Why did the
Nakba Occur things
that Led
up to it? By: Ali Thabet
Part I:
- Jewish
Immigration:Jewish National fund(kerenkiyemet) an
Umbrella organization of World Zionist Organization (WZO)- bought mass
amount of
lands and settled Jews. Lots of wealthy Arab land owners sold
land
to the Jewish fund.
- World War I- San
Remo Conference: After WWI set up mandate system. The
western countries are like teachers and
need this colonialization of the Arab states in order for them to get
on their
feet after Ottoman rule. This upheld the
Belfour declaration. After WW1 the
Ottoman Empire was split up to mostly the British and French through
the Sykes-picot
agreement.
- Balfour
Declaration -November 2, 1917- Arthur James Balfour to Lord
Rothschild
(leader Jews) to Zionist Federation: British government support Zionism
plan of
Jewish Home. Which nothing shall
be done that might prejudice the
rights of existing communities within them.
- 1922 White
Paper -
Wrote the white paper of 1922. This
paper helped translate what was being meant by the Belfour declaration. It gave the right of a Jewish homeland in
Palestine.
- 1939 White Paper-During
WWII, Zionist restriction to 5% immigration to Palestine and only
75,000 Jewish
immigrants under Arab regulation. Also
promise of British to establish an independent Arab state.
- World War II and the holacuast
played an important role in empahty
towards the Jews from Western Countries.
- UNSCOP majority
plan- The UNSCOP Report, submitted on 31 August 1947,
unanimously supported the termination of the British mandate in
Palestine. The representatives of the other states (except Australia)
favored a partition into two separate independent states (the majority
plan) with Jerusalem as a corpus separatum under an
international regime. On 29 November 1947 the General
Assembly adopted Resolution 181,
based on the UNSCOP majority plan, by a 33 - 13 vote, with 10
abstentions. The Jewish Agency accepted the resolution, and the
rejected it. Majority for Partition in
Non
contiguous regions, economic union, Jerusalem international. . Arabs rejected Zionist
accepted majority proposal. Minority
favored
binational state. This was the plan that became the Partition
plan and
was favored by the International countries and what was
implemented. Arab Higher Commitee
- UNSCOP
minority
plan- rejected by all and it was a thought of creating a
binationional
state. The representatives of Iran, India, and Yugoslavia
supported a federal solution (known as the minority plan) that
envisaged Arab and Jewish regions within a federal union with Jerusalem
as its capital.
Arab
Israeli War 1948: After UN Patition Plan Israel declares
Nation and next day the war starts:
1947- britian turns mandate to UN.
May 15, 1948, Egypt, Jordan, Syria, and Iraq attack ties this in
to Nakba
3 phases Israel extened borders: 1949 armistance sighned, Israel
with/78% of Mandate rather then 56%.
Backround: The War of 1947-48
is referred to as the al-naaba(disaster)
by the Palestinians. The new Jewish state increased its territory
by roughly one-third as a result of the fighting, and no distinction
was made between the land that they had been granted by the UN
partition Resolution of 1947 and the war. the UN set up a team
lead by Count folke Benadotte to modify the 1947 Partition
Resolution. They proposed ini modifyin ght 1947 partionon by
redrawing the boundries between Jewihs and Arab Palestine.
Palestine is attached to Trans-Jordan( Name of Jordan at that
time). The arabs opposed to unite with trans-Jordan and rejected
to recognize a Jewish state.
- Irgun- defense
in Israel was a militant Zionist group that operated in Palestine
between 1931
and 1948. It was established as a militant offshoot of the earlier and
larger
Jewish paramilitary organization Hagana. The Irgun was the armed
expression of
the nascent ideology of Revisionist Zionism founded by Ze'ev
Jabotinsky. He
expressed this ideology as "every Jew had the right to enter Palestine;
only active retaliation would deter the Arabs and the British; only
Jewish
armed force would ensure the Jewish state". Initially, a central part
of
their efforts included attacks against Palestinian Arabs, but it
increasingly
shifted to attacks against the British. Some of the better-known
attacks by
Irgun were the bombing of the King David Hotel in Jerusalem on 22 July
1946 and
the Deir Yassin massacre (accomplished together with the Stern Gang) on
9 April
1948. In the West, Irgun was described as a terrorist organization by The
New York Times newspaper, and by the Anglo-American Committee of
Enquiry.
Irgun attacks prompted a formal declaration from the World Zionist
Congress in
1946, which strongly condemned "the shedding of innocent blood as a
means
of political warfare".
