Darcy

 

Attributes

Sate v Malvo

Sate v Mayfield

Warner v Marx M.D.

Lack of Direct Evidence

None

None

none

Insufficient Quantity of Evidence

  • Sketch w/ similarities
  • Bullet fragments form Muhammed’s house
  • Finger print in Alabama
  • Car registration for Muhammed
  • Malvo and Muhammed friends
  • Stopped 18 people with long blonde hair
  • No or minimum ticket
  • Talk to them for unusual amt of time
  • Always stopped at the same place
  • Tire tracks match car
  • Vertical scratches
  • Previously asked to see bridge
  • Fibers found on Mayfield
  • Hair found on railing
  • Wiping things
  • Mayfield curious about investigation
  • Rope in trunk
  • Blood test found on boot matches 18 % o f the population
  • Fellow officers ratted out Mayfield
  • Protesters
  • Money that will be given to Rosa’s daughter
  • Neurologist’s testimony stated Rosa as brain dead
  • Dr Marx will not “kill a patient”

Logical Alternative Theory

  • Sold gun
  • Stole car with gun in it
  • Target practice on stump
  • Lonely likes to pull people over to talk
  • Rosa’s family wants the money
  • Dr. Marx wants to collect money from Rosa’s family by keeping her alive