2.7 Propositions and Implications

Category: Logic and Mathematics

Keywords: propositions, proposition, entailment, implication, contradictory, entails, negation, entail, disjunction, denial, propositional, negative, contradiction, conjunction, implies

Number of Articles: 480
Percentage of Total: 1.5%
Rank: 13th

Weighted Number of Articles: 480.8
Percentage of Total: 1.5%
Rank: 13th

Mean Publication Year: 1952
Weighted Mean Publication Year: 1960.8
Median Publication Year: 1955
Modal Publication Year: 1969

Topic with Most Overlap: Deduction (0.0551)
Topic this Overlaps Most With: Deduction (0.0429)
Topic with Least Overlap: Evolutionary Biology (0.00023)
Topic this Overlaps Least With: Evolutionary Biology (0.00071)

Propositions and Implications

Figure 2.25: Propositions and Implications

Propositions and Implications Articles in Each Journal

Figure 2.26: Propositions and Implications Articles in Each Journal

Comments

Note that the scale in the second graph is thrown off by the very high numbers from the early years of Analysis. This is, as you can see at the top of the page, one of the larger topics in the study, despite the graphs looking quite low.

This overlaps a lot with Deduction. Indeed, it is possibly best to simply regard them as part of the same topic. Fortunately if you want to do that, you don’t have to do much more than change the scales on the graphs, because their distribution over time, and over journals, is pretty similar.

This topic gets ‘implication’ rather than ‘validity’ (which is moved to deduction). And so the logical works in it are a touch earlier. But it also gets ‘proposition’, so it picks up a bit more weight from more contemporary work on propositions. Here, for instance, is the table for Jeff King’s paper “Designating Propositions”.

Table 2.4: Jeffrey C. King (2002) “Designating Propositions” Philosophical Review 111:341-371.
Subject Probability
Sense and Reference 0.4068
Propositions and Implications 0.1335
Ordinary Language 0.0935
Mathematics 0.0542
Deduction 0.0466
Belief Ascriptions 0.0430
Sets and Grue 0.0365
Truth 0.0307
Norms 0.0270
Composition and Constitution 0.0233
Explanation 0.0203

It mostly goes with Sense and Reference. That topic, despite its Fregean name, appears much later in our story. But note that the model can’t quite shake the idea that it should be placed in this topic. It’s this kind of assessment that keeps the graphs for this topic from really collapsing.