.5	13	21	29	139.8	180	17	22
Cognitive science	4.6	6	10	13	89.5	128	11	15
Models	9.3	11	21	25	151.7	183	18	22
Composition and constitution	17.0	26	38	58	271.4	402	33	48
Norms	12.6	10	28	22	295.1	219	36	26

2006

Table B.131: Measures of the prominence of each subject in 2006 ’s journals.

Subject	Weight	Raw	W-Ratio	R-Ratio	W-Pages	R-Pages	WP-Ratio	RP-Ratio
Psychology	0.7	0	2	0	11.8	0	1	0
Idealism	1.4	0	3	0	29.6	0	4	0
Life and value	2.6	1	6	2	57.1	13	7	2
Other history	3.0	2	7	5	67.1	39	9	5
Dewey and pragmatism	1.3	0	3	0	31.8	0	4	0
Definitions	1.8	0	4	0	40.8	0	5	0
Propositions and implications	2.4	0	6	0	48.6	0	6	0
Beauty	0.8	1	2	2	13.7	18	2	2
Physicalism	2.3	0	6	0	42.2	0	5	0
History and culture	0.6	0	2	0	12.7	0	2	0
Faith and theism	0.9	0	2	0	17.4	0	2	0
Self-consciousness	1.1	0	3	0	22.5	0	3	0
Ancient	3.6	5	9	12	74.3	113	9	14
Universals and particulars	2.3	0	6	0	46.8	0	6	0
Verification	1.3	0	3	0	24.8	0	3	0
Value	2.9	5	7	12	65.0	107	8	14
Deduction	3.6	4	9	10	80.7	100	10	13
Mechanisms	3.7	1	9	2	69.5	22	9	3
Temporal paradoxes	4.0	4	10	10	59.7	41	8	5
Classical space and time	4.4	6	11	15	64.3	65	8	8
Early modern	1.4	2	4	5	37.4	74	5	9
Meaning and use	2.7	3	7	7	43.8	27	6	3
Marx	1.5	0	4	0	36.3	0	5	0
Ordinary language	17.8	8	44	20	420.8	184	53	23
Moral conscience	3.7	4	9	10	90.4	109	11	14
Methodology of science	3.8	4	9	10	64.7	67	8	9
Heidegger and Husserl	0.2	0	1	0	4.7	0	1	0
Emotions	2.2	2	5	5	45.5	31	6	4
Ontological argument	2.7	0	7	0	46.0	0	6	0
Chemistry	5.9	5	15	12	80.5	55	10	7
Social contract theory	1.6	2	4	5	42.9	58	5	7
Kant	2.6	3	6	7	56.2	71	7	9
Promises and imperatives	2.7	0	7	0	62.4	0	8	0
Analytic/synthetic	2.5	2	6	5	49.1	40	6	5
Freedom and free will	3.3	3	8	7	77.9	84	10	11
Crime and punishment	2.2	4	6	10	47.0	86	6	11
Sets and grue	5.5	3	14	7	104.2	63	13	8
Origins and purposes	3.7	3	9	7	50.2	24	6	3
Time	3.9	4	10	10	51.9	35	7	4
Color/colour	5.9	9	15	22	85.4	142	11	18
War	2.6	3	6	7	53.2	71	7	9
Depiction	2.5	2	6	5	24.7	11	3	1
Denoting	3.7	4	9	10	79.0	108	10	14
Chance	6.6	9	16	22	119.9	148	15	19
Hume	2.3	2	6	5	40.2	33	5	4
Laws	3.0	2	7	5	82.0	79	10	10
Perception	8.2	14	20	35	194.9	341	25	43
Intention	1.4	0	4	0	32.8	0	4	0
Virtues	2.6	3	6	7	42.4	36	5	5
Space and time	4.6	6	11	15	101.2	176	13	22
Mathematics	5.5	8	14	20	63.2	73	8	9
Liberal democracy	5.0	7	13	17	130.8	189	17	24
Duties	3.0	2	8	5	65.4	45	8	6
Causation	7.3	10	18	25	168.0	253	21	32
Arguments	11.8	1	29	2	220.8	12	28	2
Theory testing	5.5	6	14	15	104.5	111	13	14
Decision theory	4.5	4	11	10	74.8	65	9	8
Minds and machines	2.8	1	7	2	66.5	30	8	4
Truth	7.2	5	18	12	98.8	50	13	6
Radical translation	3.2	3	8	7	72.3	95	9	12
Explanation	3.5	2	9	5	71.7	20	9	3
Personal identity	4.1	4	10	10	53.8	50	7	6
Speech acts	4.4	4	11	10	94.3	128	12	16
Sense and reference	6.6	11	16	27	137.2	245	17	31
Egalitarianism	3.3	4	8	10	74.4	98	9	12
Quantum physics	6.6	10	16	25	121.9	182	15	23
Theories and realism	6.7	6	17	15	118.7	120	15	15
Functions	2.2	2	6	5	38.7	12	5	2
Feminism	3.5	6	9	15	87.0	180	11	23
Medical ethics and Freud	3.5	4	9	10	58.1	67	7	9
Abortion and self-defence	3.6	4	9	10	81.3	98	10	12
Belief ascriptions	5.2	4	13	10	68.4	42	9	5
Thermodynamics	4.2	3	10	7	66.1	39	8	5
Knowledge	7.2	10	18	25	145.9	233	19	30
Game theory	2.3	2	6	5	47.6	30	6	4
Justification	12.3	17	30	42	208.7	294	26	37
Frankfurt cases	4.6	8	11	20	84.2	152	11	19
Concepts	5.0	2	12	5	116.9	49	15	6
Races and DNA	3.0	4	7	10	54.8	75	7	10
Modality	9.6	10	24	25	190.6	201	24	26
Reasons	7.3	7	18	17	168.5	155	21	20
Evolutionary biology	12.0	16	30	40	211.3	287	27	36
Population ethics	7.7	12	19	30	170.6	258	22	33
Formal epistemology	6.6	8	16	20	110.2	132	14	17
Wide content	5.6	6	14	15	120.1	117	15	15
Vagueness	6.0	5	15	12	78.9	70	10	9
Cognitive science	5.3	7	13	17	112.4	142	14	18
Models	8.8	13	22	32	135.0	169	17	21
Composition and constitution	17.4	24	43	60	350.6	493	44	63
Norms	11.1	6	28	15	288.9	148	37	19

2007

Table B.132: Measures of the prominence of each subject in 2007 ’s journals.

