THE UNIVERSITY OF MICHIGAN
Gerald R. Ford School of Public Policy

PubPol 495
POLICY SEMINAR
USES AND ABUSES OF INTERNATIONAL TRADE POLICY

SYLLABUS
Winter 2015, Alan Deardorff

Text and Readings Requirements Policies Assignments Contacts Readings:
Topics: Tariffs VERs Safeguards Subsidies Agriculture Export Restrictions FTAs Sanctions

OVERVIEW

TEXT AND READINGS

COURSE REQUIREMENTS

COURSE POLICIES

ASSIGNMENTS

WHERE TO FIND ME


SCHEDULE OF TOPICS AND READINGS

Click on: Title for full citation to the reading
"Online" the reading itself (via UM if labelled P=Proquest, J=JSTOR, etc.)
"CTools" the reading itself in CTools

TOPIC

Date

Class topic and Assigned Reading

Jan 7 0. Course Overview
No assigned reading
A. TARIFFS
Jan 12 1. Tariffs - General
Deardorff, "Tariff in Partial Equilibrium," [4p] Online
Deardorff, "Benefits and Costs" [42p] Online
Jan 14 2. Smoot-Hawley Tariffs
Economist, "The Battle of Smoot-Hawley," [6p] Online-Proquest
Irwin, "Smoot-Hawley Tariff," [7p] Online-JSTOR
  (Ignore details of estimation and omit Section III and Appendix.)
Koyama, "Why Did the President Sign the Bill?" [25p] Online-Ebsco
Jan 19 No Class - Martin Luther King Jr. Day
Jan 21 3. European Economic Community
Irwin, "Trade Agreements," [5p] Online
Mikesell, "The Lessons," [14p] Online-JSTOR
Eichengreen, "European Economic Community," [3p] Online
   (Omit section on Monetary Unification.)
James, "History of the European Union," [1p] Online
Europa, "History," website with links Online
Jan 26 4. The Chicken War
Talbot, The Chicken War [26p] CTools
Johnson, "Proclamation," [1p] Online
Ikenson, "Ending the Chicken War," [12p] Online
Lawrence, "The chickens have come home to roost," [1p+comments] Online
Dolan, "To Outfox the Chicken Tax," [3p] Online-Proquest
Brown, "U.S. May Drop 'Chicken Tax'," [1p] Online
Esterdahl, "Current Negotiations," [3p] Online
   (Omit section on Trade Agreements Impact.)
B. VOLUNTARY EXPORT RESTRAINTS
Jan 28 5. VERs - General
Bhagwati, "Rise of Protectionism," [17p] CTools
Jones, "Voluntary Export Restraint," [16p] Online-HeinOnline
Preusse, "Effective Means against a Spread of Neo-Protectionism?," [14p] Online-HeinOnline
ST&R, "Mexico Limit Auto Exports to Brazil," [1p] Online
ST&R, "Restrictions on Bilateral Footwear Trade," [2p] Online
Feb 2 Class cancelled due to snow. Dates below have been revised because of that.
Feb 4 6. Autos; Steel

Farnsworth & Cuff, "'Voluntary' Import Restraint". [5p] CTools
Wolf, "Why voluntary export restraints?," [19p] Online-Wiley
Crandall, "Effects of U.S. Trade Protection," [18p] Online-JSTOR
Pollack, "Japan to End Export Restraints," [2p] Online
Benjamin, "Voluntary Export Restraints on Automobiles," [2p] Online
Berry, et al., "Evaluating a Trade Policy," pp. 400-404, 428-429 only. [7p] Online-JSTOR

C. SAFEGUARDS AND ANTI-DUMPING
Feb 9 7. Safeguards - General

WTO, "Safeguards," [2p] Online
Deardorff, "Safeguards Policy", sections 1 and 6 only. [5p] Online
Bown, "Why Are Safeguards So Unpopular?". [16p] Online
Messerlin & Fridh, "Proposals for Change", read only pp. 713-732. [20p] Online-HeinOnline
Bown & McCulloch, "Are more safeguards the answer?". [25p] Online

