FOCUS ON EDUCATION // Scores show chasm between O.C.'s
rich, poor // EDUCATION: Comparing 2 schools suggests
that socioeconomics, English proficiency and parents'
education play big roles.
DATE 03/09/94
NEWSPAPER THE ORANGE COUNTY REGISTER
SECTION NEWS
EDITION MORNING
PAGE A07
STORY LENGTH 24 INCHES
HEADLINE FOCUS ON EDUCATION // Scores show chasm between O.C.'s
rich, poor // EDUCATION: Comparing 2 schools suggests
that socioeconomics, English proficiency and parents'
education play big roles.
BYLINE/CREDIT DAN FROOMKIN:The Orange County Register
SUBJECT TERMS OC:SCHOOLS:EDUCATION:TESTS:POVERTY:WEALTH:RESULT
For all their newfangledness, the California Learning Assessment
System scores released today tell a familiar story of a dramatic
achievement gap between Orange County schools serving the poor and
the rich.
On one end of the spectrum: Willard Intermediate School in Santa
Ana, where last year's eighth-graders overwhelmingly posted scores
in the bottom half of the 6-point scale, indicating that their
ability to read, write and solve math problems is inconsistent at
best, and in some cases negligible.
On the other: La Paz Intermediate School in Mission Viejo, where
a sizable majority of students scored in the top half of the scale
in reading and writing and far outperformed the state average in
math.
Statewide and countywide, one of the best predictors of test
scores remains socioeconomic status -- and Willard and La Paz are
two examples.
"We are starting at a deficit by comparison to a lot of other
schools," said Willard Principal Bob Butcher, whose school in
central Santa Ana is in a neighborhood of crowded apartment
buildings and just a block from a major drug corridor.
Almost 70 percent of last year's eighth-graders had limited
English skills, and most students' parents never graduated from
high school.
Butcher said his teachers work hard, but they can't erase the
handicaps many of the children start with -- and the scores reflect
that.
In contrast with Willard, La Paz Intermediate serves a
neighborhood of eucalyptus-shaded single-family homes, where almost
all the students speak English as their native language and most of
the parents are college graduates.
La Paz Principal Ruth Lander is quick to credit her school's
high scores to a particularly motivated teaching staff. But it's
not just that, she said.
"It's our socioeconomic level, it's the caliber of students we
have, it's the parental support we get, and it's the dedication of
the teachers," she said. "We're just so fortunate to have very
academically oriented youngsters and parents."
John Scheppach, 14, is in many ways a typical La Paz student.
His father is a doctor, his mother a college graduate. He lives in
a large house, with his own room.
His teachers are terrific, he said, but his parents often assist
him in his schoolwork.
"They don't do it for me," he said, "but they're usually a big
help. In math, my dad will explain things to me, and my mom will
always test me if I have to memorize something."
Daniel Robles, 13, is in many ways a typical Willard student.
His father is a boat painter who never went beyond junior high
in the Mexican schools. And his mother never made it to second
grade.
His parents, who work hard to pay the rent on a one-bedroom
apartment where they and their four children live, repeatedly tell
him education is important. And they'd like to do more, but they
can't, he said.
"Sometimes I don't understand stuff and they can't help me that
much," he said. "They don't understand what we're doing."
And like most of his classmates, he learned English not at home
but at school.
Try as they may, administrators say, they remain unable to make
up the difference in background between the John Scheppachs and the
Daniel Robleses of Orange County.
Results from previous statewide tests also showed achievement
gaps -- of up to three grade levels -- between districts serving the
more affluent and less affluent areas of the county.
The gap between Willard and La Paz was one full performance
level, with eighth-graders at Willard averaging 2.64, while those
at La Paz averaged 3.64. A 3 demonstrates "some understanding"; a
4, "substantial understanding."
"We do have all kinds of resources, but we could always use
more, because our kids have more needs," said Willard Assistant
Principal Liane Jacob.
And school, she said, "is only a very small portion of the day."