Subject	Weight	Raw	W-Ratio	R-Ratio	W-Pages	R-Pages	WP-Ratio	RP-Ratio
Psychology	0.5	0	1	0	11.7	0	1	0
Idealism	1.4	0	3	0	31.7	0	4	0
Life and value	1.4	0	3	0	30.5	0	4	0
Other history	3.3	2	8	5	65.5	33	8	4
Dewey and pragmatism	2.2	0	5	0	46.7	0	6	0
Definitions	2.8	0	6	0	49.7	0	6	0
Propositions and implications	3.7	1	9	2	56.7	3	7	0
Beauty	0.2	0	1	0	5.0	0	1	0
Physicalism	2.2	1	5	2	38.8	14	5	2
History and culture	0.8	0	2	0	16.2	0	2	0
Faith and theism	1.5	1	3	2	32.8	20	4	2
Self-consciousness	2.4	1	6	2	44.3	22	5	3
Ancient	1.4	1	3	2	28.8	23	4	3
Universals and particulars	2.3	0	5	0	46.0	0	6	0
Verification	1.1	0	3	0	18.5	0	2	0
Value	3.4	3	8	7	62.6	49	8	6
Deduction	4.8	4	11	9	94.0	60	12	7
Mechanisms	4.2	2	10	5	77.8	36	10	4
Temporal paradoxes	4.4	2	10	5	51.4	6	6	1
Classical space and time	3.5	1	8	2	67.2	36	8	4
Early modern	3.1	4	7	9	69.7	95	9	12
Meaning and use	2.1	0	5	0	36.0	0	4	0
Marx	2.3	0	5	0	51.4	0	6	0
Ordinary language	18.5	6	43	14	436.2	127	53	16
Moral conscience	3.3	3	8	7	66.0	57	8	7
Methodology of science	3.2	3	7	7	66.6	75	8	9
Heidegger and Husserl	0.4	0	1	0	9.2	0	1	0
Emotions	3.9	5	9	12	66.1	92	8	11
Ontological argument	4.9	4	11	9	75.1	94	9	12
Chemistry	5.1	7	12	16	97.9	135	12	17
Social contract theory	1.4	0	3	0	28.2	0	3	0
Kant	2.5	4	6	9	53.0	89	6	11
Promises and imperatives	3.2	1	7	2	69.9	10	9	1
Analytic/synthetic	3.0	1	7	2	50.6	9	6	1
Freedom and free will	2.8	1	6	2	60.7	31	7	4
Crime and punishment	3.0	4	7	9	44.1	46	5	6
Sets and grue	6.6	4	15	9	105.4	23	13	3
Origins and purposes	1.5	1	3	2	25.6	24	3	3
Time	5.0	8	12	19	75.6	115	9	14
Color/colour	6.4	10	15	23	91.2	140	11	17
War	2.0	2	5	5	34.0	32	4	4
Depiction	1.6	0	4	0	22.3	0	3	0
Denoting	3.7	5	9	12	78.1	141	10	17
Chance	8.7	15	20	35	173.9	336	21	41
Hume	3.1	4	7	9	57.8	98	7	12
Laws	2.7	2	6	5	40.3	10	5	1
Perception	5.1	6	12	14	107.8	138	13	17
Intention	3.8	5	9	12	83.2	120	10	15
Virtues	1.9	2	4	5	39.0	56	5	7
Space and time	4.6	7	11	16	83.8	134	10	16
Mathematics	5.9	5	14	12	106.3	104	13	13
Liberal democracy	4.5	5	10	12	125.5	159	15	19
Duties	2.2	1	5	2	44.9	23	5	3
Causation	6.2	4	14	9	128.5	86	16	11
Arguments	12.3	3	29	7	221.3	42	27	5
Theory testing	6.3	8	15	19	108.9	149	13	18
Decision theory	3.9	3	9	7	83.7	86	10	11
Minds and machines	4.2	4	10	9	84.2	78	10	10
Truth	8.0	8	19	19	115.4	115	14	14
Radical translation	6.8	13	16	30	143.8	284	18	35
Explanation	4.2	2	10	5	87.9	44	11	5
Personal identity	3.9	3	9	7	64.3	60	8	7
Speech acts	4.6	7	11	16	108.2	171	13	21
Sense and reference	7.8	12	18	28	159.9	247	20	30
Egalitarianism	6.4	10	15	23	177.8	296	22	36
Quantum physics	8.5	12	20	28	145.7	225	18	28
Theories and realism	5.6	4	13	9	110.9	70	14	9
Functions	3.6	1	8	2	64.9	15	8	2
Feminism	3.1	4	7	9	74.2	98	9	12
Medical ethics and Freud	3.6	4	8	9	64.7	48	8	6
Abortion and self-defence	2.7	3	6	7	51.7	51	6	6
Belief ascriptions	3.4	1	8	2	60.0	33	7	4
Thermodynamics	3.5	2	8	5	63.7	37	8	5
Knowledge	11.5	18	27	42	189.6	323	23	40
Game theory	5.3	9	12	21	93.4	148	11	18
Justification	14.6	18	34	42	236.6	277	29	34
Frankfurt cases	5.3	6	12	14	79.6	82	10	10
Concepts	4.1	2	9	5	81.5	14	10	2
Races and DNA	2.6	4	6	9	51.4	86	6	11
Modality	8.7	7	20	16	133.8	93	16	11
Reasons	10.3	13	24	30	224.8	328	28	40
Evolutionary biology	8.5	14	20	33	148.8	231	18	28
Population ethics	6.8	11	16	26	150.8	224	18	27
Formal epistemology	7.2	11	17	26	116.0	183	14	22
Wide content	5.3	5	12	12	101.7	112	12	14
Vagueness	7.2	9	17	21	112.1	133	14	16
Cognitive science	7.0	8	16	19	152.2	173	19	21
Models	10.3	12	24	28	208.8	217	26	27
Composition and constitution	13.0	17	30	40	193.3	212	24	26
Norms	14.2	14	33	33	325.9	285	40	35

2008

Table B.133: Measures of the prominence of each subject in 2008 ’s journals.