Feb 11 8. Harley-Davidson

Schaffer et al., "Heavyweight Motorcycles". [1p] CTools
USITC, "Heavyweight Motorcycles". pp. 1-21 only. [21p] Online
Irwin, Free Trade Under Fire, pp. 173-175. [2p] CTools
Kitano & Ohashi, "Did safeguards resuscitate Harley-Davidson?" read only pp. 196-190, 196 (thus skipping sections 3 & 4). [6p] Online-Science Direct

Feb 16 9. Chinese Tires

Grimmett, "Chinese Tire Imports". [33p] Online
USTR, "United States Prevails". [1p] Online
Mayer Brown, "Appellate Body Upholds Special Safeguard". [1p] Online
Chung et al., "Did Safeguard Save U.S. Workers?", sections 1, 2, & 4 only. [3p] Online
Hufbauer & Lowry, "Saving Few Jobs at High Cost". [14p] Online
Charnovitz & Hoekman, "Imposing Pain for Little Gain". [24p] CTools

Feb 18 10. Anti-dumping Duties
WTO, "Anti-dumping actions". [1p] Online
Deardorff, "Economic Perspectives on Antidumping Law". [15p] Online
Deardorff & Stern, "Centennial of Antidumping". [10p] Online
Mankiw & Swagel, "Third Rail of Trade Policy". [13p] Online
Bown, "Taking Stock of Antidumping", pp. 1955-1987, 1990-1992. [34p] Online-Wiley
Besedes & Prusa, "Antidumping and the Death of Trade", pp. 1-8, 28-29. [10p] Online-NBER
D. SUBSIDIES
Feb 23 11. Subsidies and Countervailing Duties
WTO, "Subsidies and countervailing measures: Overview". [2p] Online
WTO, "Agreement on Subsidies and countervailing measures". [5p] Online
Jackson, "The Perplexities of Subsidies". [25p] CTools
Feb 25           ***FIRST ISSUE BRIEF DUE 2:30 PM***
12. Boeing-Airbus
WTO, "European Communities - Large Civil Aircraft". [8p] Online
WTO, "United States - Second Complaint". [7p] Online
Krugman et al., "Strategic Trade Policy". [4p] CTools
Kienstra, "Cleared For Landing". [39p] Online
Hepher, "U.S. to rap European Union". [1p] Online
Hepher, "EU may challenge U.S.". [2p] Online
      ************************************************
           Spring Break: Mar 2-6
      ************************************************
Mar 9 13. Cotton Subsidies
WTO, "United States - Subsidies on Upland Cotton". [9p] Online
Gillson et al., "Impact of Cotton Subsidies", read only pp. 3-22, 63-66. [22p] Online
Woodward, "Impact of U.S. Subsidies". [13p] Online
Bjerga, "U.S. Reaches Deal With Brazil". [2p] Online
E. AGRICULTURE TRADE DISPUTES
Mar 11           ***TERM PAPER TOPIC DUE 2:30 PM***
14. Agriculture Trade - General
Peters & Pierre, "Food Policy as a Wicked Problem". [8p] CTools
Anderson, "Evolution Since the 1950s". [22p] CTools
Mar 16 15. Banana Wars
Barkham, "The banana wars explained". [3p] Online
Rosegrant, "Banana Wars", pp. 97-136 only. [39p] Online
Olofson, "Trade Gone Bananas", pp. 21-22 only. [2p] CTools
Telegraph, "Banana war ends after 20 years". [2p] Online
(Cancelled) 16. Beef Hormone Dispute
WTO, "European Communities - Measures Concerning Meat". [4p] Online
European Parliament, "Win-win ending". [1p] Online
Johnson & Hanrahan, "The U.S.-EU Beef Hormone Dispute". [22p] Online
Josling et al., "Implications for Trade Policy". [35p] Online
Nuthall, "EU and US Try to Resolve Beef Hormone Dispute". [1p] Online
Harrison-Dunn, "EU-US beef import extension". [1p] Online
Mar 18 17. Genetically Modified Organisms
WTO, "European Communities - Measures Affecting Biotech Products". [4p] Online
Lynch & Vogel, "The Regulation of GMOs". [36p] Online
Castle, "GM food must be allowed into Europe". [2p] Online
Palmer, "The WTO GMO Dispute", pp. 1-10, 13. [11p] Online
Bennett, "GMO Crops Can Be Good". [1p] Online
F. EXPORT RESTRICTIONS
Mar 23 18. Export Restrictions - General
Bouët & Laborde, "Economics of Export Taxation", pp. 1-4, 12-19. [12p] Online
Anania, "Agricultural Export Restrictions and the WTO", pp. 1-19, 35-37. [22p] Online
Mar 25           ***SECOND ISSUE BRIEF DUE 2:30 PM***
19. Export Restrictions - Examples

