"A Colossal Error in Judgement."
Kerry 1, Bush 0.
I'm partisan, but as a debater I say that he left no significant point unchallenged while putting Dubya on the defensive for 90 minutes. He even worked at disassembling some rightwing lies.
Kerry looked presidential as he skewered Bush. Some people feared that he would go on at length with difficult-to-follow answers while Bush would have some "there you go again" zinger, but Kerry spoke plainly and directly. It's as though he reverted to his role as a prosecutor in Massachusetts. Bush, on the other hand, was often at a loss for words as he hunched over the lecturn, searching for a response. Early on, he repeated a few stock phrases when he lost his verbal footing. "It's hard work!" he said several times referring to rebuilding Iraq and keeping it secure. Sure, Mister President, any task out of your league is hard.
Two points I wanted Kerry to rebut were on the security forces in Iraq and Libya's disarmament. Bush repeated 100,000 as the number of Iraqis in the security forces. Last I heard, a third of those--the foreign-trained police--have not actually been trained yet. Maybe 5,000 have been trained so far. Moreover, it has been reported that Iraqi security forces turn a blind eye to the kidnappers and the insurgents, and some even switch sides. Yes, Virginia, we're arming the insurgency. So, even if 100,000 is the correct number, it's a force of questionable effectiveness.
On Libya, Bush claimed credit, again, for Libya's disarmament. He wants people to believe that Gadaffi turned over his bio and chemical weapons because the fall of Saddam struck fear into his heart. Such BS deserves its own special pasture. The international community, including the U.S. under Bill Clinton, has been working on Libya to turn itself around. Gadaffi has wanted to remove all the trade sanctions and modernize his country. (Not that Gadaffi is an altruist; making the populace happy reduces his own chance of being assassinated.) Moreover, by taking undue credit, Bush disses Britain, France, and the leaders of the Middle East who did all the heavy lifting with Libya.
Those are minor points, however. Kerry said, at least twice, that Bush was misleading Americans about Kerry's stance on Iraq. Kerry said that he was consistent, and he made the point well. Kerry also bitch-slapped Bush on Tora-Bora and the escape of OBL. Speaking about handing over the search to Afghani warlords, Kerry said that Bush "outsourced that job, too." Ouch!
Kerry also gave a short, sweet explanation of how Dubya has screwed up our relations with N. Korea. We had observers, we had cameras in their nuclear reactors. Bush obliterated the agreement that Clinton had made with them, causing the eviction of the observers and the cameras. So, Bush went after imaginary WMD in Iraq while allowing the creation of actual nuclear weapons in N. Korea. Kerry made this point clearly and scored .
Oh, and another lie I wish Kerry had taken up (but didn't have time for) was Bush's assertion that they had broken the AQ Khan "ring." AQ Khan of Pakistan had been providing startup labs to countries to develop nuclear weapons. In fact, Khan was the supplier for N. Korea. Pervez Musharref pardoned Khan, with the blessing of the Bush Administration. (All of this was to ensure that Pakistan, which sponsored this money-making business in covert nuke development programs, would continue to "support" us in Afghanistan.) Nothing prevents Khan from starting it up again the next time the winds shift.
Anyway... tonight was an excellent night for Kerry. And when you consider that Iraq/terrorism was supposed to be Bush's strong suit, Kerry has two more excellent nights to come.