Subject	Weight	Raw	W-Ratio	R-Ratio	W-Pages	R-Pages	WP-Ratio	RP-Ratio
Psychology	0.7	1	2	2	21.8	35	3	4
Idealism	1.6	1	4	2	28.9	12	3	1
Life and value	2.4	0	6	0	53.6	0	6	0
Other history	2.1	0	5	0	42.9	0	5	0
Dewey and pragmatism	1.7	0	4	0	35.7	0	4	0
Definitions	2.3	0	5	0	43.0	0	5	0
Propositions and implications	4.3	2	10	5	70.9	47	9	6
Beauty	1.6	1	4	2	26.0	19	3	2
Physicalism	1.7	0	4	0	36.4	0	4	0
History and culture	0.8	1	2	2	19.1	31	2	4
Faith and theism	2.4	3	5	7	47.0	58	6	7
Self-consciousness	2.4	1	5	2	57.3	28	7	3
Ancient	1.2	1	3	2	32.4	51	4	6
Universals and particulars	1.8	0	4	0	34.0	0	4	0
Verification	0.9	0	2	0	17.8	0	2	0
Value	3.9	3	9	7	77.5	51	9	6
Deduction	4.9	4	11	9	63.5	36	8	4
Mechanisms	6.9	9	16	21	109.7	125	13	15
Temporal paradoxes	2.4	0	6	0	48.7	0	6	0
Classical space and time	2.0	0	5	0	35.4	0	4	0
Early modern	3.0	5	7	12	56.6	106	7	13
Meaning and use	2.2	0	5	0	44.0	0	5	0
Marx	3.7	2	8	5	64.6	24	8	3
Ordinary language	19.0	8	44	18	427.4	156	52	19
Moral conscience	4.8	4	11	9	86.6	63	10	8
Methodology of science	4.2	4	10	9	65.8	59	8	7
Heidegger and Husserl	0.4	0	1	0	10.1	0	1	0
Emotions	1.7	0	4	0	40.6	0	5	0
Ontological argument	2.2	2	5	5	42.3	43	5	5
Chemistry	5.6	6	13	14	77.4	82	9	10
Social contract theory	1.5	1	3	2	37.1	30	4	4
Kant	1.8	2	4	5	40.4	51	5	6
Promises and imperatives	4.0	1	9	2	85.6	8	10	1
Analytic/synthetic	2.0	1	5	2	32.1	3	4	0
Freedom and free will	3.8	2	9	5	55.6	18	7	2
Crime and punishment	4.5	9	10	21	81.2	161	10	19
Sets and grue	5.5	4	13	9	114.3	73	14	9
Origins and purposes	1.5	0	3	0	24.8	0	3	0
Time	3.2	4	7	9	45.0	45	5	5
Color/colour	1.9	1	4	2	47.3	28	6	3
War	3.1	6	7	14	77.1	176	9	21
Depiction	1.4	1	3	2	28.3	14	3	2
Denoting	3.6	7	8	16	71.7	138	9	17
Chance	6.6	6	15	14	102.4	70	12	8
Hume	2.4	3	5	7	44.0	68	5	8
Laws	3.4	3	8	7	64.8	65	8	8
Perception	4.8	5	11	12	113.6	128	14	16
Intention	3.2	3	7	7	65.7	66	8	8
Virtues	3.9	5	9	12	69.0	84	8	10
Space and time	5.3	9	12	21	97.8	170	12	21
Mathematics	3.9	3	9	7	63.6	41	8	5
Liberal democracy	4.1	5	10	12	96.6	135	12	16
Duties	2.6	1	6	2	63.7	44	8	5
Causation	4.6	5	11	12	77.5	64	9	8
Arguments	11.4	2	26	5	207.7	25	25	3
Theory testing	6.7	10	16	23	105.1	152	13	18
Decision theory	5.5	6	13	14	95.2	101	12	12
Minds and machines	4.6	5	11	12	97.0	146	12	18
Truth	9.6	9	22	21	125.7	96	15	12
Radical translation	4.2	6	10	14	98.4	186	12	23
Explanation	7.6	7	18	16	123.0	99	15	12
Personal identity	3.3	2	8	5	52.1	32	6	4
Speech acts	6.8	8	16	18	107.8	135	13	16
Sense and reference	5.8	4	13	9	104.3	64	13	8
Egalitarianism	4.7	6	11	14	126.7	177	15	21
Quantum physics	5.8	8	13	18	127.5	186	15	23
Theories and realism	5.7	3	13	7	91.8	44	11	5
Functions	2.1	0	5	0	34.6	0	4	0
Feminism	3.8	6	9	14	68.0	114	8	14
Medical ethics and Freud	2.9	5	7	12	46.3	77	6	9
Abortion and self-defence	5.7	8	13	18	107.6	151	13	18
Belief ascriptions	2.9	2	7	5	55.0	72	7	9
Thermodynamics	4.4	4	10	9	74.7	60	9	7
Knowledge	12.9	21	30	48	219.6	326	27	39
Game theory	6.4	9	15	21	115.7	168	14	20
Justification	11.7	14	27	32	218.5	276	26	33
Frankfurt cases	9.4	17	22	39	164.0	322	20	39
Concepts	5.2	6	12	14	107.8	118	13	14
Races and DNA	5.7	9	13	21	105.2	195	13	24
Modality	10.5	12	24	28	194.6	189	24	23
Reasons	10.4	16	24	37	229.4	382	28	46
Evolutionary biology	12.3	16	28	37	224.9	310	27	38
Population ethics	5.3	5	12	12	119.8	125	15	15
Formal epistemology	8.1	10	19	23	162.0	202	20	24
Wide content	3.4	1	8	2	79.2	37	10	4
Vagueness	6.4	9	15	21	86.4	124	10	15
Cognitive science	10.6	12	24	28	235.8	284	29	34
Models	8.1	7	19	16	154.9	125	19	15
Composition and constitution	11.7	16	27	37	234.6	283	28	34
Norms	14.1	7	33	16	340.5	168	41	20

2009

Table B.134: Measures of the prominence of each subject in 2009 ’s journals.