- Arab League – It
was created in Cairo on March 22, 1945 with six members: Egypt, Iraq,
Jordan,
Lebanon, Saudi Arabia, and Syria. Palestinian
Guerrilla army joined by 7,000 volunteers from Arab lands to join
Palestinians
in preparation of the 1948 war and a part of the Arab Liberation Army. In the context of Camp David 1, the Arab
league stated that the PLO is the sole legit group that represents the
Palestinians which was a major turning point in the Arab/Israeli
conflict. Egypt was expelled from Arab
league in
1979(readmitted 1989) and the Islamic conference in 1979 and readmitted
1984
due to the Egyptian Israel Peace treaty.
- Plan Delat- or
Plan D: is a blueprint for preventing the emergence of a
Palestinian state
and expelling the population. Plan D
became official when Israel declared independence.
Haganah in Palestine pushed and said it was
mostly defensive.
- Deir Yasin-
The number one cited village that gets broght up and is blamed as the
cause of the exodus. It was a village that was destroyed by
Israeli forces during the 48 war. 254
civilians. Many
bodies killed and thrown into well. One of
the main events that occurred and were
spread by the Palestinians. This is
event is used as one of the causes of why some many Palestinians left
their
villages during the Nakba due to them being afraid of this attack.
Part II:
- The Mass Exodus of the Palestinina
refugees: The refugee situation waws
so traumatic for the Palestinians because they left on a short
notice. They thought they would come back and took very little
with them. It was also very tough to move because they realized
that they could not go back. Israeli forces often destroyed
villages to prepare land for settlement. The situation for
internal refugees was not any better. The Palestinians now live
in campsand centers which are poorly equipped to care for such a large
number of people. They were also unable to aquire a legal
title. It was tough to claim absentee property and many were cut
off from families. The 1948 war was a political adn psychological
watershed. All hope for an Arab state were destroyed which made
the whole sitution worse from a palestinian perspective.
The Arab community thought that the Partition Resolution was
unfair. The Arabs thought that the UN probably exceeded its leal
competance in adopting a resolution. They also believe that it is
illegal for Israel to exercise sovereignty overthose refugees of
Palestine which UN
allocated to the proposed Arab state. Also the makeup of the UN was
unfair because at that time it had few African and Asian members.
It was dominated by the U.S. and European Powers. Finally, the
Arabs beleieves that there was a Western motivation for establishing
Israel because the Arabs thought this creation helped to solve the west
countries conscience for teh treatment of Jews during World War II by
payn its own debt to the Jews. Arabs point out international law
for thier cause and state: a "conquerer" does not in any way accquire
soveirgn rights in teh occupoed territory but exercises a temporary
right of administration on a trustice basis.
The Israel resoponse to this is that it was acting with the consent of
teh U.N. Assembly. 1949-armistice agreeement Arab achnoleged the
rights in areas of each party to the conflict. Lines cannot be
modified where you have a permenant peace agreement. Also since
the Partition and plan where prevoked by Arab rejection and armed
agression from entering into legal opperation, (thus) could not carry
any legal efforts binding upon Israel. Israel would have followed
if it had not been prevented from taking into effect!
Causes of the Palestinian Exodus:
Hundreds of thousands Palestinians left thier homes during and
immediately after teh 1947-48 war. The reasons why the left and
what should be done are different from both the Arab and Israeli side.
the Arabs believe that they were threatened by thier life and were
affraid that they would get massacred. An event that is highly
mentioned is the Deir Yassin village. This village massacred 254
defenseless civilians and many bodies were thrown into wells. The
arabs believe that the Israeli motivation was to initate a fear among
the Palestinian population. The arabs believe that this is not an
isolated incident. It serves as a larger pattern of events that
the Hagana (Israeli army) was doing. The Arabs believed that Deir
Yassin was an act of revenge of an earlier massacre of Jews in
Haifa. At Nasr al-Din, Irregular Jewish Soldiers entered the
village and destroyed 45 houses and killed 7 (citation). The
Arabs also believe that the Hagana officials ordered the attack of Deir
Yassin. the arabs believe that psychological warfare was
involved. There believed that Isreal actions were deliberate
zionist efforts to drive Arabs out. Arabs cited Plan D as a
strategy of total war. Some objectives included Luanching
pre-planned counter-attacks on ememy-bases in teh heart of his
territory whereever it is, including outside Palestine, occupying
important high-ground positions within the Jewish state and within
thier territores. Also occupying and controllign the enemy's
bases in rural adn urban areas. The Arabs respond to the examples
of Israels few instinces of claiming the Arabs to stay are not
indicative of Zionist policy elsewhere. They generalize Haifa
without citing the cases elsewhere.