Fliess et al., "Recent Developments in the Use of Export Restrictions", pp. 17-31, 40-49. [25p] Online
Deardorff, "A Sample of News about Export Restrictions". [14p] CTools
OECD, Inventory of Restrictions on Exports . website. Online
Mar 30 20. OPEC
Deardorff, "The Simple Theory of Cartels". [5p?] CTools
Bouman, "Oligopoly and Game Theory". [2p] Online
Carlton & Perloff, "OPEC". [6p] CTools
OPEC, "Brief History". [2p] Online
OPEC, "Our Achievements @ 50". [6p] Online
Zycher, "OPEC". [5p] Online
Garland, "OPEC Crude Oil Prices from 1960-2013". [1p] Online
Bobrow & Kudrle, "Theory, Policy, and Resource Cartels". [54p] Online
Fahey, "What Are OPEC Nations Thinking?". [2p] Online
Hirst, "OPEC Votes Not To Cut Production". [4p] Online
Bartiromo, "$100-a-barrel oil 'never' again". [2p] Online
G. FREE TRADE AGREEMENTS
Apr 1           ***SUBMIT INTENT TO DO PRESENTATION***
21. FTAs - General & NAFTA
Irwin, "Trade Agreements," (repeat from above) [5p] Online
Scott, "NAFTA's failure has cost the United States". [13p] Online
Hufbauer et al., "NAFTA at 20", pp. 1-17 only. [17p] Online
Economist, "Game of Zones". [3p] CTools
Apr 6 22. FTAs under Consideration
TPP: Trans-Pacific Partnership
Barfield, "A Model for Twenty-First-Century Trade Agreements?". [15p] Online
Wallach, "NAFTA on Steroids". [5p] Online
Eichelberger, "The Biggest Secret Trade Deal". [7p] Online
TTIP: Trans-Atlantic Trade and Investment Partnership
Europa, "The Economic Analysis Explained". [18p] Online
Buchanan, "Have we lost our democratic privileges?". [6p] Online
Kanter & Jolly, "Plans to Press Ahead". [4p] Online
EU-Ukraine
Hellyer, "EU-Ukraine free trade area explained". [3p] Online
Chaffin & Olearchyk, "EU courts Ukraine". [2p] Online-Proquest
Olearchyk & Spiegel, "Ukraine puts talks on hold". [2p] Online-Proquest
Olearchyk, "Thousands protest in Kiev". [3p] Online-Proquest
China-Taiwan
China-Taiwan website, browse. Online
Ramzy, "Opponents of Trade Deal Occupy Legislature". [2p] Online
Anderlini, "Thousands of Taiwanese rally". [3p] Online-Proquest
H. TRADE SANCTIONS
Apr 8 23. Sanctions - General
Elliott et al., "Sanctions". [8p] Online
Kryvoi, "Why European Union Trade Sanctions Do Not Work". [38p] Online
Friedman, "Smart Sanctions", pp. 1-5. [5p] Online
Bremmer, "Weaponised Finance". [1p] CTools
Apr 13 24. Sanctions against Russia
Dyer, "War by Other Means". [5p] Online-Proquest
Pifer, "Can Sanctions Deter Putin's Plans for Ukraine?" video. Online
Gaddy & Ickes, "Can Sanctions Stop Putin?" [7p] Online
Bosworth, "Effect of Sanctions on Russia's Economic Slide" [2p] Online
Apr 15 Presentations and Wrap-Up
Apr 20 ***TERM PAPERS DUE 2:30 PM***
No class, probably (I should know by the end of January.)

E-mail to: alandear@umich.edu Return to: PubPol 495
Deardorff's Home Page