Subject	Weight	Raw	W-Ratio	R-Ratio	W-Pages	R-Pages	WP-Ratio	RP-Ratio
Psychology	0.3	0	1	0	5.6	0	1	0
Idealism	1.3	0	3	0	26.3	0	3	0
Life and value	2.1	0	5	0	49.7	0	6	0
Other history	2.7	0	6	0	62.1	0	7	0
Dewey and pragmatism	2.1	0	5	0	46.1	0	5	0
Definitions	2.7	0	6	0	57.3	0	7	0
Propositions and implications	4.3	0	10	0	71.0	0	8	0
Beauty	1.7	3	4	7	19.5	37	2	4
Physicalism	2.7	1	6	2	57.8	19	7	2
History and culture	0.8	0	2	0	12.6	0	1	0
Faith and theism	1.2	0	3	0	17.6	0	2	0
Self-consciousness	2.0	1	5	2	42.1	32	5	4
Ancient	1.2	3	3	7	29.1	72	3	9
Universals and particulars	2.6	1	6	2	49.4	10	6	1
Verification	1.4	1	3	2	22.8	4	3	0
Value	3.3	3	7	7	62.4	69	7	8
Deduction	5.3	6	12	14	89.7	89	11	11
Mechanisms	4.0	2	9	5	77.6	56	9	7
Temporal paradoxes	4.2	2	10	5	56.4	10	7	1
Classical space and time	3.1	1	7	2	57.5	17	7	2
Early modern	3.2	4	7	9	100.6	134	12	16
Meaning and use	1.7	0	4	0	34.1	0	4	0
Marx	2.5	0	6	0	47.7	0	6	0
Ordinary language	17.5	4	40	9	399.3	102	47	12
Moral conscience	3.8	3	9	7	83.8	75	10	9
Methodology of science	3.9	2	9	5	77.1	54	9	6
Heidegger and Husserl	0.3	0	1	0	5.1	0	1	0
Emotions	2.2	3	5	7	46.7	61	6	7
Ontological argument	3.3	1	7	2	48.0	14	6	2
Chemistry	4.2	7	10	16	85.1	160	10	19
Social contract theory	1.8	2	4	5	40.9	52	5	6
Kant	2.2	4	5	9	49.6	87	6	10
Promises and imperatives	3.6	1	8	2	65.4	5	8	1
Analytic/synthetic	3.4	4	8	9	69.8	94	8	11
Freedom and free will	4.3	3	10	7	92.1	69	11	8
Crime and punishment	2.3	4	5	9	36.6	64	4	8
Sets and grue	6.9	4	16	9	120.6	44	14	5
Origins and purposes	2.1	1	5	2	44.3	29	5	3
Time	3.1	3	7	7	52.6	61	6	7
Color/colour	4.0	4	9	9	68.2	79	8	9
War	3.3	5	7	11	68.2	109	8	13
Depiction	2.0	2	4	5	50.9	58	6	7
Denoting	2.7	2	6	5	46.9	47	6	6
Chance	4.5	4	10	9	87.8	101	10	12
Hume	2.7	5	6	11	74.2	155	9	18
Laws	2.5	1	6	2	54.3	34	6	4
Perception	12.0	20	27	45	236.1	376	28	45
Intention	5.4	9	12	20	99.9	154	12	18
Virtues	2.0	1	5	2	38.5	7	5	1
Space and time	5.9	9	13	20	115.9	169	14	20
Mathematics	4.9	6	11	14	79.0	81	9	10
Liberal democracy	5.8	7	13	16	160.9	219	19	26
Duties	4.1	2	9	5	89.2	53	11	6
Causation	6.6	6	15	14	119.7	129	14	15
Arguments	13.5	3	31	7	268.9	84	32	10
Theory testing	8.3	10	19	23	135.3	147	16	17
Decision theory	2.9	2	7	5	41.1	15	5	2
Minds and machines	4.1	4	9	9	72.8	49	9	6
Truth	10.2	12	23	27	153.9	157	18	19
Radical translation	4.8	7	11	16	95.5	144	11	17
Explanation	6.8	8	15	18	131.5	150	16	18
Personal identity	2.9	1	7	2	49.9	16	6	2
Speech acts	4.9	7	11	16	101.0	141	12	17
Sense and reference	5.8	9	13	20	113.5	186	13	22
Egalitarianism	4.6	5	10	11	110.0	121	13	14
Quantum physics	7.3	10	16	23	125.1	180	15	21
Theories and realism	6.6	5	15	11	120.9	101	14	12
Functions	3.1	2	7	5	61.6	41	7	5
Feminism	2.7	4	6	9	53.3	71	6	8
Medical ethics and Freud	2.3	3	5	7	44.1	62	5	7
Abortion and self-defence	5.5	8	13	18	92.8	100	11	12
Belief ascriptions	4.2	5	10	11	70.6	85	8	10
Thermodynamics	4.3	4	10	9	79.4	70	9	8
Knowledge	10.4	12	24	27	185.5	187	22	22
Game theory	2.1	1	5	2	37.8	28	4	3
Justification	10.8	12	25	27	179.5	199	21	24
Frankfurt cases	5.9	7	13	16	102.3	119	12	14
Concepts	6.1	5	14	11	136.3	122	16	14
Races and DNA	4.6	6	10	14	76.5	116	9	14
Modality	11.5	13	26	30	187.3	193	22	23
Reasons	12.1	18	27	41	238.3	371	28	44
Evolutionary biology	10.8	18	24	41	192.7	312	23	37
Population ethics	5.7	5	13	11	128.2	118	15	14
Formal epistemology	8.3	13	19	30	116.4	166	14	20
Wide content	5.4	4	12	9	121.7	99	14	12
Vagueness	6.1	8	14	18	85.1	124	10	15
Cognitive science	7.6	10	17	23	181.6	273	22	32
Models	5.9	4	13	9	109.2	56	13	7
Composition and constitution	16.9	21	38	48	261.8	353	31	42
Norms	15.7	17	36	39	379.7	396	45	47

2010

Table B.135: Measures of the prominence of each subject in 2010 ’s journals.

