1699 Jonathan Whitehead sold land in Hempstead called "Shermans neck" to Joseph Place. [1]
1706 Jonathan Whitehead, justice of the peace in Queens County, witnessed a deed by Thomas Jecocks in Hempstead. [2]
1709 Jonathan Whitehead, justice of the peace in Queens County, witnessed a deed by George Pearsall in Hempstead. [3]
I do not know if "Justice Jonathan Whitehead" relates to this person or to his nephew, son of brother Daniel Whitehead. The notes for nephew Jonathan Whitehead and this Jonathan Whitehead might be incorrectly placed.
[1] Benjamin D. Hicks, Records of the Towns of North and South Hempstead Long Island N.Y., Vol. 2 (1897), 178, [InternetArchive].
[2] Benjamin D. Hicks, Records of the Towns of North and South Hempstead Long Island N.Y., Vol. 2 (1897), 305, [InternetArchive].
[3] Benjamin D. Hicks, Records of the Towns of North and South Hempstead Long Island N.Y., Vol. 2 (1897), 370, [InternetArchive].