The Israeli take on Deir Yassin is that they have a couple. They
state that they were met with rebels and asked them to leave the area
prior
to coming in with the army through a megaphone system. This
village was one of several that
avoided cooperation due to Israeli intelligence. Israeli's
defense of Plan D stated that it
is not a political blue print for the expulstion of Palestinians.
It is a military consideration and military ends. Also since
securing the interior of the Jewish state was the # 1 priority and this
meant depoppulation and destruction of villages that were
hostile.
When Israeli government heard the news of the atrocities, think they
were false or initiated. They state that most actions that
included violence was from local commanders acting on thier own
initiation. This was more common among the Arabs. Most that
were telling the stories about these massacres where among Arabs
and the stories have been exaggerated. The arabs also did acts of
hostility and were wihtout fault in teh eyes of the Israelis. The
example the Israeli's bring is the ambush of a convoy full of Dr,
Nurses, teachers were killed by Arabs. They believe the Arab
Propaganda spread the Arab atrocity stories. They believe the
radio stations aim was to create hatred towards Jews. They are
even examples of Jews trying to persuade Palestinians to stay.
The decleration of Independance of Isreal calls for Arabs to
stay. In the city of Haifa, Jewish workers council tell Arabs not
to flee.
Part III:
- Where did the Refugees Go?
(click on the link to see a table of the distribution of refugees after
the War and where they are they today!)
After 1948, Gaza was given to Egypt and Egypt established Gaza as a
nominal Palestinian Arab government led by Arab Higher commitee.
The West Bank was controlled by trans-Jordan and was considered an
extention by transJordan.
- UNRWA- United
Nations Relief and Works Agency for
Palestine Refugees in the Near East (UNRWA)
is a relief and human development agency, providing
education, health care, social services and emergency aid to over four
million
Palestinian refugees living in Jordan, Lebanon and Syria, as well as in
the
West Bank and the Gaza Strip and was created after the Arab/Israeli
War.
Initial solutions to the refugee
Problem From the Israeli Side:
Solutions proposed by the Israelis:
1) Compostated of lost of property.
2) Lived in Arab lands replaced jewish Population
3) In compatibabel with Jewish state creation. It did not fit
with Jewish as being the majority state if Pals return the jewish
population will be the minority.
The three main reasons Israelis provided to explain the jewish
immigration to Israel were:
1) Refugees result from war resolved with the countries to which
displaced population had fled
2) Refugee status was maintained by the government taht they fled
to. Denied citizenship to keep palestine idea alive
3) Religous, linguistic, and cultural affinities between palestininas
adn other Arabs were such taht palestininas can be absorbed easily by
neighbooring states.
- UN Resolution
181
- was a plan approved by the General Assembly on November 29, 1947
to
terminate the British Mandate of Palestine by August 1, 1948, and
facilitate
the creation of two states, one Jewish and one Arab. The plan was
approved by a
vote of 33 to 13, with 10 abstentions. The resolution
was accepted by the Jews in
Palestine, yet rejected by the Arabs in Palestine and the Arab states.
- The
UN General Assembly resolution 194 (III)United Nations General
Assembly Resolution 194 was passed on
December
11, 1948, near the end of the 1948 Arab-Israeli War. The resolution
expresses
appreciation for the efforts of UN Envoy Folke Bernadotte after his
assassination by members of the Stern Gang. It deals with the situation
in the
region of Palestine at the time, establishing and defining the role of
the
United Nations Conciliation Commission as an organization to facilitate
peace
in the region. It also asked the Israelis to
only
accept the Palestinians willing to live in peace wiht their Jewish
members. The Israelis did not follow this becasue the did not
believe that the Palestinians would live in a Jewish society peacefully
because they might be influenced by external pressures.
This resolution still gets brought up today during peace negotiations
when trying to settle the refugee issue. The Palestinians
refugees total is now over 4.5 million today and the issue is still
unresolved.
Resource(from my discussion): Mark Tessler.
"The Palestinian Disaster and Basic Issues after 1948," in A History of
the Israeli-Palestinian Conflict. Bloomington, IN: Indiana Universoty
Press, 1994, pp. 273-335.