Subject	Weight	Raw	W-Ratio	R-Ratio	W-Pages	R-Pages	WP-Ratio	RP-Ratio
Psychology	1.1	0	2	0	16.4	0	2	0
Idealism	1.4	0	3	0	33.1	0	4	0
Life and value	2.4	0	5	0	53.7	0	6	0
Other history	3.0	2	6	4	48.7	21	5	2
Dewey and pragmatism	1.8	0	4	0	45.0	0	5	0
Definitions	1.9	0	4	0	38.1	0	4	0
Propositions and implications	4.1	1	9	2	64.6	5	7	1
Beauty	2.6	4	5	9	33.7	70	4	8
Physicalism	2.9	2	6	4	49.9	53	6	6
History and culture	0.6	0	1	0	14.1	0	2	0
Faith and theism	1.5	1	3	2	22.2	12	3	1
Self-consciousness	2.9	2	6	4	53.3	25	6	3
Ancient	1.2	1	3	2	27.6	24	3	3
Universals and particulars	2.4	0	5	0	45.8	0	5	0
Verification	1.2	0	3	0	21.7	0	2	0
Value	4.3	4	9	9	81.2	63	9	7
Deduction	6.0	7	13	15	94.7	91	11	10
Mechanisms	4.8	1	10	2	101.2	11	11	1
Temporal paradoxes	3.6	1	8	2	57.6	27	6	3
Classical space and time	3.5	1	8	2	62.0	16	7	2
Early modern	2.8	4	6	9	86.5	137	10	15
Meaning and use	1.4	0	3	0	26.4	0	3	0
Marx	2.1	0	5	0	43.8	0	5	0
Ordinary language	19.9	11	43	24	436.2	285	49	32
Moral conscience	3.8	4	8	9	86.4	100	10	11
Methodology of science	2.9	2	6	4	57.9	51	7	6
Heidegger and Husserl	0.6	0	1	0	15.8	0	2	0
Emotions	3.6	6	8	13	75.5	136	9	15
Ontological argument	4.2	2	9	4	69.8	23	8	3
Chemistry	6.7	8	14	17	109.9	142	12	16
Social contract theory	1.4	0	3	0	30.0	0	3	0
Kant	2.9	5	6	11	83.2	146	9	16
Promises and imperatives	3.5	0	8	0	64.5	0	7	0
Analytic/synthetic	2.8	2	6	4	52.4	34	6	4
Freedom and free will	3.1	3	7	6	66.9	68	8	8
Crime and punishment	2.4	3	5	6	49.2	55	6	6
Sets and grue	8.5	4	18	9	170.9	54	19	6
Origins and purposes	2.0	0	4	0	35.0	0	4	0
Time	4.5	5	10	11	48.8	38	6	4
Color/colour	3.8	4	8	9	56.0	51	6	6
War	2.5	5	5	11	62.3	144	7	16
Depiction	2.5	4	5	9	46.7	112	5	13
Denoting	3.0	4	6	9	64.4	106	7	12
Chance	6.8	9	15	19	106.6	126	12	14
Hume	1.2	0	3	0	29.4	0	3	0
Laws	2.6	2	6	4	51.0	56	6	6
Perception	8.4	10	18	21	167.2	183	19	21
Intention	4.6	7	10	15	67.0	97	8	11
Virtues	3.5	4	8	9	70.1	88	8	10
Space and time	3.7	5	8	11	76.0	101	9	11
Mathematics	6.6	11	14	24	107.8	171	12	19
Liberal democracy	5.7	7	12	15	152.1	180	17	20
Duties	6.0	9	13	19	148.7	251	17	28
Causation	7.3	3	16	6	125.4	39	14	4
Arguments	13.7	2	29	4	234.4	25	26	3
Theory testing	6.5	7	14	15	117.1	113	13	13
Decision theory	5.3	7	11	15	98.1	119	11	13
Minds and machines	4.2	4	9	9	79.3	84	9	9
Truth	11.2	14	24	30	129.3	138	15	16
Radical translation	4.6	6	10	13	112.8	171	13	19
Explanation	6.1	5	13	11	128.1	118	14	13
Personal identity	4.8	6	10	13	63.6	66	7	7
Speech acts	7.2	9	15	19	117.1	137	13	15
Sense and reference	4.0	2	9	4	57.5	22	6	2
Egalitarianism	4.3	5	9	11	125.0	147	14	17
Quantum physics	5.6	6	12	13	113.6	117	13	13
Theories and realism	5.4	3	12	6	104.2	62	12	7
Functions	3.4	2	7	4	69.3	26	8	3
Feminism	2.1	3	5	6	60.2	112	7	13
Medical ethics and Freud	2.1	2	4	4	42.9	34	5	4
Abortion and self-defence	3.4	3	7	6	53.7	33	6	4
Belief ascriptions	5.9	6	13	13	78.7	72	9	8
Thermodynamics	4.3	3	9	6	84.6	63	10	7
Knowledge	13.9	20	30	43	216.2	290	24	33
Game theory	3.6	4	8	9	57.2	67	6	8
Justification	12.9	17	28	36	237.5	303	27	34
Frankfurt cases	7.1	8	15	17	115.0	144	13	16
Concepts	5.1	4	11	9	107.0	87	12	10
Races and DNA	0.6	0	1	0	9.7	0	1	0
Modality	12.0	13	26	28	209.7	200	24	23
Reasons	8.4	10	18	21	187.5	248	21	28
Evolutionary biology	12.6	21	27	45	211.3	334	24	38
Population ethics	5.8	3	12	6	142.1	60	16	7
Formal epistemology	10.6	15	23	32	232.9	359	26	41
Wide content	5.6	4	12	9	106.5	87	12	10
Vagueness	6.7	9	14	19	100.6	126	11	14
Cognitive science	9.9	15	21	32	218.0	340	25	38
Models	9.2	13	20	28	183.2	258	21	29
Composition and constitution	20.1	28	43	60	363.7	544	41	61
Norms	17.3	17	37	36	391.9	366	44	41

2011

Table B.136: Measures of the prominence of each subject in 2011 ’s journals.

