Executed at Sundown, 50 Years Ago

June 20, 2003
By CLYDE HABERMAN 

 

FARMINGDALE, N.Y. 
THE young landscaper stood yesterday over the graves of
Julius and Ethel Rosenberg, and decided that the shrubbery
needed a trim. He would definitely get to it, he said.
People might visit, and he wanted everything to look right.


He understood that the Rosenbergs were somehow important,
the man said in his Spanish-accented English. What exactly
they had done in life to make them famous, he had no idea.
He knew them only in death. Even then, they were not much
more than a name on a broad headstone: Rosenberg. One more
name out of thousands, representing all those souls on
their journey through forever at Wellwood Cemetery, along
the border between Nassau and Suffolk Counties. 

The Rosenbergs' first names were engraved on separate stone
markers at the foot of the graves. There was some other
writing, too, but the landscaper could not read it. It was
the Hebrew rendering of the couple's names. His was Yonah,
hers Etel. 

>From the dates of their births and deaths, the man could
tell that she had been the elder, 37 to his 35. Very young,
he said. That is so, he was told. Look, he said, they both
died on the same day: June 19, 1953. Was there, he asked,
an accident? Not quite, he was told. 

Across the language barrier, it was not so easy to explain
why it was a gross oversimplification to say that the
Rosenbergs died. 

They were executed. Fifty years ago yesterday, having been
found guilty of conspiring to pass American atomic secrets
to the Soviet Union, they went to the electric chair at
Sing Sing - first Julius, then Ethel. They died as the sun
was setting. 

Usually at Sing Sing, the death penalty was carried out at
11 p.m. But that June 19 was a Friday, and 11 p.m. would
have pushed the executions well into the Jewish Sabbath,
which begins at sundown. The federal judge in Manhattan who
sentenced them to death, Irving R. Kaufman, said that the
very idea of a Sabbath execution gave him "considerable
concern." The Justice Department agreed. So the time was
pushed forward. 

Killing the couple was one thing. But to do the deed on the
Sabbath, apparently, was quite another. 

Back then, the emotions unleashed by the Rosenbergs' trial
and execution reached almost to Wellwood's gates. According
to some news accounts, protesters stood on the road leading
to the cemetery, crying, "Bury them in Russia" as the
hearses passed. 

No such passion was to be found yesterday. Through the
morning, the only graveside visitor was a relentless rain. 

Somebody had been there recently, though. That was evident
from five small stones lying on the Rosenberg headstone.
Placing such stones is a Jewish custom when visiting a
grave. 

"I bet they were my daughter Ivy's," Michael Meeropol said
later. "She went." 

Mr. Meeropol, 60, does not often go to Wellwood himself.
Neither does his brother, Robert Meeropol, 56. They are the
Rosenbergs' sons. Long ago, they took the family name of
their adoptive parents. 

The Meeropol brothers needed no cemetery visit to remind
themselves what befell their family when they were boys.
While the Rosenberg case does not roil the country as it
once did, it has hardly gone away. How could it? It said so
much about the United States of the early 1950's, its
emotions and its fears. And, the Meeropols add, its
hysteria. 

THE available evidence now suggests to historians that
Julius Rosenberg did in fact spy for the Soviet Union. The
evidence against Ethel Rosenberg, however, is considered
flimsy at best. But whatever they may have done, it is far
from evident that they had handed Moscow the key to its
first atomic bomb, as charged at the time. 

The couple remain a special case. The United States has had
many spies over the last 50 years, including some believed
to have done great harm to American interests. Not one was
put to death. 

A remembrance of the Rosenbergs was held last night at City
Center, on West 55th Street in Manhattan. Any money made
went to the Rosenberg Fund for Children, a foundation
headed by Robert Meeropol. In ways that are often small -
piano lessons, for example - it helps children who endure
trouble because of their parents' political activities.
Children, in short, who have something in common with the
boys once named Rosenberg. 

"We don't want to dwell on our childhood," Robert Meeropol
said in a brief interview. "But the fact is that we had our
childhood experiences. I hope to get beyond them. But I'll
never get over them."

Copyright 2003 The New York Times Company