Subject	Weight	Raw	W-Ratio	R-Ratio	W-Pages	R-Pages	WP-Ratio	RP-Ratio
Psychology	0.7	0	2	0	15.8	0	2	0
Idealism	1.6	0	4	0	31.2	0	3	0
Life and value	2.1	1	5	2	43.1	16	5	2
Other history	3.2	2	7	4	67.7	16	7	2
Dewey and pragmatism	1.8	0	4	0	38.8	0	4	0
Definitions	1.9	0	4	0	42.7	0	5	0
Propositions and implications	3.9	2	9	4	92.1	87	10	10
Beauty	2.1	5	5	11	38.9	83	4	9
Physicalism	3.2	4	7	9	60.3	105	7	12
History and culture	1.2	0	3	0	21.7	0	2	0
Faith and theism	2.9	4	6	9	42.2	59	5	6
Self-consciousness	4.1	3	9	7	70.3	41	8	4
Ancient	1.3	1	3	2	30.3	21	3	2
Universals and particulars	2.6	2	6	4	56.0	53	6	6
Verification	1.2	0	3	0	23.8	0	3	0
Value	3.5	2	8	4	76.7	57	8	6
Deduction	4.2	4	9	9	73.0	40	8	4
Mechanisms	5.8	4	13	9	107.7	78	12	9
Temporal paradoxes	3.3	2	7	4	58.7	42	6	5
Classical space and time	3.9	2	9	4	72.0	30	8	3
Early modern	2.3	4	5	9	59.4	112	7	12
Meaning and use	2.9	3	6	7	57.6	83	6	9
Marx	3.0	0	7	0	60.5	0	7	0
Ordinary language	17.3	3	38	7	427.7	77	47	8
Moral conscience	2.9	2	6	4	69.1	36	8	4
Methodology of science	3.9	2	9	4	78.3	39	9	4
Heidegger and Husserl	0.4	0	1	0	8.1	0	1	0
Emotions	1.3	0	3	0	28.9	0	3	0
Ontological argument	3.4	1	7	2	47.1	2	5	0
Chemistry	6.2	7	14	15	111.5	130	12	14
Social contract theory	3.0	3	7	7	43.7	12	5	1
Kant	2.7	5	6	11	49.0	72	5	8
Promises and imperatives	3.4	1	7	2	72.4	3	8	0
Analytic/synthetic	5.2	7	11	15	110.2	168	12	18
Freedom and free will	3.6	3	8	7	72.0	55	8	6
Crime and punishment	1.9	2	4	4	56.6	65	6	7
Sets and grue	6.2	4	14	9	120.7	76	13	8
Origins and purposes	2.6	1	6	2	31.6	5	3	1
Time	3.9	7	9	15	58.8	72	6	8
Color/colour	2.9	2	6	4	61.0	29	7	3
War	2.5	3	5	7	65.2	97	7	11
Depiction	3.0	4	7	9	58.8	73	6	8
Denoting	3.6	2	8	4	83.7	96	9	11
Chance	7.1	9	16	20	124.4	127	14	14
Hume	2.1	3	5	7	48.0	82	5	9
Laws	5.2	6	11	13	84.5	92	9	10
Perception	10.2	17	22	37	239.5	440	26	48
Intention	2.8	2	6	4	45.1	29	5	3
Virtues	2.5	4	6	9	68.5	104	8	11
Space and time	7.5	10	16	22	130.6	197	14	22
Mathematics	4.7	5	10	11	85.4	99	9	11
Liberal democracy	5.7	9	13	20	165.4	267	18	29
Duties	2.7	1	6	2	64.7	19	7	2
Causation	7.8	7	17	15	139.6	112	15	12
Arguments	13.4	1	29	2	266.5	23	29	3
Theory testing	8.6	10	19	22	164.9	187	18	20
Decision theory	5.0	8	11	18	86.1	115	9	13
Minds and machines	3.9	3	9	7	62.8	19	7	2
Truth	9.7	10	21	22	119.8	103	13	11
Radical translation	4.7	5	10	11	100.9	92	11	10
Explanation	9.0	8	20	18	161.2	148	18	16
Personal identity	3.9	6	9	13	70.3	112	8	12
Speech acts	4.5	4	10	9	63.0	36	7	4
Sense and reference	6.3	8	14	18	148.2	208	16	23
Egalitarianism	3.5	6	8	13	94.1	164	10	18
Quantum physics	6.7	9	15	20	131.9	166	14	18
Theories and realism	8.5	8	19	18	137.2	129	15	14
Functions	2.4	1	5	2	49.2	24	5	3
Feminism	1.8	2	4	4	37.0	31	4	3
Medical ethics and Freud	3.5	5	8	11	56.7	72	6	8
Abortion and self-defence	4.2	6	9	13	100.7	169	11	19
Belief ascriptions	4.4	3	10	7	107.5	101	12	11
Thermodynamics	8.1	11	18	24	148.7	189	16	21
Knowledge	10.3	13	23	29	197.2	259	22	28
Game theory	3.3	4	7	9	49.2	68	5	7
Justification	11.2	11	25	24	232.0	240	25	26
Frankfurt cases	5.9	8	13	18	120.1	219	13	24
Concepts	6.0	7	13	15	146.3	184	16	20
Races and DNA	4.2	5	9	11	68.1	84	7	9
Modality	14.3	15	31	33	258.7	283	28	31
Reasons	8.3	12	18	26	176.9	246	19	27
Evolutionary biology	7.3	10	16	22	134.7	181	15	20
Population ethics	4.9	4	11	9	127.2	97	14	11
Formal epistemology	7.2	10	16	22	141.8	218	16	24
Wide content	6.0	3	13	7	142.1	55	16	6
Vagueness	6.0	7	13	15	89.0	82	10	9
Cognitive science	9.6	15	21	33	202.1	363	22	40
Models	7.8	10	17	22	138.3	148	15	16
Composition and constitution	14.6	14	32	31	269.4	224	30	25
Norms	16.1	17	35	37	432.5	486	47	53

2012

Table B.137: Measures of the prominence of each subject in 2012 ’s journals.

Subject	Weight	Raw	W-Ratio	R-Ratio	W-Pages	R-Pages	WP-Ratio	RP-Ratio
Psychology	0.3	0	1	0	7.6	0	1	0
Idealism	0.7	0	2	0	16.8	0	2	0
Life and value	2.2	1	5	2	49.7	33	6	4
Other history	3.5	2	8	5	67.7	22	8	3
Dewey and pragmatism	2.3	0	5	0	40.5	0	5	0
Definitions	2.0	0	5	0	42.2	0	5	0
Propositions and implications	4.1	3	10	7	73.3	21	9	3
Beauty	2.3	4	6	10	42.8	82	5	10
Physicalism	2.3	1	5	2	40.9	23	5	3
History and culture	0.6	0	1	0	12.7	0	2	0
Faith and theism	1.4	0	3	0	19.8	0	2	0
Self-consciousness	2.0	2	5	5	41.9	37	5	4
Ancient	1.3	2	3	5	30.2	47	4	6
Universals and particulars	1.7	0	4	0	41.5	0	5	0
Verification	1.3	0	3	0	24.8	0	3	0
Value	3.5	2	8	5	63.5	14	8	2
Deduction	3.9	2	9	5	54.2	17	6	2
Mechanisms	4.3	3	10	7	95.7	58	11	7
Temporal paradoxes	2.8	2	7	5	49.5	12	6	1
Classical space and time	3.2	2	8	5	73.9	48	9	6
Early modern	3.0	5	7	12	82.0	140	10	17
Meaning and use	2.0	1	5	2	39.8	9	5	1
Marx	3.1	2	7	5	60.6	29	7	3
Ordinary language	15.5	5	37	12	375.3	133	45	16
Moral conscience	2.9	2	7	5	68.2	63	8	8
Methodology of science	4.4	2	11	5	72.1	23	9	3
Heidegger and Husserl	0.4	0	1	0	8.6	0	1	0
Emotions	3.3	3	8	7	70.1	55	8	7
Ontological argument	2.8	1	7	2	51.1	5	6	1
Chemistry	2.2	2	5	5	39.2	32	5	4
Social contract theory	1.4	2	3	5	32.5	51	4	6
Kant	1.9	5	5	12	55.2	158	7	19
Promises and imperatives	3.6	2	9	5	71.7	14	9	2
Analytic/synthetic	1.5	0	3	0	30.3	0	4	0
Freedom and free will	3.9	6	9	14	99.1	183	12	22
Crime and punishment	1.7	1	4	2	38.6	23	5	3
Sets and grue	7.9	7	19	17	177.2	195	21	23
Origins and purposes	1.4	0	3	0	18.6	0	2	0
Time	3.3	2	8	5	45.7	16	5	2
Color/colour	2.6	4	6	10	53.2	64	6	8
War	1.4	0	3	0	28.5	0	3	0
Depiction	4.2	6	10	14	67.8	91	8	11
Denoting	4.0	6	10	14	78.9	170	9	20
Chance	6.5	8	16	19	112.5	117	13	14
Hume	1.5	1	3	2	25.6	22	3	3
Laws	2.9	4	7	10	58.8	94	7	11
Perception	6.7	7	16	17	137.2	139	16	17
Intention	2.2	2	5	5	50.6	48	6	6
Virtues	2.6	3	6	7	64.6	86	8	10
Space and time	2.6	4	6	10	60.6	100	7	12
Mathematics	5.3	8	13	19	99.7	131	12	16
Liberal democracy	3.3	3	8	7	79.2	82	9	10
Duties	4.1	4	10	10	91.7	83	11	10
Causation	5.6	5	14	12	86.8	37	10	4
Arguments	11.7	3	28	7	207.1	44	25	5
Theory testing	7.8	8	19	19	125.2	111	15	13
Decision theory	4.0	5	10	12	79.2	83	9	10
Minds and machines	3.4	1	8	2	64.0	8	8	1
Truth	9.1	9	22	22	110.0	74	13	9
Radical translation	2.8	3	7	7	64.6	72	8	9
Explanation	7.5	7	18	17	160.6	174	19	21
Personal identity	3.8	5	9	12	64.3	70	8	8
Speech acts	6.4	7	15	17	152.3	192	18	23
Sense and reference	5.0	5	12	12	109.6	113	13	13
Egalitarianism	5.4	7	13	17	115.6	162	14	19
Quantum physics	5.6	7	13	17	140.9	178	17	21
Theories and realism	4.8	4	11	10	84.8	65	10	8
Functions	3.9	3	9	7	74.0	38	9	5
Feminism	2.4	2	6	5	60.9	71	7	8
Medical ethics and Freud	3.7	5	9	12	80.2	105	10	13
Abortion and self-defence	4.0	5	10	12	78.9	100	9	12
Belief ascriptions	5.7	5	14	12	88.5	78	11	9
Thermodynamics	4.1	5	10	12	84.0	90	10	11
Knowledge	10.7	18	26	43	193.4	343	23	41
Game theory	4.6	2	11	5	86.0	43	10	5
Justification	11.3	14	27	33	215.2	276	26	33
Frankfurt cases	6.8	10	16	24	144.2	212	17	25
Concepts	4.6	2	11	5	111.6	43	13	5
Races and DNA	4.1	5	10	12	78.1	87	9	10
Modality	13.8	17	33	41	262.5	345	31	41
Reasons	7.7	12	19	29	185.8	296	22	35
Evolutionary biology	9.7	15	23	36	198.3	321	24	38
Population ethics	6.0	6	14	14	135.2	135	16	16
Formal epistemology	15.9	26	38	62	274.1	479	33	57
Wide content	3.9	2	9	5	89.4	60	11	7
Vagueness	4.8	6	11	14	70.5	101	8	12
Cognitive science	7.1	10	17	24	181.0	274	22	33
Models	7.7	6	19	14	149.2	109	18	13
Composition and constitution	13.4	16	32	38	246.0	273	29	33
Norms	17.4	16	42	38	412.6	367	49	44

2013

Table B.138: Measures of the prominence of each subject in 2013 ’s journals.

Subject	Weight	Raw	W-Ratio	R-Ratio	W-Pages	R-Pages	WP-Ratio	RP-Ratio
Psychology	1.3	1	3	2	25.1	9	3	1
Idealism	1.9	1	4	2	35.1	5	4	1
Life and value	2.4	0	5	0	50.3	0	6	0
Other history	4.0	2	9	5	79.3	42	9	5
Dewey and pragmatism	2.2	1	5	2	45.2	10	5	1
Definitions	1.6	0	4	0	35.7	0	4	0
Propositions and implications	3.4	0	8	0	65.0	0	7	0
Beauty	2.1	4	5	9	37.2	79	4	9
Physicalism	1.9	1	4	2	37.1	18	4	2
History and culture	1.0	0	2	0	23.4	0	3	0
Faith and theism	1.1	0	2	0	14.8	0	2	0
Self-consciousness	2.1	1	5	2	33.6	10	4	1
Ancient	1.4	1	3	2	36.6	46	4	5
Universals and particulars	1.8	0	4	0	35.7	0	4	0
Verification	1.2	0	3	0	18.7	0	2	0
Value	3.7	3	8	7	73.9	52	8	6
Deduction	4.2	5	9	11	78.5	95	9	11
Mechanisms	6.1	7	14	16	106.8	116	12	13
Temporal paradoxes	3.9	2	9	5	83.4	72	9	8
Classical space and time	3.7	1	8	2	65.7	12	7	1
Early modern	3.9	7	9	16	112.3	199	13	22
Meaning and use	1.4	1	3	2	30.3	19	3	2
Marx	3.7	0	8	0	77.4	0	9	0
Ordinary language	16.4	5	37	11	377.5	118	43	13
Moral conscience	3.4	4	8	9	55.0	50	6	6
Methodology of science	3.9	3	9	7	68.0	46	8	5
Heidegger and Husserl	1.8	3	4	7	52.0	94	6	11
Emotions	1.1	1	3	2	18.0	11	2	1
Ontological argument	3.1	1	7	2	42.7	2	5	0
Chemistry	3.9	6	9	14	76.8	112	9	13
Social contract theory	1.7	0	4	0	35.2	0	4	0
Kant	1.3	0	3	0	26.0	0	3	0
Promises and imperatives	4.6	2	10	5	95.9	50	11	6
Analytic/synthetic	1.8	0	4	0	29.8	0	3	0
Freedom and free will	4.9	6	11	14	89.3	109	10	12
Crime and punishment	1.9	1	4	2	39.8	11	4	1
Sets and grue	7.9	5	18	11	147.6	45	17	5
Origins and purposes	1.1	0	2	0	22.5	0	3	0
Time	3.6	6	8	14	66.4	104	7	12
Color/colour	2.0	1	5	2	44.8	22	5	2
War	2.2	2	5	5	46.5	39	5	4
Depiction	3.4	5	8	11	73.9	111	8	13
Denoting	1.7	2	4	5	32.7	34	4	4
Chance	8.4	11	19	25	139.0	163	16	18
Hume	1.6	1	3	2	33.6	15	4	2
Laws	2.8	2	6	5	51.4	42	6	5
Perception	7.4	8	17	18	170.4	205	19	23
Intention	3.6	5	8	11	68.6	93	8	11
Virtues	2.5	3	6	7	50.6	70	6	8
Space and time	4.4	6	10	14	70.8	85	8	10
Mathematics	3.4	3	8	7	61.9	53	7	6
Liberal democracy	4.8	7	11	16	133.6	208	15	23
Duties	7.3	11	16	25	160.3	246	18	28
Causation	4.9	0	11	0	97.7	0	11	0
Arguments	13.0	3	29	7	233.2	21	26	2
Theory testing	10.1	15	23	34	185.8	265	21	30
Decision theory	6.7	3	15	7	127.1	60	14	7
Minds and machines	3.4	1	8	2	74.8	21	8	2
Truth	8.2	9	19	20	138.7	190	16	21
Radical translation	5.1	7	11	16	91.4	113	10	13
Explanation	6.9	8	16	18	127.5	138	14	16
Personal identity	4.5	6	10	14	64.0	79	7	9
Speech acts	5.5	8	12	18	135.3	228	15	26
Sense and reference	6.3	11	14	25	160.6	280	18	32
Egalitarianism	5.2	8	12	18	111.4	170	13	19
Quantum physics	6.5	9	15	20	124.2	182	14	21
Theories and realism	6.5	3	15	7	118.1	62	13	7
Functions	2.9	2	7	5	49.1	20	6	2
Feminism	3.7	5	8	11	73.3	113	8	13
Medical ethics and Freud	3.4	3	8	7	57.3	55	6	6
Abortion and self-defence	1.4	0	3	0	28.4	0	3	0
Belief ascriptions	4.9	3	11	7	109.2	61	12	7
Thermodynamics	4.9	5	11	11	78.4	61	9	7
Knowledge	10.2	12	23	27	193.3	195	22	22
Game theory	6.6	9	15	20	119.7	169	14	19
Justification	13.3	18	30	41	257.7	422	29	48
Frankfurt cases	8.8	14	20	32	149.6	248	17	28
Concepts	4.3	3	10	7	97.0	53	11	6
Races and DNA	5.3	8	12	18	78.2	104	9	12
Modality	9.7	12	22	27	213.8	243	24	27
Reasons	6.6	7	15	16	140.4	163	16	18
Evolutionary biology	8.4	12	19	27	145.2	209	16	24
Population ethics	5.9	8	13	18	119.1	151	13	17
Formal epistemology	12.6	22	28	50	306.1	571	35	64
Wide content	3.8	1	8	2	80.2	33	9	4
Vagueness	3.0	2	7	5	51.1	26	6	3
Cognitive science	10.8	17	24	38	216.5	370	24	42
Models	10.3	12	23	27	202.9	229	23	26
Composition and constitution	12.3	13	28	29	256.4	284	29	32
Norms	19.9	17	45	38	460.6	344	52	39